Performance Pricing, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 241

MOTION to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP by AOL LLC, Google Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Joint Stipulation Regarding Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel Production of Documents by Third Parties Neal Cohen and Vista IP Law Group, LLP, # 2 Declaration of Emily C. O'Brien in Support of Motion to Compel, # 3 Exhibit A, # 4 Exhibit B, # 5 Exhibit C, # 6 Exhibit D, # 7 Exhibit E, # 8 Exhibit F, # 9 Exhibit G, # 10 Exhibit H, # 11 Exhibit I, # 12 Exhibit J, # 13 Exhibit K, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Declaration of Christin Cho in Opposition to Motion to Compel, # 20 Errata 1, # 21 Exhibit 2, # 22 Exhibit 3, # 23 Proposed Order Granting Defendant Google Inc. and AOL LLC's Motion to Compel)(O'Brien, Emily) Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ). Modified on 9/25/2009 (sm, ).

x y x
Dockets.Justia.com

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS Performance Pricing, Inc. Plaintiff, v. Googie, Inc. et al., Defendants. 2:07-cv-432 (LEDj REVISED PRIVILEGE LOG CORRESPONDING T0:1) SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAL M. GOHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS;.AND 2} SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS

The Revised Privilege Log attached hereto as Exhibit A is being produced in connection with: 1^ RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY NEAL M. COHEN TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS; and 2} RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA COMMANDING NON-PARTY VISTA IP LAW GROUP LLP TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS. Ali documents identified in said Privilege Log are being withheld on the bases identified, and are not being produced. Abbreviations used in the Privilege Log: "NMC" means Neal M. Cohen; "WL" means Wayne Lin; "VLS" means Valerie L. Sarigumba, wha was at al) relevant times an associate attorney at Vista--IF-Eaw Group;

"JLL" means Jocelyn L. Lee, who was at all relevant times a senior paralegal at Vista IP
Law Group;

"HO" means Hidehiko Okada, who was at all relevant times an attorney at the law firm, Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "SS" means Samuel B. Stone , wha was at a!I relevant times a partner at Lyon & Lyon
LLP; "JT" means Jeff Tekanic, who was at all relevant times an attorney at the law firm,

Okada Patent & Trademark Office; "PJE" means Patricia J. English, who was at all relevant times an employee at Cohen,
5akaguchi & English LLP;

"YPY" means Yeo-Pyo Yoon, who was at all relevant times an attorney at Honesty &
Patent;

PAG E ^..^?Z._

^^^^

^^

"A/C" means a claim of Attorney/Client Privilege; "W/P" means a claim of Work Product; "TPM" means a claim of Trial Preparation Material.

EXHIBIT __J^ PRGE _-. ^^^ .

Ref
1-1

bate 8/2/2001 NMC

Author ( s) WL

Recipient(sy

Description Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

1-2

8/13/01

NMC

WL

A/C

1-3

3/29/01

NMC

WL

client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution for

A/C

1-4

1/12/01

NMC

WL

A/C

the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between 1-5
2/20/01 NMC WL client anrf attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for

, A/C

the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. 1-5
2/27/99 NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

confidential communications between client and attorney.
1-7 1/3/01 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecu#ion for the A/C

1-8

10/1/01

NMC

WL

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

^

^

^ C'^7 ^ .^. ^^

Re#

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient ( s) and attorney.

Description

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

1-9

12/13/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

1-10

11/15/03.

NMC

WL

purpose of Segal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

AJC

1-11

4/2/01

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

confidential communications between client and attorney. 1-12
7/28/00 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney. 1-13

5/SO/01

NMC

WL '

1-14

10/14/02

NMC

WL I

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

1-15

8/2/01

NMC

WL

1-16

11/30/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

_ A/C

A/C

.^ ;;a^^ ^^ ^ ^" ^^

i'

Re#

Date

Authors}

Recipient(s)

Description

Privilege(s)

Claimed 1-17 .10/27/99 NMC WL and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

1-18

6/7,/00

NMC

WL

confidentia! communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client and attorney.

