Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College et al

Filing 421

DECLARATION re 412 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Students for Fair Admissions, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59, # 60 Exhibit 60, # 61 Exhibit 61, # 62 Exhibit 62, # 63 Exhibit 63, # 64 Exhibit 64, # 65 Exhibit 65, # 66 Exhibit 66, # 67 Exhibit 67, # 68 Exhibit 68, # 69 Exhibit 69, # 70 Exhibit 70, # 71 Exhibit 71, # 72 Exhibit 72, # 73 Exhibit 73, # 74 Exhibit 74, # 75 Exhibit 75, # 76 Exhibit 76, # 77 Exhibit 77, # 78 Exhibit 78, # 79 Exhibit 79, # 80 Exhibit 80, # 81 Exhibit 81, # 82 Exhibit 82, # 83 Exhibit 83, # 84 Exhibit 84, # 85 Exhibit 85, # 86 Exhibit 86, # 87 Exhibit 87, # 88 Exhibit 88, # 89 Exhibit 89, # 90 Exhibit 90, # 91 Exhibit 91, # 92 Exhibit 92, # 93 Exhibit 93, # 94 Exhibit 94, # 95 Exhibit 95, # 96 Exhibit 96, # 97 Exhibit 97, # 98 Exhibit 98, # 99 Exhibit 99, # 100 Exhibit 100, # 101 Exhibit 101, # 102 Exhibit 102, # 103 Exhibit 103, # 104 Exhibit 104, # 105 Exhibit 105, # 106 Exhibit 106, # 107 Exhibit 107, # 108 Exhibit 108, # 109 Exhibit 109, # 110 Exhibit 110, # 111 Exhibit 111, # 112 Exhibit 112, # 113 Exhibit 113, # 114 Exhibit 114, # 115 Exhibit 115, # 116 Exhibit 116, # 117 Exhibit 117, # 118 Exhibit 118, # 119 Exhibit 119, # 120 Exhibit 120, # 121 Exhibit 121, # 122 Exhibit 122, # 123 Exhibit 123, # 124 Exhibit 124, # 125 Exhibit 125, # 126 Exhibit 126, # 127 Exhibit 127, # 128 Exhibit 128, # 129 Exhibit 129, # 130 Exhibit 130, # 131 Exhibit 131, # 132 Exhibit 132, # 133 Exhibit 133, # 134 Exhibit 134, # 135 Exhibit 135, # 136 Exhibit 136, # 137 Exhibit 137, # 138 Exhibit 138, # 139 Exhibit 139, # 140 Exhibit 140, # 141 Exhibit 141, # 142 Exhibit 142, # 143 Exhibit 143, # 144 Exhibit 144, # 145 Exhibit 145, # 146 Exhibit 146, # 147 Exhibit 147, # 148 Exhibit 148, # 149 Exhibit 149, # 150 Exhibit 150, # 151 Exhibit 151, # 152 Exhibit 152, # 153 Exhibit 153, # 154 Exhibit 154, # 155 Exhibit 155, # 156 Exhibit 156, # 157 Exhibit 157, # 158 Exhibit 158, # 159 Exhibit 159, # 160 Exhibit 160, # 161 Exhibit 161, # 162 Exhibit 162, # 163 Exhibit 163, # 164 Exhibit 164, # 165 Exhibit 165, # 166 Exhibit 166, # 167 Exhibit 167, # 168 Exhibit 168, # 169 Exhibit 169, # 170 Exhibit 170, # 171 Exhibit 171, # 172 Exhibit 172, # 173 Exhibit 173, # 174 Exhibit 174, # 175 Exhibit 175, # 176 Exhibit 176, # 177 Exhibit 177, # 178 Exhibit 178, # 179 Exhibit 179, # 180 Exhibit 180, # 181 Exhibit 181, # 182 Exhibit 182, # 183 Exhibit 183, # 184 Exhibit 184, # 185 Exhibit 185, # 186 Exhibit 186, # 187 Exhibit 187, # 188 Exhibit 188, # 189 Exhibit 189, # 190 Exhibit 190, # 191 Exhibit 191, # 192 Exhibit 192, # 193 Exhibit 193, # 194 Exhibit 194, # 195 Exhibit 195, # 196 Exhibit 196, # 197 Exhibit 197, # 198 Exhibit 198, # 199 Exhibit 199, # 200 Exhibit 200, # 201 Exhibit 201, # 202 Exhibit 202, # 203 Exhibit 203, # 204 Exhibit 204, # 205 Exhibit 205, # 206 Exhibit 206, # 207 Exhibit 207, # 208 Exhibit 208, # 209 Exhibit 209, # 210 Exhibit 210, # 211 Exhibit 211, # 212 Exhibit 212, # 213 Exhibit 213, # 214 Exhibit 214, # 215 Exhibit 215, # 216 Exhibit 216, # 217 Exhibit 217, # 218 Exhibit 218, # 219 Exhibit 219, # 220 Exhibit 220, # 221 Exhibit 221, # 222 Exhibit 222, # 223 Exhibit 223, # 224 Exhibit 224, # 225 Exhibit 225, # 226 Exhibit 226, # 227 Exhibit 227, # 228 Exhibit 228, # 229 Exhibit 229, # 230 Exhibit 230, # 231 Exhibit 231, # 232 Exhibit 232, # 233 Exhibit 233, # 234 Exhibit 234, # 235 Exhibit 235, # 236 Exhibit 236, # 237 Exhibit 237, # 238 Exhibit 238, # 239 Exhibit 239, # 240 Exhibit 240, # 241 Exhibit 241, # 242 Exhibit 242, # 243 Exhibit 243, # 244 Exhibit 244, # 245 Exhibit 245, # 246 Exhibit 246, # 247 Exhibit 247, # 248 Exhibit 248, # 249 Exhibit 249, # 250 Exhibit 250, # 251 Exhibit 251, # 252 Exhibit 252, # 253 Exhibit 253, # 254 Exhibit 254, # 255 Exhibit 255, # 256 Exhibit 256, # 257 Exhibit 257, # 258 Exhibit 258, # 259 Exhibit 259, # 260 Exhibit 260, # 261 Exhibit 261)(Consovoy, William) (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/18/2018: # 262 Unredacted version of Declaration, # 263 Exhibit 1 (filed under seal), # 264 Exhibit 2 (filed under seal), # 265 Exhibit 5 (filed under seal), # 266 Exhibit 6 (filed under seal), # 267 Exhibit 7 (filed under seal), # 268 Exhibit 8 (filed under seal), # 269 Exhibit 9 (filed under seal), # 270 Exhibit 10 (filed under seal)) (Montes, Mariliz). (Additional attachment(s) added on 6/18/2018: # 271 Exhibit 11 (filed under seal), # 272 Exhibit 12(filed under seal), # 273 Exhibit 13 (filed under seal), # 274 Exhibit 14 (filed under seal), # 275 Exhibit 16 (filed under seal), # 276 Exhibit 17(filed under seal), # 277 Exhibit 18(filed under seal), # 278 Exhibit 19 (filed under seal), # 279 Exhibit 20 (filed under seal), # 280 Exhibit 22 (filed under seal), # 281 Exhibit 23 (filed under seal), # 282 Exhibit 24 (filed under seal), # 283 Exhibit 25(filed under seal), # 284 Exhibit 26 (filed under seal), # 285 Exhibit 28 (filed under seal), # 286 Exhibit 29 (filed under seal), # 287 Exhibit 31 (filed under seal), # 288 Exhibit 32 (filed under seal), # 289 Exhibit 33 (filed under seal), # 290 Exhibit 35 (filed under seal), # 291 Exhibit 36 (filed under seal), # 292 Exhibit 37 (filed under seal), # 293 Exhibit 38(filed under seal), # 294 Exhibit 39 (filed under seal), # 295 Exhibit 40 (filed under seal), # 296 Exhibit 41, # 297 Exhibit 42 (filed under seal), # 298 Exhibit 43 (filed under seal), # 299 Exhibit 44(filed under seal), # 300 Exhibit 45 (filed under seal), # 301 Exhibit 46 (filed under seal), # 302 Exhibit 47 (filed under seal), # 303 Exhibit 48 (filed under seal), # 304 Exhibit 51 (filed under seal)) (Montes, Mariliz).

