AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC. et al v. PUBLIC.RESOURCE.ORG, INC.
Filing
60
MOTION for Summary Judgment Filed by AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC., AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION, INC., NATIONAL COUNCIL ON MEASUREMENT IN EDUCATION, INC. (Attachments: #1 Statement of Facts Points of Authority, #2 Statement of Facts Statement of Undisputed Facts, #3 Declaration Declaration of Jonathan Hudis, #4 Exhibit Ex. A, #5 Exhibit Ex. B, #6 Exhibit Ex. C, #7 Exhibit Ex. D, #8 Exhibit Ex. E, #9 Exhibit Ex. F, #10 Exhibit Ex. G, #11 Exhibit Ex. H, #12 Exhibit Ex. I, #13 Exhibit Ex. J, #14 Exhibit Ex. K, #15 Exhibit Ex. L, #16 Exhibit Ex. M, #17 Exhibit Ex. N, #18 Exhibit Ex. O, #19 Exhibit Ex. P, #20 Exhibit Ex. Q, #21 Exhibit Ex. R, #22 Exhibit Ex. S, #23 Exhibit Ex. T, #24 Exhibit Ex. U, #25 Exhibit Ex. V-1, #26 Exhibit Ex. V-2, #27 Exhibit Ex. W, #28 Exhibit Ex. X, #29 Exhibit Ex. Y, #30 Exhibit Ex. Z, #31 Exhibit Ex. AA, #32 Exhibit Ex. BB, #33 Exhibit Ex. CC, #34 Exhibit Ex. DD, #35 Exhibit Ex. EE, #36 Exhibit Ex. FF-1, #37 Exhibit Ex. FF-2, #38 Exhibit Ex. FF-3, #39 Exhibit Ex. FF-4, #40 Exhibit Ex. FF-5, #41 Exhibit Ex. FF-6, #42 Exhibit Ex. GG, #43 Exhibit Ex. HH, #44 Exhibit Ex. II, #45 Exhibit Ex. JJ, #46 Exhibit Ex. KK, #47 Exhibit Ex. LL, #48 Exhibit Ex. MM, #49 Declaration Declaration of Marianne Ernesto, #50 Exhibit Ex. NN, #51 Exhibit Ex. OO, #52 Exhibit Ex. PP, #53 Exhibit Ex. QQ, #54 Exhibit Ex. RR, #55 Exhibit Ex. SS, #56 Exhibit Ex. TT, #57 Exhibit Ex. UU, #58 Exhibit Ex. VV, #59 Exhibit Ex. WW, #60 Exhibit Ex. XX, #61 Exhibit Ex. YY, #62 Exhibit Ex. ZZ, #63 Exhibit Ex. AAA, #64 Exhibit Ex. BBB, #65 Exhibit Ex. CCC, #66 Exhibit Ex. DDD, #67 Exhibit Ex. EEE, #68 Exhibit Ex. FFF, #69 Exhibit Ex. GGG, #70 Exhibit Ex. HHH, #71 Exhibit Ex. III, #72 Exhibit Ex. JJJ, #73 Declaration Declaration of Lauress Wise, #74 Exhibit Ex. KKK, #75 Exhibit Ex. LLL, #76 Declaration Declaration of Wayne Camara, #77 Exhibit Ex. MMM, #78 Declaration Declaration of Felice Levine, #79 Exhibit Ex. NNN, #80 Exhibit Ex. OOO (Public Version), #81 Exhibit Ex. PPP, #82 Exhibit Ex. QQQ, #83 Exhibit Ex. RRR, #84 Exhibit Ex. SSS, #85 Exhibit Ex. TTT-1, #86 Exhibit Ex. TTT-2, #87 Exhibit Ex. UUU, #88 Declaration Declaration of Kurt Geisinger, #89 Declaration Declaration of Dianne Schneider, #90 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order, #91 Certificate of Service Certificate of Service)(Hudis, Jonathan). Added MOTION for Permanent Injunction on 12/22/2015 (td).
EXHIBIT I
Case No. 1:14-cv-00857-TSC-DAR
Page 1 of4
Making Laws More Public Transcript - On The Media
Ffficr$r:Tîr..\ÌiË1
l]*,eR*ùN¡
Submit Q
.ar
ß ã t d:
N Sd.ß
*uË i
"
I'{Aiiiliü
I { df tSLt
-.,^^.,
:::vaÏ.
:..:.
:!
&å.
