Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al
Filing
1201
Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)
EXHIBIT 25
Feb 13 2008 Hrg Tr
and contains
2010
30
business
on
information
what happened
Sept
15224-15411
at
what
were
Hrg Tr
1015-1214 Oracle
at
Shippy Sept
Depo Tr
2009
25
Shippy Sept
25
individuals
as
in
report
at
at-risk
at
Notes
Depo Tr
2008
Shippy created
for
Depo Tr
2008
origin of data
explaining
at
is
customers
not
report
were
that
gill
is
in
actually
play
not
report
theyre
saying
information
report comes
Cummins Sept 23 2008 Depo Tr
in at-risk
information
30b6
825-15
Rule
814-823
field
of
8812-23
at
at-risk
at
indicating
for
Curnrnins
third
Sept
person should
that
at-risk
at
sales
testimony
indicating
by knowledgeable
30b6
testimony
that
indicating
representatives
Rule
from support
32023-3212
testimony
activity
Rule
30315-3043
report included
30b6
Rule
business
from support
30b6
transmitted
30b6
sales
Cummins Sept 23 2008 Depo Tr at 3057-18 Rule
about customer information
sales representatives knew
testimony
that
indicating
report
894-11
30921-23
report comes
Cummins Sept 23 2008 Depo Tr
testimony
report
part of her regularly conducted
in at-risk
Rule
403-4110
from information
entries
Cummins Sept 23 2008 Depo Tr
support
the at-risk
that
arguing
records
Shippy had responsibility
that
Oracle
the various
them
to
Shippy March
that
Foundation
At-Risk Report
General
testimony
indicating
representatives
30b6
because
3215-9
customers
indicating
testimony
was
it
their
account
32111-17 Rule
at risk
that
30b6
Oracle
of leaving
party provider
16 2008 Depo Tr
contact
the support
at
742-7514
sales
Rule
representative
30b6
testimony
indicating
on
find out information
to
that
given
customer
Cuinmins
that
Sept
providing
23
2008
information
Depo Tr
for
at
26919-2708
the at-risk
Rule
30b6
report was part of
sales
testimony
indicating
representatives
normal
job responsibilities
Shippy Sept
was
SVI-108747v1
kept
in
25
2008
course
Depo Tr
at
1064-14
of regularly conducted
Rule
business
30b6
activity
testimony
indicating
report
PROCEEDINGS
February
l3
2008
Pge1
UNITED
NORTEERN
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
STATES
OS
SAN
CALCFORNIUt
CHABLES
BEFORE
COURT
LECCE
FRANCISCO
JUDGE
DIVISION
Ret.
---cOo--ORACLE
Delatcare
CORPORAA.EOS
Os...t
corporation
corporaron
Colorado
ORACLE
JRA
ood
IONAIL
INTERNET
No
CalifornIa
CORPOF.AT1O1
U7CV01658FtIJ
corcoraticn
Plaintifs
SAP
AG
SAP
ANERICE
corpora
Texas
150
German 2o.rmoretion
INC
Je.i
aware
on TONORROWNON
and
corcrarIcn
DOES
INC
inclosive
Defendants
HEARING
IN
ednesday
Embarcadero
San
Rerorced
GEORGE
RE
DISCOVERI
ISSUES
February
13
Center
4th
Franci.sco
2036
Floor
CalifornIa
Cy
SCHUNER
I3G6
3326
v1errili
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
2ef4f272-5876-421
O-af$f-34b80a4f1
3b5
February 13
PROCEEDINGS
TEXT
REMOVED
TO MOTION
NOT RELEVANT
24
25
2008
think
Moreover
understand
is
one of
that
very
that
important
key documents
the
you
were
that
going
Pan
it
we
be producing
to
an
internally
because
you
call
otherwise you
JUIGE LEGGE
MS HOUSE
vibrant
This
This
document
is
of
compilation
that
of
all
that
talks
one
about
detailed
document
that
is
not
is
LEGGE
We
JUDGE
MS HOUSE
that
about
and
lost
try
not
and
about
to
keep
others
single
every
what
or what
lost
to
--
was
were
the
the
customer
it
called
risk
to
And
analysis
the
69
customers
this
customers
lost to
all
third
gift
21
something
Street
specific
all
theirs
parties
the
kept
about
detail
This
parties
third
were
they
actually
seen
Rimini
is
22
is
goes
very long
UnllkL
sn
an
way
lia
You
are
in
to
are
producing
producing
Oracle
internal
.I9
800
to
historical
to
was
that
why
or effectively
has enormous
Legal
of
LEGGE What
MS HOUSE Third-party
17
Merrill
is
notes
JUDGE
_______________________________________________________________________
it
right
mel have
to
terms of finances
in
--
sort
losses
of those customers
customer
20
it
indeed
has
--
is
as
but
perception about
concessions
is
it
keep
hard
is
the
TomorrowNow
the
to
give
you
calls
to
it
copy
you have
if
document
electronic
just
13
have
give
it
keep
12
wont
will
Yes
Oracle
or
internally
it
report
at-risk
Lji
compiling
sork
ith
it
it
This
document
and
th
in
one
tour
is
that
unit
stuft
is
--
--
shat
Dc
Solutions
8699132
2ef4f272-5878-421
O-at9f-34b80a4t13b5
PROCEEDINGS
were
the
to
So again
highly
notion
this
actually
financial
with those
we need
that
incredibly
so
you
in
were
kind of
that
what
associated
show you
to
detailed
dont
have
13
2008
play
losses
on
customers
go any
document
to
keep
--
is
it
premature
Again
you
the
than
afield
wont
that
them
were
period
one-year
farther
customers
various
what happened
February
have
if
theres
heard them
10
hear about
11
today beyond
it
But
what
problem
say theyll
there
we
is
with
come
absolutely
have
the
documents
and
back
nothing
already agreed
TEXT
to
to
you
--
will
order
produce
REMOVED
NOT RELEVANT
TO MOTION
___________ ___________
tu
Merrill Legal
800
Pages
154
cc
157
Solutions
8699132
2ef4f272-5S76-421O-af9f-4b8Oa4f1
3b6
UNITED
STATES
NORTHERN
ONOABLE
BEEOS
THS
ORACL
CORPORATION
DISTRICT
PHYLLIS
ST
DISTRICT
OE
COURT
CALl
FORNA
JUDGE
HAMILTON
AL
1C
PAINTIFES
JH
07-0658
CejI
AG
AL
PAGSS
DEFENDANTS
SAP
OAKLAND
i24
TRANSCRIPT
Ct IA
CALl
SE
DNESDAY
___________
Co.y
30
DER
20
OF PROCEEDINGS
APPEARANCES
5CR
EoEs SCEILLER
ELEXNER
99 HAPRISCJi STPEET SUITE
PLAINTIESS
OAAn
BY
CALISORNIA
BGHAX
9D7
Z46I2
HOLTEXAN
STEJEN
LLP
ATTORNEY
XCCrJTCHN
AT
LEP
EXBARCADER0ClHEP
THREE
94i-40
SAN
BY
SRANCISOO CALiRORN1A
ZACHARY
ALINDER
ANTHDNY
FALZOUE
HOLLY
HOUSE
PICKETT
DONN
SOP
D5ELONT3
JONES
ATTORNEYS
ROAD
CALISORNIA
ALTO
HARANGRErCRY
LANIEF
RAYNEE
BY
PAYNEE
LA1
OEFCS
SOLO
EPSRTED
AT
DAY
SILICON 7ALEY
755
Y3ARCADERO
APPSAP.ANOES
LA1
CONT
HUED
NEXT
1ERC.AC
CSR
91303
ATTORNEY
PAGE
NO
MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510
25
451-7530
AT
LA
10
TOMORROWNOW
THE
COMPUTERS
SERVERS
REGARD
WITH
AND
TO --
THIS
IS
AN
STILL
THE
ISSUE GIVEN
STIPULATION
LANIER
MR
JUST
ARTICULATED
IS
CLAIM
PICKETT
SINCE THERE
COURT
THE
FOR
ON
QUESTIONS
ART
THINK
THAT
GIVEN
12
HAVE
13
GOING JO
THEN
OKAY
JUST
MOOT ARE
THE
EXPLANATION
RULE
THE
SANE
PITT
COURT
THE
THE
CUSTOMER
17
THE
ARGUMENTS
18
STATEMENTS
19
THAT
20
BUT
21
NON-HEARSAY
22
CERTAINLY
IS
IT
ARE
THAT
DOES
HEARSAY
THE
PURPOSES
BE
BUT
MOST
UNDERSTAND
AS
IT
ISNT
IT
RAYNEE
TO ME
FOR
MAKE
HAVE
SURE
TO
I%iE
SINCE
ONE
TO
FEW
THAT
MOOT
FACT
REGARD
ONE
O9P.CLES
DOES
CUSTOMERS
AEPEAR
SAME
THE
JUST
REGARD
THEYRE
IF
SAP
AGAINST
I21
ONES
YOU
ALL
SIMPLY
SECOND
THE
--
CERTAINLY
COULD
22
24
IT
IN
THIRD
IN
STATEMENTS
TO
211TH
THE
THE
TO THE
JUST
WANT
WITH
KAY
GOES
IT
RULINGS
KNOW
ARE
--
THAT
REASON
LIABILITY
MY
YOU
ME
13
IS
MIGHT
AND
THESE
SAME
CONTRIBUTORY
OKAY
COURT
THE
PROBABLY
IT
4R PICTT
THE
FOR
THINK
WHICH
APPEAR
LEAVING
SAP
IS
THESE
THE
TO
MOTION
EXCLUDE
REVIEWED
REPORTS
AT-RISK
OFFERED
HERE
THAT
IS
TO
TO
FOR
CORRECT
ME
THAT
PROVE
THOSE
THE
TRUTH
PARTICULAR
REASONS
THAT
ARE
THERE
STATEMENTS
CUSTOMER
PERTINENT
IMPORTANTLY
RELIES
VERY
THE
HEAVILY
MEYERS
UPON
REPORT
THESE
STATEMENTS
CORRECT
MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510
AS
451-7530
Li
AND
REPORT
HIGH
RELIED
EXPERT
DEGREE
UPON
THERE
THAT
ERE
THEY
YOUR
THEMSELVES
ARE
WE
OT
RE
THE
GIVEN
DISCUSSION
IN SORRY
HONOR
SO
PLAINTIFF
BY
PREPARED
OFFTHE-RECORD
HO1ThBD
ORACLE
MEAN
RELIABILITY
OF
AT-RISK
THE
BY
PREPARED
STATEMENTS
THESE
WASNT
IT
UNDERSTAND
AS
---
CONTAINS
THAT
ISNT
AS
HO%ARD
JEFF
TH
THAT
CONTENDING
REPORTS
NOT
COURT
--
PIcTT
10
11
THEYRE
NOT
PART
THE
RE9ORT
13
RIGHT
EVIDENCE
INTO
THEYRE
YEAH
WERE
RECORDS
BUSINESS
12
COMING
WERE
NOT
FOCUSED
ON
SAYING
NOT
JUST
ONE
THIS
CUSTOMERS
OF
AND
14
15
STATEMENT
16
STATE
17
NO
18
VERIFY
19
THEY
20
CUSTONER
21
TIME
22
OF
OR
IN
SOME
THEY
THEM
SAID
NEGOTIATING
23
24
REPORT
25
THESE
WHICH
SO
DOWT
STAIDARDS
RA YNEE
BECAUSE
THEY
DONT
THEY
ITTS
JUST
RISE
WHI0H
TO
IERE
MERC.400 CSR
NOT
THOSE
ON
WERE
SHOWN
CERTAIN
SAY
REALLY
THOSE
THE
DUTY
DID
RELY
CUSTOMERS
THAT
AND
NOT
THEY
SEEKLNG
4EAN
SPECIflO
LEVEL
WAS
TO
TO
TO
BE
OR
IN
THE
TRUE
TEE
FROM
COURSE
KNOW
IN
STATEMENTS
OF RELIABILITY
TO
DID
CONTRARY
AS
NOT
THINGS
CR
IT
THE
STATEMENTS
OR
EXCLUDE
RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510
TO
THERES
WRTCH
vERIFY
DO
DUTY
UNDER
BUSINESS
THEIR
OF
THIRDPARTY
THAT
PARTY
THIRD
FROM
COMMENTS
THAT
IS
UNDER
WAS
HICU
DID
BECAUSE
TINE
COURSg
ORACLE
WAY
SAY
THAT
UNLESS
REGULAR
DIDNT
TO
OASES
ON
EVIDENCE
IT
THE
WHAT
THE
IN
IT
ARE
HEARSAY
IS
TRANSCRIBED
WHICH
451-7530
THE
MEET
12
COURT
AND
HOWARD
THE
HE
DIDNT
YOUR EXPERT
THOSE
RELY UPON
STATEMENTS
NOT
OR ASCRIBE
RELY ON
THERE
IN
--
AND
NOT
EXPERT
IS
REASONS
THE
THAT
FACT
AND
SO
MATTER
11
YOU
12
THIRDPARTY
13
THEN
FOR
BE
BACK
TO
THE
NO
INDICIA
HAD
SIDE
14
THE
15
YOUR
PAPERS
17
MIND
THAT
18
OF THE
FROM
OR
IS
THAT
THE
CRITERIA
COURT
WHAT
16
OTHER
THESE
IS
BUT
OF THE
TRUTH
AND
OF RELIABILITY
ADMISSIBLE
HAVENT
THERE
--
TRUTH
ANYWAY
LEAVE
RIGHT
THE
THE
TO
ARE
DEFENDANTS
THE
SHOW
GOING
WERE
GETS
AND
TO
DID
BUT
THAT
COMMENTS
THE
WOULD
IT
THE
REPORTS
CLARKE
STATEMENTS
WAS
THAT
MR
THE
USED
OF
ANY
TO
--
THE
CUSTOMERS
ASSERTED
10
--
THOSE
HE
IF
VERACITY
THE
USING
-- AND
FOR
AND
HE
RELIED
DIFFERENCE
STATEMENTS
WHICH
20
THE
21
IS
22
GOING
23
INDIVIDUALLY
24
AGGREGATE
FACT
THAT
RELEVANT
ON
25
THE
TO
WHETHER
TRUE
AND
THE
PAYNEE
IN
NOT
WHICH
SOME
COURT
IS
THAT
VERY
BRIEFLY
MARKET
OR
MAKE
THE
THAT
BACKGROUND
THOSE
IS
PARTICULAR
TO THE
IN
STATE
FROM THE
HONOR
YOUR
OR
ITS
MR MEYER
THAT
OF
TRUTH
LEAVING
FOR
STATEMENTS
WHY
SAY
DIFFERENT
CONCERNS
HAD
YOU
PERTINENT
REASONS
CUSTOMERS
THE
BETWEEN
THEIR
IS
LANIER
19
TO
SIDE
ARE
HOW
CUSTOMERS
MATTER
FROM
EITHER
OKAY
THE
THE
ORACLE
THE
MET
ITS
EXPRESSED
RELEVANT
WERE
BECAUSE
CONCERNS
TO WHAT
WAS
ACTUALLY
RELIED
ON
THEM
CIRCUMSTANCES
OKAY
MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510
451-7530
IN
THE
124
STATES
THE
THAT
FOREGOING
DIRECTION
UNDER
MY
10
FULL
COMPLETE
AND
11
ME
THE
OF
AT
TIME
THE
12
13
14
COURT
BE
ET
AND
REPORTER
INTO
TRUE
RECORD
C0701658
AL
OF
REPORTED
THAT
SAID
FOREGOING
THE
PROCEEDINGS
AS
BY
FILING
OF
VOID
RAYNEE
THE
UPON
MERCADO
MONDAY
18
REPORTERS
DISASSEMBLY
CERTIFICATION
AMD/OR
REMOVAL
CSR
RNR
OCTOBER
CRR
FCRR
CCRR
2010
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RAYNEE
IS
BOUND
FILE
17
ME
SY
TRANSCRIBED
THEREAFTER
WERE
CERTIFY
ORACLE
PJH
WERE
UNITED
THE
HEREBY
CALIFORNIA
TYPEWRITING
VALIDITY
MAY
TRANSCRIPT
AG
SAP
SHORTH.ND
CERTIFIED
IN
PROCEEDINGS
AL
ET
CORPORATION
CF
DISTRICT
NORTHERN
COURt
FOR
REPORTER
OFFICIAL
MERCADO
RAYNEE
nPORTER
OF
cERTIFICATE
MERCALQ
CSA RMR ORR FCRR CCRR 510
451-7530
OF
SAID
FROM
TEE
2009
March
SHIPPY
ATTORNEYS
CONFIDENTIAL
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
EYES ONLY
Page
UNITED
DISTRICT
NORTHERN
COURT
DISTRICT
STATES
OF
CALIFORNIA
FRANCISCO DIVISION
SAN
ORACLE
CORPORATION
Delaware
corporation
ORACLE
INC
Colorado
and
ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California corporation
USA
Plaintiffs
No
vs
07-CV-1658
PJH
AG
German corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
TOMORROWNOW
corporation
and
Texas
INC
corporation
DOES
inclusive
1-50
SAP
SAP
Defendants
VIDEOTAPED
ELIZABETH
THURSDAY
HIGHLY
REPORTED
BY
ANN
SHIPPY
MARCH
2009
ATTORNEYS
CONFIDENTIAL
HOLLY
OF
DEPOSITION
THUMAN
CSR
No
EYES
6834
ONLY
RNR
CRR
1-416868
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
c7740684.433d-448c-886d-ef57347ecc5c
ANN
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
March
SHIPPY
2009
EYES ONLY
ATTORNEYS
CONFIDENTIAL
40
Page
100340
2005
of
sunwner
1Db42
dont tecali
Ms
10c355
10cr3t57
Risk
1O035
as
Shippy
what
or
report
are
referred
is
Uncle
within
to
At
the
with
farailiar
you
At Risk repirt
