Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 534 Att. 30

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 1 of 15

EXHIBIT 16

Dockets.Justia.com

1egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

8077

.ON

RSC

,retlaP nalA yrraH

:yb detropeR

).redro

evitcetorp ehthtiw

ecnadrocca ni tpircsnart eritne eht taert esaelP .redrO evitcetorP dednemA eht fo )c(5 noitceS rep
sa

laitnedifnoc detangised ynomitset sniatnoc tpircsnart sihT(
7002
AINROFILAC

,71

YAM

,OGEID NAS
NOITISOPED

.D.HP

,.D.M

,NOHWALCM .W DLANOR FO
DEPATOEDIV LAITNEDIFNOC

.stnadnefeD

,noitaroproC

.yesreJ

weN a AL-NNAMFFOH

,.CNI
dna

,EHCOR

,ynapmoC
a

namreGa
EHCOR

,HbmG.SCITSONGAID

,ynapmoC ssiwS
oV

,.DTL
.oN

,EHCORAL-NNAMFFOH

.F

YGW-73221-VC-50 noitcA liviC

,ffitnialP
,.CNZ

STTESUHCASSAM FO TRUOC
TCIRTSID

TCIRTSID
DETINU

SETATS

7002/71/5

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 2 of 15

22 egaP
1 LxE 8663,845.008 ecivreS :dlroW etoNeviL

94:11:9O
64:11:90
93:11:90 23:11:90

s'taht s'taht

ydobitna

na

;ydobitna
fo

na

yb dezingocer

52

niteioporhtyre
a

erutcurts

yranretauq

42
32

lanoisnemid-eerht

hguorht
tahT

,ecneuqesro
.A

epotipe cificeps
yb
naem

s'ereht

22
12
02

13:11:90
92:11:90 82:11:90
81:11:90 uoy yas
od uoy tahw nehw

?"evitcaeronummi"

",evitcaeron_ummi"
dnA

.Q
taht

91
81 71

.evitcaeronummi

tcetednac
A

stamrof

41:11:90 21:11:90 90:11:90 60:11:90 20:11:90

yassaonummi fo yteirav

.elbaliava

syassa

onima

61 51

tnecsenimulomehc
.syassa onima

era

erehT
ro

deknil-emyzne
eroM

syassa

41

onima-emyzne

,yltnecer

31 21

00:11190
85:01:90 65:01:90

.yllacirotsih ,yassaonummioidaR
.elbaliava sdohtem fo

tniop

siht
.A

ta

II
0I

yteirav

a

era

erehT

35:01:90
15:0.1:90
ot

?ytivitcaer lacigolonummi
desu

erusaem

9 8
7

eb

dluow

sdohtem

tahW esohT

.Q
.A

64:01:90 64:01:90
24:01:90

.sdohtem

yramirp

eht ?esle

era

gnihtynA
.yassa

.Q
ortiv ni
derusaem
na sa

6 5
4

53:01:90 23:01:90
13:01:90 42:01:90

,yassaoib

a

sdohtem eb

suoirav
dluoc

yb
tI

,ytivitca cigoloib
cigolonummi
LAITNEDIFNOC

3

.ytivitcaer
eb

2
1

dluoc

tI

on

7002/71/5

.W dlanoR

,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 3 of 15

32

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

65:21:90 35:21:90 05:21:90
84:21:90 84:21:90 54:21:90 .54:21:90 44:21:90 04:21:90 93:21:90 53:21:90 43:21:90 23:21:90
taht

