Performance Pricing, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al
Filing
241
MOTION to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP by AOL LLC, Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Joint Stipulation Regarding Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP, # 2 Declaration of Emily C. O'Brien in Support of Motion to Compel, # 3 Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit K, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Declaration of Christin Cho in Opposition to Motion to Compel, # 20 Errata 1, # 21 Exhibit 2, # 22 Exhibit 3, # 23 Proposed Order Granting Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel)(O'Brien, Emily) Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ). Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ).
x y
Dockets.Justia.com
^ A088 Rev , f21D7^ St,bnoena in a Civil Casc
-"
^ss^ted by the
UNITED STATES D^STR^CT COURT
Central District of Performance Pricing, Inc_ California
SUBPOENA IN A CIVIL CASE V.
Google Inc . ; AOL LLC; Microsoft Corp. ; Yahoo ! Znc.; IAC Search ^ Media , Inc_; and A9.com, IneTQ: Neal M. Cohen 2fl40 Main St ,, 9th Floor Irvine, CA 92619 1 YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear in the United States District court at the place, date, and lime specifed below to testify in the above case.
PLACE OF TESTIMONY COURTROOM
Case Nt.tmber: ^ 2:07-cv-432 (LED} (Eastern District of Texas)
DATE AND TIME
^ YOU ARE COMMANDED to appear at the place, date, and time specified below to testify at the taking ofa deposition
PLACE OF DEPOSfTION
DATE AND TIME
X, .
YOU ARE COMlv'ANDED to produce and permit inspection and copying ofthe followingdocuments orobjects at the place, date, and time specifed below (gist documents or objects):
See ATTACHMENT A
PLACE
DATE AND TIME
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart Oliver & Hedges, LLP 665 Figueroa Street, 10th Floor Los An eles, CA 90017
November 6, 2006 10:30 a.m.
i . _^ YOU ARE COMMANDED to permit inspection of the following premises at the date and time specifed below. PR£MlSES DATE AND TIME
Any organization not a party to this suit that is subpoenaed for the taking of a deposition shall designate one or more officers, directors, or managing agents, or other persons who consent to testify on its behalf, and may set forth, for each person designated, the matters on which the person wilt testify. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30{b)(5).
[f^UINCs.OFFiCf:,t{'S ,${S'iNp,TUR^ AND T1TL6 (INDICATE !F ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF OR DEFENDANT) I DATE
for ^g le Inc_, AOL LLC, and IAC Search & Media ^ tone ISSUMG 0 tCER'S NAME, ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER
^lulZZ1200^
Emily C. O'Erien 50 California St., 22nd Floor, San Francisco, CA 99111, Tel. (4^.5} 875-6323
(See Federal Rulc orGvil Procedure 45 (c), (d), and (c}, an ncxt pagc) t [faclian is pending in district oUier than district of issuance, s[aIt district corder case number. / s .^ H ^ B iT r /^
PAGE
_..,
AO$$
ev. f 1J07 Sub cena in a Civil Case Pa e 2
PROOEOF SERVICE
BATE Pi^CE
SERVED
SERVEQ ON (PR]NT NAME) MANNER OF SERVICE
SERVEQ BY {PRINT NAME)
TITLE
DECI ARATION OF SERVER
f declare under penalty of perjury under the Laws of the United States of Arrlerica that the foregoing information contained in the Proof of Service is true and correct.
