Performance Pricing, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 241

MOTION to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP by AOL LLC, Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Joint Stipulation Regarding Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP, # 2 Declaration of Emily C. O'Brien in Support of Motion to Compel, # 3 Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit K, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Declaration of Christin Cho in Opposition to Motion to Compel, # 20 Errata 1, # 21 Exhibit 2, # 22 Exhibit 3, # 23 Proposed Order Granting Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel)(O'Brien, Emily) Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ). Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ).

x y

Dockets.Justia.com

^^

r

Emily^ U'Brien

rr^i s i rrrrr^

r s ^. s ^^ ^

From: Sent:
TO:

Rachel Kim [[e-mail]] Tuesday, April 2'f, 2008 3:34 PM [e-mail]; [e-mail]; eftndlay@rameyf[oclc.com; [e-mail]; mjacobs@mat'o.com; [e-mail]; Jennifer R Kash; [e-mail]; Emily O'Brien; David Perlson; Antonio Sistos; Charles K Verhoeven; mrichardson@brsfirm_com; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; Goggle-Performance Pricing

Cc: Subject: Attachments:

[e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail];
[e-mail]; [e-mail]; [e-mail]; risaac@ca ps hawlaw.com Performance Pricing v. Google, et al_- Nea[ CohenNisfa IP Law Documents Singfe_pg VIP02.zip; Multi^g VlP02.zip; Privilege Log(REVISEt7} 4'2'I'09.pdf

Counsel, Please find attached a revised Privilege Log for the documents produced by Neat Cohen and Vista IP Law along with documents previously withheld. Do not hesitate to contact me with any questions. Racket Kim Legal Assistant Dovel & Luner, LLP (310)_ 656-7066 20i Santa Monica Bvld. Suite f00 Santa Monica, CA 90401

PaG E ^^^.r

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS Performance Pricing, fnc. Plaintiff, v. Google, Enc. et al., Defendants. 2:DT-ev-432 {Lf"©) REVISED PRIVILEGE LOG CORRESPONDING TO: 1} SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAT. M. CDHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; AND 2) SUBPOENA COMMANDING NOIV-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TD PRODUCE DOCUMENTS

The Revised Privilege Log attached hereto as Exhibit A is being produced in connection with: ].} RESPONSE TO SUBPC`ElVA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAT M. COHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; and 2} RESPONSE 70 SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS. AI! documents identified in said Privilege Log are being withheld on the bases identified, and are not being produced. Abbreviations used in the Privilege Lag: "NMC" means Nea! M. Cohen; "W L" means Wayne Lin; "VLS" means Valerie L. Sarigumba, who was at all relevant times an associate attorney at Vista IP Law Group; "J LL" means Jocelyn L. Lee, who was at al! relevant times a senior paralegal at Vista IP Law Group; "HO" means l-iidehika Okada, wha was at ail relevant times an attorney at the law .firm, Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "SS" means 5amuei B. Stone; who was at all relevant times a partner at Lyon & Lyon LLP; "JT" means Jeff Tekanic, who was at all relevant times an attorney at the taw firm, Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "PJE" means Patricia J. English, who was at all relevant tunes an employee at Cohen, Sakaguchi & English LLP; "YPY" means Yeo-Pyo Yaon, who was at ail relevant times an attorney at Honesty 8e Patent;

EXHIBIT _- ^ --. PAGE -l^_ _

^^

"AJC" means a claim of AttarneyJClient Privilege; "WJl'" means a claim of Work Product; "TPM" means a claim of Trial Preparation Materiai.

E^^#(^( PACE ..^._^^^.^...

.Ref J: 1

.^^

Date 8/2/2Q01

,...

^.. NMC

Quth^o.r{s) Wl

Recip^erit{s^' __ _

Descrrpti ,on Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications Between client and attorney. Document related tp litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Dacumen# concerning legal advice and includng confldential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confldential communications. between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential commcnications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document Concerning legal advice and including confidential communications b etween c li en t an d a ttorn ey. l oc ument

'^ Prrvi[^ge(s)

Ciatrned AC, WP

_ 1-Z . 1-3 3/29/01 NMC Wi. 8/13/Q1 NMC WL

AC, WP

AC, WP

'1-4

1/12/Ql

NMC

Wi_

AC, WP

1-5

2/20/Q1

NMC

WL

AC, WP

s
i

:1-6

2/27/99

NMC

WL

AC, WP

^^

I _ AC, WP __._.

` 1-7 1/3/01 NMC

_ WL

^ 1..g i^ ^

10/1/Q1

NMC

WE.

AC, WP ,

ftef:

Date ^

^ .. .^

Au.t..Fiot{s} , ..

