Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Download PDF
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al Doc. 534 Att. 37 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 1 of 9 EXHIBIT 23 Dockets.Justia.com 1 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL *** LAITNEDIFNOC EGAP DETANGISED DNA EREW 911 *** *** 121 GNIDULCNI HGUORHT EGAP *** .7002 ,yraurbeF fo yad ht41 eht no ,.m.a kcolc'o kooC 31:9 ta gnicnemmoc fo ,sionillI ni ,ytnuoC lanoitaN fo ,ogacihC ,0014 ytiC ta eht ,azalP tsriF eht rof ot eerhT etiuS truoC ,snoitisoped setatS gnikat eht gniniatrep liviC tcirtsiD detinU ot erudecorP fo seluR laredeF eht tnausrup .S GERG ,cilbuP yratoN erofeb fo ,RRC ,RMR ,RSC ,DNALIEW ENEGUE nekat ,.D.hP ,RESSAWDLOG noitisopeD depatoediV .stnadnefeD ,noitaroproC yesreJ weN a ,.CNI EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH a dna ,ynapmoC EHCOR namreG ,HbmG ssiwS .F SCITSONGAID a ,ynapmoC ,.DTL EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .SV YGW 73221-50 .oN ,ffitnialP ,.CNI STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID EHT ROF NI ypoC deifitreC Page 2 of 9 7002141/2 NEGMA TRUOC .D.hP TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU E-HT Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 eneguE ,ressawdloG Filed 06/20/2007 84 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL ?esnes ?saw tahw ni erusaem evitcA ti a .A 52 42 ,ope saw ope eht evitca woh diD si .Q tub .yassa edurc cificeps na ti 32 tsniaga lairetam desiar fo ydobitna eht yb dezingocer tI .A 22 12 02 91 taht tnuoma derusaem ?erusaem ti did tahw ,ope rof AIR eht desu uoynehW .huh-hU °A erom 81 tib .AIR siht I tuoba 71 61 elttil a dnatsrednu ot tnaw tsuj ,woN .Q raey .taht a erofeb 51 tuoba m'I rof ,on enod saw krow eht os ,9791 saw dehsilbup .A 41 31 ,yrros 91 ni dehsilbup ruoy uoY tI .noitcellocer ereht hserfer .eerf saw ot deen uoy fi 21 iI evitcepsreP eht evah leeF nehw I .Q uoy .A .dehsilbup nac ti llet 0i 9 I ,ereh gnikool ni ?enod .bal ,uoy siht llet nac krow ym ni saw nehw a dnA ehS dnA .Q .A 8 7 cod ro tsop ehs si ohw ?eh si .B .Q .A 6 .doowrehS htiduJ 5 4 ?ope rof AIR siht gnipoleved .yas nac no uoy tseb taht htiw eht dias dekrow tuoba reve ohW oO tub 3 I s'taht ehs taht ,ti 2 1 ni dedeeccus dah ehs llacer Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 3 of 9 7002141/2 .D.hP eneguE ,ressawdloG 94 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL a saw wenk uoy eht gnihtemos did ni tup dna ezis uoy ralucelom .A 52 42 32 22 12 02 91 81 71 fo gnitros ydaerla ti fi ,lleW woh ?taht uoy llet dluow ,woH .Q .A ?yrroS ?taht od ti dluow woH .Q dellac .ope ton na saw saw taht uoy lairetam evitcaer AIR yllacigolonummi ,ezis ,lleW ope ereht fo llet dluow eht ralucelom .A llams gnihtemos ni tup uoy fi ?nietorp eht saw eritne 61 51 41 ti rehtehw ro tnemgarf AIR a saw .ti rehtehw .Q .ezis fo uoy llet t'ndluoc flesti eht tuB 31 sisab no eht no a selucelom etarapes taht od dluow dluoc ope fo taht uoY gnihtemos .A a 21 ii elpmas ?ope gnittup yb eht