?sepotipe
seidobitna

tnereffid
owt
eno

ezingocer
uoy fi ni

52
42

tnereffid

desu

rehtona ot

yassaonummioidar
eb ereht dluow

gnirapmoc
.Q
:NOSRAC .RD

32 22

tcapmi

yna

,lleW

YB

12

.suougibma

dna

eugaV
.RD

02
91

.noitcejbO

:SREWOLF

?sepotipe tnereffid

81
71

ezingocer yeht
ecnereffid
a

fi

syassa
dluoW

eht

neewteb

ekam ti

.Q
.A

61 51
41

.dluoc

yehT

?sepotipe tnereffid

ezingocer

esoht

dluow

dnA

.Q
tnereffid

3.1 21 ii

82:21:90
62:21:90

.seiceps
,lanolconom
.desu
era

,lanolcyloP

22:21:90
91:21:90
81:21:90

seidobitna fo

yteiraV
?syassa
AIR

.A

0I
desu

ni

9

era

seidobitna
.AIR

fo
no

sepyt tahW
sucof ti
s'teL

8
.Q
.A

31:21:90

7

70:21:90
70:21:90
30:21:90
no

.dluoc

,seY

6
eht

?ydobitna gnidneped ,egnahc
s'taht
taht dluow ehT

5
4

,dezingocer
.Q

10-:21:90 85:11:90 45:11:90

epotipe cificeps
esoht ni

3 2
1

.smetsys

yassaonummi

tnegaer

a

sa

desu

7002/71/5

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 4 of 15

42egaP
1 LxE 8663·845.008

ecivreSdlroWetoNeviL

55:31:90
45:31:90

eb

dluow

yassa

cigolonummi ynA
?naem

.A

52
42
32 22 12
eht

uoy
nehw

od

tahw

",erusaem
.Q
tceridni
.A

25:31:90

tceridni

na"

yas

uoy

dnA
.erusaem

15:31:90
64:31:90
24:31:90
na

edivorp

nac

ti

,niagA
tuoba
AIR
nA
na

?gnirusaem er'uoy taht elpmas
fo

02 91
81 71 61

04:31:90
73:31:90

ytivitca lacigoloib
llet
taht seod

eht

gnihtyna
.Q

uoy

,yassa
.erusaem

53:31:90 92:31:90 82:31:90 62:31:90
eht fo
nac

tceridni
toN

edivorp
.A

yeht tub

,yltcerid

?gnirusaem er'uoy
ytivitca lacigoloib
uoy eht

taht

elpmas gnihtyna
syassa

51 41 31

tuoba

32:31:90
61:31:90 41:31:90
31:31:90

llet

yeht
eht

od

,deman uoy
,won

taht

evitcaeronummi

ehT
.seY

.Q
.A

21
II 0I

.yrros

m'I
uoY

21:31:90
21:31:90 21:31:90

.ylbidua

rewsna

ot

evah

.Q
.A

9 8
eht
ro

-)esnopser
yaw
eno

elbidua oN(

?rehto

7

70:31:90 70:31:90
40:31:90

,noinipo
I

on

evah

uoy

oS

.Q
:NOSRAC
.RD

6
YB

5 4 3 2
1

tsuj
eb

I

.taht

no

gnitaluceps

30:31:90
95:21:90

dluow

I ,niagA :SSENTIW EHT .noitaluceps rof sllaC

95:21:90

.noitcejbO
LAITNEDIFNOC

:SREWOLF

.RD

7002/71/5

.W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 5 of 15

52

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS ddoW etoNeviL

01:51:90 70:51:90 60:51:90
40:51:90 20:51:90
ot
sa

".retilillim rep

stinu"

52
42

deyartrop

s'ti

semit

ynaM
sa

".stinu"

