Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al
Filing
1201
Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)
EXHIBIT 8
Foundation
A-5997
for
Defendants
Joint
Pretrial
A-5997
Trial Exhibit
Statement
Undisputed
facts
Foundational Support
section
identifying
Jeff Henley as Oracles
chairman of the board
0RCL00034267
Oracle
identifying Jeff Henley as Oracles
organizational
chart
organizational
chart identifying Craig Tate
chairman of the board
ORCLOO1
group
Oracles
Nov
2010
Trial
July
23
GyP
GVP
Tr
at
78110-14
Larry Ellison
testifying
that
Mr
Henley
is
A-64
Oracle
2008
Depo Tr
1184-5 Rule
30b6
testimony
indicating
that
at
stands for group vice president
production
North Central Applications
SVI-108747v1
Oracle
chairman of the board
Oracle
11
as
vice president
Ellison
Blotner
60564 Oracle
document
in
2006
listing
located
Craig Tate
at
as
Oracle
0RCL00747255
Group
Vice President
FiIedO4/26/12
Documentll4l
Case407-cv-01658-PJH
McCUTCHEN LLP
PICKEYF SBN 72257
DONN
GEOFFREY
HOWARD SBN
BREE HANN SBN 215695
JONES DAY
BINGI-IAM
157468
MInELSTAEDT
ROBERT
584
JASON McDONELL
SBN 115084
ELAINE WALLACE
SBN I97R82
555
California
San
Francisco
Telephone
CA 94111-4067
415 393-2000
Facsimile
415
Facsimile
Three
San
Embarcadero
Center
Francisco
393-2286
26th
Street
CA
415
415
Telephone
626-3939
875-5700
bree.hannbingham.com
ewaLlace@jonesday.com
FLEXNER LLP
BOlES SCHILLER
DAVID BOLES Admitted Pro Hac Vice
JONES DAY
333
Main
ThARAN GREGORY LANLER SBN
FROYD SBN 220776
J4E
Street
NY 10504
TeLephone 914 749-8200
dboies@bstlip.com
Facsimile
14
IS
Harrison
St.
SBN
144177
CA 94612
Telephone 510 874-1000
jfroyd@jonesday.com
JONES DAY
shoItzman@bsfllp.com
DORLAN DALEY SBN
JENNIFER
GLOSS SBN
500 Oracle
Paway MIS
Redwood City CA 94070
Telephone
COWAN
SCOTF
JOSHUA
129049
717
154227
57
Suite
TX
Pro Hoc
Admitted
Pro Hac
Vice
Vice
3300
77002
832
832
Telephone
Facsimile
650.506.4846
Admitted
FUCHS
Texas
Houston
239-3939
239-3600
swcowan@jonesday.com
650.506.7114
dorian.daleyorac1e.com
glossoracle.com
Jennifer
17
is
739-3939
739-3900
tglarnerjonesday.com
900
Suite
Oakland
Facsimile
16
HOLTZMAN
94303
650
650
Telephone
STEVEN
1999
L3
CA
Alto
Palo
138784
Road
Embarcadero
1755
Armonlc
12
Floor
94104
jmcdonell@jonesday.com
geoff.howardbingham.com
11
060359
ramittelstaedtjonesday.com
donn.pickettbinghamcom
10
133
of
Pagel
Attorneys
Attorneys
Oracle
SAP
for Plaintiff
International
AG
for
SAP America Inc
TomorrowNow
and
Inc
Corporation
19
NORTHERN
20
DISTRICT
OAKLAND
21
et
COURT
STATES DISTRICT
UNITED
ORACLE USA
Defendants
at
OF CALIFORNIA
DIVISION
Case
No
07-C V01658
Pill
EDL
22
JOINT PRETRIAL
Plaintiffs
STATEMENT
23
Date
SAP
AG
25
Time
Defendants
3rd
Judge
at
May 24 2012
230 pm
Place
IA
lIon
Floor
Courtroom
Phyllis
Hamilton
26
27
28
SVI-
Casc
107234v
JOINT
PRETRIAL STATEMENT
No
07-CV-01658
PJH
EDL
Case407-cv-01658-PJH
FiIedO4/26/12
Documentll4l
99
Charles
lOU
Safra
Catz
01
Safra
Catz was the Chief Financial
was
Phillips
Jeff
Henley
103
On
or about
Board
the
this
held
has held
and
2004
2010
to
2004
since
position
from 2005
of Oracle
Officer
Chairman of
Oracies
is
has
133
in
from some Lime
Oracle
of
of Oracle and
the President
is
102
the Co-President
of
Pagel3
2008
to
this position