Executed on
BATE SIGNATURE OF SERVER
ADpRES50FSERVER
Federal Rufe ofCivil Procedure 45 {c}, (d), and (e), as amended on December I, 2007:
([) PaO7E[7[NGA PEtLSnti SLLIrLT70A Snarnar,^
(t) Avoiding Undue $urdrn or Expense ; Sanctions . A parry or anomcy responsible for issuing and saving a subpoena must take [easgnable steps to avoid imposing undue burden o[ ta^cnse oa a person subject to the subpoena . The issuing court must enforce this duty and impost an appropriate sanction -which may include lost comings and rwsonable anorneys fees - on a party or anomey who fails to wmply. (2) Command to Produce Mazerials err Permit Inspection. {A) Appearance Nat Required . A person cortunanded to produce documents, nor appear in person at Fhe pla « of production or inspection tudess also convnandrd to appear for a depas^tive , hearing, or trial. {B) Objections . A person wmmanded to produce documents or tangible things or to permit inspection may serve ve the party or attorney dcsignatcd in the subpoena a wtincn objection to inspcctiag , copying, testing or sampling any or all of the materials or to inspec[irtg the premiss - or to producing clcc7vnically siortd ivformatign in the farm or fomu requested. The objcctitm muss be saved before the earlier of the tvae specified for compliance or i4 days aNer the subpoena is served . If an objective is mode, the following Hilts apply: (t^ At any time, on nosice to the commanded person, the serving parry may move the issuing court for an order compelling production or inspection. (ii} These acts may be required only as directed in the ceder, and the order must protect a person who is neither a party nor a parry's afSctr from sigtrirrrartt expense resulting from tomplian«, (3) Quashing or Modifying a Subpoena, {q) When Required. On tamely motipn , the issuing cotut must quash a modify s subpoena that: () fails to allow a reasonable time to comply; (ii) requires a pawn who is neither a party ear a partys officer to cave] more than 100 milts from where tlut pasga resides, is employed, or regularly transacts business in person - except that, subjat to Rulc 45(e}(3}(Bxiii), the person may tie commanded to anerd a trial 6t' 7dvcling from any such pla« within the slate where the trial ^ held; (ii) rcquires disclosuxa of privileged or orbs yrvteUCd waver, if no exception o[ waiver appGcs; or {iv) subjecu a person to undue hiadcn. {l3) lYhen Permined. To protect a person subject to or afrerxed 6t' a subpoena, the issuing won may, on motion, quash or modify the subpoena if i[ requires: () dixlosing a trade sacra or other wnfidcntiaE researdr , dcvelopmrnl, or cammacial information; ( ii) disclosing an urvrtaincd txpcrYs opinion err infommGon that dots not dcsrnbe sptciRe azureaus in dispute and resuhs from the expenk study that was not requested by a parry; or (iii) a person who is neither a party nor a party 's officer to incur substantial cxpursc m travel more than E00 milts [ o ancrtd trial (C) Specifying Conditions ffi as Alternative. ] n the eircians[ances described in Rule 45(c^3x8 ), the rant may, instead of quashing or modifying a subpoena , order appwran« yr
(^ shows a substantial rsccd for the te5rimgny or material that cannot be otherwise mtt without undue hardship; and (ii}ensures that the subpoenaed person wi11 b< reasonably compensated. {d) D trrrrs t.M R rsronornc ro w S uvvouti (]) Producing Documents or &]caroaically Stored Information. These procedures apply tq producing documents or rkevvnically stored information: (A) Documents. A person responding to a subpoena to prodv« datatmenls must produce them as they arc kept in the grdinary· course of business qr must prganiar sad label them to correspond [o the categories in the demand. (B) Form for Producing ElectronicaEly Stored ] nfornation NW Specified. ]f a subpoena does not specify a form far producing electronisalty stored information , the person responding must product it in a form yr forms in which it is ordinarily maintained or in a reasonably tssablc form err forms. (C) Electronically Stored ]nfomtarion Produud in Only One Fora . The .pcrsoa responding need no[ produce the same e [ cctronieally stored information in more than one form. {D) Inaccessible Electronically Stored [ nformativn . The person responding need not provide discovery of eleci32 A Sa'15,31^ A 5,7981U1 A
$(1998 Watberetai »,....._..__'14551zi
5,816,9I8 A · 1Q'1998 YsttY d aL .......-..._..... 4d3p6
1211998 OvftL^betd al. ......m^ 7(15114 Sr8sS;006 A 516014 A ` 6:'1999 ' IRm1Cc5aa ..,....»..,. 463!40
6O61 ,66U A · 611G, It1 Sl · 511000 F^cmoa d d ^..«.. 705114 tmvl 'WiQCrda1 . .......__^ 705!14
Forlelcll^ FA'#^t1' nocv^l^rls
W4
Ab¢sfncts modr;VPtooess is Qcsmbcdforcanductiugt>^RCA mn^ 6Var U1C illtCmt4 atlawiag buyac to tsduca Qw prior of the sciccicd ptodnd/servicc based oa !hc puper's^ pedmgaricc dwine a couitcrat aativiry. sand olict the prodnc4lsvavicc W3^ : alxd6rd F^ ^IIr ^ buycts accept 0r^ afftt, iu q[cbangc far tim Opgartnnily to clan tht t:aw ^1 the Iaavest prieb olfeted by achicvfng s 4igh smte daang.the wDsteral aetiviry. The nISmast ptlec & within elr: agrted upaa + anSe. but is a^-....r..-a baKd upaa the boytt's pedatmapct dIItioy the collatUai assiviry. Ttc activity may be a vidca firma , e]ccaamic board gain(, :pacts bvt, tact pssne, ar nay oUs:?eofslana
202
2zac
Buyer patabau3
2 I^d
te1 (erAccaunt ,
t3atebas
2I4 i
Payment fnfa 8uyerAccount
patabaee Oatabas
2I4e 2I4J
.,
Cq
4 '`:. '^ ' ^^^.
