Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Filing
534
DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Doc. 534 Att. 30
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 1 of 15
EXHIBIT 16
Dockets.Justia.com
1egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
8077
.ON
RSC
,retlaP nalA yrraH
:yb detropeR
).redro
evitcetorp ehthtiw
ecnadrocca ni tpircsnart eritne eht taert esaelP .redrO evitcetorP dednemA eht fo )c(5 noitceS rep
sa
laitnedifnoc detangised ynomitset sniatnoc tpircsnart sihT(
7002
AINROFILAC
,71
YAM
,OGEID NAS
NOITISOPED
.D.HP
,.D.M
,NOHWALCM .W DLANOR FO
DEPATOEDIV LAITNEDIFNOC
.stnadnefeD
,noitaroproC
.yesreJ
weN a AL-NNAMFFOH
,.CNI
dna
,EHCOR
,ynapmoC
a
namreGa
EHCOR
,HbmG.SCITSONGAID
,ynapmoC ssiwS
oV
,.DTL
.oN
,EHCORAL-NNAMFFOH
.F
YGW-73221-VC-50 noitcA liviC
,ffitnialP
,.CNZ
STTESUHCASSAM FO TRUOC
TCIRTSID
TCIRTSID
DETINU
SETATS
7002/71/5
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 2 of 15
22 egaP
1 LxE 8663,845.008 ecivreS :dlroW etoNeviL
94:11:9O
64:11:90
93:11:90 23:11:90
s'taht s'taht
ydobitna
na
;ydobitna
fo
na
yb dezingocer
52
niteioporhtyre
a
erutcurts
yranretauq
42
32
lanoisnemid-eerht
hguorht
tahT
,ecneuqesro
.A
epotipe cificeps
yb
naem
s'ereht
22
12
02
13:11:90
92:11:90 82:11:90
81:11:90 uoy yas
od uoy tahw nehw
?"evitcaeronummi"
",evitcaeron_ummi"
dnA
.Q
taht
91
81 71
.evitcaeronummi
tcetednac
A
stamrof
41:11:90 21:11:90 90:11:90 60:11:90 20:11:90
yassaonummi fo yteirav
.elbaliava
syassa
onima
61 51
tnecsenimulomehc
.syassa onima
era
erehT
ro
deknil-emyzne
eroM
syassa
41
onima-emyzne
,yltnecer
31 21
00:11190
85:01:90 65:01:90
.yllacirotsih ,yassaonummioidaR
.elbaliava sdohtem fo
tniop
siht
.A
ta
II
0I
yteirav
a
era
erehT
35:01:90
15:0.1:90
ot
?ytivitcaer lacigolonummi
desu
erusaem
9 8
7
eb
dluow
sdohtem
tahW esohT
.Q
.A
64:01:90 64:01:90
24:01:90
.sdohtem
yramirp
eht ?esle
era
gnihtynA
.yassa
.Q
ortiv ni
derusaem
na sa
6 5
4
53:01:90 23:01:90
13:01:90 42:01:90
,yassaoib
a
sdohtem eb
suoirav
dluoc
yb
tI
,ytivitca cigoloib
cigolonummi
LAITNEDIFNOC
3
.ytivitcaer
eb
2
1
dluoc
tI
on
7002/71/5
.W dlanoR
,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 3 of 15
32
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
65:21:90 35:21:90 05:21:90
84:21:90 84:21:90 54:21:90 .54:21:90 44:21:90 04:21:90 93:21:90 53:21:90 43:21:90 23:21:90
taht
?sepotipe
seidobitna
tnereffid
owt
eno
ezingocer
uoy fi ni
52
42
tnereffid
desu
rehtona ot
yassaonummioidar
eb ereht dluow
gnirapmoc
.Q
:NOSRAC .RD
32 22
tcapmi
yna
,lleW
YB
12
.suougibma
dna
eugaV
.RD
02
91
.noitcejbO
:SREWOLF
?sepotipe tnereffid
81
71
ezingocer yeht
ecnereffid
a
fi
syassa
dluoW
eht
neewteb
ekam ti
.Q
.A
61 51
41
.dluoc
yehT
?sepotipe tnereffid
ezingocer
esoht
dluow
dnA
.Q
tnereffid
3.1 21 ii
82:21:90
62:21:90