since
2004
information
with
the
with
That
document
10
was
made
11
information
12
regularly
13
as
at
15
16
the
17
document
at
20
regularly
21
as
or near
24
connection
25
PJF
26
business
27
therein
28
kept
No
true
of those
made by
the
SAP
matters
of fmancial
connection
EDL
PJF
business
record
by
forth therein
set
business
that
from
or
in the course
kept
conducted
regularly
in
07-C V-U 1658
of an
copy
of the matters
knowledge
and
Customer Report.xls
eta. Case
is
report
of
activity
July
15 2009
Defendants
name -SAP Customer Report
file
USA
Inc
et
SAP
at
is
of the occurrence
by
with
person
activity
et
July
2009
at
Case
No
true
AG
SAP-0R00789887
copy
of an
of the matters
knowledge
set
of those
made by
and
customer
produced
in connection
lipdate.xls
07-CV-01
SAP
forth
the regularly
658
record
by
therein
or
in
kept
conducted
with
EDL
PJF
business
matters
of financial
report
That
was
that
from
the course
business
of
activity
practice
On
with
or
with
the
from
SAP
USA
information
made
at
transmitted
et
au
SAPAG
the time
by
JOINT
activity
PRETRRL
el
is
at
true
with
and
knowledge
No
copy
07-C V-01 658
of the matters
of those
made by
in
of an SAP
the
Caj No
STATEMENT
of
report
0-30-09.xls
Case
of the occurrence
person
business
1587
13
SVI-th7234v
customer
produced
Customer Report Updated
SAP-OR0084
or near
conducted
Defendants
Inc
bates-stamped
was
of regularly
2009
name
file
Oracle
Litigation
document
that
in the course
November
or about
the
That
record
by
with
activity
business
information
EDL
15
of the occurrence
person
the time
conducted
105
financial
the
transmitted
regular
23
time
by
bates-stamped
information
22
the
or about
Oracle
litigation
19
AG
SAP
at
SAP-0R006036
business
On
with
made
ci
5SAP
0060361
customer
produced
practice
information
IS
or near
conducted
104
14
Inc
bates-stamped
transmitted
regular
USA
Oracle
the litigation
SAP-OR
name
file
Defendants
2009
January
set
forth
matters
regularly
O7-CV-01655
PJH
EOL
Organization
Chart
ORACLE
Page
Aria
of
People Search
CEO
______ _____
DhocItll
I9Od
GPO
r..d
5540
Totul
Law..n
LV
_________________
______
.S UL
x.ahU1
AsSMt
Ofac
Pr.
DftheCEOatId
Totat
s. pEssa
AsS1
Exosdv
of
Totat
TO$at68602
tha
CEO
and
_____________
O4ce
Pr
Corndtg
_______
Totsi
33235
S4
fl
ToS
13505
_______________
Ca
Tolal
kda
Saoq
ViCe
eSdtt
463
16712
Highly
Confidential
nfomation
Attorneys
Eyes Only
ORCL00034237
NA Commercial Apps Organization
ERP North Central MidSize Co
Tn
fl
us h2Ji
Sr
MUAi
sh
Oil
Ted
IIl
RWO1
MIt
cI_
Co
________________________________________________________________________________
NC
PM.Psa
NC
WSSbhCnRtuEza
NC
u0il
Slabla
L11
l.n
Asia
Co
Its
Juu
MM
ml5iie
Jj4eI
htzat
CIS.JA1
MSS
JDEE
In
ASIA
Mr
PMrrtd
Co
Ml
ThuZ
al Midoa
JOlNO
SLuwS
Proprietary
and
lii
McS
ASia
lAS
Ca
ASIA
Coins
MlaS
IAN
Mt
ASia
NO
Cinga
Lii
1U
MM
SuSj
Sal
Cetts
MN
Co
Oncl
Silt
CII
Co
NswCI
Oil
Ocaw
Ii
A@AL2
PI
CoIixitt
Mid
flflW
iAI
CIn.S
IL
CsjlTs
Ca
C4tigc.d
Toni
Ci
Snc
uSii
Asi
N.tNaqOtlge
Nil
Co
Ca
Crfr.ifl
Cuani
OH
J.ffSMn
TDI
MM IMs
Kids
Wi
Clik.qo
Ctd
iDj
IS
IAhiu.$i
________________
MiTi
eTwr
ftM
LIIdSJz
Co
NaqMIik.e
StIjitt
CJrlno.L
MM
Oi.mS
Las
Ci
St
MM MS2a
Nil
icW
bM
froae
Ca
1li
Ea
CSimjl
RsciN4
Mui
Co
Sz4
Ca
IL
Othigo
SIS.
