Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1201

Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)

EXHIBIT 26

c11
Iii

Sales and Support

23

Blotner July

2008 Depo

function of Oracles

Jones

April

software

Tr

sales

24 2009 Depo Tr

renewals/sales

at

at

function of Oracles

the

function

of Oracles

support

at

15210-15

describing

the function of Oracles

team

support

sales

at

2716-23

renewals/sales

2009 Depo Tr

function of Oracles

SVI-108747v1

describing the

team

renewals/sales

Aug

testimony

organization

253-20 describing

Cummins Sept 16 2008 Depo Tr

Duggan

30b6

1119-122 Rule

Van Boening Sept 10 2009 Depo Tr
support

Foundation

at

2316-24

representatives

Rule

30b6

testimony

describing the

team
Rule

30b6

testimony

describing the

BLOTNER

RICHARD

STATES

NORTHERN

DISTRICT

DISTRICT

OF

FRANCISCO

SAN

23

2008

CONFIDENTIAL

HIGHLY

UNITED

July

COURT

CALIFORNIA

DIVISION

-oOoORACLE CORPORATION
Delaware
ORACLE
corporation
Colorado
USA INC
and ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California corporation
Plaintiffs

No

vs
SAP

AG

SAP

AMERICA

German

07CVl658PJH

corporation
Delaware

INC

TOMORROWNOW
corporation
INC
Texas corporation
DOES
1-50 inclusive

and

Defendants

DEPOSITION
RICHARD

Wednesday
CONTAINS

REPORTED

BY

HIGHLY

CYNTHIA

OF

BLOTNER

July

23

2008

MATERIAL

CONFIDENTIAL

PACINI

CSR

6117

RMR

CRR

01411414

Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132
Cfl4

44C0

O.