'
Låi,'úS 1"1ílR[
î-ÌLiI
a,,rgS$ll.,
tù¿
n^.,t,
{P':r
1 !'tÍ1a.1
¡J, ¿ur;
:&Æffiwffiffiffiqtrffiw;
FBHg*Sgãå&qgq#q#$* Ë *
üü Lü'\'Ë$ Y¡I üñ.Rl$$ffi
@'i.y,i@
S*S
'Þnrlntr
$h{nTI
'
LD: Yürr think rr.edia citnershix :l nl,:ai:*? ¡-ow ab,:.1:t iir* issi:e ci
lr¡nsì-'aiè:tryirCc,,,¿¡,ra''"r',si¡ieijiÈiaÌC^tds?ttyas*r:*i.',;¡1 ir:ì:-c!i:ri-ì{esrjliiiiüa
G.ÀRFif
*l.Eil0t'¡.,.
.':.'.[!l!tFI
,:,,',
îilllçlçlÀflE,,
ccnfctrridirg anti ;,rçt:i,i;Ì,,' (¡n-Ír--reiji;alr ¡;r.:i;ltin. ìiraÍ i:ì. Ji,e rìâÌsf-jÍ Èiaíìaar+s iiel Ìh*
i:Èv+fiirent uses ta r¡,'r¡ti: iSws ,¡iÉ L¡nav.ìi:3ble io tne pt¡hl¡û. unìÉss:ne ::rirhlic È,ays iloiìey t,j
r
ta
see ìherÌì.
'' Ptltûefi::.,
¡Hr,sûnci ut
,
tÍ0ÊBlrstT,,
';lìis iiifhs
hêl* rloir ol iiâr: ll'ìafenìt:+. a gÕvefriììêiìì li'snspsieni:¡' fid\.,í)rìat* airc ¡rresics:n( cÍ
pL:bìic.t*scurce-oig. *e beiiaves saÍet;" :ìicnil;^íiis shorli* hÊ easìiv eriessibìe lc' niì ciiize:rs
ír':í ir:li:. Sir i'.ìaiz:nrl¡tj'* oíl;riíliì¿i!ìi:¡!-: lras ¡:i:rr':ied ir::r tl':.::, dcuqì¡ gL) Oi-rfcì':3l\rr e r::r;iiy ?.i cl th,lÉi:,
slatìdat{$. çtiirh he','v:ll ¡:u$lish ûiì:iìÈ. cL:Fví:!ìlìl rt i'o r:a;;vrigiit. i.ìèrl. !{sic.nì.ì ba,cii Tc í.)íì
Sa ilìere aie legLiiaiiolrs oL,t ïher€ the I
1lìrv ärr tl:i, li¡ly oí !i:i !ùirij, ii!l::t?
¡le
i-.r-rili
oiì iiênd.^r{is des:çned
b'",
ii:a iirciL:rtry, a:rci
tÅRL Må,LÀil{UD: üh,
absoiui.: l\;. il,rese 3{lo a;rìc¡ìllj iù!ytì. 1-irey'ie lats ci gr irtiai
+p;:iical:iiit;;. 'f i¡i n:rai:s iiìet âváiybÕ{ty :íì ihe i,jrii?ÈÕ :)tâlÊs fìas i+ *b*,v fieo:, f h*¡' f:av*
,:ii¡r-rìnai pe¡êlties an,i th¡i¡ r* c¡iii,:¿ì t¡ the ¡-.:-ibiic safat;;
BûÈ G;1RFÌËLÐi
\,1reil ,tivi:' rì1ù a for insiaÍìce
.
ffi{Jtrtrffiffiî
CS.RLf.4ÀLAl'4tfü: \{lù:1,il:¡sla:rdslrjíoipoilaLrl¡fiist'xîirigr:ishcrÈ,:neùtàllrlâidToí
dt!iliiirg \,,'¡iie:. s\tst+ír, (vríììp.ì1er¡î-s snd Ìl¡eií hee:ifì åfiÈcls, î¡e stiìrijsid fÒi le$Íiriü läí l33c
¿nd','!riÊií. ThÈse are ;rlt thiiiEs vóL: n-1av iecestaril-V víenì ic' I€sd ei¡ery deV, bu,t the¡,
¿ü;tiainlv sio:¡icì L:r] ai'¡iiaLrle ti: a t:nail businesc Þers-.n ahd tiìùy sìrù!:ld ¡ù â{¿iilalìli! tù an
e ngin+eriftg sl'r:dÊnt. ovaii;¡irl+ lr) ê jÕtjinalisi.
