Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 324

DEPOSITION of Daphne Greenberg, Ph.D. taken on April 21, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit D-1, # 2 Exhibit D-2, # 3 Exhibit D-3 - part1, # 4 Exhibit D-3 - part 2, # 5 Exhibit D-4, # 6 Exhibit D-5, # 7 Exhibit P-1)(Rains, John)

Chapter 20

Advanced Avenues

Adult

in

Development and Learning

The

Role of Doctoral

and Robert Barrier

Judith Stevens-Long

this

chapter

we

graduate

studies

in

In

intended

its

of

spring
the

at

and

2002

assessing

covered

graduate
on

outcomes

behavioral

focused

on

such

areas

clinical

study

such

One

to

of

to

this presentation

some

attendees

the

was

anxiety

for

responsible

on

as

of

ates

are

panying

emotional
graduate

them become
distinction

and

assessment

study

responsible

here between

behavioral
they
for

changes

might

them

what

by

sulted

graduate

develop

what

graduate

of

with

Re

called

and

Nyquist
the

in

appears

study

Jody

started

Bettina
that

statement

advances

in

reac

man

part

that

has

hy
in

condition

inform

ate

delineating

make

cultural

moral and

Scholarly
us

better

differences
ethical

educators

Exhibit 3 - 20

455

to

United

medicine

in

nature

our

work

in

and
of

few

social
of the
life

sci

hu
and

humanities

the

and

dimensions

our

re

en

only
the

daily

understand

States
has

and

training

new understandings

that

policy

doctoral

training

if

enabled

come from gradu
the

unitnagined

Doctoral

provided

has

in

science

were

that

ago

have

programs

produced

gineering

accom

Thus we

an

doctoral

Expertise

public
there

human

doctorate

extensive

achievements

Legendary

and

the

iii

review
the

Ph.D

2000

ences
tion

education

graduate

be

identity

striking

brief

In

the

decades
particulady

what

potentiate

particular

do

Woodford

especially

development

in

envisioning

of scholar-practitioners

organizational

psychology

on

topics

ego

to

with

and

the

and

were

seems

begin

tended

presentation

development

We

We
school

Higher

of

be intending and

to

process

ment

the

2002

affective

including

development
as

The

as

paper

of

the theme

developments

the

presented

cognitive

intellectual

In

Stevens-Long

appear

and

adults

Advancement

outcomes

ineffable
of

in

changes

authors

for the

literature

havioral

in

the

advanced

of
of

consequences

McClintock
the

conference

and

of

one

role

development

unintended

Association

Education

the

explore
the

Study

human

appreci
of

the

existence

ADULT DEVELOPMENT

456

Following
training

ethical

the

and

dents

honors
grants

to

extent

and

through

publications

of

of

books

main

indicators

addressed

only

are

of

aspects

outcomes

amined

Often

based

the

there

much

is

education

ducting

quality

side

of

that

terview

study

and

gests

Graduate
toral

of

ods

lack

that

and

social

are

out

the

research

and

struggle

skills

on

sug

to

reflect

identified

or

problems

that

This would

to

seem

Michael
or

stages

postformal

2000 doc

diction

and ambiguity and

by

intense

emotional

peri

turmoil

basis

as

to follow

for

thought

structures

formation

AND COGNITIVE

the

over

the

course

tellectual

become
to

skilled

at

existing

anticipate
structured

or

or unstated

terms

recognition

of

the
of

it

is

development
of

in

expected

to

in the

students

are

which

implies

and

area

conventional

research

forecast

about

study

research

able

to

recognize

and

problems

the

ability

these

hope

problems
define

ill-

problems

and

adult
the

development
ability

to

think

are
to

the

concept
but

that

the

outcomes

Exhibit 3 - 21

of

the

concept

to

consider

seen

posifor

able

is

the
in

these

of

patterns

cultural

one

in relationship

to

the
with-

comparisons

judgments

problems

able

trans-

tystem Furthermore

value

Commons
of

posited

At

tions

kinds

used

kinship

make

making

be

Certainly

graduate

students

engage

Similarly
the

can

thinker

necessarily

another

of these

use

must

in constant

example

characterize

in

contra-

thought

Sinnott

For

systems

that

patterns

postformal

out

posiformal
to

Riegel

tolerate

one

that are

advanced

Klaus

effective

particular

might be meaningfully

different

ing
in

of

relativity

under

problems
literature

according

resolve

resolved

on

to

ability

make

the

previously

of research

work

1981 1984

about

talk

toward

might

follows

forms

or

Sinnott

Jan
to

relationships

exists

Graduate

One must be

standings

the

of doctoral

change

question

In

agreement

In

Cer

been

one

essence

the

and

solved

are

adequately

thinking

emphasizing

requires

problem

not

1984

in

system
of

the

1973

DEYELOPMENT
modicum

be

to

Bassechess

mal thinker

If

how

been

not

Fielding

the

transformation

STUDY

on

reflect

have

character

is

student

have

argu-

adequate

finding
of

the

that

problems

are

problems

move

studies

find

cogent

1977

thinking

nature

by which

doctoral

to

ability

the

on

Most

operations

Problem

Corn

1990I

Kohlberg

1975

postformal

1975

Arlin

1984

1984

Arlins

finding

processes

of

Benack

Sinnott

formal

solving

ability

of systems

DOCTORAL

and

Patricia

is

by problem

the

about

nonlinear

posiformal

1978 1984

although

problem

tainly

in

extensive

Woodford
at

accompanied

discomfort

con

complain

emotional

Yet as

by Nyquist and
by

whether

graduates

Schoenholz-Read

usually

for

causal

and
reason

require

those

1980 1984

1984

Stemberg

of

including

Richards

ment

have

Employers

and

ized

opera

how

logical

that

descriptions

Basseches

and

that

issues

of

perhaps

one

2002

fonnal

how people

explain

offered

here

anything but

doctoral

wodd

reported

personal

cognitive

even

danger

about

for

one

the

business

University

studies

them

been

mons

linear

relationships

unex

left

AAI-IE

at

reflecting

university

supported

is

and

are

consider

employing

many Ph.D.s

required

or

irrelevant

controversy

prepares

research

in the

studied

as

of causality

number

1984

well

new systems Formal operations

but cannot

conceptions

have

op-

extensive

as

understanding

for analyzing

transformational

the

research

about

the

the

for

comprehend

adequate

in

Richards

model

others As

many

inadequate

relations

directly
to

ethical
study

be

discourse

of

raised

to

are

intellectual

are

prescnting

some even

doctoral

been

moral

of

experience

topic

the

education

graduate

is

learning

theyÆre considered

that

might argue

fact

of

come

perfor

Furthermore

they

is

graduate

training

nor

tions

with

stage

support

Francis

formal

ot

1977 1984

and

solutions

alternative

Piagets
finds

Broughton

Commons

Par

are

and

indicators

behavioral

In

of

by John

Michael
along

research

grants

training

The emotional

as

and

publications
graduate

funded

work

beyond

This argument

erations

and

conditions

movement

implies

stu

accreditation

and

evaluated

ous

and

evaluation

the

assess

proposition

those

cognitive

on

this

on

neither

by
that

and

grants

articles

been

Yet

addressed

all

education

underscores

reflect

learning

of

moral and

emphasis

Of course

lieved

cultural

traditional

matters

awards

mance

new knowledge

research

have

about ambiguous

doctoral

of graduate

faculty

in

ticularly

that

produce

the

outcomes

counting

assert

might

human

to

and

Certainly

the

ing

intended

is

scientific

kinds

ve

lead

this

AND LEARNING MEASURED AND APPLIED

systems

up

stage

to

to

and

four stages

of systematic

1984

Richards

describe

postformal
formal

beyond
order

may be determined

the

by

used
think

opera

thinker

many

sees

causes

TUE ROLE

and

observation

this

uses

tend

thinkers

atic

about

information

These

bles

2002

order

this

vious

erned by

this

the

the

of

objects

or

science

out

carry
of

most beginning

population

of

gov

the

are

that

use

function

at

systems

are

that

even

able

jority

did

estimates

now

transform and
focus

2002

universities

function

at

thinkers

to

Commons

within

their

iii

stage

and

research

at top

professors

this

the

by

According
all

systems

understanding

used

almost

are

synthesize

on

is

methods

system

particular

thinkers

Metasystematic

line

work

knowledge

curved

nf

subsequent

as

an

are

geometry

level

However
that

most

first

stages

there

of

1991

Karen

of

thinking

The

problems

torical scientific
of

stage

began

to see

stand

the

resolved

with

defined

cation
seven

of

to

that

explanation

and

that

thinkers

At

the

they

still

knowledge
next

was
did

stage
required

not

see

in

have

can

be

single

unclear

claims

in

students
to

At

under

no

were

how

his

thinkers

that

interpretation

but

scheme

problems

evaluate

situations

contexts

between

stage

re

King

in

and

those

of

justify

to

ill-

under
an

evaluate

important

more

age

argued
the

comports

with

description

of

tends

much
the

agreement

here

soning

the

as

eration

any

of

conclusions

through

to

of

test

it

is

and

that
feel

definition

of

consid
in

knowledge
the

tends

and

continuing

of perspective

it

further

trans

how we become
that

assumptions

crit

how we

constrain

not

is

and

we

integrative

open

the
feel

us

the

according

it

more

is

to

alternative

156

world
about

Here
the

on

cognitive

cations

for

emotional change

is

the

development

assump

understand
mention

first

world

Most

ignores

altogether

inte

Perspective
the

challenge

but

perspec
and

we perceive

way

inclu

of experience

discrimination

erature

Exhibit 3 - 22

to

increase

causes

about

that

only

inclusivity

constrain

affecthow

transformation

perspective

contsnually

transformation
tions

rea

discussion

permeable

that

so

gration

is

line of

careful
of

is

and

it

discriminating

also that
tives

and

emphasizes

1991

Mezirow

sive

there

study

world

the

The

The

1933

that support

grounds

work

Pogson

advanced

form

supposed

education

work

reflection

Deweys

of the

aware

ically

view

this

2002

adult

persistnt

which

which

Richards

Tennant

of

goal

critical

Mezirows

Jack

formation

the

or

Stewart

character

is

of systems

on

2000

with

belief

light of the

and

beyond

active

begins

reflection

to

of

development

is

development

undergraduate

that

stu

order

Tennant
on

the

and

literature

to focus

edu
Level

education

Yaii

systesns

systematic

the

1991

see

Commons

the

Although

1995

to

the

and

stage

ability

before

graduate

However
age

ma

the

stage

in

to

an

reported

of doctoral

time

Fischer

judgment
that

than

in

to

to

through

the

than

reflective

King
sample

typical

25

the

Mezirow

of

of

solution

and

stages

50%

about

over

by

in

appear

At

how

and opinion

bet

higher

changes

cognitive

appears

ized

Kitchener

reasoning

stage

graduate

mentors

their

evidence
or

differ

next

understands

thinker

better

of

evidence

of

the

at

college-educated

use

then

dents

ill-structured

dilemmas

everyday

King
of

the

development

knowledge

certainty

However

how

and

uncertainty

distinction

solution
about

the

evidence

Patricia

about

sampled

religious

of

many

their study

of

stages

Kitchener and

the

an

achieve

least

In

students

