Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 319

DEPOSITION of Patricia Dixon, Ph.D. taken on April 20, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 20, # 2 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 21, # 3 Exhibit Defendant Ex. 22, # 4 Exhibit 20, # 5 Exhibit 21, # 6 Exhibit 22 -part 1, # 7 Exhibit 22- part2, # 8 Exhibit Plaintiff Ex. 18, # 9 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 1, # 10 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 2, # 11 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 4, # 12 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 8, # 13 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 10, # 14 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 11, # 15 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 12, # 16 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 14, # 17 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 15, # 18 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 16, # 19 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17, # 20 Exhibit Previously Marked Plaintiff Ex. 17 - Seamans)(Rains, John)

E
X
H
I
B
I
T
22

Radal

Identity

American Children

in African

and ExperIential Antecedents

ognItIue

BENNETT

CAROLYN

identity

and

cialization

that

Black

behavio
and

has the

xamine

are to

readiness

1985
the ages

older Black

and the

The

children
remain

societal

understand

This chapter

development

how

children

come

considers the cognitive

abrupt

changes

to

been

view

that

reveal

display

larger

in

studies

Eurocentric

within

so

member

in

both

display White-biased

age

context

racial

racial

racial

Recent

findings

and

of

on the cognitive readiness of the child
identity

parental

stress

with

correlates

variability

McAdoo

whereas

that

and individual treatment

of the family

racial

on self-concept and/or

traditions

counterparts

recent emphasis

world

of group

White

their

role

focuses

historical

and White children between

choice

ence

and

intraindividual

development

cognitive

Americans

ignores developmental

societal

determinant

ship as
dicate

on African

but too often

MURRAY

MANDARA

JELANI

Most research

Development

Black

integrated with
It

is

societal

this

paramount
framework

themselves

maturation

prefer

Only minimally

of the

and

child

to
if

their

within

73

Exhibit 22 - 1

Defendants

pytil

Exhibit

MESSAGES

RACIAL

74

the

of family

context

e.g

ditions

racial

membership

system and

education

media

determinant

as

and of

socialization

race
er

mainly

cial

racial

to

shape

think

monly
able

fact

that

quite

but

entities

react

people

the

to

as

may depend
of

issue

part

and

members

of

ways
much on the

these

social

in

persons

context

and

context

social

wishes

and

agreement
from the

part

recognized

socially

and

recog

ramifica

may

identify

than

in

groups

legally

political

desires

com

distinguish

social

by

springs

Therefore

defined

People

as sharply
set

are
have

persons

politically

1998

Jones

groups

to

and manners

language

socially

may

mainly

Also the race with which people

on phenotype

more an

refer

religion

boundaries

their

group designations
hair texture
and fa

ethnic groups

and important

different

as

in

boundaries

racial

sharpness

nized race
tions

overlap

and sometimes

of races

biological

Whatever

it is

between

of

skin colo

as

of origin

base

genetic

to the phenotype

racial

ref

racial

group designations

country

heritage

race has

Although
due

ethnic

whereas

tra

stress

the concepts

understand

first

usage

such

phenotype

persons

sociocultural

current

In

language

Race

one must

identity

ethnicity and identity

historical

that

group and individual treatment

of

DefkiIng

To understand

and

societal

their

be

pheno

type
Identity

or

particular

good

at

or

sports

and the

feelings

like

The

racial

How
Children
nitive

the

racial

issue

the individuals

here

is

aspect
with

how

Racial

of the

them

African

self

mirror

in salient

schema

is

including

Black

of race

when

social

or mental
attributes

perceived

people

American children decode

develop

social

develops

as

in

identity

and can have

conception

an influence on

Fishe

1978

Amsterdam

1972

Exhibit 22 - 2

By age

Mane

general
of

do

and under

they begin

to

their

1988

Rathe

Infants

and separate

surroundings

children can
Lewis

recognize

issue

critical

is

self

Bandura 1986

they mature

come aware that they are unique independent

Bertenthal

of schemas

identity

humans

dividuals

behavior

identity

e.g lam Black

do not enter the world with

notion

system

am shy tam tall am Black lam

e.g

Kunda 1986

associated

an organized

essentially
self

complex and often abstract concept

the

form

the

characterize

that

of

representation

stand

about

Markus

settings

is

self-concept

beliefs

this

need

cog
be

to

from other in

Bandura 1986
themselves

Brooks-Gunn

in

1979

Development

75

and autonomous

from oth

Racial

children

By age
ers

Although many

ways

states

In

racial

of that

tions

themselves

or

are

usually

as

into

insight

their

membership

This chapter

examines

the development

affect

of

racial

true

peo

and at

beliefs

toward higher

group

racial

socialization and

peers

Second

move

and the conse

individuals

membership

significant

members

family

race

racial

by

two

in

occurs

it

seen

and media images

teachers

as

in

the readiness family
that

view

development

identity

development

identity
to

self-knowledge

of understanding

quences

separate

1998 who

such

forces

gain increased

tributes

affect

begin

Douglas

and macrosystem
ple

factors

First people

Cook

others

as

1988

Neisser

general

themselves

see

Identity

certain

factors

cogni

and

historical

tradi

societal

in

identity

American

African

chitdrern

Readiness

Cognitive

of the self-concept

The content

about themselves

formation

Newcombe

1952
stages
logical

others

1986 Semaj

cognitive
for

human

all

of

people Mote

volves

two

to

in

tal
ing

mental

structures

sons mental

the

ft

sensory

them

is

theory

stage

sense

and

to

received

begin

stage
to

this

Piaget

and

the incorporation
meaningful

allows people

in

their

level

to

Social

with

other

by chil

shaped

in

adaptation

accommodation
of

environmen

form

respond

fit

to

exist

new envi

to

present mental

which changes

experiences

the cognitive

is

to

process

new

development

with

from the

interactions

into

refers

situations

fit

their

For

by the bio

different

more sophisticated

assimilation

color

Assimilation

The preoperational

Thought processes

from

awareness

abilities

occur

in

per

or stimuli

during

the

years of

first

life

is

and deal with the world mainly through

children understand
messages

become

abilities

reciprocal

structure

In Piagets
sensorimotor

determined

environment

skin

as

experiences

Accommodation

are innately

processes

cognitive

such

experiences

stages

qualitatively

Piaget

of invariant

sequence

social

theft

to

According

through

is

in

Branch

maturation

1985

Spencer

by children

interlocking

Assimilation

ronmental

cognitive

specifically

drens adaptation

with cognitive

proceeds

The

beings

constructed

is

1985

growth Each

the childs

knowledge

and the way children process and convey
linked

development

sequence
as

is

and

the

starts

involve

motor behavior

about

symbols

age

such

used

and ends
as

to

react

about

skin color

that

to

age
repre

Exhibit 22 - 3

RACRL

76

sent

MESSAGES

the

in

objects

cretepresent
able

refers

the

is

11 and

age

does

internal

and

identity

cial

identity
the

the

Direct

learning

process

the color

the family

and

color

cations

Hodge

their

group

about

masculine
In

attitude

like

sum

although

mines

the

identity

development

by

their

societal

1975

Trost
than

females

and

boys

cognitive
racial

into

context

Exhibit 22 - 4

own

clear

need