EXHIBIT 232

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

1

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Garber, Alan
M;Minow, Martha

2

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Hard-copy printout of email discussing
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent

10/10/2012 2:53:00 PM

FW: Fisher amicus brief

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

11-345.pdf

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attached document providing information
for the purpose of rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

10/10/2012 7:11:34 PM

RE: Fisher amicus brief

Attorney-Client Privilege

12/12/2012 1:44:00 PM

FW: The New York Times'
Room for Debate
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice and requesting legal advice
regarding response to allegations of
discrimination

HAY00012100.tif

Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding response to
allegations of discrimination

10/10/2012 6:38:08 PM

3

4

Martha Minow

Iuliano, Robert*;Faust,
Drew Gilpin;Garber,
Alan M

5

Neal, Jeff A.

Fitzsimmons, William;
Quay, Heather*

6

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

Galvin, Kevin

12/26/2012 4:12:00 PM

FW: Fisher amicus brief

Attorney-Client Privilege

12/24/2012 12:00:00 AM

7

The 2012 Sidney Awards I
- The New York Times
Attorney-Client Privilege

8

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

12/27/2012 9:22:00 AM

Unz article

Attorney-Client Privilege

9

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

12/27/2012 2:22:04 PM

Unz article

Attorney-Client Privilege

10

Pacholok, Olesia

Iuliano, Robert*

12/27/2012 5:05:00 PM

HAY00012328.tif

Attorney-Client Privilege

11

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

12/27/2012 5:56:00 PM

12
*indicates an attorney or staff member in Harvard's Office of the General Counsel

1

FW:
Facts About Asian
American Admissions at
Harvard

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding response
to allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding response to allegations of
discrimination

Email rendering legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice regarding response to
allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding response to allegations of
discrimination
Hard-copy printout of attached document
reflecting legal advice regarding response
to allegations of discrimination
CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

13

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin;
Garber, Alan M; Smith,
Michael; Heenan,
Christine M

Neal, Jeff A.; Day, Suzanne;
Galvin, Kevin; Quay,
Heather*; Yong, Elizabeth;
Fitzsimmons, William
12/27/2012 6:27:00 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin;
Garber, Alan M; Smith,
Michael; Heenan,
Christine M

Neal, Jeff A.; Day, Suzanne;
Galvin, Kevin; Quay,
Heather*; Yong, Elizabeth;
Fitzsimmons, William
12/27/2012 6:27:00 PM
Garber, Alan M; Smith,
Michael; Heenan, Christine
M; Neal, Jeff A.; Day,
Suzanne; Galvin, Kevin;
Quay, Heather*; Yong,
Elizabeth; Fitzsimmons,
William
12/27/2012 6:39:00 PM
Garber, Alan M; Smith,
Michael; Heenan, Christine
M; Neal, Jeff A.; Day,
Suzanne; Galvin, Kevin;
Quay, Heather*; Yong,
Elizabeth; Fitzsimmons,
William
12/27/2012 6:39:00 PM

14

15

16

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

American Conservative
Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding response to allegations of
discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice and requesting information for the
purpose of rendering legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email chain rendering
and discussing legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

American Conservative
Article

RE: American
Conservative Article

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

Fitzsimmons, William

12/27/2012 10:56:29 PM

FW:

Attorney-Client Privilege

Statement on Asian
American
Admissions.docx

Iuliano, Robert*

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Garber, Alan
M;Smith,
Michael;Heenan,
Christine M

21

22

Privilege Log Description

NYTimeDemographics.xls
x
Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

19

20

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

12/27/2012 7:15:26 PM

17
18

Date - Modified/Sent

Neal, Jeff A.;Day,
Suzanne;Galvin,
Kevin;Quay, Heather*;Yong,
Elizabeth;Fitzsimmons,
William
12/27/2012 11:27:01 PM

12/27/2012 10:04:45 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Garber, Alan
M;Smith,
Michael;Heenan,
Christine M

Neal, Jeff A.;Day,
Suzanne;Galvin,
Kevin;Quay, Heather*;Yong,
Elizabeth;Fitzsimmons,
William
12/27/2012 11:27:01 PM

2

Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice regarding response to
allegations of discrimination and rendering
legal advice of R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email rendering legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Attached draft document providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice regarding response to
allegations of discrimination

American Conservative
Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

Statement on Asian
American
Admissions.docx

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email requesting and providing information
for the purpose of rendering legal advice
regarding response to allegations of
discrimination
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding response to
allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email requesting and providing information
for the purpose of rendering legal advice
regarding response to allegations of
discrimination

American Conservative
Article

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

23

12/27/2012 10:04:45 PM

Statement on Asian
American
Admissions.docx

24

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

Garber, Alan M;Smith,
Michael;Heenan, Christine
M;Neal, Jeff A.;Day,
Suzanne;Galvin,
Kevin;Quay, Heather*;Yong,
Elizabeth;Fitzsimmons,
William
12/27/2012 11:39:28 PM

Re: American
Conservative Article

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

Garber, Alan M;Smith,
Michael D.;Heenan,
Christine M;Neal, Jeff
A.;Day, Suzanne;Galvin,
Kevin;Quay, Heather*;Yong,
Elizabeth B.;Fitzsimmons,
William R.
12/27/2012 11:39:28 PM

Re: American
Conservative Article

25

Email - To

Email - CC

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding response to
allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

27

Driver-Linn, Erin

Fitzsimmons, William

28

Driver-Linn, Erin

Garber, Alan M

29

Garber, Alan M

Driver-Linn, Erin;Garber, Fitzsimmons,
Alan M
William;Garber, Alan M

12/29/2012 6:39:48 PM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

30

Driver-Linn, Erin

Fitzsimmons,
William;Garber, Alan M

1/2/2013 10:56:51 PM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

31

Garber, Alan M

Driver-Linn,
Erin;Fitzsimmons,
William;Garber, Alan M

1/3/2013 3:55:03 AM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

32

Driver-Linn, Erin

Garber, Alan
M;Fitzsimmons, William

1/3/2013 1:56:50 PM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination
Email chain discussing request of R.
Iuliano* to provide information in
connection with response to allegations of
discrimination

33

Yong, Elizabeth

[e-mail]

1/3/2013 6:12:54 PM

demographic data

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice from R. Iuliano*

26

Driver-Linn, Erin

Garber, Alan M

Fitzsimmons, William

Garber, Alan M

Fitzsimmons, William

12/29/2012 10:54:00 AM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

12/29/2012 1:07:44 PM

Fitzsimmons, William

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

12/29/2012 3:54:27 PM

RE: American
Conservative Article

Attorney-Client Privilege

3

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

36

Yong, Elizabeth

37

38

39

Attorney-Client Privilege

RE: demographic data

Attorney-Client Privilege

Discussion of Unz Article
and Harvard College
Admissions Data

Attorney-Client Privilege

Discussion of Unz Article
and Harvard College
Admissions Data

Attorney-Client Privilege

1/7/2013 8:57:00 AM

40

41

RE: demographic data

Yong, Elizabeth

Driver-Linn, Erin

Fitzsimmons, William

RE: American
Conservative Article

1/7/2013 2:09:00 PM

Driver-Linn, Erin

Garber, Alan M;
Fitzsimmons, William

1/3/2013 6:29:00 PM

1/4/2013 4:44:39 PM

Lu, Elissa

Fitzsimmons, William

Attorney-Client Privilege

1/7/2013 12:00:00 AM

Yong, Elizabeth

Demographic Apps.xlsx

1/7/2013 12:00:00 AM

35

Lu, Elissa; Driver-Linn,
Erin

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

1/3/2013 6:07:33 PM

34

Date - Modified/Sent

2_Fitz_meeting_2013010
7_v2.pptx
Attorney-Client Privilege

1/8/2013 11:25:00 AM

data

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

42

Driver-Linn, Erin

Yong, Elizabeth;
Fitzimmons, William

Scanlon, John

1/8/2013 1:24:00 PM

Re: data

Attorney-Client Privilege

43

Fitzsimmons,
William

Driver-Linn, Erin

Yong, Elizabeth;Scanlon,
John

1/8/2013 7:08:30 PM

Re: data

Attorney-Client Privilege

4

Privilege Log Description
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice
from R. Iuliano* regarding response to
allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email chain
requesting and providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding response to allegations
of discrimination
Email chain gathering information at the
request of R. Iuliano* to facilitate rendering
of legal advice regarding allegations of
discrimination
Hard-copy printout of draft document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice from R. Iuliano*
regarding response to allegations of
discrimination
Hard-copy printout of draft document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice from R. Iuliano*
regarding response to allegations of
discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Draft presentation providing information for
the purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding response to allegations
of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email requesting
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* in connection with response to
allegations of discrimination