nfl...flaefl

BLOTNER

RICHARD

July
CONFIDENTIAL

HIGHLY

23

2008

II

Page

to

take

out

flight

afternoon

Yes

400

oclock

flight

Okay
do

So

canTt

guarantee

to

my best

well try
try and

this

correct

that

is

Francisco

San

of

to

make

to

try

but

will

And

happens
that

so

we

can

that

accomplish
Are you

that

short

breaks

the

keep

sure

it

Oracle

an

employee

lam

Yes
10

How

11

Thirteen

12

What

is

13

Vice

president

sales

American

of

15

president

17

you

and two

years

current

your

Let me make

15

been

by Oracle

operations

14

have

long

of

months

have

North

for

at

position

operations

sure

operations

employed

it

Oracle

for North

its

So

American

vice

sales

operations

lB

Correct

19

Okay

20

refer

to

21

Sales
Sales

22

support

23

things

24

services

25

What

and
such

licenses

organization

also

our

you

Merrill

portion

of

that

what

education

referred to
When

sales

software

of

this
as

of

the

does

say

as

this

Legal

800

On

and

sells

services

firstyear
other

our hosting

Demand
organization

Solutions

8699132

what

are

BLOTNER

RICHARD

HIGHLY

23

Juiy
CONFIDENTIAL

2008

12

Page

you

to

referring

Which

Okay
sales

Anerican

want

topics

is

that

Mr

notice

12

structure

13

groups

and/or

14

for the

following

of

and

and

and

21

limited nature

22

Mr

23

is

Blotner

25

he

areas

addition

thats

if

PeopleSoft

been

you

what

Merrill

objections
we

the

of

and
and

also
JD

Day

responses

speak on

to

in

the

about
That

deposition

prepared

and

clarification

got

from Jones

this

is

what

and that

on

will speak
So

the

provided

of

has

responsible

lines

letter

2008

July 9th

departments

sales

product

The

reads

Oracle

at

first

lines

we

20

24

as

the

in

Edwards

JD

in

1d

functions

related to

And

J8

the

units

business

Edwards product

all

is

two

offered

being

and

of

organization

licensing

that

This

Theres

Oracle which

to

deposition

Peoplesoft

to

is

1a

are

topics

11

17

narrow

time

to

here

objection

Blotner

as

Vague

witness
The

16

North

the

cover

an

very

organization

does

Objection

interpose

which

for

30b

HOUSE

to

deposition

products

organization

MS
And

sales

Anerican

North

The

want

hes

to

him about

providing

Legal

800

ask

testimony

Solutions

8699132

just

on

those

BLOR

RICRD

HIGHLY

declare
the

foregoing

is

under

true

and

fMtt5c
of

____________

23

July
CONFIDENTThL

penalty

correct

of

2008

perjury

that

Subscribed

California

this

23

at

day

2008

RICHARD

BLOTNER

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21
22

23

24

25

149

Merrill Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

Lg.L

Mrrili

FOR READING/CORRECTING

INSTRUCTIONS

To

assist

directions

in

you

back

pages to the

This

is

Please
insert

the

additional

If

it

you

are

in

necessary

your deposition

carefully

If

you

on the errata

possession

testimony

please

furnish

please

follow

the

them and

attach

find

wish to

make

transcript

any errors or changes

sheet beside

the page

and

do

of the original transcript

you

line

numbers

NOT make

any changes

on the transcript

After
the

completing

any of the questions

your review

designated Signature

please

line

and

sign
return

ERRATA

Page

YOUR DEPOSITION

sheet

of

Do NOT change

above

your deposition
are

version

final

read

to

pages

the errata

of

the corrections

If
directly

corrections

making

below

Sotuti0n8

the

last

page

of the

errata

sheet

the transcript to your attorney

SHEET

Line

Change_________________________________
Reason____________________________________

Change
Reason_______________________________________

Change

/Reason____________________________________

the

Page

Line

Change
Reason

/1

Change
Reason

Change

Reason

Change
Reason

Change
Reason

Change

Reason

Change
Reason

________ Subject

to

No changes

signature

the

above

have

changes

certify

that

the transcript

made

certify

that

the transcript

been

is

is

true

and

correct

true

and

correct

___

date

OF REPORTER

CERTIFICATE

Reporter

hereby

foregoing

deposition

the

truth

withinentitled

place

therein

10

witness

was

11

computer

said

me

by

and

in

sworn

duly

but

the

to

tell the

the

and

under

before

13

review

14

If

15

provided

to

16

appended

that

truth

down
at

person

in the

in

to

typewriting

and
said

by

supervision
of

completion

the

of

testimony

and

time

the

the

reduced

direction

my

taken

was

disinterested

thereafter

the

requested

transcript
any

the

changes

reporter

further

17

for

either

or any

attorney

19

deposition

nor

in

20

this cause

and

that

21

parties

25

made

any

way

by

during

certify

18

22

was

deposition

that
of

the

was

not

requested

hereto

of

the

witness

nothing

deposition

stated

That

12

by me

was

truth

the

Shorthand

cause

That
shorthand

that

certify

whole

Certified

PACINI

CYNTHIA

the

the

period

allowed

are

am not

of

counsel

parties

to

the

interested

am not

and

deponent

said

in

the

event

to

any

of

PACINI

CSR

No

related

of

the

thereto
DATED

CYNT

IA

6117

or

JUAN
HIGHLY

April 24
ATTORNEYST

JONES

CONFIDENTIAL

2009
EYES

ONLY

Page
STATES

UNITED
NORTHERN

DISTRICT

DISTRICT

OF

FRANCISCO

SAN

COURT

CALIFORNIA

DIVISION

ORACLE CORPORATION
Delaware
ORACLE
corporation
Colorado
INC
USA
and ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California corporation
Plaintiffs