value

are
their

and communi
character

negative

gende

respect to

girls

being

comprehensive

in

such

Hyde 1983

when

the

tomboys

participate

and playing baseball

ethnic identity

re

culture

children
to

the

several

most boys being ego

in

of

by

Western

reinforcements

results

but

various

including

human

ex

influence

preference

and blacks

both

1995 and

childrens

that

valued Black

number

Thus

perspective

are influenced

playmates and

consideration

awareness

an egocentric ra

significant

readiness determines

and/or

they acquire

must take

male

trees

racial

Holmes

Similarly with

which

sizable

prefer

as climbing

activities

of developing

because

vary with

1983

for

racial

human

of

may

formation Within

are highly

people

negated

boys

being

pable

societal

is

for

adoles

until

complexity

Katz 1975

them of whites value

more valued

want to be

they

racial

situation

inform

and polit

have

society

learning

Struckmann

males are
centric

conflictive

social

not

their

it is

assumptions

direct

White

and

white

that

and wider

Childrens

relevant to

occurring

groups

many non-Whites

racial

stage

behavior

from

race
racial

from parents often accounts

more complex

in

placed

view

e.g

people

would have

children

non-White

of

mechanisms other than
inforcements

all

of

of part-whole

Marcia

factors

be inter

characteristic

e.g

full

that

realize

yet

The

last

that

indicates

aware of the

transitory

the

were the only antecedent

variation within
tendency

is

thinking

logical

or

age
is they would

that

within

is

or

the preschool

at

Eurocentric

periences

states

objects

stage

can

that

Another

are not

or objects

an understanding

to

literature

intentions

and

and

reversible

to classify

abstract

become

readiness

cognitive

Given

and

feelings

situations
If

children

race The

of

individual

the

thoughts

involves

it

ramifications

cence

owing

classify

is

con

concepts

constancy

racial

be

that are

objects

awareness

theoretical

and so on The formal operational

groups

ical

to

ability

which enables

relationships

about

e.g

stage occurs

operational
only with

as racial

or

some action that

to

by the individual

stage

such

ideal hypothetical

term operation

this

are concerned

real

or

tangible

to visualize

nalized

environment The concrete

and 11 Children

tween ages

social

children

are

context

model of

the age of the

child

ca

deter

identity

and

the

Racial

Awareness

Racial

and

Children

ties

make

and

among

distinctions

1983

material

am

learn

skin color

Semaj 1985
our

in

The
goes
tures

of people

racial

label

of

dolls

or

dards

of

1987

though

her skin

brown

the

closer

aged

and possess no complex ideas about

It

is

that

proposed

themselves

reference to others

in

of

acquisition

part of the
Other

racial

sell

sociocultural

ries

but

world

McCabe

la

are

stan

as

1989

that her daughter

at

mother was White even

Black
believe

identity

that

light

in

her

that chil

abstract

knowl

1992

begin

1987

Butler 1989 Ruble

so

see Wardle

than

rather

for

category

theorists

knowledge

pic

Preschoolers

which serve

years children

expand developmental

context

for

Coarse 1992
which

that

socially

race

describing

following

the

permanent

is

or identity

the

in

be

which person

identify

White than

racial

school

constancythe

researchers

argues

to

information

by the middle

membership

from others Butler

Most cognitive

on concrete

to

her

to

come

statement

will

did not have

child

edge

rely

affective

1988

skin color

as

thought

dren

to

or

themselves

brown The

White

she

that

mother recounted

mothers skin color was

mind her mother was

fact

Spencer

such

1988 One

light

young childs

the

or

before they

and hair textures

hues

mothers objections

is

symbolic

measured by showing children

usually

qualities

Burns 1979

or ethnic

racial

correctly

differentiate

Spencer

despite the

age

to

comparison

Ramsey

label

different

aware of phenotypic

keenly

is

than

skin color

their

American

racial

to apply

what

de

as

groups

is

rather

with

skin

years chil

Hart 1982
Damon
placed on
1988 Emphasis

For instance

African

as

society

of

not linked

is

in certain

truck

Hart

qualities

aware

1988

Spencer

ability

with

salient

catego
identify

recognize

In the preschool

brown

have
fire

ultimately determines

brown skin

she has
beled

and

they can

membership

have

become

Children

that

terms of

in racial

differences

categories

boy Damon

concrete

qualities

in

racial

possessions

and gender

when

characteristics

by physical

Harter

of the

awareness

racial

possess

dren describe themselves
fined

kiesdity Deuelopnient

tot knowledge

refers

Racial awareness

77

Development

Identity

This

approach

greater attention

For instance

interactions

1994 and

of

does

to

not

collective

Vygotsky

1962

are the source

meanings

theory to include the

for

reject

interpretive

places

of mental

social

mainstream

role

of

theo

reproduction

children

functioning

in

social

Peterson

concepts

Exhibit 22 - 5

RACIAL MESSAGES

78

about

Knowledge

1979

Brooks-Gunn
two develop

in

of

development

racial

and Whites
and

between

Spencei

1982

readiness

and

group

be

can

identity

messages

are

rounding

of

the evaluation

racial

of

own

racial

racial

or

to

the

definite

We

is

Blacks

attitudes

Black

children

so

that

the childs

in

changes
developing

Although some of these sociocultural

their

which

at

both

between cognitive

practices

variations

in

in racial

link

in

context

societal

for

only

and

given

the immediate

effect

will

to

on the most

focus

and sur

family

show

children

Therefore

and

awareness

racial

and the degree

categories

group

the

of contact

important

behavior

stage

the wider society

terms of the age

and the

choice

be

world

the

in

is

an abrupt change

messages

often mediate

community
in

to

expected

consistent

variation

but

appears

construction

their

and

sociocultural

cognitive

with

White-based

finds

the preoperational

There

the degree

groups

readiness

cognitive

ages

after

preferences

Thus

racial

alone because

exist

can

Amir 1969

identity

that

different

Lewis

simultaneously

grows

Neither

situations

social

of both

by research

others

1985

has with

child

The importance
revealed

to

response

that the

interaction

and

self

Spencer

occui

identity

which

they

salient

identify

sociocultural

socializers

The Role of Symbols
Children

in

general are influenced

In our society

black

fairy tales

only

that

and dark

are black

ing

she
test

was Black was asked

generally

children often used
they

said
the

knew

am

childs

In

an

peach

with

or pink

skin color

my

be considered

in

understanding

self-conception

of

of

One
heart

which

Exhibit 22 - 6

racial

related

childs

the use of

racial

color

identity

from

and that heroes and
other things

reject

flesh

by Holmes

1995

study

little

is

although

girl

peach

and the skin color of people

environment including

society

gleans

test she picked

doll

color

but

sociocultural

Misunderstanding

may

of

child

that

who was so
1992
girl of
Clark 1947 to take the color

to color themselves

that

on thc outside

child

and

the

Black

If

wear black

Hall

ethnographic

were not

they

Black

white the

by Clark

along

given

good

is

and witches
in

dressed

and symbols

by the language

white

Russell Wilson

pink to color herself

that

bad and

bad people

are always

princesses

dark

is

in

with
It

skin

that both
immediate

and symbols must

awareness

and

Black
stated

very dark
clear

is

the childs

language

may

they

color

and

threaten

awareness

preference

the developing
are important

Racial

aspects

Phinney

1985

Specifically

the color

like
eral

Rotherain 1987 Semaj 1985 Spencer
1989 Phinney
when presented colors to select children often do not

