Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 94

NOTICE by Motorola Mobility, Inc. of Filing Brief on Claim Construction (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Exhibit, # 16 Exhibit, # 17 Exhibit, # 18 Exhibit, # 19 Exhibit, # 20 Exhibit, # 21 Exhibit, # 22 Exhibit, # 23 Exhibit, # 24 Exhibit, # 25 Exhibit, # 26 Exhibit, # 27 Exhibit, # 28 Exhibit, # 29 Exhibit, # 30 Exhibit, # 31 Affidavit)(Giuliano, Douglas)

Download PDF
Exhibit 8 to Motorola’s Opening Claim Construction Brief July 28, 2011 091014.300 Office A c tion Summary IXI Flesponsive to communication Is) filed on ,M!!!!'",18C,J']9~9~8~_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ _ o This action is FIN AL. o Since this application is in condition for allowance except lor l armsl matters. prosecution lIS to the merll s Is closed In eccordlnCI with the prectiee under Ex PUflt! QU8yle, 1935 C.O. 11 ; 453 O.G. 213. A shortened stat utory pariod lor response to this aClion is set to expire 3 month(s). or thirty days, whichever is longer, from the mliling date of this communication. Failure to respond within the pei'iod lor response w ill cause the application 10 become abandone(l. (35 U.S.C. § 133). ExtenSIons of time mav ba obtained under the provisions of 37 CFFI 1.136(1). DI$OOSIllon of Claims (81 Clalml s) "C _______________________ is/are pending in the application. -2,,--' Of Ihe above, clalm(s) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ __ il /ara w ithdrawn from consideration. o Oaimb) IS /Ire allowed. iKI Claimls) ' ·21 Isl are reiected . o Claim[s) isl ere Objected to. o Claims are subject to restr lClion or eleclion requirement. Application Papers IX! See the atteched Notice of Draftsperson 's Patent Dlawing Rev iew. PTO·948. o The drawlng(s) filed on o The proposed drewing correction, filed on isfera objected 10 by Ihe Examiner. IS Dpproved O:Hsapproved. o The specification is Objected to by tha Examiner. o The oath Of deciaration is objected to by the Examiner. Pl'lorilV under 35 U.S.C. t 119 Acknowladgement is made of a cll im for foreign prOorltv under 3S U.S.C. t o D All 0 Some - D None 01 J 19(I H dl. the CERTIFIED copIes of the prloritv documents have been o received. o leceived In Application No. [Seri es Cod e/Serial Number) _ _ _ _ __ _ _ o received in this natiOllar stage ap;:llication from the Intarnational BUl8au (PCT Flule 17.2Ia)). - CertIfied copies not received: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ __ __ _ __ o Acknowladgement is m~de ol a claim lor domestic priority ul'\der 35 U.S.C. , Attachmen t(sl X Notice 01 Fleferences Cited, PTO·892 X Inl ormallon Disclosure Statement(sl, PTO·1449, Paper NO/51. o Int",vlew Summary, PTO·413 1 19Ie). 5,6 IKI Notice 01 Draftsperson's Patent Drawing Review, PTO·948 o Notice ollnfolmal Patent Applica tion, PTO·152 _ SEE OFFICE ACTION ON THE FOLLOWING PAGES .. • Y,I. ·..."' .... T_"'''.. ~. PTO·326 [Rev. 9·95) Olfice Action SummlllV EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 1 Part of Paper No. 7 " Applicaiion/Control Number: 09074300 Page 2 Art Unit: 2787 '. DETAJLED ACTION Drawings 1. This application has been filed with informal drawings which ate acceptable for examination purposes only. Forma1 drawings will be required when the application is allowed. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102 2. The following is" quotation oflhe appropriate paragraphs of35 U.S.C. 102 that fonn the s basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action: A per$OIl shall be entitled 10 ~ p!llent W1Icss- (e) !he invention was deJaibed in a potent granted on lin application for polcnt by another filed in the Uni ted Slalts before the invention lheroofby the Ipplicant for petcnt. or on an inlernatiOllol application bY another who has fulfilled the rupillements of paragraph! (I). (2) ••nd (4)ofseclion 31J(c) pfthillitle bc(ClnIlhc invention theroofby the applicant for palent. 