Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 94

NOTICE by Motorola Mobility, Inc. of Filing Brief on Claim Construction (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Affidavit)(Giuliano, Douglas)

Exhibit 19
to Motorola’s Opening Claim Construction Brief
July 28, 2011

Webster's
Third
New International
Dictionary
O F THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE

UNABRIDGED
REG. U. S. PAT. OFF.

Utilizing all the experience and resources of more than
one hundred years of Merriam- WebsteP dictionaries
EDITOR I N CHIEF

PHILIP BABCOCK GOVE, Ph.D.
AND
THE MERRIAM-WEBSTER
EDITORIAL STAFF

MERRIAM-WEBSTER INC., Publishers
EXHIBIT 19

SPRINGFIELD, MASSACHUSETTS, U.S. A.
PAGE 1

Merriarn-~ e b s t en is the M ~ You ahodd look for whm you
r
E
books it
the purdasc of didionarie or Otherfine
me
the
publishing
reputation of a company that has
1831 and is your
assurmce ofq~al'tty authorw.
and

fibraryof mngress ~ a t d o & g m l i a t i o n Data
Main entry under title:

@ 8 ~ ~ ~ - 2 0 1 - lsmite).-IsB~ P87779-m2-x
(blue
-.
1
ISBN 0-87779-7-2 (impend buckram)
1 Endish l~pgYIDi~tiOnan~. I. GWC PhiliP ~ a d c , k ,
.
1902-1972. 1 . ~ernam-webste~,
1
Inc.

-

PE1625.W36 1993

EXHIBIT 19
PAGE 2

desertion

descent
mrfm ' m+ym (it a p p a n that the water is broken

-

noyhueSby s p k m g against the rock% and that thcrdorc !he
ts r p e n d t c u b r -Anthony Trollope) b : a descendmg
way as a downgrade o r stairway) C obs :the lowest part
o
and dust
(from the extremat upward of t h r head t the
6 a
a sudden dixonc+,ng
below thy foot -Shak.)
of hts Inappearance (as for a vtdt) (unprepared for the
of the
laws) b ' a hostile n i d o r redatory assault (the
~syrianLupon
Israel) (- o f t h e locusu) 6 :a step downward in a scale of gradation' speclJ, :one seneration in an
ancutral lineor genealog&al La, e ( h s e l g r c e s h o w 11 -s)
7 :a former method o! d~sllllattonan whlch the matenal waa
heated in a v&
havtng IU outlet underneath so that the
vapors produced were forced to descend
scent (n.)] : to rid of scent
Ideascant \ )dqrent\ vt [den. Enalirh law :the descent of an edtste to an
dement
heir by the death of one who held it adverse1 to the real
owner which rior to 1833 barred tee latter's rtgtt of entry so
that he f o u l 1 recover only by rutnlt - comnarc Aovmw

.

--

+

CBd;