yllacipyt
.A

32 22 12
02 91

derrefer
.on

s'tahw
tahw

s'tahT
s'tahT

20:51:90
00:51:90 75:41:90
45:41:90
sa

?"ytivitca cificeps"
ot

derrefer
taht

s'tahw
seod

taht

sI

?uoy evig
si

eulav

fo

epyt tahw
dnA
htiw
dna

,enod

81 71 61
51 41

erudecorp
ytivitca
taht
ot

taht

nehw .taht

.Q
detaicossa

25:41:90 94:41:90
74:41:90 nwonk

s'ereht

,lairetam

ecnerefer

s'ti

oS

54:41:90
24:41:90 73:41:90 13:41:90
a

.syassa detset
neeb
ro

lacigoloib tsniaga noitaraperp suoiverp

31 21 iI
0I

sah

taht

tsniaga
a

,yassaoib

royassa lacigoloib
,detset
si
taht erehT
a
ro ro

ni

yltcerid rehtie
sah

,deyassa

92:41:90
42:41:90

neeb

taht

desu si

noitaraperp
.A

9 8

niteioporhtyre
?naem
ot

22:41:90
71:41:90

uoy od
deit

tahw

,rotarbilac
uoy
nehw

dradnats

a

7

s'ti

yas

,woN
.yassa

.Q

6 5 4 3

11:41:90 70:41:90
50:41:90 40:41:90 00:41:90
ro

lacigoloib
srotarbilac

a

ot

kcab
ro

elbaecart

,tcaf ni
esoht fo

,era

sdradnats

tsoM

.rotarbilac dradnats
fo

2 1

epyt

emos

fo

esu

eht

ot

deit

L·TNEDIFNOC
7002/71/5
.W dlanoR

,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 6 of 15

62

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

03:61-:90 92:61:90 62:61:90

erugif
taht

ot

gniyrt tsuj
uoy

m'I

.Q

52

?noitseuq
esarhper
dluoC
oA

42
32

52.:61:90 32:61:90
91:61:90 71:61:90 90:61:90 90:61:90 70:61:90
70:61:90
a

?dradnats
,esac

yreve

rof
ot

22 12 02
91

hcae ni
eb
nac

emas

eht eb

taht
eht

dluow

decart

sdradnats
eht dluow

taht

ytivitca
.Q

lacigoloib

,woN

81

?ytivitca lacigoloib
ot

71 61

elbaecart

s'ti

oS

.Q

.epyt
emos a

51
41

65:51:90
15:51:90

fo
ot

noitaraperp noitazinagrO
elbaecart siht
ta
era

htlaeH

dlroW
tsom

sdradnats
oS

eseht fo

31

94:51:90 54:51:90 24:51:90
04:51:90

,tniop
eht
ot

,yllacipyt
neeb
evah

21

.yassa

lacigoloib
slairetam

.II 01 9
8 7

derapmoc
ta

taht

reht.o
taht
ot

gnikool yb
ro

yassa

lacigoloib

63:51:90

kcab

elbaecart

yassa

lacigoloib

a

03:51:90
52:51:90 32:51:90 22:51:90

ni

yltcerid ebyam
niatrec
a

,elbaecart
ot

,niaga

tceffe

ecudorp
ot

ytiliba s'noitaraperp
tahT refer dnA
rO
tsuJ

6 5 4

taht

refer

dluow
?ot

.A

"retilillim

71:51:90
31:51:90

rep

stinu"

