Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Filing
534
DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Doc. 534 Att. 36
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-37
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 1 of 18
EXHIBIT 22
Dockets.Justia.com
I
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
,7002 yaM yad
,PLL
fo
ts13
eht
no
,sionillI
eht
a
,ogacihC
relohcS
eyaK fo
dnahtrohS
seciffo
ta
,etatS dias
retroper
fo
etatS
deifitreC
dna
rof
RSC
,sionillI
dna
,kooC fo
a
ytnuoC
eht
nihtiw
cilbup yraton
.H
,530000-480.oN
nekat
struoC
,naigidgaD
fo
drahciR
ot
erofeb
,snoitisopeD
tcirtsiD
fo seluR
gnikat
detinU
dna
eht eht
gniniatrep
erudecorP
setatS eht
rof
liviC
rednu
tnemeerga
rof fo
,eciton
ot
tnausrup nekat
,noitanimaxe
ENEGUE
stnadnefeD
eht
yb
dellac
,RESSAWDLOG
ehT
noitisopeD depatoediv
LAITNEDIFNOC
.stnadnefeD
,noitaroproC yesreJ
a
weN
,.CNI
EHCOR
AL-NAMFFOH
a
dna
,ynapmoC
EHCOR EHCOR
namreG
,HbmG
ssiwS
.F
SCITSONGAID YGW
a
,ynapmoC
,.DTL
AL-NAMFFOH
.sv
73221-50
.oN
,ffitnialP
,.CNI
,NEGMA
deifitreC
STTESUHCASSAM
TRUOC TCIRTSID
FO
TCIRTSID
EHT
ROF NI
y oC
7002113/5
SETATS
DETINU
EHT
LAITNEDIFNOC
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 2 of 18
061
egaP
1 LxE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
94:81:5
noitaluceps
rof
sllac
.etad
ti
taht fo
tcejbo
eussi
I
oS
a
42
si ereht eh
84:81:51
54:81:51
gnilif
lagel
eht ehT
32 22
12
,neht
sah
ron
,dna
a
stibihxe
rehtien
gniylrednu
si ssentiw
lla
nees
34:81:51
reywal
04:81:51
73:81:51 43:81:51
13:81:51 92:81:51 si
a
.smret
lagel
,ynam
no
dna
era era
,noitamrofni
ereht
eW
02 91
dna
stibihxe
a
ynam
,tiw
ot
;tnemucod
egap-26
fo
85
egap
81
.riafnu
71
61
ti si
taht
sdnuorg
ehT
eht
no
tcejbo
I
os
,kcirt ytrid
.RM
tnemssessa
62:81:51 12:81:51 02:81:51
81:81:51
noitseuq
.noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
51 41
.ereh s'truoC eht htiw
eergasid
uoy
oD
.seY
Q
A
31 21
iI 0I 9 8
7
81:81:51
51:81:51
?taht
morf
ees
uoy
oD
"secruos
fo
tnanibmocer
a
OPE
gniyfirup
dah
saw
dohtem ni
depoleved yranidro
591
eht
21:81:51 01:81:51 50:81:51 30:81:51
yllufsseccus tey
fo esoht
ton
tra
eht
lliks
,5891 ni
eht fo
hcihw
eht tA"
,noitacilppa
,syas
tI .seY
fo
gnilif
emit
Q
A
6
eht
30:81:51
00:81:51 85:71:51 14:71:51
93:71:51
?taht ,syas tuoba
ees
uoy
od
a
,"gnilif
si
eht
eht
fo
emit
tA"
5 4 3 2 1
taht
ecnetnes
ereht
nO
,nwod senil
.sey
eerht
,nmuloc
dnah-tfel
,85
uoY
Q
A
?85
dias
.noisiced
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 3 of 18
161
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
41:12:51 21:12:51
11:12:51
.niaga noitseuq
eht
yas
esaelp
uoy
dluoW
.seY
A
42 32 22
12
YB
Q
A
?aedi
lareneg
a
tsuj
ti
si
rO
.oN
90:12:51 80:12:51
80:12:51
Q
.RM
:HUS
O2
ni
?troper
siht
A
91 81
60:12:5
40:12:51 10:12:51