A/C

1-19

4/18/02

NMC

WL

1-20

10/16/01

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

A/C

A/C

1-21

3/6/02

NMC

WL

1-22

7.0/9/01

NMC

WL

1-23

7/5/00

NMC

WL
'r

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentia[ communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal aavice and including
confidential communications between client

A/C

A/C

A/C

1-2^}

2/18/00

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

"^ E.^ ^^ ^ n1 W ^^ °..'^

.:.

Ref`

bate

Author { s)

Recipient ( s)

Description

Privilege{s} Claimed A/C

1-25

8/13/01

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

1-26

4/17/02

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

A/C

1-27

7/31/02

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

A/C

2-5

8/2/01

NMC

WL

2-6

8/13/01

NMG

WL

2-11

3/1.7/07

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

3-1

S/7/02

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

3-2

9/10/01

NMC

WL

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

^"7 ^

rn ^

^' ^c

Ref

bate

Author(s)

Recipient ( s^

Description and attorney. Letter concerning paten# prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including co nfidentia[ communications between client and attorney.

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

3-3

x/10/01

NMC

WL

3-4

8/21/41

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution forthe purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

3-5

NMC

WL

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

3-6

$/21/01

NMC

WL

3-7

5/2/01

NMC

WL

3-8

4/30/02

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerninb patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. _ Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution forthe
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

A/C

3-9

4/3/01

NMC

WL

3-10

4/6/01

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

confidential communications between client ^' ^7 ^ ^^
°^ 11.

Ref

Date

Author (sj

Recipient ( s)

Description and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentia[ communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidentia! communications between Client and attorney.

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

3-11

4/6/0#.

NMC

WL

3-1z

4/6/01

NMC

WL

A/C

3-13

3/z0/01

NMC

WL

A/C

3-14

1 /z^ /a 1

NMC

WL

A/C

3-15

11/30/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the

A/C

3-16

11/13/00

NMC

WL

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

3-17

11/S/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. 3-18
11/6/00 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client A/C

^

rn^ T^

_

Ref

Date

A^thar ( s}

Recipients]

İescription

Privileges} Claimed A/C

3-19

1p/^6/00

NMC

WL

and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

3-20

9/28/00

NMC

WL

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

3-2^

9/12/00

NMC

WL

3-22

6/5/00

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

3-23

6/5/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

3-24

x/30/00

NMC

WL

3-25

1/76/00

NMC

WL

3-26

4/24/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Let#er concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

A/C

confidential communications between client [^"'1 ^' ^ ^ ^_ ^W ^---- ^ ^' .

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient(s^

Description and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney,
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including

Privilege(sj

Claimed 3/23/00 NMC WL A/C

3-27

3-28

3/9/00

NMC

WL

A/C

3-29

2/9/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

confidential communications between client
and attorney.

3-3 ].

1/26/00

NMC

WL

3-33

1/26/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning foreign patent rights for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent rights for
the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

A/C

3-34

3/17/00

NMC

WL

3-35

12/6/99

NMG

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent rights for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

3-36

11/29/99

NMC

WL

A/C

confidential communications between client l^ ^ m^ ,^;^, ^6

I

Ref

Date

AutEtor ( s}

Recipients}

Description and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent^application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

Privileges} Claimed A/C

^F-1

10/1b/01

NMC

WL

4-2

$/14/01

NMC

WL

4-3

4/5/01

NMC

WL

Letter Concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning foreign patent application

A/C

A/C

4-4

1/19/01

NMC

WL

A/C

4-5

6/2&/00

NMC

WL

for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning foreign patent application

A/C

4-6

6/1/00

NMC

WL

A/C

4-7

2/15/00

NMC

WL

for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application
for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

4-8

12/21/99

NMC

WL

Confidential comm^^nications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential Communications between client

A/C

^ ^

^

Z
W °"^

i^

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient(s)

Description and attorney, Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between clierst

l^ri^ilege(s) Claimed A/C

4-9

12/13/99

NMC

WL

5-1

4/17/02

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.

A/C

5-2

8/13/07.