Rec^^Pieht {'s) .. .._ w WL

Description .. ^ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related tv litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between cffent and attorney. Document related tv litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confident^^^ rommunlcativns between c[lent and attorney. Document __ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and incuding confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to iitigatian. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document

Pfivilege{s) Claimed AC, WP

1-9

12/13/00

NMC

1-1D

11/15/01

NMC

WL

AC, WP

1-11

4/2/01

NMC

WL

AL, WP

1-12

7/28/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

1-13

5]10/41

NMC

WL

_ AC, WP

1-14

10/14/02

NMC

WL

AC, WP

` 1-15 $/2/01 NMC WL ! ^

1

AC, WP

"-T,3 ' ^7 ^^
=^

1-16

11/$0/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

^^,^-1

Ref.

,"

Date

Au # Ii'ar(6)° ^^ ^ . _

Recipient{s) . WL

3-17

10/27/99

NMC

1-18

6/1/00

NMC

WL

1-19

4/18/0?

NMC

WL

1-20

10/16/01

NMC

WL

_^ _ 1-21 ^/6/OZ NMC WL

1-22

10/9/01

NMC

WL

1-23

7/5/00

NMC

WL

'"t7 1 ^^ ^^

-24

2/18/00

NMC

WL

^ Descrlption^ .. _ .. related to lltigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Darument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidentia [ communications between client and attorney. 1)oCument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidentia! eommunica#ions between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. T Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Documert concerning legal advice and including confidential Communications between client grid attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and at#orney . Document

PriviEege(s) Claimed AC, WP

_
AC, WP

AC, WP

_
AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

i

AC, WP

e i

i

..,.
'Kef . :^i: pate ^^
-

Auti^or(s)

'^ _
_

` Recipient(s)
.. .

^

_ ^ Description

^

Privilege(s7
:^Clalrned

^-25

8/13/01

NMC

WL

1-26

4/17/02

NMC

WL

^

1-Z7

7/31/02

NMC

WL

Z-5

8/2/01

NMC

4U[.

__ Z-6 8/7.3/01 NMC WL

2-11

3/17/07

NMC

WL

3.1

5/7/02

NMC

WC

related to litigation Document concerning legal advice and including conf:dential communications between client and attorney. document related to litigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including co,fidential communications between client and attorney. Document related t_o litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including conidential communications between client acrd attorney. Document related [o litigation, _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigat'an, Document conwrning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

AC, WP

AC, WP

^^ `__ ^ AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

3-2 ^ ^ ^ ^

9/10/01

NMC

WL

related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidentia[ communications between client and attorney. Document

AC, WP

^: ··Eief ..

".Date

Aut^ar ( s}

^' :Recipient(s)

^

Description

>:: P.tivifege(sy ·Ciaimed AC, WP

3-3

9/10/01

NMC

WL

3-4

8/21/01

NMC

WL

3-5

NMC

WL

related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including can identiaf communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. !Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attarney.
Document concerning legal advice and

AC, WP ,^ AC, WP

3-6

8/21/01

NMC

Vt^L

AC, WP

including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

3-7

5/Z/D1

NMC

WL

_ 3-$
4/30)01

NMC

^

WL

3-9

4/23/01

NMC

WL

3-10

4/6/01

NMC

WL

related to litigatiprs.' Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal adults and including canidentia{ communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning 1egaE advice and including canfidentia! communications between client and attarney. Document related to litigation.

AC, WP

AC, WP

_ AC, WP

_ AC, WP

^

^

i t

Ref ^ ^ 3-11

^

Date ^' .

`' ^^Author:(s) NMC WL

Recipient (s)'':.

^ Description ^ Documen# concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidentia# communications between client and attorney. Document _ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between cEient and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document _ _ related to litlp^ation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client aid attorney. Document related to liti at'son. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to iiti anon. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. bocument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.

4/6/01

; i?.riwlege(s) . Claimed ~. AC, WP

3-1Z

4/5/01

NMC

WL

AC, WP

_^ 3-13 3/x0/01 NMC WL

AC, WP

_^_ 3-14 1 1j29/01 1 ^ ' ^ 11/30/00 NMC WL

AC, WP

3-15

__ NMC

wL

AC, WP

3-16

11/13/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

3-17

11/6/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

^.

^ rn
^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^

3-18

11/S/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

Ref .. 3-19

Date ^! 10/16/00 NMC

AUtbar (s) ,^

, WL

Recipient{sy

^ ^, ...

.Descnption,:'; :.,..

_

' 3-ZD

9/Z8/00

NMC

WL

3-Z1

9/12/00

NMC

WL

3-ZZ

6/5/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidentiu; communications between client and attarney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legaE advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.