hpargarap cificeps
a
ot
gnirrefer
uoy
erA
.eugav
,noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
.RM
71
61 51
41
?tnetap 943
eht
ni eht nwonk
95:02:51 35:02:51 84:02:51 24:02:51
83:02:51
demialc
sdohtem
ni
noitceted
ot
I
saw
yassaonummioidar
dradnats eht
tahw
gnimrofrep
dluow
esu
evah
,eveileb
ta
,4891 ni
noitacificeps
eht ni
31 21
iI
tnetap niL eht
fo
eno
gnikool
ti si
tra
lliks
taht
noinipo
ruoy
,rotcoD
Q
A og
ot
10:02:51
65:91:51
.yakO
.troper
m'I .edisa
0I
trepxe ruoy
taht
tes
ot
kcab uoY
gniog
9
35:91:51
15:91:51
noisiced
nac
Q
A
8
7
?yrros m'I
.rotcoD
05:91:5
,edisa
noisiced
taht
tes
nac
uoY
Q
.RM
YB
6 5
4
31:91:51
11:91:51
:HUS
.ekatsim
I
a
saw
taht
A
kniht
50:91:51 10:91:51 25:81:51
,egduJ eht
ot
tcepser
sa
lla
htiw s'ti
rof
os
,lleW
3
.llew
eht edistuo
era
gnidael
srettam
,troper
dna
trepxe
,llew
sa
2
1
taht
sllac
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 4 of 18
261
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
34:22:51 53:22:51 13:22:51 82:22:51
41:22:51 31:22:51
ta
sseccus
.reilrae
sraey
emos
nilusni
gnisu
enomroh
42
rieht
morf
ot
gnivired
evitcejbo
a
sdradnats riehT
32
22
htiw
elpoep ylppus
..mynorca
si
detacilpmoc
tog s'tI
dlroW
.dnalgnE
A
ni
12
02 91
yrotarobaL noitazinagrO
?bal
OHW
htlaeH
eht
ehT dnA
si
tahw
Q
.bal
OHW
01:22:51 90:22:51
50:22:51 40:22:51 20:22:51 95:12:51 35:12:51
ot
a
81 71
eht
morf
PRI
dnoces
eht
saw
taht
kniht ?3891
I
A
ni
emit
taht
61 51
ta
dradnats
detpecca yramirp
a.
taht
ro
saw
tahw
dnA
Q
a
.dradnats
rehtie
dradnats
sa
yradnoces
dna
ti fo dna
A
ekam
41
ecnerefer
eht
ti
esu
elpmas
,dleif
31 21
ii 0I
teg dluoc
ni
detseretni
saw na
ohw
saw
enoyna
84:12:51
64:12:51 34:12:51 34:12:51
14:12:51
eht
dradnats
?eb
detpecca
taht
erehT
dnA .:HUS
dradnats
dluow
tahw
Q
.RM
A
YB
9 8
.si
tI
.suougib%na
eht setatssim
dna
eugav
s'ti
:DIRDAM
dna
.RM
,tnetap
7
73:12:51
,noitcejbO
943
6
si
63:12:51 92:12:51
52:12:51 02:12:51
81:12:51
taht
?tnetap
eht
ni ni
demialc
esu
taht
5
4
yassaonummioidar
tahw
nwonk
eht
gnimrofrep
dluow
ot
dradnats
evah
3891
eht
sI
ni
ni
noitacificeps
lliks
fo
eno
3
2 1
tnetap niL eht
,rotcoD
gnidaer
ruoy
tra
,noinipo
ti
.eruS
Q
LAITNEDIFNOC 7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 5 of 18
361
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS ddoW etoNeviL
91:42:51 90:42:51
a
fo
tnuoma
nwonk
a
ekat
dluow
a
eno
oS
Q
erapmoc
yassa
42 32
22 12
.yassa dna
emas
nosirapmoc
s'tI
PRI
.meht eht
a sa
60:42:51
10:42:51
dradnats
esu
yramirp
,dradnats
fo
eht
sa
htiw
eht
era
dna
tahw
yradnoces
nwonk
a
gnisoporp
A
55:32:51 45:32:51 44:32:51 24:32:51
14:32:51
uoy
tnuoma
s'tI rieht
naC .seY
O2
91 81
71
?taht
?PRI
dnoces
woh
eht
em
htiw
ot
dradnats uoy
etarbilac
dluow
enoemos
nialpxe
Q
A
61
14:32:51
63:32:51
a
ees
uoy
oD
na
."PRI ni
dnoces
eht
