Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Download PDF

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al Doc. 534 Att. 34 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 1 of 13 EXHIBIT 20 Dockets.Justia.com 02496400 CTI-MA i.atnemLrepxe fo esuaceb e/btzapmocretni syawla ton era se/rotarob�] tnere�d morf w]user ,revewoH '.pE fo y�ssaotb eht rof �rotagicsevn/t�om yb desu neeb sah esuom cimehtycylop eht gniyolpme yassa na ,sraey 02 tup eht roF .smetsys yassaoib evitisnesni ylevitaler tnedneped neeb �ah amuLp dna mures ni pE fo nod�rirnauq e='d ,yltnecer no litnU ETiKNORC .P ENEGUE d�= ,RELLIM .E NYLIRAM ,GNITTUC .O RETNUH ,REDNALLOH RETSEL ,EBBE .N YELRIHS .AICRAG .F HPESOJ a�nleb namuh �lmehtycylop dna lamron ni slevel �nlt�lu�ri� :nlteloporhtyre fo ya=aaonummiold�I 58 C Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 2 of 13 12496400 CTI-MA 454920 72 MA ,�m�koG ene�ug .rD" deEnup pE-/tna � a M n�l�,ztnummI rotseob a dev�cer taht �/bbar a mm� den�bo saw ereh desu ehT '.�rehwel�.e detneserp neeb evah no/tcudorp �dob[cna pE io l�lzteD ,Tdobltns p � �onumn ,L TI/auq� saw sdohtem eseht fo roht� htiw de�n/do/pE *'.r ,kirz.e l�tneserp neeb evah pE ot sdohtem noU�rldel owt eseht �o noUac/lppa eht "/o sliateD .)LII .drofkcoR ,.oC lacimehC ;N�G-ODOI( //ruloc/�llynehp/d-a6,a3-oto]hcartet-6.4,3,1 dez�/ltu �ht .s kcepS dna rekarF yb dohtem � ro "dohtem esad/xmapwcal eht fo no/tac�dom a roht/e htlw tuo deirrac erew sno�tan�lco/ fo nttn 03 nihtiw ehT ".mmmp'fo s m�U 004,07 y�etamLxorppa fo .A.S na ot de�rup dna snamuh cd-nena ylereves �'h'su '/� no�tClmXe yb den�tbo saw pE ehT .&nol mc4 7]et�'n�orppa dna reema/d nI mm 2 o� $nibut 7ral]tpac � nlpE dez/I/hp�j'lfo � 7.0 7letam�xmppafo detmnoc dna ,)ressewlkoC .rD morf yllanislro wla( �.27.7.M dedoc �.e�uttcsnI doolB dna &nuL ,traeH lano�aN eht hsuorht ma-dorp no�t -ub/z�d a mo�E denlaxlo saw tser ehT .ebut es�orcdn enoly�XI a fo mm�b eht ni pE d.�]lhpa71 yle�anrtc�mppa fo detmnoc dna ,2'rF BT.O�-� TH dedoc ",ro�awdloG eneguE .rD yb deppus Tldnik saw emoS ss .m'nE erup nI demaxlo saw noltan/dot rof de�u pE ehT .uoltanldoI p� .AIR a nI pu tes l/tnu ).J .N .enutpeN ..cnI .lanoltan'�tnI drasnaV( �op I,L C "02 ta tpek � lrezorE �w mu�es ro � eht dna ,nward gnieb deta'mpes �ew selpmas I/A .s,duts notcaclffrev AIR pE eht M � sa dedulcni erew --alrunibolzomeh lanrutcon lamsTxorap htlw eno dna ,s/mena s'n�tkc�Lll-dnomz/D htiw eno .a/men� s'/manaF htiw eno--stna/tap c/mena ylereves eerht m�nf selpmas smulp tn�eff/d neves-TcnewT .Tmotobelhp �bla syad I� ot 4 morE SniZmn senr� �a ,siht nah� fe�"me � m �nemeru,--em =lE tt�fte �no ;yltx�ebeU�:[ �ue�:�eh� �na�r �om eh�r ecnJ� �:�le � htnom a narb �om mohw �eneserp �ht eno st�e/tap ro �z/motobe]hp neeb reven dah ohw stneitap rehtie morE deniztbo erew tnemeruuem ro� selpmas eht fo �oM .ssam/loc der desaercni na yb detnemucod 7/la�t/nt saw almeh�c�lop ,mho/lap c/mehtTcylop lla nI .s/mehtycylop yradnoces htiw stne/tap evif e � dna �lamef ,Tttnllfa nezyxo hsd'l htiw yhtaponiboisomeh htiw elam eno ,)esaes/d yranomlup .esae � htiw stnemp evif m�w erehT .semfc tnerelfl�c ta nekat selpnz� smulp tnere�Lc no enod erew snoitanimreted 2'91 dna .)selam-� 6 .selam ! I( stneitap hcus 71 erew ereht :yduts siht ro� detpecca erew �remc pmnG ydutS zreV �me�oP. HIN eht gniteem �llanizlro stneitap arev z/mehtyc�lop ylnO �mehtycydxI yradnoces rof enola ymotobelhp dna .arev a�nehtycylop ro� .stne&a c�mmyc tuohtiw ro htiw ,Tnmtebelhp :tnemtaert fo se�ats suo/rav ni erew a�rrehtycylop htiw stneitaP dna stcejbus � lla mo� deniatbo saw tnesnoc demrofnI .eettimmoC esU 1�n'luH mmofflaC 'fo yr/er�vtnU eht dna �eYtimmoC esU namuH LBL eht yb devorppa dna deweiver erew eseht nI desu s/ocotorp ehT .LBL ta cinilC rennoD eht ta detaerc stnet�aalCUO morF selpm�, sa denfatbo erew � detcelloc selpm� tne/tap llA .sffats LNB dna LBL eht fo srebmem �nu�v �ltlzeh selpmzs mures dna amsalp namuh lamroN .s.�Jbsm latnsmH�pzE sdoht�M clmehtycyiop emos dna snamuh lamron fo seires egral a ot esu sti dnetxe ot dna A[R eht etad/lav rehtru� ot si no/tactnummoc s/ht fo eso0�rup ehT st ,".d,�tartsnomed neeb eht rof evah euqinhcet AIR "wolaY dna nosre31 lacissalc eht gnisu syassaonummi pE dUav taht *',mrof erup ni p� namuh fo noitalosi eht htiw ,ydnecer ydro si ti tub ,pE fo tnemerusaem seuqinhcet/ac�solonumm/htiw denrecnoc neeb evah ''.T srotagfcsevn/lareveS .snoitaraperp pE edurc ro ,mures ,amsalp ni tneserp era tahc srotcaf c�Lcepsnon 'fo tceffe eht ot tcejbus osla era smets,�s eseht "fo ynam tub ,,revil l�ef dna '.neelps ',worram �nob �o serutluc gnizilitu depoleved neeb osla evah tnemerusaem pE rof smstsTs yassaofb )nI/v nI fo yteirav A � .stluser yassaolb eht tceffa yam pE naht reh�o s ,retam ,os/A *.sm�lp fo stnuoma e&ral fo noitntnecnoc se-,/uqer slevel lamron fo tnemerusaem ,pE $n/lalucrtc desaercnI gn/ru�em fo elbapac s/yassaolb siht hguoht/A .'s,r/]ib�v fo slevel Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 3 of 13 22496400 CTI -MA 584920 72MA .�unp;A ,�tn�wC ,.,F.N.N.U � �d dst/ucaF ,acitnluqo�l ed |rdetiC �.F �ulao� .rD" .ret�li.m rep �uru�Jun fo smret m snwonknu rof =eulav sent�nreted dn�a pE/dnUm sol ot dnuob tnecrep s n/taler evruc dradnats ehC sevired hc�w ,�etupmoc 0067 CDC L�,L eht dna = truH dna drabdoR fo ma-dorp retupmoc diomgt � eht hnw dezylana m stluseR .)saxeT ,notsuoH ,.cnI ,stnemurtsnI saxeT ;RSA 007 tneliS( Jan/mret at=d cmowcele na =nt�u mce�sac �n�nacm ctn�ucel.e na dna epat repap =ro detceBoc erew a=lc ehT .)c�demo'nkM ;�SS-SM( retnuoc ammas epyt-llew a imsu yb detnuoc neht dna laem=ced erew sebu= ehT .)$ x 009( mpr 000� �a mm 03 rof ),fKaC ,otd/o/aP ,.cnI ,scnemu'us.nl namkceB :E6-J( egufmnec dezaregt�.er a ni sebut ehT ".yJ�mverp debircsed sa mure�L:lna �bubo][l ammag �ibbar.m'� raos a =aw pE dnuob-nUubo]s amn'=a,� eq� � n�arapeS ht/w de$�ftr.rne� �sew deh�lpmocca fo doirep no�tabucI'h na eof C "4 �a �pek dna dexenov neht erew sebut ehT .dedda ASB �5.0 ht/w ,5.7 Hp .,OP M50.O fo detmmtc stnatcaer eseht fo �dob rof meu/id ehT .)000,05 :I � no�ulid noUabuc�,L lanif( 000,02 :! fo no�mlid a ,=w pE-/tna e�d dna ,mp� 000,0I yl.�an ,cxorppa deniatnoc I�/002 eht �aht �s detu/�d saw pE de/ebal ehT ,).�P ,mahsroH ,smetsyS e�demmctM( ettep/p cuamotua na htiw ydruoenatlum/s dedda erew muresitna pE�na detulid fo d/002 dna pE delebal detuJ�d fo sret/dcrcmr derdnuh owT .snwonknu dna sdradn�s � ,sebut Ua ni sno/caztnecnoc n/etorp r�l/m/s n.lmnmm ot tpmet� n� s�w tnetnoc �SH hs�h ehT .dmLuqer mures ro �msalp/o nof�ulflc y� rof dnz l�iL�,�ts pE e�d rof meu/Uc eht � desu �w � ).