AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC. et al v. PUBLIC.RESOURCE.ORG, INC.

Filing 60

MOTION for Summary Judgment Filed by AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC., AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION, INC., NATIONAL COUNCIL ON MEASUREMENT IN EDUCATION, INC. (Attachments: #1 Statement of Facts Points of Authority, #2 Statement of Facts Statement of Undisputed Facts, #3 Declaration Declaration of Jonathan Hudis, #4 Exhibit Ex. A, #5 Exhibit Ex. B, #6 Exhibit Ex. C, #7 Exhibit Ex. D, #8 Exhibit Ex. E, #9 Exhibit Ex. F, #10 Exhibit Ex. G, #11 Exhibit Ex. H, #12 Exhibit Ex. I, #13 Exhibit Ex. J, #14 Exhibit Ex. K, #15 Exhibit Ex. L, #16 Exhibit Ex. M, #17 Exhibit Ex. N, #18 Exhibit Ex. O, #19 Exhibit Ex. P, #20 Exhibit Ex. Q, #21 Exhibit Ex. R, #22 Exhibit Ex. S, #23 Exhibit Ex. T, #24 Exhibit Ex. U, #25 Exhibit Ex. V-1, #26 Exhibit Ex. V-2, #27 Exhibit Ex. W, #28 Exhibit Ex. X, #29 Exhibit Ex. Y, #30 Exhibit Ex. Z, #31 Exhibit Ex. AA, #32 Exhibit Ex. BB, #33 Exhibit Ex. CC, #34 Exhibit Ex. DD, #35 Exhibit Ex. EE, #36 Exhibit Ex. FF-1, #37 Exhibit Ex. FF-2, #38 Exhibit Ex. FF-3, #39 Exhibit Ex. FF-4, #40 Exhibit Ex. FF-5, #41 Exhibit Ex. FF-6, #42 Exhibit Ex. GG, #43 Exhibit Ex. HH, #44 Exhibit Ex. II, #45 Exhibit Ex. JJ, #46 Exhibit Ex. KK, #47 Exhibit Ex. LL, #48 Exhibit Ex. MM, #49 Declaration Declaration of Marianne Ernesto, #50 Exhibit Ex. NN, #51 Exhibit Ex. OO, #52 Exhibit Ex. PP, #53 Exhibit Ex. QQ, #54 Exhibit Ex. RR, #55 Exhibit Ex. SS, #56 Exhibit Ex. TT, #57 Exhibit Ex. UU, #58 Exhibit Ex. VV, #59 Exhibit Ex. WW, #60 Exhibit Ex. XX, #61 Exhibit Ex. YY, #62 Exhibit Ex. ZZ, #63 Exhibit Ex. AAA, #64 Exhibit Ex. BBB, #65 Exhibit Ex. CCC, #66 Exhibit Ex. DDD, #67 Exhibit Ex. EEE, #68 Exhibit Ex. FFF, #69 Exhibit Ex. GGG, #70 Exhibit Ex. HHH, #71 Exhibit Ex. III, #72 Exhibit Ex. JJJ, #73 Declaration Declaration of Lauress Wise, #74 Exhibit Ex. KKK, #75 Exhibit Ex. LLL, #76 Declaration Declaration of Wayne Camara, #77 Exhibit Ex. MMM, #78 Declaration Declaration of Felice Levine, #79 Exhibit Ex. NNN, #80 Exhibit Ex. OOO (Public Version), #81 Exhibit Ex. PPP, #82 Exhibit Ex. QQQ, #83 Exhibit Ex. RRR, #84 Exhibit Ex. SSS, #85 Exhibit Ex. TTT-1, #86 Exhibit Ex. TTT-2, #87 Exhibit Ex. UUU, #88 Declaration Declaration of Kurt Geisinger, #89 Declaration Declaration of Dianne Schneider, #90 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order, #91 Certificate of Service Certificate of Service)(Hudis, Jonathan). Added MOTION for Permanent Injunction on 12/22/2015 (td).