college

field

of

not

of

advanced

of

presume

the

problem

among

24 The

age

the

empirical
at

Kitchener and

researchers

new

function

do

seven

outlined

of the

creation

Clearly not

thought

postformal

1994

creation

convincing

students

judgment

flective

is

of

whole

Descartess

examples

idea

cross-

Finally

create

to

of cognitive

graduate

the

replacement

example

Copernicuss
and

existing

of

development

able

are

mechanics

this

the

in

about

of

worth

relative

emerges

existing

inquiry

level

typical

is

comparison

typical

the

stage

claims

lustify

Commons

thinking

the

knowledge

us achieve

about

thinking

and

thinkers

celestial

alytical

very

for

to

geometry

paradigmatic

stood

or

able

historical

rare

pointed

space

Euclidean

the

in

are

people

stage

cross-paradigmatic

and Richards

of

fields

new paradigms

stances

fields

metasystematic

new

create

of

critical

is

we would

stage

2002
the

Beyond
to

final

clearly

of

thought

and

students

the
the

contexts

across

Such

ill-defined

The

and

opinion

argued

457

students

through

perspectives

pre

This

King

to evaluate

ing

stage

interpretations

and

graduate

ability

as

seen

order

metasystematic

contrast

assumptions

The

and
at

operates

is

can

be

Richards

variations

events

Our

thought

relationships

Richards

can

STUDY

differing

Kitchener

reasoning

van

instance

and

of

ta

of

order

next

compare

of

standard

causality

US

the

systematic

At

to

of

for

Commons

Bhavior

multivariate

20%

only

how

worth

the

of

form

in the

development

Researchers

experiments

System

representations

systems

other

most

that

argued

matrix

cognitive

each

systems

generate

might show

of

with

compared

to

build

various

tables

theories

uris

to

OF DOCTORAL

of the
the
Yet

of
lit

impli
there

is

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

458

clear

evidence

that

dant

cognitive

changes

tant

emotional

In

Read
as

2000

the

at

Some

confidence

in

increased

the

about

way

one

objective
sense

perspective

and

lest

this

per

phasis

be

on

important

quite

am

am

implies

ones

own

fixed

as

take

DEVELOPMENT

The

of

in effect

self

experience

tial

hybrid

and

truths

In

and

Rogers
self

draws

work

the

perspectives

the

dialogic

of

is

par

of lenses

the

authors

self

view

of

Vygotsky

1984 as well as of Richardson
McCarroll
1998 to describe the adult

struggle

from

the

tween

perspectives

outside

This conception

among

multiple

that
of

make

the

voices

continuous

world

self

claims
is

on

internalized
dialogue

our

postmodern

be

highly

developed

awareness

very

of the

self as
constructed

1999

has

characterized
nature

as

and

around

center
the

states

ego
tity

as

increasingly

and

tendency
People

scale

and

also
the

face

of

writing

of

that

higher

the

yond

reality

the

increased

and

the

and

wisdom

Baltes

focused

on

knowledge

Exhibit 3 - 23

emotion

relativistic

the

the

is

is

sense

the

of

self

and

part
the

inter
in the

who

argues

integration

New

with

work

Staudinger
processes

interpersonal

of

be

knowledge

interconnected
of

of cognitive

emotional and

as

at

represented

and

deeply

construction

integration

isolation

development

2000

subjective

Lindenberger

of the

and

Work

self

Labouvie-Vief

operations

soci

ego development

human

of reflection

and

life

conventional

emotional

the

use

formal

of

loss

their personal

mind and

and

Cisela

iden

some

was

conceptualizations

to include

theory

or

ego

high-end

of day-to-day

the

of

notions

of

at

loneliness

conventional

cognition

and

post-

more

broadened

parcel

of

of

sense

dialectic

of

from

high end

ones

with

study

disengage

employ

challenges

that

aspects

of integrating

difficulty

Recent
have

at

Hewletts

reported

with

reality

to

Cook

their separate

construct

mundane

the

of

go

Individuals

experience

more

the

in

self

mental

in

associated

interest

these

even

at

by

individuals

broadly

of letting

process

separate

illusory or as

times

ety

Most

developmen
occur

described

stages

ego

the

self

challenges

its

can

that

strategies these

the

of

sense

described

formula

be

than

without

not

has

handling emotions

contextual

described

by
of

sense

1984

rather

imbalances

including

emotion
Cook-Greuter

the

266

1999

self

is

2004
and

high-end

attention

conventional
Susanne

enjoy

consolidating

Kegans

have

to

however

challenges

prism self This

Bakhtin

and

as

on

one

the

1995

self that

multiplicity

described

by

Pogson

the

the

process

relationship

multiple
of

as

by

replaced

being formed

itself

recent

2000

Stevens-Long

1986

perhaps

politi

self

ongoing

Tennant
of

and

The

dialectical

construction

and

construct

in

appreciation

toward

us

an

forming and

encounteri

it

169 The

is

entity
as

stands

both

experience

drives

harmonious

self-construction

em

making

while

Robert

with

comes

Greuter

social

is

exercise

exam
the

but

along

trundling

Cook-Greuter

tion one

the

EDUCATION

experience

Two

illustrate

fathom

diversifing

Consistent

per

conse

developmental

psychological

and

stable

notion

to

of

interpretation

as well

ex

Loevinger

particular
to

ability

in

cal

work

Jane

unEthomable
to

alive

can

contracting

tal

The

by

responses

end

of trying

Dane Hewlett

AND GRADUATE

displays

awareness

instrument

completion

in the

process

best

quences

EMOTIONAL

self

profound

system developed

per-

most

its

process

Having

spectives

At

less

Certainly

about

Such

reality

Cook-Greuters

becoming

scoring

of postconventionat

ples

self-

of

process
the

and

of search-

futility

fluid

is

that

claims

postconventional

paradoxes

her sentence

for

profound

So although

may be learned

the

tends

appreciate

discuss

feels

of

self that

the

and

and

the

sees

of self or

sense
of

stage

ambiguities

learning

perspectives

or

perspective

very

an

She

assumptions

ego

person

have

sons

and

themselves

multiple

at the

has

for

that

to

ability

others

see

holds

their

empathy

They

they
to

how

ing

to

stretching

by

the

to

view

sensitivity

in

Mark

leads

of multiple

affected

conventional

posteonventional

postconventional

University

intellectual

listen

of

points

changes

change

talk

the

to

the

Schoenholz

Graduate

patience

reactive

emotionally

education

understanding

deeply

They

refers

developed

report

the

feel

of

deconstruction

rather

As

self

the

impor

by

our experience

increased

report

different

of

atten

its

by

often

adult

Fielding
to

broadening and
they

and

change

begin

spectives

and

all

been

has

it

students

accompanied

argued

personal

fact

education

are

experiences

2000

profound

advanced

reconstruction

thoroughgoing
Tennant

AND LEARNING MEASURED AND APPLIED

on

1998
with

THE ROLE OF DOCTORAL

one account

In
dents

at

Fielding

periential

when
liminal

that

process

mation

of

the

sertation
event

finding

ones

ing

based

as

that

tions
of

toward

it

All

Diehi

Labouvie-Vief

there

some

is

change

about

emotional changes

education

with

emotional
strongly

correlated

tween

cognition

tween

than

cognition

and

emotion

can

more

of

remain

ship

al 1998

although
the

education

correlation

connection

be

with

be

self-efficacy

behavior

almost

is

DEVELOPMENT

persist

FOR ACTION

STRIVING

AND GRADUATE

tend

when
play

intent

We

coughing

or

ested

in

servable
the

as

kind

sions
and

as

or

that

and
some

attitudes

and

of

writers

action

perceived

we might be

are

by
and

freedom

often

can
or

814
consider

of choice

opportunities

inter

Gist 1989

human

studying

wisdom

dimen

derstanding

education

Brandtsthdter

is

nition

Hill

the

to

the

Exhibit 3 - 24

self-

Zim
such

advantage

their

capabil

opportunities

1990

clearest

stands

research

at the

behavior

work

implications

between

relationship

and

time

in

1992

greater

such

developmental

has

their

Finally

develop

through

Elias

Wisdom

emotion

to take

and

extensively

mainstream

reflexivity

such

1990

found

facilitate

engaging

Sehrauben

dis

also

that

tracking

and

the

persevere

students

behaviors

of

in

effort

likely to

include

Cer
sense

themselves

for

greater

Martinez-Pons

more

In

expressing
In

control

be

between

strong

goals

more

are

Pintrich

of learning
ities

of

feelings

link

learning

with

schoolwork

learning

to

relate

higher

Examples

their

have been

on

another

ilure These

with

individuals

ob

Certainly

self-regulatory

study

directed

and

merman

in

relation

expend

tasks

tasks

confronted

personal

set

inter

individual

that

goal

values

personal

the

of

greater

organizing
in

span

variables

Students

With

interested

personal

intentionality

example

attention

values

serving

for

we

chosen

is

accompanied

paying

1998

of

development
be

to

here

although

awake

of beliefs

the

to

appear

interested

sleeping

behavior

personal
this

not

staying

basis

preted

are

that

Brandtstadter

Jochem

refers

development
or behaviors

to

at

longer

completion

EDUCATION

How

action-related

forging

strongly

1986

Peake

self-efficacy

by

is

Self-efficacy

CONATIVE

to

likely

strong

unknown

is

life

suspect

of these

learned

are

enable

more

is

are

they

that

the

that

and development

learning

vone

actions

adaptive

would

believe

conditions

over

re

strongly

people

behavior

their

out

or

planning

development

the

one

ever

If

in

between

at reparation

also

are

tran
linked

action

to

attempts

own

and

flexible

that
are

and

example

self-efficacy

Moreover

change

education

for

to

make

to

mismatches

actions

their

during

circumstances

current

create

to

to

begin

begin

cognition

lead

of

control

likely

see

uncharted

Conative

and

feelings

relationship

the

the

emotion

et

to

maturity

behavioral
levels

lated

lead

peopl.e

Emotions

signal

self-punishment and

they

anything

wisdom we

Baltes

researched

and

if

on

might accompany
on

high

advantage

well

less

work
and

with

little

is

that

intellectual

and socioeconomic
Even

there

age

in the

Certainly

research

developmental

emotional
the

between

Mismatches

teaming

unex

processes

time

Emotions

hopes

comes

have
that

and

execute
of

periods

processes

serve

sometime

adulthood

and

plans

mediate

or

that

argued

young

long

previous

forms

varied

to

such

more complex cogni

and

and

ac

often

often

they

own development

their

spire over

and perhaps representa

interplay

monitor

in

the

beliefs

Figs

or

that

they

consequences

Development-oriented

Although

are

tend

257

1999

that

and

conclusions

differing

implies

experience

possibilities

reality

Brandtstadter

choices

or

and

in goals

adolescence

and

goals

events

maintains

intention

unintended

ac

how

cognitive

overdetermined

are

one

or

changes

to

see

social

of

about

more complex

permit

emotional

intellectual

than

pected

from

means

It

universe

more

cbs

thinking

thinking

of

the

of interest

ex

the

to

and

other

Brandtstader

action

means

actions

memories and

and

plans

beliefi

behavior

affects

feeling

tions

capstone

transition

how

fluence

transfor

of

product