.seiceps
,lanolconom
.desu
era
,lanolcyloP
22:21:90
91:21:90
81:21:90
seidobitna fo
yteiraV
?syassa
AIR
.A
0I
desu
ni
9
era
seidobitna
.AIR
fo
no
sepyt tahW
sucof ti
s'teL
8
.Q
.A
31:21:90
7
70:21:90
70:21:90
30:21:90
no
.dluoc
,seY
6
eht
?ydobitna gnidneped ,egnahc
s'taht
taht dluow ehT
5
4
,dezingocer
.Q
10-:21:90 85:11:90 45:11:90
epotipe cificeps
esoht ni
3 2
1
.smetsys
yassaonummi
tnegaer
a
sa
desu
7002/71/5
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 4 of 15
42egaP
1 LxE 8663·845.008
ecivreSdlroWetoNeviL
55:31:90
45:31:90
eb
dluow
yassa
cigolonummi ynA
?naem
.A
52
42
32 22 12
eht
uoy
nehw
od
tahw
",erusaem
.Q
tceridni
.A
25:31:90
tceridni
na"
yas
uoy
dnA
.erusaem
15:31:90
64:31:90
24:31:90
na
edivorp
nac
ti
,niagA
tuoba
AIR
nA
na
?gnirusaem er'uoy taht elpmas
fo
02 91
81 71 61
04:31:90
73:31:90
ytivitca lacigoloib
llet
taht seod
eht
gnihtyna
.Q
uoy
,yassa
.erusaem
53:31:90 92:31:90 82:31:90 62:31:90
eht fo
nac
tceridni
toN
edivorp
.A
yeht tub
,yltcerid
?gnirusaem er'uoy
ytivitca lacigoloib
uoy eht
taht
elpmas gnihtyna
syassa
51 41 31
tuoba
32:31:90
61:31:90 41:31:90
31:31:90
llet
yeht
eht
od
,deman uoy
,won
taht
evitcaeronummi
ehT
.seY
.Q
.A
21
II 0I
.yrros
m'I
uoY
21:31:90
21:31:90 21:31:90
.ylbidua
rewsna
ot
evah
.Q
.A
9 8
eht
ro
-)esnopser
yaw
eno
elbidua oN(
?rehto
7
70:31:90 70:31:90
40:31:90
,noinipo
I
on
evah
uoy
oS
.Q
:NOSRAC
.RD
6
YB
5 4 3 2
1
tsuj
eb
I
.taht
no
gnitaluceps
30:31:90
95:21:90
dluow
I ,niagA :SSENTIW EHT .noitaluceps rof sllaC
95:21:90
.noitcejbO
LAITNEDIFNOC
:SREWOLF
.RD
7002/71/5
.W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 5 of 15
52
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS ddoW etoNeviL
01:51:90 70:51:90 60:51:90
40:51:90 20:51:90
ot
sa
".retilillim rep
stinu"
52
42
deyartrop
s'ti
semit
ynaM
sa
".stinu"
yllacipyt
.A
32 22 12
02 91
derrefer
.on
s'tahw
tahw
s'tahT
s'tahT
20:51:90
00:51:90 75:41:90
45:41:90
sa
?"ytivitca cificeps"
ot
derrefer
taht
s'tahw
seod
taht
sI
?uoy evig
si
eulav
fo
epyt tahw
dnA
htiw
dna
,enod
81 71 61
51 41
erudecorp
ytivitca
taht
ot
taht
nehw .taht
.Q
detaicossa
25:41:90 94:41:90
74:41:90 nwonk
s'ereht
,lairetam
ecnerefer
s'ti
oS
54:41:90
24:41:90 73:41:90 13:41:90
a
.syassa detset
neeb
ro
lacigoloib tsniaga noitaraperp suoiverp
31 21 iI
0I
sah
taht
tsniaga
a
,yassaoib
royassa lacigoloib
,detset
si
taht erehT
a
ro ro
ni
yltcerid rehtie
sah
,deyassa
92:41:90
42:41:90
neeb
taht
desu si
noitaraperp
.A
9 8
niteioporhtyre
?naem
ot
22:41:90
71:41:90
uoy od
deit
tahw
,rotarbilac
uoy
nehw
dradnats
a
7
s'ti
yas
,woN
.yassa
.Q
6 5 4 3
11:41:90 70:41:90
50:41:90 40:41:90 00:41:90
ro
lacigoloib
srotarbilac
a
ot
kcab
ro
elbaecart
,tcaf ni
esoht fo
,era
sdradnats
tsoM
.rotarbilac dradnats
fo
2 1
epyt
emos
fo
esu
eht
ot
deit
L·TNEDIFNOC