taht

seod

tahw

3 2
oO 1

".retilillim rep

stinuillim"
I
os

21:51:90
LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohWaLcM

7002/71/5

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 7 of 15

72

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS

ddoW etoNeviL

85:71:90 55:71:90 neeb
sah

.netfo
taht
eno

tsom .A

desu

52
42

eht

s'tahT
erA

25:71:90 64:71:90 34:71:90
14:71:90

?srehto

yna

ereht

.Q

32
22

.esuom

cimehtycylop
.A

eht

si

eno

cissalc

ehT

12
02
91 81 71 61

?elpmas niteioporhtyre
na

73:71:90 53:71:90
52:71:90 70:71:90 60:71:90 40:71:90 30:71:90
10:71:90 tahw

fo
ot

ytivitca lacigoloib
elbaliava dias
eb dluow uoy
osla

eht

enimreted.
fo

syassa

sepyt

taht

,woN

.Q
oA

ommh-mmH
?lm

rep eb

stinu dluow tI
tsuJ

.Q
.A

51
41 31

.stinu
rep

stinu

?taht
od rebmun
a

morf

teg uoy
.Q

21 ii

85:61:90 75:61:90 25:61:90

fo

epyt

tahw

os

dnA

.metsys
esuom

0i

cimehtycylop
ro

metsys yassaoib
,yaw sihT
.A

a

ni

9 8
7

05:61:90
54:61:90 34:61:90
14:61:90

,yltceridni
detset
neeb

yltcerid rehtie
lairetam

emos

ni

sah

?ytivitca.lacigoloib
a

6

ot

elbaecart

eb

nac

ti oS

taht

naem

uoy

5

73:61:90 63:61:90 43:61:90 13:61:90

od

tahw

,taht yas uoy nehw

.Q

.ytivitca lacigoloib
eb

a

ot

elbaecart uoy
tuo

2
1

dluoc

dradnats

eht

taht

dias

7002/71/5

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 8 of 15

82.eg·P
1 LxE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

81:91:90
51:91:90 31:91:90
emos

?tsniaga
AIR

stluser fo
tros

52 42
32
22 12

ruoy

etalerroc ot
deen

dradnats

a

evah ot
a na

uoy
ot

dluow
redro uoy

,lm rep stinu ni
ni fI

01:91:90
80:91:90 80:91:90 60:91:90 50:91:90 10:91:90 10:91:90
95:81:90

erusaem

etareneg

,yadot yassa
·Q
:NOSRAC
.RD

AIR

gninnur

erew

YB

02
91 81
71 61

?noitseuq
uoydluoc

taht

esarhper

,niagA

:SSENTIW

EHT

.suougibma

dna

eugaV
.RD
a

.noitcejbO
uoy

:SREWOLF

?dradnats dluow

evah
ot

ot

deen

51

35:81:90 13:81:90

,lm rep stinu etareneg
AIR
na

redro

ni

41 31 21

,yadot yassa
.sey

gninnur

nI

.Q
.A

52:81:90
52:81:90

,lm rep stinu eb dluoc £I

?niaga
,lm rep stinu eb dluow ti
oS

ii
0I

32:81:90
32:81:90
91:81:90 61:81:90 51:81:90 41:81:90 11:81:90 ·80:81:90
eb fo

.Q
.stinu

9

esu

eht

eb

dluow

ti

,niagA
esuom

oA

8
7

?yassa
a

cimehtycylop

morf refer

teg dluow uoy taht stluser
uoy dluow
woH

6
5

eht

ot

?ni
yassa
saw

detangised
detareneg

4

esuom

cimehtycylop ytivitca
ro

a

morf

3 2 1

50:81:90 00:81:90

taht
tahw

eht tahw

dluow
dnA

noitangised
.Q

stinu

7002/71/5

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 9 of 15

462

egaP
1 ,txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

10:10:71 00:10:71 75:00:71 45:00:71 taht ?i

.yakO
.seY

.Q
.A

52
42
erew

tibihxE
eht

nohwaLcM

ni
ot

dedivorp
esu

32 22 12 O2

stluser

etareneg

uoy uoy

taht
rof

35:00:71
05:00:71 74:00:71 44:00:71 83:00:71 53:00:71 33:00:71 72:00:71

tik
enod

fo

epyt eht htiw noitcennoc ni
eseht
era

ydaerla

,tuoba gniklat er'ew
fi

snoitarbilac

eseht

,woN

.Q
.snoisulcnoc

91
81
71

esoht

ward
na

uoY

.evitcaeronummi

yllauqe
revetahw

si

nwonknu

si

gnirusaem er'uoy
eht
na

61 51

taht

noitpmussa
.eussi uoy
neht

sekam
evah

enO

dluow fI

yllaitnetop

41

52:00:71
12:00:71 81:00:71

,ton

s'ti

31
eht
ot

.dradnats

si

ti

21 iI 0i

taht

yaw

emas

eht

ni eht

evitcaeronummi
sa

si
.A

ereht

61:00:71
41:00:71

ni

lairetam

gnol

oS

?nwonknu eht
ot
sa

eht

fo

ssam

9

11:00:71
70:00:71 20:00:71 95:95:61 85:95:61 45:95:61 15:95:61 15:95:61

gnidaer
ton
saw

etarucca

na

evig
ni

taht

dluow
dna

8
7

,erup
ssam a

elpmas

taht

eniru
taht

eht

fo

smret

ni

detarbilac
na
nar

saw

dradnats

6
5

tsniaga

nwonknu

uoy

fI

.Q
.oot

4

,selomillim eb dluoc
ro

tI

.smarg ti
oS

eb

dluoc

ti

3 2

smargillim·ni

eb

dluoc

.tsniaga

1

7002/7115

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 10 of 15

562

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

13:30:71

saw

eht

siht

si

,woN
sti

.Q
dna
recart

52

61:30:71 21:30:71
90:30:71 40:30:71 eht eht
sa

.dradnats

yramirp
namuh

42 32
22

niteioporhtyre

dnA

sa

.negonummi niteioporhtyre yraniru namuh
rof si

12 02 91
81
71

10:30:71 35:20:71
94:20:71 64:20:71 73:20:71 03:20:71 82:20:71 72:20:71 62:20:71 22:20:71 02:20:71
91:20:71