Privilege{sj .^: ClalniecE^ ,:: . ^ AC, WP

AC, WP

_ qC, WP

AC, WP
^ I

3-23

6/5/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidentia[ communications
between client and attorney. Document

AC, WP

3-24

5/30/00

NMC

WL

3-Z5

1/25/00

NMC

WL

'TJ 3-26 f^ ^. i^ ^ 4/24/00

NMC

WL

related to litigation. Document to^ZCerning legal advice and including confidential cammunications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attarney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.

AC, WP

_ AC, WP

AC, WP

Ref 3-27

date 3/23/00

^ NMC

Autbar{s) . , ...... WL

Recipient{s) ...

-

3-28

3/9/00

NMC

WL

_ 3-29 2/9/00 NMC WL

3-31

1/26/OD

NMC

WL

3-33

1/26/00

NMC

WL

3-34

1/17/00

NMC

WL

3-35

12/6/99

NMC

WL

3-36

11/29/99

NMC

WL

^ ^ i!.

Z Q-1 W
, ^E

10/16/01

NMC

WL

Description. _ __ ' Document concerning legal adults and .including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. document concerning legal advice and ,:

Prwilege{s) ....:. Claimed AC, WP

^.

AC, WP
_...^

AC, WP

i

AC, WP

AC, WP

^AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

1. y

Ref

_ :Date .

Autliar{sJ

^.

Reciplerit(s}

^

^ 'a'escriptian

. ^" .Ariuilege{s}

_ 4-Z 8/14/01 NMC
'WL

4-^

4/5/01

NMC

WL

4-4

1/19/01

NMC

WL

_ 4-5
5/26/00

NMC

WL

4-6

6/1/00

NMC

WL

4-7

2/15/00

NMC

WL

4-8 ^ ^. ^ ^ w..:^g 49

12/21/99

NMC

WL

12/13/99

NMC

WL

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Dncument related to Eitigation· Document concerning legal advice and including cnnfdential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. ._._ ^^ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document __ ^. related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and Encluding confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and Including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to Eitigation. Document concerning legal advice and including cnnfidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning IegaE advice and including confidential communications between cilent^and attorney. Document related to Eitigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

_ AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

^1 ' 1 C^ ,
9

Ref· ..

Oate

Author(s)

Reca^^er.,t{s) "

Description; including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between c[ient and attorney. Document
reiaeed to litigation.

PrwcEege(s) Ciaimed° .

"

S-^

4/17102

^ NMC

Wt,

AC, WP

5-2

8/13/01

NMC

WL

AC, WP

,^

..
5-3

_ 8/28/00 NMC WL

AC, WP

5-4

6/5/00

NMC

WL

5-1

7/9/07.

NMC

WL

6-2

3/2/01

NMC

WL

6-3

3/2701

NMC

WL

l^ ^ 6-^

7/12/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigatian. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. boCUment concerning legal advice and

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

,^

AC, WP

AC, WP

=^

f2e^F.^^ ..:

.:

.:Date

R'u #Har^s)

Reclplerit(s)

_.

.__

_
^ l7escrEpt[ors;..... ` .. ^' including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to iitigatian. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and includirg confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

Pnv^l>t;ig: e(s). .. Claimed .:

_

6-S

4/11/00

NMC

WL

AC, WP

_ 5-6 4/11/00 NMC
.

WL

AC, WP

7-1 7-2 7-3
7-4

7-5 7-6 7-7
8-1

^

_ 1/2/42

NMC NMC NMC NMC NMC NMC NMC
NMC

ti. .

Hd _ HO HO HO HO HO HO
WL

_

8-2

4/17/02

NMC

WL

8-3

4/17/02

NMC

WL

^ ^ 8-4 ^^ ^ _"^ f

NMC

WE. -T

related to IitigaEion. _ Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigatian, Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation, _ Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to likigation. Documenk concerning legal advice and including co^ofidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

WP WP WP WP WP WP WP AC, WP

AC, WP

_
AC, WP

AC, WP ^^

Ref '

' ^'

Date

Author(s) ^. {

Recipient(s)

·.,.

",

.^

Descriptidn^ :.

Privifege(s^ Claimed..

8-5

4/17/02

NMC

WL

_ 8-6 4/25/02 NMC
WL

! 9-1 9-2 10-1 _ ^ 12/14/01 3/21/00 NMC NMC NMC _ YPY YPY
WL

_

^

14-2 ^ 3 10-3

3/21/00

NMC

W1_

12/13/99

NMC

WL

__._ _ 10-4 11/10/99 NMC Wt

10-5

9/28199

NMC

WL

^

^ ^^

between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Dacument concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Dacument concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to I'stigatian· Document related to litigation. Dacument related to Iltigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Dacument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communlcations between client and attorney. Dacument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document concerning [egai advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related tv litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Dacument related to litigation.