EXHIBIT FF-1
Case No. 1:14-cv-00857-TSC-DAR

task_id=107010707

I of

history details do$'lrload metadata .I¡¡4g1ge
20 14-

task that qt¡er¡ed

this [File last modiûed:

3

2.4 years ago J fTime requesæd: UTC:

10-30 16:40:49, PDT 2014- 10-30 09 :40:49]

Task started àt¡ UTCr 2OL2-O5-26 18r¿8t12 ( PDTs 2012-05-26 11148112)
Task pld! 8478

ssh -À -n -c arcfour la600500.us.archlve.org '/petabox/s¡¡/work/¿rchive.php task_id-1o7010?07&

identiflêr:gov. Iaw. aera. standalds . 1999&server-i4600500. us . årchive. org&cmd*archive.php&args=commentt3Ds3putt26no1ot3D1t26dêl€te from eourcst3D2t26fro¡[_urlt3DrÊynct253Al252Ft252Fhd.çrrw3?.s3dnst252Fs33t252Fs3-5èc4fa1dr-r g g gzzZsõ'l4a-!ov. Iaw. aera. standãrds. 1999a252Ft26dir
t3Dt252F1t2s2Fitenst252Fgov.law. aera. standàrds.1999&sub¡trittl-De*20'2-05-26+18t3À48t3À12&

c4?5-4 81?-9bf

sub¡¡itter:carlt4Omêdl.a.org&priorlty:-5tsait_a.rñl n-0&f lnlshed:O .

GOTr Itask_Id:l070107O7&identlfier-gov.Iaw.aera.standards.1999&server-ia6OOSOO.us.archive.org&crd-archive.php&

args-corurentt3Ds3-

Putt26nolot3D1t26delete from sourc€$3D2t26from_urlt3Drsynct253À1252F$252Fhd.r¡r¡rr37
c 4 ? 5 -4 I 1? - 9bf 1 - 1 9 S S 2 ? 7 5õ1 4 a-!ov. law. aera. stand-ards . 1 9 9 9i 2 5 2 Ft 2 6dir

.

s3dnst252Fs33t252Fs3-sac4fà1d-

t3Dt252F1$252Fltênqt25zFgov.Iaw. aera. etandards.1999ûsubnittimê=2012-05-26+1813À48t3À12&
submltter:carlt 4 omêdla. orgtpriority--5&rrait_aùin-0 & f lnished=o I

ttask_1dl *> [107010707¡
I identlf ler I -:> [ gov, law. aera. gtandards.

199 9 ]

lserve¡l *> [la6005OO.us.archivê.org]
[cmd¡ ::> larchive.pl¡p]
Iargs¡ --¡' Icomênt-s3-put&nolo=ltdelete from_soutce-2&from_url-ra]mct3At2F

$2Fhd.v!tw37. s3dnsS2Fa33t2Fs3-5àc/tfa1d-c475-4817-9bf1-19882??5914a-gov. lar¡. aera. standards. 1999t2F&

dir-tzFlt2Fitems$zFgov.lan¡. aera. gtandàrds
lsubnlttime¡ :-> [2012-05-26 18r{8r121

. 1999

I

f subnitterl =:> lcarl€medla.org]
[priority] -:> [-51
[wait_a&ninl --> f0¡
[finished]:-> [01
args =:> Àrrãy
(

[coüment¡ -> s3-Put

[nolo¡ -¡

1

[delete_from_sourc€l :>

2

ffrom_urlI:> relmct//hd.¡nnr37.s3dns/s33/s3-5ac4fa1d-c4?5-4817-9bf1-198A27759L4agov.Iav. aera. standards . 1999/
f dlr I :> / 1 /itenrs/gov. Iaw. aera. standards . 1 9 9 9
)

Warning: fileperns()t stat failed for /l/itens/gov.law.aera.standards.1999 in lusx/Local/petabox/r.¡ww/common
/Util.inc on tLne 651
Gettlng flle(s) from urlr rsync://hd.wrvr3?.s3dns/s33/s3-Sac4få1d-c475-48l7-gbfl-19882775914agov. Iaw. aera. atandards. 1999/

I PDTI 2012-05-26 ltr48r15 ] Executingr /usr/bJ-n/rsync --tlneout=900 --safe-Iinks -rltDv -Lk --delete-after
'rsync r //hd.www37. s3dns/s33/s3-5ac4fa1d-c475-49L7-gbf1-19s82??5914ð-gov. Iàw.aera. standards. l999/ " /f/lte¡ns
/gov. J-aw. aerà. Étandards . 1999 '
receJ-ving file llst ... done
created directory / L / ltems / gov. las. aera. ståndards. 1999
gov. law. aera. sta¡dards. 1999 f lles. :ml
gov. Iaw. aera. standards . 1999-meta.:ûnI

sent 66 byt€s received 1825 bytes 1260.67 bytes/sec
total size ls 1627 apaedup l-s 0.86
s3 anowballingt from_urll-rsync¡//hd.r¡flw3?.s3dns/s32/s3-4a37e5oo-ab08-4faa-b925-c15c5b27367egov. Iaw. aera. staDdàrds. 1999/