operational

assumptions

minimum

at

the

pectations

how

in

what

influence

evaluation

Deegan

may be
with

begins

whether

and emotional

tive

but

one

just

Dewey put

of this

that

postformal

in differing
as

ing

much

perspective

personal

that

so

formal

solving

problem

here

argue

not

is

process

problem

self

interested

particularly

tor

of

aspects

the

transforms

by stu

the ex

encountered

essential

although

self

process

in the

are

read
that

uncertainty

322 We

1991

Hill

and

dissertation

writing

maintain

authors

mystery

and

distributed

widely
the

459

STUDY

2002

on

un
and

behavior

intersection

Kamer

for

of

cog

argued

that

wise

rather

open

Achenbaum
dom

and

adult

Pascual-Leone

the

may

even

and

that

very

hand

shows

1983

of

that

the

and

one

with

the

to

seems

number

im

other

in

the

unique

We

kind

the

central

to

of

grad

Kitchcner

In

their

noted
lieve

that
that

interviewees
doctoral

that

world

porate
students

These

interests

and

knowledge
than

less

of the
the

there

study

Young

faculty

sibilities

of

tion

from

wisdom

is

There
kinds

of

only

planning

and

tangentially

evidence
and

to the

suming

cor

the

that

is

the

narrow

context

research

for the

respon
evalua

the

college

service

to

the

research

to graduate

kinds

that
of

study

particular

contexts

optimal development

on

of

are

gradu

in

the

which

it

is

of

From

outside

Knowledge

Freire
dispensed

culture
this

as

entity

consumption

or

as

embedded

form

commodity
acquired

entering

knowledge

surrounding so

preconstructed

2000
quite

in
or

ideology

gain

perspective

amassing informa

with

synonymous

is

of

externalized

an

as

considerations

knowledge

sources

tion

whether

over

of

of

perspec

the

most

that

context

freely

on

view

from

for internal

be

stu

derived

transformation

personal
ing

how

can

that

multiple

critically

suggests

bankable

that

flexibility

greater
to

hold

in

show

studies

isolated

exists

ready
as

dependent

collegial

however

self

them

university

work

students

it

thought
through

these

is

this

1981

King

student

openness

knowledge

that

seen

of

1992

matriculation

to reflect

ideological

treat

one

Clearly

particular

of

from

scholarly

related

and

They

how

demonstrate

product

other

expressed

teaching

community

some

actions

most conducive

research
university

undergraduate

abstract

of

todays

outside

unprepared

an

1990

ability

undergraduate

Magolda

Baxter

knowledge

from which

years

studied

increased

the

making

problems

overemphasizes

and

is

an

and

tives

work

claimed

also

of

ed

of graduate

Kitchener

All

progressively

thought

ways

in

required

concern

seem

the

to

re

changes

conception

general

undergraduate

work

postgraduate
dents

researchers

have

1984

changes

cial

graduates

prepare

disconnected

traditional

often

curricular

university

often

traditional

much

is

are

be

industry

collaborative

practitioners

Even

in

the

interviewees

are

optimal

graduate

work

real-world

boundaries

ever

not

lack

and working

thinking

does
their

training

Ph.D.s

Many

others

and

in business

connect

meaningfully

2000

Woodford

the

of

the

over

Brenner

Generally
and

Nyquist

paper

of

AND LEARNING

in the

learning

of

Sinnott

education

uate

in

ucation

practice

accompany

that

capacity

self

OBTAINING

overview

described

and

knowledge

Schon

the

of

of

awareness

PERSPECTIVE

an

provides

have

searchers

evi

does not

On

20.1

pro
is

reflection

cope

of

but education

situations

transformation

perspective

for

to

conflicting

this

expect

form

scholar-practitioner
capacity

allows

increased

PATHWAY

FIRST

ON KNOWLEDGE

Table

appears

wise

gaining

use

contexts

DIFFERENT

1998

There

certainly

the

consis

are

and

become

the

on

action

uncertain
might

eduation

cultural

THE

the

during

developed

education

to

will

person

research

midst

to

related

is

it

em

action

and

and

of

an

obtain

gaining

community

learning

developing

include

per

Bacelar

thinking

emotion

to

advanced

that

ply

relativistic

related

foundly

the

development

knowledge

understanding

and

exceptional

resister

highly

in

complete

learning

on

we cx

chapter
to

They

study

perspective

this

lead

reality

be

1996 They

require

more

that

graduate

different

social

as wise

have

to

to experience

open

govern
internal

leadership

Nazi

Staudinger

as

of
or

being

and

nominated

are

services

like

self

mdi

to

conventional

outer

who

that

inner

positions

human

Wisdom

dence

with

one

norms

the

integrate

hold

Reich

allows

conventional

to

experiences

and

part of

avenues

the

of

membership

people

in

dialectical

context

2000

to

seen

in the

second

different

wisdom

concerns

tend

tently

In

four

that

that

proposed

Furthermore

Third

wis

students

Labouvie-Vief

from

ployed

defensively

characterized

ate
plore

to

ing

behavior

sons

respond

1991

others

understanding

both

affective

to

allow

that

ways

communicates

and caring

viduate

in

than

Orwoll

behavior

as

1990

interact

people

remain

AND LEARNING MEASURED AND APPLIED

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

460

in their

Early
see

truth

structs
lar

as

Aronson

the

in

one

Kitchener

1981
ten

is

As

come

Exhibit 3 - 25

to

the

belief

correct

premature

students

and

of

problem

solution

to

1990

any

on

and

1977

given

will

prob
King

students

problems

po

schema

solving

Kitchener

undergraduate
closure

into

rigid

2002 Markus

also

con

white

experience

notion

that

Brenner

consequence
to

black

to forceflt

Alcert
the

most

careers

absolute

related

Wilson

itself

uncover
lem

of

This tendency

categories

reveals

college

matter

of

without

TUE ROLE OF DOCTORAL
TABLE 20.1
From

View

of

and

Absolute

as

of Knowledge

The Nature

Knowledge

environment

The

commodity

as

horn

preeonstructed

that

product

that

knowledge

Knowledgc

without

to

is

absolute

declarative

1991

to

solutions

It

tend

to

and

adopt

learner has

defend

difficulty

contradictory

integrating

fixed

Learners

position
and

incorporating

is

to

the

through

perspectives

possible

becomes

thinking

of opposing

juxtaposition

1981

King

Kitchener

perspectives

1986

Baltes

2000

al

all

1992

poblem

Polanyi 1966

Dixon
et

tacit

of

alternative

relative

explore

Magolda

dialectical

as

1979

Sternberg

attempt

often

product

multiple

regarded

1986

Baxter

findings

to

Soloway

Scribner

The

and

leading

Ehrlich

and

relative

as

Brockett

1991

Wenger

articulate

formulation

1987

the broader

in

context

Lave

seen

is

Knowledge
difficult

Learners

situated

as

and

of observation

act

Jarvis

dialogue

seen

is

Hiernstra

explicit

and

Relative

constructed

socially

the very

social/cultural/ideological

culture or ideology

Knowledge

as

through

and

Knowledge

reference

Complex

as

treated

is

transformed

context-free

is

Learning

of Knowledge

reflection

be reviewed

can

be

external

2000

Freire

learner assumes

can

that

th

461

Contextualized

Deeply

viewed

is

absorbed

View

To

Deeontextualized

and

Knowledge

STUDY

Basseches

1984
Problems

are usually

Wagner

Sternberg

for

are established

1995 Uedlund

2000

Pogson

to

move

all

views

tendency
examining
concepts

into

to

closure

premature

or

to

pigeonhole

simplistic

that

al 2000

related

is

complex and

often

are

solutions

are

formulated

are

of learning

aspect

1966 Dixon

Polanyi

1990

wisdom

to

by the

guided

Arlin

This

Sternberg

1986

Baltes

create

without

first

1989

Cockrill

experiences

stereotyped

problems
and

problems

way

Sternberg

Kelly 1955

that

see

unstructured

et

constructs

impermeable

and

1986 Tennant

Sternberg

Leamers

clear

solution

problem

2000

Crigorenko
Simple

and

fur learners

predefiricd

parameters

analyze
and

categories

and

deal with

with

issues

complex

this the

1986

Swezey

information

discrepant

to

ability

Strerifert

Domangue

1978
Learning

is

as

experienced

purely

cognitive

process

to

Ability

synthesize

forms

tascual-Lcone

seem

to exist

system
because

in

potential

from

isolation

are

solistions

Proposed

in

repercussions

the surrounding
to

likely

the

system

more

adopt
with

working

elements

including

analysis

of thought

emerges

1992

Labouvie-Vief

2000

systemic
that

problensa

number

containing

unconsidered

are

Diehl

Learners

be limited
larger

1990

Labouvie-Vief
Problems

rational

objective

emotive

subjective

perspective
are

nnbonnded

of complex

and

interactive

Ackoff

factors

interpersonal

1981

examining

first

belief

often

and

belief

ing

with

The

lems

rameters

solution

and

of

hold

students

that

and

problem

contain

information

to

existing

have

Mezirow

in

tend

the

to

overuse

solving

and
be

to

work

2000

reinforced

clearly

Often

arrive

of

by

prob

defined

pa

predefined
the

at

the

problem
correct

As

students
they

years

and

constn.scted

and

They

tightly

Sinnott

Moreover

develop
problems

embedded

more
in

greater

1984

dialectical
of

college
flexible

an

Exhibit 3 - 26

extensive

is

actively

given

King
of

appreciation

and

increased

an

through

perspectives

education

approaches

summary

of

other

ability

the

itera

Basseches
helps

to

social

1992

Magolda

Kitchener

thinking

opposing

undergraduate

in

Baxter
1990

develop

integration

1984

knowledge

context

move toward

tive

their

how

see

Brenner

perspectives
to

to

ideological

1981

through

progress

begin

Kitchener

learning

predefined

statement

needed

positions

difficulty

knowledge

provide

their

Furthermore

defend

information

classroom

for

problems

to

rigidly

environments

in the

the

them

constructions

younger

views

possible

contradictory

learning

all

systems

static

that

all

leads

students

unstructured
this

research

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

462

Ernest

that

and

Pascarella

eluded

when

AND LEARNING MEASURED

1991

Terenzini

Patrick

freshmen

are

to

con-

senior-

when

facilitated

was

Learning

students

more

are

address

no

skilled

than

more

can

more

develop

works

to

deal

are

side

one

with

are

why

worked

an

ity

much

an

room

Marcia

for

future

Baxter

We

and

ran

simulated

airlines

the

in

search

In

ished

has

the

level

highest

of

reached

senior

of

year

measured

reasoning

This

study

by

increased

figure

was one
and

to

of

the

student

graduation
pared

and

niors

when

Similarly

among

thinking

between

year

freshmen
he

educabori

following

version

he

thinking

The

described

one

allows

thinking

of

analysis

to

analyze

within

relationships

problems

particular

competing

system

thinkers

also

exhibit

lem

see

great

contends

but

that

as

source

positive
are

increases

an

as

that

of

linking

status

prob

We

contend

here

one

adult

capaci

thinking

that

Instead

education

tor to

scholarly

students
self

and

the

their roles

that

require

of

their

and
tive

as

exposure

students

to

make

Gritical

complex

self-monitor

problem

can

the

two

graduate

the

exploration

years

following

degrees

of
the

as Baxter

they

discrepant

They

demand

often

one

must

is

value

op.

