Freshub, Inc. et al v. Amazon.Com Inc. et al
Filing 1
COMPLAINT ( Filing fee $ 400 receipt number 0542-12267080), filed by Freshub, Inc., Freshub, Ltd.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Civil Cover Sheet)(Palmer, John)
R IH]>H R NI8Hÿ H;XH ;<;;Tÿ;i = = Hÿ TP 8 R NOH NYP8 H;CHeC E NWDMUÿ ;ÿ DE I>>6ÿM;6 ;
\D
E
[T
W
E
> S
\C ;
C
E N=H9 =ÿ8Tÿ8Dj H<ÿC9><ÿDT6DC C9 ESR J R6 ÿE N DV 68 ÿH ;8ÿ C8 ;8
6 ÿ;ÿ8 DQ >H<ÿH = ;ÿÿ8 ?ÿ <;R EC R ÿ8 <8ÿ EP TÿY8 ? ÿ k6g=>R Cÿ ;Tÿ 8>9ÿ E< N8ÿ N\ 6 8Eÿ 79<6ÿMI>>6ÿM
E J ;8
J
[J
e >
E
5
C
;6 ;E ZDHX>YE ÿ k6g=>ÿ C <8 V = ;DJ>6MHÿ 9E J9
8 ?ÿNMHÿ <ÿ6[IE8 ÿ ;TB6> H ÿ= ;DJ>6ÿ PT><8 ÿH;IEÿJ CV
I>
e
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
!2
12
02 15 6
134 2
789 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(
ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9
6799 ÿ =ÿ @ÿ 9Eÿ?9H JK 9A MEL ?N;M9P=@Eÿ @ÿ7 ÿA RÿA ÿ EA =C@;@ÿA ÿ9 S; ÿ =U99 ÿ @ÿA ÿIÿVF PBCDÿ7OEÿ MR
ÿ:;<79>?ABCDF =ÿIÿ L ÿEÿÿKC?ÿO E9ÿA @C MQ KR9P@9>9@9S? 9 ÿ7@9; >Mÿ T<79 :;>?A@9H 7 ÿ ÿ 9E@ÿCQ?A7 M=9 ÿCK E@ÿÿ7 ÿE9RÿE =ÿ9Tÿ; ÿ7 @7ÿW @S
7 =ZK@N 7 ZK?ÿ=K ÿ7OEÿ MR7ÿ Pÿ;E ; K R<9 @C9\ 9Eÿ C99Q ; ÿA ÿ :9?E 7 @@ÿ@=Fÿ KS 9 R<9EY9 ME TR;=C?AM
?
@ÿ
M
:
C
@9<7@@S; ÿ@9ÿ?A; >ÿ 9EM?ME T: ?9Y;@7 E?Qÿ 9EJEC Waÿ ME ?WE T
9=ÿ =ÿL Kÿ7 E?CÿEMW @?WM =9ÿ @ÿ9 BCDÿPCÿ; ÿ7RÿK R?; C F Dÿ C; ÿ Z9MW; ÿ;
G
M
C
@ BC ?