3. Claim 1 is rejected under 35 V.S.C 102~ as being unpatentable over Hendry et ai, U.S. Patent No. 5,682,529. As per claim I, Henry teaches a display management architecture that detects changes in a ' display environment and notifies software programs as well as application programs of the changes in order to adjust them accordingly (Abstract). The display management architecture includes a display manager (Cover element 22) that comprises .o ne part of the computers operating system (Cover element 18)(C2 L 45-50), This display manager continuously receives infonnation from the drivers regarding the display capabilities, and provides reconfiguration EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 2 Application/Conuol Number: 09074300 Page 3 Art Unit : 2787 services to other software within the computer (C2 L6 1-67 and C4 L36-40). Whenever a change in change in configuration is detected, a notification is sent to the display manager (C6 L4-6). A change may occur from connecting or disconnecting a device, such as a video device in the form o fa video card (Cover element 14) from the computer (C6 L9- 12), or from insertion or removal from a docking station or from (he pivoting of a video device such as a monilar from a portrait position to a landscape position (C6 L12-14). In response to the notification, the display manager rearranges the display space based on new configuration information. Once the new configuration has been established, the display manager determines which objects in the display space needs 10 be reposilioned on the display device or screen (C6 L39-46). Information is provided to the operating system and other software programs by the display manager, in response to any changes in configurations (C5 L55-60). Qoim Rej«tion:r _ 35 USC § 10J 4. The following is a quotation of35 U.S.C. 103(a) which forms thc ba~is for all obviousnesll rejections set forth in this Office action: (.) A pe\cnlllllY lICIt be obtained though \he in\lallion is not identit.lUy disclosed or dacribcd n sct rorth in KCtion 102 01" this til1e, irlhe differeoocs betwcm \he subjoo;t mII\1Cf .oo.Iih11Q be pltmted UM! the prior art are IIICb that tiE ~ matter as a wbole ....wld have bo:cn otMow at !he time the inwllIion was InIIOc to a penon tI,ovingordinarysk:ill in Ihc 111 to which said subjo<:l maner pertains. P.lcnl.lbility , hall not be negatived by the IIlIMeI" in which \he invention was made. 5. Claims 2- 2 1 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103(8) 8S being unpatentable over Henry et aI, U.S. Patent No. 5,682,529, in view of Kimura, U.S. Patent No. 5,469,223 . EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 3 Application/Control Number: 09074300 Page 4 Art Unit: 2787 As per claims 6,7,10-11 , 13,16. and 19, Henry teaches a display management architecture that detects changes in a display environment and notifies software programs as well as application programs of the changes in order to adjust them accordingly (Abstract). The display management architecture includes a display manager (Cover element 22) that comprises one pan of the computers operating system (Cover element 18}(C2 L 45·50). This display manager continuously receives infonnation from the drivers regarding the display capabililie.s, and provides reconfiguration services 10 other software within the computer (C2 L6l-67 and C4 L36-40). Whenever a change in change in configuration is detected, a notification is sent to the display manager (C6 U.6) . A change may occur ITom connecting or disconnecting a cievice, such as a . video device in the fonn ofa video card (Cover element 14) from the computer (C6 L9. 