City of Winter Haven v. Cleveland Indians Baseball Company Limited Partnership
Filing
295
US District Court Middle District of Florida PLAINTIFFS' EXHIBIT Exhibit Number: 1 6 . 1 8 6:06md01769ACCDAB In Re: Seroquel Products Liability Litigation Date Identified: Date Admitted:
Exhibit 16.18
DennisCanty
From: Sent: To: Cc:
Flaster,Eben [eben.flaster@dechert.coml Friday, January19,20079:32AM jjaffe@weiElux.com; fl To: jjaffeGweitzfux.com ; Torregrossa, Brennan; l g o r n i c k G l s k g - 1 a w . c o m ( I g o r n i c k Gl s k g - 1 a w . c o m > ; d c a n t y G 1 s k g - 1 a w . c o m ( d c a n t y G l s k g .l-aw.com); MPedersonGweitzIux. com ; ftrammell Gbpblaw. com < f tramme l lSbpblaw. com>,' kbaiteyGbpblaw.com ; CBaileyGbpblaw.com ,' K S m i t h @ a w s -l a w . c o m < K S m i t h Ga w s - I a w . c o m > ; k j G k j e n s e n l a h r . c o m < k j @ k j e n s e n l a w . c o m ) Sent: Thu Jan 18 12:57:48 2001 Subject: Rer AZ IT interviews W e wil-l- meet you in
-----Oni rri n: l
the
lobby.
M-c-< q . g e - - - - - -,a
From: Jaffe, Jonathan To: Flaster, Eben (eben. f1a sterGdechert. com>; Mcconnell, Stephen ,' Magaziner, Fred ,' Kelber, Tamar B. C C : kaltmanGlawampmmt. com ; Torregrossa, Brennan , ' l q o r n i c k GI s k g - l a w . c o m < l g o r n i c k G l s k g - 1 a w . c o m > ; d c a n t y @I s k g - l a w . c o m < d c a n t y G l s k g - I a w . c o m > , ' P e d e r s o n , M i k e
( M P e d e r s o n @ w e i t z l u x . c o m >; - I r o t h u Q r o t h - 1 a w . c o m < l _ o t h G r o t h - 1 a w . c o m ) ; r f t r a m m e l l- Gbpblaw. com (ftrammell Gbpblaw. com>; kbai 1ey@bpblaw, com ,' CBailey@bpblaw. com ; Ken Srnith < K S m i t h @ a w s - ] a w .c o m > , . K e i t h J e n s e n < k j G k j e n s e n f a w . c o m ) Sent: Thu Jan 18 11:48:11 2007 Subiect: RE: AZ IT inLerviews
F o r whom shou-Id we ask when we arrive siqn in? Thanks. -----Original
Mondav?
Is there
a specific
place
to go to
Message----From: Flaster, E b e n [ m a i l L o : e b e n . f f as t e r G d e c h er t . c o m ] Sent: Monday, January 15, 2001 tI:42 PM Eben,' Keith Jensen; McConne]1, Stephen,. Jaf fe, Jonathan; Magazj-ner, To: Flaster, Fred; tkelber@Sidley.com C c : k a l t m a n G l a w a m p m m t .c o m ; T o r r e g r o s s a / Brennan; lgornickGl s kg-Iaw. com; dcantyG ls kg-1aw. com,' Pederson, Mj.ke,' lrothGroth-1aw. com,' ftrammel lGbpblaw. com,' k b a i l e y G b p b l a w . c o m i C B a i l e y G b p b l a r 4 r .c o m Subiect: RE: AZ IT interviews Seemed to have forgotten a city: liilmington, DE. That shoufd get
-----t^tri ni nr I Maqq
The complete address you there. Thanks.
