Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 319

DEPOSITION of Patricia Dixon, Ph.D. taken on April 20, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 20, # 2 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 21, # 3 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 22, # 4 Exhibit 20, # 5 Exhibit 21, # 6 Exhibit 22 -part 1, # 7 Exhibit 22- part2, # 8 Exhibit Plaintiff Ex. 18, # 9 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 1, # 10 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 2, # 11 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 4, # 12 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 8, # 13 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 10, # 14 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 11, # 15 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 12, # 16 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 14, # 17 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 15, # 18 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 16, # 19 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17, # 20 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17 - Seamans)(Rains, John)

E
X
H
I
B
I
T
2

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE
JJJ

-FJ

L.JJy

Document

235-2

Filed

09/30/10

of 19

Page

ragc

ligut

on the Use of Copyrighted Works
Education and Research

in

Policy

system devoted

As

to

providing

and

basic

the

highest

quality

undergraduate

research scholarly

and
and

graduate
creative

education

to

students

and

endeavors

pursuing

leading-edge

intellectual

the rights
of
System of Georgia is committed to respecting
with copyright
that
the
holders and complying
law The University System of Georgia recognizes
of copynght
holders are balanced
under federal copyright law
rights
on those
rights
by limitations
fair
the right to make
use of copyrighted materials and the right to perform or display works in the

copyright
exclusive
including

resources

to

course of face-to-face

The
in

faith

University

full

of

and

informs
of

activities

educates

students
as set

forth

faculty
17

in

and

about

staff

U.S

copyright

the exercise

appropriate
activities

for

and

the

law including
of the four

the application

106

107 and other copyright exceptions
develops and makes available tools and resources
status and ownership and determining
whether use

Specifically

the

fair

limited

exclusive

use factors

in

rights

17 U.S.C

law

therefore

on licensing

regarding

contact

Board

an infringement

of

of

U$.Q

Washington

of

Regents

copyright

of the

Qisclaime

Street

currently licensed

by

faculty

of

work

the University

and
in

staff

to assist

specific

System

in

situation

determining

would

copyright

be

fair

Georgia and

provides

who can counsel

faculty

of

use

information

by the University

System and
System and member institutions

the University

at

application

under copyright

materials

third-party

individuals

identifies

2009

not

use of materials

facilitates

270

bringing

University

Georgia

holders

copyright

the

inquiry

of Georgia facilitates
with
law and where
compliance
copyright
use rights by faculty
and staff in teaching
research and service

fair

of

System

the citizenry

teaching

System

University

good

applied

in

and

staff

law

University

System

of

Georgia

Privacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S

Content Source

USG

Copyright

PLAIN11FFS
EXHIBIT

Plo

http//www.usg.edulcopyright/

Appendix

Exhibit 2 - 1

Page

6/12/2009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

upyngntroucy

Document

u3u

uopyngntueneraiiy

Filed

09/30/10

of 19

Page

vs

LAgC

L.opyrlght

Syslnrn of Ceoruia Copynaht

University

PTflfl

235-2

Policy

Copyright Generally
Most copyright
ownership
copyrights

The

negotiating

answers
of

Copyright

provides

the public

and

many

the creators

and

distribute

and

interest

the

exceptions

works

will

in

words

the

of authorship

works The law

their

Time

to

work
work

are

based

intellectual
and

copyright
it

hear

it

diverse

to

few fundamental

with

rights

set

of

rights

Right

to

their

with

owners

Science

of

the Progress

the exclusive

the

inctuding

of copyright

interests

to promote

Inventors

exclusive

limited

the private

and

respective

to

publicly

and

publicly

are

rights
to

integral

listed

in

balance

the

Sections
of exclusive

copyright
to

107 through
and
rights

holders

range of materials

of

exclusive

of

chapter

producirve

socially

is

rights

the

right

the

U.S

to

Act

copyright

beneficial

make

new and

fair

use of

fair

works

original

all

creative and

are protectable

under copyright

law

Books

published

If

are

it

is

by copyright law One important
are not subject
by the U.S Government

protectable

or created

exception
to

art

photographs

journals

websites and many other materials are within
programs
are motion pictures
dance choreography
and architecture

computer

law Also protectable
or watch it chances

Works

122

works

recordings

Government

of copyright

managing our
to \Neb
materials
servers

posting

alWays begin

with

balances

Copyright law applies to nearly

wide

issues

respect

on the original

of

music sound

and

libraries

almost

of the constitution

Authors and

the exclusive

works One of the exceptions
to
work Copyright law applies
copyrighted
uses

arise with

questions

digital

questions

around

Georgia revolve

the public

to the exclusive

Limitations

These

to

copies

the

developing

copyright

original

owners

works

derivative

perform

Related

work

reproduce

display

of

limited

law gives copyright

distribute

other

intended

is

Arts by securing for
and Discoveries
Writings

prepare

existing

of

System

works

agreements

perform

useful

Copyright

the university

at

use of

law

copyright

copy

to

arise

fair

or

publication

these

to

principles

right

that

questions

new works

in

the reach

you can
is

of
it

read

the

U.S

see

works

of

copyright

Works are protected automatically without copyright
notice or registration
These
in

any

many

different

tangible

works

medium

of

under

are protected

expression

In

other

copyright

if

words once

they are original

you

create

an

woks

original

of

authorship

work and

that

are fixed

on

paper in
The law
protection

fix

it

the work now receives
clay or on the drive of your computer
instant and automatic
copyright
notice of copyright
today does not require placing
on the work or registering the work with the U.$ Copyright
as
did in the past The law provides
Office
some important benefits
you do use the notice or register the
it

