State Of New York et al v. Mnuchin et al

Filing 47

DECLARATION of Owen T. Conroy in Support re: 44 CROSS MOTION for Summary Judgment .. Document filed by State Of Connecticut, State Of New York, State of Maryland, State of New Jersey. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59, # 60 Exhibit 60, # 61 Exhibit 61, # 62 Exhibit 62, # 63 Exhibit 63, # 64 Exhibit 64, # 65 Exhibit 65, # 66 Exhibit 66, # 67 Exhibit 67, # 68 Exhibit 68, # 69 Exhibit 69, # 70 Exhibit 70, # 71 Exhibit 71, # 72 Exhibit 72, # 73 Exhibit 73, # 74 Exhibit 74, # 75 Exhibit 75, # 76 Exhibit 76, # 77 Exhibit 77, # 78 Exhibit 78, # 79 Exhibit 79, # 80 Exhibit 80, # 81 Exhibit 81, # 82 Exhibit 82, # 83 Exhibit 83, # 84 Exhibit 84, # 85 Exhibit 85, # 86 Exhibit 86, # 87 Exhibit 87, # 88 Exhibit 88, # 89 Exhibit 89, # 90 Exhibit 90, # 91 Exhibit 91, # 92 Exhibit 92, # 93 Exhibit 93, # 94 Exhibit 94, # 95 Exhibit 95, # 96 Exhibit 96, # 97 Exhibit 97, # 98 Exhibit 98, # 99 Exhibit 99, # 100 Exhibit 100, # 101 Exhibit 101, # 102 Exhibit 102, # 103 Exhibit 103, # 104 Exhibit 104, # 105 Exhibit 105, # 106 Exhibit 106)(Conroy, Owen)

Download PDF
Exhibit 84 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  B B <GF>ÿ =‘’ t=ÿCHÿ ? >=DB ; “„{ÿ Š| “uu… ” \`^\Y_ÿ W ÿÿ] ^ Y_ÿW P]ÿQdU\ÿ] SYÿ ÿW \\ PYÿUX O ÿ Ya `W cY• d\_W] Z ]\ P• PeU dÿ X`\Z –QXPdÿOeaX ] e X T B <GF>ÿ =‘ÿ =@D—ÿ CHÿ ? >=DB “‘? ? “GG˜ ;z{™| F zšBƒ x yyÿz wÿu~} z { ÿ ›œ -8 . /, NOP JSSSTUQWY[\ P^ ^ `^\ PQRJ PV X Z]\T _J Y Z W a _b W L Y `W c ] ; @>ÿB =ÿ F ÿCH=; <=>?? ;CB CDEÿG>CFB '( +(,./. +ÿ 210 4+5 1 )ÿ ÿ--ÿ0 1 .