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

5-3

8/28/00

NMC

WL

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney,
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

5-^

6/5/Ofl

NMC

WL

A/C

confidential communications between client and attorney. b-1
7/9/01 NMC WL Letter concerning Japanese patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. A/C

6-2

3/2/01

NMC

WL

Letter concerning Japanese patent
application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.

A/C

6-3

3/z/O1

NMC

WL

Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice
and including confidential communications

A/C

^

^

m ^, -^--- ^

Ref

Date

Author(s)

Recipient { s) i ` WL

Description between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent
application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications

Privilege{s) Claimed A/C

6-4

'7/12/00

NMC

6-5

^/11/00

NMC

WL

6-6

4/iz/00

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and 'sncluding confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning Japanese patent
application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications

A/C

A/C

7-1

NMC NMC NMC NMC NMC NMC ^/Z7/00 1/Z/OZ NMC NMC

HO HO HO HO HO HO HO
WL

7-2 7-3
7-4

between client and attorney. Document related to Japanese patent application. Document related to Japanese patent
application.

A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C
A/C

Document related to Japanese patent
application.

7-5 7-6 7-7 8-1

Document related to Japanese patent application. Document rela#ed to Japanese patent
application.

8-2 ^ ^ ^ ^. ""^^ ^ ^ W °^

4/17/OZ

NMC

WL

Document related to Japanese patent application. Letter related to Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application

A/C A/C

A/C

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Reciplent ( s^

Description for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between Client and attorney.

Pri^iiege(s^

Claimed

$-3

4/17/02

NMC

WL

Letter concerning Korean patent application

A/C

for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, 8-4
NMC WL Document concerning Korean patent

A/C

application far the purpose of legal advice
and including confidential communications between client and attorney.

...

8-5

4/17/02

NMC

WL

Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

$-5

4/25/02

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Document related to Korean patens

A/C

9-1 9-2

NMC

YPY

A/C

7.2/14/01
3/2.1/00

NMC
NMG

YPY
WL

application. Document related to Korean patent
application. Document concerning legal advice and

A/C A/C

10-1

10-2

3/21/00

NMC

WL

including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and
including confidential communications

A/C

10-3

12/13/99

NMC

WL

between clien# and attorney. Dacumen# concerning legal research for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

^ ^

^ Z

mw ^^ ^

^^

Re#

Date

Author(s)

Recipient ( s) and attorney.

Description

Privilege(s) Claimed
A/C

10-4

11/10/99

NMC

WL

Document concerning licensing for the

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. 10-5
9/28/99 NMC WL Document Concerning licensing for the A/C

' 10-6 9/25/99 NMC WL

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning assignment far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Document concerning licensing for the

A/C

10-7

9/24/99

NMC

WL

A/C

11-1

3/17/07

NMC

WL

11-3

7/S/00

NMC

WL

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal invoices
including confidential communications

A/C

A/C

11-4

7/1/00

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Document concerning legal invoices
including confidential communications

A/C

11-5

5/4/00

NMC

WL

11-6 ._.. 7r .^C ^7 = P"r'I ^ ^^ .-^

3/13/00

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

A/C

A/C

Ref

Date

Author (s) _

Recipient(s)

Description between client and attorney. _

Privilege(s) Claimed

11-7

3/13/00

NMC

WL

11-8

2/16/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning #areign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Document related to Taiwanese patent application.

A/C

A/C

11-9

2/10/00

NMC

Trademark attorney in Taiwan

A/C

11-10

12/31/99

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal invoices
including confidential communications

A/C

between client and attorney.
11-11 12/14/99

NMC

WL

Letter concerning research for the purpose

A/C

Ik 17.-12 11/10/94 NMC WL

of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including eonfidential
communications between Client and attorney.

A/C

11-13

9/27/99

NMC

WL

1i-14

9/28/99

NMC

WL

12

6/14/99 X ^

55

WL, NMC

Document concerning representation far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communicatians between client and attarney. Letter concerning assignments for the purpose of Segal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications

A/C

A/C

A/C, W/P

^ ^

rn w, ('' 1 `

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipients}

Description between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to litigation. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and
including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document

Privileges} Claimed A/C, W/P

13

06/10/1999 10/04/2002

WL, NMC, SS

WL, NMC, 5S

14

06/14/1999

SS

NMC, WL

A/C, W/P
"^ _.