contradictory

seemingly

br

their

formation

solutions

eduea-

Magolda

projects

with

the

who

student

pres-

com

set of

unique

accustomed

is

such

environments

learning

to

situa

produce

of

deal

of

put

anxiety

challenge

has

As one

doe-

to

iiig

that
the

my

greatest

post-courscwork
21

essentially

cogni
suddenly

increas
problems

one

1990

tional

of their

2001

good
it

problems

their

Arlin

completion

learning

of their thesis or dissertation

students

For

candidate

tations

guides

and

of

fonnulation

become

students
the

way

focus

structured

ter

the

the

adaptations

to carefully

Postgraduate

that

innovative

identify

problems

felt

large-scale

and

of

with

responsibility

take

to

postgraduate

more

creators
to

to

aware

1978

thinking

curricula

direct

tion

approaches

processes

ingly

issues

complex

1986

contribu

their views

existing

analysis

differenti

postgraduate

both

knowledge

is

effectively

and

undergraduate

becoming

reconstruct

reconstruction

more

need

toral

this

of

analysis

Swezey

Domangue

and

community

learning

dramatically

in the

selective

more

Un

complexity

cognitive
for

de

of the

during

process

avenue

important

of

cognitive

postgraduate

of

un

complex

highly

one

development

extension

begin

in the

call

deal

plex

that

velopments
years

linear

black

in

views

adolescence

past

to

ents

than

more

an

as

197

perspectives

tional

fers

believe

Streufert

1989

dialectical

more

He concluded

change

well

and

learning

isnt

much

too

no gray

with

there

things

to

work

thinking-

when you

dialectical

unfortunate

in dialectical

academic

with

clearly

not

dif

to

sensitivity

posing

there

ties

contradiction

of

is

increased

integration

information
thinkers

did
otherr

any

always

think

systems

require

Basseches

contradiction

lot

provides

problems

and

ation

Gockrill
Dialectical

than

because

taught

there

to

encouraging

move beyond

to

within

relationships

with

were

opportunity

structured
the

fin

airline

as dialectical
for

Dialectical

busi-

of
structured

postformal

their

completely

not

answer

right

and white and

strong

the

one

se

college

found

and

way

took

just

answer

right

undergraduate

1984 com

Basseches

college

members

faculty

relationship

in the

populat4on

no

airlines

our

said

like

to deal

try

one

always

12%

teacher

We

run

to

different

the

fact

approach

contextual

out
their

the

done

ever

was

partici

there

knowing

In

top

different

ferent

have

to

study

wanted

they

completely

at the

up

was

it

re

longitudinal

undergraduate

how

three

ness

class

102

found

were

pants

And

leaves

development

1992

Magoldas
of

only

businessi

we had nine groups and nine
and all of them chose differenh

class
in

There

airline

answer because

right

frame

education

cognitive

from

excerpt

team-based

simulation

155

undergraduate

an

ques

way

particular

of

description

philosophies

Generally

in

she provided

example

students

one

and

under

to

issue

abstract

complexity

things

complex

involved

it

perspectives

intellec

able

complex

sophisticated

to

there

greater

better

of

evidence

which

for

have

answers

in that they

flexibility

stand

problems

correct

and

reason

using

ill-structured

verifiably

tual

at

multiple

tioning

seniors

acknowledging

196

level

compared

AND APPLIED

In

under

reported

with

became

who

The

Exhibit 3 - 27

in

loss

of

myself

the

did

think

role

things

expec

now

this

was
to

this

process

navigat

degree

blurred

structure

Not only
of

been

my

student

and

provide

process

confidence

the

timelines

unspoken

would

sense

in

years

changed

of

portion

shift

but
was

the

only

my educa
leave
also

me
lost

mainly due

THE ROLE OF DOCTORAL
feeling

the

structural

seemed

somehow

that

to

be

to

and

void
able

do

to

should

be

self-motivate

Kerlin

able

to

of

fill

than

better

in

deeply

affect

created

29

1995

student

and

his

the

her

or

the

implications

may

how knowledge

of

of

463

community

learning

view

students

STUDY

that

is

for the

process

creator

The

that

toward

move
when

ported

less

is

they

dents

progress

work

and from

and

structured

that

solutions

broader

which

Candy

1991
As
they
tion

knowledge

students

and

themselves

perceive

evoke

and

reframe

1997
shift

dialectical

as

of

their

in

and

bedrock

out

view

the

and

larger

Learners

known

do

Technical

not

and

reflect

how

ence

position

seldom

the

on

To

of what

limits

is

being

of

More

of the

on

it

resides

occurs

landscapefocusing

phenomenological

the content

methods

or

surface

the

at

used

the analysis

in

come

to

and

learner views

which

lies

the learning

external

the

to

as

hidden

uncovering

process

something

Learners

increasingly

Kitchener
and

Schon
reflective

encapsulated

occurs

in

between

process
and

piecemeal
insights

experience

drawn

when

it

process

with

regarding

occurs

Learners

is

Reflection

segmented

and

the learning

relationships
dialogue

Reflection

they

do

critical

do

or

in

gaps

include

to

in

the

2000b

personal/critical

and

self

ideology

Privett

Kitchener

cognition

1990

Brenner

double-loop

and

hegemonic
2000a

learning

see

how

self-reflection

They

process

King
reflection-in

Argyris

mirror and

as

window

the question

How

with

interacts

can

engage

The

self

the
as

self

the
as

window

my personal biases
and assumptions
influence
my learning approach
and the conclusions
draw The self as mirror
What
raises
the
back
qsiestion
being reflected
raises

will

is

to

me

about

learning

Exhibit 3 - 28

how

change

as

re

The pres

1978

learning

disconnections

self

work

epistemic

action

learners

in every

open

dynamics

power

engage

about

reflection

1981

largely

when

1990

Brookfleld

2002

The

field

undergraduates
exist

for

constitutes

follow from

that

problems

self

assume

ones

instructor

topic

self reflection

expand

assumptions

The

as

self-monitorwlsat
what

Meacham

ting

Learners
only

to

rule

in

expert

and

Critical

Eneoisspossing

know

not
lean

when

Reflection

one

members

frequently

as

works

community

studentteacher

in

how

commu

of Self

Learners

is

acquired

their

peripheral

student

emerges

constructed

discover

allows

community

differentials

ever

the

knowledge

learning

power

systemic

in the

how

assume

initially

power

inure

within

junior-level

between

The Use

occurs

contributor

other

for

lationship

problems

20.2

accepts

enter

Large

system

as

knowledge

mentor

they

Review

knowledge

of

Students

now

They

TABLE

From Myopic

ex

of self as

ill-defined

change

Sinsilarly

forma

role

dis

changes

socially

must

Knowing

practice
it

the

students

construction

and what

of

considered

postgraduate

nity of

the

overview

section

may be

knowledge

issues

an

presents
this

learning

process

Hiemstra

problem

toward

perspective

view

of

part

Unstructured

If

the

surrounding environment

the

in

realize

contextual

view

20.2

cussed

1991

Wenger

systemic

Table

and

of

Brockett

THE LEARNING

IN

they

reflection
to

PATHWAY GAINING

COMMUNITY

constructed

come

consider

to

and

analysis

in

Bredo

begin
more

adopt

isting

Lave

1991

problems

ideological

formed

is

MEMBERSHIP

consideration

and

cultural

THE SECOND

postgraduate

socially

Postgraduates

include

must

social

is

observation

through

1987

to

ill-defined

to

than

As stu

prescribed

undergraduate

how knowledge

Jarvis

dialogue

of

from

transformed

and

experienced

previously

sup

is

environment

learning

rule-driven

may have

sec

to

complexity

face

structured

what

come

cognitive

students

function

of

my

be-

FADULT DEVELOPMENT

464

and

student

tween

Most

ting

hegemonic
In

such

part

In

as

on

dependent

by

process

lion
for

be

to

to the

Of course
also

to

of

edges

the

stitutional

Mercer

and

of

Students

are

seen

kids

Bartlett

guage

as

constructs

relation

and

fication

of

or

disciples

Mercer

concluded

which
and

complex

many

in

process

such

lan

power

oversimpli
and

fruit
of

negotiations

made

explicit

plained

that

durance

contest

their

jump through

students

time

felt

was

that

ity

to

for

within

as

and

hoops

whether

the

or professional
experiences

their instructors

that

process

of

rules

the

en
to

never

faculty
actually

and

power

take

and

the

role

can

also

describe

the

this

be

are
the

process
ers

Exhibit 3 - 29

to

by

that

relationship

Mezirow

in which

2000

we have an

understand

the

active

meaning

supervi

These

revised

and
power

au
to

role

in

inequities

discourse
dialogue
of

ac

expertise

becomes

discourse
defined

the

topographer

for experience

while minimizing

hierarchical

guide

interactive

Isben

Judith

power

of

of

subject
research

resisting

social

be

can
identities

the

and

taken

making

Students

On

supervisors

need

the

revised

belier

term

doctoral

relationship
In

pro

toward
the

use

knowledging
the

mutual

be

can

decision

postdoctoral

Hewson
that

suggested

evolves

in

fac

responsibil

legitimate

knowledge
voice

to

authority

and

experience

to

seeking

egalitarian

capabilities
result

have

thors

development
and

of

to

postgraduate

steps

establish

to

Daphne

Conti

2001

com
an

postgraduate

and

the

and

power

opportunity

power

of

experience

curricula

quality

co-contributors

sors

required

greater

negotiate

the

an

given

often

were

from

evolves

nature

very

ensuring

gradually

been

basically

they

kind
to

the

role

an

is

by-product

expected

own learning

their

for

or supervisor

are

the

to

and in

Power

negotiated

Students

demands

ulty role

never

Students

education

myriad

intellectual

by

of

They

to question

disaffirmed

compliance

ahead

as

had

roles

eollegial

and

responsibility

Janet

postdoctoral

subjected

that

Whitehouse

communities

relationships

Although

even

or

that

experience

were

they

the

community guide and mentor

unequal

of

survey

their

which

and

conformity

When

1995

described

as

from

learners

more

acknowledged

space

Kerlins

recast

off

periphery

instructor

necessarily

dynamic

are

sliced

the

apprentice

its

the
was

expertise

Balatti

move from

assume

greater

relationship

in

institution

their learning

structors

con

we

are

as

practi

but with
that

card

and

selected

competent

students

As

students

of

post

as

Aus

regional

being

careers

student

uninitiated

of the

When

these

acolytes

fundamentally

Im

Im

4445

pp

openly

records

knowledge

and
this

unsatisfactory

Scott

hazing

duced

describe

2001

of

57

learners

seemed

to

as

real work

that

dispense

keep

any re

like

act

in
in

irony

successful

full-time

invisible.