the
100400
Yes
100401
Old
10P402
to
pertain
100404
of
any
the
responsibilities
job
your
Risk
report
describe
some
in
time
rpft
Yes_
1OC406
10
.1UQ407
12
Can
resporisib
you
those
of
tlities
100414
one
point
100417
13
over
100424
14
received
100426
15
updated
10O28
16
appropriate
1004n
17
100433
18
rementher
100936
19
was
able
take
to
responsibilities
the
information
the
report
the
said
the
point
some
time
in
point
that
you
late
05
early
1004-SQ
22
tO0453
23
Risk
100456
24
tesponsibilities
106459
25
Calendar
the
with
team
time
21
re-port
that
rep
sales
support
shared
then
report
in
100442
Did
at
the
the
roughly
Its
s-dy
from
and
management
You
10039
managed
So
reportiftg
Do
yU
undertook
06
those
wouj.ci
year
you
have
prior
in
any
to
interaction
taking
late
05
over
with
the
At
those
early
06
Yes
Soutions
8699132
Merrill Legal
800
cfl4O6
443
3d -448c-88
Gd -ot57347
etc
Sc
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
SHIPPY
ANN
2009
March
EYES
ATTORNEYS
CONFIDENTIAL
ONLY
Page
100501
wa
What
100506
A-
10d509
if they
100513
could
had
from
help
When
an
assist
items
followup
any
say
Rick
whom
are
you
Rick
Patricia
or
that
anytlng
perspective
operations
ypu
interactions
those
of
nature
would
believe
10051
100524
the
41
are
referring
you
to
Gummins
Rick
am
100525
100526
And
100527
refet
when
you
Patricia
to
urquia
100529
10
Patricia
100531
11
CAn
100534
12
100541
13
100543
14
100544
15
100549
r6
100552
17
What
does
100555
1E
MS
1-lOOSE
100556
19
MR
DKLM-IUNTY
100557
20
MS HOUSE
100600
21
THE
1Q0605
22
the
100609
23
forecasting
100613
24
et
1OO19
25
A.
to
referring
her
spell
you
name
last
if
know
yOu
MURGUIA
If
recall
you
what
her
was
position
within
Oracle
Shes
sales
on
the
team
reporting-
within
support
operations
support
the
Vague
sales
the
as
do
time
to
speaking
Generally
Vague
WITNESS
team
reporting
They
business
workload
run
overbroad
time
to
as
reports
understand
to
the
which
l1cw
the
cancellations
cetera
MR
DELAHUNTY
While
you
were
nrking
Merrill
Legal Solutions
800 869-9132
c7 74068
4433d-448c
aa -efSTa4Tec
St
2009
EYES ONLY
March
ELIZABETH ANN SHIPPY
ATTORNEYS
CONFIDENTIAL
HIGHLY
160128
time
third
But
just
160131
THE
WITNESS
160131
4R
DELAHUNTY
160133
MS
160136
rights
160130
right
now
leave
the
Okay
So
open
deposition
16013
know
will
dont
and
HOUSE
will
ubviousiy
But
disagree
we
dont
all
Leserve
have
Lets
this
do
to
go
So
MR
160141
VIDEO
Thanks
DELHUNTY
THE
160140
off
the
record
l6042
160142
11
1.60146
12
160201
13
1602 04
of
This
Elizabeth
Volume
concludes
Shippy
We
are
off
11
160204
OPERATOR
15
602 04
in
the
the
deposition
record
at
Time
401
declare
16
the
foregoing
401
noted
is
under
true
and
p.m
of
penalty
correrl
Subscribed
Js-t
tni
1602DO
20
da
at
of
iO
160204
that
perjury
2011
Li
100201
00201
27
IZABETII
ANN
Sill
190
Solutions
Merrill Legal
800 8G99132
Merrill
Solutions
Legal
Sheet
Errata
Line
Page
Change Add
line
p.69
PeopleSoft
for
providers
came
TomorrowNow
Reason
121
line
other
third
in
support
party
911
18
Change Add
and
which
existed
and on
location
could
the
at
that
the products
time any
offer
credibly
the
the
on
Change Add
provider
Change
SAP
came
it
also
existed
and
on
support
the
in
any
offer
credibly
that
third
customer
party
support
manner
the
in
the
required
and out
in
depends
which
or
could
the products
on
of
besides
JD Edwards application
existence
whether
credibly
that
The few other
on the time
depending
PeopleSoft
the
any
offer
different
at
other
third
support
customer
in
time periods
party
the
support
manner
in
the
required
Clarification
Possibly -- but as
and the
TomorrowNow connection
Add
this situation
Reason
Subject
on
time periods
different
other
other
besides
application
at
existence
of
Yes again
for
providers
And again
Reason
could
JD Edwards
whether
The few
on the time
depending
or
and out
in
products
after
TomorrowNow
location
again
Clarification
service
______
on whether
depending
PeopleSoft
which
existed
Reason
24
--
the
depends
also
it
location
lnC
for
came
provider
135
in
Yes
after
providers
And again
22
periods
Clarification
TomorrowNow
line
time
different
required
service
133
at
existence
of
provider
support
manner
the
Reason
lines
out
Possibly
after
customer
124
and
in
Clarification
Change Add
14
other service
on the time The few
depending
Edwards application besides
or JD
Yes
after
after
Tomorrow
Now seems
the
explained
Safe
only
before
given
Passage program
candidate
the
for just
likely
Clarification
to
the
above
changes
cedify
that
the
transcript
correct
4dte
is
true
and
CERTIFJCVPE
Reporter
hereby
foregoing
deposition was
truth
truth
withinentitled cause
down
shorthand
in
time and
the
10
place
witness
by
said
review
13
if
14
provided
to
15
appended
me
in
the
sworn
to
tell
duly
but
nothing
said
the
stated
and
that
reduced
and
completion
the
truth
was
deposition
disinterested
my direction
before
witness
the
thereafter
was
12
and
that
therein
That
11
by
me
by
under
computer
that
certify
whoTe
the
Certified Shorthand
THUMAN
hOLLY
REPORTER
OF
the
in
taken
person
at
the
the
testimony
of
to
typewriting
supervision
of
the
deposition
hereto
the
of
requested
16
changes
any
the
reporter
further
attorney
18
deposition
nor
in
19
this
and
that
20
parties
cause
made
by
during
certify that
17
for
was
transcript
either
the
the
am
not
requested
and
deponent
period
allowed are
not
of
counsel
parties
to
the
or
any
of
any
way
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
CSR
No
am
not
the
was
or
said
of
the
thereto
21
22
25
DATED
i-
/._-
HOLLY
TRUMAN
6834
ELIZABETH ANN SHIPPY
INFORMATION
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
September
25
ATTORNEYS
2008
EYES
ONLY
Page
STATES
UNITED
NORTHERN
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
OF
FRANCISCO
SAN
COURT
CALIFORNIA
DIVISION
--BOoDelaware
CORPORATION
Corporation
ORACLE
USA INC
Colorado
and