refa- mjustice, dewadation (thcy have been to arcseasfully &&shed from c n i t i d m l u a t i n and rhcot.ticaf 9 a :
rinr to. constituting o r concerbcd with empirical tbinps o r rensltlzed that they arc unable to recognize the most obvious
b c t s -Alfred Kantomwicz) 6 :to f m (as by psycbotherevcnu o r with thctr parts. characteristics, or functions (expres?om) (- disciplines) b : factually grounded or m- apy) of the emotional charge investing a complex
formauve rather than nonnative, prcscnptive, emotive, le.sensitizer \"+\ n :a desensitizing agent: as a :a drug
which makes it possible
that reduces sensitivity to pain (a
aprioristi-+ or analytical (- judgments) (- theories) (that
thlr mcanlng shall be called "-'' whcn the responses evoked to drill and fill tceth painlessly -Jmdurrrlol & E n rneerinfl
are cognitions and shall be called "emotive" when the re- Chemistry) b :a c h c ~ i c e l(a! a dye) that reducca $ s m s r
of
to
sponres evoked are attitudes -Asher Moore) 3 a of o modi- u v ~ t y a photographsc mater~al radiation
uru
leg.er.et \:dcta:rel, usu -ed.+V\ 4, cop [fr. D e e r
[yina word: ex resdn the quality, kind, or condition of w?at
!s denoted by t i c modlified term <hot in "hot water" and stck nnckname for the state of Utah and from 1849-1850 offtcral
In "a sick man" are
adjecttves)
distinguished from Mormon name for the Utah territory fr. dcseret honeybee,
coined in the Book of Mormon (Ether i:3)1 :of or from Utah
territory o r the state of Utah
dea.en \'deza(r)lt, usu Id-CV\ n -s [ME. fr. OF. fr. L L
.
deserturn. fr. .I neuL of desenlu. nast Dart. of deserere t o
duert, fi. de- i- srrere to join t6iether.more at m l m l
compare CoMPARAnyE 41 5 :char- 1 a nrchnic ! a wild uninhabited and uncult~vatedtract :a
grammar) (a 7 study)
.
or cmrt or athleu woodland
acterized by ktnshlp name clarser that apply m part only to d&istc unoccuptcd 13"
:Y*ILDERMSI. w m
any of the formerry unsettled reuons
lineal rclaliva (as grandfather father son grandchild) and in
part only to collateral relati;es ( a r ' u n c k cousm. nephew) of the U. 5 between the MlsrisllDPl r l v a and the Rocky moun.
regardless of the ru of the connecting relatives (regarded most
European systems as
and those of primitive peoples as
classificatory -R.H.Lowie)
- compare n*JslrtcAToRY
- de.scrip.tive.ly \-tlvll, -li\ ndv - de.mrip.the-ness
of a conunent and characterized byscanty rainfall a p of lesa
\-t5vn*\ n -ES
Bdesc,fiptive \'\,n -s :n distinctive word. phrase, or wntmce than 10 inches annually) b :a more or lczr harren tract rncanabic of supwruna any cons~daable
~opulal8on
wltnout an
appltcd to a part~cular
product in advertisin&
ariificial watcisuppli C: an area of an ocean believed to be
descrlpvve nnat0my.n :anatomy dealtng with the character.
devoid of marine lnfe 3 :a secluded lacefor secretworship
form stze and osltton of organs and parts
n
desc&ptivh b i b l ~ g m p I y :a bibliagraphical record in com- by the Huguenots durinq the years 1#5-1802 when Protesin
plete detail of the ph s ~ c echaracteristics and puhlishin&his- tantism was under arorer~ntion France 4 :a dcrolatinrr or
l
tory of the books ora.re!ated s ~ i e properly including an forblddtng provpr;t (afrom pathless empuners. bleak
s
ac.wunt of internal prlntlng varlanls requtsltc for textual rrleevcd changclcrsnar or monotony, fut~lrty 01 effort. or
dcst~tutlon of mental or sptntual anrma?ton or samulauon)
CIIIlcISm
of darknus -Beverley
bEscriptive b o t a n y n :a branch of botany dealing with the (ton figures lost in an immense
(lost in a
of doubt) (eagle still soar between the
