Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 319

DEPOSITION of Patricia Dixon, Ph.D. taken on April 20, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 20, # 2 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 21, # 3 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 22, # 4 Exhibit 20, # 5 Exhibit 21, # 6 Exhibit 22 -part 1, # 7 Exhibit 22- part2, # 8 Exhibit Plaintiff Ex. 18, # 9 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 1, # 10 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 2, # 11 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 4, # 12 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 8, # 13 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 10, # 14 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 11, # 15 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 12, # 16 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 14, # 17 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 15, # 18 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 16, # 19 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17, # 20 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17 - Seamans)(Rains, John)

E
X
H
I
B
I
T
17

Exhibit 17 - 1

the

February 23 2009

Georgia State University

Office of Legal Affairs

Hall

GaStateOO2l

Copyright Policy

Cynthia

New USC

Copyright in instruction

120

Exhibit 17 - 2

is

to
it

is

large field

and

this isnt all

specific situations

GaStateOO2l

any questions or
404-413-0500

Call Legal Affairs with

Policy

on use of copyrighted
materials by an instructor and the USC

Primarilyfocused

there

Copyright

Disclaimer

121

Exhibit 17 - 3

in

recordings

Compilations of above works

Architectural works

Sound

works

other audiovisual

choreographic

Dramatic works

Pantomimes

Musical works

Motion pictures

Pictorial graphic

sculptural works

works

tangible form of expression

Literary works

Includes

Fixed

Original works of authorship

GaStateOO2l

What can be copyrighted

122

Exhibit 17 - 4

in

names

form of expression

listings

of ingredients or contents

lettering coloring

in

is

GaStateOO2l

123

common

Works by U.S government employees

property with no original authorship

Consisting entirely of information that

devices

Ideas procedures methods systems
processes concepts principles discoveries

Mere

typographic ornamentation

mere variations

short phrases slogans

fixed tangible

Familiar symbols/designs

Titles

Not

What cannot be protected

Exhibit 17 - 5

notice

was required

commercial

cqyirqct but

U.S

if

intent

is

Copyright Office

common

Registration at

Year Author

124

not

GaStateOO2l

is

conferred upon

new works

Now

But recommend providing notice

Previously notice

for

needed

does one get copyright

creation/fixation

No

How

Exhibit 17 - 6

in

copyright

or reproduce

like fair

GaStateOO2l

use

Authors of visual works have rights of
attribution and integrity

Subject to statutory exceptions

Distribute copies to the public

Perform publicly

Adapt derivative works translations

Display publicly

Copy

Copyright holder has exclusive rights to

Rights conferred

125

Exhibit 17 - 7

vs Author

or reproduce

like fair

GaStateOOZl

use

Authors of visual works have rights of
attribution and integrity

Subject to statutory exceptions

Distribute copies to the public

Perform publicly

Adapt derivative works translations

Display publicly

Copy

Copyright holder has exclusive rights to

Copyright Holder

126

Exhibit 17 - 8

Copyright Policy

Intellectual Property Policy

and students

GaStateOO2l

127

Focused on new works created by employees

Compare GSU

teaching research and service

in

copyright

holders and use of copyrighted works

Focused on respecting

rights of

Education and Research

www usg .ed u/copyright

in

Policy on the Use of Copyrighted Works

USG

Exhibit 17 - 9

Copyright Policy

checklist

Office of Legal Affairs others

Individuals to counsel faculty

staff

GaStateOO2l

128

provide information on licensing

Use

licensed

Fair

use of materials currently

see

use

staff

Facilitates

analysis

TooJs to assist in copyright

fair

educate students faculty