bC97 @ÿ7 ; R?;ÿ7<7 ? ÿA ; ME9; @R=9 @QMO 7@T7 ÿ?9H JK 9
K @7AR; 9@7 M@ÿ LC O 7 9ÿ=ÿ7ÿK=;CÿK O =9 ÿ;G=ÿIÿ L F
9
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
52
12
02 15 6
134 2
789 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(
ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9
568989 9<7ÿ@BDÿÿ 6GBÿ@9I789 IB ÿ 7 ÿ G Bÿ IÿLA 6<ÿ@ ÿ 6
7 ÿ 8; 6=>? AC A68B 7
A
< E
REA I@ ÿL6ÿBIE GEEA;9Iÿ I=B ÿ6C7EAÿ@ ÿ979ÿ 7 ÿ 8; 6ÿE ÿABE GU V ÿ= @ 9EICA E SG MCT 8989 9 SH6I9CE @ AÿB ÿ @K@ ÿB ÿE ÿE CA @ I89ÿE=CE @ AI6ÿBG F@B Gÿ ?B AÿEÿBÿ= ÿ= @ 9 6ÿDÿ Aÿ@
E9A9<679ÿ ;C79Iÿ> D7; >ÿFG:
78 :ÿ>;? A:9 C ÿ E989;A
OPR
QS
=:ÿ@ÿBI
>;? H>J
T VV
U WV
=:ÿ@ÿBIÿL
>;? H>JK
T VV
K WV
=:ÿ@ÿ N
>;? 5M ;
T X WV
X VV
OQY S\Z]Q_
RZPÿ ^Y
`8Bÿa a ÿ
ÿ6X b 8c
def
`8BÿLÿ B9deÿ BÿM 8 :ÿ6ÿ ÿ X k
ÿ6K `F:ÿ g>hA8 6Bi:dejk a
dejÿ
e6N ÿ A6 k mk a
FG@>>Cÿ ÿ n
dl dejX
`8BÿLÿ B9deÿ BÿM 8 :ÿ6ÿ ÿ X
ÿ6K `F:ÿ g>hA8 6Bi:dejk a
dejÿ
bm
ÿ
e6N ÿ E6
FGM >
bm
ÿ
e6N ÿ 76
FGB A
Xÿ
m
e6N ÿ 76
FGB A
>h6 B6 9ÿ Ch :;ÿ 9 B:
Bÿ8>C F 6 ÿB;C BE 8;
79
>h6 B6 9ÿ Ch :;ÿ 9 B:
Bÿ8>C F 6 ÿB;C BE 8;
79
oZQYQ r ] S
^pqÿsS t P
u PvSwÿyR
]p ^ x QS
RqYyÿzuPÿ
y P^ ÿQS{|
y
u PvSwÿyR
]p ^ x QS
RqYyÿzwS QS
y P^ ÿ xRr
y
{|ÿqwÿ xR
] wS QS
RqYyÿ Y ]^
y P^ ~ÿ^p
}Q
qS ^ÿ QS
}ÿ S]|yR
S Y
yS
rS YÿQS{|
QYqÿyuPÿ
}Q~ÿy Y^
Y Rs]Q S
o^ Yy~
ZSy Y
~S ws~y r
] qS
y] S
YP
PS ] y
ZssyYwÿZwQ
]ÿ ^]
RwZ]p qw
Qu
ÿ pQ
~SqSÿZssyY
Y P Yr P
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
32
12
02 15 6
134 2
789 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(
ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9
mX_ÿM
[ÿM_^
{\ÿÿ x ÿ] jXÿ]Xi
j] fW ]_[n[i _j
Y
68
79
I9J
7KL
QRTUS
S9UR
gQh
6Sl 9
LRJ
o9 R
pSq
I7t
s7
Tuu9LvL