vs
SAP

AG

07CVl658

No

PJH

German

SAP
corporation
Delaware
INC

AMERICA

corporation
TOMORROWNOW
Texas corporation
INC
and DOES 150
inclusive
Defendants

_____________/

Deposition
JUAN

of

JONES

Friday April 24

HIGHLY

REPORTED

BY

ATTORNEYS

CONFIDENTIAL

JOHN

WISSENBACH

CLR

CSR

RMR

EYES

CRR

Solutions

8699132

ONLY

CBC

01-418986

6862

Merrill Legal

800

2009

JONES
JUAN
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

24

April

2009

ATTORNEYS

ONLY

EYES

25

Page
093712

cu5tomer service

the

to

respect

O9371

Ian

Plmmuer

093726

Can

you

piece

093728

specifically

093732

the

renewal

C93740

the

093746

with

093750

get

renewal

of

involved

093754

10

directly

09375S

11

appropriate

in

to

inc

also

093803

13

customers

to

ensure

O9307

14

the

value

of

lot

support

D93810

that

we

in

have

that

16

theyre

realizing that

093819

17

talking

to

093827

may have
19

093831

for

working

those

dont have

that

regard

093835

21

993839

22

ccnimtrnicatiors

093843

23

you

093846

24

MS

HQUS-E

093849

25

THE

WITNESS

Merrill

800

when

you
is

documenting

those

Objector
You

know

Solutions

8699132

of

ensure
time

they

remediation

proactive

to

issues

customers

with

Legal

be

all

incidents

or

provide
to

to

elements

spend

also

plans

they

for

and

to

that

follow

offer

issues

In

ensure

talking

service

value

on

working

or

is

receiving

are

plans

on

customers

tine

about

customers

know

You

the

of

service

our

base

when it

of

they

all

093915

093823

contracts

so

do

spend

for

responsible

with

my team

of

support
for

093O0

Im

we

customer

our

with

connection

function

conversations

in

more

aupport maintenance

cur

-across

our

bit

in

do

you

sales

ensure

Okay

little

me

what

then

support

093734

tell

have

these

there

practice

communications
overbroad
think

its

we

JUAN
HIGHLY

449

JONES

CONFIDTIA1

April

24

ATTOYS

2009
EYES ONLY

p.m

declare
foregoing

is

true

_______________
ll\Ac.y

under
and

of perjury that

penalty

correct

Subscribed
this

California

5day

the

at
of

2009

9gnature

of

twitness

.10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

218
Merri.ll

Legal Solutions
869-9132

800

Merrill Legal Solutions

To

assist

you

attach

below

the pages

to

Please read your transcript

make

insert

and the

the changes

number

line

Please do not make

Please do

After

designated
Main

and/or

reference

your

Street

back of the

you

If

errata

on

any

your

deposition testimony
please furnish

are necessary

sheet

or changes

errors

the errata

sheet

the change you wish

br

and

pages

find

corrections

to

DEPOSITION

corrections

to

by

you wish

listing

the

page

make

on the face of the

transcript

please sign

and

the

return

the

last

Errata

CA 94105

Floor San Francisco

page of the
sheets to

or fax

them

errata

Merrill
to

sheet

above the

Legal Solutions

415

357.4301

ERRATA SHEET

Page

to

of the questions

review
line

corrections

additional

and then

any changes

Signature
4th

the

br

If

carefully

NOT change any

completing

and

making changes

the directions

please follow

them and

in

YOUR

FOR READING/CORRECTING

INSTRUCTIONS

Line

Chane
Reason_______________________________________

Change
Reason_______________________________________

Change
Reason_______________________________________

at

135

Page

Line

Change
Reason________________________________________

Change
Reason__________________________________________

Change
Reason__________________________________________

Change
Reason__________________________________________

Change
Reason________________________________________

Change
ReasOn__________________________________________

Change
Reason________________________________________

_________

Subject

to

No changes

the above

have

changes

been

made

certify that

the transcript

is

true and correct

that

the transcript

is

true

certify

and correct

c/ic/oi
dates

ature

deposition

truth

truth

in

by me

That

said

the

sworn

to

tell

taken

was

deposition

by

and

place

therein

10

the

said

11

typewriting

12

in

down

disinterested person

me

shorthand

the

nothing but

cause

within-entitled

the

in

duly

and

truth

whole