tsniaga
,yassaoib
yeht
hcihw
ot
51
41
ro/dna
,AIR
yllacipyt
detarbilac
nwo
23:32:51
92:32:51 62:32:51 42:32:51
12:32:51
sdradnats
dedeen
yradnoces esuoh-ni
rieht
ni
eraperp
31
21 ii
0i 9 8 7
elpoep dna
ton
saw
seititnauq detimilnu
dnoces eht
elbaliava
taht
PRI
ehT"
ot
,syas
eht
hpargarap
fo
ecnetnes
tsal
dnoces evah
hpargarap
Q
A
tsal .sey
eht
ot
dnoces
uoy
nehT
s'tahT
.seY
71:32:51
,tuoba
gniklat
saw
I
tahw
31:32:51 31:32:51 11:32:51 20:32:51
10:32:51 95:22:51 dnoces ruoy
fo
ot
era
Q
A
?hpargarap
eht
mottob
eht
raen
naem
uoY
6
?tuoba
uoy
gniklat
5
4
taht
dradnats
emas
eht
taht
sI .PRI
3 2 1
ecnerefer
a
evah kool
uoy
,troper
fI
trepxe
74:22:51
ruoy
73
hpargarap
LAITNEDIFNOC
ta
uoy
Q
700211315
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 6 of 18
461
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
31:72:51 01:72:51 40:72:51 00:72:51
yassa
fo
dnik
eno
ni
detarbilac
nI" ,syas
sdradnats
ti ,egap
eht
yradnoces
eht
no
42
,seirotarobal ynam
txen
32
22
hpargarap
taht
fo
eht
ecnetnes
tsal
yllautca
dnA
I
s'ti
hpargarap
ni
no
retal
neht
Q
A
12 O2 91
82:62:51
52:62:51 42:62:51 ."desu
eht hcihw ni eht
eb
ot
.taht ?taht
ees
ees
uoy
oD
gniog
ni
si
dradnats
yradnoces
ecnerefer
81
71
12:62:51 81:62:51
21:62:51
syassa
ro
eht
snoitaraperp
eht
sa
tneuqesbus
PRI
dnoces taht
hcus
dradnats
61 51 41 31
21
yramirp detpecca
.eht fo
na
fo
htiw
dradnats
yradnoces
90:62:51 70:62:51
50:62:51 73:52:51
ytivitca
eht
gnirapmoc yb demrofrep
fo
tI
si
ecnetnes
sdradnats
dnoces
yradnoces
eht
noitarbilaC"
,syas
syas
.yakO
.seY
Q
A
ii
63:52:51 43:52:51 23:52:51 40:52:51
20:52:51
a
?tcerroc
ot
,dradnats
yramirp
ereht
0i 9 8
7
dradnats
a
dnoces
a
fo
noitarbilac .sey
tuoba
noissucsid
evah
uoY
,0-5
,05
?O5
Q
A
troper
ruoy
fo
05
hpargarap
od
ni
,woN
Q
6 5 4 3
htiw
04:42:51
43:42:51 23:42:51 03:42:51 72:42:51
AIR
.serutluc od
htiw
.AIR
ti
na
dluoc ti
no
uoy od
,slamina htiw ti
dluoc
tI
dluoc
od
uoY
ot
htiw
woh
uoY
A
.yassa
eht
detnaw
uoy
sdneped
?taht
na
2
nur
eno
dluow
dna
,niteioporhtyre
fo
elpmas
1
LAITNEDIFNOC
700211315
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 7 of 18
561
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
94:82:51 74:82:51 54:82:51 44:82:51 34:82:51 04:82:51
,won ta
.m.p drocer eht
ffo
52:3
42
32
gnioG
:REHPARGOEDIV
EHT
.seY
:HUS
.RM
22
.esaelp
kaerb
a
12 02
91
evah
ew
dluoC
.thgiR
tceted
A
?tcerroc
ton
,ytivitca
AIR
na
lacigoloib ,thgir
hcihw ekam ot
ym
?ton
ylirassecen
Q
dradnats
taht
73:82:51
43:82:51 13:82:51 72:82:51
12:82:51
seod
esuaceb
dah
s'tahT
81
71
.ytivitca
a sa won
lacigoloib
saw
gnihtemos
tnaw
gnisu
I
erus
dluow I
A
61 51
41 31
si
thgir noisserpmi
kniht I
yhw
dnA
Q
A
41:82:51 31:82:51
.taht
did
reven
ew na
kniht I
htiw
?AIR
depoleved
uoy
21
20:82:51 65:72:51 45:72:51
93:72:51
taht
dradnats
reve
a
nopu
