Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1201

Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)

EXHIBIT 1

a.
A-6329-1

From

Kevin

Sent

Tuesday

Miller

November

PM

1037

02 2004

To

Jeff

Cc

Tapomoy Dey Aseem Chandra Mark

Johnson
Rarnesh

Grutzmacher

Shankar

MirandaSteven

Wood

Mark

CavacchioliGabriel

[e-mail].00m

FothergillAlan

Amit John

Singh

Boucher

Joseph

Re

Re

Subject

All

Im

forwarding

with

the

cun-ent

email

Jeff

clarlcel

ca/jeff

wider

to

distribution

as

believe

its

CAs concerns

summary of

good

functionality

Kevin

Jeff

wrote

Johnson

All

The

issue

is

is

functionality

Standard

usable

Then

end-date
then

calculate

and

generate

CA

has up

frequently

termination

of each

volumes

peak

and

for

the

the

contract

with

entries

our standard

believe

not

items

for the

The

correctly
which

which

for

The

new end-date

the

amounts

unearned

to

it

items on

line

and

trying

and

having

500

to

line

beat

the

is

down

cascade

it

the

the

all

So
at

Especially

quarter end

allowing
to

contracts

their

of

re-creation

solution

an acceptable

believe
level

does

do

applications

must

there

will

cash

unapply

manually be

later

new

is

applications

re-applied

invoice

subsequent

to

invoice

credit

of
lines

Revenue

Revenue/Deferred

the

CA

contract

existing

lines

new

items onto

the

copy/add

the

terminate

to

is

of an

them

for

functionality

end-date

the

extension of

the

the

issue

usability

end

the

of

the

is

when

quarter

actual
are

they

at

clock

user

line

to

of

end-date

alter the

There

items

the

two options

are

header

at

contract

can

that

of

think

for

this

We
line

create

form

items and
the

revenue

distributions

We
dates

add
for

the

for

remaining

the

generated
have
revenue

due

the

portion

to

automatically

to

the

NOT

distributions

invoice

to

it

create

can

credit

unapply

cash

automatically

revenue

we
the

the

an

the

date

revise

items on

line

to

the

think

invoice

this assumes

distributions

and

evaluate
the

reverse

and

to

terminate

the

should

functionality

new revenue

get

and

reallly
credit

the

require

the

an

of

the

unapplied

applied
invoice

opposite amount

we need

which

then

the

changes

end-

amount of deferred revenue

remaining

with one

away

invoice

the

revenue

and

distributions

and duration

contract

create
the

off

standard

booked

forms

existing

to

contract

for

Then

lines

original

would need

for

kicks

program

amount

and

items

functionality

apply

end-date

the

line

termination

the

distributions

new

new

program
of

as

applications

revenue/deferred

Confidential

line

the
dates

when

created
for the

extension

credit/invoicing

program

credit

new

items

new revenue

establish

change

the

be created

line

each

to

with

distributions

contract

the

all

them

them

to

should

reverse

For

allow

replicate

invoice

customer

of

following
cash

associated
the

credit

document
to

to

set

up

an invoice

above

scenario

to

with

reversing

invoice

and

to

create

is

the
the

apply

the

schedule

billing

that

or

for

0RCL006471

Information

UNITED

STATES

NORTHERN
Case

No

DEFENDANT
Date

Admitted

COURT

DISTRICT

DISTRICT

OF CALIFORNIA
PJHIEDL

407-cv-01658

Exhibit

No

A-6329-1

___________________

By ________________________
Nicole

Heuerman

44

Deputy

Clerk

invoicing

customer

the

expect that theie

for the additional

host

ate

each

with

of challenges

time for the extended

of

periods

and

alternative

contract

am

wide

to other

open

alternatives

Jeff

Kevin

wrote

Miller

believe

Tapo
rev

there

problem

is

still

with

the calculation

of

the duration

under

daily

scenarios

rec

Rarnesh

Aseem

touch

please

base with

Tapo today

so

we have

clarity for the

call

tomorrow

Tapomoy

Dey wrote

Just

there

Apparently
cancel

Mark Gnitzmacher

to

spoke

replace

objection

have

no issues raised

been

of contract
the

during

the

demo

but

customer

later

on daily rev rec Regarding

did

not raise

concluded

that

any

SAP

specific

does

it

better

Thanks
Tapo

Aseern

Chandra

Mark
Is

Jeff

there

any additional

the daily

CA

wrote

gap

rev rec issue

couple of weeks

on

the accounting

that

we

discussed

front other

during

the

demo

than
to

ago

Aseem

Original

Message

Re

Subject

ca/jeff

clarke

DateTue 02 Nov 2004 112733 -0800
FromKevin Miller Kevin.Miiler@ oracle.com
Organization