black
in

parents

our longitudinal

nicity
istic

race Skin color

Initial

children

the

it

had brown

skinned

light

tan

Black

color

positive

skin

closer
doll

e.g

identity

asked

identity

Cross

of

selected

to

who

their

of

selection

to

the

selected

play
doll

White

White

the

doll

found that the

White

the

doll

1974 When

Padilla

concrete

children

Black

the

those

Studies during the 1970s
the

Black

and they preferred

traits

children

the

and White

Black

doll

light

White children

Brand Ruin

children

that

and group

number of the Black preschoolers

eliminated

doll

category

selected

as having

brown

eth

of

and recognizable character

and very

very dark

them Most

like

self

and

awareness

more often than

sizable

to

of

dition

they

doll

significantly

as looking

in

sense of

lam

Black

called

not symbolic

1982 1984 1985

between

White

Furthermore
doll

racial

absolute

is

an oven

not simply

Spencer

of

studies

to choose

identified

with

age

is

helps the child develop

It

1985 Semaj 1985

ft

skin color

the preschool

during

refused to be

children

Sev

skin color

their

that

study reported

their

years

mommie At this

or

in terms of representing

especially

and early elementary

brown

79

Development

Identity

of

perception

by

doll

given

their

ad

light-

skin color

and not the White one

The Role of ShIn Color

In

American

bership
quire

by

knowledge

this

at

of skin color

attribute

than

conceptions

1983
at

Spencer

which

Butlez
skin

Harter
ing

are

1988

into groups

Morland 1976

person

Social

comparison

begin

to

They

either

belongs

in

salient

Asher

Tajfel

childs

world

in

in

early

to

1-larter

school

characteristics

years

such

as

1969 Bums 1979

systematically

absolute

particular

self-

reference to others

are believed to be

not belong

their

1981 Wilder 1986
is

ac
the

children

experiences
the

Allen

1985 and

Spencer

and members

or does

on

focus

comparison

Because

unconditional

personal

emerges

mem

children

expression of

describe themselves

Aboud 1988

is

their

Young

American

For African

more important
about

1983 Ramsey 1987

people

category

be

details

this

making

or ethnic heritage

an early age

1987

1989 Ruble
in

skin color

may

time children

color

and ethnic categories are immutable and

racial

culture

determined

is

classify

Williams

membership

in

homogeneous
category

Exhibit 22 - 7

80

RACIAL

MESSAGES

With regard to Black
aspect

Coard 1997

1998
as

it

contrasts

factor

in

Garth

1997

affect

members

other

to

their

determining

the

is

child

the

and the

ferences

of

racial

to

see

is

an

childs

skin

extremely

Jackson

awareness

differences

group

later racial

Bianchi

between

that childrens

family

in

in

coloi

important

McCullough

immediate

family should

awareness The greater the variation the

racial

awareness

by the personal

emplified

their

The degree of variation

development

less likely

of

contend

American

the African

and everything

1999 We

Drapei

within

considerably

from white to coal black

population

awareness an often overlooked

racial

childrens
varies

skin color

that

is

or

identity

of

experience

one

This

develop

will

dif

individual

opposed to

as

of the authors

is

ex

Carolyn

Murray

In

my

ent faces

mother
rainbow

and

gaits

and

whom

of different

hues

nese

family

child

is

who

preschoolers

who

those

live

in

1978

Fujioka

in

their racial

identity

terms of

develop

characteristics

in

Japan

is

States

1991

Phinney

mally think

children

live

the United

racial

very

by dark

because

my dad

skin

e.g

dark

in

skin color

salient

do not develop
do McGuire

but

when

them

In

identity

self-awareness

for

they are

environment

but

but

Child

do not nor

in the

through

give

Japa

awareness

McGuire

and group awareness

and the surrounding

e.g

For instance

racial

sum

but the

difference

found that White adolescents

salient

my

were

People

fascinated

perhaps

to notice the contrast

likely

dif

differ

and

midnights

especially
or

in

and had

White

variation or

exhibits

more

dark

had

homogeneous

is

community

was
brown

light

came

People

weights

hundred

looked

beautiful

fault

beyond

the childs

all

weight
and

sizes

as

Black

mine was

because

or

height

dark

was

sister although

loved

the

My father

like

in different

came

her

surrounding

White

was

color

as they

just

skin perhaps

If

skin

preschool

ferent colors

minority

maturation
their

meaning

personal
to

what

is

perceived

The Role of the Media
The media
tion

about

1994
Dixon

are

sociocultural

African

The media

2000

agents

Americans
teach

African

and

and

Hamilton
reinforce

Americans

are

stereotypical

informa

Stroessner Driscoll

Denise

source

negative

of

attitudes

disproportionately

about

Blacks

portrayed

Exhibit 22 - 8

as

RaciS

criminal

1986
is

less

aggressive

and

comic

that

argue

relevant

especially

2000

about

beliefs

American children

than

competent

Dixon

on

so

Blacks

to

Feshbach

to view

ucation

childs

sex or

reason

for the disproportionate

that Black

is

and

families

age

number

important
Blacks

view

television

using

Greenberg
source

and

socializer

as

of

ed

on

the

by

much more

than

adolescents

1968 and

used

is

television

and news Anderson

Gerson

television

mobile

1983 More

of

Blacks

American

it

entertainment

less

and baby-sitters

the usage

example

African

influencer

Whites

Williams

thnt

behavior

and cheap

an

poorer

of information

1982 When

Atkin

of information

than

of entertainment

For

1979

Tan

to learn dating

television

White

as
level

by Black children

television

use of

indicate

source

as

Williams 1983 Thn

This

African

television

of parental

Anderson

television
studies

from that of Whites

differs

Whites

of

Trolier

because

identity

much

as

independent

forms

alternative

more heavily on

rely

and

and family composition

are comparatively

able to afford

less

racial

twice

1988

Tangney

irresponsible

Hamilton

from media exposure

develop

children

One

1994

discussions about

are reported

flashy

Whites

Oliver

81

Development

Identity

as

report

occupations

and

baby-sitter

has powerful
of

self-esteem

as

potential

Black

children

Stroman 1991
Research
with

also

numerous

1988

Feshbach
have

1978
African
ence

is

cause
in

it

Anderson

the

and

negative

value

in

is

harmful
of

with

society

1982

to

Black

their

of the

intensity

of

the

the

family

the

major

socializing

agent

effect

be

1980
identity

cited

may

suggest

to Black

universality

racial

The Role of the Public School
Ifter

Another

heroes. Others

and

from

self-concept

Anderson 1982

communicate

positive

of Blacks

childrens

1982

that the influ

is

absence

existence

non-Black
are cast

conclusion
the

Tangney

1980 Rosse

Janis

on the self-concept of

television

out that

negatively correlated

and Whites

on them Barnes

places

the formation

frustrate

point

which Blacks

growing awareness

can

of

effect

Williams 1983 Powell

overidentification
roles

tion

the

the importance