AC, WP

AC, WP

WP _ WP
AC, WP

AC, WP

-

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

`^tef 10.6

Date ` · ^ 9/26/99

^ NMC

Authar(^s}

_ . Reci,pient(s}
_ WL

Dirscription
_ Document concerning legal advice and

`Privilege{s}
Claimed

AC, WP

10-7

9/24/99

NMC

WL

_ 11-1 3/17/07 NMC WL

_ __

13.-3

7/5/00

NMC

WL ^

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to [itigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confiidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including con#identiaE comrnunicatians
between client and attorney. Document

AC, WP

_ AC, WP

AC, WP

1f-4

7/1/00

NMC ·

WL

related to Eitlgatian. Document concerning legal advice and including con#idential communications between client and attorney. Document
related to litigation.

AC, WP

11-5

5/4/00

NMC

WL

11-6

5/13/00

NMC

WL

Z1-7 ^^ ^^ E^ ^ ^.

5/13/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to IiCsgation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Dacument concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to liti anon.

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

1

Ref : < 3.1-8

:ate x/15/00 NMC

Auttlo^(s^

'Recipient(s.) ::` _ WL

^

^ !]escription'

17-9 13.-9

2/10/nn 1Z/31/99

NMC NMC

Trademark attorney in Taiwan WL

Document concerning lega3 advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation involving PricePlay Document concerning legal advice and including confdential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.
nocument concerning legal advice and

Privileges} .. Claimed AC, WP

WP AC, WP

i ti .^

11-9

12/34/59

NMC

WL

AC, WP

_
11-3.0 11/to/99 NMC

_ __
WL

__ _

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, _
Document concerning legal advice and AC, WP

_

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document 11-11
9/27/99

IyMC

_ WL ^

related to litigation.
Document concerning legal advice and AC, WP

11-12

9/28/99

NMC

WL

12

6/14/99

SS

WL, NMC

13 ^ ^ ^ ^
^,.^-.d

Q6/10/1999 10/04/2002

WL, NMC, 55

WL, NMC, SS

including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice anti including confidential communications between Client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document Concerning legal advice and includng confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

AC, WP ^ 'R i AC, WP

A/C, W/P, TPM

Ref" ... --

Date

^

Author(s) ^

}^ectpienf ( s] -

^-^

Desci·Eption^

^

Privilege(s) Claimed

14

06/14/1999

55

NMC

^^

15

06/28/1999

WL

NMC

between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and ircluding confidential communications between client and attorneY· Document related to litigation.
DQCUment concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM .
A/C, W/P, TPM

,,^

16

11/10/1999

NMC

WL

__ 17 -1 5/7/02 NMC
WL

_

including confidential eammunieations between client and attorney, Document _ related to litigation.
Document Concerning legal advice and

_ AC, WP

_

-

17-2

9/19/01

NMC

WL

17-3

8/21/01

NMC

Wt

17-4

4/30/01

NMC

WL I

r^ ^ ^ ^ .----^ t ^} ^^

17-5

4/6/01

NMC

WL

including confidentia! communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to iitigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential wmmunicatians betweers client and attorney . Document _ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between Client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confiderstial communications

AC, Wp

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

Etef

^

Date. ^^^. .

^

I

AuxEi^^r (s) ,' ' ^

Recipient(5^
..

^ Description
^ between client and attorney, Document

Privilege(s) Claimed

.^ ^
_

__ 17-6 3/20/01 NMC WL

17-7

9/28JD0

NMC

WL

__ 7.7-5-9 6/5/OD NMC WL

^

_ related to litigation. Document concerni^^ legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice. and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legaE advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney , Document

_ AC, WP

AC, WP \,_..

AC, WP

17 -10

_ 4/24/00

__
NMG

WL

related to litigation. Document Concerning legal advice and
including confidential communications

_ AC, WP

17-1122

3/13/00

NMC

WL

17-13-

2/16/00

NMC

Wl_

15

17-1619

1/17/DO

NMC

WL

E"-P"i

17-20 ""^

12/29/99

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between cllent and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.l7ocumeni related to litigation. Document concerning legs! advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and Including confidential communications

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

1 vl a i

^^ Ref ^ ^

^

'Date :...

.

. ·.

Authdr ( s} .

. ..

Recipient(sj
^:. _

^.