Corporation
ORACLE
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
ORACLE
California
Corporation
Plaintiffs
No
Vs
EDL
07-CV-01658-PJH
AG
German Corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
INC
Texas
and
DOES
Corporation
Inclusive
SAP
SAP
5O
Defendants
_____________________________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
ELIZABETH
Designee
Thursday
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job
By
ANN
25
September
INFORMATION
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ORACLE
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
ARLEN
SHIPPY
2008
ATTORNEYS
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
413273
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
69e62006-fda5-433a-9192-ebecbdl793da
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
SHIPPY
CONFIDENTThL INFORMATION
25
September
2008
ATTORNEYS
ONLY
EYES
81
Page
that
that
thats
1057
manual
the
end
And
for
report
the
notes
sales
1057
8.
08
is
the
that
is
Im
10
happened
between
11
example
since
12
anywhere
as
part
13
went
into
that
think
its
called
is
comments
the
since
let
15
16
report
17
there
So
question
1057
the
anywhere
attachments
21
no
22
are
still
23
the
OKS
longer
24
check
me
in
the
make
have
for
05
of
even
going
was
some
customers
that
we
were
rep
would
renewal
OKS
into
are
being
able
to
and
notes
tracked
add
So
see
notes
if
where
through
Merrill Legal
800
that
So
you
in
in
the
though
to
be
that
still
your
ended
still
were
include
notes
though the
this
manual
and
arid
in
working
even
its at
the
recorded
reporting process
been
the
customer
understand
sure
report
the
that
is
risk
at
February
contract
deal
08
the
and
rep
right
So
20
of
manual
neg.otiation
19
sales
February
have
may
the
of
February
communications
about
the
by
OKS
So
1058
that
information
talking
it
was
information collected
that
itts
so
posted
that
but
would have
it
and
cumulative
is
been
has
there
example
Pnd
1057
It
That
infcrfttatiot
field
rep
it
of
reference
for
available
created
was
as
notes
form
reps
attach
and
them
in
were
going
to
look
we
should
att.aehments
in
be
able
to
015
Solutions
8699132
69e62OO6-fda5433a.1
92-ebecbdll93da
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
SHIPPY
2008
EYES
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
25
September
ONLY
82
Page
that
Does
Yes
those
rUSS
answer
Are
notes
the
th
needs
rep
the
once
again
is
document
what
goes
in
be
emails right
of
whatever
is
appropriate
any
12
particular
form
on
æd
attachment
could
it
be
that
for
deal
MS
13
going
the
into
could
11
the
taken
been
notes
as
that
been
væiats
have
steps
risk
at
has
team
management
it
itself
attach
speculation
Or
10
14
for
The
to
acccnjnt
that
1OB
required to
reps
contract
if
with
58
Calls
WITNESS
THE
renewal
sales
though
MS HOUSE
requested
question
your
WALLACE
it
But
ends
in
up
in
OKS
sonic
form
Correct
16
Li
1059
The
Okay
listed
by
on
79
page
name who
are
19
It
does
at
that
thats
report
identify the
customers
risk
does
Okay
21
management
was
22
1U9
analysis
Yes
20
risk
at
paxtioular
customer
23
and
24
that
25
relevant communications
It
wasnt
person
reading
yet
could
had
that
been
so
then
was
OKS
to
and
saw
identified
it
go
someone
if
report
cancelled
Merrill Legal
800
And
between
and
the
as
still
find
in
that
at
risk
active
the
customer
and
the
Solutions
8699132
60e62006-fdaS433u-9192-ebecbdl
793da
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
SHIPPY
CONFIDENTIAL
the
Whereupon
1150
25
ATTOBNEYS
deposition
was
2008
EYES
ONLY
adjourned
at
a.m
declare
the
September
INFORMATION
foregoing
____________
________
is
true
under
and
California
penalty
of
perjury
correct
Subscribed
this
day
____
that
at
of
2008
Signature
11
of
tness
IC
21
24
114
Merrill
Legal Solutions
869-9132
800
Errata Sheet
Deposition
of Elizabeth Shippv
September
25 2008
Reason
Page
Line
Change
30
20
Change Oracle
contracts
for
service
to
Oracle
Contract
Correction
contracts
for
service
to
Oracle
Contract
Correction
System
11-12
31
Change Oracle
System
Subject
to
the
above
changes
certify that
the transcript
is
true
and
correct
ionfo
Sjjature
A72717g28
date
P1CTE
CRRT
REPORTER
OF
Certified
WENDY
Reporter
hereby
foroqoing
sepcsi
truth
Li
whole
chq
on
was
truth
withinentitied
said
and
Lace
therein
10
said
witness
11
computer
under
requested
15
deponent
16
period
and
are
for
either
18
attorney
19
deposition
nor
in
20
this
cause
and
that
21
parties
22
truth
the
the
any
any
way
am
the
at
of
the
by
supervision
of
deposition
the
was
not
made
by
changes
reporter
the
during
the
hereto
not
of
counsel
parties
to
the
said
of
that
of
the
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
not
thereto
DATED
2008
24
WENDY
Lime
typewriting
to
the
to
in
down
23
25
the
in
testimony
any
certify
or
the
was
appended
further
17
tell
person
that
completi on
requested
provided
allowed
to
token
was
and
transcript
If
the
sworn
reduced
direction
my
before
14
and
stated
thereafter
was
the
on
disinterested
by
of
in
hut
nothing
arid
ness
Wi
duly
me
by
depositi
me
shorthand
review
the
cause
That
12
that
cerrity
Shorthand
ARLEN
CSR
No
4355
the
or
ANN SHIPPY
ELIZABETH
INFORMATION
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
September
25
ATTORNEYS
2008
EYES ONLY
Page
STATES
UNITED
DISTRICT
FRANCISCO
SAN
CALIFORNIA
OF
DISTRICT
NORTHERN
COURT
DIVISION
--OOoDelaware
CORPORATION
USA INC
ORACLE
and
Colorado
Corporation
ORACLE INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California
Corporation
ORACLE
Corporation
Plaintiffs
No
Vs
EDL
07-CV--01658-PJH
AG
German
Corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
TOMORROWNOW
INC
CORPORATION
DOES
Texas
and
Corporation
150 Inclusive
SAP
SAP
Defendants
______________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
ORACLE
Thursday
Reported
Job
By
ANN
25
September
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ELIZABETH