television

dren

Graves

studies

programming

minimizes

childrens
the

Several

Blacks

and the prevailing

children

is

viewing

for

writers

about

speculated

prime-time

television

of adjustment

Various

American
negative

that

indicates

indices

For

be

that

children

some chil

of such

denigra

Come

1989

Curricultin

of Black

childrens

identity

is

schools

Exhibit 22 - 9

82

RACIAL MESSAGES

American

African

an

If

four

elementary
teen

or

we

If

years

week

child

at

Furthermore the time spent
The messages

fered are designed

school

in

such

for

The teacher
School

performance

cans

overt

receive

leave

are

similar

African

Americans

because

of the plethora

for instance
of

segment

American
hold

society

seff

by

limits
ize

lower

1999

-concept

labeling

assigning

The

these

of one

of

racist

these

authors

in

in

teacher
charge

of

Do

what your

be

successful

to

to

Carolyn

pseudo-scientific

track

beliefs

as

skin color

for

Whites

their

deficit

themselves

too

and

many

their

and so on and by

Murray and

her

curriculum

children internal

group

as illustrated

the

own expecta

where an inadequate

Ultimately

Murray

influence

negatively
fulfill

slow

large

teachers

Consequently

than

Teachers

For

and predict African

explain

1999

biased

eval

which chil

detrimental

extremely

and

lay

Blacks

for

Teachers
to

they

Ameri

parent population
is

process

words such

achievement

by

until

African

1989

1994regarding

identity

ability

all

the degree

to theft

Jackson

about

and stems from ex

and

Fairchild

stereotypes

teachers

Exhibit 22 - 10

the

by

those

going

that they

1989 Murray Jackson 1999
the

In

are rewarded

byparents

success

expectations

children with

beliefs

liked

being

of self-esteem

cognitive

Murray

them to the low

as

Children

way youre

stereotypesboth

and group

their scholastic

Fairchild

of

of

of the educational

Moreovex

characteristics

Murray

behavior

Jackson

tions

uses

academic

biased

Herrnstein

significantly

childs

1997

Murray

deficient

this

and

alert

context

from the time they enter school

children

in essential

most

are

policies

legitimized

and covert messages

intellectually

are

are

by-product

uate the probability of future
dren

hours

and the society-at-large

is

Most Black

pectations

thirty-hour

22800

and domination of minority groups

the only

is

the authority

is

day
of

children

and

Hilliard

teachers

Education

you

nine

and the type of education

communicated

lessons

indoctrinatingchildren
tells

sum

when

there

practices

in particular

the

internalizing

teacher

is

grades and intangibly such

as

six-hour

derive

of

years

will total

it

the sociopolitical-economic

to perpetuate

and of Blacks

tangibly

nine

preschool

college

average

communicated

racism oppression

support

general

the

yea we

American society the curriculum
system

and

31

Kunjufu 1984

focused

with

twelve-hundred-hour

of

years

high-school

this

multiply

two

attends

each

years

Murray

by the experience

husband

Racial

our daughters

All

beautiful

though

grade

eighth

from

the

lower

made

the

decision

the

she

year

was

that she

was

track

Before

it

because

14

Black

not due

to the

dumb

was

also
because

of

me

reality

they are

dumb

children

communicates

who

God gave them
White people
teachers

cognitive

differential

the

must be smarter
must be

status

White

are

to

in their

Blacks

domination

Racial

socialization

beliefs

about

processes

ues and

race

attitudes

or

the process

their

children

more Blacks

in

if

to jail

go

environ

low

in

it

ability

must be

Moreover

track

the

Washington

freed the

world European

slaves and
conquests

and labor manifest

destiny

must be legitimate and there
decisions

as

Adolescents

have

and other motivations
well

or

less

as

the

others

continue

will

than

for

mythology sur

significant

children

somehow

are

George

Lincoln

political

parents

in

by design

do not overtly say that

the slow

placement

the

up

Black

and Whites

to

do

not

assume

Whites

SCCIaIIZGtICn

by

which the family shapes
child

fits

within

acquire the behaviors

an ethnic group

groups

born

land

and explains how the

of

being

of

the

the

but

by which children

of such

embers

is

its

are honest

countermessages

or criminal

was

see

privilege

understand

between

positive

dumb

right

their

all

were

track

she

Abraham

Racial

the

Whites

believed

now

Black
If

is

to other peoples

right

maturity

communicate

that

grades

average

children evaluate

if

and Christianized

civilized

she

and soon Teachers

lie emancipators

tell

above

reason

Mother

dumb

know who

her

track

lower academic

circumstance

Thus

arbitrarily

years

those

all

in the

moved

her

were

scores

she

grade

the fact that

despite

upper

that

first

teacher

track

that the only

and

her

have

to

Each

the

to

that

She said

unfortunate

must be because

not

rounding

me

asked

ability

test

who remained

on concrete

curriculum

Blacks

lower

they acquire abstract thinking

are

people

track

assigned

with

she shared

children

they are more criminal

Blacks

and

achievement

ment based

fore

in the

to

each year from

of

ability

her

other

and

the

her

put

communicated

school

her

upper

been

dumb

could

the

had

When

tracks

visited

and

beginning

As and Ba and

were

per

the

she

previous

the

At

ability to
to

husband

my

life

was smart and

93

Development

Identity

Phinney

and come to
Rotheram

see

attitudes

this

context

perceptions

themselves

1987

11

and
It

is

val

and other
Although

Exhibit 22 - 11

84

RACIAL MESSAGES

the

family

the

is

1999

Strokes

Peacock

1999

receive

direct

and

awareness
fluenced

the family maintains

The African
ative

received

an

the

the church

e.g

serves
early

at

two

for

First

in

Mandara

in

of

review

the

do not Marshall

of empirical

research

cial identity

1991
trast

It

of

assumes

Nobles

1973

that the maturing
tended

ple

self

due

that about
theft

to

theoretical
differences

the Nigrescene

or intrapersonal

of racism

two

of

and

which

Murray

of African

thirds

and the remain

children

and

identity

identity

Sernaj

1985

includes

This interpersonal

between

based

Exhibit 22 - 12

in

propose

sense of

of

and ra

socialization

the

of ongoing

subject

the

two predominant
posits

primarily

that

treatment

reaction

to

terms of

definition

self-identity

Cross

racism In con

an African-centered

self in

racial

on the individ

to racial

on the corporate
view

is

model which

formed

is

race

link

toward or response

racial

which is dependent

300

identity

group

and affection

consequences

indicates

the

is

attitude

that

childs

personal frame

al 1999

race-socialize

but

confusion

individualistic

uals perception

achievement

provides comfort

on the relationship between

The most noted
is

identity

is

of

and

The family

American

African

are

systems

institutions

1986

Hatchet

in the

the development

it

et

educational

see Murray et al 1999 for
review Parham
1983 Whitty 1994 Avoid still remains in terms