gnisu niteioporhtyre
eht

yassaonummioidar
sihT
.A

fonoitpircsed

a

?repap siht ni

detroper s'tahW
.si

.Q
.A

ti

,seY
?81

tibihxE

61 51
41

nohwaLcM

sa

detcelfer
noitcennoc
a

noinipo trepxe
ni deredisnoc

ruoy

ot

gnimoc
uoy

htiw

tnemucod

siht .72

sI

31
nohwaLcM

tibihxE
uoy
.rD

21 iI
0I

sa

dekram

neeb
eht

s'tahw

erofeb

decalp

s'retroper

,nohwaLcM

.Q
:NOSRAC
.RD YB

9

74:10:71

)dekram

72

tibihxE(
roF

8 7

54:10:71
24:10:71

".niteioporhtyrE

yassaonummioidaR"
dna
a

deltitne
.rD
sa

ressawdloG

6
5

83:10:71 23:10:71 13:10:71

doowrehS

yb noitacilbup
ot

72

tibihxE
ksa

kram :NOSRAC

retroper
.RD

4
3

eht

ll'I

60:10:71 20:10:71
meht

.seulav

eht

sngissa
.A

dna

2

seilppus

rerutcafunam

ehT

1

LAITNEDIFNOC 700217115
oW dlanoR

,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 11 of 15

662

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

83:50:71 33:50:7] 03:50:71
82:50:71 62:50:71

.snoitacilbup retal

ni
fo

decnerefer
tinu eht
sa

52
42

yltneuqesbus
dradnats

si
eht

taht
sa

erusaem

seettimmoc

lanoitanretni

32
22

yb detpoda

,neht

,retal

saw

tI

.emit
devrats desab tinu eht ni

taht

ta

,tar
no

12

42:50:71 81:50:71 71:50:71 31:50:71 90:50:71
30:50:71

ytivitca lacigoloib
na

eht

02
91 81
71

yrartib·a

saw

tI

.A

?ytivitca lacigoloib
ot

refer

tinu

eht

did
sa

,ressawdloG
oS

.rD

yb detangised
".edirolhc

61
fo

suotlaboc eht

selomorcim

51
41

10:50:71 85:40:71
55:40:71

evif

fo

noitartsinimda
eht
ot

yb deticilos
tar

esnopser
a

tnelaviuqe

'devrats'

31 21 ii
0I

ni
a

15:40:71 94:40:71
54:40:71 34:40:71

niatrec
tnuoma

esnopser citeioporhtyre fo eerged ,ytivitca citeioporhtyre fo

,.e.i

detceles ressawdloG

a

tneserper
.rD

ot

seugaelloc

sih

dna
saw

yb detangised
etats uoY

yll·nigiro

9 8 7
6

tinu

ehT"

,ereht
.69

62:40:71 32:40:71 12:40:71
05:30:71
m'I ruoy 81

hpargarap ta gnikool
nohwaLcM
uoy fI .sey
ot

tibihxE

noitnetta

tcerid

dluoc

.Q

5 4
3
ot AIR

,sredael
.A

84:30:71
24:30:71 83:30:71

reilrae

eht

fo

eno

s'eH ni
eht

?selpmas
dehsilbatse
ohw

OPE

gniyassa

desu

eb

2 1

laudividni

ressawdloG

.rD

LA]1NEDIFNOC
700217115
.W dlanoR

,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 12 of 15

762

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

54:60:71 24:60:71

ro

"ytivitca
ni
saw

OPE"