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

44

Iuliano, Robert*;Heenan,
Faust, Drew Gilpin Christine M

2/12/2013 5:03:46 PM

Fwd: [FROM P. MALKIN]
Emailing: The Myth of
American Meritocracy
The American
Conservative///As we
agreed,Harvard should
have corrected Onz's
error re Asian % at The
College before or at least
right after David Brooks
confirmed Onz's error
and...
Attorney-Client Privilege

45

Yong, Elizabeth

4/10/2013 5:16:00 PM

first pas at OCR request

Fitzsimmons, William

46

47

48

Lineage Applicants

Yong, Elizabeth

Fitzsimmons, William

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination,
including attached image files (no
substantive content)
Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice of R. Iuliano* regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

4/10/2013 9:15:44 PM

first pas at OCR request

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/10/2013 9:12:20 PM

OCRLinage.xlsx

Attorney-Client Privilege

5

Privilege Log Description

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

49

Yong, Elizabeth

Email - To

Fitzsimmons, William

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

4/19/2013 6:36:39 PM

6

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

OCR Lineage

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Fitzsimmons, William

Yong, Elizabeth

Iuliano, Robert*

Farzan, Ranna L*

Fitzsimmons, William

Fitzsimmons, William

OCRLinage.xlsx

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/24/2013 1:44:18 PM

RE: Request....

Attorney-Client Privilege

OCRLineage.xlsx

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/24/2013 1:44:18 PM

RE: Request....

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/19/2013 6:29:28 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

54

55

Privilege Log Description

4/19/2013 6:29:28 PM

Yong, Elizabeth

52

53

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

4/19/2013 6:29:28 PM

50

51

Date - Modified/Sent

OCRLineage.xlsx

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/30/2013 5:28:00 PM

RWI_notes_admissions_d
ata_4_29_13
Attorney-Client Privilege

Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

HAY00004106.tif HAY00004108.tif

Hard-copy printout of attached notes of R.
Iuliano* reflecting legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

56

7

Attorney-Client Privilege

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

57

Farzan, Ranna L*

Email - To

Email - CC

Pacholok, Olesia

Date - Modified/Sent

5/1/2013 10:29:00 AM

58

59

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

updated charts

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email discussing
request for legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for purpose of
obtaining legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Lineage Applicants

5/1/2013 1:30:26 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

OGC-#452479-v1admissions_data_ocr_mtg
_5_1_13.XLSX
Attorney-Client Privilege
OGC-#452479-v1admissions_data_ocr_mtg
_5_1_13.XLSX
Attorney-Client Privilege

5/1/2013 1:32:48 PM

Email requesting information for the
purpose of rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

66

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

6/11/2013 9:39:00 AM

RE: Thanks

Attorney-Client Privilege

67

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

6/11/2013 1:39:03 PM

RE: Thanks

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attached document reflecting legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Email providing information for the purpose
of rendering legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding attached document
Attached document reflecting legal advice
of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Email chain between R. Farzan*, O.
Pacholok, and E. Yong providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Attached document reflecting legal advice
of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent

68

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin

6/18/2013 3:21:29 PM

Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email reflecting and discussing legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

60

61

Fitzsimmons,
William

Iuliano, Robert*

5/1/2013 2:05:52 PM

Re: OGC-#452479-v1admissions_data_ocr_mtg
_5_1_13.XLSX
Attorney-Client Privilege

62

Farzan, Ranna L*

Pacholok, Olesia

5/1/2013 2:28:32 PM

updated charts

5/1/2013 2:26:26 PM

admissions.data.ocr.mtg.5
.1.13.XLSX
Attorney-Client Privilege

5/3/2013 1:46:23 PM

FW: updated charts

5/1/2013 2:26:26 PM

admissions.data.ocr.mtg.5
.1.13.XLSX
Attorney-Client Privilege

63

64

Pacholok, Olesia

Yong, Elizabeth

65

Heenan, Christine
M;Iuliano, Robert*

8

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

69

Goodheart, Marc

Email - To

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Email - CC

Heenan, Christine M;
Iuliano, Robert*

Date - Modified/Sent

6/18/2013 5:48:00 PM

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

FW: Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

Hard-copy printout of email chain
discussing a request for legal advice and
reflecting legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

70

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Heenan, Christine
M;Iuliano, Robert*

6/18/2013 9:48:20 PM

FW: Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

Attorney-Client Privilege

71

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Heenan, Christine
M;Iuliano, Robert*

6/18/2013 9:48:20 PM

FW: Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice and reflecting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice and reflecting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Heenan, Christine
M;Iuliano, Robert*

6/19/2013 6:29:56 PM

FW: Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

72

Goodheart, Marc

9

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description

73

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

6/19/2013 7:06:23 PM

RE: Fisher - possible
statement - early drafts

74

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

6/24/2013 12:36:00 PM

FW: Fisher comment

Attorney-Client Privilege

75

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

6/24/2013 12:36:00 PM

FW: Fisher comment

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

76

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

6/24/2013 4:36:08 PM

FW: Fisher comment

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

77

Goodheart, Marc

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 4:48:39 PM

Fisher statement for your
review
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email reflecting legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

78

[e-mail]
;[e-mail];
Tiger, Katie;Geier, Judith
A;Blatchford, Alicia;Galvin,
Kathryn;Dach,
Marie;Ingraham,
Shannon;Rom,
Suzanne;GrundlerWhitacre, Karin;Byrne,
Patricia
Liz Cohen;Ellwood,
M.;[e-mail];
David;Faust, Drew
Gill, Suneeta;Freeman,
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
Moriah;Deavor,
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber, Susan;Judith D.
Alan M;Hammonds,
Singer;Khorshid,
Evelynn;Hempton, David Roba;McFadden,
Neil;Meng, XiaoChristina;Sauer,
Li;Minow,
Michelle;Kress,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Leslie;Kenneally, Liberty
Mohsen;Murray,
Davis;[e-mail].
Cherry;Nohria,
edu;Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
Christine M;Iuliano,
D.;Smith,
Robert*;Goodheart,
Michael;[e-mail] Marc;Rosovsky,
Gumble, Stephanie rd.edu
Leah;Farzan, Ranna L*
6/24/2013 4:49:33 PM

Conf. Call on Fisher today
at 2PM
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice from R. Iuliano*

Faust, Drew Gilpin

10

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

79

[e-mail]
;[e-mail];
Tiger, Katie;Geier, Judith
A;Blatchford, Alicia;Galvin,
Kathryn;Dach,
Marie;Ingraham,
Shannon;Rom,
Suzanne;GrundlerWhitacre, Karin;Byrne,
Patricia
Liz Cohen;Ellwood,
M.;[e-mail];
David;Faust, Drew
Gill, Suneeta;Freeman,
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
Moriah;Deavor,
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber, Susan;Judith D.
Alan M;Hammonds,
Singer;Khorshid,
Evelynn;Hempton, David Roba;McFadden,
Neil;Meng, XiaoChristina;Sauer,
Li;Minow,
Michelle;Kress,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Leslie;Kenneally, Liberty
Mohsen;Murray,
Davis;[e-mail].
Cherry;Nohria,
edu;Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
Christine M;Iuliano,
D.;Smith,
Robert*;Goodheart,
Michael;[e-mail] Marc;Rosovsky,
Gumble, Stephanie rd.edu
Leah;Farzan, Ranna L*
6/24/2013 4:49:33 PM

