Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Filing
534
DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al
Doc. 534 Att. 37
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 1 of 9
EXHIBIT 23
Dockets.Justia.com
1
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
***
LAITNEDIFNOC
EGAP
DETANGISED DNA
EREW 911
***
***
121
GNIDULCNI
HGUORHT
EGAP
***
.7002
,yraurbeF
fo
yad
ht41
eht
no
,.m.a
kcolc'o
kooC
31:9
ta
gnicnemmoc
fo
,sionillI
ni
,ytnuoC
lanoitaN
fo
,ogacihC
,0014
ytiC
ta
eht
,azalP
tsriF eht
rof
ot
eerhT
etiuS
truoC
,snoitisoped
setatS
gnikat
eht
gniniatrep
liviC
tcirtsiD
detinU
ot
erudecorP
fo
seluR
laredeF
eht
tnausrup
.S GERG
,cilbuP yratoN
erofeb fo
,RRC
,RMR
,RSC
,DNALIEW
ENEGUE
nekat
,.D.hP
,RESSAWDLOG
noitisopeD depatoediV
.stnadnefeD
,noitaroproC yesreJ
weN
a
,.CNI
EHCOR
AL-NNAMFFOH
a
dna
,ynapmoC
EHCOR
namreG
,HbmG
ssiwS
.F
SCITSONGAID
a
,ynapmoC
,.DTL
EHCOR
AL-NNAMFFOH
.SV
YGW
73221-50
.oN
,ffitnialP
,.CNI
STTESUHCASSAM
FO TCIRTSID
EHT ROF NI
ypoC deifitreC
Page 2 of 9
7002141/2
NEGMA
TRUOC
.D.hP
TCIRTSID
SETATS
DETINU
E-HT
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Filed 06/20/2007
84
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
?esnes ?saw
tahw ni
erusaem
evitcA ti
a
.A
52
42
,ope
saw
ope
eht
evitca
woh
diD si
.Q
tub
.yassa
edurc
cificeps
na
ti
32
tsniaga
lairetam
desiar
fo
ydobitna
eht
yb dezingocer
tI
.A
22 12 02 91
taht
tnuoma
derusaem
?erusaem
ti
did
tahw
,ope
rof
AIR
eht
desu
uoynehW
.huh-hU
°A
erom
81
tib
.AIR
siht
I
tuoba
71
61
elttil
a
dnatsrednu
ot
tnaw
tsuj
,woN
.Q
raey
.taht
a
erofeb
51
tuoba
m'I
rof
,on
enod
saw
krow
eht
os
,9791
saw
dehsilbup
.A
41
31
,yrros
91
ni
dehsilbup
ruoy
uoY
tI
.noitcellocer
ereht
hserfer .eerf
saw
ot
deen
uoy
fi
21 iI
evitcepsreP
eht
evah
leeF
nehw
I
.Q
uoy
.A
.dehsilbup
nac
ti
llet
0i
9
I
,ereh gnikool ni
?enod .bal
,uoy siht
llet
nac
krow
ym ni
saw
nehw
a
dnA ehS dnA
.Q
.A
8
7
cod
ro
tsop
ehs
si
ohw
?eh
si
.B
.Q
.A
6
.doowrehS
htiduJ
5
4
?ope rof
AIR
siht
gnipoleved
.yas
nac
no
uoy tseb taht
htiw eht dias
dekrow tuoba
reve
ohW
oO
tub
3
I
s'taht ehs taht
,ti
2 1
ni
dedeeccus
dah
ehs
llacer
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 3 of 9
7002141/2
.D.hP
eneguE ,ressawdloG
94
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
a
saw
wenk
uoy eht
gnihtemos
did
ni
tup dna ezis
uoy
ralucelom
.A
52 42 32 22 12 02 91 81
71
fo
gnitros
ydaerla
ti
fi ,lleW
woh
?taht
uoy
llet
dluow
,woH
.Q
.A
?yrroS
?taht od
ti
dluow
woH
.Q
dellac
.ope
ton
na saw
saw
taht uoy
lairetam
evitcaer
AIR
yllacigolonummi
,ezis
,lleW
ope
ereht
fo
llet
dluow
eht
ralucelom
.A
llams
gnihtemos
ni
tup uoy fi
?nietorp
eht
saw
eritne
61
51 41
ti
rehtehw
ro
tnemgarf
AIR
a
saw
.ti rehtehw
.Q
.ezis
fo
uoy
llet
t'ndluoc
flesti
eht
tuB
31
sisab
no
eht
no a
selucelom
etarapes
taht
od
dluow dluoc
ope fo
taht
uoY
gnihtemos
.A
a
21
ii
elpmas
?ope
gnittup yb
eht uoy naht
ton
ro
eritne
erew
rehtar
tnemgarf
uoy dluoc
ot
0i 9 8
7
gnidnib
,desu
rehtehw nehw
llet
oS
woh
saw
ope
rof
AIR
eht
.yakO