svrt~matiedacrintion o r din~nostic
characters of plants
brary rocedure by which a summit of Parnassus and the Corinthian gulf, but they look
hook or other Item iq identified and Bucrrbed by m o r d ~ n down unon a
of human historv -Mark Van Doren)
des.ertr\" in sense 1 usu Nkc ID&T\
ad1 [ME fr O@ fr. L
mrint. and collatton-contrast4
desertus] i archarc :D E S ~ ~ E D
(the boat deck &n;utt&ly
.
with su6jcct corologinx . .
OescriDhve geometrs n :the theory of gecmctw treated by -Waldo Frank) 2 a:daolate and sparsely occupied or unmeans of projections. JWCIJ ' the theory of projectink an w- occu ied ' INHOSPITABLE (so a country as the Highlands of
L
Smith) b : uncultivated and unlnhabited
actly defined body 'so as i o deduce both projectrve and ~ c o t E n d ~ d a r n
:barren like a dwerl (o"c could scarcely find a more tract
metrical ptopertia from its pr,ojections. the projections usu.
for a wtder) 3 :h a v ~ n g habitat tn a . d a u t (- flora and
its
being made on two planed at nght angles to each other
Ee.scriP.UV-ism \-tb.vinm\ n -s 1:a theory of ethics accord- fauna) 4 :peculiar to or adapted to ltfe In a d e s m (sturdy
Ins to wh~ch
only descriptiveor empirical statements arc mean- boots)
ingful 2 : advocacy or use of the methods of descriptive de-sert \dl'nrlt. dl'-. -r5l.-zail. nsu Id.+V\ p -s [ME deserte.
fr. OF fr. fern. of deserr (past part. of deservrr to deserve), fr.
linguistics
de-scriR.tivdst \:v%l\
n -s 1:an advocate of dwcriptivism L der&vltus. osst oart. of deservire to scrvc zea10ud~- more
1
at DE~ERVEI'a i the quality or fact of bein6 woithy o! o r
2 :a specialist in descriptive linguistics
deservine of rewards or recomacnm o r of reaurtal or nuntshde.scrip.tiv:i?.Uc
\.:a-,vtstik\
adj :of, relating to, or based
is &entially ~nddinablee k e t in
o n d ~ r ~ p t t v t s- de.aDIiQ-tiv4!5.ti.CBI.ly \-tL(a)lF\ odv men1 (t6e concept of
m
terms of exnttng practicer and ideas -0.H Sabme)
:s
de.scnp.tor \dl'akripta(r) also -,t6(a)r pr .*(a)\ n -s [L
of
describer. fr. L dercriptvr -or1 : ~dent~fytngugn s y m b 2 c o m ~ l e x actions callinn for such rehlrns (in the midst is
an
or
s
be.scriQ.to.ry \-t(a)rE\ n - ~ [ L descseriptus E -ory] : DE- seated Justice to award t o i a c h according to his --Carleton
Brown) 2 a :rcward o r punishment deserved or eamed by
scRtPnvE
our
Ee-scrip.tnm \d6'skriptam dF1-\ n pl desCII~.ta \-la\ [L, one's qualities o r acts (not wc~ghtng -s but pardontng o u r
offenses -Missole Romanurn) (by dint of much caballing and
fr ncut. or descrl rust pasi part. 01dwribere t o describe
much dwelling u on his own -s he triumphed over hls cnembre at DrscRlsEPpht~or:something that is described
de.scfive \da'skriv. -rEv\ vt -ED/-!w/-s [ME descriren. fr. O F mia-Virsinna $oolf> b deserts .I! awards dueforsuMrior
dercrivre. fr. L describerel Scot DESCRIBE (let me fatr Na- or $"feriri;~u;~r~tu dr & i G - i n r k & s n s h i p (book re,bwcrs
. frequently p r a m the l i n t venture of a wrrter beyond ID
ture's face -Robert R,amr\,
-ldes.crv \djtskri. dT-\ vt .ED/-INO/-s [ME descrien. h. O F just -s -Harrison Smith) 3 : worthmess or excellence of
descriei to proclaim, decry more s t DE?RV] 1a :tospy out character as adduced by a good course of conduct (he won the
rather than throuah family
or come to see a p with watch!ul attention and careful ob- ao~ointmenton mounds of
secvatton of thc drrtant, uncertaon, or obscure (the grass war piistire> m - o u r
desert \"\ vb -ED/.INO s [ F d(l~rter. fr. LL desertare. fr. L
htnh in the meadow. and there was no -in* her -Gmrnc