Description

-

,: .

^^ Pr'iviiege^sj ..'Cla irned

between client and attorney. Document

18-1

9/10/Q1

NMC

WL

18-2

4/23/07.

NMC

WL

18-3

4/6/pl

NMC

WL

18-4-5

1].16/00

NMC

WL

1$-6-7

3/13/Qi]

NMC

WL

18-811

2/16/Oq

NMC

WL

18-1214 ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^

1/2fi/00

NMC

WL

18-15t^

12/6/99

NMC

WL

related to litigation, _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and induding confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney , Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document cancernina Isgal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related tv litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

AC, WP

Ref '

Date

':. A^uthor (sj

:· ^ Reciplent^s ). ^ .

.... .: Descr^ptian :^. Between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document reated to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and lndud 'sng confidential communications between , client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications Between client and attorney. 1ocument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between cliern and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document
related to [itigation.

Privilege{s^' .. =CEaimed.

^ 39 12/13/1999 01/17 /2002 NMC WL

A /C, W/1', ^'PM

21 22

12/ 13/1999 32/ 14/3999

NMC NMC

N/A T
WL

W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM

_.,

23-1

9/10/01

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

23-2

4/ 23/01

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

23-3

4/ 6/01

NMC

Wl.

A /C, W/P, TPM

_ __ 23-g-5 11/6/00 -^ NMC WL

__ A/C, W/P, TPM

_^._ _ 23-5-7 ' ^^ ""^^ ^ 3 / 13/00 NMC WL

^. 23-8 3/3/04 ^J NMC WL

-^

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney , Document reated to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

J 1^^ i f

' Ref i^ ^, :. ^ , ^ : ..:;... I

Date ^ :° ..

'^ Author(5j . ..

^

·Ftecipiei^t( s}·'

Descri^tian^^ '.^ . : ^

_

.. :.: ... . ;,:

^^

.:: ' ..,..

:.

including confidential communicatons between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and
including confidential communications

Privilege{s)` . G#ai cried,:.

_ 23-911 2/],6/00 NMC W!.

A/C, W/P, TPM

23-1.214

1/26/00

NMC

WL

24-1

1129/01

NMC

WL

_ Z4-2 11/30/00 NMC WL

NMC _____-..... 24-3-4 615/00 WL

24-5

3/23/00

NMC

WL

24_6-7

3/13/00

NMC

WL

^

^

24-8-10

2/x6/00

NMC

WL

between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Dacument concerning legal advice and inciuding con#idential communicatians between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and includingconfidentlal communications between client and attorney. Document reiated to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legai advice and including confidential communicatians between client and attorney, Document _ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Dacument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and 'sncluding canfidentiai Communications between client and attorney. Dacument related to litigation, Dacument concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P, TPM

,^

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM ,^^ , A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

_^

i

.

(^I ^^ V
E

itef.

^.^^^ DaCe
....

AU41ior(s} ^'.

liecipient{s)

^.

^

Description ^ Y

Privilege{s)
Claimed.

24-11-13

2/9/00

NMC

WL

24-14-15

2/5/Otl

NMC

WL

_ 24-16 2/5/04 NMC WL

___

25-1

9/26/02

1VMC

WL

25-Z

7/9/01

NMC

WL

25-3

3/Z/Ol

NMC

_ ^ WL

25-Q

7/1x/00

NMC

WL

["^ ^

Z5-S

4/17./00

NMC

WL

including confidential communications between client and attorieey. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and incuding confidential communications between G[ient and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to lltlgatlon. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to lltlgatlon. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, 7PM

_,

_ A/C, W/P, TPM

AC, WP, TPM

^ AC, WP, TPM

AC, WP, TPM

AC, WP, TPM

AC, WP, 7PM

R;wf

'1]'2te '.^ ^

Authsir( s)

^

^

:Recipient ( s)

^ Description

^
. ,..

... _

:`Privilege{sJ
. , Claimed

__ 25-6-7 3/13/00 NMC WL

25-$

,10/$/02

NMC

Jfi, WL

_ 26-1 9/27/02 NMC
1T, WL

26-2-3

9/26/07.

NMC

JT, WL

.^ i"^

26-4 26-5 26-6-7 26-8-4 Z6-101S 26-1214 6-i56 6-17$ 6-19-

7/2/01 3/2/01 2/28/01 7/12/00 7/4/00 7/5/00 . 6/22/00 6/z1/^ 6/21/00

HQ Ji' NMC NMC HO

NMC NMC HO HO NMC NMC NMC _^ HO _ HO

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attomey. Document re#ated to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation, Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. _ Document related to litigation. _ Document related to litigation.