Cued
MM
Co
fl
Co
tO
I4oMI..Th
06/20/2008
Confidential
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
tdSe
ASia
Srcdisi
MM ias
Co
sPdSsNott
Auetn
LMdS
DdTM
Oracle
Uiy
MM M6I
Co
InsLa
OiOol
SI
a.t
JaM
sum
SM
Mi
Ca
o.o
in
il Nil
Ca
i1
EflhJOIjS.S
dLMO
ed.fl.are
5erb
MMMSI.Ca
Pg Sll CSao
MIIn.
sd
JoJii
AsiA
.aLa
dwOaINl
M.CO
qr
MMMpdS.CCCa4XeI
Ciwago
Co
NC
ke%io
Rile
a.drey
WiE
1W
MCCI
L.
A5MISaC
Si
Mirnellois
MdIe
RM
NC
Prod4CedJi
0jo-L
MNflhSgeCo.Sr
NM N.N5
aalr
ce$
aft
Ca
Jat 8ol
SrÆthw
AI
NC
MuraeepotWi
MsC
Save
MaC@
AUORNEYS
EVES ONLY
MM
ClaMS
MbmpcS
CIoIL
RALCLE
12
0RCL00160564
UNITED
STATES
NORTHERN
BEFORE
THE
ORACLE
CORPORATION
HONORABLE
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
PHYLLIS
FT
OF
CALIFORNIA
HANILTON
AL
JURY
JUDGE
TRIAL
NO
PLAINTIFFS
VS
SAP
COURT
07-01658
PJH
VOLURE
AG
ET
AL
PAGES
DEFENDANTS
754
CALIFORNIA
NOVEMBER
OAKLAND
I4ONDAY
__________________________
TRANSCRIPT
OF
946
2010
PROCEEDJNG.S
APPEARANCES
FOR
PLAINTIFFS
BINGHAM
I4UCCUTCHEN
LLP
THREE
EMBARCADERO
CENTER
SAN
CALIFORNIA
FRANCISCO
94111-4607
ZACHARY
ALINDER
HOLLY
HOUSE
GEOFFREY 14 HOWARD
DUNN
ATTORNEYS
PICKETT
BY
AT
LAW
SCHILLER
FLEXNER
LLP
HARRISON
SUITE 900
STREET
OAKLAND
CALIFORNIA
94612
DAVID BOILS
STEVEN
ATTORNEYS
AT
HOLTZMAN
BOlES
1999
BY
APPEARANCES
REPORTED
BY
CONTINUED
RAYNEE
DIANE
RAINEE
vr
IL
ier
ClIR
CSR
MERCADO
CRR
IL
NEXT
NERCADO
SKILLMAN
RMR
CRR
FCRR
LAW
PAGE
CSR
CSR
NO
NO
CCRR
8258
4909
510
4517530
Riiinn
15aa486af-96d5-4O92bO78-2f276d57563o
781
Page
IF
WOULD
YOU
SIR
THERE
YOU
A4089
TO
BINDER
DOCUMENTS
REVIEWING
ARE
YOUR
IN
TURN
TAM
YOU
THNil
YOU
AND
HENLEY
JEFF
SEE
JOB
AT
COPIED
THERE
TIME
YOURE
BETWEEN
EXCHANGE
THIS
THAT
SEE
YOU
EMAIL
AN
AND
MS CATI
AND
THATS
THAT
IDO
10
11
WHAT
MR
WAS
HENLEYS
THE
IS
MARCH
OF
2005
WAS
12
TBE
THE
13
30
14
AND
16
THATS
YOU
BOSS
HAVE
DIRECTORS
OF
HE
WAS
YOUR
BOSS
CORRECT
15
EXTENT
BOARD
OF OUR
CHAIRMAN
SHE
MS
SHE
CATZ
REPORTING
WAS
DIRECTLY
TO
YOU
AT
THE
TIME
CORRECT
DOES
STILL
YES
YOU
SOMEBODY
20
TRUST
AND
RELY
ON
ASSUME
YES
21
MR
LANIER
22
MR
BOlES
NO
23
TRE
COURT
ALL
YOUR
HONOR
WE
RIGHT
25
RECEIVED
_.r
4089
ADMITTED
EXHIBIT
DEFENDANTS
iIsan
OF
OBJECTION
24
vta
MOVE ADMISSION
IN
A4089
EVIDENCE
FC
Sa
aSUf.96d5-4O92-bO18.Zf276d57563O
94
OF REPORTER
CZBTflICATE
tE
REPORTERS
FOR
UNITED
THE
HEREBY
CALIFORNIA
BY
ON
MONDAY
SHORTHAND
10
DIRECTION
INTO
11
COMPLETE
12
THE
AND
REPORTERS
TIME
2010
SAID