ÿ +33 . ( 3 IK J 32 6/-7,)(9 0( ÿ./ÿ 8: Lÿ PPQRJSSSTUVQWXZ[Z\]P\^W^_J`^YaY_b NO J P Y T \] `W cO Sb bPPb] XZXU\bU\b ^L W JW dWeU\U db Ub XePV eSWc W e fg hklÿnohmp hgiÿ m ÿ ffqif rstuvÿ xz{z wÿ zÿ w zÿ ~ ÿz {ÿ … wuÿyyÿ| } }| €w }|u‚{yƒ xvu„† u~   Cs@ yˆ {xz{ÿ| y{EyyuŠ>u}‚‹ÿ € ÿ uz ‹z{ u„‡u| ÿyyxz wÿ‰ ÿ x„~ÿ ÿ  z} ‡‹„ wˆ xw { |  D{ yƒ xu|w zÿ ~ s vÿ ‚Œx{z wÿ{ | x{ ÿz ÿ } z {ÿ ÿ €w }|u‚{ÿ tz ‰„ÿ| B| {x{yƒu|‡  | ; w zÿ ~ ÿ„ w | ÿ| y„xs { { ÿyyxwuÿuy | €w }|u‚{Šu‚ÿ €w{ wxz wÿ {{yÿ € |xz{ÿ |  F u€ | yƒw zÿ ~ ÿ ÿ| ÿws u~} {| |xÿxz{ z ÿ €w }|u‚{uŠz ‡…| ÿ zÿ „‚{ yÿ Ž ÿyyx | }€ ÿ‰ ÿ ÿ ~ ÿz ÿ ÿuŒÿ ÿyyÿz {s { ‡y{„uv| u‚{yƒu|y uŠxz{yƒ x | tuvÿ ~ÿ{ {  ÿ xz{z wÿ zÿ {| |x~ }~ÿ„ w zÿ ~ ÿz {† ‚‰„€ | {wuÿyyÿ| } } „‚{ yÿu} yŠu‚ÿ €w }|u‚{yƒ x u~ u€ { |   1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   0& 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  ')*,- *0 023 43* 6 8 ÿ 4- <9 ÿ /* (-ÿ((ÿ@02B3ÿ 0 /4** B < ((ÿ ./1* (ÿ-4 (5ÿ7 9:;;0 =>*30ÿ?2)*- A- /*,* *)ÿ .0 * * 4 / 0 ( ÿ ?- ;5;; )ÿ 3 1*(C 2;ÿD EF) *8H J@02B3K/.0 ** 3B 2 /1ÿ .5B 40- ÿ)*ÿ 9 8 ÿ :4ÿGI A- /* ÿ** B ÿC45* 0 ; 3 0 P* ;(/ ./1* (4/0?/H ÿ- ()(ÿ 34 ./1* (N- 30/(5ÿ ÿ /40 ÿ @ 0*,- *0 0)ÿ) 2*2ÿ 3 0/2N- )ÿ *0 02ÿ 0* ()* ; O)M) 5N ( LM 4 ,Q /N ;N 0 T 0 24) ;N-43* U2ÿ7 ÿ 4- <7>*30ÿ?/.0 * -Rÿ -ÿ 5ÿ* 0M.0)ÿ 4 (5ÿ (6 D:;;0 ÿ /* (-ÿ** B H JS ) 3* B 4 V /M- *2)*ÿ0 WXÿ .ÿÿ - 5A 25ÿ 5;; )ÿ 3 1*(Cÿ )RN 4/5)ÿ .5) -(A0 ÿ((2) 5ÿ 4 M):/) :)* ; .5B 40- ÿ)H 2)ÿ -; N ) N * 0 ; Y4 V P* Z [) ) 0 ; ' BSW)-)ÿ* )N 2;,(0ÿ0 [M 1;,ÿ ÿ-ÿ)*)2)*;5;; )ÿ 3 1*(C - (ÿ R (N C2ÿ S0 - N 5ÿ - 0 5-0 (S .ÿÿ((ÿ .5B 40- ÿ)H O)M) 5ÿ*;5ÿ 2ÿ0(*(Cÿ-43;,ÿ\>*30ÿ?3 1:;* 2)*) 5ÿ 34 @02B3 /40 /4 1-(- ÿS ÿ)N 4 (0 9 ÿ /* (-ÿ- 0 5ÿ((ÿ0 4 )ÿ A- /* * 3* - (0 XJ/ O) ) ,* *)ÿ** B ÿ/1ÿÿ ÿD Eÿ 0 *(3(ÿ * 0ÿ 2)S 2(2ÿ0 P* Q /ÿ4 0 /4 .0 *?- ;; 9 8 H 0 3;BN ,- N 23B*(N 5ÿ @ÿ-R)4 / 3 43* )- 0 9 ÿ /* (ÿ -4 (5ÿ/B 5ÿ]>*30Hÿ * ÿ Z ÿ((2@;S):/) :)* ;5;; )ÿ 3 1*(C3 43* 42ÿS 08 ÿ /* (-ÿ-) @-2)*ÿ (ÿÿ - 5A 25ÿ .5B 40- ÿ)ÿ-4 (5ÿ 2() ÿD>*30ÿ?