Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al
Filing
1201
Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)
EXHIBIT 1
a.
A-6329-1
From
Kevin
Sent
Tuesday
Miller
November
PM
1037
02 2004
To
Jeff
Cc
Tapomoy Dey Aseem Chandra Mark
Johnson
Rarnesh
Grutzmacher
Shankar
MirandaSteven
Wood
Mark
CavacchioliGabriel
mendezlina@rgmgw2.us.oracle.00m
FothergillAlan
Amit John
Singh
Boucher
Joseph
Re
Re
Subject
All
Im
forwarding
with
the
cun-ent
email
Jeff
clarlcel
ca/jeff
wider
to
distribution
as
believe
its
CAs concerns
summary of
good
functionality
Kevin
Jeff
wrote
Johnson
All
The
issue
is
is
functionality
Standard
usable
Then
end-date
then
calculate
and
generate
CA
has up
frequently
termination
of each
volumes
peak
and
for
the
the
contract
with
entries
our standard
believe
not
items
for the
The
correctly
which
which
for
The
new end-date
the
amounts
unearned
to
it
items on
line
and
trying
and
having
500
to
line
beat
the
is
down
cascade
it
the
the
all
So
at
Especially
quarter end
allowing
to
contracts
their
of
re-creation
solution
an acceptable
believe
level
does
do
applications
must
there
will
cash
unapply
manually be
later
new
is
applications
re-applied
invoice
subsequent
to
invoice
credit
of
lines
Revenue
Revenue/Deferred
the
CA
contract
existing
lines
new
items onto
the
copy/add
the
terminate
to
is
of an
them
for
functionality
end-date
the
extension of
the
the
issue
usability
end
the
of
the
is
when
quarter
actual
are
they
at
clock
user
line
to
of
end-date
alter the
There
items
the
two options
are
header
at
contract
can
that
of
think
for
this
We
line
create
form
items and
the
revenue
distributions
We
dates
add
for
the
for
remaining
the
generated
have
revenue
due
the
portion
to
automatically
to
the
NOT
distributions
invoice
to
it
create
can
credit
unapply
cash
automatically
revenue
we
the
the
an
the
date
revise
items on
line
to
the
think
invoice
this assumes
distributions
and
evaluate
the
reverse
and
to
terminate
the
should
functionality
new revenue
get
and
reallly
credit
the
require
the
an
of
the
unapplied
applied
invoice
opposite amount
we need
which
then
the
changes
end-
amount of deferred revenue
remaining
with one
away
invoice
the
revenue
and
distributions
and duration
contract
create
the
off
standard
booked
forms
existing
to
contract
for
Then
lines
original
would need
for
kicks
program
amount
and
items
functionality
apply
end-date
the
line
termination
the
distributions
new
new
program
of
as
applications
revenue/deferred
Confidential
line
the
dates
when
created
for the
extension
credit/invoicing
program
credit
new
items
new revenue
establish
change
the
be created
line
each
to
with
distributions
contract
the
all
them
them
to
should
reverse
For
allow
replicate
invoice
customer
of
following
cash
associated
the
credit
document
to
to
set
up
an invoice
above
scenario
to
with
reversing
invoice
and
to
create
is
the
the
apply
the
schedule
billing
that
or
for
0RCL006471
Information
UNITED
STATES
NORTHERN
Case
No
DEFENDANT
Date
Admitted
COURT
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
OF CALIFORNIA
PJHIEDL
407-cv-01658
Exhibit
No
A-6329-1
___________________
By ________________________
Nicole
Heuerman
44
Deputy
Clerk
invoicing
customer
the
expect that theie
for the additional
host
ate
each
with
of challenges
time for the extended
of
periods
and
alternative
contract
am
wide
to other
open
alternatives
Jeff
Kevin
wrote
Miller
believe
Tapo
rev
there
problem
is
still
with
the calculation
of
the duration
under
daily
scenarios
rec
Rarnesh
Aseem
touch
please
base with
Tapo today
so
we have
clarity for the
call
tomorrow
Tapomoy
Dey wrote
Just
there
Apparently
cancel
Mark Gnitzmacher
to
spoke
replace
objection
have
no issues raised
been
of contract
the
during
the
demo
but
customer
later
on daily rev rec Regarding
did
not raise
concluded
that
any
SAP
specific
does
it
better
Thanks
Tapo
Aseern
Chandra
Mark
Is
Jeff
there
any additional
the daily
CA
wrote
gap
rev rec issue
couple of weeks
on
the accounting
that
we
discussed
front other
during
the
demo
than
to
ago
Aseem
Original
Message
Re
Subject
ca/jeff
clarke
DateTue 02 Nov 2004 112733 -0800
FromKevin Miller Kevin.Miiler@ oracle.com
Organization
Oracle Corporation
ILccJP
ToChandraAseem
ShankarRamesh
RAMESF-
Confidential
the
full
email
trail
0RCL006471 45
nformation
fl.