15

Ofi/28/1999

WL

NMC

related to litigation. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document
related to litigation.

A/C, W/P

^^

16

11/10/1999

NMC

WL

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney. DOCUrIIEnt

A/C, W/P

17-1

5/7/02

NMC

WL

related to litigation, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

17-2

9/19/01

NMC

WL

17-3

8/21/01

NMC

WL

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Natent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution far the

' A/C

A/C

17-4 ^' ^ ^^ {T='^4 W 1 ^

4/30/01

NMC

WL

A/C

^, ^-_ c

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipients )

Description purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

Privilege(s) Claimed

17-5

4/6/01

NMC

WL

A/C

17-6

3/20/01

NMC

WL

17-7

9/28/00

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

A/C

A/C

17-8-9

6/5/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

and attorney.
17-10 4/24/00 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the A/C

_

purpose of legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client
and attorney. 17-11-

3/13/00

NMC

WL

12

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

A/C

and attorney. 17-1315
2/15/00 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including A/C

confidential communications between client and attnrney. 17-16_°^ Ii ^
iC

1/17/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/G, W/P

^ ^

_ ^

1 '.

Ref 1g

Date

Author { s)

Recipient ( s)

Destriptian purpose of legal advice and including confidential communicatians between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communicatians between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legak advice and including
confidential communications between client

Privilege(s) Claimed

17-20

11/29/94

NMC

WL

A/C

1$-1

9/10/01

NMC

WL

A/C

and attorney. 18-2
4/23/01 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

18-3

4/6/01

NMC

WL

and attorney, Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including confidential communicatians between client and attorney.

A/C

18-4-5

11/6/00

NMC

WL

18-6-7

3/13/00

NMC

WL

18-811

2/16/00

NMC

WL

18-12-

1/26/00

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including tanfidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning foreign patent application or the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

A/C

A/C

A/C

t^ ^ t"^'1 ^

r

Ref 14

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient(s)

Description purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

Privilege(sj Claimed

1$-1517

12/6/99

NMC

WL

Letter concerning patent prosecution forthe
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

19

12/13/1999 01/17/2002

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and
including confidential communications

A/C

22

12/14/1959

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Letter concerning legal research for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between

A/C, W/P

client and attorney. Document related to litigation, 23-1
9/3.0/01 NMC WL Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between A/C

23-2

4/23/01

NMC

WL

client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

23-3

4/6/01

NMC

WL

23-4-5

11/6/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning toreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential
communications between client and

A/C

A/C

"^' ^"`1
^r ^^ I^ `^' °°'--9

^'I^` 1

Ref

]ate

Author ( s)

Recipient ( s)

Description attorney. Letter concerninb `oreign patent

Privileges} Claimed
A/C

23-6-7

3/13/00

NMC

WL

application for the purpose of legal
advice and including confidential

23-8

3/9/00

NMC

WL

communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between
client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent

A/C

23-9-

2116/00

NMC

WL

A/C

11

application for the purpose of legal advice and induding confidential
communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for

23-12-

1/26/00

NMC

WL

A/C

14

the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between
1/29/01 NMC WL client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including A/C

Z4-1

24-2

11/30/00

NMC

WL

24-3-4

6/S/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

24-5 ^' `^s 7 = m^ ..... ^^ ^ ^{

3/23/00

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient(s)

Description

Privilege(s)

Claimed purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application forthe purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including

24-6-7

3/13100

NMC

WL

A/C

24-$-10

2/16/00

NMC

WL

A/C

24-11-13

2/9/00

NMC

WL

A/C

confidential communications between client and attorney. 24-14-15
2/5/00 NMC WL Email chain concerning patent prosecution

A/C

24-16

2/5100

NMC

WL

for the purpose of legal advice and including confiden#ial communications between client and attorney, _ Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