development

theories

by neg

affected

1995

Williams 1993 Spencec

debate There

Allen

deleterious

literature

but

aL 1997

et

indirectly

and other value-laden

self-worth

American parents consciously
der

and

functions

Murray

press

Jackson

directly

society

and often

the negative

lessen

1982 Quattrone 1986

economic

Second

society

group stereo

political

fosters

self-identity

other behaviors

Miller

of

in

are

Murray

curriculum

notions

racial

Thornton 1997 Messages

White Jesus

it

As children mature

and

internalize

racial

of other races

people

their

role

is

that

children overhear

of Blacks

the

media

important

development

reference

family

American

within
least

1989

and treatment

through

subsystems

and

see

Murray

other races

and school

as peers

interpretive

American

conceptions

even

such

and prejudices Devine

types

to

1997

identity

howeve

suggests

reactions

developed

learn

to

they begin

racial

from them regarding

are being

identity

of

many forms When
their

observe

race

instructions

by external agents

1999

et

literature

Recent

McAdoo

awareness

in studies

ignored

the family takes

parents talking about
or

the childs

often

it is

within

socialization

of

origin

Stevenson

we
of

necessitates

view

or the

ex

ones peo
an inves

RaciS

of key

tigation

and/or

of

understanding

and

development

be

can

that children

interactions

in

experience

such

agencies

socializing

more

Burke 1980

confirmed

either

shape damage

to

likely

proposes

supported and/or

buttressed

agency the fmily and that are
surrounding

situations

This theory

identity

racial

development

messages

or

identity

peoples

protect

identity

institutions

socializing

as

$5

Idatity Development

the

interactive

Specifically

alienated

or disconfirmed
clergy

peers

by

first socializing

the

by other
and

media

teachers
Because
in

of

historical

perceptions of opportunity

Thornton 1997 Thus

ety

nificant

differences

in

factors

variations

Jackson
in racial

about

1992

Greene

African

sive

American

that

world with

To

mately prepares
in

which

parents

Either
leave

and

versa

vice

however

that

is

in

must

sig

social

mainstream norms Spencer
evidence

that

indicates

1983

Spence

status

and geo

1997

1983 Thornton

socialization

find

extreme

the

relate

Chatters

voiced

was

strategies

child

will

the

facilitate

by

about

their children

them

development

prepared

inadequately

to

or being
of

defen
the

negotiate

64

function

American

by African

socialization
to

of warning

ways

without overwhelming

perspective

racial

children

either

or

effectively

parents

ineffectively

ulti
in

the

they live

Ideally parental
those of other

and

argues

realistic

great extent

world

reflect

economic

available

Spencer

and disappointments

protective
styles

soci

should

identity

al 1997 Tatum 1987 Thornton

socialization

variations

who

racial dangers
overly

et

expe

group and of the broader

group

to

The

and

with

parents

1990

Allen

Concern

293

in

life

backgrounds

family

age gende socioeconomic

marital status

Taylor

of

the experiences

in

variability

their racial

measures

1990

Markstrom-Adams

graphic

the

and degree of acculturation

situations

to

of

amongAfricanAmericans

differences

Moreove

influences perceptions

riences

variance

within-group

States there are individual

United

major

socialization
socializing

Thornton

socialization

frequently

et

values

al 1990

occurs

incompatible

within
with

should

teachers

For

African

broader
attaining

and complement

reflect

e.g

agents

clergy

and police

American

societal

positive

families

environment

mental

health

Exhibit 22 - 13

MESSAGES

RACAL

$6

Thornton

401

al 1990

et

means by which

The process

and

Types

Black

communicate

parents

e.g we-ness

ethnic

can

group

be

ence

and/or

activities

Toms 1985

tend

dren

e.g

behaviors

identified

to be

and

overtly

parents communicate
an

literature

openly
on

discuss

issues

Howard

1985

Parham
latter

is

sumption
acquired

American
Black
ica

1998

open

receive

stand

believe

racial

to

all

within

to majority

Porter

Kardiner

Ye
is

documented

has been

Bowman

that

in

to

designed

messages

group

American
to

Howard

parents

about

1983
active

issues

socialization

Spence

and higher

and

responsibility

across

consistently

Clearly without

self-esteem

studies

unit

is

as

logical
will

be

toward African
at

least

and that opportunities

knowledge

rearing

press

racial

regarding

1983

self-concept
of unity

in

1994 1995 The

Stevenson

discussion

stance

Bowman

Mandara

1985 Murray

actively

defensive

take

racial

behave

may

deal with race issues

reactively

talk

not important

the primary

of the race

third
in

chil

messages

the family one cannot

of

Amer
under

development

many

from poorer

pared

positive

race

identity

For years
fered

racial

African

no

for

recognition

communities

parents

are

dren

more

that

through

or

little

provides

it

socialization

Williams 1993 Spencer

strategy

certain

chil

strategies

Toms

Boykin

experi

suggests that

press

never

passively

American

their

and discrimination

or

see Stevenson

sues

children

their

race

racial

that

indicates

teach

in

system

respect no matter what

with

Furthermore

Jacobs

also

in

displayed and taught to Black

of childrens

understanding

The

African

evidence

consistently

specific

1985 Smith Fogle

proactively

no monolithic

racial

or

and others

These

review

everyone

Toms 1985

Boykin

still

treat

mainstream institutions

for

Empirical

their

or ethnic group

blame perspective or

group

is

to

messages

individualism

in

aL 1999

et

identified There

readily

Boykin

race

e.g

participation

blame perspective see Murray

problem

socialization

of race

range

one

is

Messages

mainstream prescriptions

children
values

this

of Race

Effects

SocIalIzation

socialization

racial

parents address

American

African

of

researchers maintained

self-concepts

group

Washington
Oversey

members

African

from
no

Americans

suf

lower self-esteem

com

1967 Gordon

1980

Coopersmith

1979 Aside
1951 howeve

Exhibit 22 - 14

that

and consequently

easily

significant

biased

clinical

self-concept

studies
studies

Racial

wereconducted
were

1976

ing that both

the negative

siders how
Recent

who

studies

in

who

deal with
higher

negative

et

1990
those

also

It

who

are not

con

self-esteem

of

socialized

to

be cognizant

of

if

in

society

Sanders

sense of

common

fate

Rasheed 1981 and
difficult

to

oughly

certain

dictable

behavioral

This

preference

and so

on

Thornton

racial

study by

and

proactive
investigated

the

strategy

to

or whether

are often

messages

thor

in

counter

pre

outcomes

given

education

who

youth

resulting

media

and

findings

investigate

disconcerting

e.g

pride

self-esteem

inconsistent

those

especially

that for

institution

to

those

that

both

of the

al 1990

Murray and Mandara

strategies

of Black

did not

effi

1983

Spence

relate

to

attain

Rotheram

problems

These

youth

strategies

messages
grades and/or psychological

societal

socialization
et

is

and

more personal

negatively

communicated

e.g

In particula

strong inculcation

internalized

situation

youth

have

racial

studies

American

who do not

to those

behavior

that the

given

outcomes

American

1995

race

1985

in identity

along

ethnic pride

1995

about

Howard

farther

fewer

Marshall

socialization

self-esteem

i.e

other Blacks

of the messages

received

parent

grades

interpret

the content

to be

1998 Whitty 1994 and