work

but

you are the copyright

if

owner

even

http//www.usg.edulcopyrighlisite/copyrigh

without

these

formalities

t_generally/

Exhibit 2 - 2

Appendix
Pane

6/12/2009

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
Lopyngnt roncy

copyright

Document

USO

Jenerally

09/30/10

Filed

235-2

of 19

Page

o12

Page

Copyright

Copyright protection lasts for

many decades

The

the

of

basic

term

of

works made

120 years
works

hire

receive

works

created

below

explained

from creation

often

for

protection

for

work The

of the

today

for

is

the copyright

rules

for

owner

of

works

of the

life

created

author

the lesser

for

lasts

of

1978

before

plus

seventy

either

years In the case
from publication or
different and foreign

95 years

are altogether

treatment

distinctive

Copyright ownership
As

general

employment
are

rule

the author

is

the

initial

the copyright

the copyright
owner If you created
you are
the work may be
work made for hire

photograph

an employee

and

empler

Ownership

university

System

of

Georgia

create

is to

your job

of copyrights

and

software

other forms

institutions

is

the
in that

code
of

governed

event

work

you wrote the book

employer
in

property

the University

If

employee

the

the copyright

intellectual

by

the

in

work as an

that

acting

code

System

of

probably
by faculty

or took

the

the copyright

is

created

within

owner

belongs
staff

the

scope

to

of
If

your

you

your

or students

Georgia Intellectual

at

Propety

Policy

For Further Information
Full text p3 the

Database

U.S Copyright

of International

summary of copyright
Research by Kenneth

2009

Board

Contact

270

of

USO

Washington

Law
for

academic

work

can be found

in

cQPyrigttt

Ljw and

Qrdppte

crews

Regen

Disclaimer

Street

Act

Copyright
fundamentals

of the

UniversIty

Systern

ofgqgj

lrjvay

Atfanta

GA 30334

U.S.A

content Source

USG

Copyright

Appendix

http//www.usg.edu/copyrightisite/copyrightgenera1Jy/

Exhibit 2 - 3

Pane

6/12/2009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

roncy

tupyrignt

Use

tie

Sstrn

whether

the

of

amount

the effect

is

fair

Policy

forth

use

depends

the

U.S

such

use

of

whether

including

making

upon

107

Section

in

holders

the copyright

use

fair

permission
reasoned

and

commercial

of

of

balanced

Act Those

Copyright

is

The determination

factors

are

or

nature

is

for

work
of the portion

the potential

use upon

used

market

ln relation

to

value

for or

work

the copyrighted

whole and

as

work

of the copyrighted

should

Moreover

each

to

o1 Georgia Copyriqht

without

within

is

of the

substantiality

the

factors

is

use

or not the

of the

factors

receive

member

is

and

fair

the benefits

of

the

within

institutions

therefore

to

subject

is

Simple rules and

important

users

arise at

to

apply

whether

factors

tot2

Page

Copyright

be evaluated
in each
case and no one factor will determine the outcome While fair use
an educational
teaching research and other such activities
purpose alone does not make
rhe purpose
and character of the use is only one of four factors that users must analyze
in order to
to

conclude

four

of 19

Page

purposes

the copyrighted

and

of

four factors

intended

use

character

educational

the nature
the

work

use factors set

fair

and

purpose

nonprofit

work

copyrighted

copyrighted

of the four

application

All

use of

fair

use of

09/30/10

Filed

235-2

Use Exception

Fair

One may make

USU

Exception

er-iPy

The

Document

lawful

interpretation

work

as courts

to

apply

the

law Working

the University

of

System

the

through

and
may be compelling but by understanding
laws application to the many new needs and technologies
solutions

the

applying
that

continue

Georgia

Understanding the Four Factors
The

following

brief

is

balancing

nonexciusive

so other factors

The law

explicitly
in

university
are

favors

transformative

more

the context

of

that multiple

This

educational
education

not

are

work

copies

or

and

for

examines
to

different

of

of

use

Keep

in

mind that

the four

Additionally

fair

factors

use requires

are

work

to

are

mixed
also

use

over commercial uses

likely

receive

favorable

transformative
to

give

iransformed

may

whether

use

that are

truly

confined

Courts also favor

has been

defined

as

favorable

product

treatment

to

uses
use

new expression meaning or message
something new or of new utility such as

multimedia

into

Activities

treatment

it

into

be given

is fair

the

that

that

use

Fair

quotations

teaching The use of works
The statute also notes

for

in

permitted

Work

characteristics
types

is

analysis

classroom

determining

mere reproductions
in such
way as

pieces

critical

in

uses

are

work

the copyrighted

criticism

use statute

fair

conclusion

Use

of the Copyrighted

factor

differently

of the

original

paper

into

incorporated

Nature

when

likely

from the

reaching

considered

nonprofit

that

or
the

factors

before

may be

of nonprofit

support

adds to or changes
is

four factors

all

and Character

Purpose

of the four

explanation

weighing and

works

of

the

work

being

used

For example courts

simply courts have tended
concluded that the unpublished

Quite

have

to

apply
nature

fair

of

use
work

weighing against fair use Courts more readily favor the fair use of nonfiction
as opposed
to fiction and
other highly creative
works
including novels short stories poetry
and modem art images
Only those portions of
is

the

fact

work

which

are relevant

uses of consumable

http//www.usg

to

materials

be used lnstructors should
review
purpose favoring fair use should
carefully
such as test forms and workbook pages that are meant to be used and