Gina

model

master

be

to

and

students

the

of

basis

had

of the

center

in

on

and

hierarchy

deeply

is

involves

In

The

one-sided

doctoral

noted

the

who

tioners

outer

emphasis

Bartlett

who

post

two

on

novices

not

is

the

construct
high

relationship

power

of

and

to

to

accomplished

away

it

work

seem

fel

expe
several

managed

busy

already

throw

my

years

20

university

swipe

institutions

students

power

used

often

is

fonTiat

dispensing

Often

Alison

supervisors

unknowing

and

predominant

assumes

students

metaphor

fully

As
the

noted

knowing

students

exercise

place

compliance

study

inforrna

that

community

learning

2001

graduate

of

programs

confine

relationships

power

to

power and

Ive

doesnt

have
to

slate

Similarly
tralian

educational

undergraduate

educators

graduate

as

are

made
and

several

heavily

letrners

instructors

what

and

that

with

dont need

There

supposed

learning

and

infonTiation

here

workplace

and

for

just

the

sequencing

pace

this

exercise

actively

restricted

sists

the
of

as

sources

the

focused

clean

understand

to
caine

Baxter

Instructors

to

in

Sixty-eight
in the

managing

students

directing

knowledge

for

in

spect

themselves

accountable

rience

view

their

seems

businesses

me

authority

instructors

one

most entenng

viewed

study

delivery

by

students

participant

to

Kerlins

in

way

this

it

low students

adopt

to

put

contributor

as

identity

One

creation

study

No

at

to

college

their

establishing

the

found

students

the

knowledge

pos

years

substantiated

1970

absolute

of

entering

1992

Magolda

were

their

They begin

must be

Perry

study

figures

of

negation

the

who

figure
of

course

knowledge

from

follow

as

change

students

the

of

the

views

one

undergraduate
structors

teacher

Over

that

position

evidence

sumed

basic

as

submerged

discrepancies

the

knowledge

percent

set

undergraduate

1995

power
of

views

college students
the

in the

remains

it

assumption

students
sesses

teacher

often

MEASURED AND APPLIED

AND LEARNING

more
as

with

the

oth

an experience

THE ROLE

14

As

scribed

an

of

example

model

the

graduate

de

Mezirow

discourse

seminar

as

and

that confines

follows

new

words

become
There

are
the

support

that

commonly accepted norms

ideal

conditions

discoursethere

of

has

everyone

an

op

equal

to

the

on
of

contribute

active

courtesy
and

vance
permits

be discussed

to

topic

lished

listening

turS

taking
to

anyone
cultural

and

be

talk

to

norms

or

there

postgraduate
in

1998

Hiernstra

Roger

socialization

from

the

which

of

ad

iii

in

participation

estab

of

and

traditional

the

become

partners

lily

the

allowing

from

apart

protØgØ

the

For

and

loyalty

also

and

which

to

munity
terms

theyve

beliefs

ate

members

and

values

webs

constructed

the

students

communitys

nected

to

of

meaning

Wenger

with

away

able

methods
one

community
As

veloping
quiry

creators

emerging
that

challenge

awareness

that

practice

define

while

of

and

being

the

and

being

the

learning

Note

Another

dents

man

of

degree

the

knowledge
students

norms

to trace

and

unique

de

models

of

in

dents

the

community

the

boundary

of
area

to

policies

with

care

student

for

support

of

the

learning

community

of

the

learning

community

that

shows

20.1

Figure

and

center

move

this

students

help

from

shift

of

co-ownership

to

of experiences

feature

in the

community
over

time

that
is

from

also

serve

They

supportive
At

scaffolding

Fielding
students

are

that

Finally

Exhibit 3 - 30

as

faculty
design

they

journey

to

curriculum

student

ex

newer

process

or

or

for

guide

on

the

to

can

University

members

may become

to

students

invited

of

stu

help

guides

orientation

stu

structuring

novice

Graduate

doctoral

enhance

the

Milestones

their transition

alongside

committees

ap

cognitive

structured

are

to

the

the

through
sit

of

community

expect

students

Of

medicine

center

expert

of

information

apprenticeships

they

factors

ample advanced

of

is

the

identit5

one

face

to

stu

transform

help

some form

these

or milestones

and

should

eta1 1989

teams

center

the

position

practi

Brown

tri

government

from law and

offer

in the

the

the

the

design

formed

from one-way

cognitive

development

supports

of avail

member

in

selected

projects

implications

toward

dents

true

When

power

moves

learning

professions

periphery

prac

for

busi

American

instructional

University

programs

for

participated

project

Mason

science

become

delineate

able

many

research

understanding

frill

of

postgraduate

course

markers

To

kind

to

the

Lave

of

relationships

exchanges

students

become
culture

its

dentteacher

con

cultural
skills

officials

e-learning

nient

that

also

law

Native

hy

regulated

George

tax

be

and

arguments

arguing

in

agencies

acculturation

methodology

must
and

such
surface

only

and

by
of

learning

at

how

of
are

discover

is they

what

Duguid

aware

tribal

another

In

students

the

socially

shape

local

student

involved

and

prenticeship

communities

of inquiry

configured

the

Without

1991

come

tioner

is

learning

subsume

that

tices

That

than

Postgradu

Collins

become

pro

largely

intricate

evaluate

Experiential

com

rather

beliefs

modes

preferred

culture

its

by

these

by

Brown

do

the

learning

that

als

contextual

membership

Such

belief

Postgraduate

1989

the

underlie

practitioners

as

they

of

the

community

connected

are

practitioners

of

understand

to

begin

community

owned

create

commu

methodologies

that

that

relationship

learning

gained

and

de

ones
means

it

of the

of

the

the

to

experience

of practices

the

of

of

from

cases

reducing

Taylor

lawyers

the

For both

purpose

Scott

Practicing

asked

tribe

this

students

cause

accomplish

by

law

were

nesses

serve

with

it

mean watching

mock cases Chal

for

can

presented

is

or

asked

working

iden

the

his or her

may be

students

treatments

critical
clerks

court

described

mentor

awareness

greater

features

who

2000

knowledge

as

with

learn

of

often

are

work

to

Medical

example

good

work

to

co-construction

assistantships

For

develop

center

Undergraduates

tØgØ

in

requires

cultural

suggested

in

the

asked

trials

research

court

feature

the

generate

lenging

moot

means

it

mock

re

professional

mentor

move toward
nity

own

must be

trust

to

one

to

conduct

would

parties

central

community

learning

settings

might be

relationship

This can

protØgØ
the

on

pendence

shift

relationship

the

protØgØ

ones

surpass

ments

that

mentor

the

success-

of

particu

more

opportunities

in

contextualized

students

to

the

requires

co-creators

by both

adjustment

means

that

agreed
students

supervisory

He suggested however
quire

has

to

seem

toward

their

provide

instructors

within

ing

Law

15

that

Experiences
peers

freedom

reflective

viewpoints

graduate

engaging

experiences
students

moving

to

flit

while

citizen

norms

are
issues

Academic

critically

scholar-practitioner

how

dissent

helpEd

ized

studying

other

must team

informed

are

participants

465

In

community

that

community

STUDY

is

larly

portunity

constrains

good

creative

Certain

coercion.

outside

no

of

set

OF DOCTORAL

Stu

program
determine

members

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

466

AND LEARNING

MEASURED AND APPLIED

Students

become

Mentors

encourage

Students

discover

and boundary

of knowledge

co-contributors

discourse

equalitarian

the

norms models

that distinguish

areas

of

inquiry

the

learning

community

ThjjT
ernetso

Students

sthve

from

apart

Students

of

of

committees

dissertation

culty

various
these

member

ment

as

help

transfer

definition

of

those

be

the

tacit

of

of postgraduate

study

fined

as

Berg

knowledge

implies

rather

the

ity

plex

and

1986

perts

to

schema

solve

meaningful
verbally

Schmidt

The
fessional

new

spots

that

an

role

expertise

to

are

often

has

as
in

tacit

been

abil

com

highly

Baltes

of the

when an
an

difficult

diverse

as

computer

management

At

ular

in

increases

through
ate

the

of

activity

At

lowed

the

with
tor

to

as

chances

we

Fielding

attend

many

of

in

best

the

model such

they

support
students

present

arise

from

currently

authentic

considering

students

committee

might

and

context

be

al

meetings

and

between

interchanges

this

Wagner

committee

dissertation

of the

occur
to

are

predissertation

permission

members

that

problems

several

among gradu

again

apprenticeships

when

reg

undergraduate

psychology

Cognitive

expertise

ill-defined

and

in

faculty

1986

growth

with

education

and

from

knowledge

tacit

demonstrated

has

study

business

and

programming
one

least

graduate

students

there

disserta

faculty

are

few

dialogue

scholarly

ex

THE THIRD PATHWAY GAINING

expert

The

x-ray

to

community

learning

1966

enables

nonroutine

MORE COMPLETE

UNDERSTANDING

OF THE USE OF SELF

highly

LEARNING

convey

tN

THE

PROCESS

Simons 1988

Johnston
Boshuizen

that

the

Polanyi

knowledge

see

Tacit

processes

involves

It

1979

quickly

one

Norman

114

Dixon

abnormality

Myles-Worslcy

explicitly

thinking

within

Tacit

values

information

whether

learned

not

2002

ts

as

may be de

typically
often

settings

information

by

critical

is

problems

data

permit

critical

is

Soloway

identilji

radiologist

not

order

acquisition

al 2000

et

is

of

unstructured

Sternberg

They
are

learning

and

Sternberg

knowledge

Stemberg

Ehrlich

develop

that

sets

of

timing

community

and

higher

and

to formulate

ones

to

knowledge

Tacit

instruction

expressed

than

tacit

that

knowledge
formal

through

and

abilities

apprenticeships

center

experience

lhe development
pect

co-authors

knowledge

in the

implicit

as

critical

learning

the

to

variety

The

can

experiences

well

as

publications

Moving

the

practices

from one-way

to cognitive

exchanges

20.1

understand

cultural

evolves

Learning

and

identities

develop

mentors

to

begin

communitys

FIGURE

to

their

1990

knowledge
demonstrated

Table
plays
in

in

pro

fields

as

Exhibit 3 - 31

ical

of

20.3

outlines

those

undergraduate

the

changes

who continue
years

in

their

understanding

educations

past

typ
the

THE ROLE OF DOCTORAL

TABLE

From

Membership

Peripheral

The

learner begins

member

20.3

Novice

aa

and

novice

as

of the learning

Membership

in the

Central

The

peripheral

Role

of the

joumeyman
Leaming
and

regarded

is

intemalized

aa

individualized

an

solely

at

as

experienced

is

one-way

largely

instructor-directed

arms-length

seen

is

the

leamer

learning

is

process

mode

given

encased

implicitly

of inquiry

that

is

within
by

leamer

the

able

are

leamer

functions

as

follower

compliant

aware

the

citizens

the
the

for

community

themselves
by

within

the
the

articulating

embedded

modes

in

of the boundary

that

As good

community
when

learn

they

community

how

and

to

in

engage

dissent

creative

productive

from

guide

1988

Stein

constrains

the expert

growing

of the

assumptions

become

Leamers

between

practice

reflection

community

responsibility

situate

of

epistemological
of inquiry

The

to

the

becomes

greater

community

larger

personal

each

with

members

new

from

movement

iterative

within

instnsctor

assumes

Leamers

unexamined

largely

the

as

leaming

an exchange

as

The

socializing

The

contributing

and mentor

expert

ioumeyman

exchange

Expert

progressing

the dialogue/exchange

sod

information

to

self-directed

Learning
of

transfer

central

community

experienced

between
and

Leaming

is

Learning

experience

Contributing

as

becomes

lesmer

member

community

467

Community

Learning

To

STUDY

It

fri

An

entry-level

or her

his

lion of

and

hire

Reflection
side at the

surface

landscape

used

in the

power

flective

fails

to

drawn

insights

Part

much

reason

ing

requires

demic
arate

selling

from

seldom

intense

self

is

and

learning
for

or

the

is

viewed

and

as

into

postgraduate

abstract

education

that

that

that

with

re
is the

between

and
in the

emotions
yet

This

Caspi

wisdom

of

mind

the

of

At

at

academic

learn

treatment

within

the

completely sep
experiences

process

community

vised

more
and

or

be balanced

to

intellect

Dixon

et

the

is

regarded

1986

Baltes

al 2000 Sternberg
feature

of

all

of different

balancing

of

insights
they

communities

statements

2003

about

of
the

In
the

of

and
these

aspects

changes

education

determine

whether

Exhibit 3 - 32

In

the

as

that

and

they

instances

statement

to

Graduate

in cognition

of

re
their

Stevens-Long

proposed

Fielding

stu

assists

self into

members

one work

many

orchestration

self-reflection

authors

alumni from

the

about

operate

development

professional

to

how

called

level

postgraduate

view

graduate

Baltes

been

2000

Diehl
and

1984

has

Cornelius

maturity

common

in translating

McClintock

sity

As stu

in

the

dents

learning

aca

and

of

wisdom

is

had

this

Sinnott

what

be

to

mind

offered

Specifically

engage

the

to

what

Labouvie-Vief

that

models

connecting

in deciding

that

Sternberg

write

undergraduate

that

emotion

of

to

of

course

support

Magolda

66

1990

1966

of

from

aware

1987

fundamental

Polanyi

Baxter

characteristic

Pascual-Leone
as

logic

reflection

key

Kenny

and

essential

integration

called

together

recognized

were

they

rational

environ

learning

that

the

over

was

associates

individual

nature

emotive

learning

study

dialogue involvement

the

dispassionate
learning

something

the

which

learners

disconnection

this

assume

self discovery

how

as

experience

and

often

result

incorporated

enter

the

detached

The

there

piece-meal

with

that

into

phase

emotion

participants

lieve

early

learning

enter

they

of

wrote

studies

hege

the

view

addition

undergraduate

students

level

from

during
to

out

occur

cerebral

largely

this

of issues

about
given

of

tend
lie

In

to

follow

discovery

integration

their

hidden

the

make important connections

the

of

the

is

self

tenth

in

participates

by

the

to

process

learner

self

that

re

to

method

or

see

worth

learners

things

not

the

1995

knowledge

phenomenologi

that

other

years

about

extemal

are

do

cul

appear

content

the

problems

assumptions

learning

on

In

and

personal

ment and developmental

construc

dominant

would

individuals

on

reflects

social

the

self

Learners

and

of

undertaken

focusing

analysis

undergraduate

the

of the

dynamics

monic

is

it

the

self

impact

on

ideology

when

cal

about

or the

knowledge

seldom

student

college

assumptions

code

the

Univer
and

personal

attribute
it

should

was

to

their

difficult

be coded

as

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

468

retitally
the

of

spoke

participant

behavior

or

emotion

cognition

and

confident

more

doing consulting

of

conditionality

one

and

demand

theo

was

correct

or

had

never

done

For instance

more

feeling

io

grounded

AND LEARNINC MEASURED AND APPLIED

to

and

relationships

of

aware

able

to

suspend
about

talked

In

judgment

more

feeling

federal

it.