.seY
.Q
.A
?ydobitna
taht tcaf
eht
eht
uoy
ot
os
dnib
dnA
dluoc
ti
6 5
4
derusaem ti
.sey
naem
,yllacigolonummi
woh
erusaem
evitcA
ti
?lla
ta
saw
ti
evitca
diD
.oN
3
2
.yllacigoloib
Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 4 of 9
7002141/2
.D.hP
evitcA
oO
1
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
eneguE ,ressawdloG
05
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
hcihw ti
nodnoL
fo
edistuo
ta
lliH
lliM
a
ta
dehsilbatse erehT
tahW
.seY
.A
saw
52
42
nehw
emit
taht
yrotarobal
?naem
si seod
taht
.Q
.A
era
32 22 stinu 12
02 91
?ope rof
lanoitanretni
tahw wonk
AIR
uoy
od
oS
.yakO
llet
ew
.Q
t'ndluoc
.flesti
eW
eht
ot
tsuj yb
dluow fi
.gnitros
a
eht fi
od
evah
ew
,ti
.A
tuoba
81
71
noitseuq
dah
ew
erew
,lleW
naht
?elucelom
a ro
ope
etelpmoc
ope
rellams
a
61
51
41
tnemgarf
a
susrev
elucelom
etelpmoc
uoy
ot
gnidnib
woh
ydobitna
eht
neewteb
hsiugnitsid
uoy nehW
dluoc
,stnemirepxe
esoht
gniod
erew
31
.ope
21 ii
rof tahw
AIR
eht
no
s08'
ylrae
ekat
.on
,s07'
s'tel
etal
oS
eht
ni
did
uoy
fo
elpmaxe
taht
.yakO
toN
.Q
.A
0i 9
ezis
,ylenituor
eht
?AIR
did
uoy
uoy
erofeb
8
7
eht
rof
tros AIR
uoy
did
,depoleved
ni
oS
taht
m'I
.seY
stnemirepxe
.Q
.A
ruoy
gniod
.yrros
6 5
did 4
?AIR
eht
uoy
erofeb
tros
ot
dah
uoy
snaem
taht
oS
.Q
3 2 1
.gnorts
yrev si ecnerefni eht
,thgiew
ralucelom
rellams
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 5 of 9
7002/41/2
.D.hP
eneguE ,ressawdloG
15
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
llec
eht
ot
doolb
der
gnitomorp
ni
eht taht
ytivitca lacigoloib
dias
kaerb
saw
52
42
tnelaviuqe ytivitca
.nwod
uoY
nac
I
fi
ees
32
tsuj
em
teL
.noitinifed .lamina
gib
a
tahT otni
a
oQ
22 12 02 91
81 71
yassa
eht
detcejni
noitamrof
edirolhc
llec
tlaboc
doolb
fo
tnuoma
deificeps
ni
fo
der
gnitomorp
ytivitca lacigoloib
eht
eW
ot
eht
m'I
ot
tnelaviuqe ytivitca
eht
sa a
gniyrt
.A
evitceffe
ti
denifed tahw
?tniop
taht
ta
tinu
saw
dnA
.Q
od
ot
61
51
41
.syassa
evitatitnauq
.A
yrt
ot
detrats
tsrif
ew
nehw
no
ylrae yreV
.seY
.Q
.A
31 21 ii
?nehW ?taht od uoy
did
nehW
saw
.yrartibra
tinu
fo
taht
0I
noitinifed
a
edam
uoy
dias
uoy
oS
erew
.Q
ew
9
woh
.ylevitatitnauq gnikrow
wonk
na
8
7
ot
dedeen
ew
nehw
a
edam
fo
ew
hcihw
eno
yrartibra
lairetam
si
,revewoh
,tinu
.bal
noitinifed morf
emac no
ehT
6 5
4
OHW
eht
taht
dezidradnats
a
htiw fo
nosirapmoc
a
sdneped ytivitca
eht
lacigoloib
tA
tinu
fo
fo
noitinifed
fo
,tneserp
ro
3
2 1
.senomroh
noitazidradnats
htlaeH
gnihtemos
eht
tnemtraped noitazinagrO
Filed 06/20/2007 Page 6 of 9
7002141/2
.D.hP
dlroW
deniatnoc
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
eneguE ,ressawdloG
25
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
peehs evitca
tsrif
ew
tub
edurc
ylriaf
uoy
fo llet
saw
noitaraperp
t'nac
I
a
evag
52 42 32
22
nehw
,etad
eht
.A
?taht
nehw
dnA
.seY
.Q
.A
ta
?emit
emoceb tinu fo
tnemerusaem
yna
dexif
12
eht
diD
.yakO
.seY
.Q
.A
saw
02 91 81
71 sllec
?yrartibra
tinu
fo
tnemerusaem
taht
taht
dias
uoy
yassa
dnA
.Q
ni
.A
.lamina
doolb
der
eht
ehT
61