�lzC ,yelekreB ..cnI .seJrot�rob�L ret�uC( ASH �5 ht�w ,5.7 H� .lv/5O.0 .reffub e�hp�ohP .sebuc hcus omi dettep�p erew ,da;�m ot nwod lm/Um 005 mo'� dnoces( Jnzdnars pE "fo �o�m/�d zmvlzh fo 1� 0OI ,yfrzlt�S .)mar 5"7 yb 21( sebut enerytsylop elb�ls�c otni denep�p erew mures ro �m�Lp de:ul�d ro detul�cnu � 1� O01 fo selpnr�S .4LR pg .000.05 :! d nmtulEc noUabucnt � a = AIR eht m ,debro ,hairu ,)lt�esoprup ,desu s=w muresUna sihT ':devresbo neeb evah s'pE yeknom dna ,n�xlab ,god ,peehs �ibar .tar ,esuom htiw snoUcaer-ssorc ,pE namuh ot no/t/dda nI .metsys AIR eht m s'pE l�ndra � �enav = htiw tcaer-adre seod ti ,mure�lnz mh ,r htiw tuo den-ac neeb �r evah s'pE 'seiceps reh� �maga noica�u uen h�uohkA '.rett/lUtm rep pE namuh fo U 003 nzht erom ezif�"uuen ot/unia ehtseiduts mures�nz . s/hT sah ':enarbmem noidoUoc a hsumht n�lazldf eru�p yb deraperp pE yraniru namuh M tcawxe edurc a htiw dezmummi ylsuoiverp neeb dah =bbar ehT "'.gar/U 0008 fo .A.S na htiw "no/taraperp pE namuh .=nottaztnecnoc .syad 4 pE A eh� dna syassa z�om rof desu s=w evruc wol yrev htiw selpmas rof devreser saw B �tr�rof locotorp rof loco�mp ehT .AIR pE ehz rof sevruc/ac�pyT .I .�fF Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 4 of 13 32496400 CTI-MA 68492O 72 MA ..,Um � m 4.0 sI �mu �u�;�o s�et nI AIR pE � fo eg� e� taht tuo �n� � dlu�s � .e�uc sl� �o cnem pE � � � a �I m .giF � � fo � g�n� pE-�n� � ntht� � s�s .�8.8 � � �etni � �z �.6 � VC y�m �a nt A e�uC � .�/Um 80.79 � � �lUm �(1 � �h m� c�h�a e� a .�7.9 � VC y� d� �3.9 hcus ta� e� � � lm�E �t� �na � tnu� �t � � �m � � s� eht no � �� m� �m tI .pE �u ym n�c � � tub � � �W�c�r �� A� � �lpi�p � ta� � � tn� � � �l � lm � � e� � �� .�u� � A� � �� l�'�E � tnu� �t � ,� nI ,pu � � �m �n� ,e�uc h� � Sn� .�m AIR � �e ylm�m�pa � ,y� � � g� pu � � � �pm� a tu� � m �uc �d�S eht dnz sAIR pE �om rof desu si �c�orp sihT .1 �IF � )A w�'c'( detne�xi si evruc gnitluser 000,00I S �bmu� Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 5 of 13 42496400 CTI-MA 784920 72 MA y�eh 544 � �m a no enod �ew �nemeru�em pE m� d� am�lP .pE PRI dno� e� � �n�bo � ot �p ylban�r � n� ese� �o no�u� yb �bo �s� e� .mm� otev �e�ycyl� fo elp� a �w � ,yaw s�t d�n�p � �uc m�p � ,�u �u �w � �w eht � �muh m� �e� .pE �uh fo PRI dnoc� � � �bo �e �ew � A� e� � .�u� y� �ew m� )1 .siF ,� �uc( e� �p e� AIR pE ev� �m e� ne� �m eerefer � rof �w e� � )PKI dno�( pE ,� �SH � �tw e�m ,�sys .y�b � � e� � �/Um �.� � �9 m� d� AIR � � �iUm �7,61 o� �5 m� � no�necnoc pE �p e� �8.0 � tne� no�oc a � .s�em owt �e� n� n� � �ed �ih a �a�m � 2 .giF � �n�p �e� .�ms �n� c�e� � e� m� �p h� e�m �ew y�b e� � �bo u�s� pE � seu�v A� pE fo �moC �uom �e�ycyl� m � pE M ej� eht � g� �o�u� �t � ta r� �ec� erew pE m� �f �uMV �SH � � pu e�m pE � ro m� � �u� � � d� � I � �u�v a �h .U 8.0 m 1.0 � es� a j�ev� )�1 �o�( p� � �iw �me8 �c � u�mw � � � �u� �b a fo � e� � �u�c uw �u�v m �pmoc �w �w a m �nu� �w �b fo �u� �m eF" e� � �ew �ua ta �5 �ew .egd�C ,�uN dinE weN( eF" � � 5.0 �o � � � d� � �ameh m ,�du�u�u, �jm h� uw � .�w 3 t�a � �7 ).eM ,r�H � k�w � s� 5 .yad/� �s ,�� n�J( � �F� �ef w� �v �f �yn�b pE .y�b pE ui n�u� �f � �ne�oc pE � n� �h �u su� .m�ys n� .�u�em � �b y� e� .y� su� e� fo � m � � y� e� � eS� pE �u� e� .re� ;7 y�a�mp� fo rm�r � yb ev� � � ewuc a hcuS �/Um 5.4 � z�mb � �lUm � m 4.0 y�mp� fo sn�necn� pE fo eS� a .�1 m e� � ,woN .� � � �bo uw .liF m S �C i� pE-� m� �ub�g a�g �-b� �i �,w �p uw pE-� eht hc�w r� .C "4 � sy� OI �dn�xe �w � nruom e� .mu� no�uc� � � re� e� pu �m �,� :1 pE-� � � 2 � )mpc �,01 y��a( pE � � n� owT .�d� � �hp� e� � � �ew m� ro �p d� pE �d�s fo �o�u� h�em� �[� �w � d� �m �ew �/Um 2.0 m nwod �/Um �1 fo noUa�necn� d�( pE � J�u� l�dh � � �c �s pE e� roF .)