is
1800 Concord Pike.
From: Flaster, Eben Sent: Monday, January 15, 2001 l-1:38 AM To: 'Keith Jensenr,' McConnell, Stephen; jjaffeGweitzfux.com; Magaziner, Fred; tkel,berG Sidley. com C c : k a L t m a n G l a w a m p m m tc o m ; T o r r e g r o s s a , . Brennan; lgorni ckGf skq- faw. com; d c a n t y G l s k q t - l a w . c o m ; M P e d e r s o n G w e it z l - u x . c o m ; l r o t h @ r o t h - l a w . c o m ; f t r a m m e l l G b p b J . a w .c o m , ' k b a i l e y G b p b l a w . c o m , ' C B a i l e y G b p b f a w . c o m Subiect: RE: AZ IT interviews AZrs address is Thanks.
-----Ar i n in:l
1800 Concord Pike,
DE
Yes, letrs
start
at
9 am.
Macc
rrom: xeith Jensen imailto;kjGkjensenlarr.coml Sent: Monday, January 15, 2001 11:14 AM To: Ffaster, Eben,' McConnell, Stephen; j jaf f eGweitzf ux. com,' Magaziner, Fred; tkelber@Sid1ey. com C c : k a l t m a n @a w a m p r u n t .c o m ; T o r r e g r o s s a , f Brennan; lgornickG 1s kg-law. com; d c a n t y G l s k g - 1 a w . c o m ; M P e d e r s o n @ w e i tz I u x . c o m ; L r o t h @ r o t h - I a w . c o m ; f t r a m m e l f Gbpbl-aw.com; kbai leyGbpblaw, com; CBai leyGbpblaw. com Subject: RE: AZ IT intervj-ews
Got address -----OriqinalF r.m. Fl aq.tor
for
22nd (presumably
9 a m )?
Thx
Message----El'ren lm: i I t ^.al-ran Fi ecf arOclar-hprt cnml
Sent: Monday, 15 January, 2007 10:08 To: Mcconnell, Stephen,' jjaffeGweitzlux-com;
Magaziner,
Fred;
tkelberGSidley.
com
C c : k a l t m a n G l a w a m p m m t .c o m ; T o r r e g r o s s a , Brennan; lgornickG 1skg-1aw. com,. d c a n t y G l s k g - L a w . c o m ; M P e d e r s o n G w e it z l u x . c o m ; l r o t h G r o t h - l a w . com,. f t r a m m e l -1 G b p b l a w . c o m ; k b a i I e y G b p b l a r r . c o m ; K e i t h J e n s e n ; C B a i l e y G b p b l a w , c o m Subiect: RE: AZ IT intervi ews Jonathan -identify below with the them (by IT witness with
In response to your request, we specifically knowledge) AZ's systems and attempt to align 14 categories requested: Daryl Draper: Event Reportj-ng
Adverse C]ini-caL Clinical
- CLINTRACE; SAM; GESISS - SAMSON Report lIRIS; A M O S , / D i p l o m a t , , 'I M P A C T
Communications Trials/Research - GEL
Regulatory
M e d i c a l - Llterature John Dowling: Sales Ca]l Visitor Instant
- PLANET
Tracking/IMS
- Compass/NORTHSTAR Leaders - Vier,rpoint forum, etc. - NICE; MAX,' ICON; KNOViBOL
Speakers Bureau/Thought
Message, voicemaj-l-, discussion
I note that, since our inj-tj-al disclosure (listed another system, Viewpoint above)/ Thanks, Eben
on the subject, we have identified potentially responsive to your request.