edulcopyrightlsite/the

al

ruseexceptionl

Exhibit 2 - 4

Appendix

6/12/2009

108-cv-01425-ODE

Case

u1n4

uyJlt6ALL

repurchased

as

Amount

of the

Amount

measured

law

is

proper

Any copying
because
of

the

is

less

an

likely

both

as

qualify

relative

The amount
work usually

entire

might

and

quantitatively

user nearly always wants

image

to

Filed

235-2

09/30/10

of 19

Page

fair

otz

rage

uopyngnt

use

Work Used

objective

of

to

taken

from

weighs
the

or the

measures

work

and

fair

use Images

amount

full

of the

taflored

problematic

exist

quantity

amount
serve

to

serious

generate

thumbnail

are also

pictures

allowable

of

in light

be narrowly

should

against

Motion

exact

the entire

work

the

image

full

of

heavily

amount

be an acceptable

No

qualitatively

the length

needed

these

portion

purposes

even

version

short

clips

the

use

fair

against

on the Value of or Market

Effect

assesses

factor

the

work The

the extent

to

for the

which

given

Work

use serves

substitute

as

for

the

markets or potenbal

markets

For example
of the use
factor
purpose
the purpose
of the use is commercial any adverse
market effect resulting
from that commercial use weighs
fair use
If the
an adverse market effect is less likely
against
purpose of the use is non-commercial however
no adverse market effect
but
weighing in favor of fair use Occasional
quotations
or photocopies may have
fbr

the

controversies

or low-resolution

because

in
to

small
most extraordinary
or creative elements of the work One may also reproduce only
of
measure that may weigh
qualitative
any work but still take the heart of the work This concept is

may borrow

This

use

must be evaluated

Quantity

serve

usu

nut use cxcepuori

itic

their

Document

of software

reproductions

All four

factors

Revised

for

Copyright

on the market

effect

and videotapes

must be considered

use by the University

Advisory Office

factor

at

can

in

closely

make

of

Georp/a

University

linked

to

the

direct inroads

determIning

System

Columbia

is

whether

based

upon

on the potential markets

use of

the

fair

work

is

fair

use resources

for

if

such works

use

provided by the

httpf/www.ccpyjgitcoiiirnbia.eduIcopyright/qfour

factors/

2009

Board

Contact

270

of Regents

USS

Washington

DisclaIrne

Street

QLthe

University

Sy$epQfj3eorgia

Prkacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

http

//www

USG

Copyright

usg.ectu/copyri

ght/site/thejairuse_exception/

Exhibit 2 - 5

Appeflthx
PaQe

6/12/2009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE
ttiuuutXtlOfl

to tnt

Introduction
use

fair

factors

in

checklist

and

As you
column

use the checklist

against

fair

or

and

weighs

make

from

use The

You

the checklist

should

not

are

notice

first

is

license

that

contemplated

balanced

use

fair

application

the four

of

outlines
It

various

derives

from the four

use

fair

factual
fair

use

law

the cumulative

most

the factors

of

weight

with your

familiar

weighs

you are probably

project

in

favor

in

of

use

fair

best positioned

to

the checklist

regarding

of

USC

Washington

or

federal

nonprofit

link

1101

copyright

II

if

license

by

to

law

be protected

work without

has

use

into

falls

in

for
the

this

fair

the

also
If

fair

statutory

of

if

duties

or permission

be available

All

no copyright

to

with

distributed

are

an

through

so you may be

able

to

use analysis

performance
course

use analysis
official

by copyright

even

license

web

their

protected

materials

conducting

allows

specifically

instructors or students

your proposed

on

available

not

by copyright

use The work may

legally

that

employees
are no longer

you or your institution
For example
some

educational
or

to

If

as part of

1923

to

prior

presumed

library

directly

work

of

published

by copyright

protected

be considered

should

questions

or display

face1o-fec

exception

but

not

teaching

you need

not

use analysis

be

can
to

fair

use

use

under

use under

or

license

other

should

exceptions

attribution

found

establish

here Complete

and
and

TMreasonable

retain

good

copy

of

checklist

this

faith attempt

at

applying

for

each

fair

shir

use

use should

of

any

use arise

Regeritsof

Diclajrner

Street

and

notice

order

such

whether

materials

copyright

in

that

is

U.S government

by

be

threshold

the following

be used

to

use analysis

within

for

first

institutions

work

that

distribution

copyrighted

Bctard

allows

work

created

should

fair
falls

at your

U.S.C

work

the

1978

after

your use

to

fair

proper

copyrighted

270

of

and

use The checklist

fair

use analysis

fair

Works

exception

conduct

of

conduct

specifically

activities

Contact

are

by copyright

database

separate

2009

whether

works

and

copying and

of

to

published

direct students

dispute

is

you

present
need to conduct

electronic

copy

concern

not

use the work

uses

is

copyright

For example

not protected

You do

include

reasoned

making

your proposed
use you are likely to check more than one box in each
columns
Some checked boxes will favor fair use and others wi weigh