the

was

Shorthand

witness

the

that

certify

Reporter hereby

the

Certified

WISSENBACH

JOHN

foregoing

REPORTER

OF

CERTIFICATE

the

at

time

supervision

witness

That

13

the

of

14

review

15

requested

16

deponent

17

period

was

requested
provided

allowed

are

further

19

or

20

said

21

event

22

any

attorney

of

of

this

the

cause

patties

in

and

the

deposition

was

fI

not

made

the

by

the

to

or

direction and

changes

reporter during

the

hereto
that

certify

deposition nor

was

my

any

appended

for either

to

of

completion
fIX

of

testimony

reduced

thereafter

transcript

the

that

computer under

before

If

and

18

23

by

stated and

any

any

of

way

that

am
the

not

patties

not

to

the

in

the

related

to

interested
am

counsel

of

thereto

DATED

24

CSR

25

No

6862

JOH/WISSENBACH
219

MICHAEL VAN BOENING
HIGHLY
CONFIDENTIAL

10

September

ATTORNEYS

2009

EYES

ONLY

Page
STATES

UNITED
NORTHERN

DISTRICT

DISTRICT
FRANCISCO

SAN

OF

COURT

CALIFORNIA

DIVISION

ORACLE
CORPORATION
ORACLE
Delaware
corporation
Colorado
USA
INC
and ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
California

CORPORATION

corporation
Plaintiffs

No

vs
SAP

AG

SAP

AMERICA

German

07CVl658

PJH

corporation
Delaware

INC

TOMORROWNOW
corporation
Texas corporation
INC
DOES 150 inclusive

and

Defendants

VIDEOTAPED

DEPOSITION

MICHAEL

REPORTED

BY

10

ATTORNEYS

CONFIDENTIAL
HOLLY

BOENING

SEPTEMBER

THURSDAY

HIGHLY

VAN

OF

THUMAN

CSR

No

2009

EYES

6834

ONLY

RMR

CRR

1421903

Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132
cflOn._fl

fltfl.

Afl..fl

SA.

4.flfl.....7flfl

MICHAEL
HIGHLY

VAN

BOENING

10

September

EYES

ATTORNEYS

CONFIDENTIAL

2009
ONLY
152

Page
124701

sign

them

1Z47O3

Does

Okay

124710

tar

compensation

124714

mean across

124718

sales

and

all

MR ALINDER

124721

124726

wouldrt

WITNESS

THE

1247i.1

if

for my group

MR

CSlls

cbjectitn

for

foundation

lacks

speculation

by all

license

across

and

lines

the

sales

support

124720

And

associates

sales

product

describe

document

that

that

to

applies

124731

iP

124731

11

124733

12

13

Does

124736

14

1-24741

15

124742

16

1247 46

1-7

12474g

18

19

Okay

124752

20

124754

21-

22

Okay

Would

124801

23

for

license

124.005

24

124S07

25

referring

to

Yes

124755

sales

Yes

124750

license

your

that

as

groip

have

support

that

support

it

selling

for

support

all

include

product

lines

services
that

believe
Would

sales

renewal

group

you

than

other

Yes

124723

Me

DELAHUNTY

know

to

for

include

services

And

for

the

be

for

case
associates

example

databases

Oracle

example

support

services

Grade tujddleware

structure

it

sales

wOuldYt
Okay

Merrill

To

Legal

800

include

knowledge

Solutions

8699132

compensation

associates

wouldnt
your

the

know

its

that
just

for

Legal Solutions

Merrill

FOR READING/CORRECTING

INSTRUCTIONS

To aslst you

in

making

and

below

attach the pages

Please read your
make1
and

insort

the

please

line

do

Please do

After

to

for

and/or

If

NOT

change

any

and /ot

find

any

errors

the

errata

corrections

testimony

deposition

please

ltrnlsh

sheet

errata

number reference and then the change
make any changes

your

are necessary

on

you

corrections

you wish to
the page

or changes
sheet

you wish

to

by

listing

make and the reason

on the face of the

transcript

of the questions

above
of the errata sheet
please sign the last page
your review
sheets to Merrill legal Solutions
the Errata
line and return
Signature

the

completing

Street

Floor San

Rancisco

CA 94105

Errata

Page

pgs

of the

the back

to

corrections

ifaddition

careftily

transcript

the changes

not

designated
Main

and

dianges

follow

please

YOUR DEPOSITION

Line

Change
Reason
Change
Reason
Change
Reason

or

sheet

fa them

to

415

357.4301

at

135

Page

Line

Change

easom____________________

_________

Reason
Change

Cbange___________________________________
Reasan
Change

Reason______________________________
Change________________________________________
Reason____________________________________________

thange________________________________________
Reason____________________________________________