uoy naht ton ro eritne erew rehtar tnemgarf uoy dluoc ot 0i 9 8 7 gnidnib ,desu rehtehw nehw llet oS woh saw ope rof AIR eht .yakO .seY .Q .A ?ydobitna taht tcaf eht eht uoy ot os dnib dnA dluoc ti 6 5 4 derusaem ti .sey naem ,yllacigolonummi woh erusaem evitcA ti ?lla ta saw ti evitca diD .oN 3 2 .yllacigoloib Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 4 of 9 7002141/2 .D.hP evitcA oO 1 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY eneguE ,ressawdloG 05 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL hcihw ti nodnoL fo edistuo ta lliH lliM a ta dehsilbatse erehT tahW .seY .A saw 52 42 nehw emit taht yrotarobal ?naem si seod taht .Q .A era 32 22 stinu 12 02 91 ?ope rof lanoitanretni tahw wonk AIR uoy od oS .yakO llet ew .Q t'ndluoc .flesti eW eht ot tsuj yb dluow fi .gnitros a eht fi od evah ew ,ti .A tuoba 81 71 noitseuq dah ew erew ,lleW naht ?elucelom a ro ope etelpmoc ope rellams a 61 51 41 tnemgarf a susrev elucelom etelpmoc uoy ot gnidnib woh ydobitna eht neewteb hsiugnitsid uoy nehW dluoc ,stnemirepxe esoht gniod erew 31 .ope 21 ii rof tahw AIR eht no s08' ylrae ekat .on ,s07' s'tel etal oS eht ni did uoy fo elpmaxe taht .yakO toN .Q .A 0i 9 ezis ,ylenituor eht ?AIR did uoy uoy erofeb 8 7 eht rof tros AIR uoy did ,depoleved ni oS taht m'I .seY stnemirepxe .Q .A ruoy gniod .yrros 6 5 did 4 ?AIR eht uoy erofeb tros ot dah uoy snaem taht oS .Q 3 2 1 .gnorts yrev si ecnerefni eht ,thgiew ralucelom rellams Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 5 of 9 7002/41/2 .D.hP eneguE ,ressawdloG 15 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL llec eht ot doolb der gnitomorp ni eht taht ytivitca lacigoloib dias kaerb saw 52 42 tnelaviuqe ytivitca .nwod uoY nac I fi ees 32 tsuj em teL .noitinifed .lamina gib a tahT otni a oQ 22 12 02 91 81 71 yassa eht detcejni noitamrof edirolhc llec tlaboc doolb fo tnuoma deificeps ni fo der gnitomorp ytivitca lacigoloib eht eW ot eht m'I ot tnelaviuqe ytivitca eht sa a gniyrt .A evitceffe ti denifed tahw ?tniop taht ta tinu saw dnA .Q od ot 61 51 41 .syassa evitatitnauq .A yrt ot detrats tsrif ew nehw no ylrae yreV .seY .Q .A 31 21 ii ?nehW ?taht od uoy did nehW saw .yrartibra tinu fo taht 0I noitinifed a edam uoy dias uoy oS erew .Q ew 9 woh .ylevitatitnauq gnikrow wonk na 8 7 ot dedeen ew nehw a edam fo ew hcihw eno yrartibra lairetam si ,revewoh ,tinu .bal noitinifed morf emac no ehT 6 5 4 OHW eht taht dezidradnats a htiw fo nosirapmoc a sdneped ytivitca eht lacigoloib tA tinu fo fo noitinifed fo ,tneserp ro 3 2 1 .senomroh noitazidradnats htlaeH gnihtemos eht tnemtraped noitazinagrO Filed 06/20/2007 Page 6 of 9 7002141/2 .D.hP dlroW deniatnoc Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 eneguE ,ressawdloG 25 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL peehs evitca tsrif ew tub edurc ylriaf uoy fo llet saw noitaraperp t'nac I a evag 52 42 32 22 nehw ,etad eht .A ?taht nehw dnA .seY .Q .A ta ?emit emoceb tinu fo tnemerusaem yna dexif 12 eht diD .yakO .seY .Q .A saw 02 91 81 71 