Freshub, Inc. et al v. Amazon.Com Inc. et al

Filing 1

COMPLAINT ( Filing fee $ 400 receipt number 0542-12267080), filed by Freshub, Inc., Freshub, Ltd.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Civil Cover Sheet)(Palmer, John)

EXHIBIT 21

02 15 6
134 2
5 7ÿ;<=>?>×Õ: Ò
68:ÿ 7ÿ; :>ÿ ÚÆ
@ØÙÕ
%ÿ
 
2 

ÀÁ ÄÁÆ È É É
Âÿ ÅÇÿÉ Ê ÿ

789 ÿ ÿ  ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(

 ÿ    ÿ  7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ  ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9



 
Ë++
 

 (%  ¼ ÿ
+8 ½ÿ  $' ¾ ÿ   ¿ ( 0
 9»ÿ 9  789 * 9    & 

ÿËÌ

$ & ÿ
 ÿ 
 0
Î ÿ ÓÓ
Ðÿ
ÿ ÍÎ ÇÏÂÅ ÑÒÅ

ÔÕ Õ ×ØÙÕÚÆ
ÖÆÓ Õÿ Ò

Ê ÛÁÕ
Å

CDEG JK MK ÿPA ÿ RSTÿ ÿUBÿ= S:ÿ ÿUBÿYÿ ÿZ7[@ ÿ\; ÿ@]7^ ÿ_@7@_@S ÿR?@XB@ ÿa@:b@ ÿ dB7A [ ÿ_@7@5 8 ;:ÿe= = @g ]ÿ >@ := [_@7@
F Hÿ LNO ?;Qÿ @= 7@VW@X 7@V
> Sÿ <@5 ?B:ÿ `?ÿ =X ?X;7X B7 [c@]WX@ `?ÿ] 8 B > f ÿ; Ba; :>ÿ> ÿ `?X

aA ?ÿÿA ÿ@7@?>BS@:BX;ÿAX8; ]:=@?<8 :W@j7A^ ]ÿYÿ; > ÿs 7<@ :ÿ> ÿ= S›=@S@W T
@67:@[ `?ÿ; :;ÿ =]@ÿd:7ÿB[ ?ÿBÿ; =7Sÿ :ÿ; BV h ] [@ ]8 >h [?W@X:S:ÿ;z
d
d
X
=
7
”=><;@= ; :?<8 :W@[ `?X
@Bÿ BÿW ]ÿ; =7Sÿ@7@

UBÿYÿ W h = [iB@j7ARSTÿ> ÿZÿ :=\_h:@<7f<@ 7ÿS^B
7@V a] @ÿ > Xd@ÿ :ÿÿ@== [k lSBÿ ÿ B= > ÿ [=8=@
A
X

C®¯ÿHÿMK‘•
KEG {ÿ
W ÿ m>
^R<=;

=
X
j@ ÿ s ;7ÿS W @ ` ? B ? ÿ = S @
B :á?
ÜK€ÿ‰H…ÿKG Kkhnoÿ]X;<@BB`7jX ÿqooorÿ>X@TVhR<=@X>;>X;fÿA@ÿ>?][@[ÿX7`7@<;:`=7=WS:;>
® EG „ ÿ ÿÿÿÿ k ? : ÿ@ @ ÿp =RS@ÿ@[ÿ]m@XXX>][i=X[ÿ;7@ÿ@?ÿ@h7ÿ@z5@S?ÿ
‰O
UB Yÿ@7 ÿ 7 : 7 S ` @B ÿ @ ÿ
7 [ `? ]
;
=
RSTÿ= ÿ@8<=;>taA;7@f^dBA <@@]W Bj7A
@=?>A SR<=@<= =? ÿ;;ÿbBÿ`?X@ÿ :
ÿ 6ÿX > f> ] u @:ÿ 7u
m
7
; ÿ=
s @:; ÿB?<<= [:ÿ@ÿ> ÿ@BX<8@BX; XX
] X7>;ÿ; > ÿ;X@= [A =ÿ= Sÿ@8 >@
S:ÿ> ÿ<=:\; ÿ; > X
7 X= [5 Bÿ <@?<<= [z
X
d; RSTz
B<ÿ @=
vB?wx q zyQÿ|} ÿM Hÿ :7
7@ q yy ÿ { }~ €€M z =S
_@ X
ÿ ‚ÿ;;6X; 8> ÿX²
™A>X:ÿ z 8 7fS:
=tÿ>? ÿA
:5 <^
7
ƒE ÿÿ …HK…E‡‰HKŠ ŒB@ÿ :7ÿŽÿÿ HO= [?; Xÿ’GJE ÿM H=ÿA ?; :ÿ :7
H„MƒK O †ÿ ÿ‹ÿ [ Bj7A>Š ÿ ODM ÿ> ÿA ;@‘ “ †~ €€M ÿ:?@6 ]z =S
„
ˆ
_@ X
A d; [ X <^ÿ ; _7
7
ÿ [t X6:<ÿ>fÿ;[WÿR<=ÿXÿ f:S @`?X”az
R[5j=ÿBA ÿ; ÿ;ÿÿ^;[ m7: 7=ÿ B7@ÿ”
ÿ8Sÿ @= [t S :i;S>z 5
:
a; bf B:; wMK‘•ÿ
> ]=7>ÿ ÿ –‰—K
{
5 ;{ÿ =–‰—K <z :ÿ; > ?@@V a] @raS] ÿ <
: ÿ W XB
A
MK‘•ÿ tÿ; Ý
7
ÿA jÿ>@W]^a= ; ÿj7A?> @:BÿYÿ W ÿÿ ; [a=
ÿ U[yz´
R<=¸ŠŠ‹¹; [ <Þ
m ÿ‹‹ ÿ
; aS
xy y
q