determine whether

first

necessary

materials

All

Use Checklist

decision

using

is

ot

Page

Copyright

to

it

across

use Because

of 19

Page

Georgia Copyright Policy

of

work

interpreting

apply

boxes

ultimate

fair

against

that

Before

and

check

even

in

of

09/30/10

Filed

usu

Checklist

the evaluation

to

decisions

judicial

you

use

given

circumstances that are important
factors

assist

to

whether

determining

235-2

to the Fair

tool

is

use

Pair

System

Uniiersity

The

Document

the

University

Systqm

p1

Georgi4

Privacy

VI

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USC

Copyright

Appendix
Page

http//www

usg.edu/copyright/site/introduction

to

he

fair

usc_check

Exhibit 2 - 6

1st

6/12/2009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

Document

Use

Fair

Name______________
Class

Project

or

Work

Where

consider
against

facts

total

use

fair

in

determinative

factors

fewer

of

use

fair

fair

use outnumber those against

than half the factors

Where

only

the

favor of

in

whether

Check

counts

favoring

weighing

deciding

situation

any given

timer

pages

the rights holder

from

the

the

Where

justified

permission

e.g

be used

to

Instructions

or at

Date

__________

and Publisher

Portions

is

Checklist

______

of Copyrighted

Author

use

of 19

Page

________

Course and Term

Title

09/30/10

Filed

235-2

use

fair

those facts
should

Instructors

the Office of the Board of Regents

if

fair

use

Not

justified

that

apply

consult

to

split

the

they have

of

your

the

facts

Affairs

Legal

facts

total

No

use

questions

instructors

the

to

all

should

instructors

are evenly

use as opposed

fair
is

favor

factors

will

fair

seek

should
weighing

be present

in

item or factor

single

office

on

reliance

it

at

is

their institution

analysis of the four

regarding

factors

For more
Policy
of

information

on the Use

of

regarding

Complete and

retain

reasonable

establish

on

the

Weighs

Purpose

including

multiple

copies

classroom use

Research

or

Criticism

and Research

sections

use

for the

of

University

the

System

Reporting

new

utility

Personal

use

work

changes

Weighs

Use

in

activity

distribution

exceeds

necessary

Study

educational

Use

For publication

purpose

to

Fair

from use

Profiting

educational

necessary

intended

Weighs Against

For public

Parody

or

Use

Non-transformative

Comment News
or

of the

and Character

Entertainment

Scholarship

Transformative

Factor

fair

http//www.usg.edu/copyrighU

Commercial

Educational

Teaching

is

at

Favor of Fair Use

in

Nonprofit

Use

Education

the

work in order
for each fair use of
copyrighted
copy of this checklist
and good faith attempt at applying fair use should any dispute

Factor

for

in

web

see

please

such use arise

regarding

for

use factors

fair

Works

Copyrighted

which can be found

Georgia

the

achieve

to

that

which

achieve

is

your

intended

purpose

your

purpose

Favor of Fair Use

Factor

Weighs Against

Appendix

Exhibit 2 - 7

Pace

Fair Use

to

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

Document

Factor

Weighs

educational

to

creative work

films plays1

objectives

Weghs

Favor of Fair Use

in

Factor

Amount

and Substantiality

Factor

Small

Amount
to

taken

is

educational

Factor

whole

research

Weighs

in

being

Favor of Fair Use

in

Favor

market

of

for

used

work

or

more than necessary

is

comment research

similar

product

work

for original

marketed by the

in

Licensing

or

potential

work

market

unavailable

or permission

Required

lawfully

or

acquired

distributed
or

reasonably

copies

made

or distributed

or long-term use that
the market

affects

demonstrably

One

made

or

copyrighted

available

the

few copies

for

or derivative

Supplemental classroom reading
User owns

Fair Use

impairs market

Significantiy

Repeated

print

permission

Against

for Original

Numerous

copyright holder
longer

Fair Use

Weighs

for

work
classroom reading

User does not own

purchased copy of original work
Restricted access to students or

Unrestricted

access

other appropriate

other public

lawfully

acquired

forum

Factor

Revised

Columbia

Weighs

for

in

group
Favor of Fair Use

or

purchased copy

Factor

Weighs

of original

on

Agamst

the

work

web

or

Fair Use

use by the university System of Georgia based upon the Copyright
Advisory Office
Fair
use Checklist http//www
copyrlght.columbia.edu/fair-use-checklist

universitys

Appendix

Exhibit 2 - 8

Page

for

or subject

Against

Weighs

Licensing

or

to

work

taken

Fair Use

copyrighted

market

stimulates

Effect on Market

work

No

central

is

taught

Factor

on market or

effect

significant

potential

No

Fair Use

being taught

Weighs

Use

the

of

criticism

or

Factor

No

heart

Amount

tailored

such as

purpose

comment

cribcism
subject

narrowly

Fair Use

work

entire

or

portion

Portion used

test

Used

of Portion

Large
or

work as

entire

fiction

workbook

Weighs Against

used

not central

is

to

significant

work

of

portion

Portion used

work

Weighs Against

Favor of Fair Use

in

Weighs

art music novels

poetry

Consumable

Factor

Fair Use

Against

work

Unpublished
Highly

of 19

Page

Work

of CopyrIghted

Weighs

work

or nonfiction

Important

09/30/10

Filed

Favor of Fair Use

in

work

Published
Factual

Nature

235-2

at

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
nuuzLuna1

uucy

Document

uuiQelines

235-2

ror Itlectronic

09/30/10

Filed

uou

keserves

of 19

Page

tot

rage

uopyrtgnt

Additional Guidelines for Electronic

Reserves
The

University

The

primary

related

of

course materials

be made available

on electronic

authored

reserves

by

such

professors

The following

standards

apply

similar electronic

and

with electronic
reserves
Georgia supports instruction
these services is to assure
that
and teachers
students