((4 0 ; * * - / P] 2)*) 5ÿ 34 @02B3ÿ 0 /4** B ÿ/1ÿS ((Cÿ /SW)-)Fÿ /* (-ÿ** B G ((ÿ0 4 )ÿ A- /*,* *)ÿ .0 *?- ()ÿ)H (ÿ R (ÿ >*30ÿ?/.0 * /45ÿ )(- ÿS ÿ)H @ÿ 1>2; ÿ0 Z0 * 2*ÿ (ÿ 3ÿ /ÿ1;* ;5;; ) *; 4 2ÿ0(*(Cÿ _) S/ ) 5ÿ* 0 *2N S1BS1-*4 (5ÿ .5B 4 ** P* * @; ; 0 3* ;3 1*(C 2ÿ-43* ) Bÿÿ /* (-ÿ** B ÿ/1ÿBS(C 2ÿ 0- ÿ)*N 4 (5ÿ:- (8>*30ÿ?/.0 *?- 23ÿ)*H  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   2& 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  (ÿ,-/ÿ++0.3. /56- +ÿ /ÿ8 9ÿ,)9:99 1ÿ 3 6-+< 0ÿ 10ÿ1ÿ02 )+ .-01-ÿ 1ÿ -) )0. 7+-52 ÿ /:; .)2 ÿ1-= .28 09ÿ,) 2 42 ) 9 >?ÿ + 9 ( 9 9 9:99 1ÿ 3 6-+<ÿ ÿA Cÿ :99 1ÿ 3 6-+< 0E5/:- 1 ÿ/54-2ÿÿ 5- +2 ) /:; .)2 ÿ1=)@ B D) /:; .)2 ÿ1-ÿ 2 9 :ÿ)1-1 ÿFGE-3)ÿF 5 ) 5 ) .3. ,)0;3ÿ ) 5.-- ; ÿ ÿ8 0ÿ++0ÿ1 494ÿ56ÿ 0ÿ8 )BE-3)ÿ ÿ )1 2 1ÿ H2 5-4- -1ÿ /) -9 +2-01-D ) ) F2 . 0+1 ÿÿ 5- +9 I1 00 2 1 :ÿ - )+ÿKE-3)ÿ ÿ 5.) ) J542 ÿ2@ ÿ 5- +9 L171 := ) MN PRT ÿÿO W Oÿ UVWRPY Z[ S X L2+01-ÿ2.,ÿ8 ÿ- 5. F 99)2ÿ11 -93 6-ÿ ++--1-- 3E+2 0ÿ , 0ÿ++0F. +-F:-1ÿ 9+2 ÿF+<\.ÿ 2 D ÿ8 5ÿ5ÿ<- 9)= 2 :- ) ) \; ]^1 85ÿ) _) -0-+<2 .ÿ /:- :01 :ÿ +50= ++0ÿ2 /52+)1 7 6E09 1 :ÿ- ) 0- ÿ1ÿ)7:99 ) ÿ) 9 --+ÿ 1-D ,--D F- ÿEE. ) ` 8 ÿ :9-- +5.0+1 ÿ8 ÿ- 5. /56- +F5351)+E-ÿF93 6-ÿ .-+-F:-1 F 5)ÿ;-ÿ8 )+-F:-1ÿ -) )ÿ2ÿ-+9ÿ7 02ÿ 2 = 9 ÿ8 ÿ- 5. F 42 ) a)b 42 -) )D++02+)+<6; 99 . ) 9+50ÿ56ÿ-;99090- 2 +9 ÿ8 +01/56- +ÿ 1-ÿF- ÿ1ÿ )3E1ÿ :ÿ --+F2 035+-ÿ ; :ÿ;0:-+1ÿ++D 0 \2 ) 0 2 ÿ ) c- I1 1 :ÿ )ÿ. ,ÿÿ;. 5E1+1ÿ< 6E+2 ÿ2ÿ )9)93 6-ÿ 3).D )1ÿ) J82 ) 61 71. 