•¶ ·
J}

c;S `B7 f ÿ;m; 7
S; @ÿ @:ÿ; <ÿ
ÿ <=
>
ÿ@ÿ =ÿ @=?>[
5 @jA :RSTÿ= ÿ;

7@V W ÿÿ @bB:A [ @
U
˜
[
7
ÿ ^\_e‚Yÿÿz@7^Aÿ X::> Xd@ÿ:@<7f<@ 7ÿS^Bj7ARSTzB<ÿ?;X:@B; ÿ XÿXÿ @=:ÿ]>; ÿA ÿYÿ7 :@S AX
¢] ÿUBÿS^@W=X:]ÿ >ÿ=ÿ iBzXB= > ÿ [=8=@ÿ :ÿ @=ÿ ; =BXÿA ÿ; <h]:=6RSTÿ;:Bÿ>:@V h <ÿA ÿf :h
? a]
= [ÿ= S : ; j= ÿ;j=?
> ÿ = jA ÿ
8
:A
™7AdBb@[` 7@B?f 77>ÿ7Aÿ ?; A > Xÿ> ÿ@<dB > ÿ@A ;; ^ÿ7@V a] @A =X^ ]d; = ^[B?7>ÿ>; ÿ= [i
:ÿ=i Sÿ;?ÿ@; >:; h f :<7B8 ; @h [W = ;<7f:?> Sfh BÿYÿ W ÿ@Bÿ; ÿB<ÿ> ÿ7@:; z ˜^A > X
@
=
U
P
B ` @? ;
;
ßG MOE d@@ÿ;7=Xj@SÿSÿd?>f@ÿ7šXWSÿh8S:h8=@ÿ@hd>@dÿj=B˜ÿ:^;]B`@zvSX?>:;S:@ÿ;j@B=>[ÿ;S<@ÿ>ÿ;]BVYhX]>[W=Bÿ>[ÿ Y
LKÿH…ÿ?7@?’O:;X?ÿ;>:>`ÿ@=BAÿ=^ÿ7]XAÿ=XÿXB:ÿh=>[ÿ B ÿz ÿ; B ÿA 8 ÿ ` ] ; ^ ÿ ÿ; h= R›
‘•ÿ ÿÿ;>B=ÿ @ : ? = S: :S [X <; ?]
B ^`Gÿ @ 7@=XBS@? ;ÿ @S
@Oÿ ÿ
U> ÿ; :>ÿBUBÿ]B=WB:X=W;Si>78X= B:=X@X^ ]?=?ÿAj7A=AÿÿXÿ;:@:@> jXÿ; :;ÿ; =7Sÿ<=:A <@[ `?Xÿ> ÿ Bš
7[?>@ :d;@@;Yÿ `@7S`[A7@`X@z @@ABÿ :ÿ;?A>6:@j@]@h7:>7ÿA ÿ@ h >BS <8 :W@X Bÿ; ÿ@7@h [<;@
<ÿVBd ;ÿ=ÿÿ]ÿ 7ÿ @6 ÿ :S ÿ @ ÿ : BS @ ÿ;
?=
7 a] A
:
? ?
=
@@ ÿ :ÿA ÿYÿœz7@V a] @7ÿS ^ÿ@:> ÿ<=:Bj7A> jÿ @=X7X= [` 7@d>:; =7^
`>j7A:@V ; ÿBÿYÿ W ÿ =j=Xf :7fX B@ÿ :ÿ@ RSTÿ6Sÿ> ÿ;?ÿ] ?7> S z
U
X
S