....
heres
oraciecorn
thanks
em
As
Director
Service
Contracts
Product
Management
Oracle
Corporaton
500 Oracle
Redwood
Parkway
6503028043
t4obile
Work
6505065385
Re
Subject
Prom Don
Date
To
CA94065
Shores
caijeff
clarke
don.klaiss@oracle.com
Klaiss
081916 -0800
cKFVT\ MILL FR@oiacie corn
ROLD.CAMPBELL@oracJe.com
Tue
02
Nov 2004
Kevin
Miller
Kevin/Drew
note
HA
for subscription
be the case
assume
for subscription
on par with
comments about SAPs
the
SAP
in
relates
this
Do
services
this
us Do we
than
accounting
we
ability
believe
11.11
to
Harold
support
believe
our
to
better
Cimpbell
this
sell
and
will bring
to
bill
us
area
Don
Original
Message
SubjectRe
ca/jeff
DateTue
02
clarke
Nov 2004
FromJeff Henley
OrganizationOracle
081024
-0800
jeff.henlny@oracle.com
Corporation
ToKeith
Keith.Block@oracle.com
Block
CCCharles
Phillips
char1es.phillips@oracccom
RON.WOHL@oracle.com
WohlRonald
John
JohitWookev@oracle.com
Wookey
Steven
Miranda
steven.miranda@oracle.com
KlaissDonald
DON.KLAISs@oracle.com
EllisonLawrence
LARRY.ELLISON@oracle.com
References4
86COCA EDI4CF28@orac1e.com
to Jeff
spoke
last night
this
morning
will make
They
the latest
Its
decision
and
he
gave
me
the
same
feedback
as
he
ga
you
at
Confidential
Information
either
late
this
week
or
early
next
week
horserace
0RCL00647 146
in
across
the board in
functionality
pretty much
leading
is subscription
The
need
accounting
giv
biggest
they have
is
Sarbanes
Second
CRM through
their SEC and
problems
biggest need
and
In
both
is better
more integrate
order taking
areas
they
say SAP
who
works
the software
to 45
SAP references
plus theyve
spoken
say
well
in
these
areas
SAP
is
mind
their
and
Pricing
cost
for
sense
Net
turn
Keith
sides
bundle
well
lose
now
right
jeff wants
key points
to
Lots
large
to
of
on
This
There
Im
somewhat
of
what
did
he
Netweaver
with
unless
so
functionality
not
optimistic
we
are leaiing towards
perceive
sap given
think
th
offer
from sap
go to market
and
their users
like sap
Th
but Barrenchea
stronger
software
global
our
should
really
is
time
faster
and
cost
We
Oracle
were
for
one
of
financials
the
first
to
the
with
resonate
lower
at
run
companies
ourselve3
including
statements
to
much
in
the
somehow
successtully
SEC
of
stuff
function
area
this
they
with us
go
make
are
off
their
because
is
company
discounts
of
week
believe
and
yo
he
wrote
functionality
quite
sign
for either
so
some
around this
this
Block
Jeff
to
think
net
can
both
offered
say SAP
Oracle
gotomarket
assume
They
wash
ownership
favors
Relationship
makes
of
element
that
and
cost
him
at
they
lot
also
have
less
stuff
disruption
our
to
is
ca
the
huge
business
Once
we
get
the
past
initial
April
there
deadline
unleash our example
golive
shareholder vaiue
that
we can
them
help
transformation
and
increased
operating
of
margin
The
GTt4
We
stand
sales
heat
His
Tapomoy
places
behind
Information
as
for
CA
consulting
about
number
as
good
the
then and
ours has
mo
people behind
with database
and
specifically
apps
synergy
with
more
support
than
our
the
product
development
EC
He
has
whole
to
organizat
be
feeling
risk
is
631
342
2980
Let
ne
know
how
it
goes..
.Keith
Dey
Financial
Director
oracle coin
us oracle
www-apps
Confidential
are
plans
reach
more
peoplesoft
Applications
corn/f
Development
inancials
0RCL006471 47