Oracle Corporation

ILccJP

ToChandraAseem

ShankarRamesh

RAMESF-

Confidential

the

full

email

trail

0RCL006471 45

nformation

fl.
....

heres

oraciecorn

thanks
em

As

Director
Service

Contracts

Product

Management

Oracle

Corporaton
500 Oracle
Redwood
Parkway
6503028043
t4obile

Work

6505065385

Re

Subject

Prom Don
Date

To

CA94065

Shores

caijeff

clarke

[e-mail]

Klaiss

081916 -0800
cKFVT\ MILL FR@oiacie corn
[e-mail]
Tue

02

Nov 2004

Kevin

Miller

Kevin/Drew

note

HA

for subscription

be the case

assume

for subscription

on par with

comments about SAPs

the

SAP

in

relates

this

Do

services
this

us Do we

than

accounting

we

ability

believe

11.11

to

Harold

support

believe

our

to

better

Cimpbell

this

sell

and

will bring

to
bill

us

area

Don

Original

Message

SubjectRe

ca/jeff

DateTue

02

clarke

Nov 2004

FromJeff Henley
OrganizationOracle

081024

-0800

[e-mail]

Corporation

ToKeith

[e-mail]

Block

CCCharles

Phillips

char1es.phillips@oracccom

[e-mail]

WohlRonald
John

[e-mail]

Wookey

Steven

Miranda

[e-mail]
KlaissDonald

[e-mail]
EllisonLawrence

[e-mail]
References4
86COCA [e-mail]

to Jeff
spoke
last night

this

morning

will make
They
the latest
Its

decision

and

he

gave

me

the

same

feedback

as

he

ga

you

at

Confidential

Information

either

late

this

week

or

early

next

week

horserace

0RCL00647 146

in
across
the board in
functionality
pretty much
leading
is subscription
The
need
accounting
giv
biggest
they have
is
Sarbanes
Second
CRM through
their SEC and
problems
biggest need
and
In
both
is better
more integrate
order taking
areas
they
say SAP
who
works
the software
to 45
SAP references
plus theyve
spoken
say
well
in
these
areas

SAP

is

mind

their

and

Pricing

cost

for

sense

Net

turn

Keith

sides

bundle

well

lose

now

right

jeff wants
key points

to

Lots

large

to

of

on

This

There

Im

somewhat

of

what

did

he

Netweaver

with

unless

so
functionality
not
optimistic

we

are leaiing towards
perceive
sap given
think
th
offer
from sap
go to market
and
their users
like sap
Th
but Barrenchea

stronger

software

global

our
should

really

is

time
faster

and

cost

We

Oracle

were

for

one

of

financials
the

first

to

the
with

resonate

lower

at

run

companies

ourselve3

including
statements
to

much

in

the

somehow

successtully

SEC

of

stuff

function

area

this

they

with us
go
make
are

off

their

because

is

company

discounts

of

week

believe

and

yo

he

wrote

functionality

quite
sign

for either

so

some

around this

this

Block

Jeff

to

think

net

can

both

offered

say SAP

Oracle

gotomarket

assume

They

wash

ownership

favors

Relationship

makes

of

element

that

and

cost

him

at

they
lot

also

have

less

stuff

disruption

our

to

is

ca

the

huge

business
Once

we

get

the

past

initial

April

there
deadline
unleash our example

golive

shareholder vaiue
that
we can
them
help
transformation
and
increased
operating

of

margin
The

GTt4

We

stand

sales

heat
His

Tapomoy

places

behind

Information

as

for

CA

consulting

about

number

as

good

the

then and
ours has
mo
people behind
with database
and
specifically
apps

synergy

with

more

support

than

our

the

product

development

EC

He

has

whole
to

organizat
be

feeling

risk
is

631

342

2980

Let

ne

know

how

it

goes..

.Keith

Dey

Financial
Director
oracle coin
us oracle
www-apps

Confidential

are

plans

reach
more
peoplesoft

Applications
corn/f

Development

inancials

0RCL006471 47