desab
syassa
elib
nI
detarbilac
ii 0I
uoy
evah
,ecneirepxe
ruoy
Q
A
.seY
9
8
?taht
ees
uoy
oD
83:72:51
73:72:51 43:72:51 03:72:51 82:72:51
ot
."rehtona
7
yrotarobal
,elbats eb
eht
eno
morf
derapmoc
neeb
sah
eb
nac
stluser
6
5
eht
ot
nwohs
ot
dna
evruc
,dradnats
esnopser
dradnats
yramirp
esod
a
fo
taht
lellarap
4
3
sa
detarbilac eht
sa
yletarucca
sa
neeb
ecno
sah
42:72:51
91:72:51
yradnoces
fo
gnol
ni
,niaga
tub
,syassa desu
era
2 1
sdnik
rehto
noitarbilac
retfa
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 8 of 18
661
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
33:73:51
13:73:51
?tahw
a
etarbilac
oT
:DIRDAM
.RM
42
32
?tcerroc
a
,yassaoib
a
62:73:51 91:73:51 81:73:51 81:73:51
71:73:51
etarbilac
eurt
ot
AIR
na
rof
dradnats s'tahT
.seY
gnisu
Q
A
ot
22 12 02 91
tcepser htiw
ylirassecen
ton
?taht
ees
uoy
oD
."rehtona
ot
81 71
61:73:51 41:73:51
21:73:51 90:73:51
esod
yrotarobal
,elbats eb
eht fo
eno
morf nwohs
ot
derapmoc eb
neeb sah
nac
stluser
eht
ot
dna
evruc
,dradnats
esnopser dradnats ,syassa
61
51
yramirp
a
taht
lellarap
sah
,detarbilac
sa
yletarucca
sa
neeb
ecno
sah tub
41
60:73:51
20:73:51 85:63:51 55:63:51
yradnoces eht
fo
yassa
gnol
ni
,niaga
31
21
II
sdnik
rehto
eno
noitarbilac
retfa
desu
.era
fo
dnik
ni
detarbilac
nI"
sdradnats ti dnA llA
yradnoces
Q
A
,seirotarobal
ynam
,syas
0i 9 ,troper
erew
45:63:51
45:63:51 15:63:51 74:63:51
.thgir
.ecnetnes
tsal
ot
eht
8
7
trepxe ruoy fo 05
ew
hpargarap
siht
gnirrefer
Q
.RM
,kaerb eht
erofeb
,ressawdloG
rotcoD
6
YB
ta
34:63:51
24:63:51
:HUS
5
4
.deecorp
drocer eht
no
esaelP
.m.p
EHT
33:3
83:63:51
94:82:51 94:82:51
kcab
gnioG
).nekat
saw
:REHPARGOEDIV
3
2 1
ssecer
trohs
a
,nopuerehW(
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 9 of 18
371 egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
33:94:51
33:94:51
.dradnats
ot
a sa
:HUS desu ot
.RM
YB
ees
42
32
yeht
evah
dias
yeht
tahw
A
72:94:51 42:94:51
tnemucod
eht
ta
kool
dluow I
22
.egaugnal
mialc eht setatssim
12 02
32:94:51
02:94:51 91:94:51
41:94:51
,noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
.RM ?PRI
dnoces
91
81
71
eht
fo
dradnats
eht
sa
yraniru gnisu
eb
eht
ot
ro
dradnats
eht
tnanibmocer
ni demialc
tnetap 943
eht
ot
ot
90:94:51 30:94:51 65:84:51
45:84:51
yassaonummioidar
dnatsrednu
ot
ta
dnatsrednu
eno
eno
yeht
dluow
61 51
41
,taht
eht fo
yrt
kool
erew
erew
fi
fI
,tnetap 943
Q
.erus
smialc
eht
31
94:84:5
74:84:51
34:84:51 04:84:51 62:84:51 32:84:51
eb
t'nac I
tub
?OPE
,os
kniht I
.wonk
rof
t'nod I
dradnats
na
A
21
II 0i
tnanibmocer
noitaraperp
yltnerruc
Q
A
ecnerefer
CSASBIN
lanoitanretni
evah
sI
.seY
eht
seod
yltnerruc
ereht
9
8
7
a
?dradnats
a
sa
OPE
tnanibmocer
htiW
Q
.dradnats
91:84:51
71:84:51
sa
6
5
4
taht
htiw
m'I
erew
stluser
ruo
tahw
C
on
gnirrotS
,P
kcirtaP
31:84:51