� 911 � 61( hcuS � mw � �� u� e� d� �cu� uw n�necn� pE� e� ,.ewoH � � d� � m e� �ew k�w � � �p Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 6 of 13 52496400 CTI-MA g84920 72 MA �p� am�p no sno�necnoc pE rof �lus� �cn�mp � ]I elbaT � � .5�< fo eu�v p a ht� ,I elbaT nI �n� �u�v m�es ev�s� rieht m� re� �d�clf� dna II elbaT ni �tn�p �u�v am�p �on �e� .6.4 fo .D.S na � �/Um 8.SI �w �em � eluref � e�m ATDE eht rof �em eht � ,5.5 � .D.S � � �/Um 2.51 �w am�ip ev� tfeht m� no�cu� t�c�M a �hs ,selp�s m� LBL &�m e� � �U e� e� ca ,ATDE � ne� �lp�s am�lp e� no mluseR .�< � eu�v p a � �lUm 8.81 fo noU�necnoc e�m� �m e� m� tn� �.71 � n�necnoc pE e�m �em e� �1� �ew g�p�s �lu� eht nehw ,r�e�H �n� n�m� � gninrom n�w� .set�s gnU�on d� gnU� � fo ml� � �u� LNB dna LBL e� n� tn�a elbaemat �w me� � nI .�u� LNB � LBL e� � �u�v etef d� �m e� nt ecn�e� t�cif�ts � �w me� L elbaT m �n� sno�n�c p� m� e� .� m� �o�m� td�ameh d� sn� -�ne� �omeh ,� �t �a ;�jbus LBL eht fo g�p� �n� e� ta am�p ATDE � elp� �no� � � �pecxe m� � �D� m �lp� � .M.� �:II d� �:9 n� �lp� � �ew �jbus LNB e� .M.e � :3 o� �:I d� .M.� � :9 d� �:7 n� ,ec� �p�s �ew �jbus LBL e� � �� )�( �s em� .�m� 951 d� se�m 392 ,�,�ey 46 m 81 fo egnn ega na �rtw �ce�bus eht ht/w plh�no/�adr lecrap a &n�arrsnomed 2 4 ares .pE namuh "4c noitaraperp ecnerefer namuh suolr�v � no�ulld �/reS .3 .giF 821 )lacorpicer( noitulid mureS 23 46 8 61 mu�es 0�2 0O � �ielfed nm[� lamroN mures namuh mures arev aimehtyeyloP �L(� 057 000I 0051 0571 00I 0I lm/Um PRI � pE S �mnuN Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 7 of 13 62496400 CTI-MA 98492072MA .pihsnoitaler noitartnecnoc pE-nlbolgomeh enevni eht ez=ahpme ot 4 .giF m detneserp .osJa era stsorb�oleym htiw amrehtycylop a dna ad'nena na'diealB-dnonraiD eht morf amsalp no stluseR .atev =lmehtycylop htiw e�oht dna atnrehtycylop Tzadnoces htiw stneitap elam morf selpnu� amsalp no seulav pE eht neewteb nees s� palrevo on erehw ,4 .E iF nI detciped rehtruf si �hT .=eulav lamron morf elbah�ugnits� ton erew =eulav arev amtehtycylop laudividni ,=eulav otev atmehtTcylop dna lamron eht revo desaercni yletinifed erew seu/av a/mehtycylop yradnoces laud�vidn/eht hguohtlA .100.0< fo =eulav p ht/w av amsalp lamron naem eht mo�f sa llew sa ,rehto hcae morf tnereffLd ydnaclftngts ,eeurlew selpmas amsalp cimehtycylop 7zadnoces dna yramirp eht rof snoatartnecnoc pE naem .selpmas amt.bp amrehtycylop yradnoces 9� rof lm/Om 7,351 dna �elpnras amsalp aehT rev amrehtycylop 311 rof lm/Um 3.9 erew snoUartneeno� pE naem ehT .=elam lamron eht rof 5,51 ot dezapmo� sa ,ylevucepser ,ld/ms 9.51 dna 4.51 saw selam cdrrehtycylop yzadno -ces dna T',amnp detaert eht rof noUartnecnoc nlbo�omeh naem ehT .tnalugaocitna eht sa ATDE htiw detcelloc selpmas am�lp no erew ereh detroper stluser amsalp llA .cinifC rennoD eht mm� tnemtaert fo segats suoirav ni atmehtycylop htiw stne�r�p muh denQt � .100.0 < p htiw ,rehto � nm'E ta�re'qLd ydn�J�atil= e� �aem pE i� .�e� � n�dlWt LnaJu;�tca�= eht �a ATDE htiw l� erew � = 1�" �ehtm�me, ni =tnemeru�em nQe�lmht�e "rodetceebmo�n ;.D,S =:edlemr=em ammt�=IeulaV ru 7.0 = 3.51 = = = �.� = 7.57 6.5 = 7.8 6.4 = �.51 )01( 3.1 0.1 9.0 6.51 3.3� 9.51 4.51 5.51 �y� �o�S )97� �ev �loP )�( �N rUmeF 0� = )92� �eht�c� 7.