Conf. Call on Fisher today
at 2PM
Attorney-Client Privilege

80

Heenan, Christine
M

Faust, Drew Gilpin;Andrew,
Paul;Iuliano, Robert*
6/24/2013 4:52:40 PM

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

6/24/2013 4:58:23 PM

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice from R. Iuliano*
Email chain reflecting and discussing legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

6/24/2013 5:01:21 PM

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Faust, Drew Gilpin

6/24/2013 5:03:43 PM

RE: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting and discussing legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 5:07:32 PM

RE: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing request for legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

81

82

83

84

Email - To

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

Goodheart, Marc

Goodheart, Marc

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

11

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

85

McFadden,
Christina

86

mengharvard@gm
ail.com
Gumble, Stephanie

Email - CC

Goodheart, Marc;Faust, Heenan, Christine
Drew Gilpin
M;Iuliano, Robert*

FW: Conf. Call on Fisher
today at 2PM

Attorney-Client Privilege

6/24/2013 5:20:17 PM

Re: Conf. Call on Fisher
today at 2PM

Attorney-Client Privilege

6/24/2013 5:23:40 PM

RE: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

6/24/2013 5:36:55 PM

Faust, Drew Gilpin;Garber,
Alan M;Thomas, Dr Sheila

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

6/24/2013 5:08:05 PM

Smith, Michael

Date - Modified/Sent

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing request for legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Email chain discussing legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

87

Andrew, Paul

88

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

89

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 5:47:12 PM

RE: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

90

Goodheart, Marc

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 6:42:14 PM

FW: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

91

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

6/24/2013 6:59:02 PM

Privilege Log Description
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from R.
Iuliano*
Email chain discussing request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

Email chain discussing legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

92

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 7:42:32 PM

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

93

Faust, Drew Gilpin Goodheart, Marc

Andrew, Paul;Heenan,
Christine M;Iuliano, Robert* 6/24/2013 7:45:05 PM

Re: Fisher statement for
your review

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain reflecting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Heenan, Christine M

Statements on Fisher v.
University of Texas

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Fantasia, Amy

Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Goodheart,
Marc;Iuliano, Robert*

95

Iuliano, Robert*

Heenan, Christine
M;Faust, Drew Gilpin

96

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

94

6/24/2013 8:21:19 PM

Goodheart, Marc;Andrew,
Paul
6/24/2013 8:22:41 PM
Heenan, Christine
M;Goodheart, Marc;Andrew,
Paul
6/24/2013 8:24:44 PM

12

RE: are we good to go?

Attorney-Client Privilege

Re: are we good to go?

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from R.
Iuliano*

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

97

98

99

Drew Faust

Martha Minow

Martha Minow

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

Goodheart, Marc;Iuliano,
Robert*;Heenan, Christine
M

6/25/2013 9:11:15 PM

Re: Fisher Decision
Follow-Up

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain reflecting legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

6/26/2013 10:07:31 PM

RE: Race Conscious
Admissions/Fisher

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

6/26/2013 10:07:31 PM

RE: Race Conscious
Admissions/Fisher

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Andrew, Paul
Iuliano, Robert*;Cohen,
Lizabeth;Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hammonds,
Evelynn;Hempton, David
Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith,
Michael;[e-mail]
rd.edu;Murnane,
Richard J.
Rosovsky, Leah
Iuliano, Robert*;Cohen,
Lizabeth;Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hammonds,
Evelynn M.;Hempton,
David Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith, Michael
D.;[e-mail]
u;Murnane, Richard J.
Rosovsky, Leah

13

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

100

Martinez, Alexandra;
Berg, Anne L.; Berg,
Russell; Peshkin,
Catherine;
[e-mail].
edu; Leopold, Deirdre
C.;
[e-mail]
d.edu; Nederhoff, Geri;
Holbrook, Julie S.; Korn,
John F.;
[e-mail];
[e-mail].
edu; Soban, Jessica
Lynn; Buttenbaum,
Karen E.; Feliz, Loida;
Clemons, Matthew K;
Hernandez, Maritza
Suyapa; Pacholok,
Olesia; Mayer, Robert J.;
Spreadbury, Suzanne;
vincentjames@harvard.
edu; Fitzsimmons,
Seaman, Elizabeth P.*; Fox,
William
Matthew Tyler*
6/27/2013 9:49:00 AM

101

Iuliano, Robert*

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

6/26/2013 12:00:00 AM

14

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

Fisher/Race Conscious
Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Harvard University Office
of the General Counsel
Memo re: Fisher

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

102

Martinez, Alexandra;
Berg, Anne L.; Berg,
Russell; Peshkin,
Catherine;
[e-mail].
edu; Leopold, Deirdre
C.;
[e-mail]
d.edu; Nederhoff, Geri;
Holbrook, Julie S.; Korn,
John F.;
[e-mail];
[e-mail].
edu; Soban, Jessica
Lynn; Buttenbaum,
Karen E.; Feliz, Loida;
Clemons, Matthew K;
Hernandez, Maritza
Suyapa; Pacholok,
Olesia; Mayer, Robert J.;
Spreadbury, Suzanne;
vincentjames@harvard.
edu; Fitzsimmons,
Seaman, Elizabeth P.*; Fox,
William
Matthew Tyler*
6/27/2013 9:49:00 AM

Iuliano, Robert*

105

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

Fisher/Race Conscious
Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
from R. Iuliano* rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email requesting
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice of R. Iuliano*

6/26/2013 12:00:00 AM

103

104

Email - CC

Harvard University Office
of the General Counsel
Memo re: Fisher

7/3/2013 2:57:54 PM

Re: op-ed on the Fisher
decision

Drew Faust

Iuliano, Robert*

Farzan, Ranna L*

Bever, Erica Jane;
Driver-Linn, Erin;
Fitzsimmons, William;
Pearce, Karen; Seaman,
Elizabeth P.*; McGrath, Pacholok, Olesia; Jilek,
Marlyn; Donahue, Sally; Tiffany Lee; Rufo Andrade,
Banks, Roger
Loreta
7/8/2013 4:33:00 PM

15

Post-Fisher Meeting

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

106

Bever, Erica Jane;DriverLinn, Erin;Fitzsimmons,
William;Pearce,
Karen;Seaman,
Elizabeth P.*;McGrath, Pacholok, Olesia;Jilek,
Marlyn;Donahue,
Tiffany Lee;Rufo Andrade,
Sally;Banks, Roger
Loreta

107

Farzan, Ranna L*

Fitzsimmons,
William

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

7/8/2013 8:32:37 PM

Post-Fisher Meeting

Email reflecting legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email chain
discussing legal advice and request for
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

7/26/2013 12:00:00 AM

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

108

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions
Harvard University Office
of the General Counsel
Memo re: Fisher

7/31/2013 12:27:01 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

7/31/2013 9:14:00 AM

Attorney-Client Privilege

109

Fitzsimmons,
William

110

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 12:27:24 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

111

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 12:27:24 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

112

Fitzsimmons,
William

7/31/2013 12:27:24 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

7/31/2013 12:28:55 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

7/31/2013 12:28:55 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

113

114

James, Vincent W.

James, Vincent W.

James, Vincent W. Fitzsimmons, William

Pacholok, Olesia

Pacholok, Olesia

Pacholok, Olesia

James, Vincent W. Fitzsimmons, William R. Pacholok, Olesia

16

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

115

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 1:10:30 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

116

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 1:14:03 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

117

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 1:14:03 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

118

Fitzsimmons,
William

James, Vincent W.