Getting flle(s) from url¡ rsyncr//hd.www3?.s3dns/s32lã3-4837e5oo-ab08-{faa-b925-c15c5b2?367egov. law. aera. standards. 1999/

I PDT! 2012-05-26 ¡.1148t16 ] Executingl /usr/bin/rsync --tineout-900 --safe-Ilnks -rltDv -Lk

'rsyncr//hd.wtl'3?.s3dns/s32ls3-4837e5o0-abo8-alfaa-b925-c,scsbz?367e-gov.lâw.aera.standards,1999/',/L/iteurs
/gov. Iaw. aera. standards . 1999 I

recefvlng lncrenental fil-e list

aera. standards . 1999 .pdf
aera. standards . 1999 .pdf_neta.txt

sent, 66 byteB recelved 14934120 bytes 298683?2.0O btrtes/sec
total size l-s 14932104 speedup ls 1.00
. . Checklng I tl lte¡-/ gov. lar¡.aera. standards. 1999 fo¡

new

zotero zlps.

..

ln _files.¡qnl IF ürSSINc...
CHANGING gov.law.aera.standards.1999 files.:(m]. aourcê-"n to gource-"original"
ÀssIG¡¡fNG "gov.law.aera.standards.l9t9 fites.:(rll" to fornat "t{etadatan
CEÀNGING gov.l-aw.aera.standards.1999 meta.¡oI source:"" to sourcè:"original"
ÀSSIGNING " gov. lan. e€ra. standards. 19õg ¡¡eta. :ol " to f ormat "U€tadeta"
cl{Àl{cft¡ç aera. standa¡ds. 1999.pdf sourcã-" " to 6ourc€-"origi¡el"
eSSIGNfNc "aera.standards, I 999. Þdf " t.} forrnât- :Text PDFí
t .,: I¡J! ¡¡s{¡'ir.i lJ ìr¡rr F¿¡

ÀSSrcNINc Ifornåt.ls

'

https://catalogd.archive.org/log/1070 10707
IA-AERA.OO5

2of3

task id=107010707

history details dowuloacl ruetadata gpsaæ
20

task that oueued

this [File last modiûsd:

2.4 years ago

14-10-30 I 6:40:49, PDT: 201+ 10-30 09:40:491

requested: UTC:

of files.:<ml to disk...

nade changes, SAVING new vergion

...

] [Time

done

fl.nlsh( ). . .
parent collections¡ additfon¿I col"lections
loaded meta xltf, f¡om¡ /l/ite-o/gov.laf.aera.standårds.1999/gov.larr.aera.standards.lggg meta.:<¡rl

ÀddJ-ng

nodlfylng element¡ collection[2 I
with value¡'addLtional_collectLons,
found (2) "collection. elenents

collectiont0 I r publicsafêtycode
collectionf 1 I r UscovernmentDocunents

appendlng elenent "collectLon"

¡ addltl-onal_collections

checking and fornattlng nêrr meta.:<riI wlth :<mllLnt¡
I PDTI 2012-05-26 1l!48t50 ¡ ExêcutLng: /usr/bln/:<¡¡11lnt --forrnat '/var/tnp/autoclean

/gov.Iaw.aera.standards.1999_tup.tml'>'lvar/t-mp/autoclean/gov.law.aera.stàndàrds.1999

fmt.:rril'

[fornat]s ln files.xml IF !{ISSrNG...
u¡rdatedl true
size! 1?14
rntlltre¡ t33BO5g13O - verlfied: true
updating checksum( s ) for aera. standards. 1999.pdf . ., conputlng
u¡rdated: true
sizsr 149304?0 mtime¡ 1338osgo92 vêrLfiedr tru€
Updatlng checksum( s ) for aera. gtandards. 1999.pdf_nêta. txt. . . computing
updated: true
s.lzê! 1634
tntime: 1338058093 verified¡ true

ÀSSIGNI¡¡G

updeting checksum(sf for gov.law.aera.standards.lggg meta.:snl... conputlng

.,.

done

RE¡iOVING

...

dons

flLe info fro¡n files.xml

nade cbangesr sÀvlNc new ve¡slon

...

done

FOR

rII¡ES

THÀT NO I,oNGER

EXIST...

of fIles.:o1 to disk...

Updatlng netadata tãble

Sètting f .lIe permlssions for
This is a public J.tên.
sync-1ng iten...

I

gov. Iaw, aera. atandards. 1999.