15
FROM
THE
VALIDITY
TRANSCRIPT
SAID
PROCEEDINGS
COURT
MAY
BE
OF
TI-IC
VOID
REPORTERS
UPON
24
25
AS
MERCADO
RAYNEE
DIANE
CSR
BOUND
BY
US
OF
AND/OR
REMOVAL
SKILLMAN
IXC4L.C14
R1R
CSR
CR
FCRR
RPS
FCRR
TUESDAY
NCVEPIBER
2010
OUR
FULL
IS
rILE
22
23
UNDER
CERTTFIC1TION
DISASSEMBLY
tL
21
CERTIFIED
FOREGOING
THE
WERE
OF FILING
14
18
AL
El
TRANSCRIBED
THAT
OF
AG
SAP
THERAFTEP
WERE
RECORD
AL
NOVEMBER
TYPEWRITING
TRUE
THE
13
ET
OF
DISTRICT
PROCEEDINGS
FOREGOING
THE
INC
USA
US
AND
THAT
CERTIFY
NORTHERN
COURT
OFEICIAL
SKILLMAN
DIANE
AND
STATES
ORACLE
C0701658PJR
REPORTED
MERADO
RAYNEE
CCRR
AT
BLOTNER
RICHARD
July
CONFIDENTIAL
HIGHLY
UNITED
NORTRERN
SAN
DISTRICT
STATES
DISTRICT
OF
FRANCISCO
23
2008
COURT
CALIFORNIA
DIVISION
000
ORACLE
CORPORATION
Delaware corporation
ORACLE
Colorado
USA INC
and
ORACLE
corporation
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
California corporation
Plaintitfs
No
vs
SAP
AG
German corporation
Delaware
INC
SAP
AMERICA
corporation
INC
DOES
O7CVl6SSPJfl
TOMORROWNOW
corporation
inclusive
Texas
1SO
and
Defendants
DEPOSITION
RICHARD
Wednesday
CONTAINS
REPORTED
BY
HIGHLY
CYNTHIA
OF
BLOTNER
July
23
2008
CONFIDENTIAL
PACINI
CSR
MATERIAL
6ll7
RNR
CRR
Ol4ll414
Merrill
Legal
Solutions
800 8699132
fa6333c2.5247.4156-8fef.c02a2d623366
RICHARD
BLOTNER
23
July
CONFIDENTIAL
HIGHLY
2008
118
Page
starting
appear
under
the
have
theres
Bouchers
name
GVP
their
Mr
letters
What
under
does
GVP
Group vice
Are
10
MS
11
12
me
president
14
have
GVP
15
level
15
vice
of
level
Mr
or
presidents that
level
that
Overbroad
The
their
you
the
Im
Boucher
underneath
VPs
vice
relation to
In
WALLACE
vice
names
Objection
sales
So
clarify
them
of
earlier
WITNESS
North American
several
for
senior
the
MS HOUSE
THE
stand
and
president
those
referred to
you
people who
number of
160553
what
level
sorry
would
people
names
referred to
be
at
below
is
below
that
Yeah
Let
the
senior
that
that
under
The
who
the
the
first
senior
presidents
Yes
18
And
Bouchers
20
more along
23
24
25
the
geographical
MS
22
sorry
organization
Yes
21
Im
it
Was
forget
one
that
was
John
organized
lines
was
WALLACE
Lets
mark this one
as
Exhibit
whereupon
Defendants
Exhibit
was
marked for identification
Merrill
Legal
800
Solutions
8699132
fa6333c2-5247-4l
%-Sfet-c02a2d623366
RXCHARD
BLOTNER
Ju1y
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
declare
the
under
foregoing 15 true
and
t$C.