Pacholok, Olesia

7/31/2013 1:14:03 PM

119

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

8/22/2013 8:59:25 PM

Farzan, Ranna L*

Cheng, Grace

Fall 2013 Admissions
Orientation.docx

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Attached draft document providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice of R. Iuliano*

8/22/2013 9:04:13 PM

Farzan, Ranna L*

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions
Attorney-Client Privilege
RE: Availability of Bob
Iuliano to speak to the
Admissions/Financial Aid
Office September 6?
Attorney-Client Privilege

8/22/2013 8:43:18 PM

Cheng, Grace

120

121

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

RE: Availability of Bob
Iuliano to speak to the
Admissions/Financial Aid
Office September 6?
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

122

James, Vincent W. Fitzsimmons, William

Pacholok, Olesia

8/27/2013 5:31:48 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

123

James, Vincent W. Fitzsimmons, William R. Pacholok, Olesia

8/27/2013 5:31:48 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

124

Pacholok, Olesia

James, Vincent W.

8/27/2013 5:50:54 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

125

Pacholok, Olesia

James, Vincent W.

8/27/2013 5:50:54 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

126

James, Vincent W. Pacholok, Olesia

8/27/2013 5:52:27 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

127

Pacholok, Olesia

Iuliano, Robert*

8/27/2013 5:54:44 PM
17

FW: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

128

Pacholok, Olesia

129

Iuliano, Robert*

130

Pacholok, Olesia

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Iuliano, Robert*

8/27/2013 5:54:44 PM

FW: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Pacholok, Olesia

8/27/2013 7:16:22 PM

Re: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Email chain requesting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain requesting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

8/27/2013 7:19:50 PM

FW: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing a request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of rendering legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

James, Vincent W.

Email - CC

131

Pacholok, Olesia

James, Vincent W.

8/27/2013 7:19:50 PM

FW: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

132

James, Vincent W. Pacholok, Olesia
Fox, Matthew
Tyler*;Driver-Linn,
Erin;Donahue,
Sally;Fitzsimmons,
William;Banks,
Roger;Bever, Erica
Jane;Pearce,
Karen;McGrath,
Marlyn;Seaman,
Farzan, Ranna L* Elizabeth P.*

8/27/2013 7:21:23 PM

RE: Fisher/Race
Conscious Admissions

133

134

Spanier, Sandra

Fitzsimmons,
William;Yoshino, Kenji

9/4/2013 1:55:58 PM

Iuliano, Robert*;Farzan,
Ranna L*;Chance, Christina 9/9/2013 8:52:45 PM

18

Fisher v. University of
Texas Discussion

Overseers Institutional
Policy discussion, 9/22 phone call 9/11

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

135

Spanier, Sandra

Fitzsimmons, William
R.;Yoshino, Kenji

Iuliano, Robert*;Farzan,
Ranna L*;Chance, Christina 9/9/2013 8:52:45 PM

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email providing information for the purpose
of rendering legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent

9/14/2013 2:40:55 PM

Overseers Institutional
Policy discussion, 9/22 phone call 9/11
FW: OGC-#493537-v1fisher_questions_9_13.D
OCX

136

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

9/14/2013 2:35:37 PM

fisher.questions.9.13.DOC
X
Attorney-Client Privilege

138

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

9/16/2013 9:34:00 AM

fisher questions 9 13

Attorney-Client Privilege

139

Iuliano, Robert*

File

9/13/2013 12:00:00 AM

Memo Re: Post-Fisher
Questions

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attached document rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

140

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

9/16/2013 1:33:55 PM

fisher questions 9 13

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

9/16/2013 1:31:48 PM

fisher questions 9 13.docx Attorney-Client Privilege

9/16/2013 1:33:55 PM

fisher questions 9 13

137

141

142

fisher questions 9 13.docx Attorney-Client Privilege

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William R.

143

144

Attached document rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent

uagroupbounces@hsphsun [e-mail]
3.harvard.edu
vard.edu
Iuliano, Robert*

9/27/2013 12:28:42 PM

19

Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Attached document rendering legal advice
of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with
legal precedent

[Uagroup] The C-Span
video I mentioned at the
UAG meeting

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

10/4/2013 3:49:13 PM

RE: Deanna Lee
questions - race
conscious admissions

Iuliano, Robert*

Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
Ranna L*

Iuliano, Robert*

Spanier,
Sandra;Fitzsimmons,
William

Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
Ranna L*

151

Iuliano, Robert*

Spanier,
Sandra;Fitzsimmons,
William R.

Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
Ranna L*

152

Spanier, Sandra

Fitzsimmons, William;
Yoshino, Kenji

Iuliano, Robert*;Farzan,
Ranna L*;Chance, Christina 11/9/2013 4:53:00 PM

155

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding request for information
and compliance with legal precedent

10/4/2013 3:49:13 PM

RE: Deanna Lee
questions - race
conscious admissions

Spanier,
Sandra;Fitzsimmons,
William

154

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding request for information
and compliance with legal precedent

10/2/2013 4:56:54 PM

Spanier, Sandra

Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
Ranna L*

153

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email requesting legal advice regarding
request for information and compliance
with legal precedent

Deanna Lee questions race conscious
admissions

Fitzsimmons, William
R.;Iuliano, Robert*

150

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email requesting legal advice regarding
request for information and compliance
with legal precedent

10/2/2013 4:56:54 PM

Spanier, Sandra

149

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email requesting legal advice regarding
request for information and compliance
with legal precedent

Deanna Lee questions race conscious
admissions

Fitzsimmons,
Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
William;Iuliano, Robert* Ranna L*

148

Attached image file (no substantive
content)

10/2/2013 4:56:54 PM

Spanier, Sandra

147

Attorney-Client Privilege

Deanna Lee questions race conscious
admissions

Fitzsimmons,
Pacholok, Olesia;Farzan,
William;Iuliano, Robert* Ranna L*

146

Privilege Log Description

image001.png

145

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

10/4/2013 3:49:13 PM

RE: Deanna Lee
questions - race
conscious admissions
Overseers Institutional
Policy discussion, 9/22 phone call 9/11

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

7/29/2013 12:00:00 AM

Why 'Fisher' Means More
Work for Colleges Commentary - The
Chronicle of Higher
Education
Attorney-Client Privilege

6/12/2013 8:30:00 PM

What's Your Hurry? Opinionator - The New
York Times

7/10/2013 9:00:00 PM

The Cost of Compromise Opinionator - The New
York Times
Attorney-Client Privilege

20

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding request for information
and compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email discussing
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

156

Faust, Drew

158

Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Rosovsky, Leah

Goodheart,
Marc;Gershengorn, Ara B*

159

Fisher v. Texas

Attorney-Client Privilege

20140204114030850.pdf

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/7/2014 2:13:29 PM

OGC-#551006-v1fisher_cod.docx

Attorney-Client Privilege

4/7/2014 2:11:35 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

1/15/2014 12:00:00 AM

157

Date - Modified/Sent

2/4/2014 4:39:49 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Email - CC

OGC-#551006-v1fisher_cod.docx

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Memorandum rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Memorandum from R. Iuliano* to D. Faust
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email attaching draft document reflecting
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Attached draft document rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

160

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

4/7/2014 2:43:57 PM

161

Pacholok, Olesia

Iuliano, Robert*

4/7/2014 3:03:35 PM

FW: POFR launch of
Email providing information for the purpose
Harvard, UNC and UW
Attorney-Client and Work of rendering legal advice and prepared in
web sites. Press Release. Product
anticipation of litigation
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
FW: Seen This?
Attorney-Client Privilege Iuliano*

162

Iuliano, Robert*

Pacholok, Olesia

Gershengorn, Ara B*

4/7/2014 3:04:35 PM

RE: Seen This?

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing legal advice
rendered by R. Iuliano*

163

Iuliano, Robert*

Pacholok, Olesia

Gershengorn, Ara B*

4/7/2014 3:04:35 PM

RE: Seen This?