51 41 31
delebal
ylwen
fo
noitamrof
?ytivitca
lacigoloib yb
naem
uoy
did
tahw
fo
a
dnA tlaboc
.A
a
.ytivitca lacigoloib
htiw
tlas
saw
eht
21
derapmoc
sa
ytivitca
?tinu
fo
tinu
tI
II
saw
ytivitca lacigoloib
eht desu
uoy
taht
0i
,ope
rof
tinu
mret
nehw
oS
9
.taht
8
7
ekirts
.ope fo
enifed
uoy
did eht
woh
oS
.yakO
tI
noitamrof
setalumits
6
eht otni
?lamina
5
4
detcejni
nehw
od
edirolhc
tlaboc
seod
tahW .nwod
3 2 1
taht
kaerb
em
tel
os
,lamina yassa eht otni
tnuoma
detcejni
noitamrof
edirolhc
tlaboc
fo
deificeps
·
fo
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 7 of 9
7002/41/2
.D.hP
eneguE ,ressawdloG
35
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
ylevitatup
lla
erew
yeht
,ecnesse
ni
tuB
52
.sdradnats 42 32 22 12
dnoces
dna dna
tsrif
eht
htiw tsrif
derapmoc
eht
a
dradnats
driht
dna
tnew tI
eht
neht eb
dradnats dradnats
htiw
os
derapmoc
dnA
.tuo
edam
dluow
dnoces emoceb
.elbaliava .emit
ton
tsomla
dluow
I
dradnats
.A
02 91 81
71 61 51 41
tsrif
ehT
htiw
deirav
eno
ti
,dias
ereht
sA oS .seY
?dradnats
saw
.Q
.A
?epyt
a
emos
fo
dradnats
ot
ti
erapmoc
ot
evah
uoy
tuB
.era
.yakO yeht
sa
.Q
yrartibra
.]stinu
fo erapmoc
ni
desserpxe
nwonk
a
s'taht
ta
dna
,ytivitca lacigoloib
er'uoy
a
no
31
21 ii
tnuoma uoY
ot
gnikool
lairetam
era
eht
.sisab
evitarapmoc
uoy
enod
syassa
.A
llA
.dexif
yb
naem
tahw
wonk
t'nod I
0i
?tinu 9
rof
dradnats
dexif
a
ereht
saw
,3891 ni
oS
.Q
tsrif
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
.dradnats eht
tI
ot
detaler
lla
saw
a
ti
saw
tub
reven
,emit htiw deirav
erehT rof
oD .A
.dradnats
elgnis
?reve
fi
wonk
,tinu
uoy
dradnats
elgnis
a
detaerc
OHW
eht
nehw
.Q
.etubirtsid
dna
ezidradnats
ot
bal
OHW
eht
ot
ope
amsalp
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
Document 534-38
Filed 06/20/2007
Page 8 of 9
7002/41/2
.D.hP
eneguE ,ressawdloG
45
egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008
ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL
gniklat er'uoy
taht
tset
AIR
eht
od
ot
tuB
.Q
.dradnats
52
42
a
sa
taht
ew
detpoda tsuj
nehw
ew
,tlaboc fo
ot
tceffe dedeen
ta
32
22
eht
ew
derevocsid
dna
,ti
a
ezidradnats
gnizilaer
,reilrae
ni
kcab
neht
dna
dradnats
gnivah
s05'
ton
tsrif
12
02
neve
spahrep
,kniht
I
etal
eW
,s05'
.A
eht
syassa
evitatitnauq dehsilbup
91
81
71
.dnatsrednu I
.srepap ym fo
.Q
.A
tsil
etelpmoc
.uoy
a
ton
si
sihT fi
spleh
?taht
taht
saw
evitcepsreP
.Q
.A
61
51 41
ruoy
ta
kool
ot
eerf
leeF
nehW
.seY
·-'
dluoc
enoemos
?saw
tinu
a
tahw
enimreted
31
21 ii
woh
hsilbup
tlaboc
uoy
no
diD
.Q
.A
.edirolhc
desaB
.yakO
.seY
.Q
.A
0i 9
8 7
?bal
ogacihC
fo
ytisrevinU
.ba· yM
.Q
.A
?gnieb
.su
sU
.Q
.A
6
5 4 3 2
eht
yb denifed
lla
saw
ti
,oN
?snoitazinagro
htiw
tnereffid
ro
sdradnats
tnereffid
eht
ereht
saw
erew
,OHW
eht
yb
denifed
ylno
dradnats
dnA
.Q
emas
.ytivitca lacigoloib
Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 9 of 9
700214112
.D.hP
fo
tnuoma
1
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
eneguE ,ressawdloG
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?