_
A/C

25-1

9/26/02

NMC

WL

25-2

7/9/01

NMC

WL

and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning Japanese patent
application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications

A/C

A/C

25-3 ^' ^ ^ __ ^W ^.. ^

3/2/01

NMC

WL

between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent

A/C

Ref

date

AutE^or ( s^

Recipient(s)

Description application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent
application for the purpose of legal advice

Privilege(s^ Claimed

25-4

7/12/00

NMC

WL

A/C

25-5

4/7.1/00

NMC

WL

25-6-7

3/13/00

NMC

WL

and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communica#ions between client and attorney. Letter concerning foreign patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Email concerning Japanese patent

A/C

A/C

25-8

10/$/02

NMC

JT, WL

A/C

26-1

9/27/02

NMC

Ji', WL

26-2-3

9/26/02

NMC

JT, WL

26-4 2fi-5 26-6-7 ^' ^'7 = 1-r'l ^ °,....^

7/2/0 3/2/01 2/28/01

HO JT NMC

NMC NMC
WO

application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Japanese patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning lapanese paten# application for the purpose of [ega[ advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Emai[ concerning lapanese patent
application.

A/C

A/C

A/C A/C A/C

Document concerning Japanese patent

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipients}
application.

Description

Pri^iiege(s) Claimed A/C A/C
A/C A/C

26-8-9 26-1011 26-1214 26-1516

7/12/00 7//x/00 7/5/00 6/22/00 6/21/00 4/21/00 4/21/00 4/21/00 4/17/00 4/11/00 4/7/00
4/11/OD 4/11/00

NMC HO HO HO NMC NMC HO HO NMC NMC HO HO
HO

HO
NMC

NMC NMC HO HO NMC NMC HO HO NMC NMC
NMC

Document conce^ icing Japanese patent application. Document concerning Japanese patent application. Document concerning Japanese patent application, Letter concerning Japanese patent
application.

26-1718 26-14 26-20
26-21

Document concerning Japanese patent application, Letter concerning Japanese patent application, Document concerning Japanese patent
application.

A/C A/C
A/C

Letter concerning Japanese patent
appiication.

A/C
A/C A/C A/C

26-22 26-2324 26-25
26-26

Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent
application.

Letter concerning Japanese patent
application. Letter concerning Japanese patent

A/C
A/C

26-27 26-2829 26-30 26-31-

4/7/00 4/7/00 4/5/00

NMC HO NMC

HO NMC HO

application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application. Letter concerning Japanese patent application, Letter concerning Japanese patent

A/C A/C ^.
A/C

^7 Z

lm ,^

Ref 33 27-1

Date

Author{s)

Recipient(s)

Description

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

application.
9/26/02 NMC WL Leiter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client and attorney.

27-2

$/21/07.

NMC

WL

A/C

27-3-4

11/7.4/07.

WL

NMC

A/C

27-5

5/2/01

NMC

WL

Letter concerning trademark application for
the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

27-6

11/13/00

NMC

WL

confidential corrimunications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

A/C

27-7

10/16/00

NMC

WL

27-8

9/7.2/00

NMC

WL

27-9

5/30/00

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

A/C

A/C

^^ ^ ".r. _^ "'.,^

o^

r

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

R tipient ( s)

Description and attorney, Letter concerning trademark application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client
and attorney.

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

27-10

5/1b/00

WL

NMC

28-1

10/4/02

NMC

WL

28-2

9/30/02

NMC

WL

Email concerning trademark and patent applications for the purpose of legal advice and including canfidential Communications between client and a#torney. Email concerning trademark and patent applications for the purpose of legal advice
and including canfidential Communications

A/C

A/C

between client and attorney. 28-3
9/28/02 NMC WL Email concerning trademark and patent

A/C

applications far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications
between client and attorney.