12), or from insertion or removal fro m a doclcing station or from the pivoting of a video device such as a monitor from a portrait position to a landscape position (C6 LI2-14). In response to the notification, the display manager rearranges the display space based on new configuration information. Once the new configuration has been established. the display manager determines which objects in the display space needs to be repositioned on the display device or screen (C6 L39-46). Information is provided to the operating system and other software programs by the display manager, in response to any changes in configurations (C5 L55-60). As per claims 10 and 13 , although Hendry does not specifically state the immediate use of "hot-plugging" it is suggested in the design and implementation. Hot·Plugging is merely a feature that allows equipment to be connected to an active device, such as a computer, while the device is EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 4 " Page 5 Application/Contro] Number; 09074300 An Unit : 2787 powered on, and since Hendry clearly intends for the process of reconfiguration to occur in real lime (while computer is running), hot-plugging is an obvious implementation of Hendry' s combined system. As pel" claims 13 and 20, although Henry does not specifically state the need for at least one display for displaying images, it is obvious that in order to display images, a medium must be present to present those images properly. This medium would appropriately be a display or monitor. As per claims 2, 10, 14, and 17-18, Hendry does not specifically teach the use ofa frame buffer within the video device or video card. Kimura teac~es the use ofa VGA frame buffer (Figure I element 14) that is general1y bitmapped to a display device, which could be a monitor (Figure I element 13) so that the storage locations in the frame buffer have a' one-Io-one correspondence with the pixels in Ihe display device (video device or monitor) (CI L 32-27). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary slcill in the art, at the time the invention was made, to allow Henry' s system to use a frame buffer, as suggested by Kimura, beuuse the frame buffer merely acts a~ a storage means to hold the contents of a screen image and this information is already processed, according to Henry. This would have been obvious because Henry teaches an invention similar to Kimura in that they both are directed towards the use of a video device (video card) and the means of displaying information of a display device and one of ordinary skill in the art would have recognized these similarities and concluded that they are from EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 5 Application/Control Number: 09074300 Page 6 An Unit: 2787 the same fi led of endeavor. Accordingly, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the an to allow Henry's invention to use a frame buffer from within the video card, as suggested by Gray_ .As per claims 3, 12,1 S, and 17, although Henry's combined system does not specifi cally state the sl orin~ of a preferences file that identifies the status o f displayed objects prior to change, it is suggested in the design. Since the framc buffer, as discussed above. serves as a means of preserving a "screen shot" or the contents of a screen image. it could be interpreted that this information would comprise the "preferences fi le". That is. a device such as the display manager or the video card could contain a frame buffer, which could capture or store the contents of a screen image, this information (the contents) would represent the same information that has been identifi ed as a " preferences fi le". As per clai m 4, although Henry's combined system dOes not specifi cally teach the repositio ning of objects in accordance with a status stored in a preferences file, it would have 15een an obvious implementation of its design. Since the frame butTer, as discussed above, could store information (preferences file) which is indicative of the contents of a screen image or "screen shot", as discussed above. this information could be used by the display manager to reposition object in the display space due to the addition of a video device or extra video card. Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the an al the ti me the invention was made, to allow Hcnry's combined system the ability of reposilioning objects (after detection of added video device) in the display spaCe in reference to information store in a preferences fil e. EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 6 Application/Control Number: 09074300 Page 7 Art Unit: 2787 As per claims 5,14 and 18, it is obvious that the frame buffer corresponds to an allocated portion of the display space, as previously discussed above, therefore, it is obvious that the display manager could the infonnation in a frame buffer exclusively for a certain corresponding display device, or possibly many corresponding devices, depending on the need and the configuration desired. As per claims 8 and 21, although Henry's combined system does not specifically state the use of a color look up table it would be an obvious implementation of Henry's combined system. Henry teaches the use of a look up table for possible communication problems involving the display manager and possible display devices (C4 L I 0- 14). Since it is generally accepted that a display device may pertain to a color monitor, the look up table, which could be represented on the display device, would certainly be able to be in color as welL As per claim 9, although Henry's combined system does not specifically state the recognition of a error condition it is suggested in the design and implementation, According to Henry, when a display device has been removed, a switch could provide a signal 10 the display device (C7 L60-65). This signal would therefore act as the "error condition" which would let the display manager know that a device has either been diSCOMected or has Slopped functioning correctly. In response to the signal, the display manager deactivates the display by removi ng it from the active device list, and then dynamically reconfigure the environment accordingly (C7 L60-66). Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, at the time the invention was made to allow Henry's combined system the ability to recognize an "error EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 7 Applic'ation/Contro] Number: 09074300 PageS Art Unit: 2187 condition" through the direct use of a signal, generated from the disconnecting of a certain display device. 6. The prior art made ofrecord and not relied upon is considered peninenl to applicant's disclosure. 7. Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the e",aminer should be directed to Ronald D. Hartman fr. whose telephone number is (703) 30S-7001 . The e"'aminer can normally be reached Monday-Thursday from 7:30 AM to 5:00 PM. The e",aminer can also be reached on alternate Fridays. S. If attempts to reach the e",aminer by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner's supervisor, Joseph Palys. can be reached at (703)305-9685 . The fax number for this Group is (703) 305·3718. Any inquiry of a general nature or relating to the status of lhis application should be directed to the Group receptionist whose telephone IVJmber is (703) 305-9618. Any res po nSl!: to this action should be ma iled to: Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 8 Application/Control Numb;er: 09074300 Page 9 Art Unit: 2787 Washington, D .C. 2023 1 Or raxed 10: (703) 308-9051, (for fonnal communications intended fo r entry) Or: (703) 305-9724, (for informal or draft communications, please label "PROPOSED" or "DRAFT") Ronald D. Hartman Jr. Art Unit 2787 September 14, 1999 EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 9 'e AppH cat;on No, 091014. 