with

behavioral

positive

that African

reported

contrast

Murray

protocol

are taught nothing

Marshall

few researchers reported that

pride

one

and

Bowman

appear

in-group messages

the broader

are

who

has been

socialized

racially

Howard 1985
Bowman
1990 and higher in-group

African

understood

interracial

messages

Borus

e.g

em

between

al 1990 show more

in-group

are

proactive

grades

about

outcomes than youth

than

development
receive

cautioned

Thornton

press

receive

children

are

research

on myth not

identity

group

who

that youth

indicate

and

Rotberam-Borus

cacy

the

Porter

earlier

inconsistency

apparent

more dearly

be

affects

1995

from

were based

identity

Cross 1991 The

socialization

race

and psychological

who

Spence

Holmes

The conclusions

indicat

Americans

of African

self-images

self-concepts

1999

and current findings can

barriers

Mandara

or

period

Banks

Americans

JAfrican
racial

Duringthis
orientation

racial

racial

nature of personal

documentation

earlier

their

especially

1989

Washington

the

and the

the personal

are often positive

pirical

on

almost

entirely
group
number of recent works provide evidence to the contrary

findings

about

1991

1939 and 1960 Cross

between
based

87

Development

Identity

to

deal with

are necessary

socialization

in press

the broader

The

suggests
societys

messages

longitudinal/cross-sectional

and personality

development

ethnic

i.e
study

among 116 Afri

Exhibit 22 - 15

SB

RACLAJ

American

can

years The

ment

reflects

change

things

teaching

children

teaches

dislike

is

of the

defensive

whereas

in

strategy

Eu

Whites Race na

e.g

issues

racism

thing

is

fectively

with

The

nities

racism and

racial

racial

These

identity
as

whether

why some

research

cialization

and

There
children

are

are

of

parents about

also

ef

commu

not found

to

predicted

content

message

not The study

as

is

impor

helps explain

between race so

relationship

positive

American

the African
about

racism

positive

racial

the needed

most

identity

1985

In

in

strategy

sum

as

chil

group iden

the absence

understand

as well

in their

from the delete

substantial
to

how

Moreove

all

of constructive

the need

lack of

effective

at

if

protection

agendas

underscores

including
the

Semaj

socialization

about

community

and

race

instill

to

children

health

families

strategies

or

hamper the development

racial

American

of various

their

mental

positive

ineffectiveness

African

give

that

influences

and

in

educated

ill-equipped

do not

dren They

fmd

not

views

many
be

that

emphasize

ac

outcomes

child

should

some parents

does

were

is

deal

to

and they only moderately

race-socializes

race-

self-esteem

strategies

and race naivete approaches

findings

and

to

exposed

positive

race

identity

toward African American

of self-esteem

parent

that

achievements

responsibility

awareness

predictors

significant

is

of Black

racial

those

for

to

exposed

in

higher

found

was

conclusion

logical

recognition

Americans

African

significantly

the reverse

strategy

through

cate

like

act

to

power

usefulness of imitating
to

race

the

active

Race-defensiveness

group

the

best

it is

modem

that

were

strategies

quired

tity

but

think

an

empower

and the abil

e.g

barriers

16

to

empowerment

Racial

identity

reflects

racial

groups

e.g

revealed

findings

self-concept

rious

their

from 14

age

past

The

tant

racial

that minimizes

strategy

racial

awareness

of

proud

other

for

empowerment

be

be

to

racial

stresses

despite

life

Racial

American behavior

ropean
ivete

in

in

racial

and race naivete

approach that

school

were

investigated

defensiveness

obstacles

at

them female ranging

of

strategies

race

proactive

overcome

to

54.3%

youth

socialization

awareness

racial

ity

MESSAGES

or

number
the

the need

of

effects
to

edu

approach

CondSon
An
can

examination
society

of
is

like

racial

identity

studying

Exhibit 22 - 16

development

plant

out of context

growth without

i.e Ameri

considering

carbon

Racial

dioxide

Clearly childrens

which

knowledge
searchers

conclude

phenomenon
racial

stereotypes
values

rocentric
to racial

the

1988

Mien

and

Blacks

Contact

The

than

socializa

implications

its

racial

proactive

children to

American

MA

Cambridge

media and

social

in ethnic

that

Blackwell

Basil

reality effects

131

Research

relations

so
face

13

rule

the

Communications

hypothesis

and

of

Eu

exposure

the

Whiny 1994 notes howeve

prejudice

1986
of

African

rather

exception

Children

orientations

1969

Anilr

the

unchallenged

Thus

issues

and prepares

childrens

Therefore

context

social

Some re

knowledge

Instead

reflect

1999

Europeanized

discrimination

racial

to

appear

Spence

their

sociobiological

as

structures

cognition

are important

Hatchett

tem

in

buffers

is

strategy

Aboud

race

Americans

of

social

to

or stereotypes

agenda

challenges

such

concerning

of race

cognitive

to

group status

minority

awareness

developing

related

development

identity

cialization

their

tied

intimately

is

identity

by

although
to

not

is

epithets

of African

tion
for

that

related

is

racial

influenced

is

89

Development

Identity

Self

and sys

97-113

ii

PsychologicalBulletin

319-342

1972

Amsterdam

Mirror

Anderson

1983 TV

Williams

children

reactions

self-image

before

two Developmental

age

5297-305

Psycholo

about

say

shows

the

they

and

Black child

the

What Black

92

watch Journal of Black Psychology

27-42
Asher

1986

Bandura

Social

1976

Banks

nomenon
Barnes E.J

ogy

Social

Englewuod

theory

Black

1969

Allen
Journal of

cesses

White

pp

Bertenthal

The

self-esteem

Black

Fisher

1978

1998

Psychology
The

in

and

Blacks

of

comparison

pro

social

action

cognitive

paradigm

in search

phe

of

1179-1186

as the source
In

Harper
Development

of positive

Jones

Ed

self-concept

for

Black psychol

Row
of

self

recognition

in the

infant

1444-50

relationships

awareness

836

perspective

New York

social

Hall

community

106-130

and

preference

157-165

Prentice

Bulletin

theoretical

Developmental
Bianchi

NJ

preference

Psychological

1980

25

foundation of thought

Cliffs

children

Racial

Issues

racism

among
individual

racial

identity

self-esteem

attitudes

collective

and optimism

among

Exhibit 22 - 17

90

RACIAL

MESSAGES

males

Afro-Brazilian
ence

Howard

ademic

1985
study

Journal of

the

work

In

ED 1985

Black

young

children

pp
1986

33-51
Racial

attitude

Ruiz

review

1980

The

Social

spective

1979

Burns

The

1989
drens

Measurement

Psychology

of

among
and

longitudinal

and

preferences

from an

interactionist

per

18-29

measurement

In

work

and

development

1947

color

among

developmental

Child Development

Racial

identification

Hall

Wilson

Russell
skin

of

ability appraisal

peers

Clark

tics

educa

Sage

development

identification

43

Theory

versus

Mastery

observations

Clark
dren

CA

Hills

712-721

requirements

Quarterly

self-concept

frame

Social

be

New York Longman

havior
Butle

self

Ethnic

children

attitudes

573

134-141

860-890

81

Bulletin

Psychological

Burke P.J

of parental

1974

Padilla

Black

ac

families

Aconceptual

Beverly

function

as

24

Psychology
socialization

study Child Development

cross-sectional

Brand

Child

of

and

motivation

in three-generational

Eds

Newcombe

Branch

The Sci

Section

socialization

youth

Blackchild

envirotunents

parental

Black

McAdoo

H.P McAdoo

and

tional

Race-related
of

Academy

American

Toms