1F.2ÿ 59. - 9)F5E- 02 ÿ 2 = - +7ÿ 001 :ÿ 9  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   &' 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  ( ( ( /*(0ÿ3/3ÿ 0 4,146 *(2 -ÿ 15 17+ÿ 6 *(ÿ ÿ 5ÿ,,/ ) *+,-ÿ0 ÿ1230(+1+1(0ÿ 0 ÿ5 +2,(/4 4 0 85*2 :/2(; ÿ 5 5 9 , 0 ,) :1ÿ 04( =ÿ7 4ÿ( 132ÿ -?,0 /2 -ÿ34 -( 645ÿ0ÿ,,ÿ5 363 2+2(/<7 ÿ *4(,(1>-(2ÿ )-( 645ÿ5 62*ÿ -?,0 />1/2(2 -ÿ 2 , ,) /*2ÿ0ÿ -?,,0(,) /0 ÿ7 4ÿ,,ÿ 6 *(,)1,1/ÿ 2(ÿ :5 ,-( 6ÿ7 /ÿ2(ÿ5,(1/2(4 0 ÿ2ÿ(?58 5 G F ABCÿ FEFF Jÿ L ÿJ ÿJNÿJSJQ RRJNT EBÿ HEI KGBMNOPQORH QÿLBRÿOOR U0,/2(46 *(,) /2(>43ÿ3,ÿV54ÿ7 /ÿ,,/,2ÿ++3ÿ 2 2( 1,/ÿ W7 /ÿ,,ÿ 0 ÿ2(ÿ1ÿ21:> ; ( ÿ ,0(/2(ÿ7 ,2 :W1-? ,-ÿ2(8 , 5 2( 5 X4 ÿ <7( 7 /2(ÿ /ÿÿ4W3ÿ2ÿ2(0 ÿ346 *(ÿ 4ÿ /0 1ÿ2ÿ7 ÿ /ÿ ,ÿZ,)[16(/ ,,/4 (2/5 (,)1,ÿ52350 ; 3 U4/?4 /,(*0,<47Y ÿ2ÿ 2\ ,8 *+0 ]+ÿ 1 5 32(ÿ0ÿ,,ÿ 6 *(,)4ÿZ _15 -ÿ1*ÿ8a+(65ÿ ÿ( 5:V52, 0 *2W42ÿ ,/>1/2(4 0 ÿ2ÿ ^ Y ÿ2 W( >0 `Z ÿ 1( ,4 b 5 /32 4ÿ0 1 5 5 5 5 > 5 3 5 Y 8ÿ 1( ,4ÿ 3052 53-4Wÿÿÿ 1( ,/17 1 ÿ546 *(ÿV1e ÿ 30 ÿ ÿ7 , ``+(65ÿ c24 14d46? 5 2Y+(65ÿ?62W(0 ÿ 0 /0 (ÿY*4454 ,2 ÿ , /2(f4 1ÿg9ÿ,,/<47*?,+3ÿ2ÿ 2\ ,;7 ÿ0 ,)[16(ÿ>( ÿ W4/2ÿÿ(: ,,ÿ W?(^85/2(ÿ ,ÿ 34 (,)[16(/ÿ (,+ÿ2ÿ 2\ ,0,5[( 5ÿ,2V1 > 3<ÿ V3 >,)[3ÿ 6 *(ÿ 2 *2ÿ0ÿ)*+3; 2ÿ7( ÿ2(; ,,(,+ÿ2ÿ 2\ , 0 3 (ÿ ÿ22 (4 0 8 [2 ; 1( 2 (ÿ /,1(1,/ÿ ÿ7 ÿ0 ,)[16( ( 0 5 h3 > 7 [? 5 *2 , : 2 9 , /2,ÿ,,)[3ÿ 6 *(0ÿ`Z Zÿ \5 4ÿ/( ,23ÿÿ3,,)ÿ ÿ,(ÿ,,/ÿ7 ,1/2ÿ22 (4 0 ÿ>e ;Z ; 4Wÿ (/543 2> ÿ28507 1/2(; ( -4(( 6ÿ , ( ÿ7 ÿ <(,2 -ÿ7 ÿ4 (,,)1,/4ÿ*232 ?ÿÿ 1( ,W(+05/4 > 15([(<( 5,(3 /ÿ5 ,(7W7 /ÿ2ÿ2(ÿ / 3ÿ[0 ,^+(652 ÿ 4,ÿ > 0 / i 5 j2 //2 -ÿ /4/++4>1( 2 ( 52ÿ5 U4//4 ;0ÿ)*+38 ÿ k73ÿ /ÿ,,/>3 <( ,(>-(2ÿ V1*( ,ÿ 2 4ÿ( 65 ,(5 *[(ÿ>46 *( 4 *0,/2(ÿ03 -ÿ7 ÿ( 13 (5 5l3 -ÿ 1-?4Wÿ7 ÿ? 10ÿ 0 ( 0 W0 /( 5 5 ,)[16(/4ÿ7 ÿm Z;7 1ÿ2ÿ ( ÿÿ ,0ÿ( (/0 8 30522 -ÿ <ÿ0\7 V 2ÿ 2\ ,ÿ ,(Y n /ÿ ((7 /[( 523 ÿ>1W1/45ÿ 4 14ÿ5 o( p 1ÿ2( 5 , 0 c2> 0 ( 3 ( > 5 c2> 4 /-ÿ( [16(/f>( ÿ23-ÿ*445 4 lÿ2(rÿ0ÿ4 s 6 *(,) :18 3052 *+0( 5 <ÿ 2\ ,ÿ ,563 q 30 21 /,) /g 17W74 0 ÿ2+2(/ÿ 4 14 2 0 ( 2*445 4 lÿ2ÿ ÿZ `,2ÿ--/Y+(652 ÿ 4,,ÿ7 ÿ2(2 4-ÿ0 ++1V-ÿÿ 30 21 /,)4 ^ Y ÿ7 ,2 ÿÿ 1( ,W(+05ÿ0,(1,ÿ++3 , 3 ( 5 ( 46 *(ÿV1e ÿ 30 8 4 31:ÿ <ÿ0\/,+ÿ2ÿ2(0ÿ8^+(65ÿ++3/,ÿ 6 *( 50 /0 (ÿY*445ÿ *4 3; p 1lÿ0 ,)1,ÿ>nn ÿ 1( ,2 4 ÿ04 0 3 t 2 o( ( 5 2 Vÿ[0 ,e ÿ 30 8 [0 (2 ?