oS

.Q
dradnats
,erusaem

52 42 32
22

.stinu
ecnerefer
eht

taht
,esac
a

lairetam siht
oS

93:60:71
73:60:71 43:60:71

gnisu

ni

noitartnecnoc

si

ti

.noitacilbup
eht
ta

12
O2 91

82:60:71 52:60:71
12:60:71 02:60:71

kool stinu

uoy

fi

,sretil
fo

ro

sretilillim
rep

ni

,emulov
s'taht

stinu

ytivitca

gnitneserper
a

erusaem

noitartnecnoc

81
71

tuoba
on

gniklat
eb

er'uoY erehT
ro

6·:60:71
31:60:71
21:60:71 21:60:71 90:60:71 50:60:71 30:60:71 95:50:71 85:50:71
?AIR

.ecnereffid
na

dluow
a

.A

61
OPE
na

ni

noitartnecnoc

ytivitca

51
41

neewteb

ecnereffid

eht

s'tahW

.yrartibra
ti
llac
on na

31 21
ii

ot
saw

gnidaelsim
ti

dna

yrartibra
oviv ni
ro

regnol
ortiv
OPE

,yassaoib

ni
na

AIR

ni

0i 9 8 7 6 5 4

tneserper
eht

ot

noitartnecnoc ro ytivitca ytinummoc lanoitanretni
saw

yb

nopu

deerga
ot
no

tinu

taht

ecno

65:50:71
45:50:71 25:50:71 84:50:71 74:50:71

,revewoh

,etats

og

uoY

.Q

.ytivitca
lacigoloib
saw

rof tinu

noitnevnoc
eht

a

sa

detpecca
eht

ti

won

rof
ot

noitinifed

emaceb
saw

siht

neht

dna

,taht

roirp gnihton
na sa

3 2
1

44:50:71 34:50:71

ereht ti

esuaceb

tinu
emos

yrartibra
ta oS

tuo

detrats

,tniop

700217t/5

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 13 of 15

862

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS

dlroW etoNeviL

74:80:71 44:80:71

eh

t'nsi

,noitaraperp
eht fo
sa

ecnerefer
na

lanoitanretni deniatnoc tinu
a

52 42 32 22 12 02

elupma

fo

0I/I ni
OPE fo oS

14:80:71 83:80:71 72:80:71 52:80:71

ytivitca
detats

eht

denifed
.rD

si

taht

ressawdloG
.taht ekirts

nehw

noitaraperp ecnerefer
taht
dnA

lanoitanretni

91:80:71
71:80:71 41:80:71 80:80:71

?noitaraperp
eht
ot

ecnerefer

lanoitanretni
s'taht
oS

dnoces
.Q

91

gnirrefer

81
71
61

.noitaraperp
dnoces eht eb
ta

ecnerefer ti
eht

lanoitanretni
eb

dluow

dluow.taht ecnerefer

%0:80:71
10:80:71

,emit

taht

dna

,dna noitaraperp
eht fo

51
41 31

lanoitanretni dluow sihT
?ot

elupma

eht

0I/I eb
.A

53:70:71

)tnemucod
refer
taht

gninimaxE(
seod tahW

52:70:71
22:70:71 91:70:71 61:70:71 41:70:71 11:70:71 40:70:71 95:60:71 75:60:71 05:60:71 05:60:71 94:60:71 eht
ruoy

21
eht

".noitaraperp
fo

ecnerefer

lanoitanretni
deniatnoc
fo ehT tinu

II 0I 9 8

elupma
eht
sa

na

fo

0i/i ni
si
OPE

ytivitca
A"

denifed
fo

,syas

noitces

taht

enil

tsal

".sdohteM rednu

yassaoiB"
dnoces

7

,668 egap si hcihw
nohwaLcM uoy
ot

,egap

6 5
4

,72

tibihxE

kcab

noitnetta

tcerid

dluoc

fi

,woN

.Q
.A

.mmh-mmH

3

?gniht
emas

2
1

eht

ot

refer

"AIR

ni

noitartnecnoc"

LAITNEDIFNOC
7002171/5 .W dlanoR

,nohwaLcM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 14 of 15

962

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS ddoW

et)·NeviL

13:01:71
42:01:71 91:01:71

".stibbar
desiar .688 ti
erew

etihw
OPE ot

dnalaeZ

weN

elam

ruof

ni

52 42 32 22 12

seidobitnA"
no

si
eht

egap

hpargarap noitazinummi
og

41:01:71
41:01:71

rednu

uoy

fI

.A

.72 nohwaLcM
sa

tibihxE

11:01:71 01:01:71
80:01:71 70:01:71 20:01:71 95:90:71 75:90:71 92:90:71
72:90:71

dekram

neeb

s'tahW

.Q

O2

?repap
ressawdloG
dna

91 81
71

doowrehS

ehT
.seY

.A

?s'ressawdloG

.rD

on

61
siht

?yassaonummioidar
ni

eht tahW eht

ni

repap

51
41

desu

erew

seidobitna

.Q
rof stinu rof

.yassaonummioidar

31 21

ygolonimret

eht

esu

osla

yehT
.sey

62:90:71 42:90:71

ii

,ecnatsni

ralucitrap
?OPE

siht

nI

.A-

0i

22:90:71
91:90:71

eht ni

ni

ytivitca
tinu
oS

eht

serusaem

9
8

yassaoib

eht

desu

.Q

41:90:71 21:90:71 80:90:71 50:90:71 30:90:71 00:90:71 05:80:71 eht taht
sa

.yassaoib
ni

eht

7

s'ti

dna

,ytivitca

eht

si

tI

.A

6
5

?niteioporhtyre
denifed si
yas

eht

fo

ytivitca
fo

niteioporhtyre
siht .taht

tinu

a

4 3 2
1

tnemetats

t'nseoD
etatseR
sa

.Q
.A

?"ytivitca"

tinu

gninifed

700217115

LAITNEDIFNOC .W dlanoR ,nohwaLcM

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-31

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 15 of 15