Boykin

International

588-B 4437

achievement

Bowman

Abstracts

Dissertation

and Engineering

Eds

of

The

study

of chil

1350-1361
preschool

Negro

color

complex

New York

Americans

African

60

chil

The poli

Harcourt

Brace

ovanovich

1997

Coard
tity

and

national

Psychology

The

lege

Cook

and

352-3

1967

The

Black

iden
Inter

1523

583-B

in childrens

racial

Abstracts

peer

cultures

Social

160-177

the

education

of the

children

young

Col

Teachers

61
self

looking-glass

123

Journal of Family Psychology

Coopersmith

coloi

Dissertation

Engineering

reproduction

1998

Douglas

analysis

for skin

Americans

and

Science

552

Racism

903

Record

preferences

African

Interpretive

Quarterly

1989

Comer

among

Section

1992

Coarse

and

of

Perceptions

self-esteem

antecedents

in

family

context

social

299-309
San Francisco

of self-esteem

Free

man

1985

Cross
sonal

identity

Allen
children

Cross

Black
and

Eds

identity

reference

group

Beginnings

The

pp 155-171 Hillsdale
1991 Shades of Blacks

adelphia Temple

University

Exhibit 22 - 18

the

Rediscovering
orientation
social

NJ

on

Spence

affective

Lawrence

Diversity

Press

and

distinction

In

Afri

between

per

Brookins

development

of Black

Erlbaum
can

Amen can

identity

Phil

Racial

Damon

1982

Hart

Damon

1988

Hart

New York

Cambridge

1989

Devine

2000

Dixon
the

and

psychological

Social

color

The

Section

racial

and

Science

60-68
attitude

identity

women

American

in African

well-being

in

stereotyping

61

Perspectives

socialization

com

controlled

5-18

racial

to studying

Research

skin

and

56

Psychology

approach

American

International

stracts

and

automatic

Their

prejudice

Intrafamilial

and adolescence

Press

cognitive

African

1999

Drape

and

841-864

on childhood

Self-understanding

Personality

social

media

mass

52

Development

in

from

of self-understanding

development

Child

University

Stereotypes

Journal of

ponents

The

adolescence

through

fancy

91

Development

Identity

Ab

Dissertation

601-B

Engineering

0363
Mass media

1968

Gerson

Social

ences

1980

Gordon
Press

sity

The

and

vision

of Black Americans

self-concept

The impact

of

on

television

of minoritychildren.In

opment

behavior

socialization

differ

Negro-White

40-50

MD Univer

Lanham

America

of

1982

Graves

45

Forces

the socialization

of the

and

the cognitive

child

minority

devel

affective

Eds

Kernan

Mitchell

Berry

Tele

New York Aca

pp.37-67

demic Press

Atkin

Greenberg
research
the

socialization

1982

In

agenda

the

of

Eds

Mitchell-Kernan

pp

child

minority

from

aboutminorities

Learning

Berry

television

New York

215-243

and

Thlevision

Academic

Press

1992

Greene
American
culture

Racial

children

socialization

L.A

In

pp

Hamilton

S.J

Stroessne

nition

and

Social

cognition Impact

Academic

the

study

approach

discrimination

and

1983

Hetberington
personality

1988

Yawkey
to

with

African

with

Working

children

minority

1994

Denise
Devine

psychology

social

Eds

ad

and

Jossey-Bass

In

pp

Stereotypes

and

1986

Trolie

of the cognitive

Harte

ethnic

Driscoll

of stereotyping

on

psychotherapy

Social

San Diego

291-321

cog

Eds

1-larnilton

CA

Press

HamiltonD

Harte

with

San Francisco

63-81

in

Koss-Chioino

intervention

Psychotherapeutic

olescents

tool

as

Vargas

Eds
social

of

development

Development
Johnson

middle childhood

perspectives

Handbook

pp

processes

Eds

Academic

275-3

Integrative

45-78

Hillsdale

In

Vol

psychology

in the

85 New

construction
processes

NJ

An overview

Eds

Prejudice

Press

the self-system

on

child

pp

stereotyping

Gaertner

FL

racism Orlando

Development

and

Dovidio

Inj

and

Lawrence

Mussen
Socialization

York John
of the

Wiley

self In

socialization

Early

Erlbaum

Exhibit 22 - 19

92

RACIAL MESSAGES

Murray
1994 The bell curve
New York Free Press

Herrnstein
ture

in

America

1997 SBA

Hilliard

The reawakening

of

and

mind

can

theAfri

class

struc

Gainesville

Intelligence

FL

Makare

and group

oppression

HydeJ

MA

Lexington

bases

Cultural

racism

of

Rider Press

Health

ronment and

Ed

Black

1980

Thousand

families

pp

children

1998

Journal of

television

Eds

Abeles

Withey

Television

161-189

544

Issues

on

NJ
and

MeAdoo

In

Sage

behavior

social

Lawrence

Beyond

violence

Erlbaum

new American

the

In

decision-making

personal

and

Hillsdale

knowledge

Psychological
Social

CA

Oaks

of

influence

envi

socialization

Family

Black Americans

in

development

identity

The

1997

Gurin

McCullough

Jackson

and

Two

Vol

tions

Jones

CA

Berkeley

1995 How young children perceive race Race and Ethnic Rela
12 Thousand Oaks CA Sage
1983 Half the human experience The psychology of women 4th ed.

Holmes

Janis

1975

Trost

Struckmarm

1-lodge

dilemma

of

race

641-662

Oversey
1951 The mark of oppression New York Norton
1975 Toward the elimination of racism Elmsford NY Pergamon
Black chil
1984 Developing positive self-images and discipline

Kardiner
Katz
Kunjufu

in

dren

African

American

Brooks-Gunn

1979

Chicago

Lewis

Images
Social

and

cognition

the

of

acquisition

self

New York Plenum

1983

Marcia

Some

directions

adolescence

Journal of

Kunda

early

1986

Markus
Journal of

1995

Marshall
tions

for

and

Personality
Ethnic

parenting

1985

overtime

Racial

McAdoo

1997

McAdoo

In

The

their children

244

of the

malleability

514

in

ego development

215-223
self-concept

85 8-866

American

children

Implica

achievement

and academic

Journal

377-396

attitudes

and

Ed Black

of

self-concept

young

families

Thousand

American

fathers

Ed

McAdoo

33

of African

development

roles of African

In

and

Psychology

socialization

identity

of

investigation

Adolescence

Stability

Social

of Youth and Adolescence

McAdoo

for the

E.arly

Black

families

Black

Oaks

children

CA

Sage

in the socialization

Thousand

of

CA

Oaks

Sage

McGuireWj

McGuire

in the

spontaneous

social

environment

Child

self

concept

as

Journal of

511-529

Exhibit 22 - 20

1978

Fujioka
function
Personality

of

ones

and

ethnic

Social

Salence

of ethnicity

distinctions

Psychology

in

the

365

Racial

Mule
1982 In the
New York Praeger
Murray

of

sity

at

Jones

Ed

VA Cobb

1999

The

American

African

2001

MandaraJ
as predictors

identity

Murray

of

Strokes

can American

conditioned

Berkeley

model

failure

Univer

revisited

and parenting

youth

children

1988

An

assessment

self-esteem

1999

Five

In

pp

parenting
kinds

of

of racial

Unpublished

Peacock
review

children

and

youth

Neisse

academic

adolescent

adolescents

In

Hampton

Henry

Murray

dren

Black

of

Black

Berkeley

JacksonJ

L.Jones

Models

Ed

is stereotyping

issues

Contemporary

1989

In

California

Murray

ft

beholder

Fairchild

underachievement

nic

the

of

eye

93

Development

Identity

209-229

self

Racial

Ed

Jones

knowledge

socialization

of

Afri

American

African

VA

Hampton

and eth

socialization

manuscript

Cobb

chil

Henry

Psychology

Philosophical

3S-S9

1973

Nobles
review

Journal

1994

Olive

shows

lice

382

291

Issues

Portrayals

content

and

research

Psychological

Social

of crime

the Black

and

race

in

aggression

Journal of Broad

analysis

critical

self-concept

11-3

casting

po

reality-based

and

Media

Electronic

179-192

ParhamT

P.11993

Williams
factors

ground

to racial

identity

The

of

relationship

attitudes

back

and

demographic

191

Journal of Black Psychology

7-24

McCabe

Peterson

decontextualized

1989

PhinneyJ
lescents

1994

narrativeskill
Stages

of

social

ethnic

1991

Ethnic

CA

PorteJ B.