:
d
:
P
ÿ =ÿP;@7>tÿB@:i7@8?]@s =7^j7A=?Xÿ;``[k lSBÿ ] ÿ; ÿ8ÿ> ÿ ÿ>; ÿA ÿ] 7ÿSB:ÿd_;W ÿ <;ÿ>XS?
vS^tB8 B@A@:] i;S ÿ7:Bÿ] S ÿ :ÿ?@X:ÿ77ÿZÿ :=\_ÿ8:ÿodX= [\_cz ˜^:@= [;?=7^;ÿ S^R: X; ÿ@@:
fTj>7 ?
à
X
vB<@Y7@ ÿ7SX
7 ÿ [ ;::@z
P ˜^:>ÿd:; X> X;ÿA > @Xÿ8 Xÿ> ÿ @=X7Xÿ :; @ÿo ho ÿ `@ÿ> ÿYÿ8X[ Xd;  @¡7h 7 ÿ [ ;ÿ Sh
>; ÿ@ X;ÿA ]= [ÿd?= > Sh 8h [RSTÿ6Sz ÿ`BŸ oo o<; 7X= [V @ 7; @ÿB<ÿ : Tÿ <@Y7@ h ]ÿ
= =
S ž@
vB
\] \¢h
ÿ =ÿ5<@;‚Ah> Xÿ\¢Þ Bz
vS^t= ÿdeP; @t= [<;@
ž\™VV B ¢ah> ÿ
ÿ ÿ ÿ
Ý
R?@Xg ] ] @ÿ=@ ; 6ÿ [ 7h> ÿ Bÿ W7@ÿ :ÿ7 ÿ> ÿ7@;ÿBjXBz
?Xÿ; V W h ?W ; h [:ÿ [<;@j@ X:Xj7A5S = [UBdTW; @X
U
c@ =
6
R>R<=; ÿ 7 ÿ <W BA8] S?X:; X> X;ÿ `@ÿ> ÿYÿ8X[ X7?] 7fuA B[ ^ 7Aÿ; :=Sÿ> ÿ 7 ÿ 77=XS@
ÿ m>vB<@<@ @X7ÿ>;6ÿA ]= [ÿd<; 7X= [V @ 7; @ÿ S[> ÿV ]X=ÿ f :U ;W S = [vB<@Bf> Sÿ6
>
u
7
£A ÿ f5?¤= [£> = ^v :¤
V @¢7ÿ76ÿ> ÿ5 @6ÿ@@z
”] ?ÿ> ÿ; :;ÿ; :>ÿ :ÿA ÿ @=Y;?ÿ <;@¥> ÿ >z :Ad` B:Xd;  @¡7h 7 ÿ [ ;ÿ Sh V h \™VePÿB
= >A= [?>BS >@ :j7A:@RSTÿ 7@c@ :ÿ [ž@ §™=?ÿ=;7@ÿB<ÿ : Tÿ <@Y7@ h ]ÿ Rc¨ÿ ‚ h
?
¦
ÿ
vB
\] 5 5
;
a¢5RSR?@XÿSXXB= dBd@ÿ :ÿ ];V he_WU@[`h> ÿ:@X
ÿ S ?Xh ]ÿ:@<ÿ;ÿB@j7AvS:ÿYÿ ÿB@ 7@ÿ [;A Bz
ÿ 8
‚
=
ˆD€ÿGÿ <8 Bÿ7@V d<7ÿp ÿ@A 7=ÿ@=S
‰ „© =@UBÿYÿ= S V?>?S :7
a;
^
[ X

