Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1150

MOTION for Extension of Time and to Seal Documents re #1024 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Documents Re Apples Opposition To Samsungs Motion For Summary Judgment, #1022 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Documents Re Apples Opposition To Samsungs Motion For Summary Judgment, #1020 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Documents Under Seal Re Apples Opposition To Samsungs Motion For Summary Judgment, #1023 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Documents Re Apples Opposition To Samsungs Motion For Summary Judgment, #925 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Apple's Motion for Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement of U.S. Patent Number 7,362,867 and Invalidity of U.S. Patent Numbers 7,456,893 and 7,577,460, #1013 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Documents Under Seal Re Apples Opposition To Samsungs Motion For Summary Judgment filed by Samsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC(a Delaware limited liability company). Responses due by 7/2/2012. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1 to Samsung's Motion, #2 Declaration of Anthony P. Alden in Support of Samsung's Motion, #3 Exhibit 1 to the Alden Declaration, #4 Declaration of Hankil Kang in Support of Samsung's Motion, #5 Exhibit 1 to the Kang Declaration, #6 Exhibit 2 to the Kang Declaration, #7 Exhibit 3 to the Kang Declaration, #8 Exhibit 4 to the Kang Declaration, #9 Exhibit 5 to the Kang Declaration, #10 Exhibit 6 to the Kang Declaration, #11 Exhibit 7 to the Kang Declaration, #12 Exhibit 8 to the Kang Declaration, #13 Exhibit 9 to the Kang Declaration, #14 Exhibit 10 to the Kang Declaration, #15 Exhibit 11 to the Kang Declaration, #16 Exhibit 12 to the Kang Declaration, #17 Exhibit 13 to the Kang Declaration, #18 Exhibit 14 to the Kang Declaration, #19 Exhibit 15 to the Kang Declaration, #20 Exhibit 16 to the Kang Declaration, #21 Exhibit 17 to the Kang Declaration, #22 Exhibit 18 to the Kang Declaration Pt. 1 of 5, #23 Exhibit 18 to the Kang Declaration Pt. 2 of 5, #24 Exhibit 18 to the Kang Declaration Pt. 3 of 5, #25 Exhibit 18 to the Kang Declaration Pt. 4 of 5, #26 Exhibit 18 to the Kang Declaration Pt. 5 of 5, #27 Exhibit 19 to the Kang Declaration, #28 Exhibit 20 to the Kang Declaration, #29 Exhibit 21 to the Kang Declaration, #30 Exhibit 22 to the Kang Declaration, #31 Exhibit 23 to the Kang Declaration, #32 Exhibit 24 to the Kang Declaration, #33 Exhibit 25 to the Kang Declaration, #34 Exhibit 26 to the Kang Declaration, #35 Exhibit 27 to the Kang Declaration, #36 Exhibit 28 to the Kang Declaration, #37 Proposed Order Granting Samsung's Miscellaneous Administrative Request)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 6/28/2012)

KANG DECLARATION
EXHIBIT 21

Bressler Decl. In Support of
Apple’s Opp. to Samsung’s
Mot. For Summary
Judgment
Ex. 38
Filed Under Seal

TRANSLATION

Aries-Q (GT-I9050)
Global GSM Level. 2
Product
Planning

Department
PP
PM
VPS

Enabling
Development

Design

PM
PL
H/W
S/W
Device
Sound Lab.
Antenna
SE Group
Product
UX

R&D Management
Sales
Purchasing
MSC
CS Team (Reliability)
Product Technology H/W
S/W

Responsible Executive
Vice President HanGil Yoon
Vice President JoonYoung Kim
Vice President JongIn Kim
Vice President YongBae Lee
Vice President TaeMoon Noh

Senior Vice President
SeungHwan Cho
Vice President HyunMyung Song
Vice President JunTae Kim
Vice President SukHo Kim
Vice President TaeShik Kim
Vice President SukGeun Kim
Vice President DongHoon Chang

Working Level
Senior Manager ByungJin Kang, Assistant Manager IkSun Kang
Senior Manager HyukMin Kwon, Manager HyunDuk Yang
Senior Manager TaeGil Kim, Assistant Manager DalWon Kim
Manager JongHoon Park, Associate EonJi Lee
Vice President TaeMoon Noh
Vice President HakSang Kim
Lead SangRyul Park
Principal WonIk Ahn