derertus, past part. of k s e r e m to d a e R - more at WFSEUTI
rt 1 :to withdraw from or l a v e aermanentlv or less often
tcm%arily (as a place) :~ u k ( f a r m & scontinu; to the land
to take up factory work) (the smile -in# his broad face
the memory -T.S.
-T.B.Costain) (phrases which never
Eliot) 2 a :to turn away from (what has previously engaged
~dWCIY -ES obs :discovery o r view from ifar
n
one) u p . by withdraw,ing~rupportor disrupting bonds of
d e - s m \ O d e + \ vt [descum (n.)l :to rid of scum
Ew.cu-ram-in \ deka'SnZo dZk-\ n cop [NL, fr. F r d s attachment o r duty :reject In order to take up something else
(who 30 years before upon beln -ed by .her
N L cia] :a qenus of annual : ABANDON
Ddscounrln t174b Fr. b o t a n s
(comtng al
or biennial herbs (family Cruciferae) of Amertca and Europe lover had taken ;o her bed - - ~ a r b r e t ~ e l a n f )
the Prohibition party) (he -ed prose for the comdiffering from memben of the genus Sirymbrivm in having a last to
pubescence of stellate or forked hairs and commisinn the g e y t i n g rhythms of poetry -Tyrus Hillway) b :to leave
. ehrnd or give up (as a person) - used with to (forced 10.iansy mustards - see TANSY MUSTARD
the m t of the miners to lhetr fate) C :to renounce manta1
Be-seam \(')dE+\ vt [de- reom (n.)] :to chip out or fl?me.
cut seams o r other similar surface defects from (stmitintshed relations by quitting the eom ny of (one's spouse) 3 a :to
break away from or break oP?-iation
wtth (some matter
metal)
involving legal or moral obligatzon or some object of loyalty)
Be.sea.son.+im
\dj.~q(~)na,l-%dF-\ vr[dcseasonal
: B ~ A (not propose to the 100-year-old Monroe DocY
-ire] :to adjust (as an tndustry) to conttnuons rather than
trjnc-A.H.Vandenberg
tl951) (would be n calamity if t h v
seasonal o cratlon
1aes.e.craPe \ ~ e e + r s t . -lea-, usu-zd.+v\ rt - i n / - t ~ o / s ~ d e - wlencea -ed the ideal of accurate and verifiable syslematrc
D :to abandon
-secrate (as in consecrate, v.)] 1 a :l o violate the sanctity knowledge for its o,wn sake -M.R.Cohcn)
(milnary service) w~thoutIcave :forsake In nolation of duty
of by divertine from s a d purpose by contaminating, o r ,
~
defilinp (thev desecrotcd theshnne outnnht- barnainln~ 1 % (autltv of -in= his fellow soldiers) 4 : to dron away o r
the MG~lcm
merchants -Tame) (11 wourd
the Ltncolz Memortal to ha\e an obrrously false votce speak from the statue
there-N Y . Tlmcr Mox )<the qutvertnn host whose house has
been profaned and whose religion desecrated-W.L.Sullivan)
h :to divest of sacred character or treat as unhallowed (many
cemeteries e r e desecmrcd) 2 archoic :to dedicate (someone
o
or oomcthinnl l false pods l condemn to an evil fate 3 :to
treat (an o b h t d ven;rat~on reverent devoclon. or adm~ra(lo") lrrevercntly or contempt;ously oftcn tn a way to provoke
outragcon the onrtof others (lhtsl nreat memory .has been
deseciated. . . -Margery AIiinhim) (Amerkans love the
scenic outdoors, and they do not want to see it desecrated
4 : to make d a o l s t e (churned up
-R.LNeuberger)
lawns and drives and desecrated houses with their broken
windows - ~ . ~ . ~ . k a i s
. m r a t c (as in corueIdes-e-crate \-.krat. -&St\ adi [dccrate adj.)] ' W E ~ A W
les-e:wat.er70r des-e.cra.tor \-,krid.o(r)\ n -s :one that
desccrata
the
nU
1es.e.cra.Uon \ .s'krZshan\ n s 1: act o r t n i r m of
deKuat8np (1 Lave heard this c h o w sung tn a umfonn
-Warwid;
fortiuimo right from the beginnins. What a
Bratthvaite) (the United Natiom ma8 of Authority may be
subtect to -a
World F ~ Encw.) 2 :the condition of beinn
P