S T77q
LSK
9S L
ST
79
U R
SL
STÿS R
79TuLS
Tpl7 L
S L77q
S
USl 9
LRJ
QSL
RU
uT9
l S
7
7
S
U R
SL
S 9
uLuL
R L
SplU
U R9
SL
:<ÿÿ;=?:@ÿ CDEEÿÿCDEEÿÿCGEEH
;=?:<ÿÿ;=A ;ÿ ?B ;ÿ ?F ;ÿ
B
D ;ÿNAC ÿH
C?9: B@ @ @ 9D;E
7: 6: @ÿ;A ;<ÿ7ÿCDÿ@
ÿ
HIKÿ OJQJ Sÿ SÿN WL YZ IRJ
JLMNPÿ RNJTOUV TJÿX ÿN[
PXWIÿÿJ [W\PRV S_J`WÿMÿJOJ
N SN\]W^ OJÿN LOIÿOJa Y ZP
ÿcd
bd e
f gg ÿ
d hg
ÿ
iU ÿ V S]kWX ÿ JLSÿN WN ÿV LJo
PNj [ÿÿ OlHIKÿNm [ÿTX\JnW
X
kIP
Ln
ÿcp
bb g
f gg ÿ
b hg
ÿ
`Wÿ b ÿL ISTOUHIKÿ X \`Jc sb
OJqrÿsa_Jÿ Sÿ JLqL YoWJÿ ht
b
b u V` Iqrÿ \Imÿdvkc WX h
s s ÿ[I rOVLc ÿ ÿ OJh
ÿ
e wL h
ÿxy b
e cs
f y hg
b gg ÿ
ÿ
iU ÿOno{WL Uo R[OÿNm [ÿSWN
PNzX ÿÿSJRÿO|ÿ \PSÿN W\JJ
\\J
mSR
ÿ}
p
f g hg
b gg ÿ
ÿ
iU ÿ S~Wÿ XÿÿRLS\JnWTOUHIKÿ
PNrNÿ YvJ { WÿV LJÿ Sÿ JLo
e
o
U WN I
LPL
ÿpy s
e cy
f gg ÿ
d hg
iU ÿ[ ÿÿN W[ÿ[
PN{ _o TJI _
\
W^ OJÿN LOIÿP
J [W\PRV S_JiU
ÿcp
be e
f d hg
b gg ÿ
7 +
ÿ 9F
ÿ
ÿ
¢
ÿ
egN SNÿÿSW
hÿ[ÿ}\L\
}\L
ÿSW
y\L
ÿSW
e\L
ÿSW
d\L
ÿSW
b\L
ÿSW
ÿ
ÿ
ÿ
}
e
b
}
b
d
u
b
d
{ JLI[SRJÿ l \
JÿIP\N WO J
ÿ
RL
ÿ
{WL ^ LOm
SJRÿ[ I
S
HIKÿ SlLOX
JLO J WSN
X
MNPÿ Pl OOX
OJQJN XSN
ye
h
yb
h
yb
h
ÿ
ÿÿ
|WÿZP_ ÿ |WÿSP ÿ Z OJPRRL Y ÿ Z OJPXWI ÿ P_J_ K
JSÿ[ J
J\On
NPÿN X \
NPÿN SN
L IÿN
J\ÿN\S ÿ IOlWN ÿ LJLSW ÿ _LnOL ÿ R[U_ SJ
LmSÿJ
OX ÿN R
Z
IKÿ[X
IPÿWY m
PÿJSW
Z OJWPl OOX ÿ J\ÿN[J ÿ Ul IÿJN X ÿ JJ ÿU [ U
NPÿJN XSN
LmSÿ\
OUmWPRRJ Y
ZXSN l
ÿÿ
ÿ ÿ
{ Wÿ RJ
RLSqN
iJSN O\
IPWXP
a {N
MÿU T\
jÿU\L[JU II
\SOÿJSWÿJV[
ÿÿ
eu
h
eu
h
eg
h
\
J
{ LJm [ÿU [ U\TOUNU WP\N W
U WÿN WSN l Sÿ SÿSJÿ[SRJ\
¡N
£ ÿ¥ÿ
¤¦ÿ
ÿ
a VQJOT\
N ÿ ZJ
aK\`N Y
JLÿIN
§ÿ ÿ ÿÿ¨ÿ ÿ
¨ ÿ ¨ ¨ ©
¥
¡N J Jÿc s u
ZR_ W}ÿ b
d
N |l WSN ªOJa [ J «¬ÿ
X [LOXÿWÿMÿ _
`
jXSI YSJX TÿJ\N ÿSJ`WÿMÿ _ ÿU\TJnÿ ÿWZN \\SVTLÿN my a c N m{ [ Y Lc