Designee
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
ARLEN
SHIPPY
2008
ATTORNEYS
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
413273
Merrill Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
69e62006-fda5433a-9192-ebecbdl793da
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
SHIPPY
2008
ATTORNEYS
INFOPJ4ATION
CONFIDENTIAL
25
September
ONLY
EYES
Page
or me
patricia
or
information
in
enter
reps
1105
same
time
is
10
manual
11
information
1106
would
16
them
17
if
19
23
of
didnt
in
it
the
it
kept
just
to
at
as
that
literally keying
the
email
and
then
when
So
email
it
to
accounts
give
cf
they
your
into
it
they
report
reps
to
the
reminding
that
send
them
the
would
would
paste
Merrill Legal
800
renewal
wqulU
enter
and
copy
the
running
the
the
Rick
or
risk
at
gets
template
fields
that
in
cases
and
to
reps
spreadsheet
would
some
the
was
arid
input
cases
they
had
will
some
24
We
referring
is
did
out
me
to
They
report
been
when
So
they
forth
1106
work
Patricia
you
their
needed
how
notice
that
20
21
Ad
to
send
you
just
the
in
infonnatiOri
1106
Ive
it
and
have
to
multiple users
get
somebody
Okay
15
tried
we
didnt
just
because
information
11
that
online
te
why
Okay
12
database
able
thats
manual
the
time
it
the
putting
rep
information
So
and
the
was
werenTt
We
fly
pasting
owned
We
the
and
Rick
through
always
to
talking
There
was
copying
literally
information
1105
It
information
the
enter
the
cmailed
go
just
back
in
spreadsheet
free
type
into
the
master
information in
the
irEormation
did
email address
Solutions
8699132
69e62006.fdaS43Sa-91
92.ebocbdll9ada
SHIPPY
INFOR4ATION
CONFIDENTIAL
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
25
september
ANN
2008
EYES
ATTORNEYS
ONLY
Page
Personal
correct
account
Personal
89
account
Uhhuh
Do
No
Fs
several
as
would
it
the
email
10
take
from
11
then
delete
ll7
email
14
sound
plus
in
reps
North
would
information
the
get
place
it
into
the
seen
in
some
document
Ive
Now
AtRisk
addr.ss
report
and
Does
us.@oracle.Com
an
that
you
familiar to
15
Yes
16
qhat
17
It
doesnt
Oh
okay
20
No
it
21
1107
200
this
doing
email
the
Okay
1Z
hava
we
And
Pmerica
CT
and
years
Ive been
imagine
can
emails
those
to
happened
you
exist
still
not
do
they
What
1106
cmails
the
Okay
18
.Q
email
that
is
address
far
exist
Did
ever
anyone
try
and
email
to
alert
is
it
22
1107
there
evolved
email
new
23
There
24
is
okay
25
so
2thd
to
renewal
when
address
you
for
email
an
say
alert
renewal
renewal
address
for
alert
renewal
alert
No
But
its
Merrill Legal
800
not
At
Riscus@oracle
Solutions
8699132
69e62OG6fda5-433a-91
92.ebecbdl
793da
ELIZABETH
HIGHLY
ANN
SHIPPY
CONFIDENTIAL
September
the
Whereupon
1150
deposition
was
2008
EYES
ONLY
adjourned
at
a.rn
declare
the
25
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
foregoing
_____________
_______
true
is
under
of
perjury
corect
Subscribed
this
and
California
penalty
day
____
that
at
of
2008
Stoftness
24
114
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
Errata Sheet
Deposition
of Elizabeth Shippy
September
25 2008
Reason
Page
Line
Change
30
20
Change Oracle
contracts
for
service
to
Oracle
Contract
Correction
contracts
for
service
to
Oracle
Contract
Correction
System
31
11 -12
Change Oracle
System
Subject to the above
changes
Sijjature
A727782
certify
that
the transcript
is
true
and
correct
date
RepoLte
hereby
certify
forego
dopos
ion
th
truth
Lt
whole
said
me
by
and
therein
witness
11
computer
That
13
review
14
requested
15
deponent
16
period
at
depositi
the
the
in
the
reduced
and
completion
L/
to
of
19
deposition
nor
in
20
this
cause
and
that
21
parties
any
way
am
was
not
made
by
the
during
that
the
of
the
not
of
counsel
parties
to
the
said
of
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
not
DATED
2008
23
NcLQ
WENDY
by
trig
thereto
24
the
hereto
certify
any
of
deposition
the
was
appended
or
time
supervision
reporter
either
the
at
typewrit
the
are
in
testimony
to
provided
attorney
25
te1
down
person
changes
18
22
taken
any
further
for
the
truth
the
requested
allowed
17
but
that
direction
my
before
If
and
to
was
on
and
stated
transcript
the
sworn
nothing
thereafter
was
under
12
in
duly
disinterested
shorthand
said
witness
the
me
by
Shorthand
cause
That
10
was
that
truth and
withinentitled
place
Certified
ARLEN
WENDY
trig
REPORTER
OF
CERTIFICATE
ARLEN
CSR
No
4355
the
or
RICHARD
HIGHLY
CUMMINS
CONFIDENTIAL
23
September
INFOATION
ATTORNEYS
2008
EYES ONLY
Page
UNITED
STATES
NORTHERN
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
OF
FRANCISCO
SAN
256
COURT
CALIFORNIA
DIVISION
--OOoORACLE
Delaware
CORPORATION
Corporation
ORACLE
USA INC
and
Colorado
Corporation
ORACLE
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California Corporation
Plaintiffs
Vs
SAP
07CV-0l658PJH
No
EDL
AG
German
Corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
INC
Texas
DOES
and
Corporation
1-50
Inclusive
SAP
Defendants
_____________________________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
Volume
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job
By
CUMMINS
RICHARD
Designee
Tuesday
23
September
II
Pages
256
ARLEN
2008
436
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ORACLE
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
412497
Merrill
Legal Solutions
800 869-9132
f4294576cc2c-45bf-9a42-2d77645a99c8
CUMMINS
September 23
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
2008
RICHARD
HIGHLY
EYES
ONLY
309
Page
Also
eNS
in
specific
1053
or
and
may
The
Access
E1
World
up
that
and
if
theres
more
to
down
strategic
in
why
was
whether
Beth
it
stuff
nterp.ise
nothing
it
because
told
Thats
true/false
as
it
then
reps
the
then
were
reps
territory
coumns
our
database
database
1053
next
Some
narrowed
have
within
something
OKS
from
Mostly
that
these
an
was
The
Access
it
shows
field
look
like