Lead ByungJoon Lee, Senior HeeJun Lee
Senior JoBong Cho, Associate SookKyung Kim
Lead DongHwan Kim, Associate JaeHo Lim
Lead DongIk Shin, Lead JongSook Lee, Associate SungRae Cho
Principal MinHyouk Lee, Associate GiYoung Lee
AUI Lead JoongSam Yoon, UI Senior YoungMi Kim, GUI Lead
SoYoung Yoon
Senior Vice President DongJin Ko Senior Manager JinGyu Kim, Manager YoungJoong Kim
Senior Vice President HeungShik Cho, Senior Vice President YoungWoo Lee, Vice President GiYong Suh,
Vice President GeunIk Yoo, Vice President MyungDong Park, Vice President ChulJin Kim
Vice President JongKwon Lim
Senior Manager,ImSoon Lee , Assistant Manager GyungPil Kim
Vice President KyungHan Lee
Head of Department SungWon Cho, Assistant Manager HyungSoo Kim
Vice President DooPyo Yoon
Senior Manager JungTae Lee, Manager Yong Kim
Vice President TekWon Ryu
Senior Manager HyunGyu Park
Vice President JungHo Baek
Manager DongGu Kim, Manager YoonDo Huh

TRANSLATION

Aries-Q (GT-I9050)
Global GSM Level. 2
Department
Product Planning
PP
PM
VPS
Enabling
Development
PM
PL
H/W
S/W

Design

Device
Sound
Lab.
Antenna
SE Group
Product
UX

R&D Management
Sales
Purchasing
MSC
CS Team (Reliability)
Product Technology H/W
S/W

Responsible Executive
Vice President Hangil Yoon
Vice President Joonyoung Kim
Vice President Jongin Kim
Vice President Yongbae Lee
Vice President Taemoon Noh

Senior Vice President
Seunghwan Cho
Vice President Hyunmyung Song
Vice President Juntae Kim
Vice President Sukho Kim
Vice President Taeshik Kim
Vice President Sukgeun Kim
Vice President DongHoon Chang

Working Level
Senior Manager ByungJin Kang, Associate JiWon Ahn
Senior Manager HyukMin Kwon, Manager HyunDuk Yang
Senior Manager TaeGil Kim, Assistant Manager DalWon Kim
Manager JongHoon Park, Associate EonJi Lee
Vice President HakSang Kim
Principal ByungDo Ahn
Lead YeonBum Kim
Lead JoonHyuk Lee
Senior oonChul Lee
Senior JoBong Cho, Associate SookKyung Kim
Lead DongHwan Kim, Associate JaeHo Lim
Lead DongIk Shin, Lead JongSook Lee, Associate SungRae Cho
Principal MinHyouk Lee, Associate JinHoo Lee
AUI Lead JoongSam Yoon, UI Senior HyoYoung Kim, GUI Senior
JunSuk Kim
Senior Manager JinGyu Kim, Assistant Manager SungMi Kim

Senior Vice President DongJin
Ko
Senior Vice President HeungShik Cho, Senior Vice President YoungWoo Lee, Vice President GiYong Suh,
Vice President GeunIk Yoo, Vice President MyungDong Park, Vice President ChulJin Kim
Vice President JongKwon Lim
ImSoon Lee Senior Manager, , Assistant Manager GyungPil Kim
Vice President KyungHan Lee
Department Head SungWon Cho, Manager HyungSoo Kim
Vice President DooPyo Yoon
Senior Manager JungTae Lee, Manager Yong Kim
Vice President TekWon Ryu
Senior Manager HyunGyu Park
Vice President JungHo Baek
Manager DongGu Kim, Manager YoonDo Huh

0. Content
1. Positioning
• Roadmap
• Competition map
2. Sales Point
3. Competitor Comparison
4. Evaluation
5. Specification
• H/W
• S/W
• UX
• Service
• CMF
• Assignment Check List
6. VPS
7. Target Sales Volume, Price and Profit
8. PLC
9. Schedule
10. Summary

CONFIDENTIA
L

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION
4-1. Evaluation – Aries

CONFIDENTIAL

Design Evaluation Result
Category
Exterior
Design

Evaluation Result
8
Appropriate

8.1 (Acceptable)
•
•

Color/Material
Usability

•

•

8

Appropriate

•

8.2

Appropriate

•

Problems/Issues
No hanger hole, camera key,
flash, or mirror

Need to mark high/low division
on the volume key – imprint or
apply separated high/low keys
(refer to the Samsung Standard
Proposal)

•

•

Remarks
A new change tried by applying the curved glass on
the lower front.
Applying to the lower backside a curve with the
opposite value from that of the front created a
connected feel and a better grip feel, and protects the
surface when laid down.
Added luxurious feel by applying the metal edge to
the simple black body
Very slim for its size, and the key operation is highly
stable.