3 0 0 Notice 01 References Cited I IAPPlicanUI. Ian H""c hy Examin. , Aooold O. Hllttm lln Jr . 1" ~1 1 ~ Pille 1 01 1 U,S, PATENT DOCU MENTS / ' "', I' ~ / '419 4 ; , 5,682,!>29 5. 4 89.223 ' 314 19 4 !' , 5 , 282 . 268 .8 114 /91 .-:, --;., - "'~- o.n I)OCIJ"'UIT 0/0, ," ,- ., / 5.211'1,1130 \ 7123199 ~~ 1)1/1 4 18)1" I \ 5,014, 193 I '" '" 348 Miera. GI .01. / m Baldwin " ' ,I. 364 G.rner GI 01. '" '" '" '" , '" I I i' / "I , , 1 / , / •, / ,I I- I I FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS , ~- Kimura I I' 1 1 ,~. )'fondrv . , II, OOCUME.rT 0/0. om I ,~ -- CLASS I aUBCLAS& [oj • 0 • • I 1 I I , _"'_J NON ,PATENT DOCU MENTS 0 CwUfT I~-"'. l1'" _ . .... DAn " " w • u. $.1'" ,,", ....,,' ....... ,. DIleo PTO -S92 (Rev . 9-95) NOlice Of Rele<ences Cited EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 10 Part 01 Paper No. , INFORMATION u.",,1 ~ , CITATION (U ~~ ~ ~~: , ';'"'"0" '''', ~ , ...'1"-. ' , " '~·PTO-1449~::,i;JC"'~ ' -_. . ,. . . 5,682,529 lO/28t97 ' . , a:vl1 . ;. "" "M./ / ~ I:J ' I ~ ' . " 0"''' ,f Hendry at 81 . ' ' I""" l' £ 't: D 0 i!. / ... f / 1/ / [,,~~ ~ ~ ,.,,,,,,, lei: " ;, , "i'.', , ~~ 0"" " I ' , , ~ , .. .I , ' I~ , EXAMINER \l...J~ ~ \) \.L~ ~I , I OATE' I \nh~ \ OJ"', eXAMINER; Ini1,"11! .. je .. n~. considered, wh&the' Of net cil~!ion i' in ~O<Itonn.ne. with MP'EP 609 ; d,aw 11M INough cilillo" 1 not 1 In conlOfmlneelllll nOI con ' ide..-cl. lnel~de copy of t!>i, lotm with next commyl\lc.don 10 .ppHc.nl , 1' !W71 EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 11 ... INFORMATION DISCLOSURE CITATION ~ , ~n 1 I·~ ~~,;~; 1 ""= / .:0. ~"AY 0 6 199~ /I I / I ~ I I <co" 'm ! I - ~ ,~ .,.l! 1) I\~(\".., \)/ , a_<_""'... ............._.lII!!I_ C<l"I_......uo. _ t)(",,"NIR, 1 ·.1 H ~ ' .. ... I"" "' ..... d:dDn 10 ., """""........:0 .. ,,, _609, copyo1 tho """' _ ""'" """'~ 10 ."" ....... , I D\J.~I~' ~ ..... I "" 'r....... ft c"a'OOft H "'" "<,.-,,, EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 12 Fot .. I'TO 948 ( Rc~ . a.9S) U.S. DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE . P"cn' ,1>11 T .. dc .. ark om« Applic"'Oft No. NOTI CE OF.DRAFTSPERSON'S . PATENT' DRAW ING REv'IEW ~ The "',WIIIAI) ri l.d ('11K" dllt) pproVcd ~ 10 0qjafJtfr;2J)O " ,. '~ ". . e· . by."" D,d1lpc ..... n. , J1 CfFt 1 11-40. 1. 1'lobjcClcd .o by.,.. Drd'.pc ..... " • ...,.. 31 C FR 1.$4 Of 1.152 r", ,he ru ...... iMtc ... d below n.c E"II\,nc, w,lI lU~ft of ~ .... C""CCled d .... I... wI>< .......... 'l._ Coo;~cC1l'd drlw;", .. ~., ~ '~.l!'.d _d"S 10 II>< i .. ".c'~ O" ,Joe ty,;:~ af Ihi. noticc. 'cq.,,.. " 1. DRAWINGS. )7 C1'R 1.80'(1): Aee<PO~ ~'ii>ri'" of ......1"", . Bltc:k ~inI:_ Col .... CO!<>< d,,"""JI'" IIO;M KlCtpllbk u",il ",," IOn i. V.n'ed. -Fi,(.) . _ _ Pencil·.nd nori bl ... k Ink "'" ' F~.) _--'_ _ 2. PHOTOGRAPHS, 37 CFR 1.84 (b) __ I MI .......... ll rcqui .. d. Fi,(.) ~~~~ 1'110"""~ "'" ~ ,IJ ...... nttd ( .......... brySlol_ or ploololJoptI;c IIooob .. •...."bl popc"~.>~'~;.~.~)~_ _ -:__ f<Iot '1ullil, (Ul f_ ~ FicCo)_ 1. TYPE Qf PAPElt 37CfR l.II-4{c, 0, l"''''''''.d. __ _ _ .. ARitASGEME.VfOF VIEWS. 37 tFJt 1.101.(1) ,_ _ _1110 ...... J'PU, "" I .... l~n'-"', .. r.·....., il ... rls/J"", . ..hen ,.. ...... e;'Ii!-' uprja .. a, 1.,nt<j1O I"" • • he top , , SCAL~;"~':"I ~kii"".' '''''pI fo, , .. ~ .., f i,(o) _ __ ~ Sale"", I.". lhow """"' ni. m wi,,,,,,,, a _ _, ",he" d.... i.' . .. duccd in to ...... 'hirdl in .. protIaction. Fi&(I) 'r " • 10. CHARACreR. OF UNES. NUMBERS, It L.EITElI.5. J1 Q11 I.84(ij ..:...- I:iaco, ... mbe~" ~ .. _ o",fonnly , ..... IIId .... 