�1 2.9 2.5I l.l 0.1 = = )311( otev ')18( �oN �M� �ycyloP )�1�( "sgnieb namuh cimehtycylop dna lamron ni snoitartnecnoc pE amsalP .!I elbaT = = 8.81 5.2 5.2 8.2 t: 5.93 7.83 4.44 8.0 0.1 = 5.31 3.31 4.51 5.51 2.6 0.7 7.4 8.5 = : = = 7.81 7.81 0.91 � 2.71 = )ggl( gnilpmas elamef erUnE .M.^ 00:11-00:9 )79( LNB 03:3-03:1 )55( LBL 03:9-03:7 )55( LBL elameF .M.^ )463( gnilpmas elam erarnE 0.1 0.1 = 7.5 O.S 5.5 0.71 5.71 6.71 8.2 : 5.44 � .M.a00:11-00:9 03:3-03:1 .M.^ 03:9-03:7 )212( "LNB )18( LBL )18( "LBL elaM �meb namuh lamron ni snoitartn�noc pE mureS L e/baT .g� �e mcra ,C 035 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 8 of 13 72496400 CTI-MA 094920 72 MA .arev atmehtycylop htiw stneitap fo amsalp morf deniatbo seulav eht dna seulav pE atmehtycylop yradnoces eht neewteb palrevo on saw meht ,5 .giF ni nees sa .osLA .100.0< fo seulav p htiw ,naem amsalp elamef lamron eht morf dna rehto hcae morf tnereffid ydnaciflngls erew seulav esehT .selpmas amsalp aitnehtycylop 7zadnoces Ol rof lmIUm 7.57 dna selpmas amsalp arev aimehtycylop elamef 07 rof dnIUm 7.8 erew snoitartnecnoc pE naem ehT .selamef lamron eht rof 3.31 ot derapmoc sa ,ylevitcepser ,llc/mg 3.51 dna 6.51 saw selamef aAmehtycylop atmeh�3cylop detaert eht rof noitartnecnoc nibolgomeh naem ehT yradnoc,� dna =tev 136 �te�ogrcr�re [� /�assao�ammioidaR Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 9 of 13 82496400 CTI-MA 194920 72 MA ,tcaf ni ,s/ares eseh� ni tneserp lairetam evU�aeronumm/fo tnuoma llmrrs eht taht sisehtopyh eht gnitroppus suht ,drxdnats ecne -refer pE eht ot pihsnoigaier/eJ]arap ylbanosaer a wohs ares/anrron dna ,cJnrehtyc,�lop ,cit -hpena namuh fo snoitulid gl ,Lvlah dna ,yassaoib esuom cimehtycylop eht htiw nottaterro� fo eerged hgih a swohs AIR ehT .lamron woleb desserped ylbaredisnoc era taht slevel pE fo tnemerusaem eht rof swolla hcihw ,Um gn/calucrtc lamron ydro tnuoma ton osla tub slevel pE 4 .0 ot tne]aviuqe pg fo �tulosba na ot evi:lt�res sI detneserp p-g rof AdP ehT noissucsiD 0 0 OO�OOI La ge �cramC 236 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 10 of 13 92496400 CTI -MA 294920/"2 �.A rehg/h htiw ,selpmas hcuS .yduts siht ni elbal/ava ton erew stneitap arev �meht��lop detaercnu mo�f selpmas amsalp ,yletanutrofnU .stneitap eseht rof stsixe osla pihsnoitaler noitartnecnoc pE-nlbo0lomeh esrevni eht caht tsesgus snibolgomeh rehgih htiw stneitap elamef ni pE amsalp fo snoitartnecnoc rewoL �,31 fo noitartnecnoc nlbolgomeh elamef lamron a ot derapmoc sa ld/m& 6.51 fo noitartnecnoc n/bol ,gomeh naem a dah stneitap arev alme�ycylop elamef detaert eht ,revewoh ;selam lamron fo esoht ot elba'spmoc snolc -a'nnecnoc nibolgomeh dah arev a/mehtysy|op detaert htiw stneitap elam ,yduts tneserp eht nI .stcejbus lamron eht nI slevel amsalp eht ot derapmoc sa desaerced ydnacift�i$ erew stneitap are� adnehtycylop elamef dna elam htob morf snoitartnecnoc pE naem ehT .y�esaolb esuom clmehtycylop eht yb derusaem pE htiw � ,euqdrhcet noitcartxe pE yraniru a dna � euq/nhcet noitcawxe pE amsalp a morf devresbo neeb osla evah spihsnoitaler hcuS .AIR pE ralimis a gnisu ,stneitap hcus fo seires egral a no "ress�wdloG dna relffeoK fo snoitavresbo tnecer eht smrifnoc sihT-.AIR yb derusaem sa stne�lap arev ainrehtycylop dna stcejbus lamron fo samsalp eht nI nees slevel eht revo desaercni ylbaredisnoc erew stneitap almeh.tycylop yradnoces morf samsalp eht ni nees snolcartnecnoc pE ehT .slaudividnI lamron rof eulav etulosba etairporppa tsom eht enim -reted yletamitlu ]]iw smetsys yhsa pE fo yteirav a fo esu evisnetxe eroM .noiterces pE fo no/sserped ro no/�alumits htiw d,-..s�/cossa eb ot nwonk snolt/dnoc �clnllc dna lacigolo/syhp htiw detalerroc noitartnecnoc pE ni segnahc evitaler etairporppa etartsnomed ot yt�ba eht sa tnac|lt�is sa ton si metsys yassa ralucitrap a htiw deniatbo eulav etutosba eht spahreP "Smron deredisnoc �w lnr/Um 04 yletamixorppa fo eulav a ,no/lartnecnoc pE mures namuh lamron[o weiver a nI Lm/Um 008 fo noita-alnecnoc pE mures namuh egareva h�glh yrev eht deniatbo ydnecer ".la te latsyrK ,yasaaolb worram enob eri/v ni na gnisU .�m /Um 8.7 fo naem a wohs yassaolb esuom clmehtycylop eht nt deyassa amsalp lamron fo stcartxE .spum& elamef dna elam otni det_'-rapes ton era atad eht hguohtla ,ereh detneserp � seulav mures nmrruh lamron deniatbo yltnecer evah � dessawdloG dna esoht ot relTIeoK ,AIR pE ral/m/s a gnisU .emit emas eht ta detcelloc mures no den/atbo shuser A[R pE morf re�d ton od tnalu'saoclcna na sa nirapeh htiw detcelloc amsatp no stluser yranimt� -erP .nees saw ecnereTgd xes tnaclfing/s on ,seulav mures evitcepser rieht morf desaerc -ed yltnacif/n�is erew seulav amsalp ATDE hguohtlA .AIR suoiverp eht htiw dnuof saw tahw fo esrever eht si hcihw ,elam eht rof nees taht revo desaercni y]tnacifmgis si naem elamef eht ,dezylana era seulav fo puor� e�l a nehw tah� sraeppa won rI ,os/A .retarc eht sa noitaraperp pE delgrup ylla/trap a dezI/I:lu hcihw ",tpmetta AIR pE suo/verp a ni nees seulav eht semit ruof yl�tam/xorppa era seulav esehT .den�bo erew 8.81 fo mures elamef lamron dna lm/Um 2.71 fo mures elam lamron rof snaem ,AIR pE tneserp eht nI '.pE rof sdohtem yassaolb nit/v ni n/atrec htiw melborp a neeb osla sah ,revewoh ,slhT �' "' .nite|oporhtyreolafsa dna tcatni neewteb hsiugnitsid ot ytilibani eht gnidrager taht si ycnapercs/d ylno eht spahreP .pE gninrecnoc noitamrofni lacinilc dna lacI�olo1$�hp nwonk eht htiw tnetsisnoc era AIR pE eht ht/w den/atbo stluser suhT ".AIR eht yb elbarusaem pE amsalp fo noisserped a ni stluser eclm lamron fo nolsufsnartrepyh ,oslA ".retal rh 42 pE e|bayasaaonummioldar ni esir tpmorp a ni detluser peehs fo gnidee|b etucA 'I .nocbab dna tar cixopyh e� nt rucco ot nwohs neeb evah AIK eht htiw derusaem pE mures ni segnahc etairporppA .pE.itna eht rof pE namuh delebal eht htiw gn/tepmoc ni evitcaer os�a era s'pE lamina fo yte�av a ,ereh desu muresitna pE-/tna eht htiW .pE ni segnahc etairporppa nwohs evah adnehtycylop yradnoces dna ,adrrena '?noisufsnart doolb ,ssol doolb ,stceJ -bus namuh nI .AIR pE eht setadilav rehtruf noiterces pE fo noisserppus ro nolcalun�cs htiw det�/cossa eb ot nwonk snoitidnoc lacdrJlc dna laci�olo/syhp ot esnopser ni sno�art -necnoc pE Sni�alucr/c nI semmrced ro sesaercni etairporppa fo noitceted ,noit/dda nI .336 �iteioporhtjlre fo �]assaonummioidaR Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 11 of 13 03496400 CTI-MA 394920 72 MA .11 .01 .9 .8 .7 .6 .5 .57gl ,041� D�M m,�C �L J .nite�opmhtwe namuh rof yassaonumm/ottcar a no seidutS :WJ rehmF dna ,BA egeR .AP nogr,aD ,JJ �roneL .711 .p ..oC gnihs/lbuP dnlLloH-htroN 1791 .matcre�smA .srotide .SR wolaY dna A$ nosreB ,sonomroH yratiutipnoN .HI naP .ygolonircodnE citsonga/D dna ev�agttsevnl m sdohteM :mi ,nitemporht�e fo yassaonumnUo/daR :MP snroC ,231 .p ,etnoP 11 .96gl ,onalfM .srott.de ,C elhcseP dna .M �l�rodnoC .SA nodroG .siseiopmhtw� fo no/ralugeR :�i ,m�opmht�e namuh fo yassaonumm/otdar ehT :FJ aictaG .9691 ,87� )�EM NuC sA,] J �ldob�tna tnereffid owt fo nouaziretca'�ahc �nap :ntteiopothtyre ot �re,�nA :T nadroJ dna .PT dlanoDcM ,DR egnaL .