resources

library

electronic

of

System

function

will

have

timely

services

access

to

course-

notes or exams may
works for
use of copyrighted

as syllabi lecture
to

reserves

Instructors

for

are responsible

on electronic
instructors

reserves

requires

must complete

on

evaluating

copy of the

basis whether

case-by-case

or

permission

as

qualifies

fair

use checklist

fair

use

before

If

use of

the

relying

material

submitting

copyrighted

the

upon

fair

work

use exception

for

electronic

his

or her

reserves
Inclusion

of materials

educational

needs
made available

Materials

and

publication

The

instructor

form

for

electronic

Access

course

has completed

the

Library reserves
available
rather

at

the request

should

include

of the instructor

citation

to

the

for

of

source

original

must possess

institution

lawfully

obtained

copy

of

any material

reserves
on electronic

and

be

should

reserves
for

responsible

should

check

an electronic
and

scanning

Library reserves

be

restricted

course Access

the

should

by

and

to students

password

be terminated

as

soon as the student

course

staff

through

than

in

reserves

of the

unit

will

notice

copyright

material

instructors enrolled

reserves

on electronic

of

or other

library

submitted
to

on electronic

posting

the

should

delete

the University

System

staff

see whether

to

database

or are

materials

otherwise

submitted

legally

for

available

electronic
If

so

staff

reserves
should

are
provide

rink

material

materials

available

on electronic

reserves

of

at the conclusion

each

semester
Institutions

at

on electronic

2009
Gqntat

270

Board

of

U$G

Washington

of

Georgia

will

impose

no charge

to

students

for

access

to

materials

reserves

Regents

Pisclairner

Street

efihe

University

System

of

Georgia

Privacy

Atlanta

GA 30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USG

copyright

Appendix
Page

http//www.usg.edu/copyrightJsite/additiona1

guide lines_for

electronic_reservesl

Exhibit 2 - 1

6æ2/2009

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
nUUIUUIIUI

USU

tcesources

Additional

235-2

Filed

09/30/10

Page 10

of 19

rage

Copyright

University

FTIIP

Document

System

of

ox

Georqia Cop1right Policy

Resources

Other Exceptions
Permissions
the

Identifying
Collective

Copyright

Licensing

Owner

Agencies

Orphan Works

TEACH

2009

Board

Contact

270

Act

of

USG

Washington

Reg.qpttof

Dlsclaime

Street

the University

System

of

Georgia

erivacy

Atlanta

GA 30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USG

Copyright

Appendix

http//www.usg.edu/copyright/addiuonaI_resourcesl

Exhibit 2 - 10

6/1212009

Case
uult1unaI

108-cv-01425-ODE

kesources

Other

Document

USU

bxceptions-

Fited 09/30/10

235-2

of 19

11

Page

IJnIty SYStf

ot

Vage

Copyrtght

Georgia Copyright Policy

Other Exceptions
of

more

includes

in

dozen

than

and

application

copyrighted

works

course one

can

parts

The

of

is

following

connection

make

also

website

this

with

point

is that

in

mind

the law

means

several

gives

and

research teaching

service

from

some

of

the

of

with

exceptions

statutory

is

lawful
of

System

to

uses

uses

in their

general
of

Of

Georgia

owner Other

the copyright

references

and

flexible

making

for

the University

at

lawful

summary

use

fair

narrow

are

exceptions

By contrast

certain

Act however

copyright

most of these

that

conditions

specific

uses of copyrighted works with permission
guidance about fair use and permissions

offer

brief

of

make

to

the provision

of the

U.S

Act

Copyright

COPY1NO

LIBRARY
and

in

Keep

variety

the public

ultimately permit

exceptions The u.s

these

of

exceptions

statutory

upon meeting
The important
scope

that

exceptions

known

the best

is

depend

and

application

and

limitations

Fair use

works

copyrighted

many

to

are subject

Copyrights

to

security

108

Section

This provision
for

users

to

give copies

loan Like most of the exceptions

this

their

provision

libraries

permits

study or

private

applies

certain

to

only

to

research

make
and

of materials

copies

send copies
and
types of works
to

for

through

preservation
interlibrary

under certain

only

circumstances

109a

FIRST SALE Section
passed
and

is

DISPLAYS
An

may

institutions

It

instructors

the

or

simple

performed

The

and

COMPUTER
the

software

programs

of

works

to

recite

and

new

known

allows

universities

use

in

are sold

to

the event
for

use on

ARCHITECTURAL WORKS

of

right

for

materials

make public displays

can place

where
books

the

work

on display

1101
at

Under this excephon
most educational

project slides
plays show videos play music
works in the classroom setting This exception
permits only displays and performances in the

read

mind that
digital

lend

by

be

see

to

all

to

the place

at

Section
classroom or similar place

of protected
in

the

bookstore

it

works

on servers

1102

IN

posting

his

of materials
with

117

Section

work on

cases

is

the public

to

holder
turn

at

are struggling

SOFTWARE
program

to

is

law

to

on the wall

poetry

of

it

libraries

in

DISTANCE EDUCATION Section
When materials are
the rules
remote locations
or transmitted to students at any location
to address issues
of online
as the TEACH Act and was revised in 2002