PDT¡ 2012-05-26 11¡48r51

/gov. law. aere. ståndarda.1999

] Executingr /petabox/swlbin/dsync.py /r/iterns

,..su¡k in 0 eeconds.

Éychronizing item to the backup server...
I PDTI 2012-05-26 11t48r51 ] Executingr Ësh -À -n -c arcfour ia?o05o0,u6.archlve.org 'nkdlr -p /varltn¡r
/bup-ttnk/zO12-05-26/l/ltens ÊÊ /usr/bJ.n/rsync -av --delete -b --backup-dir-/varlt¡np/bup-tlni/20L2-os-26
/1/ttens rsyncr//ia6o05OO.us.archlve.orglltens_l/gov.law.aera.standards.l999 /l/itens t& /petabox/sw/bln
/dsync.py' / L / lt ^ñç / gov. Iaw. aera. standards. 1999,',
receivlng incremental file list

NoÌû

gov. Iaw. aera. standards. 1999/

gov.lan. aera. etandards. 1999/aera. at,andards. 1999.pdf
gov. law. aera. standards. 1999/aera. standards. 1999.pdf_¡¡eta.txt

gov. Iaw. aera. standards. I 99 9 /gov. law. aera. gtandards. 1999 f iles. )(rrl
gov. law. aera. standards. 1999/gov. Ialr. aera. standards . 199g-meta.xEll

sent 109 blrtes receivod 14937109 byt,ês 29874436.OO bytes/sec
total size ls 14934912 speedup ls 1.00
Deletlng from hd.wrrw3?. s3dns.us. archive. org
I PDT¡ 2012-05-26 11t48t53 ¡ ßxecuting: ssh -À -n -c arcfour hd.nnr¡37.s3dns.us.archive.org,lbln/rm -rfv
/.1/itconlng/RBl'toTE_sltBMIT/s3-5ac4fa1d-c475-481?-gbf'-'.9aa27759l¡ta-gov.lan.aera.standards.rógs/
/RElroTE sttBufT/s3-¿83?e5oo-abo8-¡¡faa-b925-c15c5b27367e-gov.la¡¡.aera.atàndards.1999/

,

lz/íncoøjtng

renoved--/g/inconing/ruxotn SUBUIT/83-5ac4fåld-c475-d81t-9bf1-19882775gL4¿-gov.law.aera.standards.1999
/gov. Iaw. aera. standards. 199t f 1Iês.xml,

removed'/S/inconi.ng,/REHofE SUBI.[T/s3-5äc4fald-c4?5-4817-9bf1-19882?7591/¡a-gov.làw.aera,stãndards.1999
/gov. law. aera. standa¡ds. 199t netå. )snl'
reúovsd directorys'/3/lnconi1g/REüoTE_SUBMIT/s3-5åc4fa1d-ca¡?5-¡181?-gbf.L-Lga8'z?75914agov. law. aera. standards. 1999 ,
rettroved'/Z/incoulng/REuotE SUBUIT/s3-483?e50o-abo8-4faa-bg25-c15c5b27367e-gov,law.¿era.standards.1999
/aera. standards. 199t. pdf '
removed -/2/inconing/RBt{OTE SUBI|ITIs3-4837e500-abo8-4faa-bg25-c15c5b2736?e-gov.lan¡.aera.standards.1999
/aera. standards. 199ó.pdf ¡neEa. txt,
removed directory: - /zltÃcontng/REMOTE_SUBr,lrTls3-483?e500-ab08-4fäa-b925-c15c5b27367egov, larr, aere. Etandalds. 1999 ,
ì 1 .1:

htçs ://catalogd.archive.org/log/1070

I

lut ¡¡r¡i¡k:,1 lJ r¡¡r r ¡¡,

0707
IA-AERA.OO6

task id=107010707

3 of 3

history details dow¡rload metadata !¡Âg4e taskthatqtreuedthis [Filelastmodiûed: !.4yearsago]ffimerequested:UTC:
201,1-10-30 16:40:49, PDT: 201¿l-10-30 09:40:491

Itera queued for derive taskl

ltotal task tiEet 4o.o

aeconds]

TAsX ¡'INISIIED IIITH SUCCESS

¡

I

at

UTC! 2OL2-O5-26 18¡¡18:53,

.'.f 1$l

u¡,ri¡l¡r{ l"l r,'*r '

(

PDTr 2012-05-26 11r¡18r53)

¡*.,

htçs:/lcatalogd.archive.org/log/1070 10707
IA-AERA-O07