The

childs

Washington

studies

PorteJ B.
and

23

937-948
group

ado

13

reviewand

integration

His

208

193

Childrens

ethnic

Newbury

socialization

conception

of

the

world

London

Routledge

Paul

Kegan

tity

in minority

Sage

1952

Piaget

of

1987

Rotheram

Phinney

of developing

306

34-49

self-esteem

identityand

panic Journal of Behavioral Science

account

Psychology

development

identity

Journal of Early Adolescence

PhinneyJ

Park

interactionist

Developmental

of

Black

1979

B.

self-concept

1989

Washington
self-esteem

1979-198

Black

Annual

identity

Review

of

Developments

Revue

Internationale

and

self-esteem

in research

de

review

53-74

Sociology

on

Black

Psychologie

iden

Sociale

339-353

Powell
minority

1982
group

The impact
children

In

of television
Berry

on

the

self-concept

development

Mitchell-Kernan

Eds

of

Tele

Exhibit 22 - 21

94

RACIAL MESSAGES

and

vision

ademic

of the

the socialization

105-131 New YorkAc

pp

child

minority

Press

1986

Quattrone

On

Eds

Austin

the

of

perception

Psychology

of

InS Worchel

variability

groups

pp

relations

intergroup

25-48

Chicago

Nelson-Hall

1987

Ramsey

CA Sage
1981 Self-esteem

Ncwbury

children

Abstracts

ethic

ethnic

ethnic

difference

In

pp

socialization

56-72

The

to

gifted

child

challenge

Michigan

of

third

Dissertation

2604

Young

American

in African

identity

University

426B

International

health

and

dissertation

Doctoral

1978

Rosser

about

thinking

Childrens

Park

Rasheed
grade

Eds

Rotheram

Phinney

and

children

Young

Black

the

and Black

In

Ed

Gary

pp

community

95-113

Mental

Philadelphia

Dorrance

1990

Rotheram-Borus
and

adjustment

Adolescents
of

Journal

choices

reference-group

and

Personality

Social

self-esteem

595

Psychology

1075-1081

1987

Ruble
In

The

New York

Wilson

Hall

Russell
color

among

1998

Sanders
racism

and

Spencer

Afrikananity

pp

development
Smith
tion

Issues

59-72

Hampton

VA

Cobb

1982

Spencer
synthesis

Genetic

gies

An

self-concept

25

In

achievement

Assessing

social

to

response

83-93

self-identity

The

and

In

affective

Erlbaum
ethnic

parental

Ed

Johnson

as

661

external

Lawrence

of skin

Racial

socializa

socialization

cultural

34

Review
Black

values

183
and

An

children

alternative

59-84
child

parental

rearing

strate

351-370

childrens

interpretation

Black

identityof

Monographs

race

awareness

racial

Journal of Child Psychology

attitudes

and

and

Psychiatry

433-441

1985

Spencer
Black

childrens

Eds
pp

NJ

and group

Childrens

1984

Spencer

and

politics

Brace Jovanovich

Education

Beginnings

in press

Psychology

Developmental

process

psychology

Henry

Personal

1983

Spencer

Eds

implementation

complex The

Harcourt

Academic

Hillsdale

Jacobs

and

color

cognition

Allen

Fogle

The

New York

Journal of Negro

Brookin

developmental

Wiley

obstacles

Overcoming

in

topics

1992

discrimination

1985

Semaj

John

Americans

African

self-socialization

self-knowledge

Contemporary

243-270

pp

of

acquisition

Ed

Eisenberg

Cultural
personal

Beginnings

215-230

The

Hillsdale

Exhibit 22 - 22

cognition

growth
social

NJ

and

and
In

social cognition

Spencer

affective

Lawrence

as identity

Brookins

development

Erlbaum

of Black

factors

in

Allen
children

Racial

1988

Spence

New

development

Self-concept

95

Devdop.nent

Identity

Directions

Devel

for Child

opment 42 S9-72

1999

Spence

of an

plication

cultural

and

ethnic

school

ecological

The

adjustment

ap

Educational

perspective

43-57

1990

Markstrom-Adams

Spence

on

influences

cultural

identity-focused

341

Psychologist

and

Social

children

minority

Identity

America

in

racial

among

processes

612

Review

Developmental

290-310

1994

Stevenson
American

204

Psychology

tion

to

racial

and

socialization

and

Theoretical

socialization

self

and

Televisions

1979

Tan

29

Communication

TangneyJ

socialization

Education

and

social

Television

1988

Bulletin

and

differences

chology

1987

141

1997

Mainstream

African

603

Henry
American

314-327

Cambridge

Uni

Eds

CA

Oaks

Childrens

of

racial

cultural

Family

life

Journal of

frequency
and

Personality

CT

Social

In
Psy

Greenwood

socialization
In it

messages

in

and

among Black parents
Taylo

pp

Black America

Taylo

environmental

Jackson

16-248

Thousand

1962 Thought and
1992 Supporting biracial
of

children

1994
At The

152

speech

of

racial

MIT

Cambridge

children

socialization

by

in

the school

Press

setting

Education

and

163-172

Ethnicsocialization
significance

1990

Allen
correlates

61 401409

Black parents Child Development

males

Blacks

television-viewing

correlates

blues Westport

Strategies

Chatters

Sociodemographic

WhittyJ

of

Sage

Thornton

Treatment

self-esteem

145-158

minority and

Chatters

and

use

demographic

Assimilation

Thornton

fi

of

African

Cobb

New York

categories

Ed

Jones

identity

129-135

Feshbach

dividual

Wardle

In

HamptonVA

Henry

racial

measuring

Journal of Negro

adolescents

role

African

Press

Tan

Vygotsky

further

identity

Ed

VM Cobb

Hampton

217-255

racial

Jones

in

socializa

49-70

measuring

In

in the

1981 Human groups

versity

Tatum

self

of racial

211

in

further

considerations
the

Extending

1991

children
Tajfel

for African

Journal of Black

perceptions

217-255

Theoretical

developmentpp

identity

Stroman

Socialization

Psycholo

considerations
the

Extending

1999

American

of Racial

multidimensionality

Journal of Black

Americanidentitydevelopnentpp
Stevenson

Scale

of adolescent

Relationship

identity

H.C 1998

Stevenson

the

toward

Steps

445-468

1995

Stevenson

of

Validation

adolescents

of

ethnic

The

case

identity

and

socialization

for African

Exhibit 22 - 23

96

RACIAL MESSAGES

American
ducted

youth

at the

from

Findings

Fifth Biennial

adolescence

pre-to-Iate

Meeting

of the Society

of

symposium

Research

con

on Adolescence

California

Wilde

1986

intergroup

chology

Social

bias

In

University

Berkowitz

Vol 19 pp 293-255
Morland

Williams

categorization

of

North

1976
Carolina

Exhibit 22 - 24

Advances

New York
Race
Press

color

and

for creation

Implications

Ed

on

experimental

Academic
and

the

reduction

of

social

psy

Press

young

child

Chapel

Hill