�f91 ,492.�41 |cS dacA �N nnA .nite|opmhtwe fo yassaonummi ha no noicasusevnl :WH neJlrK dna ,R tmruduoG .CLGP xuaongaD sregurK .57� ,56-,� imameH pxE .sUec tev/i latef esuom gnmu nite�oporht/,re rof yassmkb uvlfat/tnauq A :MJ namn�urG dna .HJ �vraJ .RDC nnuD .6691 .646-./"2 doolB .1 .esuom ��mehtycylop eht fo neelps eht no n/t�opm�yre fo tceffe orti� nI :F uka�aT dna ,J arulM .K �kaN .�791 ,513:/'� ygolonncodnE Lev�l rof yassa nA :D amekklS dna ,FJ no�tl ,F ,E ressawdloG tmu�m eht ta orRv ni �eioporht,�e .4 .3 .kroY weN .ro�/de ,WJ rehsiF ,[l LoV �mromroH yendiK :�i .7 .p ,.cnI ,sserP c/meda�A ,7791 ,mtmopmht�re rof syassA :FI,alcraG ntteioporhtyre ntce� .9791 ,34�e deM fo nosirapmoc A :WC amsalP :E sbboC dna ,O relliM ,E usnaK ,J )naC ,J A veJnE Z .2691 ,�4�01I laeM loiB pxE dna ,D mc�oH ,LR niwo ,CeD .I yemuG SECNEREFER .�pncsunam eht fo �o�raperp n/pleh rof namlaK n�raK .sM ot dna ecnmm� lacmhcm elbaulav rof nelhoB loraC .sM dna ,naUA en/,rhtaC .sM ,ttubraG aicmaP .sM ,ekuD aterG .sM ,/eW divaD .rM ot eud osla era sknahT .selpmas mures lamrcn eht fo emos gnitcelloc ni pleh rof aiccoM eppesutG .rD dna ,yassaonumm/oldar nice/apor�yre eht fo no/tazlretupmoc eht m pleh reh rof snomelC .K alesiG .rD ,krow siht tuohguorht memesaruocne gnidnats-gnol sih rof ecnerwaL .H nhoJ .rD knaht eW dna ev�isnes ylemertxe si yassa eht dna deriuqer si ,noitcartxe on htiw ,mures ro amsalp fo emulov llmns a ylnO .yldipar deldnah eb nac selpmas fo srebmun egraL .deen siht stif mrof tneserp sti ni AIR pE eht taht deveileb si tI .cinilc .elbicudorper /ac�ccarp elbaredisnoc fo eb dluohs yhsa ygolotameh pE maruc�a ,tsaf a '� eht ni ecnatropmi ,velsrE yb detseggus sA .yletarapes enomroh hcae fo AIR yb denl.mbo esohc ot tnelav/uqe erew AIR suoenatlumis eht yb deniatbo stluseR ,yletarapes epotosi hcae gnitnuoc ni nekat saw erac itna ,lm htiw eno dna l�a' htiw delebal saw enomroh enO � .� .mures fo elpmas emas eht ni senomroh htob gnirusaem ylsuoenatlumis sAIR ni dexmr yllufesoprup neeb evah senomroh tnereffid owt ot seidobitna hcihw ni snoitacilbup lareves eza mehT .AIR eht etad/lavni ton seod = pE rof cificeps ydobitna sa llew sa snietorp rehto tsniaga seidobitna fo erutxim edurc a s/muresitna siht taht tcaf ehT .AIR suoiverp eht ni desu tahc sa muresitna emas eht si ereh desu muresitna eht ecnis � ,lcetseggus neeb sah sa ,muresitna pE.ima eht htiw ton saw melborp ehT ".tpmetta A[R p:E suo/verp a ni nees seicnapercsid lla devomer sah enidoioidar hRw delebal pE erup fo esU .stne/tap hcus m plhsno/raler p:E-nibolgomeh esrevni na fo evitroppus osia e�a 4 .giF ni nwohs ,sisorbifoleym htiw tneitap arev tycylop e n hgih ehT '= .slevel lamron ot decuder saw noitartnecamrehnibolgomeht enhit snoUarcdneescanoc noc h ehw erc -ni noitercxe pE eh.r ,snolfaxrnecnoc nibolgomeh hgih ta desaerced y/dekranr ro tnesba si tu�uo pE hguohtla taht etacidni arev a/mehtycylop htiw stneitap nI seiduts no�lercxe .sno�artnecnoc pE rewol neve evah ot l�rcepxe eb dluoc ,sno/ta'nnecnoc pE nibolgomeh Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 12 of 13 13496400 CTI-MA 494920/"2 MA .63 .53 .43 �3 .23 �lihsn�taler .13 .03 .9� .82 .72 .62 .52 .42 .32 .22 .12 ,02 .91 .81 .71 .SI .51 .41 .175 .p ..cnI .ss,�h:1 