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain discussing legal advice
rendered by R. Iuliano*

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Hard-copy printout of email chain
discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation

164

Fitzsimmons,
William

Smith, Michael

165

Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael

166

Sauer, Michelle

Fitzsimmons, William

Pfister, Donald

Fitzsimmons, William;
Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 11:20:00 AM

Hard-copy printout of email chain
discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Hard-copy printout of email attaching
memorandum from R. Iuliano* rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
Attorney-Client Privilege legal precedent

4/8/2014 11:29:00 AM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

4/8/2014 12:01:00 PM

Confidential memo from
Mike Smith

Attorney-Client Privilege

167

Iuliano, Robert*

Council of Deans

4/7/2014 12:00:00 AM

Memo Re: Fisher v.
Texas

168

Sauer, Michelle

Fitzsimmons, William

4/8/2014 12:01:00 PM

Confidential memo from
Mike Smith

Attorney-Client Privilege

169

Iuliano, Robert*

Council of Deans

4/7/2014 12:00:00 AM

Memo Re: Fisher v.
Texas

Attorney-Client Privilege

21

Hard-copy printout of attached
memorandum rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email attaching
memorandum rendering legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached
memorandum rendering legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

170

Smith, Michael

Pfister,
Donald;Fitzsimmons,
William;Meng, Xiao-Li

Smith, Michael; Khurana,
Rakesh;Collins,
Nina;Iuliano, Robert*

Smith, Michael

Pfister,
Donald;Fitzsimmons,
William;Meng, Xiao-Li

Smith, Michael; Khurana,
Rakesh;Collins,
Nina;Iuliano, Robert*

4/8/2014 3:10:43 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

Email discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation

4/8/2014 3:10:43 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

Email discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation

Smith, Michael

Pfister,
Donald;Fitzsimmons,
William;Meng, Xiao-Li

Smith, Michael;Khurana,
Rakesh;Collins,
Nina;Iuliano, Robert*

4/8/2014 3:10:43 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

173

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons, William;
Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael;Pfister,
Donald

4/8/2014 3:19:59 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

174

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons, William;
Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael;Pfister,
Donald

4/8/2014 3:19:59 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons,
William;Khurana,
Rakesh

175

Smith, Michael;Pfister,
Donald

4/8/2014 3:19:59 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

176

Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons,
William;Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 3:28:35 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

177

Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons,
William;Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 3:28:35 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

178

Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael

Bill Fitzsimmons;Pfister,
Donald

4/8/2014 3:28:35 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

179

Khurana, Rakesh

Smith, Michael

Bill Fitzsimmons;Pfister,
Donald

4/8/2014 3:28:35 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

180

Sauer, Michelle

Fitzsimmons, William

4/8/2014 4:00:41 PM

Confidential memo from
Mike Smith

171

172

Iuliano, Robert
2014.4.7.pdf

181

22

Privilege Log Description

Email discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Product
Email attaching memorandum rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
Attorney-Client and Work legal precedent prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Attached memorandum from R. Iuliano*
rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Product

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Iuliano, Robert*

Email - To
Liz Cohen;Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hempton, David
Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Minow,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith,
Michael;jim_ryan@gse.h
arvard.edu;Pfister,
Donald

183

Iuliano, Robert*

lizabeth_cohen@radcliff
e.edu;Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hempton, David
Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Minow,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith, Michael
D.;[e-mail]
d.edu;Pfister, Donald H.

Goodheart,
Marc;Hausammann,
Marilyn;Newell, Margaret
E;Rosovsky, Leah;Heenan,
Christine M;Andrew,
Paul;Johnson, Mark
R.;Lapp, Katie;Margulies,
Anne;Rogers, Tamara
Elliott;Shore, Dan;Madsen,
Lars Peter Knoth;Karmon,
Sarah Clark;Casey, Kevin 4/8/2014 4:35:45 PM

Fisher

184

Smith, Michael

Iuliano, Robert*

Smith, Michael

4/8/2014 5:12:43 PM

Re: Fisher

185

Smith, Michael

Iuliano, Robert*

Smith, Michael

4/8/2014 5:12:43 PM

Re: Fisher

182

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Goodheart,
Marc;Hausammann,
Marilyn;Newell, Margaret
E;Rosovsky, Leah;Heenan,
Christine M;Andrew,
Paul;Johnson, Mark
R.;Lapp, Katie;Margulies,
Anne;Rogers, Tamara
Elliott;Shore, Dan;Madsen,
Lars Peter Knoth;Karmon,
Sarah Clark;Casey, Kevin 4/8/2014 4:35:45 PM

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Fisher

186

Pacholok, Olesia

Farzan, Ranna L*

Fitzsimmons, William

4/8/2014 6:18:29 PM

RE: Meeting request

187

Iuliano, Robert*

Smith, Michael

Smith, Michael

4/8/2014 8:33:32 PM

RE: Fisher

188

William R.
Fitzsimmons

Smith, Michael;
Khurana, Rakesh

Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 8:45:53 PM

RE: Admissions and
affirmative action

23

Privilege Log Description

Email requesting information for the
purpose of rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

Email requesting information for the
purpose of rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work litigation strategy and prepared in
Product
anticipation of litigation
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work litigation strategy and prepared in
Product
anticipation of litigation
Email discussing a request from R. Iuliano*
regarding the provision of legal advice
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work litigation strategy and prepared in
Product
anticipation of litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

189

Fitzsimmons,
William

Smith, Michael;
Khurana, Rakesh

Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 8:45:53 PM

RE: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

190

William R.
Fitzsimmons

Smith, Michael;Khurana,
Rakesh
Pfister, Donald

4/8/2014 8:45:53 PM

Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

191

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons, William

4/8/2014 11:11:57 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

192

Smith, Michael

Fitzsimmons, William

4/8/2014 11:11:57 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

193

Neal, Jeff A.

Fitzsimmons, William

4/9/2014 1:05:00 PM

In other news...

Attorney-Client Privilege

194

William R.
Fitzsimmons

McGrath, Marlyn

4/9/2014 2:44:54 PM

FW: Confidential memo
from Mike Smith

Iuliano, Robert
2014.4.7.pdf

195

Privilege Log Description
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Hard-copy printout of email providing
information reflecting legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

Email providing information for the purpose
of obtaining legal advice of R. Iuliano*
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Attached memorandum from R. Iuliano*
rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Product

198

William R.
Fitzsimmons

McGrath, Marlyn

4/9/2014 2:45:47 PM

Email chain attaching memorandum from
FW: Confidential memo
R. Iuliano* rendering legal advice regarding
from Mike Smith
Attorney-Client Privilege compliance with legal precedent
Attached memorandum from R. Iuliano*
rendering legal advice regarding
Iuliano, Robert
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent prepared
in anticipation of litigation
2014.4.7.pdf
Product
Email chain providing information for the
FW: POFR launch of
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Harvard, UNC and UW
Attorney-Client and Work Iuliano* and prepared in anticipation of
web sites. Press Release. Product
litigation

199

Neal, Jeff A.

Fitzsimmons, William

4/9/2014 5:06:24 PM

In other news...

Attorney-Client Privilege

200

William R.
Fitzsimmons

McGrath, Marlyn

4/9/2014 5:43:48 PM

FW: In other news...

Attorney-Client Privilege

196

Fitzsimmons,
William

McGrath, Marlyn

197

4/9/2014 2:44:54 PM

4/9/2014 2:44:23 PM

24

Email discussing legal advice of R. Iuliano*
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

201

202

Fitzsimmons,
William

Email - To

Email - CC

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

4/9/2014 6:00:13 PM

4/10/2014 2:18:20 PM

Balian, Andrea

203

Re: In other news...

FW: POFR launch of
Harvard, UNC and UW
Attorney-Client and Work
web sites. Press Release. Product

4/10/2014 5:32:08 PM

McGrath, Marlyn

Neal, Jeff A.