28-4

4/17/02

NMC

WL

28-5

8/13/01

NMC

WL

28-6

8/28/00

NMC

WL

28-7

6/5/00

NMC

WL

Latter concerning patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney.. Letter concerning patent application far the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between client and attorney, Letter concerning patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential cnmmunicatians between client and attorney. Email concerning patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

A/C

A/C

A/C

^z r-n ^

x

a ^' ^^

Ref

Date

Author { s)

Recipient ( s)

Description confidential communications between client and attorney.

Privilege{s) ^,

Claimed

28-8

5/31/00

NMC

WL

Document concerning patent application including confidential communications between client and attorney.

A/C

29-1

9/13/00

NMC

WL

29-2

9/1.3/00

NMC

WL

30-1 30-2 30-3 30-4

10/13/O^l 10/11/04 10/13/04 10/6/04

Honesty & Patent Honesty & Patent PJE 5e-Chang Kang, Korean patent

PJE PJE Honesty & Patent NMC

Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document concerning legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Korean patent application, Email concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean paten# application.

A/C

'

A/C

A/C AJC A/C A/C

I I

counsel
30-5 30-6-7 10/1.9/02 10/1$/OZ NMG NMC YPY YPY, WL Email concerning Korean patent application, Email concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Document related to
litigation.

A/C
A/C

,
A/C

30-$-9

1.0/7.7/02

NMC

YPY, WL

Email concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

and attorney. Document related to 30-1011 30-1213
10/17/02 9/26/02 YPY NMC NMC YPY, WL litigation. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning Korean patent application for the purpose of legal advice and including A/C A/C

i;'7 Z li"^ ^ 10^ ^

}Zef

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient(s)

Description confidential communications between client and attorney, Document related to
litigation.

Pri^iiege(s)

Gaimed

30-14 30-15 30-16 30-1719 30-2030-21 30-2223 30-24 30-2526 30-2732

7/29/02 7/29/02 4/17/02 12/29/01
12/26/01

YPY YPY YPY YPY
Honest & Patent

NMC NMC NMC NMC
NMC

Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application, Letter concerning Korean patent application.
Letter concerning Korean patent application.

A/C

A/C A/C A/C
A/C

12/25/01 12/24/01
1Z/14/01

YPY NMC NMC NMC NMC
YPY

NMC ^ YPY YPY YPY YPY
NMC

12/14/01 12/9/01
11/15/07.

Letter concerning Korean patent application. Document concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email chain conc^:^ ^^ing Korean patent
application. Letter concerning Korean patent application.

A/C A/C A/C A/C A/C
_ A/C

30-3334 30-35 30-3637 30-38 30-3940 31-1

11/15/01 11/15/01
11/14/01

YPY YPY
NMC

NMC NMC
Honest & Patent

Email concerning Korean patent application. Letter concerning Korean patent application,
Email concerning Korean patent application.

A/C A/C A/C
A/C A/C

11/1/01 10/4/02

Honest & Patent NMC

NMC WL

Letter concerning Korean patent application. Email concerning patent prosecution for
the purpose of legal advice and including

confidential communications between
client and attorney.

31-2 rn ^^ ^7 = ^W ^_ ^ ^6 i ^^

9/30/02

NMC

WL

Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

Ref

pate

Author ( s^

Reciplent(sJ

I)escriptian and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

31-3

9/26/02

NMC

WL

31-4

4/17/42

NMC

WL

and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between
Client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the

A/C
.,^ ti

31-5

8/13/01

NMC

WL

A/C

31-6

$/28/44

NMC

WI_

^

purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning patent prosecution for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C

31-7

6/5/02

NMC

WL

31-8

5/31/01

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal
advice and including confidential

A/C

A/C

communications between client and attorney. 3z
10/29/2002 NMC WL Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications

A/C

33 ^^ ^] ^ ^^

12/27/2402

NMC

WL

between client anp attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution and legal invoices including confidential

A/C

I

Ref

Date

Author(s)

Recipient ( s)

Description communications between client and attorney. Email concerning Natent prosecution including confidential communica#ions between client and attorney. Email Concerning legal invoices including
confidentia! communications between