students

to

keep

or the posting

owners

may

copies

allows

TEACHING

in

displays

but

broad

of copies

making

This exception

education
colleges

types

those

This exception

display

the display

in

students

and

to
it

FACE-TO-FACE

IN
all

performances and

other

many

work

of the copyright

rights

work

of

copies

of copyright

rights

may hang

put materials

display

lawful

or other transfer

the

painting

AND PERFORMANCES

DISPLAYS

modify

and

perform

comparatively

classroomnot

displayed

may

of

of

copy of

lawful

owns

that

library

allows
in

engage

change

museum

of

AND PERFORMANCES

DISPLAYS
educators

actually

One

and

windows

in front

is

art

109c

owner

the

gift

the distribution

limits

exception

the release

loan

Section

allows

This important

authorizes

owner

by sale rental
books

sell

to

statute

this

located

and

the

others

to

along

bookstores

PUBLIC
but

once

that

providing

or her

damage

to

this

or

http//www.usg.edu/copyrightladditional

120

or

but only

servers

and

This exception

computer

many

allows

or the

the

of

rights

Architectural

of

the

origInal

to

instead

on

owner

of

and

copy

long
fair

copy

are protected

exceptions/

Exhibit 2 - 11

list

of conditions

Many

use or permissions

of

computer

program

to

make

back-up copy of the
Realistically most commercial
to

use may be governed

designs

resources/other

subject

rely

platform

computer

destruction

multiple platforms

Section

to

statute

by license

by copyright

Appendix

Pacell

but

agreements

this

exception

6/12/2009

Case

clear

picture

of

Document

JUICE

makes

108-cv-01425-ODE

uu

that

that

once

cALCpLLuflS

building
without

building

is

constructed

at

Page 12

of 19

rage

uopyrignt

visible

place

the copyright

infringing

09/30/10

Filed

235-2

the

in

when we

reproduce blueprints or duplicate the Trump Tower
in
book or on postcards
and use
photograph

to

the

we

but

anyone

public

design

architectural

are not

We

infringing

014

may make and use
might

copyright

infringe

when we snap

it

SPECIAL

FORMATS

exception

permits

order

they

that

may be

and

institutions

FOR PERSONS

certatn

organizations

useful

to

may be

libraries

WHO

ARE BLIND OR HAVE OTHER

make

to

persons who are
able to

make

formats

specific
blind

of

have

other

or

or

large-print

Braille

DISABILITIES
non-dramatic

published

Section
121 This
works in

Iterary

For example some educational
some works in the collection

disabilities

versions

of

For Further Information

Full text

Revised

for

Copyright

2009
Contact

270

ofthe

IJS copy

rIght

use by the University

Advisory Office

Bpard

of

USG

Washington

Regents

at

System

Columbia

of

Georgia based

University

of the University

Disclatmej

Street

Act

upon

the

fair

use resources provided

by the

http/frww.copyjgtcpiqrntia.ed.u/apprOprfatq-use

System

of

Georgia

Frlvacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USG

Copyright

Appendix
http//www.usg.edu/copyright/addfflona

resources/otherexcepnonsI

Exhibit 2 - 12

6/12/2009

Page

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
LWaJLLICA

UJ

rCLIIbSLOIlS

235-2

Filed

09/30/10

Page 13

of 19

ox

rage

opyrtgnt

Sys tern of Georgia Copyright Policy

University

II

Document

iii

Permissions
If

you

are seeking

owner

may be

transferred

agency or
to decide
permission
protected

Creative

2009

is

not

of

Washington

conditions

necessary
at

by copyright

USG

publisher

Sometimes

and

Commons

Board

Contact

270

the cost

to

all

license

Regents

if

or

work

the copyright
are

to

obtain

permission

from

the copyright

owner

The

author may also have
persons employer The original
the owner
or some other party
In some
instances you may contact
or

that

on

behalf

of the

may

acceptable

owner

require

owner
and

should

by contacting

fee or
feet

free

impose
to

an industry

other

conditions

Keep

negotiate

in

licensing

You

mind

have

that

you
the work is not
fair use or another
your use is within
copyright
exception
license agreement
for example
including
your use is within the terms of

from the author

of the

Disclaimer

Street

work you may have

of the

you can secure permission

cases

publisher
if

copyrighted
creator

original

the copyright
other

In

directly

use

to

the

University

System

of

Georgia

Prjvacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USO

Copyright

http//www.usg.cdulcopyright/additional

resources/permissions

Exhibit 2 - 13

Appendix
Page

13

6/1

2/2009

Case
rtuutuUIWl

08-cv-01425-ODE
uenurying

itesuurces

Lr

The

source

first

United

States

09/30/10

Filed

USIJ

Page 14

of

19

ot

Vage

Copyright

the Copyright Owner
the copyright

for identifying

Copyright

Owner

Copyright

owner

2005 XYZ Corporation Another

copyright

235-2

System of Georqia Copyriaht Policy

Hh1frtv

Identifying

tne

Document

Office

For

is

the copyright
source

important

information

about

searching

notice
the

is

on the work

registration

of

often

which

the claim

looks

of copyright

like

this

with

the

records see

registration

httpllwwwcopyrlght.govlrecorcis/

However

law does not require

the

Sometimes

the copyright
publisher

or

benefactor

Sample ptrruission

2009

Spard

Contact

US

copyright

notice

you simply need to contact
and ask about the copyright

or registration

and

the

associated

any person
and ownership

original

with

the

owner

work

may have

transferred

such as the author

status

letters

of Regents.pfJhe
DisclaImer

270

Washington
U.S.A

Street

Content Source

USG

Unfrersity

System

of

Georgja

Privacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

copyright

Appendix
Page

http//www.usgedulcopyright/additional

resources/identifying_the_copyright_owner

Exhibit 2 - 14

14

6/1212009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

w.utn%3

t..uitccttvc

Document

icerising

Page 15

of 19

rc%c

L.upyrtgrkt

Ut

Agencies

for their
meant to centralize copyright ownership information
agencies are organizations
These
centers can expedite
in
touch
with
either by putting you directly
your search
or by negotiating
the copyright
most of these agencies
do charge
itself However
usage