Change_______________________________________
Reason_______________________________________

Subject

_______ No

to

changes

tte above

have

thanges

certify

that

the

transcript

made

certify

that the

transcript

been

true

is

arid

corect

true

and

correctS

Reporter

hereby

foregoing

deposition

truth

the

cause

me

by

tere.in

under

That

11

review

13

If

14

provided

to

15

appended

the

but

completion

of

the

taken

person at the
the
to

reduced
and

in

truth
was

deositio

my direction

before

12

testimony

of

t.yp.ritiflg

supervision
the

was

deposition

was

not

requested

hereto

of

the

tell the

that

witess was thereafter

computer

to

stated

place

by

sworn

disinterested

the
10

the

duly

said

that

time and
said

in

truth and nothing

whol..e

shorthand

in

by me

was

Shorthand

witness

the

that

certify

within-entitled
down

Certified

TRUMAN

HOLLY

requested

transcript
any

the

changes

reporter

further

16

attorney

18

deposition

19

thIs

20

parties

am not

of

counsel

to

the

any

of

any

way

interested

in

and

that

am not

re

allowed

parties

that.I
the

and

deponent

the period

or

nor

cause

the

by

during

certify

for either

17

made

related

or

said

in

the

event

to

any

of

of

the

thereto

DATED

25

HOLLY

THUMAN CSR No. 6834

CUMMINS
September 16 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION

RICHARD
HIGHLY

ONLY

Page
UNITED
NORTHERN
SAN

DISTRICT

STATES

CALIFORNIA

OF

DISTRICT
FRANCISCO

COURT

DIVISION

--OOoORACLE

Delaware

CORPORATION

INC
ORACLE
USA
Corporation
and
Colorado Corporation
ORACLE
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California Corporation
Plaintiffs

No

Vs
SAP

AG

SAP

AMERICA

German

EDL

07-CV-01658PJH

Corporation
Delaware

INC

INC
CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
Texas Corporation and DOES
150