of
___________
penalty
correct
of
23
2008
perjury that
Subscribed at
California
this3
day
2OO8
RIC1PRD
BLOTNER
1.0
11
12
13
14
15
.LI
fl
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
149
Merrill Legal Solutions
800
8699132
Merrill Leg1 Solutions
YOUR
INSTRUCTIONS FOR IEADING/CORRECTING
To
assist
pages
in
you
directions
makIng corrections
below
back
to the
This
is
Please
the
final
read
it
directly
you are
in
your deposition
furnish
follow
the
of the
possession
original
the
transcript
transcript
do
NOT make
any changes
on the transcript
any of the questions
After completing
your review
the designated
Signature
please
line
arid
sign
return
ERRATA
Page
please
make
of
necessary please
Do NOT change
above
testimony
If you find any errors or changes you wish to
the errata sheet beside the page and line numbers
on
version
pages
sheet
are
careftilly
insert the corrections
If
your deposition
attach
the errata
of
to
them and
additional
If
DEPOSITION
the
last
page
of
the transcript to
the errata
sheet
your attorney
SHEET
Line
ii
Change_____
Reason_________________________________________
Change
Reason
Page
Line
Change
Reason_______________________________________
Change
Reason
Change
Reason
If
change
Reason
Change
Reason
Change
Reason
Change
Reason___________________________________________
to
the above
changes
certify
that
the transcript
is
true
and correct
made
certify
that
the transcript
is
true
and
________
Subject
7i_
No changes have been
/4
signaturØ
correct
___
date
OF REPORTER
CERTIFICATE
CYNTHIA
Reporter
truth
whole
the
That
said
me
by
10
witness
11
computer
was
and
that
reduced
sworn
to
tell
but
the
the
truth
before
13
review
14
If
15
provided
to
16
appended
completion
at
person
the
to
down
taken
was
and
my direction
That
the
the
nothing
disinterested
thereafter
under
12
and
deposition
therein stated
place
in
in
the
time
and
the
said
cause
within-entitled
shorthand
witness
the
by me duly
was
foregoing deposition
truth
that
certify
hereby
Certified ShorLhand
PACIt1It
in
the
testimony of
typewriting
by
supervision
of
the
not
hereto
of
requested
transcript
any
the
19
deposition
nor in
20
this
and
21
parties
cause
or
any
that
by
during
certify
either
attorney
25
for
made
reporter
18
22
changes
further
17
was
deposition
that
the
was
the
the
am
any
of
way
interested
am not
thereto
and
deponent
period
not
parties
related
requested
are
of counsel
to the
in the
to
allowed
said
event
any of
of
the
fo
DATED
CYNT
IA
PACINI
CSR
No
6117
or
From
Mio SchIiren
Sent
Friley
lo
Jefl
Cc
Keith
Subject
RE FW EW
FYI
woke
pracbve
me
thaI
peffiormt
The
jrnce.sNnorocI..cvn
PM
30.20061024
June
NsnJ.y
Crolg
Tait
bbck
John
Bouchen
jim Tesla
with
sol
she has
vetella
hr
el
e.llv
the
is
she
thai
lead
Ann
do
will
McFarland
Frarico
OSO
from
and
wwPang
however
Kith
on
To
Hwworth
the
the
go
oTher
is
rlty
and
hat
Oracle
Their
stand
lie
todd
the has
apfrtn
his
in
of
part
things
dredio.i
stuaon
the
tiarule
Jim
pojecl
raqon on where
status
no..