industries

owner

copyright

Select

09/30/10

licensing

respective

for their

Filed

uu

i-tgenetes

Collective Licensing
Collective

235-2

fee

services

type

work below

of

Works

in

view

to

on licensing

information

agencies

for

that

industry

Prftit

Online Works
Musical

Mui

Works
Works

Performance

Rights

Mechanical

Rights

Dramatic Works

Graphic and

Pictoral

Works

Sculptural

Motion Pictures and other Pudici-Visual

Works

Software

Comics

Syndicated
Religious

Works

and Eitorials

Cartoons

Woks

in Print

The CCC

should

can

permission

grant

The kutbqrs
The

be your
for

point

starting

thousands

of

you are looking

if

works many

to

instantly

get permission

for

text-based

work The CCC

online

Registry

collaboration

Authors

Center

clearance

Copyright

of

literary

rights

The

organizations

Guild and

Dramatists

Guild The American

Authors

The Association

of

Authors

Society

of Journalists

Representatives

Access Copyr3ht
Licenses

Auffiors

works

under Canadian

and

Ucensing

copyright

Society
The largest licensing agency in the United Kingdom
book authors to poets and radio dramatists

Online

your

sources have
point

starting

contact

The

CCC

should

can

grant

permission

iCopyrigt
Focused on

information

However

Cearance

Copyright

Musical

the

ALCS

represents

writers of

all

genres from text

Works

Most online
best

Collecting

this

Directly

information

is

contacting

the

not helpful

try

owner or administrator
these

of the

site

is

usually

agencies

Center

be your

copyrights

if

for

of

starting

point

thousands

digital

and

Works Performance

of

If

you are looking

many

works

online

to

instantly

get permission

for

text-based

work The CCC

online

content

Rights

Appendix
Page

http//www.usg.edulcopyrightadditionaLresources/collectivjicensing_agencies

Exhibit 2 - 15

15

6/12/2009

Case

uuecuve

zi.cnJuiccs

CtULIILZULIQ4

Performance
concert

108-cv-01425-ODE

are

rights

performances

an

playing

encompass

agencies

licensing

Licensing

uses associated

all

to

of

association

DM1 Broadcst.Mu$

It

works

Performance

and

of

performance

Page 16

of 19

music

copyrighted
in

ut

reigc

from

everything

these three

space Together

retail

music

PublIshers

Au.tbors

and

lyricists

songwriters

licensing

of

speakers
American

majority of published

Composers

Fited 09/30/10

UJ Lupyrignt

ngencies

with public

composers

lnc4
media

235-2

music on overhead

artists

the vast

ASCAP Amrl.ctSociety
Membership

Document

musical

publishers

center

sgSAc
One

of the fastest

growing performance

and

London

Angeles

Musical

Works Mechanical

Mechanical

Rights

cover
as

Once

ringtone

mechanical

license

by law and

set

artists

Hany

is

Fox

with

organizations

offices

New York

Nashville

in

Los

Rights
with reproducing

those associated

are

of another

rights

Atlanta

song Other examples
has been

composition

commercially

pursuant to 115 of the United
known
as the statutory rate

the

be reproducing
recorded

States

Copyright

work such as

of copyrighted

derivatives

would

work

as

part

of

obtain

anyone may
Act The royalty fee

recording

album or

collection

compulsory
for

using

the material

is

Agy

Dramatic Works
Dramatic works

or in smaller portions
may not be publicly
performed without permission either in their entirety
dramatic work
such as excerpts acts scenes
to publicly
monologues etc The rights that are needed
perform
that combines
musical
work together with staging
etc are
dialogue costuming special lighting choreography
referred to as grand
obtained
from the creator of the work
performing
rights Grand performing
are typically
rights
or

publisher

their

The

to

rights

referred

to

publicly

as small

ASCAP DM1

single

of

music

from

Small performing
To qualify as
non-dramatic

SESAC

and

piece

rights

musical

rights

are

play

performance

of

are often

from organizations

obtained
piece

make use

fashion

non-dramatic

in

typically

music taken

from

such as
musical

of any form of staging choreography
the use of any of these
elements
etc even
musical
steps to
any past of the original
play For example creating your own dance
of music from
musical play disqualifies the use as
non-dramatic
use and permission
for the grand
piece
rights must be sought
performing

play

may

intended

not

perform

performing

if

is

not

to represent

Dratnatkts

mc

Playjervice

MTIMusLcal

Theatm

International

Harnmtrstein
Rqdggrs
Qrgnjzation
Tams7Witmatk Music .Library tact
PrNPatlc
Sarnitel