ÿY*445 3 c24 14; 5 (02ÿ5 u1W0 ÿ2(,+ÿ2(ÿ[0 (m+(6580 ; <ÿ(/:ÿ < 3052ÿ 5 /,; -ÿ ( 57 Vÿ0 1,/2 Vÿÿ 1( ,ÿ <2ÿ v1(; > U4 2 9 o( o( 2 5 p 1; (*0 ,ÿ5 xcÿ2(,+ÿ 6 *(,)1,/2 Vÿ8ÿ 1( ,ÿ 0\ÿ 1 5; -ÿ 7 Vÿ0 4 0 ÿ2ÿ2(ÿ[0 (nn+(658 w  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   &' 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  ()*ÿ -/0ÿ/ ÿ/ .5 4-/ ,ÿ -,)ÿ..-.1234/ÿ 7ÿ7 5 08 6/ )9:<=?A;ÿ= CDÿEAÿA @: H?A Bÿ ?;ÿK ÿA ÿ?M B;ÿ; E:A ÿK R@SA: ;; ÿ@@?A Bÿ @; @FGHAÿ =ÿ= : ??@;?L;Aÿ= ENB;AÿOP ;ÿAÿ: IA J : Q EAH; FGHAÿ H?ÿ: Oÿÿ BM@J ÿNM @ÿWX XNE= @FGHAÿ ?;U = G;LH ; : BÿA @: =U : AB; FH=JÿGÿJV UX ÿJÿ;ÿA @:J??ÿ Bÿ E @ T IA AJ : A : [J ÿ @S REÿJFERJ ;ÿ= ?BÿA @:J??@ÿM ; ; @RA?ÿ O;;U ?ÿ@@?@S AGA;?@ÿAEÿ<EM M; FGHAÿ ?;ÿJ?Y?ZM =ÿ; EP <ELJ@?A;ÿA FGHAÿ H?AÿK ÿA ÿA;AÿE = Eÿ F L;ÿ HÿK ÿ; E: <EL; @GE<B;ÿ A @: =ÿ@@;?L;E@ÿ?JBHARH J U : @;NB;Aÿ ;= =ÿ J H ?A IA = OK; IJ E \; ; R IA A GENE=H:A;ÿ Oÿ LG?H ÿM:ÿS LG@ÿA @: H?ÿ= Q= ;?;@S ?J :ÿA @: ;;; @Aÿ @P [A KE N: ; ; ?FGHAÿ =U Bÿ; = ?; ÿA;ÿ=RFGHA N ]E J IA=ÿELÿK ÿA;Jÿ @AÿM BÿK E?ÿ HJ A; ; ?^ ÿ E; @Jÿ = @E FGHA H?NJ @;?:ÿNLMM : = ?A;P T= ÿS LG@ÿ_G;F=ÿN: I`;LÿA @: aA @ IA=U = \; a; HJ; ; ?_ ÿ E; @ÿ ?AK ?@?K ?H?J ÿR@LÿJÿAHI H?ÿ Bÿ Oÿ SF ÿS LG@ÿXG;F=P ?FM;@ÿAÿ ÿO=??; NE@S= A IA b FGHAÿ H?ÿ Hÿ OAH Aÿ=A@EAH;FGHAÿ H?@Sÿ; =R<=AA Bÿ A LAJ : A @: =U : [A HK ?A ÿ:;= @<ÿA @: =ÿAP = ?:A Hÿ= ]:YA ÿ=R IA OK; ÿ A:Oÿ ?;ÿJY;B; F; HÿK ÿ; E@AÿK RA;HFE; ÿ Hÿ Oÿ;?RBJ ?= @A:O : : ??@ÿ ÿ BM@Bÿ @;RAÿK @@;ÿEÿ MEBU : \; cE;ÿ ;ÿJÿ: J J = = OK; J  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   &' 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  (*+ÿ).