sllec ?yrartibra tinu fo tnemerusaem taht taht dias uoy yassa dnA .Q ni .A .lamina doolb der eht ehT 61 51 41 31 delebal ylwen fo noitamrof ?ytivitca lacigoloib yb naem uoy did tahw fo a dnA tlaboc .A a .ytivitca lacigoloib htiw tlas saw eht 21 derapmoc sa ytivitca ?tinu fo tinu tI II saw ytivitca lacigoloib eht desu uoy taht 0i ,ope rof tinu mret nehw oS 9 .taht 8 7 ekirts .ope fo enifed uoy did eht woh oS .yakO tI noitamrof setalumits 6 eht otni ?lamina 5 4 detcejni nehw od edirolhc tlaboc seod tahW .nwod 3 2 1 taht kaerb em tel os ,lamina yassa eht otni tnuoma detcejni noitamrof edirolhc tlaboc fo deificeps · fo Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 7 of 9 7002/41/2 .D.hP eneguE ,ressawdloG 35 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL ylevitatup lla erew yeht ,ecnesse ni tuB 52 .sdradnats 42 32 22 12 dnoces dna dna tsrif eht htiw tsrif derapmoc eht a dradnats driht dna tnew tI eht neht eb dradnats dradnats htiw os derapmoc dnA .tuo edam dluow dnoces emoceb .elbaliava .emit ton tsomla dluow I dradnats .A 02 91 81 71 61 51 41 tsrif ehT htiw deirav eno ti ,dias ereht sA oS .seY ?dradnats saw .Q .A ?epyt a emos fo dradnats ot ti erapmoc ot evah uoy tuB .era .yakO yeht sa .Q yrartibra .]stinu fo erapmoc ni desserpxe nwonk a s'taht ta dna ,ytivitca lacigoloib er'uoy a no 31 21 ii tnuoma uoY ot gnikool lairetam era eht .sisab evitarapmoc uoy enod syassa .A llA .dexif yb naem tahw wonk t'nod I 0i ?tinu 9 rof dradnats dexif a ereht saw ,3891 ni oS .Q tsrif 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 .dradnats eht tI ot detaler lla saw a ti saw tub reven ,emit htiw deirav erehT rof oD .A .dradnats elgnis ?reve fi wonk ,tinu uoy dradnats elgnis a detaerc OHW eht nehw .Q .etubirtsid dna ezidradnats ot bal OHW eht ot ope amsalp Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 8 of 9 7002/41/2 .D.hP eneguE ,ressawdloG 45 egaP 1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL gniklat er'uoy taht tset AIR eht od ot tuB .Q .dradnats 52 42 a sa taht ew detpoda tsuj nehw ew ,tlaboc fo ot tceffe dedeen ta 32 22 eht ew derevocsid dna ,ti a ezidradnats gnizilaer ,reilrae ni kcab neht dna dradnats gnivah s05' ton tsrif 12 02 neve spahrep ,kniht I etal eW ,s05' .A eht syassa evitatitnauq dehsilbup 91 81 71 .dnatsrednu I .srepap ym fo .Q .A tsil etelpmoc .uoy a ton si sihT fi spleh ?taht taht saw evitcepsreP .Q .A 61 51 41 ruoy ta kool ot eerf leeF nehW .seY ·-' dluoc enoemos ?saw tinu a tahw enimreted 31 21 ii woh hsilbup tlaboc uoy no diD .Q .A .edirolhc desaB .yakO .seY .Q .A 0i 9 8 7 ?bal ogacihC fo ytisrevinU .ba· yM .Q .A ?gnieb .su sU .Q .A 6 5 4 3 2 eht yb denifed lla saw ti ,oN ?snoitazinagro htiw tnereffid ro sdradnats tnereffid eht ereht saw erew ,OHW eht yb denifed ylno dradnats dnA .Q emas .ytivitca lacigoloib Document 534-38 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 9 of 9 700214112 .D.hP fo tnuoma 1 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY eneguE ,ressawdloG

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?