30:84:51 10:84:51 85:74:51
gnillet
tub fo
,eb yam
K
dna
,L
snoitaraperp
A ?owt
tahw
noitcellocer
evah I
3 2
1
hpargarap
ni
OPE
tnanibmocer
negmA
,OPE
tnanibmocer
LAITNEDIFNOC
700211315
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 10 of 18
471
egaP
1 LxE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
53:15:51 53:15:51 23:15:51 82:15:5
62:15:51 22:15:51
I
esu
:HUS
.RM
YB
42 32 22
12
.ti
tuoba
snoitavreser
evarg
evah
na
hguoht
ot
neve
dradnats
detpecca yllanoitanretni gniod
erew
referp
dluow I
,ti
I
fI
A
.lacitehtopyh
02 91
etelpmocni
,eugav
,noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
.RM
02:15:51
71:15:51
90:15:51
na ro
?dradnats
OPE
eno
OPE
yraniru
taht
na
81
71
tnanibmocer
dluow
a
ot
dezidradnats
saw
AIR
sa
esu
,yassaonummioidar yb denimreted
xis
ot
61 51
41
40:15:51 00:15:5
55:05:51
sruoh stinu
84
ni
sllec
ot
net
ot
rof
erew
niteioporhtyre
eno
fo
00I
enimreted
yrt
fI
no
.egap
tsal
eht
dnA
si
hcihw
31 21
II
04:05:51 83:05:51
03:05:51 72:05:51
,smialc eht
ta
gnikool
era
ew
niaga .yako
,hO
,seY
.tnetap
niL
943
eht
s'taht
.5
0i 9
tibihxE
62:05:51
52:05:51 42:05:51 22:05:51 91:05:51 61:05:51 41:05:51
01:05:51
nrut
.5
?5
.5
tibihxE
8
A
a
gnihtemoS
ta
7
ekat
tibihxE
kool
6 5
4
tnetap 943
?em
eht
si
hcihw uoy
,5
era
tibihxE
,yrros
ta
,seY
m'I
a
Q
A
gnisserdda
.smialc
uoy
eht si
kool
ekat
dluoc
ot
3
fi
,tnetap
uoy
nac
943
eht
hcihw
,5
tibihxE
2
1
esaelp
,rotcoD
,lleW
.yakO
Q
LAITNEDIFNOC 700211315
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 11 of 18
571
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
85:25:51 85:25:51
85:25:51
.seY
A
42
ees
?taht
32 22
uoy
A"
oD
."e.i
0.8
a
slauqe
si
ereht
082
,tnecrep
"fo
eno
eht
ot
05:25:51 24:25:51
,ereht
alumrof
ni
)5p(
fo
ot
noitpmussa
traP" ,syas
ruoy
12 02
eht ti si
eil
dluoc
melborp
eht
93:25:51
43:25:51
13:25:51 02:25:51
,ruof
hcihw
hpargarap
,41
tibihxE
,gnirrotS
ot
rotcoD
rettel
91
81
71
kcab
gniog
.os
,woN
I
Q
A
kniht
?PRI
saw
dnoces
eht
tsniaga detarbilac
OHW
61
81:25:51
21:25:5
OPE taht
tnanibmocer
dradnats
eht
rof
oS
eht
I
yb detpoda
Q
.RM
YB
51
41
yltnerruc
si
.ees
01:25:51 01:25:51 90:25:51
30:25:51 85:15:51 45:15:51 35:15:51
ecnerefer
saw
:HUS
31
21
.noitaraperp
lanoitanretni
eht
tsniaga
dezidradnats
A
.RM
II
0I
9
OPE
tnanibmocer .eugav
gnisu
dradnats
ehT
,noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
?OPE
8
7
yraniru
rof
dradnats
PRI
a
rof
emas
eht
OPE sI
tnanibmocer
94:15:51
74:15:51
rof
eht
si
.OPE
dradnats rof
eht
Q
A
6
dradnats A
:DIRDAM ?OPE
5
4
3 2
44:15:51 24:15:51
14:15:51
ro
.eugav
,noitcejbO
.RM
tnanibmocer
eb
OPE
yraniru
rof
dradnats dluow
a
dradnats
73:15:51
ecnerefer
lanoitanretni
taht
dnA
Q
1
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 12 of 18
671
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