deficit

You

as

presence

had

practitioner

ones

integrated

research

and

scribed

an

action

ments

of

an

of

third

of

integration

thinking

the

literature

on

kind

of

example

2001

Magoldas

and

workers

education

an

what

of

lot

was

being

seeing

that

part

journey

unique

as

spoke

Doing

self

Stephen

from

the

role

doubt

of the

only

of

and

into

you

maintain an

to

ability

are

been

has

ity

1983
1993

active

not

talking

and

reflective

as

for

2001

the

with

their

when
positions

like

One

personal

of

interpretation

group

one

graduate-level

2003

knowledge
data

participant

In

Baxter

course

had

to

positionwe

pick

had

topic
to

use

are

per

de

presented

an

the

own

capa
initial

Hughes

felt

imposter

microscope

what

like

felt

felt

inadequate

and

scared

felt

the

along

like

Everyone

me

evaluating

times

at

these

way

feel

and

par

20

doubt

of

intellectual

adult

student

have

that

The

been

the

courageous

there

to

enough

grapple

Stevens-

1989

Bunker

defense

moving
of

an

2001
in his

willingness
ing
ideas

he

validated

tock

of

tools

their

had
by

grow

top-performing

The

learn

and
and

127

the

he

of

1998

wise enough
to

Kerry Bunker

eallsthis

resisted

research

Lessons

themselves

more

inside

how

personally
the

of being

1992

against

describes

experi

Morrison

frailties

Webb

to

alumnus

look

the

parallel

learning

in

nothing

is

graduate

by

profiled

characteristics

believe

part

The

described

valued

described

executives

with

logic

highly

McCall Lombardo

shared
to

are

insecurity

development

we have

and

intense

Experience

not

or

experiences

of

behind

experience

economic

her

somewhere

of

type

all

kind

often

their

Frances

matter

Fcelings
cel

ences

as follows

and

self-

gradu

students

regarding

like

and

no

changed

ings

ability

grain One
learned

to

but

had

that

the

Field
accept

been

McClin

Stevens-Long

2003
critical

We

me

stupid

leaders

and

Magoldas
an

felt

succeed

confused

of social

about

public

to

abilities

express

talked

described

economics

processes

alumnus

the

to

of

be

about

cognitive

the

Fielding

McClintock

talk

they

tales
of

accompany

student

under

watching

King

own minds

thinkers

can

to

feelings

describing

In

fake

constantly

of

level

understanding

dcconstruct

to

arguments

Long
from

as

and

own thought

students

referred

the

wrote

and

their

situationsbecoming

of their

into
with

knowledge

highest

Fielding

an

graduate

opportunities

their

or

analyze

orchestraters

Similarly

fend

to

at

different

deploy

to

thinking

and

the

of their

of

development

self

individual

postgraduate

doctoral

as

had

how stu

limits

1994

that

performance

was

Schon

Kitchener

cognition

conscious

able

the

how

of

what

to

Alumni

judgment

systems

into

enter

they

the

reflective

confrontation

of uncertainty

abil

Tremmel

illustrates

on

reflect

awareness

constructionism

haps

example

epistemic

more

being

such

how

This

1997

the

in describing

Entering

levels

was

Langer

to

corresponds

called

coming

come

The

intersect

1990

experience

the

learn

of

state

itself

reflection-in-action

Magoldas

also

knowledge

and

called

Baxter

can

knowing

the

mindfulness

or

dents

within

forces

to

bring

felt

ing

or reflection

and

often

what

action

that

we

stu

painful

impostership

high

report

reflection

that

Brookfield

education

ate

208
we speak

however

self-uncertainty

reflection

Quite

one

side

dark

experience

When

the

to

did

think

something

much

sometimes

and

And

lcarning

it

why you

define

to

starting

part

re

had

pp 197198

of

tolerate

lonely

is

intense

bility

that

is

not You

reason

do

more

anxiety

the

postgraduate

work

when you do put

of yourself

of

were

you

would

Baxter

respondents

and

taught

what

with

also

the

have

to

level

this

often

accompanying

from

study

of

in clinical pastoral

along

identity

One

must

an

longitudinal

students

had

Someone

economics
would

it

something

and

feeling

comes

it

To reach

state

wisdom

echoes

Another

of

of these

dents

that

acting

through

de

human

of

All

do-ing

or

time

Every
little

in

respondent

more

becoming

human

than

suggest

effects

settings

experience

rather

be-ing

the

was

participant

something
to analyze

encouraged

side

supply

the

argue

another

Which

econonsics

in

duce

why we thought

explain

incorrect

why

explain

increasingly

and

charts

take

pears

supply

mental

to

factor

be what
surrender

Exhibit 3 - 33

in

growing

Bunker
the

1989

willingness

against
has

the
called

to accept

grain

ap

develop
temporary

tic

THE ROLE

setbacks

performance
from

formative

learning

subjective

emotional experience
of

ideas

and

to

The
ate

the

those

runs

individuals

the

exposure

to diverse

become

to

seems

more

tional

In

fact

it

which

stronger

seems

is

an

make

to

Later

either-or

of culturally

arena

in

might

be

Pratt

provided

1991

PATHWAY

tion

of

awareness

fluences

how

PERSPECTIVES

is

the

described

and

social

development

during

as well

cultural

educa

and

20.4

Insular

To

1991

how

the

2000b
the

to

influenced

are

by

learners

cultural

and

bias

personal

implicit

and unexamined Leamers

possible

to

pure and

take

ii

ideology
assume

broaden

that
the

aware

shapes

learners

transaction

is

the

educational

Ca

itself

served

certainly

itself

setting

by expe

individual

of

perspectives

may

or

may

Perspective

and

Inclusive

stance

objective

Learners

are

that

it

to

is

come

ideological

Global

to

As

become

they

reflective

cultural

acknowledge

can

that

perspectives

experience

learning

members

sensitive

community
that

disagreements
in

discrepancies

and

the learning

of the learning

to

of underlying

biases

shape

may

be

ideological

viewpoints
Leamers

2000b

2000a
and

hcgemonic

accept

epistemological

should

be shared

learning
those

hold

assume

by

all

Leamers

the

own

either

within

may

based
and

or

the

the

1991

distance

treat

instructor-driven

iisequities

to

culturally

ming

approaches

of knowledge

management

joint

Caffarella

Pratt

lea

2000

Merrians

should

dominant

approach

are

learning

pedagogy
merely

as

Learners

traditional

existing

serve

power

amplified through

technology

discover
as

an

learning

among

become
and

community

Exhibit 3 - 34

how

inclusive

access/power
Learners

4%

sensitized

regarding

learning

Learners

St

more

assumptions

that

assume

perspectives

culturally

beliefs

are

become

Learners

Brookfield

their

participants

minority
to

that

assumptions

cousrnunity

who

accommodate
to

they

assumptions

of

more

context

learning

learning

1994

sensitized

become

the

bias

ideological

Brookfield

They

ap

knowledge

fosters

become

inclusiveness

Although

Cultural

and

aware

learning
of

which

experiences

and

and

regarding

iL

The

is

Perry

Merriam 2000

dents

TABLE

that

become

students

that

Learners

learn

they

riences

20.4

in table

Pram Hegemonic

in

context

one

to

viewpoints

as of cultural

about

learning

instructors

post-graduate

from

transition

management

joint

relationships

power

AND

the

1991

farella

How

for different

structure

education

Hiemstra

that

ways

DEVELOPING AN iNCREASED
CULTURAL

As
stu

Terenzini

the

alternative

some

education

Pascarella

assumptions

assumptions

Candy

OF SOCIAL

of

based

Brockett

AWARENESS

value

and

proaches

in

THE FOURTH

accompany

many

world

the

across

tolerance

greater

For

provides

college

changes

in their

support

developmental

itself

views

accepting

an

certainly

develop

of

de

1970

emo

or

journey

of

course

world

larger

from

learners

context

in graduate

path

enclave

political

absolute

encour

little

to

and

that

through

469

STUDY

in the

exist

final

learning

the

These

more

develop

likely
is

personal

This

most postgradu

promote

There

ones

difficulties

to

unlikely

painful

share

tend

dents

religious

responses

1991
of

over

result

our

under-girding

our emotional

environment

surrender

to

velopment

threatening

and

arenas

Trans

change

to

education

agement

we have

assumptions

competitive

mental

intensely

communities

learning
social

involves

it

an

supporting

surrender

MI
larger

cautioned

when

which

in

both

need

the

2000

often

is

shift

new learn

voluntary

completely

especially

refraining

aware

plague

within

As Mezirow

situation

ing

that

novice

to

expert

OF DOCTORAL

more

to

use distance

web

for

to

balanced

community members
aware

those of others
are

learning

providing

influenced

of
in

by

how

their

own

the learning
power

relationships

stu
not

470

ADULT DEVELOPMENT

serve

inclusiveness

tives

related

tempted

to

wanese

work

recognize

to the

students

students
In
curs

of

community
culture
In

that

this

form

reasons

the

why

men

often

than

women

more

women

are

exposed

of

high

mentors

and

guides

on

provide

opportunity

that

shape
what

for

sideration

and

dley

sexual

the

experienced

poor working

ulty advisors
itiveness

in

the

approach

of

one

idea

When

marginalized

fined

to

the

of

role

that

is

in addressing

the

and

in

that

viewpoints

such

constrained

power

rules

voices

through

readings

conditions

compet

mony

cultural

remain

excluded

from

individuals

con

but

works

also

center

of

cal

deeply

be

assump

unexamined

into

2000b

Fur
to

likely

is

Hege

that

assumptions

incorporated

Brookfield

thinking

subtle

of

back

peel

the

finger

people

whoth

point

conscious

our

can

day-to-day

and

faculty

without

critical

to

lifethe

stock

common

sense

that

conspiracy

the

opinions

people
here

of

it

take
is

the

ideas

As

on

parcel

and

seeing

that

to

granted

conspiracy

logic

the

practices

of

wisdom

If

there

of the

the

study

by

can

set

the

increasing

stage

open

for

as

discus

and

for

set

voices

all

be

student

requires

concerted

effort

The

ethics

of

with

1986

suggest

in discourse

Nancy

that

centers
It

and

play

of
the

students

outcomes

equal

to

academic

much

Clenehy

is

es

permit

risks

can

cultural
In

means

less

the

new

generate

and

differences
this

space

dia

posi

graduate

of self-replication

more an instrument

and

It

Blythe

discourse

located

and

criti

optimal
task

incompatible

students

which

becomes

supervisor

both

mean

negotiating

implicit

can

education

ordering

and
give

in

space

Tarule

Jill

egalitarian

dis

everyday

we

share

tionality

comrmiunity

of

change
et

Belenky

for

for

al

1986
or

the
is

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

normal

more

dialogue

in
and

would
graduate

it

time

final

and

Nyquist

perspective

es

134

or attacking

must engage

supervisors

of

of

and

Returning

Postgraduate

under

which

in

no

atmosphere

p.4l

clusive

by

often

speakers

necessary

Mary Belenky

understanding

and

silent

and

and

groups

instigators

conventional

for

the

or

group

people

and

part

ways

as

keep

Instead

become

hegemony

of oppression

identifiable

we accuse

cx

that

faculty

including

topic

make

may be seen

Goldberger
and

is

dismissing

competitive

discourse

them

layers

the

environment

students

that

sential

wrote

the

an

conspiracy

enfranchised

world

at

on

allows

an active

taking

discourse

critical

flourish

Such

One cannot

in

can

inclusiveness

hegemonic

and

implicit

an

di

of the

discourse

selling

and

po

attempting
that

and

outside

tone

discourse

cultural

strength

dialectical

hias

many

implies

become

fuel

and

be included

to

Building

the

early

about

niarginalized

have

male fac

with

by

discrepancies

students

sion

are

cducational

an

by

that

lacks

Han-

bring

mentality

those

the

to

finding

students

community

The environment

thermore

tions

the

reside

effort

environment

among

ground

tablishing

listen

power
verse

who

her

This means

flourish

to

between

ist

male fuc

this

emphasize

groups
affects

only
of