ÿ \LI ÿU ÿJ ZWOXNÿU ÿOJa [ JSOÿ Jh VJO[ÿJ[ ÿ \{ X ÿ®ÿMÿ X ÿN X _ W
O J
wm
{
qLRN mq[ c n ÿ SLÿX ÿ °XiU h SÿU Sÿl SLIU ÿSJROly PXJ Sj XJ ÿÿNPÿN SNh
W X ÿ _ÿ [¯IWc YHRLN ÿPNÿ USLcÿNÿISJ\WL X ÿ®ÿN SXÿTL SY²Z OJPXWI
QN
L
±O j ÿ
ÿ
a J`WÿMÿ[ JU \SJL OSÿNWVLJeNÿU \ÿJOJÿ W Xc n cPNcNX SWI ÿU YSÿWÿh
U ÿOJa P_ ÿLÿU ÿ_ImSÿJ IPÿÿSNJY ZP\~ RN mÿ [ÿ U \ÿL[LIj L ÿNSmO
O
qL QN i ÿ
mÿ
S
qJJU \_ J ÿ ÿK JOXJ\ÿLª
WÿLÿJXRmJV WJ PÿNWÿ
kLn W[ Yÿ
PlN X ª
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
62
12
02 15 6
134 2
568ÿÿ=8@9ÿ97B
79;<>? 66A9
789 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(
ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9
P ÿ>J ÿL ÿ79T M= 9A;V XC ;ÿ Zÿ 8ÿÿ7; 7ÿ 869ÿ? J <7Jÿ7>;HK89H8>ÿ?8 6
Q =7R89S6ÿUÿ O ÿ7ÿW YC IB;9
@
J
PJ 9 ;
= K 8>7 K;9[;86>87R= ÿL ÿ979ÿ
G ;9ÿ 78HÿI9ÿ98J ÿG89K A>G 69>Y 9>9ÿL Jb R8<ÿ 6 JY 9B7;KI= K; K<698[ÿJ ÿB;ÿG; ÿ= JJ ÿ ÿÿ9 @7=9Y ÿ9K8ÿ9 9<@G9ÿ? 8J >I6G B97RK A<>
? ? 9 8D KP >= ÿJ6J 7R7 ;IBÿ J 8>ÿ J 9 ÿ?K ZJ ÿ? Hf6=79ÿ?ÿ? 6J ÿ979
; ÿ
J
e?
? ÿJ ÿgY 6ÿ <ÿÿHR; KG;ÿ>69G 69 ÿ988ÿ99? Y K >8ÿL
J; Kÿ ÿ [@=L;G= ^J ^H[=9ÿf 97J9ÿ <ÿ@ >6ÿ >J ÿ;[I;ÿ?K AHGÿ ?ÿ?89
? U9
BL Q
h=
>N9K@?9>? L>G 6
?8;6 = J87 ;8
IB;9R6
[
CE FG ? Hÿ? J ÿL>L HIH
DE ÿ9 G9I= K87ÿ9G=
M? Jÿ N9 ?8; =9
@@9 8 G 6ÿO >
c9G=
HIH
Y
7 I
@@[
ijlÿpor uÿ uÿmruj ÿ mt |}rl~
kmo qstvwxu zuÿ px{xrsÿ km
y m
e? 9 9ÿD W V
A@O 6ÿ C
X
M? ZR 68? ]79T M= 9 xkx{ÿ m
J =;7Jÿ6ÿUÿ O r }kox
S
_ DQ ÿG ;7R@[777H97Bÿ6@ÿÿ868ÿÿ86ÿ9; >ÿL ÿ6K <ÿ= G 6ÿ9@ÿ9<9 ÿ=ÿ?@98
?ÿ@ = K 8J ÿ ÿ 8;ÿ A9 I? C>;ÿ?F>;>O <=9;ÿ 9G? =8>G ?88; 6;L K? 88ÿ ÿ?
P
J 6
8
L Hÿ6= H>? 8897>9ÿJ ÿ J ÿI896>R 98? >ZfK897>9ÿB;ÿ;7R;A6ÿK ÿ6O9 8;
9G8? O9L ?ÿL ÿ = D KOÿ 9?ÿL 7ÿ= R >7Jÿ 9 ÿL ÿ = Yÿ >L AJ ÿÿ9[? KG? H@ÿL 8
> ; ?