AC, WP, 7PM

AC, WP, TPM

_, l

__ _ AC, WP

AC, WP

WP WP WP WP WP WP WP WP WP

Hp
HO NMC NMC

^1 i 1 ^ 1
S

^Ref.^
18

l]at2^ ^-:.

^. Author^sJ : ...

. .Recipient(sj:
.._.

:

^

Desc^ip#ian .

___...... 26-17 1& 27-1 6/21/00 9/26/07_ NMC NMC I-10 WL

P.rivilege(s) Clainietl --`WP
A /C, W/P, TPM

Document related to litigation. Document concerning Eegal advice and including confidenti :.: _ ommunicatians between client and attorney. Document _ related to litigation. T Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communicat'r'ons between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between cient and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

27-2

S /21/01

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

27-3-4

1 11/14/01

WL

NMC

A /C, W/P, TPM

I 27-5 S /2/01 NMC WL

A/C, WJP, TPM

27.6

11/ 13/00

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

27-7

10/ 16/00

NMC

WL

_ A/C, W/P, T'PM

' 27-8 ^ ^ l^ ^ ^ Z7-9

9 /12/00

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

_ 5 / 30/00

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

P ^^

.

i

Ref :? ..

Date .. ,. ..

'^' Author{sJ ^... ^. . _ ._

Rec 's^pient ( s) ^.^

^-^^

Description ^

Rriv^lege(s) . CJaimed^^:

27-10

5/16/00

WL

NMC

28-1

10/4/OZ

NMC

WL

28-2

9/30/02

' NMC

_ __ WL

includin ronfldeniial communications between client and attorney , Document related to litigation. Document concerning Icgal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. . Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Dacurnent related to litigation. Document concernint; legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document
related to ]itigatian.

A /C, W/i^, 7PM,

A/C, W/P, TpM

A /C, W/P, TPM

_

28-3

9 / 28/02

NMC

WL

28-4

4/ 17/02

NMC

WL

28-5

8 /13/01

NMC

WL

Z8-6 ^ ^ ^ ^ ,,^ .. 28-7
^- ^^/^ i

8 /28/00

NMC

WL

6 / 5/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential comnlunitations between client and attorney . Document related to litigat'san. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

A /C, W/P, TPM

A /C, WJP, TPM

A/C, W/P, FPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

^.

Ref

^ ^I)ate

Author(s)

Recipierif(s).

^^

Descriptldn :.

^

Privilege(s)

Y
2i3,$

._ NMC WL

5/31/00

29-1

9/13/00

NMC ^

WL

Z9-2

4/13/00

NMC

WL

30-1 30-z 303 30-4

10/13/04
10/11/04

Honesty & Patent
Honesty & Patent

PJE
PJE

including con#identiai communications between client and attorney. Document related tv litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including cvrsfidential communications between client and attorney. _ Document concerning legal advice and including con#idential communications between client and attorney. __ Document related to litigation,
Document related to litigation,

r

A/C, W/P, TPM

AC

AC

WP
WP

10/13/04 10/6/04

30-5 30-5-7

10/19/02
10/18/02

PJE 5e-Chang Kang, Korean patent Counsel NMC NMC

Honesty & Patent NMC

Document related to litigation, Document related to litigation.

WP WP

YPY YPY, WL

30-8-9

10/17/02

NMC

YPY, WL

L. ^^^

^^ ^^ i°^^i ^ -^..^

34-1011 30-1213

20/17/02 9/25/02

YPY NMC

NMC YPY, WL

Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation, Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

WP WP

AC

WP AC, WP

·itef

D,ate .

^°

.

Author( s) ^ · ^

Recipient(s)

^

>]escription^ .. ^

^ Prlvilege(s} . Claimed .

30-14 30-15 30-16 30-1719 30-20-

7/x9/02 7/7.9/02 4/17/02 12/29/01 12/26/01 1x/25/01 12/24/01 12/14/01 12/14/07.
IZJ9/01

YPY YPY YPY YPY

NMC

T

NMC __ NMC NMC NMC' NMCi YPY YPY YPY YPY NMC
NMC

between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. __ Document related to lirigation. Document related td litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. ^ Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Documentrefatedtofitigatlan. Document related to Iltigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation,
Document related to litigation.