edge

those

against

not

it

participation

interaction

Tisdell

of positionality

programs

1990

win-lose

shape

described

education

an

create

to

difference

related

that

and

con
race

into perspective

sitionality

groups
that

doctoral

graduate

environments

individualism

from

exclusionary

argued

relationships

news
those

put

in

Mary Handley

ting

to

to

follow

orientation

2000

Taylor

how

implieit

raise

differences

positionality

American

African

and

can

It

can

leaming

how

of

hegeinonie

bias

and

believe

as

Or not

action

into

cultural

lt

viewpoints

uncover

discourse

our
to

Transformational

gender

the

of

range

to

to challenge

agreements

One

insidiously

percentage

many women

an

wider

to

exposure

sumptsons

beliefs

oc

marginalized

Kerlin

can

possibilities

Asian

some

an

broader

for the

impact

For

Lomperis

fact that

ulty as

students

of exceptional

More

complete

to

Tai

marginalization

1995

Kerlin

at

be marginalized

to

is

needs

the

Scott

respect

the

negative

may develop

practice

ignores

of

embarrassing

understand

to

authors

efforts

performance

innocuous

ftiilure

as

the

reading

have

to

out

singled

of

an example

as

subsequent

most

its

by

appeared

be

to

perspec
Merriam

one

proved most

that

also

It

class

multiple

outstanding

student

decision

student

the

MEASURED AND APPLIED

Sharan

and

which

in

stow

graduate

paper aloud

encurage

Caffarella

Rosemary

2000

the

and

AND LEARNING

take

to

support

education

Exhibit 3 - 35

to

the

2000

Woodford

issues

we

might ask

developmental

Whereas

the

described

maturity

evidence

by

What

clearly

in

..-

THE ROLE

that

suggests

postdoctoral

intellectual

the

we

years

of

development
integration

of

behave

probably
als

Pulling

and
First

often

even

expected

the

should

learning

projects

as

quickly
are

faculty

of

gotiation

ment

power

role

supervisors

an

of

dent

brings

in

along

with

his or
the

problems
Third
support

ery to the
in

the

way

the

accompanied
to

portunities

education

graduate
in

and

maturity

Fourth

of

tives

the

dialectical

fuel

the

plore

ment

of their

generate

and

ferences

This
ments

and
and

own

of

field

to

they
often

Op

support

feature

of

study

can

suggests

be

creased

profound

may begin

unified

stable
continual
tives

broaden

the

faculty

people

encourage

in

perspec
This can

ex

to

assumptions

and

the

develop

discourse

which

can

cultural

dif

be located
wide

conducted

variety
in

experi

conventional

more

in

self as

less

self that

is

among

the

of

in

perspec

that

is

reality

within

self

full

fluid

ev

with

that

and

ambiguity

paradox
there

Finally

and

cates

one

uate

with

that

the

reflection

in

paradox

with

the

the

and

unique

practice

Exhibit 3 - 36

self

We

and

lead

midst

ambiguity

and

might

well

and

We

the

argue

for

acceptance
one

conflicting
this

grad

scholar-

capacity

the

allow

expect

allow

affective

especially

training

action

uncertain
might

may

wisdom The

to

of

communi

reality

education
at

dur
with

behavior

wise
that

internal

conventional

aimed

should

practitioner

with

Wisdom

caring

inner

emo

the

associated

behavior

and

outer

that

experience

may be

as

best graduate

education

people

perhaps even
defined

the

integrate

believe

to

educations

understanding
to

here

reason

changes

changes

may be

concems

of

is

cognitive

their graduate

Wisdom

of
of

the

and

that

they

ways

world

self-confidence

of

more

with

chal

to

including

more aware

and

constructed
is

and

between

may become

construction

ing

de

entity

the
the

change

as

the

addition

students

experience

and

dialogue

They

socially

post

he

to

In

intertwined

are

empathy

patience

Students

evalu

associated

is

about

personal

those

to

through

constrain

feel

changes

cognitive
of

idence

that

and

prob

and

learn

opinion

causing

assumptions

uncer

the

explanations

and

experience

understand

These

tional

should

Egalitarian

space

the

perceive

syntlsesize

between

they

are

they

and

certainty

and

transformation

perspective

toward

which

distinction

differing

evidence

poten

moving

with

that

students

They understand
the

solution

educational

graduate

lenge

of

of

evidence

transform

resolved

single

worth

the

toward

progress

oo

comparison

growth

encourage

the

thinking

dialogic

might

Changes
ways

anxiety

hegemonic

positionality

chapter

that

bias

their

new

and

periph

are

and

ate

be

learning

in

thought

and

product

graduate

thinkers

of

relationships

can

that

op

perfect
the

developmental

but

contrast

knowledge

behavioral

and

discourse

constrain

that

the

the

inclusiveness

students

cultural

address

to

and

with

for these

encouraged

both

at

thinking
and

diversity

and

regular

along

the

of

have

that

honored

look

knowledge

to

in
stu

understand

feelings

we hope

wisdom

reflective

dialectical

liberately

if

the

the

is

intends

self-doubt

become

ne

guide

community

these

explore

might

self-discovery

of

fresh

self
of

and

environ

the

what

must

the

intense

that

that

take

to

construction

by

lems

and

experience

learning

define

people

understand

life

students

of the

center

of

students

emotional journey from

learners

tainty

that

community

and

problems

relationships

toward

ability

learning

faculty

systems

graduate

level

compare

innovative

and

litera

might imply

presepts

great

doubt

matu

some

and

process

chapter

dialectical

more

to

the

has

little

is

metasystematic
able

community

When

power

of

her

become

choose

There

of any kind on

offer

to

insti

behavioral

terms

development

this

education

for their

learning

This means

terms

sum

then

tial

acknowledgment

evolve

of adult

such

seems

both

capture

study

graduate

what

that

measures

students although
tn

in the

allowed

move

that

to

work

little

471

conventional

less

emotional and

of

STUDY

of

range

many

education

Postgraduate

as

currently

relative

exists

portunity

in

doctoral

among

ture

be

they

is

In

chapter

Furthermore

to

try

There

self-directed

identify

This means

authority

this

ill-defined

relationships

slim

programs

development

rity

recommendations

to

of the

in the

may

stead

of

to

people

faidy

is

methods

to

the

individu

responsibility

with

hierarchical

resists

mature

competencies

center

possible

mature

should

the

sensible

supported

considered

is

strands
four

greater

and work

the

tutions

fundamental

is

less

be encouraged

toward

students

Yet

must be more

and

seems

the

behavior

or

that

Students

their

on

might be undertaken

proposition

with

case

demonstrating

it

this

various

to take

students

as

the

curricula

Second

from

education

graduate
is

educational

for

we begin

than

for

we

together

review

its

and

contend

differently

evidence

although

life

intellect

maturity

wisdom Furthermore

doctoral

information

little

and

emotion

characteristic

key

have

as well

the

over

changes

emotional

either

of

function

OF DOCTORAL

to

cope

situations

capacity

to

472

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

accompany

the

velopment

perspective

in the

fluidity

been

intellectual

sense

and

the

by

stretching

and

self

these

Indeed

research

adult

alectical

have

de

adult

1984

Basseches

Baxter

learning

wise

psycho-gerontological

book

of

Job

Journal

the

1981

New

future

corporate

York Wiley

1978

Schon

learning

MA

of

theory

action

Reading

Addison-Wesley

1975
hood

fifth

stage

1984
structural

adult

Psychology

Developmental

11

Late

psychology

The

Age

role

New

Trans
259300

Four

Transformation

Peter

Baltes

ogy

In

New

in

Cam

Prentice

and

personal

Rutgers

Uni
In

Holquist

pp

Bakhtin
of Texas

Press

In

Postgraduate

research

at

Bartlett

5569

New

in developmental

Lemer

Vol

New

for

the

child

of

York

of
York

psychol

Eds

Handbook

Construction

mic

of

of

practice

Eds

Relations

Peter

learning

Vol

11 pp

study

of

frame

development

of

di-

5th

Hand
pp

of learning

academic

The
San

ed

educational

CA

Diego

In

learning

psy
Acade

1991

tional

on

Tales

of adult

from

Handbook

of

San

and

adult

Francisco

2000b

phe

203216

educa

continuing
Jossey-Bass

San

as

learning

Ed

Learning

on

theory

Francisco

Jossey

perspectives

pp 125148

re

critically

Hayes

Mezirow

Critical

transformation

of

Transformative

In

critique

progress

and

Interna

Wildon

pp 349

ideology

13

concept

In

practice

side

reflection

Learning

2000a The

tion

research

the dark

critical

of Lifelong

Journal

Eds

in

Self-direction

theory

York Routledge

nomenography

Bass

1977

lege

thought

Not

Piaget

beyond

In

Armon

Late

adolescent

pp 395411

Brown

and
16

1989

Bunker

Issues

and

beyond

operations
Teachers

Col

New

the

culture

operations

Commons

Eds
and

formal

Beyond

adult

York

of

formal

cognitive

opera
develop

Praeger

1989

Duguid

Collins

leaming

ing

adolescence

1984

Broughton

tions

formal

Beyond
in

79 8798

Record

Exhibit 3 - 37
1_

of

knowledge

1994

Researcher

schemata

Handbook

Perspectives

New

Brookfield

ment

research

Lang

Dialectical

empirical

In

supervision

Postgraduate

Eds

development

Vol

Hiemstra

but

metaphors

Mostly

human

on

Press

adult

in

knowing

Lerner

human

of

pp 345

series

chology

of

ways

perspectives

psychology

Richards

2001

Goldberger

Damon

Ed

Theoretical

ed pp 10291143

5th

Transforming

1980

New

807863 New York Wiley
Bredo
1997 The social construction

as

supervision

pp 435

Vol

forty

Staudinger

theory

Mercer

Basseehes

103120

Action

models

Bruughton

from

In

Handbook

Womens

In

Brookfield

Novice

or re-invention

Mercer

supervision

book

flective

York Wiley

Bartlett

Theoretical

practice
cognitive

Ling

lheorizing

perspee-

intelligence

Books

1998

Hall

adult

imagination

2001

SY Damon

Bartlett

work

origin

Social

by

University

of child psychology

Praeger

Eds

pp

Basic

Phye

finding

York

Emerson

Life-span

opera

cognitive

Multiple

of

the

El

formal

adult

York

2002

1986

Brookfield

Lindenberger

1998

New

NJ

dialogie

Relations

Transforming

prublciii

nature

dissertation

essays

Eds

Mercer

de

NJ

The

Austin

and

Clinchy

El

Tarule

297298

problem
Its

experiences

life

Whitehouse

Balatti

York

of

Ed

Ilolquist

of

opera

2002

River

Bninswick

1981

Bakhtin

art

differences

doctoral

Unpublished

versity

in

13

Wisdom

Saddle

Upper

complexity
ity

Belenky

development

Praeger

Akert

1998

Beyond

340-356 New

development

Brockett

Wilson

Bacelar

Eds

adolescence

development

Press

University

Aronson

York

pp 230243

development

bridge

adult

and

Commons

Andreoletti

Brandtstadter

El

cognitive

uperaturs

The

Ed

Sternberg

adult

Psychology

1990 Wisdom
and

New

Piagetian

Developmental

finding

formal

Beyond
and

adolescent

1977

Arlin

thought

Commons

Eds

pp 258271

velopment

adult

In

Armon

Vol

and

Adolescent

interpretation

Richards

In

the

on

Student

College

epistemology

In

Sternberg

New York

Arlin

Arlin

pp

Berg

of

relational

epistemo-

Kluwer Academic/Plenum
in

development

Cognitive

602606

tions

Late

Dcmiek

Organizational

perspective

Postformal

Armon

Vol

tives

Argyris

Arlin

tions

of

adults

young

Journal

empathy

development

the

Creating

of

Richards

Hu

Aging and

of

adult

36 205216

1984

growth

32 2139

man Development
Ackoff

of

interpretation

International

23

and

thinking

integration

in

development

Benack
Becoming

The

knowing

impersonal

Development

1991

Dialectical

1995

Magolda

and

References

Orwoll

Development

New York Ablex

development

logical

Achenbaum

Human

thinking

40042

greater

gains

on

literature

compatriot

its

de

cognitive

transformation

of

by

suggested

velopment

AND LEARNING MEASURED AND APPLIED

Situated

Educational

learning

3242
Leaders

and

Observations

the

dark

chasm

56

of learn

STUDY

THE ROLE OF DOCTORAL

Webb

Bunker
from

1992

NC

Greensboro

Center

individual

mA