> P
?K 6G? 6@>L B>7ÿ[ K<8? ÿÿS;76998K86= Le97D ; ÿ?; K?ÿ K8;ÿJ ÿ9 6
H9ÿ6R; ÿ ? ÿ >J 7;7JH96>9ÿ H<9 ÿL? R ÿ 8 fÿ KJ ÿ= 7Y ÿL 8; [J B9
> J
7
>
L
K
G? 6@ÿÿÿ 8 f>69D 7ÿ;9; K?ÿ 86>G ?8L K@98[A6? >; K?>87Rÿ?J ÿA7ÿÿ >
6R; H9;e97ÿ97>ÿ KL Aÿ= 7Y 9ÿ= G 6ÿ; ÿ ÿ6ÿ;7=ÿ= 7ÿ98J >8ÿ?;;H7B;
7
K
`I
D8
Y
7
ZJ H ÿ= R >9 ÿL 8P9 ? 889S6ÿUÿ O ÿ[= G= RJ ÿÿ?ÿW>Y\= >ÿ ;D8B?Kÿ
;H>R 98K8;ÿ6O ?ÿL ÿ79T M= 9O ÿJ HR 7R7I6E ÿ9? KYÿ 9>BL 8ÿÿ 69
[
ÿ
8
_ ÿ 7 ÿ@ÿ9[R; ÿL ÿ>9>6>H9 Dÿ= >ÿ@ÿÿ8Hÿ 67K8;ÿÿ; G J K7ÿL ÿ >ÿH<ÿJ ÿ
?BLH P A6ÿHK897 = Qÿ9?AKÿ ÿR 9>P ;H89B?69 ÿL 87L G 9 9 ÿ 89Z68G;9; KO
9Q
>
;P Q 7
8
J
B? K 6J ÿÿÿ HL G 9 ÿR 7YQ ÿ? J ÿ6@ÿÿ E8;ÿAÿ>KI6ZAÿ96ÿJ ÿ99ÿ; ÿJ ÿ>9ÿ8
J 97R77B7ÿ; G J; ;Jÿ@ <@7RI? ;N? = ÿL 8P9=9 ÿ?ÿ 9[;>; KJ A6L K; [7 = >;
I8 H
P
Q
>
;H f9 8I6899H>ÿ9 @? 8>BL<ÿÿ [P 979 ÿÿ >8@98ÿ9 H<ÿÿJ ÿL = LÿKRAÿL ÿ79T
H9ÿ 8IBÿ JLÿ 7L7BL ÿK ÿ
8
8
Q
M= 9;8[ÿ
O ÿÿ6Y
A6HÿH97ÿJ ÿ@ÿ 6>9 ÿL 8;HL ÿ? H;9 ÿ8gÿ8? R 87ÿ =KL Aÿ6O9 ÿ 8D<= H
9;HP7 ÿ ; K; 7 9>K8;ÿH89<@G7 8K>= PL = Lÿ B? Hÿ;9G? H@>B7Lÿ 8;H
Dÿ 8
@G
ÿ
<
ÿ
8
; [
B?Q ÿ>J ÿÿ; L ÿYÿ6<79ÿ>89L O8;ÿH@[@9 7ÿ979ÿ6ÿ? J <9 ÿ?; K=97>>H
6>ÿ@ =7R;a @; ;CF ÿ99A6;ÿL ÿ= ÿL 8;H ÿ K;K A<>;9ÿ ÿ?9
P
ÿ
8
cP =G 88ÿÿ; = RT Y 9;B7ÿ=J? ÿJ ÿI89>f@9 7ÿ979ÿL Aÿ? J <9 ÿ?7DJ ÿAJ
ÿ 8=ÿ?;_ @>J ÿUÿ fÿ H86ÿJ; [?ÿL ÿ7ÿ K;K A<>P ;9