7002/71/5
.W dlanoR
,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 6 of 15
62
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
03:61-:90 92:61:90 62:61:90
erugif
taht
ot
gniyrt tsuj
uoy
m'I
.Q
52
?noitseuq
esarhper
dluoC
oA
42
32
52.:61:90 32:61:90
91:61:90 71:61:90 90:61:90 90:61:90 70:61:90
70:61:90
a
?dradnats
,esac
yreve
rof
ot
22 12 02
91
hcae ni
eb
nac
emas
eht eb
taht
eht
dluow
decart
sdradnats
eht dluow
taht
ytivitca
.Q
lacigoloib
,woN
81
?ytivitca lacigoloib
ot
71 61
elbaecart
s'ti
oS
.Q
.epyt
emos a
51
41
65:51:90
15:51:90
fo
ot
noitaraperp noitazinagrO
elbaecart siht
ta
era
htlaeH
dlroW
tsom
sdradnats
oS
eseht fo
31
94:51:90 54:51:90 24:51:90
04:51:90
,tniop
eht
ot
,yllacipyt
neeb
evah
21
.yassa
lacigoloib
slairetam
.II 01 9
8 7
derapmoc
ta
taht
reht.o
taht
ot
gnikool yb
ro
yassa
lacigoloib
63:51:90
kcab
elbaecart
yassa
lacigoloib
a
03:51:90
52:51:90 32:51:90 22:51:90
ni
yltcerid ebyam
niatrec
a
,elbaecart
ot
,niaga
tceffe
ecudorp
ot
ytiliba s'noitaraperp
tahT refer dnA
rO
tsuJ
6 5 4
taht
refer
dluow
?ot
.A
"retilillim
71:51:90
31:51:90
rep
stinu"
taht
seod
tahw
3 2
oO 1
".retilillim rep
stinuillim"
I
os
21:51:90
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohWaLcM
7002/71/5
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 7 of 15
72
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS
ddoW etoNeviL
85:71:90 55:71:90 neeb
sah
.netfo
taht
eno
tsom .A
desu
52
42
eht
s'tahT
erA
25:71:90 64:71:90 34:71:90
14:71:90
?srehto
yna
ereht
.Q
32
22
.esuom
cimehtycylop
.A
eht
si
eno
cissalc
ehT
12
02
91 81 71 61
?elpmas niteioporhtyre
na
73:71:90 53:71:90
52:71:90 70:71:90 60:71:90 40:71:90 30:71:90
10:71:90 tahw
fo
ot
ytivitca lacigoloib
elbaliava dias
eb dluow uoy
osla
eht
enimreted.
fo
syassa
sepyt
taht
,woN
.Q
oA
ommh-mmH
?lm
rep eb
stinu dluow tI
tsuJ
.Q
.A
51
41 31
.stinu
rep
stinu
?taht
od rebmun
a
morf
teg uoy
.Q
21 ii
85:61:90 75:61:90 25:61:90
fo
epyt
tahw
os
dnA
.metsys
esuom
0i
cimehtycylop
ro
metsys yassaoib
,yaw sihT
.A
a
ni
9 8
7
05:61:90
54:61:90 34:61:90
14:61:90
,yltceridni
detset
neeb
yltcerid rehtie
lairetam
emos
ni
sah
?ytivitca.lacigoloib
a
6
ot
elbaecart
eb
nac
ti oS
taht
naem
uoy
5
73:61:90 63:61:90 43:61:90 13:61:90
od
tahw
,taht yas uoy nehw
.Q
.ytivitca lacigoloib
eb
a
ot
elbaecart uoy
tuo
2
1
dluoc
dradnats
eht
taht
dias
7002/71/5
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 8 of 15
82.eg·P
1 LxE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
81:91:90
51:91:90 31:91:90
emos
?tsniaga
AIR
stluser fo
tros
52 42
32
22 12
ruoy
etalerroc ot
deen
dradnats
a
evah ot
a na
uoy
ot
dluow
redro uoy
,lm rep stinu ni
ni fI
01:91:90
80:91:90 80:91:90 60:91:90 50:91:90 10:91:90 10:91:90
95:81:90
erusaem
etareneg
,yadot yassa
·Q
:NOSRAC
.RD
AIR
gninnur
erew
YB
02
91 81