on copyright

Inform

USG

Exhibit 17 - 10

use

attribution

Lawful copy

citation

work

checklist for each

on

Use

relying

out Fair

fill

or fair

Instructors should

use

needed

use

GaStateOO2l

fair

whether permissions
know details of work

Reserves

Guidelines on Electronic

Instructors evaluate

USC

129

Exhibit 17 - 11

No charge for student use

rather than scanning material

Wherever possible link

end
of

each

GaStateOO2l

130

or post references

materials at the

semester

Remove

terminated at the end of the semester

access

cont

restricted with

Reserves

Guidelines on Electronic

Password

USC

Exhibit 17 - 12

work

in

U.S.C

Basis

if

107

but

now

at

17

fair

not an

determined to be

common law

infringement

is

GaStateOO2l

use

purposes of criticism

reporting teaching

for

Use

scholarship or research

comment news

Copying

Fair

131

Exhibit 17 - 13

Use

Columbia University

GaS tateOO2l

132

at

market

compiled by

potential

used

Kenneth Crews formerly of IUPUI and now

originally

Checklist

Based upon one

Fair

use upon the

substantiality of portion

Effect of the

Amount

Use Factors

character of the use

Nature of work

Purpose

Fair

Exhibit 17 - 14

new

utiity

or

Factor

to

achieve
nour

Er

Favor of Fair Use

educational purpose

Weighs

intended

News

purpose

Persona Study
Use is necessary

for

Lisa

use changes work

or Parody

Reporting7

Transformative

Cornnient

or Scho4arship

character

Factor

pwpose

is

your intended

which
to achieve

that

GaStateOO2l

Weighs Against Fair Use

educational

necessary

Use exceeds

distributhn

publdcation

For public

For

Non-tran.sfornmative

Entertainment

use

activity

Proæting thorn

Commercial

Weighs Against Fair Use

Punpose and Character ot the Use

muftiple copies

Criticism

Research

Factor

Purpose

Favor of Feir

Educational

in

Teaching including
for classroom use

Nonproti

Weighs

Factor

133

Exhibit 17 - 15

or
to

cx flit

jcatbaaag

Use

cUjeclives

work

-wor

nonlictictn

work

to

Factor

Weighs

Yn Fti

VOOi Fair Use

___________________________________

lrnpotanl

i-actual

Puffll

wergrs

Factor

tUrns

cLays

Fa2tcr

pcety

ficlioli

IflUSIC

rovela

GaStateOO2l

frstFÆrLisd

work worethoot tea

WeigIs

Cons-jniatle

aa

Agais fir Use

UnpubLisheG wcrt
work
l-hghly cveative

Wwgs

Nature

134

Exhibit 17 - 16

use.ji

portion

nnf
re.ntraI

nr

narrawity

thilorod

be

in

Factor We/ciMs

sUoject

in

Favor

taught

Use

or

of Fair

rc3camh1

education pirpose such as

13

whole

Far Usa

used

of

ci the

usad

portion

Fecto1r

is

or

torc

entire

thar

WeiQhs Agiiist EcU

for

Us

GaStateOO2l

or sutject

no cc3aory

wor used
iwtr tn wnr at

gains flfr Use

cornmit research

bcing taught

criticism

Amount tukcn

heart

Pcrtnn

Large

Wefighs

ot Vortion 1F5e6

substantiality

Amount anu SuaataaRty

Amount

enhre work as

AS

crlticizn conirncnt

to

Fi var

tactor

ot work

in

Ani.ount takcn

significerLt to

Pnritn

SniI

Weighs

Factor

135

Exhibit 17 - 17
in

appropriate

access

Factor Weighs

cther

Hesnicted

purchased copy

IawfuHy

owns

User

students

FavcirofFafr

group

Kto

Use

or

work

or

or distributed

acquired

made

of original

copies

kw

or

One

clasaroom reading

Supplemental

in pthil

pemlission wmvaillable

longer

holder

the

Licein sing or

No

copyright

by

work

market

bit

not

own
access

purctased copy

dae

classroom

fcctor

other

Use

GaStateOO2l

________

or

work
on the web

Fair

for

acquired
of original

lawfully

readThg

the market

Weighs Against

pubic

toruni

Unrestricted

or

Useir

Required

work

affects

that

or distributed

use

made

or long-term

copies

demonstraUy

Repeated

copyrighted

or permission reasonably

Numerous

the

for

or derivative

potentiaJ

availa

similar prodtttt

marketed

for original

work

No

market

for copyrighted

Use

or

Fair

impairs market

Weighs Aga/nst
Significantly

Licensing

stinnu fates

market

or

Fak Use

Effect

work

Use

potential

of

09 market

Favor

effect

in

No sgmicant

Weighs

Factor

136

Exhibit 17 - 18

1101
work by

was

is

means

made..