@?97 6>79ÿ 9;7ÿ 8HR JÿJ = L8ÿ?@G7K8 ^76Kÿ? J >ÿ9DI@[9 86ÿ[8@ÿÿL 8
6ÿ 9>AD fÿ 7 9H 9 89 ? R ÿ?K ÿ7 H ÿB?899 <@@; KDYY7ÿ ÿJ79>>9 7>=
@G
`H >J 7
9
7ÿ
6
KN9ÿÿKP Hÿ 8ÿL ÿ? @ÿJ ÿ;D`HfD H[89L ÿ 69? >6Y 79D8 ? ÿL 87ÿ >ÿ >
? ;;@?ÿ 7 ?896? ; K>[ÿ 9;ÿ ;ÿL ÿ 9;AH=ÿ >ÿ >H ÿÿJ B>8;ÿ @=8Z68
BJKJ ÿ9 J
B;
G
T
; 7
8
F WG ? Hÿ? J ÿL>L HIH
F ÿ9 G9I= K87ÿ9G=
M? Jÿ N9 ?8; =9
@@9 8 G 6ÿO >
c9G=
HIH
xou ÿx rwm
x ÿuÿ kx
568ÿÿ=8@9ÿ97B
79;<>? 66A9
,9ÿ '
+ÿ
ÿÿ ¢£
¡ÿ
9
,&
7 ÿ
789
4ÿ
¤2ÿ
¥9
789 ÿ 2+
%
ÿ789 ÿ ÿ
9 ÿ
8
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
¦§ ¦ ÿ ¢£
¨ ÿ ©¡ª«ÿ
0789
ÿ
ÿ
0 49,
# ÿ ÿ 9
ÿ
2
0789 ÿ 89
ÿ
$9
ÿ
0 02+ ÿ
¬ ÿ ÿ789
ÿ
0789 ÿ
ÿ
,
ÿ
0 7' ÿ
¬ ÿ 'ÿ789
ÿ
, ÿ7
+89 ÿ
9
7¬ ÿ
2 ÿ 4 +
04 ÿ
ÿ #
¼ ÿ
0 3
®§ ÿ © °±
¯ °§ ® ÿ ²³´£
789 ÿ 9ÿ ÿ & 99
¥ 90 ÿ
789 * 0ÿ
+8ÿ 9
789 ÿ ÿ
,9
789 * ' ÿ µ
+8ÿ 9
ÿ
0 'ÿ
ÿ 4
ÿ '9
939+
ÿ
¥ ¬ ÿ
9 ÿ ,99 +
789 ÿ +ÿ
( 2
¶ÿ ÿ ¸ º
¢£·¹ÿ³
¬ ÿ +
7+
¬ ÿ
/
0' &¥9ÿ 4
' ÿ »ÿ
+
789 ÿ
4
8
¥ÿ ¥ +8
»ÿ '9
39 9 ¬ ÿ ÿ 2+
& ÿ ÿ %
9
789 ÿ 9
7
$'
2 12
52
02 15 6
134 2
789 ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 99 ! #9$% 8&8 ÿ(
ÿ ÿ 7 ÿ ÿ"ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9'9
5
&
ÿ
#0
ÿ 9
7898ÿÿÿ
3 +
0 8
9 ÿ
789992&
79 ÿ
ÿ
ÿ +
ÿ ÿ
789ÿÿ&2ÿ
%
9
ÿ
0 9
'
8ÿ
0+ÿ ÿ
76
ÿ
, 6
, ÿ
9ÿ
78ÿ 64 ÿ
ÿ
7 ÿ &
79 7
ÿ
7+ 9 ÿ 9( ÿ
+
789ÿÿ ÿ
,