71 61
?noitseuq
uoydluoc
taht
esarhper
,niagA
:SSENTIW
EHT
.suougibma
dna
eugaV
.RD
a
.noitcejbO
uoy
:SREWOLF
?dradnats dluow
evah
ot
ot
deen
51
35:81:90 13:81:90
,lm rep stinu etareneg
AIR
na
redro
ni
41 31 21
,yadot yassa
.sey
gninnur
nI
.Q
.A
52:81:90
52:81:90
,lm rep stinu eb dluoc £I
?niaga
,lm rep stinu eb dluow ti
oS
ii
0I
32:81:90
32:81:90
91:81:90 61:81:90 51:81:90 41:81:90 11:81:90 ·80:81:90
eb fo
.Q
.stinu
9
esu
eht
eb
dluow
ti
,niagA
esuom
oA
8
7
?yassa
a
cimehtycylop
morf refer
teg dluow uoy taht stluser
uoy dluow
woH
6
5
eht
ot
?ni
yassa
saw
detangised
detareneg
4
esuom
cimehtycylop ytivitca
ro
a
morf
3 2 1
50:81:90 00:81:90
taht
tahw
eht tahw
dluow
dnA
noitangised
.Q
stinu
7002/71/5
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 9 of 15
462
egaP
1 ,txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
10:10:71 00:10:71 75:00:71 45:00:71 taht ?i
.yakO
.seY
.Q
.A
52
42
erew
tibihxE
eht
nohwaLcM
ni
ot
dedivorp
esu
32 22 12 O2
stluser
etareneg
uoy uoy
taht
rof
35:00:71
05:00:71 74:00:71 44:00:71 83:00:71 53:00:71 33:00:71 72:00:71
tik
enod
fo
epyt eht htiw noitcennoc ni
eseht
era
ydaerla
,tuoba gniklat er'ew
fi
snoitarbilac
eseht
,woN
.Q
.snoisulcnoc
91
81
71
esoht
ward
na
uoY
.evitcaeronummi
yllauqe
revetahw
si
nwonknu
si
gnirusaem er'uoy
eht
na
61 51
taht
noitpmussa
.eussi uoy
neht
sekam
evah
enO
dluow fI
yllaitnetop
41
52:00:71
12:00:71 81:00:71
,ton
s'ti
31
eht
ot
.dradnats
si
ti
21 iI 0i
taht
yaw
emas
eht
ni eht
evitcaeronummi
sa
si
.A
ereht
61:00:71
41:00:71
ni
lairetam
gnol
oS
?nwonknu eht
ot
sa
eht
fo
ssam
9
11:00:71
70:00:71 20:00:71 95:95:61 85:95:61 45:95:61 15:95:61 15:95:61
gnidaer
ton
saw
etarucca
na
evig
ni
taht
dluow
dna
8
7
,erup
ssam a
elpmas
taht
eniru
taht
eht
fo
smret
ni
detarbilac
na
nar
saw
dradnats
6
5
tsniaga
nwonknu
uoy
fI
.Q
.oot
4
,selomillim eb dluoc
ro
tI
.smarg ti
oS
eb
dluoc
ti
3 2
smargillim·ni
eb
dluoc
.tsniaga
1
7002/7115
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 10 of 15
562
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
13:30:71
saw
eht
siht
si
,woN
sti
.Q
dna
recart
52
61:30:71 21:30:71
90:30:71 40:30:71 eht eht
sa
.dradnats
yramirp
namuh
42 32
22
niteioporhtyre
dnA
sa
.negonummi niteioporhtyre yraniru namuh
rof si
12 02 91
81
71
10:30:71 35:20:71
94:20:71 64:20:71 73:20:71 03:20:71 82:20:71 72:20:71 62:20:71 22:20:71 02:20:71
91:20:71
gnisu niteioporhtyre
eht
yassaonummioidar
sihT
.A
fonoitpircsed
a
?repap siht ni
detroper s'tahW
.si
.Q
.A
ti
,seY
?81
tibihxE
61 51
41
nohwaLcM
sa
detcelfer
noitcennoc
a
noinipo trepxe
ni deredisnoc
ruoy
ot
gnimoc
uoy
htiw
tnemucod
siht .72
sI
31
nohwaLcM
tibihxE
uoy
.rD
21 iI
0I
sa
dekram
neeb
eht
s'tahw
erofeb
decalp
s'retroper
,nohwaLcM
.Q
:NOSRAC
.RD YB
9
74:10:71
)dekram
72
tibihxE(
roF
8 7
54:10:71
24:10:71