given by

not lawfully

work

of

GaStateOO2l

copy that

motion picture or other audiovisual

classroom. unless in the case

of

course of face-

to-face teaching activities...in

instructors or pupils in the

performance or display of

17 U.S.C

Face-to-Face teaching exce ption

137

Exhibit 17 - 19

literary

NOT

instructor

as an

and

Reception

limited to

teaching content

Directly related

mediated

digital

students

officially

GaStateOO2l

enrolled

138

of material assistance to the

instructional activities

By

for online

integral part of

works marketed

databases etc

But

use

or musical work or

TEACH Act

reasonable portions of other works

Nondramatic

17U.S.C.11O2

Distance Education

Exhibit 17 - 20

measures reasonably prevent

may be

No

AND

of technological

GaStateOO2l

measures

139

unauthorized further dissemination

circumvention

session

retention of the work for longer than the class

Technological

subject to copyright protection

Notice to students that materials used

and students

staff

has policies regarding copyright and

TEACH Act

provides informational materials to faculty

Institute

Distance Education

Exhibit 17 - 21

copyrighted

work

it

available with

within

license for this

an exception

Do we have

Fair Use

Use

Links or mere references

Can we make

use

GaStateOO2l

140

no copying

Public domain expired copyright

U.S government work

Is this

Methodology of Analysis

Exhibit 17 - 22

the use

does not
fall

into

to

copy display perform etc

linking

ASCAP
BMI

databases

licenses

Library holdings

GALILEO

is

in

GaStateOO2l

particular

referencing without copies

Georgia State resources

Web

Collective rights organizations

needed

of the

license

one

exceptions then permission

If

Copyright Licensing

141

Exhibit 17 - 23

in

easy-to

Example

Caution on

party materials

OO

3rd

Gaining more popularity on the

using

web

GaStateOOZl

now

cont

understand terms that more authors are

Provides standard licenses

CreativeCommons.org

Copyright Licensing

142

Exhibit 17 - 24

Criterion

composer etc

author

GaStateOO2l

for motion pictures

Individual contact with studio

Swank

iCopyright online content

online

Copyright Clearance Center print and

Copyright Licensing COflta

143

Exhibit 17 - 25

if

name of

the

work

publisher year copyright holder

Include the author

GaStateOO2l

fair

of the

using without permission i.e

use or another exception

Even

Always attribute the author source
work

Attribution

44

Exhibit 17 - 26

Copyright Act

GaStateOO2l

few uses but

such access

to talk to Legal Affairs

Limited exceptions for

need

if

unauthorized

access controls

would be

digital

Generally cant go around any type of

Digital Millenium

Antici rcu mvention

145

Exhibit 17 - 27

is

is

fair

it

not

GaStateOO2l

is

the public

game for copying

in

no copyright notice then

copyrighted

there

work

more than 25% 20%

the internet are

domain and

Works on

of the

entirety

10% etc

If

give attribution

copy as long as you dont

if

legal to

copy the

It

can copy

Copyright Myths

146

Exhibit 17 - 28

System

of

Minnesota

html

GaState 0021147

http//www.lib.umn.edu/copyrightlfairuse.p

University

http/Iwww.copyriqht.columbiaedu/

Columbia University

www.knowyourcopyrights.org

Your Copy Rights

Association of Research Libraries Know

Resources

Exhibit 17 - 29
if

OSP and
our

own standard forms

GaStateOO2l

Reviews ALL contracts involving the
University except Research Agreements

notify Legal Affairs

you receive
subpoena or legal request for documents
related to your research or university work

MUST

contract or other legal violation

if

148

you receive an
infringement breach of

notify Legal Affairs

accusation of

MUST

Office of Legal Affairs