Pri^iiege(s) Claimed

34

Ob/12/2003

NMC

WL

A/C

35

07/22/2003

WL

NMC

A/C

36

12/OZ/2004

NMC

WL

client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including
confidentia! communications between

A/C
I

client and attorney.
37

I
A/C

12/03/2004

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

Email concerning patent prosecution for

38

1x/03/2004

WL

NMC

39

12/03/2004

NMC, WL

WL, NiYiC

the purpose of legal advice and including confidential Communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent
prosecution for the purpose of legal

_ A/C

A/C

advice and including confidential communications between client and
40 12/7,3/2004 NMC WL attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications A/C

41

09/17/200509/2D/2005

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice and including confidentia! Communications between
Client and attorney.

A/C

"t^ ^1
^i 'a ^ i^ U^

l^l

i^
!^-

Ref 42

Date 09/17/200509/23/2005

Author ( s)
NMC, WL

Recipient ( s) WL, NMC

Description 1=mail chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney,
Document concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and A/C

Privilege(s)
Claimed

43

10/06/2005

NMC

WL

AC

44

12/20/2005

WL

NMC

including confidentia! communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patenE prosecution for
the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between

A/C

45

12/22/2005

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

^

46

02/02/2006

NMC

WL

client and attorney. Email chain concerning licensing far the purpose of legal advice and including confidential com'municatians between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for
the purpose of legal advice and including

A/C, W/P

A/C

confidential communications between
client and attorney. _ A/C

47

02/08/2006

NMC, WL

WL, NMC

Email chain concerning patent prosecution and licensing for the purpose of legal advice and including con#idential
communications between client and attorney.

48-1

3/3/07

NMC

WL

Email concerning legal invoices including

A/C

48-2

x/26/07

NMC

WL

conidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent
prosecution including confidential

A/C

communications between client and ^^ ^^ i'T'1 W ^ ;^ i

Ref

Date

Authar ( s^

Recipient ( s)

Description attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent
prosecution including confidential communications between client and

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

48-3

2/26/07

NMC

WL

49-1

2/26/07

WL

NMC

A/C

49-2

2/2b/07

WL

NMC

A/C

attorney. 49-3
2/26/07 WL NMC Email concerning legal invaiees and patent A/C

50-1

2/27/07

WL

NMC

50-2

2/27/07

WL

NMC

prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning legal invoices and patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and
attorney.

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

50-3

2/27/07

WL

NMC

Email concerning licensing and patent prosecution including confidential
communications between client and

A/C, W/P

51 -^^ ^^ C'"^^ W

02/27/2007

NMC

WL ^

attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution and
legal invoices including confidential

A/C

communications between client and

1^

Ref

Date

Author(s)

Recipient(s)

Description attorney. Email Concerning Natent prosecution and
legs[ invoices including canfidentia!

Privi[ege(s^ Claimed A/C

52

03/02/2007

WL

NMC

53

03/05/2007

WL

NMC

communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Email concerning patent prosecution for

A/C

_ ,,^
A/C

54

03/06/2007

WL

NMC

55

03/Ofi/2007

NMC

WL

the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution far
the purpose of legal advice including

A/C

Sfi

03/07/2007

WL

NMC

confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for
the purpose of legal advice including

A/C

57

03/07/2007

NMC

WL

confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between
client and attorney.

A/C

SS

03/11/2007

NMC

WL, VLS

59-1

3/13/07

WL

NMC

Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning prior art for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and

A/C

A/C, W/P

^^ ^7 ^ ^ ^

f 1

^P ^ ^^

Ref

Date

Author ( s).

Recipient ( s^

Descrip #ian attorney. Email Concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
canfidentiaE cammunications between client

Privilegs(s3 Claimed A/C

59-2

3/13/07

WL

NMC

60-1

3/13/07

NMC

WL

60-2

3/13/07

NMC

WL

61-1

3/17/07

NMC

WL, VLS

61-2

3/17/07

NMC

WL, VLS

62

03/17/2007

WL

NMC

63

03/17/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legaE advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney, Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential cammunications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including canfidentiaE communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for
the purpose of legaE advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Letter concerning representation

A/C, W/P

A/C, W/P

_^
i

^ A/C

A/C

A/C

A/C

64

03/17/2007

NMC

WL

A/C

--^ ; ^^ ^^ ^ l^ ^
^^^ d ^^ i

including confidential communications between client and attorney.