Date - Modified/Sent

Attorney-Client Privilege

MIN71-18.XLS

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

4/12/2014 9:04:58 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

204

mengharvard@gm
ail.com
Smith, Michael

205

Smith, Michael

Collins, Nina

4/14/2014 5:09:38 PM

FW: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

206

Collins, Nina

Smith, Michael

4/14/2014 5:50:44 PM

FW: Admissions and
affirmative action

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

Iuliano, Robert*

Privilege Log Description

Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation

207

4/14/2014 5:54:17 PM

Backup of 2003sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

208

4/14/2014 5:54:30 PM

Backup of 2004sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

209

4/14/2014 5:54:41 PM

Backup of 2005sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

Backup of 2006sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

210

4/14/2014 5:54:51 PM

25

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

211

Smith, Michael

Email - To

Collins, Nina

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

4/14/2014 6:53:09 PM

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

Privilege Log Description

Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation

4/14/2014 6:53:09 PM

Re: Admissions and
affirmative action

213

4/14/2014 7:18:34 PM

2001sav.xlsx

214

4/14/2014 7:24:18 PM

2002sav.xlsx

Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
Product
litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

2003sav.xlsx

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

2004sav.xlsx

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

2005sav.xlsx

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

212

215

216

217

Smith, Michael

Collins, Nina

4/14/2014 7:25:32 PM

4/14/2014 7:27:33 PM

4/14/2014 7:28:54 PM

26

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

218

219

220

221

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

4/14/2014 7:30:48 PM

4/14/2014 7:34:06 PM

4/14/2014 7:34:46 PM

4/14/2014 7:35:22 PM

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

2006sav.xlsx

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

Backup of 2007sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

Backup of 2008sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

Backup of 2009sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

222

4/14/2014 7:35:49 PM

Backup of 2010sav.xlk

223

4/14/2014 7:50:46 PM

Backup of 2011sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

Backup of 2012sav.xlk

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

224

4/14/2014 7:53:11 PM

27

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

225

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation

4/14/2014 7:56:25 PM

2008sav.xlsx

226

4/14/2014 7:56:38 PM

2007sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

227

4/14/2014 8:01:29 PM

2009sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

228

4/14/2014 8:02:57 PM

2010sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

229

4/14/2014 8:03:54 PM

2011sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

230

4/14/2014 8:05:25 PM

2012sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

231

4/14/2014 8:07:04 PM

Backup of 2013sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

232

4/14/2014 8:11:15 PM

Backup of 2014sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

233

4/14/2014 8:13:41 PM

Backup of 2015sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

28

Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

234

4/14/2014 8:15:41 PM

Backup of 2016sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

235

4/14/2014 8:17:47 PM

Backup of 2017sav.xlk

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

236

4/14/2014 10:05:05 PM

New20142017sav.xlsx

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

237

4/15/2014 2:16:00 AM

Apps - old.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

238

4/15/2014 2:16:40 AM

Apps - old nlna.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

239

4/15/2014 2:17:55 AM

Apps - old sav.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

240

4/15/2014 2:18:47 AM

Apps - new ipeds.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

241

4/15/2014 2:19:29 AM

Apps - new nlna.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

242

4/15/2014 2:21:34 AM

Apps - new sav.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

Demog20002017.pdf

Attorney-Client and Work
Product

243

Email - To

Email - CC

4/15/2014 2:23:25 AM

29

Privilege Log Description
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Document providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent and
prepared in anticipation of litigation

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

244

William R.
Fitzsimmons

Email - To

Iuliano, Robert*

245

246

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

4/16/2014 1:55:57 PM

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

FW: stats

4/16/2014 1:55:34 PM

Fitzsimmons,
William

Iuliano, Robert*;
McGrath, Marlyn; Yong,
Elizabeth

Demog20002017.pdf

4/17/2014 12:00:00 AM

Memorandum

247

DRAFT

DRAFT - Facts About
Asian Americans at
Harvard

248

Privilege Log Description

Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client and Work compliance with legal precedent and
Product
prepared in anticipation of litigation
Attached document providing information
for the purpose of obtaining legal advice
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Product
Hard-copy printout of document providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice regarding response to
Attorney-Client Privilege allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information to R. Iuliano* for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information to R. Iuliano* for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information to R. Iuliano* for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

249

Facts About Asian
Americans at Harvard

250

Addendum on the
Collection and Reporting
of Data on Race and
Ethnicity

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information to R. Iuliano* for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

Today's Supreme Court
Decision

Attorney-Client Privilege

Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

251

Iuliano, Robert*

Liz Cohen;Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hempton, David
Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Minow,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith,
Michael;'jim_ryan@gse.
harvard.edu';Pfister,
Donald

Goodheart,
Marc;Hausammann,
Marilyn;Newell, Margaret
E;Rosovsky, Leah;Heenan,
Christine M;Andrew,
Paul;Iuliano,
Robert*;Johnson, Mark
R.;Lapp, Katie;Margulies,
Anne;Rogers, Tamara
Elliott;Shore, Dan;Madsen,
Lars Peter Knoth;Karmon,
Sarah Clark;Casey, Kevin 4/22/2014 8:37:41 PM

30

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

252

Iuliano, Robert*

'lizabeth_cohen@radcliff
e.edu';Ellwood,
David;Faust, Drew
Gilpin;Flier, Jeffrey
S.;Frenk, Julio;Garber,
Alan M;Hempton, David
Neil;Meng, XiaoLi;Minow,
Martha;Mostafavi,
Mohsen;Murray,
Cherry;Nohria,
Nitin;Singer, Judith
D.;Smith, Michael
D.;'[e-mail]
d.edu';Pfister, Donald H.

Goodheart,
Marc;Hausammann,
Marilyn;Newell, Margaret
E;Rosovsky, Leah;Heenan,
Christine M;Andrew,
Paul;Iuliano,
Robert*;Johnson, Mark
R.;Lapp, Katie;Margulies,
Anne;Rogers, Tamara
Elliott;Shore, Dan;Madsen,
Lars Peter Knoth;Karmon,
Sarah Clark;Casey, Kevin 4/22/2014 8:37:41 PM

253

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

4/24/2014 10:37:00 AM

254

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William

4/24/2014 2:36:52 PM

255

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William R.

4/24/2014 2:36:52 PM

256

Goodheart,
Marc;Heenan, Christine
M;Andrew, Paul;Iuliano,
Madsen, Lars Peter Robert*;Faust, Drew
Knoth
Gilpin

4/25/2014 6:48:34 PM

257

Bever, Erica Jane

4/28/2014 8:57:34 PM

Fitzsimmons, William

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

Today's Supreme Court
Decision

Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

FW: Today's Supreme
Court Decision
FW: Today's Supreme
Court Decision
FW: Today's Supreme
Court Decision

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege
Attorney-Client Privilege
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain providing information for
purpose of requesting legal advice from R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
RE: One College
Attorney-Client Privilege precedent
Email chain providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
FW: Meeting re: raceAttorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
conscious admissions
Product
litigation
Draft document providing information for
the purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
fisher.task.force.5.2.14.D
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
OCX
Attorney-Client Privilege precedent

258

5/12/2014 2:35:18 PM

259

[e-mail];
Goodheart,
Marc;Gershengorn, Ara B* 5/20/2014 5:00:42 PM

Ryan (Fisher) Committee Attorney-Client Privilege

260

5/20/2014 4:53:24 PM

dgf.letter.ryan.task.force.r
wi.comments.DOCX
Attorney-Client Privilege

261

5/20/2014 4:53:24 PM

262

5/20/2014 4:39:14 PM

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin

31

fisher.charge.final.5.20.14
.DOCX
Attorney-Client Privilege
Proposed Fisher
committee membership
list.DOCX
Attorney-Client Privilege

Email chain rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Attached draft correspondence reflecting
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Attached draft document reflecting legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Attached draft document reflecting legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding
Proposed Fisher
Committee with
bios.DOCX
Attorney-Client Privilege

Gershengorn, Ara B*

5/20/2014 9:35:33 PM

Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

5/21/2014 11:14:01 AM

Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

5/22/2014 7:46:41 PM

Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

5/23/2014 2:05:49 AM

Re: Ryan (Fisher)
Committee

Attorney-Client Privilege

5/23/2014 2:24:48 AM

RE: Ryan (Fisher)
Committee

Attorney-Client Privilege

263
264

Iuliano, Robert*

Pfister, Donald
H.;Khurana, Rakesh

265

Khurana, Rakesh

Stephanie Khurana

266

Rouse, Joan

Khurana, Rakesh

267

Faust, Drew Gilpin Iuliano, Robert*

Harvard College Dean

268

Iuliano, Robert*

Faust, Drew Gilpin

269

Khurana, Rakesh

R. Iuliano*

Pfister, Donald;Joan Rouse 5/24/2014 12:59:02 AM

Re: Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

270

Khurana, Rakesh

R. Iuliano*

Pfister, Donald;Joan Rouse 5/24/2014 12:59:02 AM

Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

271

Iuliano, Robert*

Khurana, Rakesh

Pfister, Donald H.;Rouse,
Ms Joan

5/24/2014 9:20:47 PM

Request for students

Attorney-Client Privilege

272

Khurana, Rakesh

R. Iuliano*

6/4/2014 8:15:22 PM

Request for
info/background

Attorney-Client Privilege

273

Khurana, Rakesh

R. Iuliano*

6/5/2014 1:04:34 AM

Request for
info/background

Attorney-Client Privilege

274

Iuliano, Robert*

Khurana, Rakesh

6/5/2014 1:37:14 AM

Request for
info/background

Attorney-Client Privilege

275

Khurana, Rakesh

Counter, S.