WP _ _ WP
WP

__ -

WP WP WP WP

30-21
30-22-

Honest & Patent__ _ YPY NMC NMC NMC NMC YPY
YPY

_

Z3
30-24 30-25· 2& 30-2732 30-33^_ __ RA WP WP WP WP
WP

11/15/01
13/15/01

34
30-3537 30-38 30-3940 31-1 _. . 11/14/01 11/1/01 10/4/02 NMC Honest & Patent NMC Honest & Patent NMC -Wl __ . Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legs! advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to Iltigation. Document concerning legal advice and

WP WP ^ A/C, W/P, TPM

^^ ^^ ^^ r'°^°`1 ^

31-Z

9/30/02

NMC

Wl.

A/C, W/P, TPM i
A/C, W/P, TPM

31.3

9/26/02

NMC

WL

Ref

Date ,... ^

Author(s) _ , ^ ,.^

^l^ecipient (s)

^flescriptian

31-4

9/17/02

NMC

WL

31=5

8/13/01

NMC

Wi

^. 31-6 8/28/00 NMC
WL

^ including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. u owment related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legs[ advice and including confidential communications k^etween client and attorney. Document
related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

__

Privileges} `Claimed I A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

__
A/C, W/P, TPM

31 -7

10/4/02

NMC

WL ^

__ A/C, W/P, TPM

31-$

6/5/02

NMC

WL

31-5

5/31/07.

NMC

WI_

^

32

10/29/2002

NMC

WL

33 :.^ t

12/27/2002

NMC

W[.

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning fegai advice and including confidential communications between client and atiarney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to liti anon. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Documen# concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P, rPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TpM

A/C, W/p, TPM

1

^Ref^.

^

^^ Date ' ^ .

^ _

Author ( sj

Rec^pierit( s^.^ _

Uescriptidn :

^^

^ ^ Ri·ivifege(sJ .` Cla^mecE^

_ 34 06 / 12/2003
NMC

WL

35

07/22/2003

_ WL

_ NMC

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal^advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document refated to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and
including confidential communieat'sons between client and attorney , Document

A/C, W/P, TPM

_ A/C, W/P, TPM

36

12 / 02/2044

_^ NMC

WL

^

37

12/ 03/2004

NMC , WL

WL, NMC

38

12 / 03/2004

WL

NMC .

_ 39 12 / 03/2004 NMC, WL WL, MC

40 ^X ^ ""^""' ^ ^ :,^ 41

12 / 13/2004

NMC

WL

09/17/x005-

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

refated to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document refated to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document refated to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Oacument concerning legal advice and including con idential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and

A /C, W/P, TPM

A /C, LN/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TAM

Af C, W/P, TPM

i i

A/C, W/P, TPM

1

Ref ^ ^

:· pate 09/20/2005

^ . Author(s)

Recipient (s)

description including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document related to litigation . Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

I

Privilege ( s)
Clamed - ^ .

^ . -.

42 i 43 44

09/17/200509/23/2005

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

A/C, W/P, TPM

10/06/2005 } 12/20/2005

NMC WL

N/A

_

W/P, FPM
A/C, W/P, TPM

NMC

45

1 1Z/22/Z005

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

46

i ^ 02/02/2006

NMC

WL

_ 47 OZ/08/2006 NMC, WL WL, NMC

4&1

3/3/07

NMC

WL

^_ _ _`___ 48-2 ^ ^ 2/26/07 NMC WL

related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document =oncerning legal advice and including confidentia! communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and incuding confidential communications between client and attorney. Oacument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. pacument concerning legal advice and including confidentia! communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

_ A/C, W/P, TAM

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

Ref . 4$-3

Aate . .,;.:....... 2/Z6/07 NMC

Author ( s) WL

Recipient ( s)

Description ` ..

^ ^

u 49.1 2J2b/07 ^ WL NMC

_

49-2

2/26/07

WL

_ .NMC

49-3

2/2b/07

WL

NMC

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to Ittigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related tolitigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between silent and attorney. Document

Prlvllege^s} Claimed A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

__ A/C, W/P s

A /C, W/P

50-1

2/27/07

WL

NMC

50-2

2/27/07

WL

NMC

SO-3

i 2/27/07

WL

NMC

°^ m
!^ ^ t ^ ^ ^^

related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, bacument concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related tolitigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related tolitigation.
Document concerning legal advice and

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

5^

02/27/2007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.

V

Ref

^

D^t'E^^ ^ ^

^Authar( s) .. ..^ WL :,

sx

.-:' 03 JDZ/ x007

Recipient ( s) ^

^

^

Description.

NMC

53

03/05/x007

WL

NMC

5^4

03/Q6/2007

WL

NMC

55

03/06/2007

NMC

_ WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document ronrerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. __ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

`Privilege(s) Claimed A/C, W/P, TPM

T ^^^

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

.A/C, W/P, TPM

56

03/07/2007

WL

NMC

57

03/Q7/x007

NMC

WL

_ related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. Document

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

58

03/11/x007

NMC

WL, VI.S

°°^^ 59-1 ^ ^ 3/13/07 WL

NMC

related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation.