52 ÿ
( &
789ÿÿ
ÿ
;+ 7ÿ
3
789
9ÿ
;
0'/ ÿ
ÿ
$ ÿ6ÿ
802+
ÿ
$9 '+ 4 ÿ
789ÿ
ÿ '
=
% ÿ + 9ÿ
& 5 9
9
789ÿÿ'ÿ
<9
ÿ
ÿ
78929 ÿ
ÿ
< 9
(
ÿ ÿ 8ÿ
ÿ &
ÿ
: ÿ
,
ÿ
789ÿÿ ÿ
9 ÿ 2+
0
0+ ÿ
99
&02+
8' ÿ
ÿ
59 ÿ
ÿ
%9
% 3 @ÿ
& ÿ
9
ÿ
789 ÿ ÿ
4
# 4 ÿ 9
ÿ 0& ÿ
8
9ÿ
ÿ 4
8
<&
ÿ
ÿ
089 8
ÿ ÿ
$
0ÿ
+(0(8
& & ÿ8
9 +
<ÿ: ÿ
& ÿ %
7ÿ 7ÿ 9ÿ
> , 6ÿ /
ÿ ÿ
&
7 ÿ 89 +
4
9 ÿ
+
789
8ÿ
=9
9
(
,6ÿ 'ÿÿÿ
%
6 (
, 9
ÿ
%(9
ÿ
2
; ÿ
9
0 &
&ÿ ÿ
A
7ÿ &
"
4 ÿ % +ÿ
ÿ
8
ÿ
% ÿ
39 59(
ÿ
ÿ
9ÿ
, 62 ÿ
ÿ
7ÿ 9
+88
0 ' ÿ
'
%
& ÿ
9 ÿ 9
,
B& ÿ 'ÿ
7' ÿ
0 8ÿ"ÿ
9 ! ÿ
ÿ (< 8
52ÿ
< ÿ ÿ 09(7
9 8 7ÿ ÿ
8
ÿ 9
ÿ
9
$9 ' ÿ 99
' ;
,ÿ ÿ ?ÿ
/+ÿ
3
3
ÿ 2
,ÿ %99
/+ÿ
= ÿ
3%
3ÿ
2
ÿ
7ÿ
789 ÿ
99 ÿ
;9ÿ 9 ÿ
ÿ
%
A (#4 +
9ÿ ÿ
0 ÿ
+ ÿ 789 ÿ
%+27ÿ(
ÿ ÿ
+
ÿ2+
'
7ÿ+
+
<
+
8ÿ
8 &ÿ
(
ÿ
9
% 8
&ÿ +
9
= 4ÿ
3%
;ÿ ÿ 9 ÿ
58
=
4 ÿ
9B
9 ÿ 396
ÿ ÿ
789$ ÿ
Cÿ 9
+
;+ÿ
(0
4496
+ÿ
4 +ÿ 8'
989(0
39 59(
ÿ
6ÿ&
ÿ ÿ
0'4ÿ ÿ
9
9 +
= ÿ &
4 ÿ
9
ÿ ÿ
+9
9ÿ 9
%4<ÿ
2
39 59(
ÿ
%
&ÿ
9
4 &9
' (
=% ÿ
ÿ &ÿ &
94
39 59(
ÿ
<55ÿ %(
4 ÿ ÿ
2
ÿ (9ÿ
52 (= 8
"% +ÿ ÿ
ÿ &
4
9
D
ÿ
% ÿ ÿ
99 ÿ
0 &
9 9
789 ÿ ÿ
<
< ÿ +
' ÿ
ÿÿ 9
99(
4 ÿ ÿ
B
8
E9 '
' ÿ
0 ÿ
7ÿ
&
789 ÿ + ÿ 9 + ÿ
0
49 ÿÿ
ÿÿÿ9 ÿ
&2ÿÿÿ
9+ ÿ
ÿ 49(B = 7 2 6 5 6ÿ
+8* ÿ
ÿ
# +ÿ ,9 ÿ Fÿ6 04 2 * ÿ +ÿ ÿ9
2
+
789
= 9
1 9
+81',5 6 6 -. 21 0341
)*89 * 1 3 2 3 /%014 01
'1
212
22
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.