Inclusive

Defendants
____________________________________________________/

VIDEOTAPED

RULE
ORACLE

30b

DEPOSITION

CORPORATION

Designee

RICHARD

Tuesday

September

Volume
HIGHLY

CONFIDENTIAL

Reported By
Job
412495

CUMMINS

16

ARLEN

Merrill Legal

800

2008
255

Pages

ATTORNEYS

INFORMATION

WENDY

OF

CSR

4355

CRR

Solutions

8699132

EYES

RMR

ONLY

HIGHLY

2008
ONLY

EYES

ATTORNEYS

INFOATION

CONFIDENTIAL

16

September

CUL4NINS

RICHARD

21

Page

MR
hasnt
since

MODONELL
in

changed

What

responsibilities
responsibilities

Esurin

1.0

11

in

my

And

12

how

15

looking

Give

17

The

do

renew

support

that

custothers

blur

are

that

do

you

details

the

me

htt

do

you

want

process

or

what

are

process
of

the

general

me
you

contacted

regarding

19

time

frame

20

that

we

21

their contract

22

contracts

23

those

We

work

then

and

if

questions

cc

customers

for

their renewal

purchase

get

please

outline

outline is that

general

IS

25

of

for

16

with

order

the

before

the

upcoming

customer
the

are

ensure

to

date

start

there are

services

on

any questions

about

the

we

of

answer

questions
Do

24

base

renewals

whole

the

through

go

your

base

your

director

we

support

There7
14

are

about

changed

AmErica
that

for

space

talk

senior

as

fot Notth

renewals

O9t5

lets

Then

Okay

0936

about

mistaken

responsibilities havent

My base

0936

job

your

that

0935

O53

Am

Oracle

at

said

you

your responsibilities

of

terms

been

youve

thought

deal

you

directly

with

customers

in

your

job

Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

..e.VtQeC_

n-A

4C a-

CUMMINS

RICHARD

MR
break

for

MCDONELL

the

16

September
CONFIDENTIAL

See

day

Im

Counsel

to

then

Thank

you

going

week

next

you

2008

sir
This

VIDEOGRAPHER
1701

videotape

number

Cummins

Going

four
off

the

in

the

the

marks

end

deposition

record

the

time

of

of

Richard

is

502

-o0o-the

Whereupon

502

deposition

was

adjourned

at

p.m

10

11

declare

12

13

14

15

the

foregoing

under

iue

and

.Calia

penalty of perjury

correct
this

Subscribed

/Sday

that
at

of

__

2008

Signature

19

of

Witness

20

21

22

23

24

25

253
Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

Errata Sheet

Deposition

of Rick

Cummins

Page

Line

21-22

Change

Reason

Change

41

16 2008

September

Juans

manager

to

responsibility

Juan

is

responsible

is

service

delivery

for service

Clarification

delivery

managers
14

124

Change

No

havent

havent talked

to

talked

hundreds

to

customers

of customers

to

No

Clarification

about

TomorrowNow
Change less

151

to

more

Change

welcome

176

Change

Hutton

207

Change

McGee

Change

were

Change

or doesnt

Change

IP

174

23

22

219

232

14

245

Subject

to

the

above

changes

Signre/2

7267826

to

to

to

Correction

Oracle

Correction

Hunt

Correction

Murquia

Correction

new to renew

to

Ierfky

to

does

or

Correction

doesnt

Correction

IT

that

Correction

the transcript

is

true

and

correct

//

te

CERTIFICATE

was

deposition
whole

the

truth

within-entitled
That

said

and

therein

deposition

was

stated

and

11

computer under my direction

the

of

13

review

14

requested

15

deponent

16

period

and

for

down

the

in

the

the

of

not

made

the

deposition

nor

in

20

this

and

that

21

parties

any

way
am

by

that
of

the

am

not

parties

of

counsel

to

the

said
of

interested

in

the

event

related

to

any

of

not

thereto

cic

DATED

2008

23

24

WENDY

the

hereto

certify
any

by

deposition
was

was

appended

or

the

supervision

reporter during

either

of

typewriting

to

the

are

time

testimony

to

19

25

the

in

the

at

changes

attorney

22

taken

any

18

cause

truth

the

requested

further

17

but

that

before completion

provided

allowed

tell

was

and

transcript

If

to

reduced

thereafter

said

That

sworn

duly

nothing

10

12

the

disinterested person

me

by

witness

and

in

cause

shorthand
place

me

by

Shorthand

witness

the

certify that

Reporter hereby

truth

Certified

ARLEN

WENDY

foregoing

REPORTER

OF

AREN

CSR

No

4355

the

or

DUGGAN

PAUL
HIGHLY

2009

August

EYES

ATTORNEYS

CON Fl DENT IAL

ONLY

Page
IN

THE

UNITED

DISTRICT

STATES

DISTRICT

NORTHERN

OF

FRANCISCO

SAN

COURT

CALIFORNIA

DIVISION

--oOo
ORACLE
CORPORATION
Delaware
ORACLE
corporation
Colorado
INC
USA
and ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California corporation
Plaintiffs