true
false
11
12
Arid
again
on
these
1O3
that
columns
columns
products
that
explained
you
14
16
information
in
That
MS HOUSE
THE
WITNESS
Yeah
The
product
product
19
is
20
how
21
22
not
thats
information
Calls
just
23
Ta
my
24
So
then
25
Column
comes
were
specific
dont
family
release
know
on
your
the
that
kripwledge
sales
reps
yes
AD
product
Legal
800
speculation
the
to
from
knowledge
AD
for
Sc
McDONEJ4L
Merrill
that
in there
indicated
MR
is
OKS
18
1054
but
Oracle
the
iriformaticn
11
1054
to
previously
AC
through
Correct
refer
us
Okay
15
to
notes
as
we
indicated
Solutions
8699132
f4294
51
Ecc
Zc.45bf-9a42-2d
77 645ag9c8
RICRAPD
CUMMINS
September
CONFIDENTIAL
23
2008
I-
declare
the
foregoing
is
true
under
and
penalty
correct
this
_____________
/S-
of
perjury
Subscribed
day
that
at
of
2008
Signature
witness
10
11
12
13
14
j5
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
434
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
whoLe
the
truth
truth
said
That
and
therein
witness
11
computer
That
of
review
14
requested
15
deponent
16
period
If
and
before
the
the
to
he
was
not
made
by
in
20
this
and
that
21
parties
way
am
mg
of
counsel
of
the
parties
to
the
said
of
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
riot
thereto
2008
DATED
23
24
WENDY
the
not
that
certify
any
dur
the
hereto
appended
nor
tion
depos
reporter
deposition
the
by
typewriting
was
any
of
supervision
cemplet Ion
or
time
testimony
the
either
in
the
at
person
to
arc
down
taken
changes
19
25
the
in
truth
the
any
attorney
22
but
requested
18
cause
tell
was
and
direction
my
further
for
to
reduced
thereafter
provided
allowed
17
sworn
that
transcript
the
L3
and
stated
was
under
12
the
nothing
arid
disinterested
by
said
in
duly
deposition
me
shorthand
place
witness
the
me
by
Shorthand
Led
cause
wLthin--enti.tled
JO
was
deposition
oreqorng
that
cert Lfy
hereby
Cert if
ARIFN
WENDY
Reporter
REPORTER
OF
CERTIErCATE
ARLEN
CER
No
4355
the
or
CUMMINS
September 23 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES ONLY
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
HIGHLY
Page
STATES
UNITED
NORTHERN
SAN
COURT
DISTRICT
CALIFORNIA
OF
DISTRICT
256
DIVISION
FRANCISCO
--OOoDelaware
CORPORATION
ORACLE
USA INC
Corporation
Colorado
and
Corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
ORACLE
ORACLE
California
Corporation
Plaintiffs
EDL
07CV-0l658PJH
No
Vs
German Corporation
Delaware
ANERICA
INC
INC
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
and
DOES
Texas
Corporation
150 Inclusive
SAP
SAP
AG
Defendants
______________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
RICHARD
CUMMINS
September
23
Designee
Tuesday
Volume
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job 412497
By
II
Pages
256
Merrill
ARLEN
Legal
800
2008
436
ATTORNEYST
INFORMATION
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ORACLE
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
Solutions
8699132
f4294576-cc2c-45bf-9a42-2d77645a99c8
CUNMINS
September 23 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
HIGHLY
ONLY
303
Page
You
could
Whos
for
Lets
losses
know
dsc reporting
at
losses
projected
against
sure
for
be
would
1O4.E
this
in
responsible
actual
tracking
dont
her
ask
go
back
lets
go
55
Exhibit
to
Okay
And
there
were
data
talked
we
that
many
the
to
of
columns
about
which
time
last
Okay
11
the
least
12
to
13
already
know
burden
each
of
these
told
us
what
the
14
of
17
for
19
one
20
each
have
one
And
columns
column
so
if
where
it
quickly
what
but
want
youve
and
is
with
.and
mean
headings
Im
every
customer
of
example
nonU.S
customers
somebody
22
didnt
Yes
24
25
from
our
report
this
support
Merrill
who
is
sales
Legal
800
source
you
Oracle
said
didnt
on
the
to
on
Ill
there
get
might
reported
is
at
you
dont
right
be
some
because
right
thera
information that
reps
you
list
this
.from
tell
because
is
best
information
of
all
at
curious
you
us
tell
information comes
the
helps
reasons
For
the
what
the
of
21
1047
possible
through and
run
you
your knowledge
Oracle
1046
as
Yes
can
this
do
as
you
nfl
for
15
1046
to
Want
Okay
So
itTs
was
as
reported
accurate
as
Solutions
8699132
f4294576-c
c2c-4Sbf-9a
42-2d
7764
99 cS
CUMMINS
September 23 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
HIGHLY
ONLY
304
Page
what
we
pull
from
from
given
1O47
tell
go
1041
11
So
lobk
just
If
and
just
know
dont
dont know
you
from
report
you
with
starting
comes
this
to
gets
say
columns
information
columns
the
was
the
Starting
MS
what
16
ci
off
these
come
from
soutce
and
21
from
22
sales
you
the
pull
of
the
that
me
let
is
were
on
what
you
know
with
looked
support
from
information that
was
page
And
Data
about
the
through all these
So
Beth
didnrt
else
anywhere
to
her
is
there
reps
sales
given
source
colwin
information
inforraation
exhibit
actual
record
So
reason
other
of
tell
have
you
tha information starting
20
25
know
The
T9
24
Do
McDONELL
to
want
17
23
HOUSE
MR
14
15
can
ii
Discussion
12
19
customer
these
at
12
1048
it
It
with
10
1040
before
any
to
answer
that
data
reps
the
through
where
rile
through
right
me
not
source
other
no
sales
support
walk
Oracle
within
1048
our
So
and
Theres
anywhere
its
doesnt
It
given
were
go
It
from
all
all
is
back
came
support
reps
Okay
information
the
But
do
sales
you
reps
know
would
what
sources
of
have
Okay
MErill
Legal Soluti.ons
800 8.699132
f429457
6-cc2c-45
bf-9a42-2d77
45a99
eB
RICHAPD
September
CONFIDENTIAL
CUMMINS
declare
the
foregoing
_____________
under
Ga
is
true
and
penalty
correct
this
/S-
23
2008
of
perjury
Subscribed
day
that
at
of
2008
SignaLure
Witness
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
434
Merrill Legal
800
Solutions
869-9132
ARLEN
WENDY
hereby
Ioreqoinq
deposition
said
That
me
by
and
therein
10
said wit ness
11
uornputer
was
under
13
review
11
requested
15
deponent
16
period
the
of
stated