'^ i w
PItoB Acceptance Database
Buyer i:ngagement Hfstary patebas
^r 7 =
m^
^^ G^g ^' ^,,e"^ ^^
^ S ^
^ D FC Ctl ^ ^ ·Qw^" .^, .^Y ^ N h04 " C.^ ^ {^'^ ^ ^ li' Q {^^ 'L ^^^ p p p
^ S
°°'^' M
^'' R g^`'* ° y ^ ^^ ^ ^k7. "y_6.^L^9 ^r crn ^' ^,
^^^ ^, b @ ^
^n
B
8 ^.
^^ O
fir'
Fri 6 tl 4A S
pg ^ ^Av° °'^. ^ ^ ^'^^^yy ^^g
a
a ^qj
^7'
i''
^
^'q^ ^ Ei '$ ^ ^$. "^'^ ^, ^
N a eQ^F^ ^ ^" t^ s }i R^
F
^ ^^ M
^
^
w.
f^ia^ I.J ' st' F_ ^^^^ "jj ^'
M" 6 }C^q eQ. ·R ^^^^. Q ^ J^ fc' ^X' ^ ,8i S ^^'
^'
D ^' ^17 8 ^ T^s ^ '" V ^^^ ,^'^^^
S
b ^yq^^ ^ R^^.f ^R ^^^ 1^7^gi F' $^Q¢y'^. ^7. ii^^ O'ff` ^ ^ ^ ^'. ^ ^ 8 ^ a ^ ^i M . ^40 ZJ' ^ ^ ^ ^ Ji r P s ^· ^ ph ^ i7 ^ ^, ^ S,` ^4^ ^ ^. ^^" ,g ^ ^o ^R¢q ^ ·a MO^ ^'^ ^ ^ }. '^a 4' ^
^i. .d :8 6 ^a' a fi
^^
r S
^^ 8 ^'g" ^^
o^ s z am
^^R^
ffi ^ N ^^{ j^, iiEE P^ ^ 23. ^r^, ·^ `^ " ^
{ ^^^L^.^^^^'^ {QQ tt^ .
^^ Y^ 6B{' .^^, rpp6' ,pf^,,^ ^ny'^$^^`" °o
"r ^`a ^aa
'^,^o^
oa o Q^
^i
CCl7
^
as
0.F
w
^ " ^ ,b ^^ ^ K
"h^s^ o ^od^ ^e
^, ^
A. ^ c^E g^^.^^^a a
ro^G g^^^^^ ^ti^pg^^.R "^^'^'^^^ ,, N^Q q" ·en^r g' ^a5 ^^n
N
f
^^y+^a ^^ ^^,$^y771·b6s^^ ^^ ^. ^ ^ e a c^' [r^."^ ^ ^^ ,^
a^^n '^
^+
q
^$^^^roF^^A .^F'·'^^^^'^n.^'^°~^ .R^
^,, ^
9911 445KIi ^ ^ 'e
^ ^ cL E'· ^' ^'^ ^ '^ p' .^^ ^ 'n : C,^^
S^^M^^^ 8^'^ ·^ ^` ^^+^^'
^
" 8^^$^tr
R
R'
$R ^i,^ i F " ^s^ ^^
^ ^aB. ^o'eg'8
·^
'
^ ti W tl ^' ^ ryp^ F^ [yry ^ ^i7 s6 p' ^· ^i .^ ^ ^ 9a 8 ti ^· p 7f F'' ^^ ^ ^{ 6 ^^ ^^^ C^ i aE ^^i` G Mp ^ a^ ^ ^ y}y^ ^]$ppE!^.^pp^ S' ^ d q *,
^iS ^^gjJ'
^^,^.