07CV-1658

vs
SAP

AG

SAP

AMERICA

German

PJH

corporation
Delaware

INC

TOMORROWNOW
corporation
Texas corporation
INC
DOES
150 inclusive

and

Defendants

VIDEOTAPED

DEPOSITION

REPORTED

BY

ATTORNEYS

CONFIDENTIAL

SARAH

Merrill

LUCIA

BRANN

Legal

800

PAUL

DUGGAN

2009

August

HIGHLY

OF

CSR

EYES

3887

ONLY

421893

Solutions

8699132
snajan

a.J0

AASfl

LS

aIAza..aeeae

DUGGAN

PAUL
HIGHLY

2009

August

EYES

ATTORNEYS

CONFIDENTIAL

ONLY

23

Page
094905

Can

094906

methodology

MR

ALINDER

Objectich

094915

THE

WITNESS

Can

094916

MR

DELAHCJNT

094901

0913

ih

forecasts

those

of

creating one

the

describe

you

Vaue

ambiguous

04920

arid

0949

these

service

support

094929
10

forecasting

.094938

11

percentage

094945

use

to

close
the

in

track

our

and

date
OKS

create

track

like1ihod

system

of

one

which

the
terms

in

the

is

renewals

support

managers

to

refer

you

the

do

representatives will

The

094B34

How

representatives

that

forecasts

that

clarify

you

system

there

094947

13

typically verbal

conversations

094-950

14

the

and

the

directors

095003

15

those

in

our

095004

16

do

those

095006

17

responsible

095009

in

forecasts

095012

19

20

are

sale

095014

we

standard reporting

095019

managers
numbers
Flow

for

The

forecasts

cases

the

C9021

22

with

that

095025

23

from

quotation

095031

24

to

manager

customer
to

and

record

Is

Merrill

Legal

800

would

of

in

be

tracking

the

of

Solutions

8699132

of

the

closing

and

constant
sales

with the

those

and

are

purchase order
created

rollup

representative

communications

eventually getting

on

reps

creating

or

likelihood

sales

support

based

the

individuals who

determine the

soMe

25

those

between

of

in

contact

cycle
customer

PAUL
HIGHLY

113457

DUGGAN

EYES

ATTORNEYS

Whereupon
concluded

113457

2009

August

CONPIDENTI2%L

the
at

deposition

ONLY

was

a.m

1124

cOo

113457
declare

113457

under

foregoing is true and

113457
113457

5Pri
of

CO

frUGrUS

penalty

correct

of perjury

Subscribed

California

the

at

this

day

2009
_______

Paul Duggan
10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

80

Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

Legal Sokdious

MrriU

To

assist

please

them and

Please

make

you

follow

in

making changes

the pages

read your transcript
insert

and the

line

the changes

do not make

Please

do NOT change

completing

any

Street

4th

any

of

your review

designated Signature
Main

changes

line

Floor San

you

find

testimony

your deposition
are necessary

any

please

furnish

br corrections

you wish

or changes

errors

sheet by

errata

then the change you

and

DEPOSITION

sheet

on the

corrections

wish to

on the face

listing

to

the page

make
the transcript

of

the questions

please sign

and

return

the last page of the errata

the Errata

sheets to

Frandsco CA 94105 or

ERRATA

Page

to

pages

of the errata

If

carefully

and/or

corrections

additional

If

the back

number reference and

Please

After

to

br

and

below

the directions

attach

YOUR

FOR READING/CORRECTING

INSTRUCTIONS

fax

them

Merrill

to

sheet above the

Legal

415

Solutions

at

135

357.4301

SHEET

Line

Change
Reason

N1-2J.E-1
.C-t--

1Th

.s-17Z
IN

Ar iaS

change

Reason_______________________________________

changeU
Reason

tSr 2.C/03

54-

ag

Page

Une

Lk

change

-f po

Reason

ELI

Reason

rS

rF

Change

1ThPo

Change

Reason

Change

Reason

Change

Reason

Change
Reason

Change

Reason

Subject to the above

________ No changes

signature

have

changes

been

made

certify that

the transcript

is

true

and correct

certify that

the transcript

is

true

and correct

date

OF REPORTER

CERTIFICATE
LUCIA

SARAH
hereby

foregoing

deposition
whole

the

truth

said

That

place

me

by

10

witness

was

11

computer

and

the

tell

the

truth

in

the

time

and

the

said

the

before

13

review

reduced

14

If

15

provided

to

16

appended

in

down
at

person

the

the

testimony

to

of

typewriting

and

by

supervision
of

completion

deposition

the

was

any
the

changes

that

or any of

for either

attorney

19

deposition

nor

in

20

this

and

that

21

parties

any

by

during

certify

18

cause

made

reporter

further

17

was

requested

not

hereto

requested

transcript

taken

was

that

direction

my

That
of

but

nothing

the

to

sworn

duly

disinterested

thereafter

under

12

and

rue

deposition

stated

therein

by

in

witness

cause

within-entitled

shorthand

was

truth

the

that

certify

Reporter

Shorthand

Certified

BRANN

way

the

the

the

period

allowed

are

am not

of

counsel

parties

to

the

interested

am not

and

deponent

related

said

event

in

the

to

any of

of

the

thereto
DATED

c9A 3Z0O

24

25

SARAH

LUCIA

BRANN

CSR

No

3887

or