".niteioporhtyrE
yassaonummioidaR"
dna
a
deltitne
.rD
sa
ressawdloG
6
5
83:10:71 23:10:71 13:10:71
doowrehS
yb noitacilbup
ot
72
tibihxE
ksa
kram :NOSRAC
retroper
.RD
4
3
eht
ll'I
60:10:71 20:10:71
meht
.seulav
eht
sngissa
.A
dna
2
seilppus
rerutcafunam
ehT
1
LAITNEDIFNOC 700217115
oW dlanoR
,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 11 of 15
662
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
83:50:71 33:50:7] 03:50:71
82:50:71 62:50:71
.snoitacilbup retal
ni
fo
decnerefer
tinu eht
sa
52
42
yltneuqesbus
dradnats
si
eht
taht
sa
erusaem
seettimmoc
lanoitanretni
32
22
yb detpoda
,neht
,retal
saw
tI
.emit
devrats desab tinu eht ni
taht
ta
,tar
no
12
42:50:71 81:50:71 71:50:71 31:50:71 90:50:71
30:50:71
ytivitca lacigoloib
na
eht
02
91 81
71
yrartib·a
saw
tI
.A
?ytivitca lacigoloib
ot
refer
tinu
eht
did
sa
,ressawdloG
oS
.rD
yb detangised
".edirolhc
61
fo
suotlaboc eht
selomorcim
51
41
10:50:71 85:40:71
55:40:71
evif
fo
noitartsinimda
eht
ot
yb deticilos
tar
esnopser
a
tnelaviuqe
'devrats'
31 21 ii
0I
ni
a
15:40:71 94:40:71
54:40:71 34:40:71
niatrec
tnuoma
esnopser citeioporhtyre fo eerged ,ytivitca citeioporhtyre fo
,.e.i
detceles ressawdloG
a
tneserper
.rD
ot
seugaelloc
sih
dna
saw
yb detangised
etats uoY
yll·nigiro
9 8 7
6
tinu
ehT"
,ereht
.69
62:40:71 32:40:71 12:40:71
05:30:71
m'I ruoy 81
hpargarap ta gnikool
nohwaLcM
uoy fI .sey
ot
tibihxE
noitnetta
tcerid
dluoc
.Q
5 4
3
ot AIR
,sredael
.A
84:30:71
24:30:71 83:30:71
reilrae
eht
fo
eno
s'eH ni
eht
?selpmas
dehsilbatse
ohw
OPE
gniyassa
desu
eb
2 1
laudividni
ressawdloG
.rD
LA]1NEDIFNOC
700217115
.W dlanoR
,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 12 of 15
762
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
54:60:71 24:60:71
ro
"ytivitca
ni
saw
OPE"
oS
.Q
dradnats
,erusaem
52 42 32
22
.stinu
ecnerefer
eht
taht
,esac
a
lairetam siht
oS
93:60:71
73:60:71 43:60:71
gnisu
ni
noitartnecnoc
si
ti
.noitacilbup
eht
ta
12
O2 91
82:60:71 52:60:71
12:60:71 02:60:71
kool stinu
uoy
fi
,sretil
fo
ro
sretilillim
rep
ni
,emulov
s'taht
stinu
ytivitca
gnitneserper
a
erusaem
noitartnecnoc
81
71
tuoba
on
gniklat
eb
er'uoY erehT
ro
6·:60:71
31:60:71
21:60:71 21:60:71 90:60:71 50:60:71 30:60:71 95:50:71 85:50:71
?AIR
.ecnereffid
na
dluow
a
.A
61
OPE
na
ni
noitartnecnoc
ytivitca
51
41
neewteb
ecnereffid
eht
s'tahW
.yrartibra
ti
llac
on na
31 21
ii
ot
saw
gnidaelsim
ti
dna
yrartibra
oviv ni
ro
regnol
ortiv
OPE
,yassaoib
ni
na
AIR
ni
0i 9 8 7 6 5 4
tneserper
eht
ot
noitartnecnoc ro ytivitca ytinummoc lanoitanretni
saw
yb
nopu
deerga
ot
no
tinu
taht
ecno
65:50:71
45:50:71 25:50:71 84:50:71 74:50:71
,revewoh
,etats
og
uoY
.Q
.ytivitca
lacigoloib
saw
rof tinu
noitnevnoc
eht
a
sa
detpecca
eht
ti
won
rof
ot
noitinifed
emaceb
saw
siht
neht
dna
,taht
roirp gnihton