provided
are
tell
but
ruth
the
further
either
attorney
ion
comple
19
deposition
nor
in
20
this
cause
and
that
21
parties
any
the
the
way
am
time
the
by
supervision
the
of
was
riot
made
chanqes
reporter
Lon
10105
the
by
during
the
hereto
that
of
the
not
of
counsel
parties
to
the
said
of
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
riot
thereto
DATED
2008
24
WENDY
of
typewriting
to
the
any
in
the
at
23
25
the
in
testimony
any
to
down
person
was
certify
or
taken
was
and
appended
18
22
to
that
clireution
requested
allowed
for
sworn
reduced
thereafter
my
If
17
and
transcript
arid
the
nothing
deposition
before
rfha
in
duly
disinterested
shorthand
place
and
witness
the
me
by
Shorthand
led
cause
itleci
within--cot
was
truth
whole
the
Cert
that
certity
Reporter
truth
REPORTER
OF
CERTIFiCATE
ARLEN
CSR
No
4355
the
or
CUMMINS
September 23 2008
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS EYES
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
HIGHLY
ONLY
Page
UNITED
NORTHERN
CALIFORNIA
OF
DISTRICT
FRANCISCO
SAN
COURT
DISTRICT
STATES
256
DIVISION
--OOoDelaware
CORPORATION
USA INC
Corporation
ORACLE
and
Colorado Corporation
INTERNATIONAL
ORACLE
CORPORATION
California Corporation
ORACLE
Plaintiffs
Vs
No
EDL
07-CV-0l658-PJH
AG
German
Corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
INC
Texas
and
DOES
Corporation
150 Inclusive
SAP
SAP
Defendants
_________________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
RICHARD
Designee
Volume
HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job
By
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ORACLE
Tuesday
DEPOSITION
CUMMINS
23
September
II
256
Pages
436
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
ARLEN
2008
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
412497
Merrill Legal
Solutions
800 8699132
f4294576.cc2c-45bf-9a42-2d77645a99c8
RICHARD
HIGHLY
CUMNINS
INFOTION
CONFTDENTIAL
23
September
2008
ATTORNEYS
ONLY
EYES
305
Page
So
where
would
they
Calls
MODONELL
say
dont
you
1049
take
us
McDONELL
cQuld
get
12
their
just
too
about
systematic
customer
arid
just
would
rep
it
because
they
this
was
is
account
know
So
ii
Yes
And
they
would
15
renewal
16
the
18
next
they
information
11
25
then
information
be
This
the
them
includes
the
on
date
start
tº
are
customers
working
theyre
given
Im
But
gets
into
MS HOUSE
You
their
know
which
Okay
asked
how
MR
24
who
any
and
this
OKS
In
shows
it
the
is
which
year
given
column
21
22
would
date
start
19
20
D49
be
sales
support
13
1049
to
start with
information
this
would
Just
So
Okay
it
10z49
dont know
you
it
through
10
if
Its overbroad
you
if
speculation
know
MR
this
for
hgin
MS HOUSE
-I
column
in
that
get
MS HOUSE
1048
amount
revenue
example
for
is
it
OKS
Thats
got
into
4cDONELL
preOKS
want
not
this
This
how
in
what
the
OXS
particular
report
is
him
asked
you
report
riot
frotn
OKS
right
to
know
Merrill Legal
800
not
about
whats
talking
where
the
information
came
Solutions
8699132
f429457
B-cc
Zc-45
bf-9a42.2d77
645a99c
RICHARD
CUMMINS
September
CONFIDENTIAL
declare
the
foregoing
____________
true
is
under
and
cia
penalty
23
2008
of
perjury
correct
Subscribed
this/S-
day
that
at
of
2008
Signature
Witness
13
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
434
Merrill Legal
800
Solutions
869-132
CERTIFICATE
hereby
LoLeqoinq
deposition
whoLe
the
said
me
by
and
therein
was
witness
11
computer
under
That
13
revi ow
of
14
request
ed
15
deponent
16
period
stated
tell
but
truth
the
are
either
19
deposition
nor
in
20
this
cause
and
that
21
parties
the
supervis
ion
of
any
way
am
by
ion
was
riot
the
made by
reporter
dur
mg
the
hereto
that
of
the
not
of
counsel
parties
to
the
said
of
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
riot
thereto
DATEDQC1Oe2
24
WENDY
the
depos
the
any
of
typewriting
to
chaniqes
certify
or
time
testimony
the
any
to
the
23
25
in
in
down
person
was
appended
attorney
taken
was
and
ipt
provided
18
22
to
reduced
compie
requested
further
for
sworn
that
direction
before
aUowed
17
and
thereafter
my
If
arid
the
nothing
deposition
transor
the
arid
in
duly
disinterested
shorthand
aa id
me
by
witness
the
cause
That
10
was
truth
withinentit1ed
place
that
certify
Reporter
Shorthand
Certi fled
ARLEN
WENDY
truth
REPORTER
OF
ARLEN
CSR
No
4355
2008
the
or
HIGHLY
RICHARD CUMMINS
September 23 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
ONLY
Page
UNITED
STATES
COURT
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
NORTHERN
256
CALIFORNIA
OF
FRANCISCO DIVISION
SAN
--000-Delaware
CORPORATION
USA INC
Corporation
ORACLE
and
Colorado
Corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
ORACLE
California Corporation
ORACLE
Plaintiffs
No
Vs
EDL
07CV--0l658--PJH
AG
German Corporation
Delaware
INC
AMERICA
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
INC
and
DOES
Texas
Corporation
150 Inclusive
SAP
SAP
Defendants
______________________________________________________/
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
RICHARD
CUMMINS
September
23
Designee
Tuesday
II
Volume
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job
By
256
Pages
ARLEN
2008
436
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
WENDY
OF
CORPORATION
ORACLE
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
412497
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
f4294576-cc2c-45bf-9a42-2d77645a99c8
RICHARD
HIGHLY
CUMMINS
2008
EYES
ATTORNEYS
INFOR14ATION
CONFIDENTIAL
23
September
ONLY
320
Page
email
the
from
you
Yes
Can
Its
111-0
third
that
identify
you
e-mail
an
that
of
current
the
this
Is
was
went
that
---
and
list
party distribution
highlights
please
it
to
the
some
gave
report
that
report
did
you
on
regular
basis
Yes
1110
How
10
ii
like
1110
It
or
latest
19
how
wquld
third
18
1110
you
with
report
here
riSk
it
the
at
which
22
summary
was
risk
would
what
risk
at
is
the
anaiysis.