IC
does
sock
914
thought
anything
ii
5pm
at
yesterday
na o.e he
speot
alroy
dditl
botwewi
met wit
emctions
us wtd
agaSt
we
wtio
Ne
LInda
rtffs
convrallon
today
So
ow
on
is
nothh
Pne
donna
and
vdatas
further
OUT
aclon
plan
flegardw
Mce
Schtimgoa
Message
Heey
Sent Friday
une 3t 2006 4Q1
---Oægbial
From
Jeff
Cc
hn
ect
EW
Subject
doWt
what
intend
has
in
time The
on
big
call
is
problem
win
but
lunch
If
you
purpose
her feedback
et
to
is
want
guys
can
on
our cofletm
out
hying
and
bitch
will
not
be
vet
That
posilive
will
me
help
in
just
of
the
was
It
call
not
will
arent
Franco
on
overrule
rarely
try
to
show
loam
his
shake
fair
getting
to
unroaona2.e
the
given
it
sure
the
be
hen
think
Late
at
otice
peraon
Franco
9SSLt
not
really
loose
tasonabie
that
we
him
we
if
wbats
to
on
rully going
we probably guante
think
we
her
torpedo
welt doomed
and
lose
here
Jeff
Thanks
Highly ConftdeThaI
CEO
up The
it
brings
at
McFarnd
Btck
fMr chance
thax
we ct
etc
Otherwise
will
stale
Im
look
fonard to the weekly cMl Mike knows the windows
form she
to
she
us
Kth
WInk
Tate
on
the
that
if
lei
professionafly
Qaig
true
me
flIfl and
are
hes
unless
us wth
agathst
thin2s
if
call
Panco
ahfs Unda
donna
and
flanco
Fnnco
with
we dont
Franca
she and
stacked
bow
see
etwe
cowersatbn
the
since
seem
to
rnIPeshhgenOorecom
Phore
meiaion
to
IMI she deck
The
BotcMr
FYI
transpjjtd
checking
call
PM
Ta
Cza
and
Oat you
expect
sm.tI
but
vindow
to
didnt think
it
an
tIwitflo
was
to
could
unreasonsble
tbe
calls
not
arent
for
as
watt
make
today
dealing
to
run
but
with
suggest
she
blew
dad
is
ie
eaiI
Infonnation
extenced
alt
hne
she
is
trail
tc
reach
ptazrnurg
with
Mtomeys
out
to
Fraflcos
Eyes
to
be
her
on
directly
the
athir
Franco
and
be
just
call
have
careful
been
am
She
trying
Was
to
Monday
keep
not
it
ORGLOO74fl51
Only
Noznmtlq
Case
No
WflXTctCIflNTA
407-cv-oIosgPsHtDt
DDArFtrbaIt
Dic
Nt
A-6411
Ad_______
By___________
Nicole
Hcath
that
dont
obviously
way
that
prepared
she
may
you
and
Donna
Ill send
want
on
it
the
be
con
need to
on the
call but we
finds
out about
it
her
if
she
info
call
under
be
email
seperata
Regards
Craig
From
Sent
Jeff
LmllLQ
Henley
359 PM
June 30 2006
Friday
To
Craig
Tate
Cc
Keith
Block
can be
the
on
could have
clear
the
doubt
dont
slot
it
John Boucher
FW FW
Re
Subject
call
been
think
its
thrash
through the
unreasonable
but
voicemail
Craig Tate
at
least
McFarland
Block
we
thought
list
initial
small team of people
should have
should have
Perhaps
been
on
the
call
had
else
something
at
that
one
and
to
but
so
only time
notice
before our
morning
rahlls Linda
Keith
10 Calif time
at
might have
that
Ann
should also call
think
and
Franco
The only time she gave us today was noon her time
difference
today giveil the short
Monday
morning
on the call today but
and
air
between
conversation
Monday
would make
donna
mike.schflmqen@oracIe.com
Phone
1-4
call
as
to
followup
with Franco
she cant say
didnt
to
try
meeting
todays
shes
true
reach
to
form
Id suggest
try
her
out
If
Ill
probably just get
wrote
Jeff
We
have
Please
set
see
Given your
un
ut
call
note
previous
for
below
Reith to
On
the
exposure to
talk
co
weekly
F.ranco
Franco on
call
status
and the
tone
Ronday
at
1000am POT
earlier today
of
thi
with
Ann
conversation
Thanks
Craig
Ressage--From Rith Block
Sent Friday
June
30 2006
------OriginaL
.Block0oraclecom
232
PIJ
To
Cc
Craig Tate
Linda McFarland
Smith
John
Boucher
mike.sohlimcien@oracle.com