11 ..fined. dc.ln, dvtlble, and (poor Ib.. ~ ..,it,). fiJ(.J . II. SHADINO. _ en. l.8-I(m) 11 __ SoIidbl.ck~palc. Fitll) __ Solid blocl.Udi", .... pcmrill«l. FicCI) , __ Sbodc (i ..... pal<., .....'" JI,II bill""" . Fil(I) 12. SUMBERS: L.£TT"ERS, &: REf ERENCE CHARAcreRS. )7 CFR 1.8.c{p) _ N"mbr .... ncJ .. 0....."'...' '''''' pll b.-.nd I'Sibl •• F'a[I),==_ __ Fi'''....&<ndo.'''poor. Fil(I)~=~= ..... nuit>!<, IlIOn&. .. bilr, .O(Id ........ f 'l(') , al .. ta< _ _ .... Er_~ hi'" . nt,"'.........i ...........; folds.,'.:opy tnodIiooo .... rks nor._pI<CI. FisC I) ____ _ _.101;'1 • •• ~'PC' ;. "'" ICCCpoabIc (100 .IM). ,,'.m F"('),=~~ 4. SIZE OF PAPER . )7 CAt 1.84(1): A<:c.plaIlk ....,0: __ 21.0 om by2<l,7 em (DIN II ....... ) __ 21.6 em b,. 2";1.9 om,(8 1/2. 1 .II":hel) rc,,,,,,, __ All dra"'i", ............ , ,lie ....... Ii .... SII<:<t(.)~",,",~ __ Dn ... i........... """"n...,...,..bl.li... . fi&(I), _ _ __ S. MA RGIN~ )7 CfR LJA(s): Aorcpooblr ....,,"'"' .......... Numbon-' .. r••o""" ct\a,act< .. """ or"_ i" the .. __ dire....., _U the vi...., ~1- en. . L..84(p)(I ) . .:, T't>p2.5cm Ld,l.Sc:rrI 1l1," IJlaoo Sonom 1.0 em SIZE: A4S ... _ _ Ericliob 11,,,,,'''',Il0l 11tIII. T""2.5 .... Ldl2.5~ R . .. ,. SIZE: '"Ilzl i , _ ll:; :;z:,,O~T;"~~ '~ '' _ ~T!.Oem C ~) 'm fI L) _ _ _ Ft i&fn(R) _ _ _ . . . . 6. VIEWS. 37CFR 1.84(h) R E~!N D ER : Sj><cirOCltioo. m.~ .. qui'" ,. • ......, '" ... msp>nd '" d"wi.o"''''n. P."iol .;'w.. 17CFR 1.84{h)(2) __ Brack... Medoo1lO.now ri,. ,e •• on< .lIIi'1. fi'(')=~~7 _ _ Vit .... """ lobeled .. ,.. ...." Of properly. Fi«<')',,"==~ __ Enlupd ...... """ 1."d oo1 "pOt.,ely Of pr<>pe"Y. F"'I('1,,",,==1. SECTlONAL VIEWS. 31 C1'1l 1.IoI. (lo)() __ Ii..chi ...... indiQJcd r", ItCIloMoI pMio... or 1& objo<I. _n . ._.. 1",,(1)=,== _ _ Sea;"""1 oIIOuld be - . . ... ~~ Anbic or 1';&(.), _ _ __ dclic~ioot. .ii. «.,..'" '" _ ...... F"oc(.): ~""",~. " )7 CFR 1.84(p)(2) ' I'ip , Noombcro,!<,..,.. _,crercroo<cI,••_ .. _ b e .. .J2 .... (III fllOfo) in Io<i,IoI. )7 CFR l.801(p)(3) !<»t Fil<')~=~~ U. LEAD UNES. 37CfR 1.8oI(q) = leoti Ii.......... ctc:. OIhe,."~'~;':':') ;;;-::= ; LtotIli .... mi ..il\l. FiI(l) : \4. NUMBU!!'IG Of~HEETS Of DRAWINGS, )7 CfR 1.8-l(tl _ Shuu IlOl ""mb<~ .......""'1.. 1" • .., In A.. b .. lMJm..... ""&inni", ",il~ ... mb<, I , She.'('),OOc-_ _ i$. "'U MBERING OF VIEWS. 37 CF1I. 1.84(0) _ _ v ...... _ ".mb<..d ""","",hoeI1, alld in Arabi< "".....,.. "",1 "";"1 .. ;,~ ""....... I. F"'I(I) _ _ __ 16. CORREq'lONS. 37CF11. 1.8-1(.. ) _ _ <:ar=t ..... "'" _ from priot PTO·.... S ~~ "''''" _. i 17. DESIGNDRAwtNGS. J1CfP: 1.1!2 _ S<rlfacc_"" __ ",,,'PP"'I"i"oe. Fi&<.)' _ _ _ _ _ Solid blKt Il0l • ..., for_ ..... ''' ... Fi&(o), _ __ COMMENTS REV IEWER'_ _ _ ~ , ~D _ _ _ _ 'tlOL~ ..L A TIACHMENT TO PAPER NO. . TELEPHONE NO. _ __ _ _ __ _-,1k~~7 ,--_ EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 13 .' WEST I Help Logout Search Results· Term L . II II ~O, USPT. ~/IOOS I71018s 201 1 0 : II !'JOI IO.USPT. 110/l0S 1931 Ii . 1 '1011 7.USPT. 1 Iful111S 1'10146.USPT. 710{46$ II; «LI)AA1)(7131100.CCLS , OR ?lO/s.eeLS . OR 7l0/ l0.eeLS . OR 710/ 17.CCLS. OR 710/46.CCLS. OR 710/47 .CCLS. OR I710/48 .CCLS. OR 7 14/5 ,CCLS. OR 71417.C:CLS) .l!SPT. .. There are more results than shown above, click here tQ view the entire set. \-1 Da tabase:! u s Patents Full-Tert Oatabase (11)a nd(113/100.ccls. or 710/8 .cc1s. or r-=-""'~-'7...., I 71o/1 0 .ccls. or 110/17.ecls. or , Refine Search: ~ • Search 8 jstory . = DB Name Hit Count Sel Name USPT (ll)and(7131l00.cc!s. or 71O/S.eels. or 7JOIIO.cds. or 710/ 17.eels. or 710/46.ccls. or 710/47.ccI5. or 7] O/48.cds. or 7 14/5.ccls. or 71417.ccls. ) 22 USPT (hot)(plugging or docking or insertion or swapping) 261 1012Y99 2:44 PM J of! ....... - ~ .. ......... ~ ..:.-. EXHIBIT 8 PAGE 14

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?