na sa
3 2
1
44:50:71 34:50:71
ereht ti
esuaceb
tinu
emos
yrartibra
ta oS
tuo
detrats
,tniop
700217t/5
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 13 of 15
862
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS
dlroW etoNeviL
74:80:71 44:80:71
eh
t'nsi
,noitaraperp
eht fo
sa
ecnerefer
na
lanoitanretni deniatnoc tinu
a
52 42 32 22 12 02
elupma
fo
0I/I ni
OPE fo oS
14:80:71 83:80:71 72:80:71 52:80:71
ytivitca
detats
eht
denifed
.rD
si
taht
ressawdloG
.taht ekirts
nehw
noitaraperp ecnerefer
taht
dnA
lanoitanretni
91:80:71
71:80:71 41:80:71 80:80:71
?noitaraperp
eht
ot
ecnerefer
lanoitanretni
s'taht
oS
dnoces
.Q
91
gnirrefer
81
71
61
.noitaraperp
dnoces eht eb
ta
ecnerefer ti
eht
lanoitanretni
eb
dluow
dluow.taht ecnerefer
%0:80:71
10:80:71
,emit
taht
dna
,dna noitaraperp
eht fo
51
41 31
lanoitanretni dluow sihT
?ot
elupma
eht
0I/I eb
.A
53:70:71
)tnemucod
refer
taht
gninimaxE(
seod tahW
52:70:71
22:70:71 91:70:71 61:70:71 41:70:71 11:70:71 40:70:71 95:60:71 75:60:71 05:60:71 05:60:71 94:60:71 eht
ruoy
21
eht
".noitaraperp
fo
ecnerefer
lanoitanretni
deniatnoc
fo ehT tinu
II 0I 9 8
elupma
eht
sa
na
fo
0i/i ni
si
OPE
ytivitca
A"
denifed
fo
,syas
noitces
taht
enil
tsal
".sdohteM rednu
yassaoiB"
dnoces
7
,668 egap si hcihw
nohwaLcM uoy
ot
,egap
6 5
4
,72
tibihxE
kcab
noitnetta
tcerid
dluoc
fi
,woN
.Q
.A
.mmh-mmH
3
?gniht
emas
2
1
eht
ot
refer
"AIR
ni
noitartnecnoc"
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002171/5 .W dlanoR
,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 14 of 15
962
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS ddoW
et)·NeviL
13:01:71
42:01:71 91:01:71
".stibbar
desiar .688 ti
erew
etihw
OPE ot
dnalaeZ
weN
elam
ruof
ni
52 42 32 22 12
seidobitnA"
no
si
eht
egap
hpargarap noitazinummi
og
41:01:71
41:01:71
rednu
uoy
fI
.A
.72 nohwaLcM
sa
tibihxE
11:01:71 01:01:71
80:01:71 70:01:71 20:01:71 95:90:71 75:90:71 92:90:71
72:90:71
dekram
neeb
s'tahW
.Q
O2
?repap
ressawdloG
dna
91 81
71
doowrehS
ehT
.seY
.A
?s'ressawdloG
.rD
on
61
siht
?yassaonummioidar
ni
eht tahW eht
ni
repap
51
41
desu
erew
seidobitna
.Q
rof stinu rof
.yassaonummioidar
31 21
ygolonimret
eht
esu
osla
yehT
.sey
62:90:71 42:90:71
ii
,ecnatsni
ralucitrap
?OPE
siht
nI
.A-
0i
22:90:71
91:90:71
eht ni
ni
ytivitca
tinu
oS
eht
serusaem
9
8
yassaoib
eht
desu
.Q
41:90:71 21:90:71 80:90:71 50:90:71 30:90:71 00:90:71 05:80:71 eht taht
sa
.yassaoib
ni
eht
7
s'ti
dna
,ytivitca
eht
si
tI
.A
6
5
?niteioporhtyre
denifed si
yas
eht
fo
ytivitca
fo
niteioporhtyre
siht .taht
tinu
a
4 3 2
1
tnemetats
t'nseoD
etatseR
sa
.Q
.A
?"ytivitca"
tinu
gninifed
700217115
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-31
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 15 of 15
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?