rri n: I M.a . s s a g e - - - - .From: McConnell, Stephen Sent: Monday, January 15, 2001 9:42 FI.JrI rF^. I - . i- . i ^ . F F ^ D , , ^ . i 'tkelberGsidley. com' r-. rra.!!e\:wur"zlux.com'.' F'l-aster, Eben; Magaziner, Fred,' ' k a l t m a n @l - a w a m p m r nc.o m r ; T o r r e g r o s s a , 'lgornick@Iskg-J.aw. com' ; Cc: t Brennan,' ' dcantyG 1s kg- 1aw.com' ; 'MPedersonGweitzlux . com' ,' t l rothGroth-law. com' ; ' f trammel-IGbpblaw. com' ,' ' kbai leyGbpbl-aw. com' ; ' k j Gk j ensenlaw . com | ; I CBaileyGbpblaw. com' Subject: Re: AZ IT interviews -----nri
No surprise here, but it is my understanding that the AZ databases do not (I know that you were not perfectl-y correspond to your list of categrories. ctaiming that) Frankly, I right now don't have the answer to your question and That being expecting to get the best answers out of the j-nterviews. r I was really . said.. welll,hunt a : : o u n d . - . a n d t r y , t o . . ' g i v e - , y o u . . s o r n e ,s s , r l o f h e L p f l . r l - - - t h o u g h , i r t p r e e i s e . : - - c o r r e s p p o d e ! n c e : b b h w e e n , - r t h b ,d:a t a b a a e s . . a a d c a t e q o r i e s ; . , OriginaL'Mdssage -----From: Jaffe, Jonathan 3 -----
To: Ffaster, Eben; Mcconnell-, Stephen; Magaziner, Fred,- Tamar Kelber Cc: Keith Altman ,. Torregrossa, Brennan,. Larry Gornick < l g o r n i c k G 1 s k g - 1 a w . c o m > / ' D e n n i s C a n t y < d c a n t y @1 s k g - 1 a w . c o m > , . P e d e r s o n , M i k e (MPedersoncweit zfux. com>; Larry RoLh ,. Fletch Tramme l_ 1 ; Kenneth Bailey ,' Keith Jensen ,' Camp Bailey Sent : Fri- Jan 12 16 : 10 : 0'l 20Q1 Subject: AZ IT interviews
It would be very helpful if you could match up your list of database names (beIow) with the correspondinq categories to which they relate. C L I N T R A C E / G E S I S S / S A M , G E L / S A M S O N ,I I R I S , N O R T H S T A R ,NICE, MAX, ICON and KNOWBOL 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) 7) B) 9)
1O r v i\/
AMOS, IMPACT, PLANET, COMPASS,
adverse event database sales cafl trackinq database IMS database clinical communications database regulatory database regulatory contact databases clinical trial database medical literature database research report database
^ n n r srrn v h l . vvv r l a rrm ^r ^ +- s;.m u r - Ll - LFd r L1l .d L la rur d^s- e s ri
(document
management
systems
used
by
many
p h a r m a c y companies ) 11) visitor speakers bureau and/or thoughL leader databases payments database 12) clinical force rosters 13) field discussion 14) instant message, voicemail, forum and prior website transcripts recovery. databases, and Best regards, Jonathan Jaffe Manager of Software Development Weitz & Luxenberg, P. C. 2r2 .558 .5522 j j affeGweitzlux. com
page
com] From: Kelber, Tamar B. [mailto:tkelberGSidley. Sent: Friday, January 72, 2001 10:38 AM To: Camp Bailey Cc: Eben. FlasterGdechert . com,' McconnelI, Stephen,' Torregrossa, Nathan A.,' Mil-1er, Rodney K. Subi ect: AZ TT interviews
Brennan,' Huey,
address in the IT Here j-s our current understanding of the databases we wilf be able to and we will continues, interviews on January 22. Our investigation provide you with updated inforrnation at the beginning of the interviews.