Ref 65

Date 03/17/2007 NMC

Author(s) WL

Recipient(s)

Description Letter concerning representation including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose
of legal advice including confidential

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

66

03/20/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

A/C

C7

03/20/2007

NMC

WL

communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose
of legal advice including confidential Communications between client and

A/C

68

03/21/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

59

03/26/2007

NMC

WL, VLS

attorney. Email chain concerning licensing and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning infringement for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C, WP

A/C, W/P

confidential communications between
client and attorney. _

70

03/26/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

Email concerning infringement for the
purpose of legal advice and including

A/C, W/P

71

03/28/2007

WL

NMC, VLS

confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning infringement for the purpose of legal advice and including Confidential communications between
client and attorney.

_ A/C, W/P

72 .. ^ ;^C ^^ [""^I W .^

03/29/2007

JLL

NMC

Email concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications

A/C

^^

Ref

Date

Author ( s)

Recipient ( s)

Description between client and attorney. Email chain concerning licensing for the purpose of legal aavke including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential Communications between client and attorney. _

Privilege(s) Claimed A/C

74

03/30/2007

NMC

WL

75

03/34/2007

NMC

WL, VLS

A/C

76

03/30/2007

WL

NMC, VL5

A/C

77

03/30/2007

NMC

WL, VLS, JLL

A/C

_

7$

03/30/2007

WL

NMC, VLS, JLL

Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including
confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for

A/C

79

03/30/2007

NMC

WL

A/C, W/'

80

03/30/2007

NMC

VLS, JLL

82 _,^ m ^^ iii ^ N

05/01/2007

WL

NMC

the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client and attorney. Emaif concerning patent prosecution including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice and including confidential communications between client

A/C

A/C, W/P

._.. ^^

Ref

Date

Author ( sy

Recipient(s^

Description and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Emall chain concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney.
Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential

Pri^i[ege(s) Claimed A/C

83

05/01/2007

NMC

WL

84

05/03/2007

NMC

WL

A/C

85

05/09/2007

WL

NMC

A/C

communications between client and
86 05/1$/2007 NMC WL attorney, Email chain concerning patent prosecution far the purpose of legal

A/C

87

07/04/2007

NMC

WL

advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and
attorney. Email chain concerning patent

A/C

88

10/02/2007

NMC

WL

A/C

89.,
t..d Fes'/^ /'^ ' ^ ^ '`y ^ -.^6.-..

10/02/2007

WL

NMC

prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent

A/C

^r E

Ref

Date

Author( s)

Recipient(sj

Description

Privilege(s) Claimed

prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential
communications between client and attorney.

90

10/03/2007

WL

NMC

Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal
advice including confidential

A/C

91

10/05/2007

NMC

WL

communications between client and attorney. Emaii chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal
advice including confidential communications between client and

A/C

92

10/OS/2007

WL

NMC

attorney, Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal
advice including confidential

A/C

93

12/17/2007

NMC

WL

communications between client and attorney. Email chain concerning patent prosecution for the purpose of legal
advice including confidential

A/C

94

06/11/2008

WL

NMC

95

06/14/2008

NMC

WL

communications between client and attorney. Email concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. Email concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose of legal advice including confidential

A/C

A/C

^ ]C i^ ^ m ^ W -^ ^

^ ^r

EZef

Date

Author( s)

Recipient ( s)

Description

Privilege(s)

^

Claimec4 communications between client and attorney. Email concerning discovery related to the litigation.
Email chain concerning representation and patent prosecution for the purpose

96
97

10/25/2008
10/27/2008

Christie Cho
WL

NMC
NMC

W/P, TPM
A/C, W/P

of legal advice including confidential communications between client and attorney. .^

^7 ^ t^ ^
^^