and

Creative

for

to the

learner

and

1991

The

influence

and

Personality

Social

The

1989

Personnel

change

analytic

of

stage

chological

Association

Commons

San

model

of

Vol

tions

Eds

Armon
Late

and

adolescence

Commons

In

stages

Eds

Handbook

199220 New

In

voice

Power

161173 New

York

1999

ment

study

of

Peter

Hill

tween

liminal
in

tin-

old

age

education

New

York

1986

Baltes

on

gence

In

Practical

the

Toward

life-span

and

pragmatics

of

functions

Wagner

Sternberg

pp 203234

intelligence
University

Domangue

Decoding

complexity

tolerance

nonverbal

inconsistency

re

of

Eds

of

and

gation
In

hood

Ed

of the

tacit

Thomas

plan

knowledge
Schneider

in

investi

programming

Eds

the

doctoral

Policy

Adult

MA

of personal

Critical

years

Archives

Analysis

stages

Human

Vol
cent

and

Wisdom

1990

Pracgcr

Exhibit 3 - 38

Its

nature

York

about

critical

In

knowing

reflection

Francisco

adult

in

Jossey-Bass

Developing

reflective

Jossey-Bass

Which

pp

levels

postformal

are

Richards

Eds

methods

thought

judgment

reflective

1994

Sinnolt

adult

uncer

12229 New

assumptions

Francisco

Models and

of

Ed

Commons

In

face

Press

San

1990

Kohlberg

the

in

pp

King
San

and

1990 Wisdom

Fostering

pp 159180

judgment

verbal-

Personality

empirical

experi
life

hridge

psychology

Knowing

University

Grotzer

1979 An

Soloway

The

Surviving

Transfonning

Mcxirosv

of cognitive

ambiguity

Cam

heads

development

Kitchener

lournal

nor

King

model

Cambridge

effects

from

Press

Stemberg

and

Kitchener

intelli

1953
Ehrlich

In

origins

Press

1978

Cambridge

meaningless

Brenner

Cambridge

search

over

judgment

reflective

Teaching

Collier

Dixon

and

Education

Kitchener

tainty

and

Experience

of

Department

139

be

and

programs

sociology

first

New York Norton

1995

Kerlin

disserta

Doctoral

the

doctoral

37 164172

Ed. 1955
constructs

Psy

In

University

perspectives

of the self Betwixt

journeys

into

education

of learning

analysis

Quarterly

Harvard

Every

an

1984

Kegan

322332

19

1933

and

adulthood

2144153
1991

graduate

Sociology

Dewey

in

solving

and Aging

Deegan
as

Education

University

1987

Caspi

Hu

17

inquiry

State

Meaningful

Toward

Kelly

problem

tions

measurement
Harvard

dissertation

Kenny

of counselor

man

beliefs

29 1972

Idaho

Adult

midcarcer

self-efficacy

qualitative

Pocatello

Lessons
for

4351

Refraining

and

being

Gradu

partner

Directions

79

Management

1987

Jarvis

develop

ego

1990

of

Counseling

MA

Boston
Cornelius

chology

and

nature

its

doctoral

published

Postautonomous

to

New

2001

ence

Cook-Creuter

mentor

experience

.students

Transforming

Lang

day

Resource

semester

Eds

Mercer

supervision

Vol 11 pp

Relations

man

postau

CA

Barbara

history

pp

between

ways

journey

Elias

of

bridge

Fielding

Education

Career

Hughes

2001

Barlett

research

Postgraduate

L.A

The

transcendent

From

Continuing

agers

pp

development

Isben

and connection

Hill

post-

Plenum

York

Hewson

personal

Andreoletti

adult

of

from

and

Four

Santa

University

1998

Praeger

Demick

.1

ate

Eds

intelligence

dissertation

doctoral

Fliemstra

opera

cognitive

2002

Richards

formal

adult

and

practical

Parker

emotional

development

Unpublished

intelli

Too-many

Bar-On

ego

on

among managers

emotional and

social

of

postconventional

formal

New York

pp 340356

development

CA

Beyond

York

method

of training

generation

2000

In

handbook

tonomous

Psy

1984
general
Commons

In

theory

stage

Richards

New

136170 San Francisco Jossey-Bass
Hewlett
2004
qualitative
study

Piagetian

Francisco

Richards

169198

47 787805

Integrating

intelligence

stnac

Western

at

presented

pp

oppressed

influence

idea

Sternberg

lime

The

development

Paper

rapid

86 5256

1978

of the

Psychology

gences

for

competence

Richards

stage

Conti

of

The

and

Hedlund

of

50 492501

Psychology
kind

postfonnal

1989
Personnel

heuristics
Journal

behavior

Eds

Andreoletti

development

Pedagogy

self-efficacy

efficacy

and

Management

Commons
tural

Anchoring

of judgmental

judgments

self-efficacy

2000

Gist

1986

Adult

develop

Continuum

learning

lifelong

adult

of

the

in

New York Plenum

San

Jossey-Bass

Peake
action

for

Dynamics

Demick

In

Handbook

of

pp 5570

web

mental

learning

Handbook

Nor-

2002

Stewart

development

cognitive

Freire

Self-direction

Francisco

Cervone

Cockrill

the

pp 113133

systems

wood NJ Ablex
Fischer
IC
Yan

Jossey-Bass

Candy
San

adult

computer

in

factors

coping

Linking

Eds

education

continuing

Francisco

of

context

Hayes

learn

to

Leadership

2000

Wilson

adult

on

how

stress

of

Merriam

Caffarella

and

Learning

Impact

experience

473

in

26

Adult

development

the study

3268

of

adoles

New

York

474

DEVELOPMENT

ADULT

2002 Wisdom

Kramer

Eds

letti

130152 New

the

transcendent

Eds

Young

Eds
MA

Reading

women changing

profession

journal

Markus

ecutivee

lessons

How

of experience

on

develop

the

ex

success/li

MA

job Lexington

Lexing

the

Assessing

the

1990

berg

Ed

ment

Pp

University

of

concepts

Ed

New

York

Francisco

as

an

like

and

theory

Critical perspec

San

Fran

influence
Journal

Learning

on

of expertise
Experimental

2000

Ph.D What

do we

concerns

Washington

Center

have

for

Instruction

Pascarella
students

years

of research

Pascual-Leone
organismic
Sternherg

Findings

Develop

San

Francisco

1990 An
processes

Ed

that

Wisdom

essay

make

on

Its

Digest
house

it

nature

wisdom

Toward
In

and

Development

24

the

the

195
June

relativis

Ar

pp

operations

Praeger

and

mind

the

In

Baltes

foundation

learning

from

Life-span

of cognition

per

pp

University

Cambridge

Columbus

social-interactive

minds

interactive

social

2003

The

Richards

Press

adult

education

ERIC

Clearing

in

Ok-f

Vocational

Education

Re

http//ericacve.org/docgen

asptbldigestsID48
Sternberg

de

mets-

relativity

reasoning

Wisdom

Adult Career and

trieved

possible
origins

York

276315 New York
1998 Situated

twenty

on

of

pp

Press

University

fonnal

Beyond

Eds

college

Jossey-Bass

Nature
life

everyday

Commons

of

insights

from

character

Sternberg

in

Postformal

In

19%

1991 How
and

devel

CA

Barbara

intelligence

Human

development

Eds

spectives

Stein

Terensini

affects

student

Some

In

Practical

competence

Staudinger

the

and Research

exper

Medicine

manuscript

Santa
action

in

thonght

foundation

Univer

Seattle

of

on

report

Unpublished

University

Eds

1984
stage

Staudinger

53557

Re-envisioning

pro

Books

medical

on

Academic

Interim

study

Thinking

298325 New

image

x-ray

How

Basic

Boshuixen

New York Cambridge
1981 The theory
for

mon

Psychology

Memory and Cognition 14
Woodford

Nyquist

Graduate

Sinnott

Simons

of

final

Develop

293-3 11

tic

Johnston

York

perspective

2000

origins

Sinnott

Mexirow

pp 133

progress

Core

adult

Human

practitioner

New

implications

of practical

istics

of adult

In

Sri

The

operations

reflective

action

diversity

1986

1330

theory

transformation

in

theory

processing

and

Fielding

jossey-Bass

1988 The

of

think

to

Learning

The

and

Theory

Scribner

Jossey-Bass

transformation

1998

Behavioral

65611621

Cambridge

dimensions

Transformative

Myles-Worstey

ment

develop

Xavier

McCarroll

Norman

Schoenholx-Read

Stern-

and

Francis

American

self

cognitive

Wagner

Learning

on

cisco

In

inquiry

Cansda

development

in

think

opment

origins

NS

ca

with

critical

346370

1983

tise

MA

nature

reflection

Saint

thesis

Dialectical

cognitive

Schmidt

Paper

Advancement

wisdom

of

loss
its

181211

2000

Mezirow

16

1973

Press

San

learning

sity

The

the

for

Boston

Wisdom

1991

Mezirow

of

fessionals

June

education

graduate

Association

Education

Higher

Meacham

in

ineffable

at

presented

tive

2002

Rela

41 496515

1990
Stevens-Long

develop-

intercultural

of

Rogers

phase

Books

McClintock

masters

dialogical

Schon

Morrison

adult

practitioners

Antigonish

Riegel

and

China

within

self

critical

Facilitating

ment

Lombardo
The

2002

Unpublished

6378

Psychology

McCall

in

processing

of

Contrasting

journal

development

reer

entist

self journal

City

2853 10

Toward

of Personality

the

States

Richardson

and

formation

Hillsdale

Garden

dimension

tacit

International

na

61643677
1977 Self-schemata

pp 149183

Conceptions

15

tions

Higher

the

of

the classroom

in

perceptions

United

University

Are

academic

in

Schunk

In

1991

Univer

about

Education

ton

the

Legiti

Cambridge

The

and

learning

learning

Student

1966

Privctt

Situated

tasks

moti

engagement

Doubleday

Pratt

Oxford

mind/id

Bolt

Students

cognitive

consequences

NY

Press

1990
of the

of

participation

Lomperis

of

York

York

NJ Erlbaum

and person
Whit

New

power

1991

Cambridge

1988

and

Addison-Wesley

peripheral

Social

Eds

Causes

ment
The

Wenger

hire

Meece

Cavanaugh

.1

Gerontology

1997

of

Self

1992

their

academic

spirituality

Polanyi

1999

and

beliefs

classroom

pp 103119

intellectual

New

years

Schrauben

vational
of

and

of ethical

college

Wilson

Pintrich

Press

University

Langer

mate

views

Cambridge

Cambridge

Fonns

the

in

Eisendrath

of mature

transcendence

In

development

Lave

and

1970

Jr

Rinehart

Press

University

Miller

Diehi

bourne

pp

development

Routledge

Philadelphia

Press

development

Sternberg

complexity

psychology

and

Labouvie-Vief

sity

Affect

In

The

wisdom

Integrity

ality

intellectual

2000

perspective

In

development

New York Cambridge

Labouvie-Vief

pp 244278

University

pp
Peny

Neo-Piagetian

Eds

Berg

velopment

Andreo

development

Plenum

York

cognitive

28

1972

adult

of

1992

adult

on

Demick

In

Handbook

Labouvie-Vief

AND LEARNING MEASURED AND APPLIED

mal

Exhibit 3 - 39

R. 1984
operational

Higher-order

thought

In

________________________

reasoning

in

postfor

Commons

OF DOCTORAL

IHE ROLE

Vol

tions

Late

Sternberg

Wagner

11

2000

Eds

The handbook

PP 215243

San

Parker
gence

2000 The

Stevens-Long
road

to

Eds

spirituality

integrity

pp 160174
changes
opment

Cognitive
in

Fielding

graduate

and

transcendence

and

education

devel

professional

Barbara

CA

Complexity

man

Santa

Institute

organizations

Orlando

FL

Academic

Press

mental

6078

learning

experiment

Active

in

Learning

reciprocal
in

experi

Education

San

perspective

2000

Taylor
on

for

teaching

Wilson

In

and

It

education

con

critical

Eds

Hayes
education

continuing

pp

Jossey-Bass
the

of

alt

Harvard

1985

Sternberg

knowledge

reflective

prac

Educational

Re

real-world

Practical

intel

Journal

1986

of

role

and

of Personality

Thought

MA

Cambridge

Zimmerman

MIT

and

Social

tacit

Psy

sex and

use

5159

Exhibit 3 - 40

in

self-regulated

gsftednesss

Journal

of

2nd

language

rev

Press

1990

Martmnez-Pons

differences

grade

The

pursuits

49 436458

chology

egy

and change

Learning

developmental

of adult

in

ligence

ed

pp

63 434458

view

dent

2000 An

Taylor

1995

years

teacher

in

Eds

Hayes
education

Wiley

132146 San Francisco
Tsemrnel
1993 Zen and

Vygotsky

1986

York

perspectives

sciousness

tice

self-development

continuing

Handley

Tisdell

Wagner
ineffable

and

475

jossey-Bass

Handbook
on

of mature

2003

Swezey
and

Bass

Rontledge

personal

Graduate

Streufert
agers

Philadelphia

intelli

Miller

McClintock

Stevens-Long

Jossey

psychology

wisdom

mr

for

learning

Wilson

Pogson
the adult

Different

self Multiplicity
In

The

Practical

of emotional

Francisco
prism

transcendence

Eisendrath-Young

in

Bar-On

In

development

its

Tennant

York

Adult

In
of adult

Francisco

Crigorenko
and

telligence

2000

al

New

life

and change

87100 New

Florvath
et

everyday

2000

Tennant

Handbook

Press

University

Sternberg

de

Praeger

Williams
in

opera

cognitive

Hedhmd

intelligence

Cambridge

formal

adult

New York

Forsythe

Practical

Beyond
and

adolescence

pp 7491

veopnient

the

Eds

Anion

Richards

STUDY

to

learning

self-efficacy

Educational

Stu

Relating

and

Psychology

strat

82