c/nred�cA ,7791 .kroY weN .rot/de .wJ rehsiF .loV .senomroH yend/K :�I .stnemerusaem n/ce/oporhtyre fo ssenlufesu lacln/lc ehT :J A vel�rE ..5791 .914:11 �tgolotebaiD .n/lusni dna nogaculg rof yassaonummi denibmoc A :R q:nelceL dna .;W esal�g .O odel�XleR .I, dnahcraM ,V reyeM-qcrolceL .76gI .33]:/� lom'�cdnE nllC � .enomroh htworg namuh dna n/LuenI fo ya�aonunum denibmoC :A negaK dna MS kc/lG .5691 ,402&� deelB .n�e/opmhtyre wamru namuh htiw dez/nummt �/bbar � deniatbo mure� fo se/�reporp emoS :F� � dna C� y.koohcS .7791 ,S86:�2 deM J l;nE N .slse}opmhtyre fo n�alugeR :GD nahtaN .8691 .795:23 doolB .nol�aluger �mrram �o sn�acllp -arI :nam c/mehtyc/bop dna l*mron n� t/rcetameh nic�e ehT :WJ nosmadA .0891 ,132& lmameH p'xE .seuqinhcet yu�a fo lamrppa na :mures namuh/amron ni netlc n0e�E :DR egnaL dna RDC nnuD .1891 .851:� )�,M �tC �,L J .wmrxm enob esuom gnisu ,n/t�opo'u}tyre mu�es namuh/anrron'to no�tani,,meteD .JC sevaE dna ,C^ sevaE .G lats�K .|891 ,44:49 deg nretni nnA .�/mehtycylop htiw �lneUap gn/taulave nI yassaonummlo�dar niceloporhtwE :E ressawd]oG dna PH re�eoK .572 .p .AEAI .4791 ,anneiV .enicideM ni s-�udecmP detaleR dna yasaaonummloidaR :nI .mtelop)nhtyre namuh fo yasuonummlo�aR :F� alcr�G .0891 ,63�,�I deM loiB "pxE ceS cerP .sivel n�e/oporbtyre no arohte]p fo tceffe ehT :PE etdlnmC dna ,F� alc�aG ,EM relliM ,G atccoM .0891 ,757�88 doolB .peehs AA bH nI gnihctiws nlb)kgomeh dna ,s/s)uycereLm ,sserts cO� :BS tehohS dna ,DP grobnes/E ,F� a�czaG ,LJ ttayW ,RM kralC .N sadnehoM .669� .3,3&1 tsevnI baL nilC J dnatS .�xopyh-OC ot desopxe ec/m no yassa nOelopm�yr.c ev/tlsnes A :J hgoF .44 .p .sserP ege/loC e�atS awoI ,6591 ,awoI .semA .5 .de .sdohteM l�eOslta�S :WG rocedenS .561 .p ,AEA| ,4791 ,anneiV .e�c/deM ni serudecorP detaleR dna yassaonumm/nidaR :nI .gn/tt�l evruc cl:ts�o[ rof dohtem serauqs-gael .evI[aretI ,d�,rhglew detareneg A .syassa )ydobyna deleb ememo/daronummI dna yaassenummlo/dar fo s/sy/ana lac0s�atS :MD truH dna D d,,abdoR .7691 .5�31:�'2 bateM lon�rcodnE n�lC I, ,stneitap ��lagemorca dna s�audlvldni lamron ni seiduts enomroh htworg amsalP :H J ecnerwaL dna .LJ nro� ,E na�guonaM ,AJ toofn/L ,Fi al�.aG .7891 .145&B deM !oIB pxE co$ ccrP .stneitap cimena fo eniru mor'� cOeiopm�yre tnexxl ylhg|hfo n�artnecnoC :HJ ecnerwaL dna .Fi al:naG ,CD ekyD naV .0791 .221.02 mA ta,[ lolsyhP atcA ,anamuh alrannu aniteyo�mt/re ed n�(icac�//ruP :A ykslmuG dna J adapsE .8791 ,948:0� nummoC seR syhpolB mehcolB .�ruo�,)�g-lynehpid-X6 .X3.orolhcar�et-6.4,3.1 .edlnraoro]hc elbulos y]�niraps a htiw no�anido/enarbmem llec dna niet�:1 :rJ CJ kcepS dna ],P reknF .1791 .363:1�2 a�cA syhpoJB mlhco|B .yt/vitca eiceps hgih ot I" ht�w edlcpepylop fo noOanldol c0amyznE :GB nossnahoJ dna lJ UerohT .5';"91 .5:�1 |otameH n/meS .sa/mehtycy|op eht fo noitacifissalc dna slson�a�D :[N n/HeB .9791 ,S�:4S deolB .nI�elopmhtyre rof yassaonumm|oldar A :E ressawdloG dna BJ doowrehS ,9791 .504;8 slieC lcooIB doowrehS ,FJ a/craG woixY dna AS nosro� oIS:� atcA m/hC nt1C .nlte/opmh�yre "io yassaonumm/o/daR :E ressawdloG dna .J .yalsaonummio/dar'to selplcn�p ]areneG :SR .31 .21 mehC iolB l,.ls0e�pou�/,re namuh fo n�i:la��t/rup .7791 ,8555�82 ehT :E ressawdloG dna ,H.KC $nuK ,T ekayiM � emul�V Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-35 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 13 of 13

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?