ior rxar¡þie. thet* ¿re îirnd',ìrds ihñl sav tir:nEs tiie ¡,6'.¡ =¡.¡1 nÕi usr: leaíi pei:ìi *Íì rïalle,:í
schaols. ¿.riiii whal thË is\-.j sni:",ù is fou si¿il illri i:sê leac paint. lr-:rì t,û dÉf:r:ù lead pailt'. iii
th-. follo'.'v:r:S s;iarìcarri d-.ri eisp€d trr", in t:ì:s r.ss,e, lh+ ÀiiiÊíirxri Socieîv lcr'ì'á,íTiìg an.ì
MaÌelials. kt':cwn as i\-î;h'1. ¡\ni-ì tii*se stande:is aie pi,:t:y exoansi..;e: iirei"ie 5il to 'lûi:
dciìais íoi ä ùcuplÐ of Þaçes. Ar:i so, ií vou'ie ä coiìsc¡êtt:úL]È s{::rû-:ji È\ii:ìLìilai. ¡t's lJotìna
¿+sl'¡çr,¡ hr:riir--ds r:r llir¡:.r::¡:nis of c^{elìars si¡1ply ït rãerl iiìêse sÍ.êÍdijrc$ tö -.,Ée \¡;hal Lhe'r'
. Fffi.NT
I^.89ÌlSSNf$N:Y l**{S
L.¡ ! ìJ
Ë:l
[e$Å.{sJJ,l.$lLü$$
Elame, Shame, or Deny?
Ca
iifornia's #DroughÌShaming
The Denizlist ftfystique
Roiiing Stone's Fallol¡t at UVA
Climate Feedback
The Guardian Takes A
Bì)S CÅRFIËL$; lces tì-iilt Èrlìccl L\rirìciÞal îÂ\iÉ Ììo o::l,Jr ¡rêai,t
sl¿ìiìdari.:$
iiar
iÇ Þ3',J Ì5e +r.qar:ir.aÍiori
ilat lìas pirblist¡¿cl Lhern')
ü1
ÍJeft¡rìç:iose'
S{
Every Edit You've Ever
Facebc'ck Pcst ls Visible
g
^EXHlBlf n
* þ¡.a\a¡,r,nrç,-cJ
ióL
É
il,J
@
/x
t-l
É.5[,,
À J(r*l(
http://wrr-w'.onthemedia org/story/19921í-maktnglaws-more-public/transcript/
ì
1,,_.J
4t14tZjr5
AERA_APA_N
CM
E-O
O
32
07 5
Making Laws More Public Transcript - On The Media
Page 2 of 4
N'losti'r'. t[-rç:-s+ sf¡;irr.ìaiigai4 -sfi¡1¡;j¡r n{)iåveil¿::il(ì irr pu!>l:r: iii¡i¡rir's. Íi<:
the oirl'¡ \'e;l.r yoi.J .:¿n gei'em ¡ito s1-.nnd th* :nclìey o: pr-.3':ìì!-'i-v go io \fuiìslì¡lgic,r: ihere's
{iíìe L)lsciri','ij oìÎc¿l in thù iLAUûi-lsl CíÍlùr cf ll-ìè Fe deral ile¡Jis9¡i liìat iiüù cnc ùcfìy .:l tvr:1
sl¡¡e¿rc thiìt's b-.eri i¡cr¡ipnlafeC b¡.", reì*reirrx. A:rii íi '",ot¡ (;êt :nirì{ç,vcl.:r $/ei' fo lli¿:i r¡{í:c+,
Ì'ci.; fiìi$iri Þ+ abie i+ te,¡d ihâi siariiãrd.
Ç,qRt fulål-S,$di,ÌS-
ËûSG¡\RplÈLÐ: \r\,ù:1.ûrìtììa3:r:,jli:ci¡ltt:eFeceral lilgistsr',arorì'iir¿iìeSii:¿it¡i\ir!
pr:r..il:':ir.:d i¡ Íi:ll c'L il:ê liilq iì:r¡; ir -sccpiri.Í'ì
The Unreported Story, Part 1: Thê
Bui.ien <¡f Proof
Episr:des 7
g g: A Chånge in tho
The Cance¡ Shov;: Pait 2
FEEÐS
O¡'i The
'',ï;riia
2,:d;asl
ili+ :;c..irai
then th6!
:i¡ncard ii-.e:"' sillr:-.!-v cubiìeh tiie íact th¡i iire si¿ndei-C ¡¡s beeìr :lcolpcr:ted.