DATTyI John
DTapeT:
CLINTRACE, GESISS/
SAM, GEL/
SAMSON/ IIRIS,
AMOS, TMPACT, PLANET
Dowling:
COMPASS, NORTHSTAR, NICE,
MAX, ICON and KNOWBOL
-----Ori Fr.)m:
rli na I Flesl-.'r-
Maq< El-ran lma ilf o.cl-rcn flaqfarada.horiu i
..1fi1
uvr"I
Sent: Friday. January 12, 2001 3:35 pM To: Keith Jensen; McConnell, Stephen,. Camp Bailey; Magaziner, Pred Cc: Jaffe, Jonathan; Keith Al-tman; Torregrogsa, Brennan; Tamar Kelber; Larry Gornick; Dennis Canty; Pederson, Mike; Larry Roth; Fl-etch Trammell-,' Kenneth Bailey; Kelber, Tamar B. Subject: RE: CaII AZ sent the afternoon. -----Original list of databases to Camp, and I forwarded it to you earfi-er this
Message----F r o m : K e i t h J e n s e n l m a i l t o : k j Gk j e n s e n l a w . c o m ] Sent: Frlday, January t2, 2001 3:25 PM To: Flaster/ Eben; McConnel-L,Stephen; CampBa-lley; Magaziner, Fred Cc: Jonathan Jaffe,' Keith Altman; Torreqrossa/ Brennan; Tamar Kefber; Larry Gornick,' Dennj.s Canty; Mike Pederson,' Larry Roth,' Fletch Trammelfr Kenneth Bailey Subject: RE: Cal-1 Fred/Eben: Pfease advise whether or not AZ intends to comply (apparently belatedLy) with the first sentence of CMO+2/ paragraph II F whj-ch reads: "On or before January 5, 20A'7, Astrazeneca shaLl provide Lead Counsel- for plaintiffs with a -list of databases that correspond to the proposed order regarding document 14 categories identified in plainuiffs' production and preservation, I and which potenLially contain information relevant t o SeroqueJ- , " Yes or no, pl-ease . the very
Steve and Eben have typed LhaL AZ i s apparently willing to compfy with next sentence (regarding intervj-ews) so we'd like to know.
-----nri rri n: I Macq
F r o m : F I a s t e r , E b e n [ m a i l c o : e b e n . f I a s t e r , : a d e c h e r t .c o m ] Sent: Thursday, 11 January, 2O0T L6:32 To: Keith Jensen; McConneIl, Stephen; Camp Bailey Cc: Jonathan Jaffe,' Keith Altman; To-rregrossa, Brennan,' Tamar Kelber,' Gornick; Dennis Canty,' Mj-ke Pederson; Larry Roth; Fletch TrammellSUD] eCt : HEi: Ua1_L
I,arry
To what order are you referring? From what f understand, plaintiffs are tomorrow filing objections to the Judge's r-and-r. Be that as it may, there is no need to quibble. to facilitate AZ wants to move forward with the IT witness interviews you want, let me the larger discovery process. If there is something specific know.
-----Ari rri n: I Macc
F r o m : K e i t h J e n s e n l m a i l t o : k j G k j e n s e n ] - a w .c o m l Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2001 2:04 PM Eben,' McConnell, Stephen,' Camp Bailey To: Flaster,
Cc: Jonathan Jaffe; Keith A.l-tman; Torregrossa, Brennan; Tamar Kefber; Gornick,' Dennj-s Canty,' Mike Pederson,. Larry Roth; FIetch Trammel.L Subiect: RE: CaIl Eben, thank you. May I presume 9 am t.he 22nd? Got addre ss,/directions F list of databases
Larry
pls?
And, pls tell me who AZ gave the CMO#2 para. I/5/0'l as ordered. f 've not seen it. Thx.