.Rc
Ft Phone conversation between France and keith Block
Subject
Id
tuck
be
willing to do this call
lets swing away
her
Craig Tate
in
the
think
morning
the
next
approach
week
should
Sean
whistler
time
be
are
it we
wasti
wrote
Linda
Highly Confidential Information
Attorneys
Eyes Only
0R0L00747252
The
back
response
Keith
just
could
Let
me
from
was
1.5
staous
update
bnt
wrong
know
office
off
got
be
Francos
what
hr
honestly
dorit
10th
July
think
call
w/
pushed
the
and her
010
directed
France has
back
them
think
you
Craig
--Original Message--From Donna Wnlderzak
imailtcDonna Malderzak@Haworth
Sent Friday
June
30 2006 155 PM
To
Craig Tate
RE Phone conversation
Subject
between
France
coin
Keith
and
Block
Craig
France said
Keeping
the
will
he
with
talk
difference
time
on
you
in mind
from
Monday
he will be
Italy
hours
ahead
what
Walderzak
Executive
kdmin Pasistant
One Bawooth Center
Donna
Holland
Direct
MI
4923
616.353
1955
Fax
616.3931033
Donna.walderzakSbaworth
Originai
From Craig
corn
Message
Tate
June
Friday
30 2006 122 PM
Palderzak
RE Phone conversation between
Subject
Scent
To
Donna
France
and
Keith
Block
Thank you
Craig
Origiral Message-From Donna Waldersak
Sent Friday
June
30
rnaiitoiDonna
2006
128
.Walder-zak@Haworth
corn
PM
To
Craig Tate
Subject
RE Phone conversation
Hghiy Confidentia
Information
Attorneys
Eyes Only
between
France and
Faith Block
0RCL00747253
Craig
Franco
ctua1ly
is
on
vacation
but
will
be
to
happy
forward
your mes
you
Thank
Donna
Walderzak
Executive
Admin
Donna
Haworth
One
Assistant
Center
MI
49423
1olland
616.393.1959
Direct
Fax 616.393.1033
.walderzak@haworth
Donna
con
---Crigiual Message
From Craig Tate
rafltocxaig tate9oracle.com
June
Sent Friday
30 2006 126 P14
To
Donna
Subject
Ann Harten
Naldersak
Phone conversation
RE
between
Franco
and Keith Slock
Donna
Thanks
for
the
response
My
only
concern
is
that
laworth
Is
on
very
Regards
Craig
---Original
Message
FrOm Donna Walderxak
fmeiltcDonna.Waiderzak9Haworth
1216 P11
Sent FrIdsy
June
30 2006
To
Ann
Subject
Is
That
Monday
Please
Thank
Harten
Craig.Tete6oracie.com
Phone conversation between
July
and
Keith Block
Franoc will be leaving shortly after 200 PM today
PM EST
could be available
for
call
at 600
correct
107
Franco
.cos
he
advise
you
Walderaak
Executive
Admin
Donna
Oe
Maworth
Assistant
Center
MI
49423
Holland
Direct
616.393.1959
Fax 616.393.1033
Highly Confidentiel
Information
Attorneys
Eyes Only
0RGL00747254
r_na
ide
we
Origina
From
Sent
Message---
Karten
t.n.n
1212
June
30 2006
Friday
Craig.Tateorace.con
To
Re
Subject
Phone
conversation
Donna
tD
Craig
am copyirl9
around
200
PM
us
after
to
Donna
speak
SST
he
confirm
Waldertak
between
that
Donna may
returns
PM
be
Franco Elanchi
and Keith Block
France
Franca is leaving
able
to provide
today
for
suggested
Europe
time
fo
Ann
tnn
VP
Harter
Information
Inc
Global
Haworth
ire1ess
Sent
from
my
BlackBerry
Handbeld
Original
Messag
Craic
rate
From
To
CC
Services
Ann
Harten
mrke.sch11mgenorac1ecor
Sent
Jun
Fri
Subject
Phone
30
115233
2006
conversation
between
Franca
and
Keith
Block
Ann
Keith
has
time
between
330pm
EST
and
500pm
EST
today
for
phone
cart
Cra
Craig It Tate
Group Vice President
North
Centra
Applications
Oracle
312
LISA
Erm
Suite
1525
Cincinnati
Phone
Fax
Highly
Confidential
Information
Inc
Street
OH
45202
5136292229
51365L4463
Attorneys
Eyes Only
Mobile
Email
5137034529
Craiq.Tate8oracie.cout
0RCL00747255