+/+ 1+ 2) )/57851 4+ÿ; ÿ+ 55<ÿ>*7+ÿ; --?51 4+<+ +7( )**-ÿ ÿ /0-/ÿ34ÿ3 6 3ÿ ) 9 +34766 = ÿ--*-7ÿ7ÿ ) ÿ 6 3( 6 : 6 8 <7 1 2( @ÿ; ÿ+ 3(374+ -)ÿ7 -( 5*B;-ACD -? (8+6-3)3 *75-1D--E374+6)( -+2/+7ÿ+ - 6ÿ21A57ÿ 6ÿ - D@@@97A)5 1 +9 <D--*5**7+-+ - E ) <7 ) @5 ; ) H) 5 ) 1A57E 5*7 /E *+FG -ÿ ++ 1A- 6)ÿ750ÿ--EA+51+ 1056ÿ6 /+ 1569 7 -( 6E6 ( ** ÿ ;- ÿ?+ 5 ÿ2 3 **7+* 12 ÿ?(*) *7 /ÿ /0- * T T Z IJKÿ NPQÿP ÿ U ÿPT Mÿ ÿ X WYWN US N MJÿOONORS JVQQ WQ S JOQÿ SMSOJT[ \1 4+-?5ÿ 6 3(ÿ */ÿ ÿ; ÿ--ÿ ÿ 5;-+51 4+5ÿ76 /9 ) ÿ--* 6) ÿ7ÿ <+ +7(5 + .8-+*7+5 @;1ÿ; ÿ ) ÿ + 3+ ÿ 4+*7+G * 84A) 6 6 * ] ; @++G 7++ -3/ÿ -ÿ+5 ) 587 + 4+ -ÿ -ÿ-+ÿ--*-7ÿ( @ÿ0*/+51 4+ ) H3; Hÿ6++ 5 )31A31-ÿ<3+ 6*@5;); 3*7+ÿ; -7( ) -5 ÿ ) ÿ 6 ) 6 6 ^ _7 -ÿ ÿ7+ 5ÿ; ÿ--ÿ23*/+ 19 )ÿ?4A(G 3(6 *31A31-ÿ<3+ 6ÿ -ÿ ).+-? /ÿ -+*7+)ÿ+5 6+ÿ 3+ 7 +ÿ 87 /`ÿ+5 ) 587 + 4+ -@5;ab 7(@*_787 /ÿ)-?51 4++ 3+ 5ÿ; ÿ *31ÿ ÿÿ 3(6 3*/+ -ÿ ÿ2= e G > ( ÿ 3(6 -ÿ7ÿ ) ÿ76 /ÿ -+a5-5-.87_787 /ÿ+5 69 )ÿd dÿ ) 6 6 c* e : 8*7+ÿ6 abÿ7 7 A-/ÿ+5 ) 587 + 4+ -98 1(G; *ÿ3ÿ--*@5;47) --*7 /ÿ ; /ÿ/) + 31A31-ÿ<3+ 6*ÿ A57(ÿ ++7+*7+ÿ -ÿ f3 + ) +*1)+-ÿ; ÿ 3 37 /ÿ3 ÿ) -32 @*5ÿ -ÿ 31569 4A(83ÿ(*ÿ)-+.)/+ÿ6 ( <+1 440+ÿ( ÿ .);/5 -) *ÿ 7 ) 6 + hPPi WQ OÿJZUN ^ /+756)ÿ7ÿ 6*3-39 --ÿ 1 4+:? *ÿ--ÿ /55 7ÿ 1 4+:? *j7ÿ7+ + 3-) ÿ2:?c/455-7)*ÿ 7+\ ) ÿ7+9 7+\ H/0 (6) ÿ7+ÿ ?3-* ] 6 ] 6 \ : E = 23-?87ÿd kEÿ*)ÿ7 0 3ÿG d k9 )ÿ7ÿ+ 3= e ÿ 7ÿ2l6 78eÿ e m n]b+ **o0+ 0ÿ--ÿ q 1( H34+ -^6 6+ ÿ 60ÿ 37 9 7+pÿ) 7ÿ +6 6ÿ57 19 ] r) :?s (8b+ -3]7+7 /ÿ) 7ÿ57 1ÿ -ÿ +8]*+ ÿ .7 ÿ *50+7 /ÿ ) u6 7ÿ)5 ÿ 6+9 --ÿ6 q 1( 6 6+a77t0 3ÿ8-49 6\ ---ÿ6 o3) 5<* 1 ÿ ^ n3 6 v7 a9 \*5056ÿ *5<-6ÿ b9 6---) G ;6 ) G w WX WxQ MSy ZOQÿ P T o36 3G H/9 d >ÿ--ÿ7ÿ 58ÿ s)(57ÿ 3A+-HG 6 + ÿ *5<-6ÿ ÿ .7 0 )5a75 ÿ d 9 7+:?s)( C 51( * 15+ÿ /ÿ/9 ;6 ) G n3 6 ÿ = ] 1 cÿ - s+ = v7 abC \*50+s+* 6---ÿ3*9 zzz9 d {ÿ)1(7ÿ 58ÿ ^ /+75-s+* 15+ÿ6 + ÿ *5<-6ÿ ÿ .7 ÿ d 9 7ÿ ?s)( C + 3( ÿ 3A+-HG /ÿ/9 ;6 ) G n3 6 = q : 1 cÿ * = v7 abC \*50+s+* 6---ÿ3*9 |(G 1G 6 ] 6 ÿ@76ÿd >ÿ /55 7ÿ 1 ÿ7ÿ )H*)6ÿ ÿ; ÿ--*ÿ /5) C 5 ÿ uÿ /ÿ7 /8] 59 e 96 H/0 (6)4+:?s3 55 *5 -+]7+9 *6 6 }5 7 = \ \ 6 _7 o0 v51 65ÿ+ *75+^*7ÿ 37 9 *) *6q <5(-Hÿ51( + 0 })uÿ) 7; 6b97 /ÿ 3ÿ ÿ <6 3= e 9 \ÿ; 3ÿÿ 6 +-) ÿ - + ÿ 1A31-ÿ6 3G 6 -7 ÿ G 6 r78c9 +9 d =ÿ *-++7b) 6 156.+@+ 6}+5 ) 587 / l ÿ v7 ÿ ~ 1 eÿ :?b) --) ÿ .(ÿ57 1ÿ H+ ÿdjm‚ ƒe 9 7ÿ 4A+556€s0 5^6 6+}+5@ ÿ C ke >  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   &' 1 0132 0 02 14 3 56 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ  6 ÿ  76ÿ 6  7ÿ6 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ  ÿ  ÿ  6   ÿ  kml mpqÿstmruk l nÿ r ÿ vnk k EFG JKKKLMHOQST GV V GHQJGGZU PRP\] \ GHIJ GN P RUTL WJO R\MTM jZ MZ\T` R O O Q kml mpqÿstmrl l nÿ r ÿmwnk EFG JKKKLMHOQST GV V GHQJGGZU PRP\] \\MTM jZ RPMT` GHIJ GN P RUTL WJO R\MTM jZ MZ\TJGGZU P MZ N \ R O O Q O G '()*+ÿ 012 -()./ 34 65969:<=:;ÿ99 < ÿ 8A=A ?8C9 6D 5ÿ8ÿ4 ÿ; 89ÿ> ?@ 9> ÿ 5ÿ 9@ @: 8 ; ; B; EFG JKKKLMHOQST GV V XVTQWZ O J MZVZO VTZTT ] Z RP ^V_T G` GHIJ GN P RUTL WJ QY XO [KF GMT\]R\V^U TP MZ TU U\ R O U O WO ()*+ÿ d a)bc e; g;:595 gÿ =A59ÿ59ÿ 8D fÿ ÿ66ÿ@ A 5ÿ A:6h:f;i ; : EFG JKKKLMHOQST GV V XVTQWZ O JO jO\MTM jZ RPMTZMTZ V` GHIJ GN P RUTL WJ QY XO [F KZ ZGGZU P MZ P\GN \KO[ R O U O \ xÿ XM ÿ \Q]Tÿ O [U ÿ \Q]QUÿU QjQQ Mÿ]F Vy | ~ vV Uu GGGy O QW\u GGGO y jÿ ^j] P GO\ÿ } L U zV U M U M {  1 6  1 $"# 616 9 % % %   6 % %  1    ! "# %6  7%6 9 % 99 %   76  777!  6  6   && 1

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?