Bakers

Publishing

Frep

Ln

Plays

Pioneer Drama

BPPIBroadway

Play Publishingjrcj

and Sculptural

Pictoral Graphic
Many
that

license

organizations

industry

contact

Instead

specializes

List of

in

the

use of

the publisher

the dissemination

St9ck

still

Works

images

Unfortunately

of the picture

of free

stock

or

in

there

the alternative

is

not

real

seek

out

collective

agency

for

this

royalty-free organization

photography

phcttp_pgcncle.s

Appendix
Page

http//www.usg.edu/copy

rightladditionaljesources/collectivejicerising_agencies

Exhibit 2 - 16

1/

16

6/12/2009

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
nuuiiluttul

rcesources

Collective

Document

Licensing

USU

Agencies

09/30/10

Filed

235-2

of 19

Page 17

Page

Copyright

ot

Motion Pictures and other Audio-Visual Works
Start your

search

Credits Some

Movi

with the Internet
of the licensing

Motion Picure
Criterion

agencies

Qatabase

to

identify

who owns

the

film

listed

Company

under the

are

Liceosjg Corporation

Pictures

Licenses

non-theatrical

provides

licenses

for

performances

public
the

of

feature

films

entertainment

in

Canada

CriterionlJSA

US

Pictures Inc

$wan.k..M9tlon

Iino international
Source for world cinema

independent

and

films classics

documentaries

Software
Permission must be secured
alt

Nearly

software

to

reproduce

may be

pubhshers

distribute

contacted

perform

make

or

display

their

through

homepage

on

derivative

woris of software

the Internet

QNI
CNET

has comprehensive

through

download

its

reviews

of software

Comics Cartoons and

Syndicated

It

also

acts

as

hub

for

the dissemination

of

free

software

section

Editorials

creatos

Eloon

Kingeture
TdbunMdia

Syndicate
Syndicate

ComicsPage
United Fc4ure Syndicte
Unversaj

Press

-ComcZp.

$yq4tte

cartcqnBa.nk
CartoonStock

Religious

Works

Chrltian

Revised

for

Copyright

qopydgly_Iicnlng

use by the University

Advisoiy

Office

at

International

System

Columbia

of

Georgia based

University

upon

the

fair

use resources

provided

by the

Mtpi/www.copyrjgt.cJunthiaedu/olIectFve-licensjng

agencies

@2009

Boardp

fteggjhe
Disclaimer

ConttctUSG
270 Washington

Street

S.W

Unverskty

$ystem

of

Peorgi

Privacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

USG

Copyright

Appendix
Page
http//www

usg edulcopyrightladd

itiona

esources/co

Iective_l

Exhibit 2 - 17

iccnsing

agencies

17
6/12/2009

Case

108-cv-01425-ODE

zxsuurees

jtr

Document

USU

Works

urplian

235-2

09/30/10

Filed

18 of 19

Page

ot

Page

Copyright

System of Georgia Copyright Policy

university

Orphan Works
The

You

or

common You

high

some

owner

copyright

owner

and

beyond

have

tue

timits
to

attempted

of

seek

Worse perhaps
for

you wrote

work

copyrighted

fair

use or other

copyright

permission but the
but with burdensome

effort

you did receive permission
and the permission was flatly denied

permission

conditions

choice
but to absorb the bad news and change
your plans Much more
when you exert an honest effort but you simply cannot find
copyright
When you cannot identify or locate the current owner the copyright
your efforts
go unanswered
what do you do when you reach that
called orphan works In the meantime
are sometimes

situations

and

complex

use

to

likely

no conclusion

Perhaps

price

want

down

tracked

has produced

simply

In

is

situation

exception

or

materials

en

dead

mysterious

Return to

you might

frustrating

have

however

of the

little

is

quest

use

fair

When

fair
you originally evaluated
use you may have focused on an assumption about the potential marker for
the work in question
and the possible harm to that market caused by your use of the work
you discover that
market for this work you should
there is truly no permissions
reevaluate
the fourth factor in the fair use analysis
II

You may

USG

Replace
If

find

that

Copyright

the materials with alternative

dead

reach

you

materials

that

Alter

and

multiple copies

you should

your goals

available

in

favor

of

fair

use

For

more information

plans
for

for

In

use without

the copyrighted
involved

and

those

use pages

fair

of

the

or potential

for

colleagues

rapid

works

digital

are the only
with

results

works

in

the

owners

works

scanning1

digitizing

uploading dissemination

the copyright

causing

owner

your ambitious plans to something more modest and
holders mind or increase the likelihood
that you are within

scope of access

copyrighted

specific

your desired end
you can achieve
restriction
or from other copyright
copyright

may have

students

whether

many cases

uses Changing
copyright

the

visit

works
ask yourself

of

use

your planned
ambitious

Your

end

will satisfy

domain

public

now weighs

factor

this

Policy

duplication

and

to

deny

controllable
fair

use

dissemination

may

Reigning

may

Internet

permission

tip

the

either
in

the

for

access

change
number

balance

and

such broad

in

the
of copies

favor

of

fair

use

Revised
Copyright

for

use by the University System of Georgia based upon the fair use resources provided by the
Office at Columbia
University
htp/Anrw.copyrigft..cpIupnbi.ecu/orpflan-vorks

Advisor

200g

Board of Regeflts
Contact use
Pisclaiinec

270

Washington

Street

of the

Uniyerskty

System

of

Georgia

Privacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

U.S.A

Content Source

http

USG

Copyright

//www.usg.edulcopyrightiadditional

resources/orphan

works/

Exhibit 2 - 18

Appendix

6/12/2009

Case 108-cv-01425-ODE
n%3%.14.I%/GI

L\LSuU3..C

TEACH
Guide

Contact

of

USG

to

UU

235-2

Filed

09/30/10

Page

19 of 19

LUpytitit

CA5.

.aa

of Georgia Copyright Policy

System

Act

For more information

02009 Board

t%CL

University

iTJfli

Georgias

Ct\LI3

Document

regarding
the

Regents.of

Disclaimer

270

Washington
U.S.A

Street

Content Source

USG

requirements

of the

TEACH

Act please

visit

the University

System

of

TEACH Act
the University

System

of

Georgia

Privacy

Atlanta

GA

30334

Copyright

http//www.usg.edu/copyrightJadditiona1jesources/teacftact/

Exhibit 2 - 19

Appendix

6/12/2009