22:45:51
12:45:51
ylirassecen
toN
A
42
?syassaoib
tuoba
32
22
91:45:51
71:45:51 71:45:51
41:45:51
11:45:51
ton
gniklat yllaer
si
.ton
siht seod
oS
tI
A
erusaem
12
?ytivitca cificeps
seod AIR
O2 91
esuaceb
s'ti
dnA
.ees
I
a
Q
sa
.ytivitca cificeps
eht
stluser
A
81 71 61 51
65:35:51 25:35:51 94:35:51 64:35:51
44:35:51
sserpxe
ot
tnaw
uoy
sselnu
ton
,oN
?niteioporhtyre
rof
syassaonummioidar
noitpmussa
siht
si
rof
tuB
desu
s'taht
noitpmussa
na
Q
.ti
erusaem ro
41
31 21
34:35:51 73:35:51
13:35:51
ot
evah
ro
uoY
ro
.ti
emussa
saw
t'nac
tsuj
A
uoY
.21
4.7
,saw
5.8
0.8
tnecrep
eht tahw
na
eno
eht
rehtehw
eht
no
II
0I 9 8
7
stnebrosba
dluow tahT
cificeps
,nietorp
s'ti
dneped
82:35:51 52:35:51
.noitpmussa
esuaceB
A
?noitaluclac siht
eht fo
42:35:51 12:35:51 02:35:51
41:35:51 01:35:51 60:35:51 10:35:51
fo rep
noitpmussa
uoy
siht
ni
seil
melborp
Q
fo
trap taht
gniyas
era
yhw
ereht
dnA
6
.tnebrosba
derusaem sah ti
ni
retemillim
5
4 3 2 1
smargillim
teloivartlu
net
na
nehw
retemotohportceps
082
eno
ni 08
sretemonan
ot
ta
noitulos
A
a
noitprosba
eht
si
tnecrep
?taht
si
A
tahW
Q
LAITNEDIFNOC 7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 13 of 18
771
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
60:65:51
40:65:51 10:65:51
no
;dradnats
nettor
a
si
PRI
dnoces eht
eht
taht dna
delaever
42 32 22
12
sbal
troffe tsal
gnitaroballoc
sihT
lla
yb
,syas
ni
trap
ruoy
esnemmi
ot
:yltsaL"
tsal dluow
eht
ti
hpargarap
Q
taht
em
85:55:51 65:55:51 52:55:51
dnoces .wonk
dnA
gnirrotS
m'I
kcirtaP
tahw wonk
02
tcepxe
tel
ot
I
hguohtla
raf
taht
,tuoba
og
gniklat
91 81
12:55:5
71:55:51 01:55:51
kcab
t'nseod
yromem eht
yM
ni
I
.tnemucod
ot
lanigiro
rewsna
thgie tniop
A
71
gnidnopser
?OPEr
m'I
ot
.taht naht
ot
t'nac
ot
61
si
OPE
70:55:51
30:55:5
mures
rehtar
OPEu ti
resolc
51
41
rehtehw
wonk
tnatropmi
si
yhW
.seY
A
10:55:51 10:55:51
10:55:51 ?taht
ees
31
21
uoy
."OPEr
oD
ot
naht
ew
OPEe
II
75:45:51 45:45:51
ot
resolc
si
OPE
mures
taht
OPE
wonk
ton
od
ecnis
0i 9
detnarraw
ton
si
a
kniht
sa
I
'gnirrucco yllarutan'
OPEu
txen
a
94:45:51 54:45:51
24:45:51 92:45:51 72:45:51 62:45:51 62:45:51 42:45:51
rof ,syas
ti
dradnats
noitaraperp
,egap
fo
esu
ehT"
8
7
,thgie hpargarap
t'nod I
ot
ehT fo
Q
evif
A
.evah
ta
hcihw dluow I
,tnemucod
.wonk
ti
taht
egap
6 5 4
kool
evah
t'nod I
?ot
gnirrefer
si
tahW
:HUS
Q
.RM
YB
3
2 1
.tnemucod
eht
setatssim
,noitcejbO
:DIRDAM
.RM
LAITNEDIFNOC 7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 14 of 18
871
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
22:75:51
81:75:51
.edirolhc
tlaboc
ot
kcab
toN
og
A
dluoc
42
32
yeht
esoppus
nwo
I
,lleW
rieht
.on
,yramirp yeht
31:75:51
90:75:51 90:75:51
?sdradnats
ekam
t'ndluoC
:HUS
Q
.RM YB
22
12 O2
.tuoba
gniklat
esu
erew
uoy
tahw fI
wonk
t'ndluow
elpoep
40:75:51.