A/C, WJP, TPM

A/C, W/P

, ·.

a ^'^

. Ref ^ ..

bate ^ 3/3.3/07

..

, ^ .. WL

Author ( s)

. ,..., ^ Retip^ent ( s^' _ ,. NMC

..Description .. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. pocument related to litigation.
Document concerning legal advice and

59-2

'Atiy^lege(s}`: GlaE^ned^: A/C, W/P

..

50-1

3/13/07

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P ,^ A /C, W/P

_

_

50-2

3/13/07

NMC

WL

61-1

3/17/07

NMC

WL, VLS

A/C, W/P

61-2

3/17/07

NMC

w -^

WL, VL5

A/C, W/P

_ 62 43/17/Z007 '
WL NMC

A/C, W/P, TPM

63

03/17/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

^

including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation.
Document concerning legal advlCe and

A/C, W/P, TPM

^` ^ i^ ^

54

43/17/2007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to litigation.

' Ref ^ .^
65

^

Date

', Author,'( s^^^^ NMC WL

Recipient { s^ ,

Description =,

^

Privilege{sJ
A /C, W/P, TPM

03 / S7/2007

66

03/20/2007

WL

NMC, VI_S

__ 67 03J20/ 2007 NMC WL

68

43 / 21/2.007

WL

NMC, VL5

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document
related to litigation.

A /C, W/P, TPM

_ A/C, W/P, TPM

.^

A /C, W/P, TPM

69

03/26/2007

iVMC

WL, VLS

70

03/26/2007

WL

NMC, VL5

71

03/28/2007

WL

NMC, VL5

' 72 74 03 / 29/2007 03 /30/2007 JLL NMC NMC WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to Eitigation, Document concerning legal advice and incuding confidentia communications between client and attorney . Document re{ated to litigation. Document related to litigation . Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

W/P, TPM A/C, W/P, TPM

r--^-^4

.^ ^ ]

Ref ^:^^

^,...Uate

^

^ AdtE^or( s)

Recipient ( s).:

D.escrlptinn _^ related to litigation. Document cancerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document cancerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and nclud 'sng confidential communications between client and attorney. pacument related to litigation. _ Document cancerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document ___ related to litigation. Document related to litigation . Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications 1}etween client and attorney. Document related to litigation. _ Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications _

Privilege(s)

^: .

Claimed; A/C, W/P, TPM

.

75

03/30/2007

NMC

WL, VL5

76

03/30/x007

WL

NMC, VLS

A/C, W/P, TPM

77

03/30/2007

NMC

WL, VLS, JLL

A/C, W/P, TPM

78

03/30/2007

WL

NMC, VLS, JLL.

A /C, W/P, TPM

79

03/30/x007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

80
82

03 /30/2007 05 /01/2007

NMC WL

VLS, JLL NMC

W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P, TPM

^83 ^ ^

05 /01/2007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

^'E

84

OS /03/2007

NMC

WL

A /C, W/P, TPM

^

tl
i

' Ref .

:' ':^nate

Author ( s) ^^

., ^

.;:

^

Re[ipient ( sj

Description
between client and attorney, Document

.

Pri^ilege(sj

85

05 /09/Z007

WL

NMC

$5

05/18/2007

NMC

WL

87

07/04/Z007

NMC

WL

__ 88 10/02 /2007 NMC
WL

_

84

10 /D2/2007

WL

NMC

9D

10/03/2007

WL

NMC

9J,

1D/05/2007

NMC

WL

^^ f;"^ ^ 92

10 /05/2007

WL

NMC

related to litigation. Document concern "sng legal advice and including confidentia communications between client and attorney . Rocument related to l itigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and ..t^arney. Dacument related to litigation. Rocument concerning legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential comrnunlcations between client and attorney . Document related to litigation, pocument concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and Including confidential communications Between client and attorney . Rocument related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

i

^1

Ref

Date .

Author ( s)

·^

Recipient(s) ...

D"escription. between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document
related to litigation.

^ Priwiege{s) ''.Claimed

93

1Z / 17/2007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/P, TPM

94

06/11/Z 008

WL

NMC

95

06 / 14/20D8

NMC

WL

_ 95 10/26/Z008 Christin Ciao NMC

97

10/ Z7/Z008

WL

NMC

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to itigatian. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation· Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney . Document related to litigation.

A /C, W/P, TPM

A /C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

A/C, W/P, TPM

i

^_ ^^

^^