ƒK’E ÿG ÿGº ’©
ÿ H„† ‰„ÿHG

™7ARSTÿ>UBÿYÿ W h; ÿ= ÿ; :;ÿ; =7SÿYXÿ; > W Bh> ÿ Yÿ@@`BÿB<ÿ; ÿB> XS@5 <X> h ; ^ÿžh m;ÿ>
:ÿ @=; ÿ7@V a] @ÿ ]?>?>BS <8 :W@V h ] [ =Xÿ [R› B?7@Xd; :8W= [ÿ6ÿ= ] fÿ >h ÿ 7h [
^
?
X
=
7
5 ” Y7 =
<;@ÿ ]h] @:ÿ`ÿYÿA > @Xj7A?W@;ÿ=@S@W TXd; 8; 7@XS@a; =:ÿ 5 ÿ cP YR QVli@Xh> ÿ Bz;
Bz Xÿ > ÿ;S@V ?= > Sÿ :ÿ= SÿBX:S:ÿ;@ÿB<ÿB`[ Bÿ6ÿ <?Xh \h aV ›V ÿ `B@ÿ [<;@ÿ ]
vS : 7
7
7
_‚ _‚
=
g
”
?> ;ÿXÿ; B` 7@:ÿA > @?= > SÿA; f ÿ>; @iA i7ÿ = :> =ÿ@Bÿ BÿW ]ÿ] 8 B@ ÿ@7@z
= > :]@^ ]ÿ;?ÿ;?= f ÿA > @X:B] A= ÿ`B:@=B\_ÿ>@ > z =><;@= ; :X8 ;:[[ `?X
 ;ÿ`Bÿ8 ÿ=ÿA ÿ= ÿ;?ÿ; :;ÿT @7>@ÿ > ÿ8 X=Sjÿ; ÿ;?>BS S^ =6;ÿ; :>ÿ S^ÿ= Xh@] § X> ÿ @=;
:@@^= 8A X:@X<@` 7@?>BS 8 B@ ?z ^= 8ÿS ^ ]:ÿ; :;ÿ =W ?ÿd?>@ :¥ =h ]@ÿ X<@ÿ 7fRSTÿ>
@
e=
;
8
8 8 B ]
UBÿYÿ W z ; ÿ[ 77> S 8 X7?] 7f @¡7h Sh ÿ5 ÿ> ÿV ÿ=@7:f=@ ÿ]:@ÿ :ÿ @=ÿS j7f^ ]:ÿBjXÿ>
7@V a] @ÿ <@= [:; =ÿ 8ÿ S[> ÿ : Tÿ ]ÿ P v h [5 Rc¨A `ÿ @ B:[dBA Bj7ARSTh S > ÿ; ÿ;W; @= [
5
= >
\] R¢ah =
>
=;
X=?h> ÿ=7=@]7f^ ]ÿ;?ÿ^X^> ÿRSTh ;Bf :ÿB£ @=ÿ@@:¤
@BAÿ [> `f :ÿX> ÿ; B` 7@W ÿ=7f£ @=ÿ ÿ7A¤;ÿRSTh S?z
=
f
X
RSTÿ S> ÿ e@Xf> h ] :;A?> @:; X:ÿ WSÿA > Xÿ> ÿ8 :dÿ] 8 Bÿ;ÿ S7c; <ÿ X?=@> :?B@ :^X8 ;:[;
@=a=S fQÿ X= 7fÿ @; :ÿ; > ?7>ÿ;<; 7 8 ; @h [5 ;7^X8 ;:dBe]:i ; e]7ÿBÿ;ÿ]B>Sÿ] 8 B@ ÿ>
7
¢S
@
=
UBÿYÿ W z
7@V a] @

1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341 
 )*89 *  1 3 2 3 /%014 01  
'1

5 =@ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ
AB
l8 B[ ÿ> ÿ=@j7AV= @‚
f= @= [X`ÿ :ÿB[ i>
«:w q
^
} G ÿE„ÿ|} ÿ ®L ‡
H¬†­O‡ }…KMK†
{
KN‰MK…K ®ÿH…ÿ 
¯®OL ÿ EOE C’E…“
ƒM HDG MO°ÿ O ’O’M
HHM ÿ LKÿ ‘•ÿG ÿ „
±DK
Mÿ
aS6A Bÿ> ÿ:Bÿ=7f:[ ^
7 ÿ@@= [X=:X`> ÿ; =
?
j7A{ O‡ |} ÿ ®L 
:ÿE„ÿ }JKMK†
{
R[ ÿ;a=:
[:ÿ B
¢] ÿ j
^ ;
ÿAX7ÿÿ7:ÿ;> :S 6:ÿ
V 7ÿ =fdh ÿ;ÿ> ÿ;<^
X [ 7
=?] :ÿ ^7ÿAX7 ;:>²
?; >z ÿ :7ÿ B= :
™A X <8
R[ ÿ [:; =ÿ@
[R[ 77> S:<X
‚

\_e‚ W@¥;ÿ ?] @ §³U@
ÿ Sÿ :7 S[ [w ÿ@:
a= > >
ÿ
x zy
Ÿy
vB:?7>vS>dB^ ]ÿ7@V
;@:; ÿ = ÿ;ÿ; BUBÿY
a] @ÿÿ@Bx yy
W w ^=ÿq zy
³
c7f™7Uÿ> W@ ÿ [ ;_; B@S
> ÿ i7 = S[Y7@ ÿ ;W S
P
w
5 :> 76S y zy
=7ÿ ?@ÿ yy
x
5 > S[¦W SXrA Wÿÿ=65 d
@ f@ ÿÿ]Wÿÿ] w v ?ÿ;:
¦
™A:ÿ :x yy
7@Z7ÿ³ zy
V i765 Bÿ ] ÿ >w 7f@
v”> ÿ<=:vSfe775> S
ÿ
v ?ÿk zyx qy
=6x yy ÿ¦ z´
_@7@ÿ;5 >e=@ ÿk o ÿ
S B:ÿ= ÿ :;y k k
`

R[ ÿ;”X
[:ÿ7:
~ L ÿ HÿG —‰ ÿ KG …ÿ LNO
EK’K † ‰ÿ †€“’HK …K MK
–K„µK |K‰ O …ÿ R[[ÿ;ÿ B
M …ÿ ­ —MK
: a=:
x yy
y zy

22
12