00:75:51
,taht
t'ndid
uoy
.noitaraperp ecnerefer
ylno
saw
91
81
lanoitanretni taht
ot
eno
ti
,si
noitseuq
A
85:65:51 55:65:51 05:65:51 84:65:51
64:65:51 34:65:51 83:65:51
sa
evig
nac
I
rewsna
ylno
ehT
71
61 51 41
31
.rehtegot
owt
sgniht
tnereffid
dna
gnittup
skcal
era
uoY
.evitatnemugra s'ti
:DIRDAM .RM
,noitadnuof
,noitcejbO
rof
?niteioporhtyre
rof
stinu
yassaonummioidar
dluow
uoy
enimreted dluow
PRI
yllautca
ti
woh
ot
21
ii
ecnadiug edivorp
nettor
a
,sselehtenon
eht
taht
,dradnats
uoy
23:65:51 92:65:51 62:65:51 52:65:51
91:65:51 71:65:51 41:65:51
nehw
si
dnoces
eveileb
0I 9 8
7
taht
tcaf
eht
etipsed
ruoy
taht
troper
,rotcoD
trepxe ruoy nopu
,oS
.seY
desab
ynomitset
ti
si
Q
A
no
?drocer
nettor
a
eht dah
dradnats dias
6
5
4
PRI
ot
dnoces
derrefer
eht uoy
dellac
tahw
uoy
uoy
reilrae
s'tahT
.seY
Q
A
21:65:51
11:65:51 ?taht tsrif
saw
3
."nesohc
ees
uoy
oD
2 1
01:65:51
ti
nehw
kcab
ekam
ot
deirt I
tniop
a
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 15 of 18
971
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
65:85:51 45:85:51
25:85:51 74:85:51
a
tnetap elohw eht
kool
ot
em
hguorht
A
42 32
tnaw
uoy ni
si
oD
.wonk
t'nod I
dradnats
?tnetap
ot
943
eht
eht
denoitnem
eht si
PRI
dnoces
22 12
ecnerefer
,rotcoD
Q
.stinu
24:85:51 52:85:51 02:85:51 61:85:51
51:85:51 21:85:51 90:85:51
70:85:51
02 91 81
71 61
illim tahw
.ot
ro
stinu
ni
tluser
a
evag uoy
uoy tahw
nehw
tnaem
ti
ro
,ot
gnirrefer
uoy
erew
wenk
enoyrevE
t'ndid
derrefer
tahw
ecnereffid
reporp
htiw
yna
tuB
ekam
ti
,noitazidradnats
.dnuora
og
ot
eno
tsrif eht
51
41 31 21
eht
rof
fo
hguone
eht
t'nsaw
esuaceb enoyna
PRI
ereht
ti
taht tbuod wonk
ot
saw
eno
dnoces .ti
A
nosaer
rehtar
I
gnisu
50:85:51
llits
saw
rehtehw tsrif
t'nod I
20:85:51 55:75:51
35:75:51
?dradnats
eht wonk
gnirrefer
od
tuB
llits
saw
iI 0I
3891
ni
enoyna
rehtehw
uoy .pu
Q
ot
taht
kool
evah
9 8
7
84:75:51 64:75:51
dluow I
a
.rebmemer
t'nod I
,on
.noitaraperp yraniru
A
saw
ti
kniht I
ehT
dradnatS
saw
saw
,kniht
14:75:51 73:75:51
13:75:5 82:75:51
I
,PRI
tsrif
.tlaboc ni
ton
tahT
PRI
A
6
eht
ot
?3891
dradnats
wonk
tsrif
oD
5
4
gnirrefer
erew
elpoep rehtehw
uoy
Q
A
.seY
3 2 1
62:75:51
42:75:51 tsrif
eht taht
?depoleved
t'nsaw
saw
uoy
taht
dradnats
tahT
.eruS
Q
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 16 of 18
081
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
41:00:61 90:00:6
uoy
oD
.ii
egap
ot
pu si