Solutions
Hanger hole to be added; camera key/flash/mirror are
strategically removed for the competitiveness in design and
size (confirmed by the Head of the Division on 1/19)

High/low division to be marked on the volume key

TRANSLATION

Design Evaluation Results

Category

Evaluation Result

8.0 (Appropriate)

Remarks

Appropriate

► A new change tried by applying the curved glass on the lower front.
► Applying to the lower backside a curve with the opposite value from that of
the front created a connected feel and a better grip feel, and protects the surface
when laid down.
► Samsung logo on the front and the back seems a bit small.

Color//Material

Appropriate

► Added luxurious feel through the balanced application of the metal edge to the
simple black body
► Luxurious feel by using the appropriate contrast of gloss and matte

Usability

Appropriate

► Very slim for its size;ue to the curve at the bottom, high stability during front
surface/QWERTY key usage

Exterior Design

Problems/Issues

► No hanger hole, camera key, flash, or mirror

► Need to mark high/low division on the volume key –
imprint or apply separated high/low keys (refer to the
Samsung Standard Proposal)

Fix Action

► Hanger hole to be added; camera key/flash/mirror are strategically
removed for the competitiveness in design and size (confirmed by the Head of
the Division on 1/19)

► High/low division to be marked on the volume key

TRANSLATION

Feature Evaluation Results

Model that is Compared Against

Detailed Evaluation Results

Remarks

Superior Items

Inferior Items

Problems/Issues

Solutions
Aries (14 languages, Samsung XT9 Keyboard
standard) is currently inferior to iPhone (30 languages),
but in process of developing 15 additional Locales, and
to review consequent expansion

TRANSLATION

Service Evaluation Results
Comparison Target Model

Detailed Evaluation Results

Remarks

Superior: SNS, IM, Widget, Kies

Superior Items

Equal: Video, E-book
Inferior Items

Problems/Issues

Solutions

1) Google plans to have a Global Promotion of the
Android Market in the second quarter of 2010
Android Market is inferior compared to Appstore

2) Respond to the Needs of Local consumers by loading
More Widgets that will allow Samsung to be
distinguished
3) In countries where the Android Market is not
available, load Slideme to provide a Marketplace in place
of the Android Market.

25

TRANSLATION

(Manual, PK)

Separated type 12x07
Resonance Space: 0.625 cc
Volume Standard: Reliability 65dB
Pole
Reinforced glass
PC molding

TRANSLATION

(Supports SUPL)

Variably applied depending on the carrier’s request

(SEUK Spec)

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

UX RELATED
PLANNED ARIES UX APPLICATION
DISTINGUISHING POINTS

Support integrated phonebook & Calendar
Add Online album to the Media browser
Android OS UI Based
:Basic component, popup, settings, wireless
controls

Support push event (Email, SNS activities), Support IM

Apply Samsung
TouchWiz 3.0 UI
Add Additional Features

TRANSLATION

UX RELATED

3. Distinguishing the Additional Features

TRANSLATION

5-6. Project Review Checklist

Presentation of the Development PL
- Presentation focused on main issues

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

TRANSLATION

Aries Regional Development Schedule (Based on Internal Goal SRA 5/20)

Classification

GPG
4 Major
Carriers
North
America
GSM TMO
Domestic

China CMCC

Central/South
America

Japan

March

April

May

June

July

August

September

October

November

December

TRANSLATION

M/C, ASP

Release Area

TRANSLATION

M/C, ASP

Release Area

TRANSLATION

Strengths compared to iPhone

Strengths compared to other Androids

Samsung Android UX applied

Multi-tasking supported
(Up to 6 viewable on Aries, possible as permitted by
memory)

Superior HW spec
(Super AMOLED, 1GHz Chipset, VT Call support, etc.)

Diverse video file formats supported
(iPhone only supports mp4)

Additional marketplace other than Android Market provided,
such as More Widget, Slideme, etc.

Carrier customization allowed

Plenty of User Memory Provided for storing applications and
contents (16GB default)

FOTA upgrade allowed
(has to connect to iTunes via cable and download
at home for iPhone)

Multi-touch Pinch zoom in/out applied
Convergence between devices: 3 Screen (DLNA)

Adobe Flash 9 Supported

[Shared Strengths]
Fast typing with Swype Integration
Social Hub (Integrated Phonebook) Supported

Context Awareness UX applied

Android Froyo (Former Flan)
OS version upgrade with the goal of improving performance as well as increasing user convenience
More features than the Éclair but same or less RAM/ROM requirement through OS optimization (fit & polish) 
Scheduled for announcement 2010 May or June, Official Letter is scheduled for delivery to partner companies by 
the second week of February 
Performance 
Improvement 

JIT(Just in Time Compiler) loaded – Increase performance of JAVA application
(Also loaded on the Éclair but function revitalized for the first time with Froyo) 
Loaded Stagefright instead of the formerly used Opencore to make the OS more lighter and faster  
Kernel: 2.6.32 (Éclair: 2.6.30)
Applications can be saved on the SD card (formerly: Only savable on the internal memory)

Increasing 
User 
Convenience 

Adobe Flash supported: Adobe Flash Browser Plugin downloadable through Android Market  
Unbundling of apps with platform
‐ Update possible for Google Mobile Services as well as system app through Android Market 
New UI as well as partial UI refresh for Music & Gallery App

Etc. 