to by
-----Ori
ni nal
Maeq: ge----..--*3
From: Flaster, Eben [mailto: eben. flaster@dechert. com] Sent: Thursday, 11 January, 2007 L2:28 To: Keith Jensen,' Mcconnel-l-, Stephen,. Camp Bailey Cc: Jonathan Jaffe; Keith Altman; Torregrossa, Brennan; Tamar Kelber; Gornick; Dennis Canty; Mi.ke Pederson; Larry Roth,. FLetch Trammeff S u b - ie c t : R E : C a l l
Larry
f have been in touch with Keith (Altman) on this subject, to and, in an effort move forward v.rith this process, I am willinq to reschedule our other obligati-on (to occur only on the 23rd) such that we can conduct the Seroguel interview on the 22nd. Message----F r o m : k j G k j e n s e n l a w . c o m [ m a i J - t o :k j G k j e n s e n l a w . c o m ] Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2001 7:02 PM To: Mcconnell, Stephen; Camp BaiIey Keith Altmani Torregrossa, Cc: Jonathan Jaffe; Brennan; Eben,' Larry Gornick; Dennis Canty,' Mike Pederson; Larry Subject: Re: CallSteve, if Eben agrees to reschedule an unrelated matter then we'IL all be OK that dav. Eben are we all OK that Sent via BlackBerrv from Cinoufar Wireless -----Original
Tamar Kelber; Flaster, Roth; Fletch Trammelf
with Keith dav?
A.
on the
22nd
-----OriginaI
Message----From: "McConnef1, Stephenrr Date: Thu, 11 .Tan2007 05:44:58 T o : k j G k j e n s e n l a w . c o m ,C B a i l e y G b p b l a w . c o m C c : 3 j a f f e 0 w e i t z l u x . c o m , k a l t m a n G l a w a m p m m t .c o m , " T o r r e g r o s s a , B r e n n a n " < b r e n n a n . t o r r e g r o s s a B d e c h e r t . c o m > ,t k e l b e r G S i d l e y . c o m , " F l a s t e r , Eben" (eben . ffas ter@dechert. com) Subject: Re: Cafl Keith, - on Yes/ the other witness is avai-lable - indeed, both witnesses are availabfe Are none the 22nd. It would be great to wrap up the interviews on the same day. of the plaintiff lawyers availabl-e to conduct an interview on that day? after Aside from that, as far as I know the other witness is unavail-abLe until lawyer but you the 25rh. If you let us know your schedule (assumi-ng no plainriff can do an j-nterview) , we can almost certainly line something up very shortly thereafter.
I am aware of the Judge's order and seriousness and am pleased to hear that pJ-aintif f s' counsel is just as determined to comply with the Judge's orders as are we. I will be getting on an airplane soon and for several hours wonrt have the pleasure of reading your (or anyone else's) But I am sure Tamar, Eben, e-mails. and Brennan can get a handl-e on the scheduling issue. - Steve ,.--sage ----From: Keith Jensen T o : M c c o n n e l I , S t e p h e n ; C B a i l e y G b p b l a w . c o m < C B a i L e y @ b p b l a w .c o m > Cc: jjaffe@weitzlux. corn ; kaltmanG lawampnmt.com < k a l t m a n e Iawamprnnt. com>,' Torregros sa, Brennan,. tkelberG Sidl ey. com ,' Ffaster, Eben Sent: Wed Jan 10 22:03:23 200"1 Subject: RE: Cal1
----nri rri nr I Mae
Steve , confirm Can the witness be made available before the 25th? I think Eben wilf you that Judqe Baker is quite serious about getting discovery moving and that his order. Camp and I canrt be part of an agreement to amend same. Things Keith are great, thanks, and I hope the same for you. for is
-----Ori
rri n:
I
M a e c . a , , . r a- - - - -
F r o m : M c c o n n e l l , S t e p h e n [ m a i l t o : s t e p h e n . m c c o n n e ] . le d e c h e r t . c o m J Sent: Wednesday, 10 January, 200'7 LB:.32 T o : K e i t h J e n s e n ; C B a i l e y G b p b - L a wc. o m Cc: l jaf fe@weitztux. com,' kaltmanGlawampmmt com,' Torregrossa, Brennan; . tkelberGSidfey,com; Flaster, Eben Subject: Re: CaflKeith, As per my earlier on the 23rd. messag'e to Camp/ one of the witnesses i-s available So if you'd Iike to come to beautiful downtown Wilmington on that date, we'd be delighted to see you. But for the other witness we will need to find another Do vou have anv druthers? date after the 23rd.