yaw
eht
lla neht
no
seog
ti
dna
42 32
,evif
,ruof
,eerht
egap
ereht
dnA .seY
Q
A ? "owt
60:00:61
60:00:61
50:00:61
22
12
egap"
,egap
syas
ti
,elddim pot yrev
eht
no
eht
no
si
ereht
02
91
20:00:61 25:95:51
15:95:51 84:95:5
943
dnoces
ees
uoy
oD
.yakO
,seY
saw
Q
A
.taht .5
eht
ta
tog ev'I
dekram
I
81
tibihxE uoy
sa
hcihw
tnetap
71 61
kool
ot
tnaw
.yrros
m'I
Q
A
34:95:51 04:95:51
53:95:51 82:95:51 22:95: 91:95:51 81:95:51 61:95:51
.943
erofeb
dias
uoy
tahw
raeh
t'ndid I hcihw
51
tibihxE
tnetap 943 eht si
ot
,5
Q
41
gniog
ot
nrut
uoy
fo
nac
,rotcoD
yna
31
t'nod I
A
.ti
yromem
evah t'nod I
21
.gniyas tsuj
m'I
tahw
s'tahT
.llacer
II 0I
9
?llacer
uoy od
llacer
uoy
ni
oD
.yrros kool m'I
m'I
ot
Q
dluow I
A .RM ot
.tnemucod
eht
ti
rof
ton
evah
8 7
6 5 4
41:95:5
11:95: 60:95:51 40:95:51
.yromem
ot
siht
dna
dettimmoc
,niagA
:DIRDAM
.suougibma
eugav
,noitcejbO
?dradnats
yramirp
ot
a
dradnats
htiw
yradnoces
noissucsid
a
a
eht
morf
noitarbilac eht
tcepser
10:95:51 85:85:51
75:85:51
evah
tnetap 943
.llacer
seoD
3
2
Q
t'nod I uoy
oD
?llacer
1
LAITNEDIFNOC
700211315
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 17 of 18
181 egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
04:10:61
83:10:61
eht
dna
atad
eht
rof
kool
ot
tnaw
uoY
A
em
42
rof
?si kool
ot
atad
taht uoy
ot
erehw
32 22
63:10:61
yrt
ot
emit
emos
dneps
.yromem
naC
Q
fo
33:10:61
72:10:61
42:10:61 12:10:61
61:10:61
ot
repap
eceip
I
12
O2
yklub siht dettimmoc
.ereh ni
era
ton
ev'I
wonk
,gniyas peek
t'nod I esod dnif
A
sA
atad
eht
taht
91
81
71
?sevruc
esnopser
atad eht
eseht
ot evaH ot
etareneg tnetap eht
Q
dluow I
A
desu
reve
saw
hcihw
evah
21:10:61
80:10:61
00:10:61
ni
dekool
uoy
reve
uoy kool
tub
61
.ti
.tnemucod siht ni
rof
evah
51
41
ylbaborp
?I
s'ti
,oN
ereh
AIR oD
85:00:61
erugif
ni
detroper
siht
,saw
31
21 II
75:00:61 35:00:6
15:00:61 84:00:61
eerht
ro
gnieb
dradnats
s'taht
OPE
namuh
dradnats wonk
ralucitrap
siht
tahw
uoy
Q
.selpmas
dna
na
evruc
0I 9
dradnats
evruc
a
htiw
snur a
tnereffid
ruof
73:00:61 92:00:61
32:00:61 81:00:61 71:00:61
AIR
fo 1
esnopser tahw
em
esod
llet
s'tI
naC
A
8
7
?si
erugif
uoy
Q
Q
A
.yakO
.seY
6
5
?i
a
erugif
4
61:00:61
51:00:61 51:00:61
si
ereht
,egap
txen
eht
neht
dnA
.seY
Q
A
3
2
ees
?taht
1
LAITNEDIFNOC
7002113/5
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-37 Filed 06/20/2007
Page 18 of 18
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?