6/11/2014 11:06:46 AM

Re: questions

Attorney-Client Privilege

276

Iuliano, Robert*

Fitzsimmons, William R.

6/12/2014 2:52:21 PM

FW: Hasty Pudding/Jim
Ryan's Committee

Attorney-Client Privilege

277

Fitzsimmons,
William

6/12/2014 4:18:33 PM

Re: Hasty Pudding/Jim
Ryan's Committee

Attorney-Client Privilege

Iuliano, Robert*

32

Privilege Log Description
Attached draft document reflecting legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email chain discussing request for legal
advice of R. Iuliano* regarding compliance
with legal precedent
Email chain discussing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain containing legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Email chain rendering and discussing legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain rendering legal advice
regarding compliance with legal precedent
Email chain requesting and rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Email chain rendering legal advice and
providing information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email chain rendering legal advice and
providing information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice of R. Iuliano* regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

278

Khurana, Rakesh

R. Iuliano*

Iuliano, Robert*

Driver-Linn, Erin;
Fitzsimmons, William

Iuliano, Robert*

Driver-Linn,
Erin;Fitzsimmons,
William

281

Iuliano, Robert*

Driver-Linn,
Erin;Fitzsimmons,
William R.

282

Iuliano, Robert*

279

280

283

284

Farzan, Ranna L*

Fitzsimmons, William
Ryan, James; Avery,
Christopher; Banaji,
Mahzarin, Byrne,
Patricia; Canfield,
Michael; Carrasco,
David; Chetty,
Nadarajan; Dingman,
Thomas; Ely, Robin;
Fallon, Richard;
Fitzsimmons, William;
Forsyth, Ann;
Hammonds, Evelyn;
Jha, Ashish; Katz,
Lawrence; Kennedy,
Randall; Leopold,
Deirdre; Mayer, Robert;
Soban, Jessica Lynn;
Warikoo, Natasha
Kumar; Driver-Linn, Erin;
Gershengorn, Ara B*;
Goodheart, Marc;
Iuliano, Robert*

Email - CC

Gershengorn, Ara B*

Fwd: students

6/17/2014 9:24:00 AM

FW: NYTimes.com: If
Affirmative Action Is
Doomed, What’s Next?

Privilege Log Description
Email chain requesting and providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
Attorney-Client Privilege legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of email rendering legal
advice regarding compliance with legal
Attorney-Client and Work precedent and prepared in anticipation of
litigation
Product

6/17/2014 1:24:00 PM

FW: NYTimes.com: If
Affirmative Action Is
Doomed, What’s Next?

Email chain rendering legal advice
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation

6/17/2014 1:24:00 PM

FW: NYTimes.com: If
Affirmative Action Is
Doomed, What’s Next?

7/12/2014 10:52:00 AM

Gershengorn, Ara B*

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

6/12/2014 7:37:43 PM

Gershengorn, Ara B*;
Goodheart, Marc

Date - Modified/Sent

FW: Hasty Pudding/Jim
Ryan's Committee

Email chain rendering legal advice
Attorney-Client and Work regarding compliance with legal precedent
Product
and prepared in anticipation of litigation
Hard-copy printout of email chain
requesting information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding
Attorney-Client Privilege compliance with legal precedent

Bremner, Kim; Dial,
Christopher; Higbe,
Charlene; Jilek, Tiffany Lee;
Kearney, Susan; Lamond,
Margaret; Martin, Torey;
Murphy, Jean; Pacholok,
Olesia; Rom, Suzanne;
Shack, Monica
7/13/2014 11:13:00 AM

7/26/2014 12:00:00 AM

285

Re: Ryan Committee

Attorney-Client Privilege

Committee on Student
Body Diversity Agenda

Attorney-Client Privilege

Charge to the Committee Attorney-Client Privilege

33

Hard-copy printout of email chain providing
information for the purpose of rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

6/26/2013 12:00:00 AM

286

287

Manning, Colin

Fitzsimmons, William

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding
Harvard University Office
of the General Counsel
Memo re: Fisher
Attorney-Client Privilege

7/17/2014 6:29:02 PM

race/admissions

Attorney-Client Privilege

289

Fitz_meeting_20130107_v
2.pptx
Attorney-Client Privilege
Robert Iuliano re Fisher v
Texas 2014.04.07.pdf.pdf
Attorney-Client Privilege

290

HAY00003194.tif HAY00003195.tif

291

Harvard College
Applicants and Admits
Average Scores and
Grades by Race, Classes
of 2014 to 2018
Attorney-Client Privilege

288

Attorney-Client Privilege

Privilege Log Description
Hard-copy printout of attached document
rendering legal advice regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Draft email providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Draft document providing information for
the purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding response to allegations
of discrimination
Memorandum from R. Iuliano* rendering
legal advice regarding compliance with
legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of handwritten notes of
W. Fitzsimmons reflecting legal advice of
R. Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of document of W.
Fitzsimmons providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of the General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent

292

Harvard Admit Rates by
Race/Ethnicity, 1990-2015 Attorney-Client Privilege

293

Lineage Applicants

Attorney-Client Privilege

294

HAY00004113.tif HAY00004114.tif

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of document of W.
Fitzsimmons providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice from
Office of the General Counsel* regarding
compliance with legal precedent
Hard-copy printout of document of W.
Fitzsimmons providing information for the
purpose of obtaining legal advice of R.
Iuliano* regarding compliance with legal
precedent
Hard-copy printout of notes of W.
Fitzsimmons reflecting a request for legal
advice from R. Iuliano*

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination

295

Fitzsimmons,
William

luliano, Robert*; Day,
Suzanne; Madsen, Lars
Peter Knoth; Christine
Heenan; Neal, Jeff A.;
Quay, Heather*; Yong,
Elizabeth;
kevin_galvin@harvard.e
du; Driver-Linn, Erin;
Bever, Erica Jane;
McGrath, Marlyn;
Donahue, Sally

Unz Article and David
Brooks Column

34

CONFIDENTIAL

SFFA v. Harvard -- Privilege Log

Doc # Email - From

Email - To

Email - CC

Date - Modified/Sent

Data - File Name/Subject Basis for Withholding

Privilege Log Description

Ron Unz's article, "The
Myth of American
Meritocracy" in The
American Conservative

Attorney-Client Privilege

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of email providing
information for the purpose of obtaining
legal advice from R. Iuliano* regarding
response to allegations of discrimination
Hard-copy printout of email requesting
legal advice regarding response to
allegations of discrimination

Attorney-Client Privilege

Hard-copy printout of attached document
providing information for the purpose of
obtaining legal advice regarding response
to allegations of discrimination

296

Fitzsimmons,
William

Faust, Drew Gilpin;
Smith, Michael

luliano, Robert*; Day,
Suzanne; Heenan, Christine
M; Neal, Jeff A.; Quay,
Heather*; Yong, Elizabeth;
[e-mail]

297

Fitzsimmons,
William

Iuliano, Robert*

Neal, Jeff A

Various drafts discussed
today

Faust, Drew Gilpin;
Smith, Michael

luliano, Robert*; Day,
Suzanne; Heenan, Christine
M; Neal, Jeff A.; Quay,
Heather*; Yong, Elizabeth;
[e-mail]

Ron Unz's article, "The
Myth of American
Meritocracy" in The
American Conservative

298

Fitzsimmons,
William

35

CONFIDENTIAL