with
typically
the
attached
says
typically send
points
it
but
work
you
21
suiumary
analysis
send
see
out
out
some
kind
here
bullet
of
some
bullets
24
25
is
think
23
1111
framer
along
it
that
at
party
along
20
time
would
So
report
send
said
Yes
16
1-7
cut
mont.hly
Would
report
the
on
depends
roughly
roughly
14
15
send
you
this
12
13
would
frequently
want
risk
to
make
report
sure
was
4erri11
we
you
covered
were clear
intende4
Legal
800
this
capture
little
The
before
third
but
party
at
informatipn by
Solutions
8699132
f429457
6cc2c45bf9
a42.2d
77 645a9
Oca
RICHARD
HIGHLY
September 23 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CUFTh4INS
CONFIDENTIAL
ONLY
321
Page
customers
for
who
that
is
any reason
MS HOUSE
1112
inisatates
were
provider
which
was
MR
II
looking
74
on
15
know
list
it
vendors
21
did
also
it
self
asked
indicated
and
customer
could
that
indicating
as
they
they
were
would
ended
they
situations
of
is
that
anweted
yeah
then
provider
be
include
support
If
number
McDONELL
customers
such
up
you
the
way
they
but
they
go
had
talked
to
at
In
who
least
went
Microsoft
to
as
other
the
of
reports
software
you
familiar
with
am
23
And
24
MS HOUSE
25
Are
one
that
22
1112
third party
provider
reflects
20
It
bhose
for
to
going
Objection
report
third party
of
to
going
third party
at
this
answered
and
designed
customer
if
MR
1112
Arid
WITNESS
in any
on
got
17
of
HOUSE
before
this
asked
primarily TomorrowNow
THE
said
risk
at
MS
12
1112
risk
was
It
McDONELL
at
11
support
right
WrTNESS
that
1.0
Oracle
leaving
Objection
customers
customers
of
testimony
his
THE
1112
risk
at
were
vague
and
what
would
Legal
800
the
Objection
overbroad
Merrill
be
Ycu
can
there
circumstance
calls
for
speculation
answer
Solutions
8699132
f429457
6-cc 2c-45bf-9a42-2d77645a
99c
RICHABD
CUNHINS
September
CONFIDENTIAL
declare
the
under
penalty
23
2008
of
perjury
true
is
_____________
and
correct
Subscribed
this/S_-
foregoing
day
that
at
of
2008
SignaLure
Witness
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
434
Merrill
Legal Solutions
800 869-9132
WENDY
Ioreqorng
deposition
whole
the
me
and
10
11
by
there
said
witness
the
of
13
review
14
requested
15
deponent
16
period
arid
for
before
but
truth
the
taken
the
in
reduced
and
on
comple
to
the
of
the
was
deposit
was
deposition
nor
in
20
this
and
that
21
parties
way
am
the
by
dui ing
of
counsel
of
the
parties
to
the
said
of
am
interested
in
the
event
related
to
any
of
not
thereto
DATEDQCi2
23
24
WENDY
the
not
certify that
any
tori
hereto
appended
any
the
riot
made
reporter
or
of
supervision
the
either
time
ting by
typewsi
to
are
the
at
testimony
chanqes
19
25
the
in
down
person
any
attorney
22
tell
reques ted
18
cause
to
that
direction
my
further
17
and
thereafter
provided
allowed
sworn
was
deposition
transcript
If
the
nothing
stared
in
was
That
and
in
duly
disinterested
under
.omputer
me
by
witness
the
cause
said
shorthand
place
was
truth
withirient.iL1ed
That
that
certify
hereby
Shorthand
Certified
ARLEIl
Reporter
truth
REPORTER
OP
CERTIFIC1\TE
ARLEN
CSR
No
4355
2008
the
or
HIGHLY
RICHARD CUMMINS
September 16 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES ONLY
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
sage
UNITED
STATES
NORTHERN
DISTRICT
CALIFORNIA
OF
FRANCISCO
SAN
COURT
DISTRICT
DIVISION
--00 0-Delaware
CORPORATION
ORACLE USA INC
Corporation
and
Colorado
Corporation
INTERNATIONAL
ORACLE
CORPORATION
California
Corporation
ORACLE
Plaintiffs
No
Vs
EDL
07-CV01658-PJH
AG
German Corporation
Delaware
AMERICA
INC
TOMORROWNOW
INC
CORPORATION
and
DOES
Texas
Corporation
150 Inclusive
SAP
SAP
Defendants
______________________________________________________
VIDEOTAPED
30b
RULE
ORACLE
RICHARD
CUMMINS
September
Tuesday
16
Volume
CONFIDENTIAL
Reported
Job 412495
By
WENDY
Merrill
OF
CORPORATION
Designee
HIGHLY
DEPOSITION
255
Pages
ATTORNEYS
INFORMATION
ARLEN
Legal
800
2008
CSR
4355
EYES
CRR
ONLY
RMR
Solutions
8699132
e6a0856a-Oee4-4b35-al
bf-ca2Oaf8a26bc
HIGHLY
September 16 2008
RICHARD CUMMINS
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
ONLY
74
Page
customer
MR
It
In
In
know
talked
10
interest
11
need
or
Is
the
the-re
11
that
14
communications
customers
With
16
Any
we
months
three
do
their
of
terms
in
general
customer
Yes
tjhhuh
1041
They
about
their
25
in
is
the
the
Do
have
their
on
there
with
official
in
renewals
any
are
reps
communications
Thats
23
24
that
that
recordkeeping
22
ilotes
keep
Beyond
20
just
in
Yeah
17
and
standard recordkeeping
of
to
you
some
is
next
the
very
customer
the
given
customers
with
15
1042
kind
be
there
to
in
supposed
are
reps
and
is
rep
simply
be
could
them
some
Gould
it
talked
with
the
feedback
customer
know
you
back
to
12
1-041
the
to
have
customers
the
its
others
it
the
what
will
it
youve
Does
there
on
with
the
yeah
spreadsheet
the
explains
on
depends
be
could
is
been
sifruaticris
some
detailed
1041
that
have
communications
So
detail
much
narrative
Like
there
sure
MoDONELL
how
described
1O4L
Im
So
kind
OKS
of
to
supposed
maintair
customers
process
is
to
keep
them
015
you
Merrill
Legal
800
access
to
that
OKS
data
Solutions
8699132
eGaOSSSa.0ee44b35.al
bfcaZOafOa26bc
CUMMINS
september 16 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
INFORMATION
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
HIGHLY
ONLY
75
Page
Ido
So
youre
out
terms
be
to
wanted
to
look
Waste
what
would
for
assigned
would
them
conversation
the
there
if
and
you
stood
iii
come
to
you
with
who
rep
license
is
license
rep
you
just
have
they
were
out
that
contact
sales
support
And you mean
Okay
12
is
Cep
well
as
verbal
them
would
1042
What
15
could
16
you
LI
written
do
is
look
at
would
records
The
19
Anything
20
Mow
22
all
to
go
discussed
No
23
Why
Q.
As
24
25
spreadsheet
custotners
we
and
What
records
written
you
sidk
No
21
if
what
if
18
1043
going
and
information would
of
sources
things
was
Management
contact
responsible
1043
where
on
find
status
Management
Waste
to
to
1042
11
with
wanted
you
the
in
apprised
fully
Oracle
If
e2cawple
interested
very
whether
of
back
an
discussions
Oracles
1042
me
give
else
about
information
on
the
database
OKS
riot
said
the
0KB
is
focused
on
existing
existing renewals
Merrill Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
eOaOSS6a.0ee44b35-al
bI.ca2OafBa2Bbc
MR
break
16
September
CUMMINS
CONFIDENTIAL
RICHARD
the
for
Counsel
McDONELL
See
day
next
you
Im
2008
to
then
Thank
you
going
week
sir
This
VIDEOGRAPHER
videotape
Going
four
number
Cummins
1701
off
the
in
the
the
end
depositiOn
of
marks
record
the
time
of
Richard
is
502
--o0o-the
Whereupon
502
declare
the
foregoing
under
is
and
true
_____
California
19
adjourned
at
-o0o-
12
15
was
p.m
10
13
deposition
____________
of
penalty
Subscribed
correct
this
perjury
f.Sdaj
that
at
of
2008
Signature
of
Witness
20
21
22
23
24
25
253
Solutions
Merrill Legal
8699132
800
Errata
Deposition
of Rick
Cummins
Sheet
16 2008
September
Reason
Page
Line
Change
41
21-22
Change Juans
manager
to
responsibility
Juan
is
responsible
is
service
Clarification
delivery
for service
delivery
managers
Change
No
havent
havent
14
124
talked
to
talked
hundreds
to
customers
to
No
Clarification
of customers about
TomorrowNow
Change less
151
23
174
Change
more
to
welcome
176
Change Hutton
207
Change
Change were
22
219
245
14
to
the
Change
above
to
new
IP
to
Oracle
Correction
Hunt
Correction
Correction
Murquia
to
to
renew
does
or
Correction
Correction
doesnt
IT
changes I5ertfy
Signref
726S7826.I
to
Change or doesnt
232
Subject
McGee
to
Correction
that
Correction
the transcript
is
true
and
correct
______
te
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
1
I,
2
WENDY E.
AELEN,
a
3
Reporter,
hereby certify
the witness
in
the
4
foregoing
deposition was by me duly sworn
to
tell
5
truth,
6
within-entitled cause;
the whole
that
Certified Shorthand
truth and
nothing but
That said deposition was
7
8
shorthand by me,
9
and place
therein
10
said witness was
11
computer,
a
the
stated,
and that
thereafter
truth in the
taken down
disinterested person,
the
reduced to
the
at
in
the
time
testimony of the
typewriting,
by
under my direction and supervision.
12
That before completion of
[X I
13
reviei.