-

-

-

-

9:

-

-sun-

-

--

N~X~I~)

-

-

--

-

+

9

-

+

-

-

.

...-

..

-

-

-

-

+

+

-

+

+

:ESPY. PEICEIV. ..
de-s&b-er \ - b a ( r y a y
that dcscribc~ 2 Brit :an
instrument (livinp details about trains moving or scheduled to
move between mven m i ---nu
per,.i

?-ze

P-;~

des.cri.er \dj'skri(o)r dP-, - \ : w that dacriu
3n -s o
deSUiea pres 3d sing 0) IKKXY
de.s&pl \ d ~ % k r it. ( )~z.s-\ ad] [L drrriphrr past part of
drscri&ml 1 ar&lc :&sauna 0 archaic :;~ocru.e~
deWXiQtP 1 oJ D . X R ~ P ~ U M
d e - s w l p t l b n \dl'skripshan dF-\ n 4 [ME dcscripdoun f r
M F o r L; MF dc.rrip!ion ' fr. L description-, descrlptia' fr:
the
dr~r:lptnr Jon-. -lo -3onj 1: act o r an Instance o / d r
scnb~ng: a : dtscrihingor a represcnuuon roducep by a
aa
a
d-ibtng
of lomething material o r tmrmtenal &of t h ? w is
a mode o f classification which in turn furnishes matffnl for
(the meuculous
a more eacral classification -V.F.lcnzen)
S.
I
of t L rocks d u c h of the Pnlcozoie svstems -Am*?.
l ; . 0 s C ( i C l ) ( i & d i ; a I Oi0 iurdGe.i&i~OOltin~ i
o): 1
.!
hii
pictura both enable o o r to say "so that*%what he's,lrkc"
smcll : c o m m i t i o n intended ~romnnlyto
-J.M.Shona):
m
p-nt
to @i i d o r imagiiation graphically i n d in detail
f
a untt of ob~ecuve suhtscuve a a a ~ e n c c u r scene. -n.
or
scnwuon A o u o n ) tn t&tbooks in disuncu~ihtnga
acpuate itwary genre. EOmpre a n o s m o N (11 is the urpose
of auch - that cxolains why thnr t y ~ t c a mcrtU and femnnu
s
l
arc what Ih+lr are 2 namelyl rr$ctr&, minuteness accuracy
(L:
detail fullnsketchiness. misleadinnncrs - ~ . ~ . i o u l m i n
K. Biicr) b f a r m t m c ~ t o fthe proptrues of a thing or i u
relations to o h t h i w raving to tdentify it :,a u n t v w l
desiplruuon of .a object by m a n s of a phrasz beslnntng with
the or a as ?be present king of the Eklplanr" or "a house next
to mv ohice") c :a d e u r i ~ t i w
statanent or account oftcn
mntnsled m t h anolyrl, and ralvarion d :an individualizing
o r ident~frinp
daignation (as 8 name, l a e l , epithet) (the
"wax" u B misnomer since tho substancc~safar-J.N.Goldsmith) 1 o h a :nscnIPnoN b :ONROLLMEHT 3 :kind or
c h a n a e r e d ~ M d e t ~ m i n e dby salbent features (each state
.
mar still confer them upon an alien. or.. .upon any class or
-of pasons -R.B.Taney) (oppqsed to any lax of w radical
a -) 4 obr r pictorial reprMntatlon S a :a tracing out of a
geometrical f i p r e b :a traversing of a epurse (the rocket's
of a hi@ arch~ng
curve) 6 ; specificatton of the boundariu
8
a v
aoeurscv for l e d ournoses
of 1 ~ ~ of h n d wath r u f f r ~ e n t
$ y i i ~ ~ m r t n agdeed of transfer) sgllS&e n ~ i
on.lst \-sh(a)n*t\
n -s 1 :one proficient In d o
scrrption 2 :oucrlprrvtm
de.scrip.tion-le9. \-rhanlk\ 4 :being wtthout description
be-s&PUo W-so-lue \dS'rkriDshFd~~lr)'s5~.>nn [L
n
dacription o? the m n l . : matt& mo&ly'desc;ibtivi of ihe
m of the p a n i u and not cascntial to the validity of a
=document
- m m p a p D f S R j N A m P-NAE
Ide.mrlD.tlv0
\dd'sknnt~v. dle-. -tZv o l r ~-tav\ ad! f L L
di&riprZ~&~ir d & r r & n ; +--ivw -iv;j-1 :&vii<ddc~
scribe : cha;acteri+cd by description : representational
thmunh wesentation of obauved facu (a m~nutaanatomh l and ndknerally
a.ccount of thc.hrpc fulvow orangutan -B.A Poc) (oul~utung formattonr, h a w been given
nama: the Devil's Chair it 80 f a t ht& -Amer. CPrlda
poetry -Yvor W i t a s )
distinSeries: Mlnn.) (purely

+

-

+

-

.

.

+

-

-

-

. . . . ... -. .
.
. .. .

eaert date n :s r m
eserted ad1 :left without the accwtomed aecumncr cornpan or support :AIJANK~D@Dr s + r a n ( f o u ~ d
m
shelrw in..
-stack) <stood there, mouon/ess wtthout d a m I ~ k e ah1
a
at sea.
of all winds -~.I'.&th)
- de-serf-ed-h a!
d

-

-

+

i & - i r : i Jeserro; fr. d e b r u t
&j one who iorsakts a
dut;. acaure, or anyone to whom heow&tervice; erp: a m e m
b a of a mtlitary force who deserts
esert fever or d e s e r l rheumatism n :a mild form of uw.
c~dioidomycorirresrmbling ~nflucnra
c s e n lox n 1:a fox (Vulpcr irucopur) of the wa(ern d a a N
?f Asia 2 :the ktt fox (Vulwr mocmtlr) of the southwedtM

-

-

-

-

-

-

+

U.b.

esert gum n : any of several trcer of the -nus Eucalyptus
(csp. E. rudls)
low anltbush (Atridex b m m e l y ~ r a ) arid
of
esert holly n
reg~on*of the:&uthvestcrn U.S. and Mextco ytth smooth
blulnh grcen o r silvery.prickly-edged foliage that 1s often used
for Chrutmas decorallon
e.+tic
\d('nrd?k, de'-\ ad] :belonging or p c u l i i r t or
o
havtna the dtsttncttvc character of a desert (the red
hills
d o t t d wlth junlper -D.C.Pcattic)
:found in a desert (a
roil ma be rich In nutrients) (a
climate)
a , [jdesert
d
-Iea.er.dc.o.10~
\:dw(r):ttkalss\
.coleus] : dwelling in a desert
B.8er.tiOlt \d5'wlshan dF'- -231 -z*I\ n -S[bW' Or LL' b W
fr LL descrton- deserko & desertus us
-ion- -lo'-ionJ
1': th6 act or an instance df d-ting:
a :a b a n d o b e n t of a

-

+

+

-

EXHIBIT 19
PAGE 3

-+