^rÌc
.:.Ì thê È!,âiìiards LìoCv tlìat seilr it. Sc íf yc.Lì ..viìrìi io iû.ùiJ iiìù lL:;l ie,(! af lilù
FrLii iiìe 3a:Lìíù!s
lâi..,, -r'¡r¡¡ håve tLr !Ð ivh*iê Íhese riÕri-pr+fj[a:r arâ ieSdqu¡;íieiêrj xi'gr) tn liiÊ W*.b arìÇ. atìd
ti¡,RL l"{ALÀ\,1lJÞ. i:.ìeguieiic:rs
pâr*
3r-= Êr.ìhl:srÈ)d in ír1:ì SlJi
lfiey
.1¡1x'¡ puiriic
frr i¡ìî-"Ê ì;linùs.
îlìÕre is a ¡:iiriciple in Ai:reliia:'r iai¡,,tl-:at tl-.e !3ì'i ccûsil'l
f¡. :ir¿ r.=¡r.l¿
pr"O*no. li
a¡a.ì ha.a!:<:¿;ri
i:r2{
if:a¡ä q h^.'11$rriñhf
l ¡v¡i¡abi* fîr ev€ryb,ccìy.
ll,.e:r aJl ,:f a
.'\nd :f
)./o,-r
:Jí:ii t{i the
li
-
Sù\'e'ñtr:ùr-11, ii ì:,:ion¡;s
il irn i ¡.::r:¡:¿
nâ,ie"io Íhaige 'lCC cic,il¡¡s
i¡
reac ìhe l¡rr,
¡rddei: it Lre¡on:e s a p.:ll iâx r:r aciurs io iirstiùe
EûS GÀR9-ìËLD: ìlìerî ii; arì ex$erse :jiiaîii€C
st3ìì*îrir.
Lre
...1 iirÊ ¡îr'
Lrr
develoi;ìrig êrd r,'aiiíli,*,S JhÊ5è
itis \...o:k. t:ìãn rr,rhet he;:;-.e ns?
if rïe i,rkÈ ihe ievenue elvev íio:Tl ilìos€ $..ho do
\r'.,råll. lhrre l ll..'o arsrì,ers to ì:ìat. l)iå is ihñi thÊ ncn.praíits ihai ieveìo¡:
s9¿iiii3ids h¿ivc â Io! of iìíÍeiûnt reiJ',!îue òiiEärÌìs. Tiiùy Co c:oDíÉtùl'ì(Ès, tþ,ú:r'cc
csii:lirxiior. 'ì-îç'l deÌ,+l(ìp ÊÌaÍìiìa'ii$ iiìei äreíì t lê,.v. iíì ì'ar)T, li:e v'*st i¡¡jioír:v .,Í Ìhe;r
aianc¡ris aie nal. Ând so. :naybe ine,v neeci :o;d;usi ilieir birsiiress inodeì. ¡raiticr"rlariy çirre:r
the laÇl tilai iney a[e å rìorì-ir[clit pr.t+iti: cirarit',;.
CÀñL f'.{,{LÁÍ,4Uü.
1lì,rs.J
ihal Sü\,,âìríìiìls:ri ir¡:s s-riiiind.,:r.;
ià:'
1Sî4 inât saic that theíi is nc ccÞi¡iiglt
'{ì$ lhere
i$ iì ri$k fh3t we da Tiris
ô.rr'1.êrec r'ô:,:1 ¿la.ìêi^..e
ìn
lire !arv. Sû !rô !iink
\.,ie
tir'ê \Âbô^i.n
r¡ f:*farc
ic
'l! ryìir.
ailil ss ¡j ies,Jil fiiÊ iiìiv r.}ogir lìíJncy iï)Ígv*r.
Htt,+
i.ve cc,ri'i
thiiik a¡a:'l: happe:r.
BûÐ üARFlËLù: C;:ri. nìa:rv tiìair:is
ûS.RL ¡$ALAi"'llJÐ
:
Tlirink
1j*¡n.
F*S GARFIfiLÞ: C¿:rì [',1a!at¡uC
[[4lJl-)lO l-rÌr
Àlil.l
:s fríes:ceñt.)f Pi.:bìiî ììes+t¡re:e.
ilìal'.r Frrhlì., Íe:rcìirce ûre .
r-Jl'JDF-Ri
C:rinti;iü Lip- iÌ\il1ådiai1 s.:ilc'*iE nre fÂiline cr iì.it îaÌlirg. Tìrll is ün thÈ N'ledie
GUESTS: Ca¡i Malanrud
HOSTPD 9Y: ûr:Lr Garfie
ic!
http://u'rwv.onthemedia.org/story/i 99276-mal