LL l r r^ -,^J i r - r 'r ct_Lt .: J _^D . , c I r 1 ,w . - rL l1 - , Y,v u ., w^ L ,l1 - r . a,
Steve
M-a-c- s a g e - - - - .. From: kj Gkjensenlaw. com T o : C a m p B a i l e y < c b a i l e y G b p b l a w . c o m > , ' M c C o n n e . l - 1 ,Stephen c o m > ; K e i t h A I t m a n Cc: Jonathan Jaffe Date: Wed, 10 Jan 2001 1,159:05 : To: "Ke j-th Jensen" sUDtect: tw: ual r
See below.
I told
them you r,rould respond to stay involved
their in
question. this set up.
Let me know if
you want me to
getting
K. Camp Bailey Attorney at Law
cri n.a l M- - - - a g e - - - - - oqq F r o m : M c C o n n e l l / S t e p h e n [ m a i l - t o : s t e p h e n . m c c o n n eL I G d e c h e r t . c o m ] Sent: llednesday, January I0, 200'7 3:17 PM To: Camp Bailey Cc: Torregrossa, Brennan; FIaster, Eben; tkelberGSidley. corn -----Ori arrFrian{-. DF. a^lI
Camp, Thanks. It turns out that one of the two interviewees on the is available but the other is not. Would you like to schedule the one interview on the and, meanwhile, I'11 try to t-rack down dates for the other interviewee? * Steve ^--,-age----From: Camp Bailey [mailto: CBaileyGbpblaw. con] Sent: Wednesday, January I0, 2001 1:48 PM To: McConnel , Stephen Cc: Torreg.rossa, Brennan; Flaster, Eben Subject: RE: CaIl
cri n: l Meq< -----Ari
23rd, 23rd
He I have been trying to get Keit.h avail-abLe to calf, but haven't been able yet. would work for him dld pass along that the 23rd or 19th (in order of preference) and our IT quy, . . Let me know if those work and I wifl re.Iav the messaqe.. -
K. Camp Bailey Attorney at law ----.-age----F r o m : M c C o n n e L I , S t e p h e n [ n a i l t o : s t e p h e n . m c c o n n el l $ d e c h e r t Sent: Tuesday, ,fanuary 09, 20O'l 9118 PM To: Camp Bailey
-----t'lrininal Mecq
, com]
Cc: Torregrossa, Brennan; Fl-aster, Subj ect: Re: Ca-l1 I never received a call does not work for you.
----Orirrin.rl
Eben
from you. What dates
I heard do?
indirect-ly
from Tamar that
January
22
----M.a c, s a g e ,From: Camp Bailey T o : M c C o n n e ll , S L e p h e n Cc: Torregrossa, Brennan; Kelber, Tamar B. Sent: Mon Jan 0B 18:59:22 2001 Subject: RE: CaIl" Keith Jensen and I will caII you back on this i-n the morning, if possible.
K. Camp Bailey Attorney at La\,r
M- a e c a g e - - - - - .--From: McConnell, Scephen [mai]to: stephen. mcconnel l0dechert. Sent: Monday/ January 08f 2007 3:48 PM To: Camp Bailey Cc: Torreqrossa, Brennan; Kelber, Tamar B. S u b i ect : RE: Cal-l -----t^lrinin:1
coml
Camp, T wanted to chat with you about the IT interviews, ft witnesses are availabfe How does that on Januarv 22. fooks
r^rnrlr fnr
li ke the
r;nrr"
two
You certainly - Steve
-----f)ri
seem to be busy these days.
P l e a s e c a l - L m e when you free
up.
rri n: I M- - * ; r g e - - - - - acq Froml cbaileyGbpblaw. com lmailto: cbaifeyGbpblaw. com] Sent: Monday, January 08, 2007 4:42 PII To: Mcconneflf Stephen Subiect: CaIl
I
am running
i nrr nr
to
another
f hinrli
meeting
n iho
right
now.
I wiII
be able
to
call
you back this
arrcn
fir
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?