^, ' ^^^ ' 4 F'. ^ ^ El {7, a i a '7n ,F ,7. ° ^Q}t ^' ^ p ^' ^1] ^ ^ pp dO' ^. p, TTYJJJ ^ [p] tf r ^.
'
rT.': I^ ^d [R[7] Vi ^ ^ ^1^ ^ .®
w ^^
yy^^.
^ "^
^I ^ ^ by
^i' kap@f. ° ^ M y4 ^c^ r] ^ Q^t .ky "^f ^t ^y ^ R' :3 ^ w `C ^. p. ^n ^, ^.' F ^ ^. g· S' QC Ll ^(4 ^ Rc M ^a1 ^ g ^ (^ ^ pr, np ^ M MJg^ X '^ 7i iS r ^ .^ 'xr a.
r ¢z
dd ^ .^^R
C
^
g^'
^G
f.^ ^,^^^^g'
C· ,'yp
k1A,^
s
^^Gs
,^ o ^
^ "`lll
i g ^ ^ ^ ^. a. ·, ^ ^Y^ ^` '° ^ ^ ^' ^ ^^ `° A. 5 ^
^^·
9 ^: s^
^
a
^
yy
^a
^ WA 991y7
^
RR
^
^^^111 ^ iiiiii · ^ A ^ 99VV
a ^
y(BpQ^^
S
^
^·
,^^ ^ e $^$^-^w'A ^^^^'^^^ ^^ ^
s q $,}'^^i^C"a "^C'^B ^ `. {qt G p^^ . C1 *C^LL ^L' ^ ] ^E^ ^7 w^ ^ s^ ^ !^ ^ ^ ^rS V a^ ^ }S^.{., ^' Y_ fl ytl dV^,+^·^^iSy^G·^tl,^gy ^p"^^^^^,p .
^^^ ^ ^ ^'^^^ ^ F'N g
d^r
^ iY ^
^g·^^ @^^^ ^ ^'^ ^` tlp ^^ ^ N^ ^ ^^ ^
a ^ ^
`.r w . ^ p ^yy^ ^ ^a ^ lK q r ^' ^ WW ^ ^ ^ ^ Q' ^ M ,'9y. ^ O, /^ M p r ^tl
^
4e^
rp O y ^y ^ ^^ ^ ^y OT gp_ ^+ Q' ' ^ 3V ^ ^ } ^ ^1 O ^f+I W'^}QQj.^ $
h^ w '^
^
"'
R {1 .}9AA^
^G ^^
8 43 ^^^,q ^^
A'
E'^^
is a,i
pg
·a s
^^&
^ 'a.^~
^} iG , 1^ ^' fa jQ^ kT Q ^ ·C iiY ^,
R^aa ^e^'c^'gSµ^· ^,^ '^.^? y'^'',
'^^M ^^^^
'tS..
O
,,^Cx S ^ A ii
x
r
^ ^, f
^-^g'.°^^6^^,
y^+ u C^ ^i ^ p ,^ $ AAA o C. ^ ,^
w
^Qr g,^P ]^ i O. ^ '^ ^ ^ ^ ^. iF ^ IS. ^ ^ I4 V
^.
^ a^
s^
^ ^ ^. .!^ G M
" ^^' .^ '^, R.^^^^^R''^'S'^A eW^^
,
^a^
^e
o^^
^^
^^B
C> ri o
, g,
s
^«$.