Exchange Support – Calendar Sync, Password Admin (Remote Wipe function loaded)
Tethering function using USB as well as BT(DUN) 
Publication of referential sample code scheduled to support game developers

77 Countries
133,979 

26 Countries
Number of Applications 

On‐Device Client (Wireless)
iTunes(Non‐Wireless) 
Superiority of Apps with a variety of local apps 
through entering many countries 

23,475

On‐Device Client (Wireless)

Etc.

Comparatively inferior expansion speed as it is not 
a source of profit but only uses GSM’s partial appl 

Membership fee $99 (individual), $299 
(corporations) 

Memership fee $25 (same)
Business friendly by sharing 30% profit 

Continuous expansion and growth in number of 
apps along with the iPhone, iPad 
(300,000 anticipated by the end of 2010) 

The number of Apps is comparatively lesser due 
to a slower terminal expansion speed of the 
iPhone however a an Android Market Promotion 
is scheduled for the middle of 2010 

Assessment

4 Menu Customizing  possible  within the Widget screen
Combined Home screen 
Title set‐up possible by 
Widget/Menu page 

Maximize contents within the 
screen with simple Menu/Key 
arrangements on screens such 
as Video, Browser 

Easy of Managing 

Maximization of the Multi‐Tasking environment 
with Quick Panel, Task Switcher and others 

Eliminated unnecessary interaction and 
strengthened usability by inserting Quick Panel & 
More Option window through Sweeping Up/Down 
Gesture 

Improved information gathering by comprising various features in one Widget.
weather, stock, latest news information real time Update

Consolidated management of SNS and Contact Update status possible in one Widget
(Live Buddy, etc.)

Fast word input possible with a finger or
stylus gliding on the keyboard
SWYPE vs. iPhone performance comparison
(Inputting 25 words)
: SWYPE 39sec vs. iPhone 79sec
1.5x faster

Ex) Inputting the word “cool”

Provides words frequently used by the user in advance by prediction (able to set on/off)
Able to add & edit desired words by the user

Improved user convenience by providing various voice recognition features
(Voice Dialing/Playing/Recording)
Provides notifications to the user through Text-to-Speech control
(Time & Date, Battery Level, Signal Strength, Memory Status, etc.)

Provides Beyond Touch Experience

Establishes 'Always-on Communication Channel' through real time updates
based on PIMS(Phonebook/Calendar), SNS, Messaging(IM, Email) Push

TRANSLATION

- Consolidated management possible on phone through integrating 4 portals and major SNS
- IM Login confirmation and chatting possible in Contact info
4 portals
Major SNS

Contact List
Consolidation

- Consolidated management possible on phone through integrating Outlook and
Facebook
- Displays the integrated schedule information sorted by the source

Schedule Information
Consolidation

- Easy set-up of Email using the Email address and Password possible by
providing information for more than 10 thousand Email ISPs

TRANSLATION

Customizing Google Chrome browser
- Value-added Features added on Chrome Browser provided by Android Ếclair version
Flash Lite 3.1 support : Displays Flash videos on major portals
Improved Download feature : OMA Download support

DRM Contents Download possible

Provides PC-like Web Experience compared to other Android Phones

[Flash support]

TRANSLATION

Social browser based on Augmented-Reality
Displays the location of desired contents as an icon through
Camera View (Wikipedia, restaurant location and phone
number, others' SNS, etc.)
Record & Access possible anytime, anywhere through Text, Photo, and Audio
Text, photo & audio notes creation possible
Text search possible within image
Text search possible within image
Share and Synce of all created Note among Phone, PC, and Server

Phone Title/Menu font can be modified to a font downloaded by the user
Customizing possible according to the user preference

TRANSLATION

- Improved Wireless Access performance by supporting 802.11 b/g + 802.11 n

WiFi usability improvement
(Image modification planned)

WiFi on/off setting possible in Idle screen
WiFi automatic access possible when the frequented AP is found after the AP search

TRANSLATION

Expands utilization of short-distance communication through mobile phone by
supporting various Bluetooth 3.0 Profile
Added features such as BPP (Remote Printing), FTP (File sending) unsupported by iPhone

- Supports Tethering Application which utilizes
mobile phone as Wireless Access Point
3G N/W communication from WiFi enabled
Mobile Device possible through mobile phone
Internet access anytime & anywhere