^ ^C
.a
r x.$ ^p ^' p' ^r ^^^ ^ h^f I^ G tr
^ J
^ i{sg5^' ^.y ^ ^ ^.^+^^]y{ ^6'r ^i Q r ^ ^^S CE ^ ^Q'^ ^y p tt. ^nr ^ ^ ^ . o^ ^t ^ i$y7 ^ ^ ^ ^ .+ +p^ ]5 ·'C .S ^ · ^ o ^ ^J' ^ r ^n d ^ y a^^ ^a' tt ^^ ^ ^ ^· ^ ,1r^ ^R, p p ^y ^ s7 $ ^ ^ ^^ w '^ ^.^ ^ &e ^ 'i .., $^^. ^S q'A 1^ Z5' ^
^·
^
fie'
.^
~
^
~
^
P
w
^^ 6
R ^ ^ A Y' 4 ^C
^^^
^,^ ^^ ^^ ^ ^
p^ h- r5^q ^^µ^
^^^`^ ^^^
C^B^ s ^ c fix.. ^`^ ^ ^^^
^: ^
S
^,^' Q^^A R
°,^59. ;g^^a.
^^^.g
uRi
s
a' a ^ ^^·^
s
^^ a ..^^
B^ e ^ -
^^SC ObQ,
.M .
°^^^
^ ^^
^^^^^^^
^M' A .^7
G]
^^'^^ ^
^ r ^^^ ^r
a
^
^
t^
R^^^^^ ^ bR' ^^^ ^M^a^ ^ ^^^ ^ ^ ^^ ^^
^^QQee
'^.
.p ·^:^s^s^^ ^ .^ g ^^
^
.^'
'^^'^
a ^^^^.
f
^_
^^
`^
-`'
^^ ^
} ^^
f
'^^`^R' r+a.
, '^. ^s n ^·^'^'^^y.^^ a^ , S ^ITa ^
^
^
^ ^,, ' {p4^ ^, ^^r p
^
^
^
a
1 .^ 1f -,, ^ 10^^
6 OI ^^ ^'^
^^^^
S fi, ^* ^ ^ ^ V P
^".^R^ ^+1*7bf^?^^
^a
R ^ 8^^ S·^' 2t fi^. ^^^b^Ys
A
A· .fi.H fi^ c
^7 ^^^ S . S6R . i"^^' ^° ^^ $ R^ ^ ^ ii'a^^· L' ^1"E^6
N C
$
$' ^ ^ ° 'y+
,^ ,6 ,
^^^ ^^ ^`^ ^'^^ k .°. a^·^·°.R
M
^.
G'^ ^^^
O V'
.^
,ebb
^^^^
.z
·`^^
^.
^ ^:
A^^^ ^` ^^^`,^a
^R·^^^
R^
^a^
· $ .o
fz·F FI^^. G1'^ + + ^p^ 6^, ^i^ ,^S'^^`'^R· ^25
^, .1'^^8
np^ ^ .^^' ^` L 6^^ .^ '^
oe
^^ ^g
u ^, + " 1 ^^ ^ ap 'tl' ^
^
R.q
^^^ . ^'^ ^ _
" L',^^' ^,^^' 66 ^
^^, ^ ^," g^·^^^"
^
^,,
^ ·. ^
'ia'y^ ^'^1S ^
^^ ^
!i ^^
pp
·^^ ^ $ ,^ "^ ^^
.^'
G ^ N ^ RAJ ^ ^ ^ ^ L G'
^^ ^·°° q
O
,^
b ^' ^ ^ ^^ ^ig ^'.Ca ·,^'a^ Q^fl,^
spy.
w p.
P
^_
^^·^' k. ^n ^,^8 M·a^^ ^p.^^ n·a s R e ^1, · ?^'·
^^` ^'
. ^ ^·^ .w ·^^' ^^^a.F^ ^ ^ ^K ^^^·^ ·^ ^ a J' p 6 p
^·e^^85p',R' 8g
s+
ti c, ^ o ^ S ^ ·15 ^
^
s g
a
.^ ^·
n· ^ ^'·^ ^ a ^^ ^·^ g ^ ^ ^ ^ ^' a· ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ t ^ s ^' ii ^· : ^ ^ ^^
^.,7 = ^ ^ ^ ^' a· t^ ^
__
...................................................................................
^·^^p ^^ ^
0
E
A
^ ^^^ ^^^^
^
0:
N C M a
f^ ^ w },^^
'.
^^^^^^
^. ., ^ ^ ,a
^^a
^
apt
b^ ^K^ ^^
A6
^
^. ^.
^a ^^s^ a
i
,gam
·
sBdd
a ^ .3 ^ ^^ ^^ ^ ^P^.
^ ^ ^^^^
F
'!
^^ W
.
!I
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?