Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1201

Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1182 Statement Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier iso Joint Statement Regarding Exhibit Objections filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59)(Related document(s) 1182 ) (Froyd, Jane) (Filed on 8/2/2012)

EXHIBIT 12

Foundation for
A-6205-1

Defendants

0RCL00034305
Oracle

Senior

Trial Exhibit

Oracle

Director

A-6205-1

organizational
Support

Sales

Foundational Support

chart identifying Richard

Rick Cummins

as

an

Mid-Market

Cummins Sept 16 2008 Depo Tr at 102-11 143-23 1425-1511 276-23 4911-13
Rule 30b6 testimony by Cummins identifying Cummins as Oracles senior director
of support

renewals/sales

discussing

the support

Feb 23 2010 Oracle
Cummins as

Richard

SVI-108747v1

in

North America describing

sales/renewals

Expert

Report

Senior Director

his

responsibilities and

team and reporting structure

of Paul Meyer redacted
Support

Renewals

for

excerpt identifying
North America

Chart

Organization

ORACL.

Page

Aria

People

of

Search

set

..-

Directs

Total

367

an
VP

Suppod

RiewS

Dlrocts

TotaL

taDthaa
Dror Suppod Sas

SdJes

211

thhIt.aLinter
Qacto.

5Mpport

8pIM4-

rotar

TstZg

SSss

ToTaL2

Dy11nS
$LQimcQLwoj

Coordlna

Suoqi

mocd
QCWliQfl

Sublicene

Pru4ecI

Sr

btSCa

Total

19

Sntnic

TotaLs

St

tot43

.._

hghIy

ConfjdentaI

Information

Attornev

Eyes

Ord

0RCL00034305

RICHARD CUMMINS
September 16 2008
ATTORNEYS EYES ONLY
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
Page
UNITED

STATES

DISTRICT

DISTRICT

NORTHERN
SAN

OF

FRANCISCO

COURT

CALIFORNIA

DIVISION

--OOoDelaware
CORPORATION
Corporation
ORACLE
USA INC
and
Colorado
Corporation
ORACLE
INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION
ORACLE

California

Corporation

Plaintiffs

No

Vs
SAP

AG

SAP

AIVIERICA

German

EDL

07-CV-01658-PJH

Corporation

INC

Delaware

CORPORATION
TOMORROWNOW
and
Texas
Corporation
150 Inclusive

INC
DOES

Defendants

________________/

30b

RULE

VIDEOTAPED

ORACLE

RICHARD

CONFIDENTIAL

Reported
By
Job 412495

CUMMINS

16

September

Volume
HIGHLY

ARLEN

Merrill Legal

800

2008
255

Pages

ATTORNEYS

INFORMATION

WENDY

OF

CORPORATION

Designee

Tuesday

DEPOSITION

CSR

4355

CRR

EYES

ONLY

RNR

Solutions

8699132

e6a0856a-Oee4-4b35.albf-ca2oaf8a26bc

RICHARD
HIGHLY

September
16 2008
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS
EYES

CUMMINS

CONFIDENTIAL

ONLY

10

Page
Understood
Where

do

Oracle
0913

What

North

Corporation

is

Im

have

long

Edwards

which

acquired

by Oracle

ii

industry

for

ten

MR

McDONELL

12

was

renewals

support

So

years

that

for

by

Ive

the

in

Oracle
have

we

Exhibit

42

with

was

was

in

the

job

since
this

3D

which

Peoplesoft

been

With
Can

position

2005

since

acquired

Defendants

13

2005

marked

marked

for

identification

14

MR
16

marked

17

Im

MCDONELL

42

showing

you

whats

been

record

as

Exhibit

18

19

MS

HOUSE

TUE

Can you

WITNESS

identify

that

for

the

Yes

20

21

22

in

this

morning

MR

So

with

When

25

is
is

various

Its

that
my document

brought

notes
document

you

prepared

Yes

24

what
This

McDONELL

23

0914

of

you had

Oracle

10

0914

director

America

Within

0914

job

your

senior

How

0913

work

you

Yesterday

Merrill

did

you

Legal

800

prepare

it

Solutions

8699132

eaOO5sa.O..4-4b35-afbf.caflafaa2sbc

RICHARD
HIGHLY

September
16 2008
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS
EYES

CIJMMINS

CONFIDENTIAL

ONLY

Page
those
of

offerings

of

business side

support
When

0918

the

really developed

14

existing

came to

you

separate

did it have

Oracle

kind

renewals

team

Did

support

any

group merge

into

Yes
And what
it

or

it

replace
We

0919
10

At what

11

Well
you

started

14

At

Oracle

the

team

the

highest

level

about

this

you

renewal

JD Edwards

teani

said that

--

Then

right

Right

16

17

of

moved

you

Oracle

to

upon

the

acquisition

Peoplesoft

18

Right

19

And

20

Oracles

at

that

time your group merged

into

similar group

21

Yes

22

was

23

0919

of

talking

support

at

15

0919

it

Uhhuh

13

0919

into

level

Im

the

happened

the head

was

your

What

merged

Who

12

happened

there

head

of

that

support

renewals

team

24

MS HOUSE

25

MR McDONELL

Merrill

Legal

800

At

that

At

time

that

time

Solutions

8699132

oBaOBsea-o.e44b35Ibf.ca2oafssflasc

HIGHLY

RICHARD
CUMMINS
16 2008
September
CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS
EYES

ONLY

Page
At

Chris

that

into

reported

reported

in

0919

to

And

worked

time

Chris Madsen
Juan

well

Juergen

Jones

and
who

Rottler

Juergen

has

for

15

that

structure

reporting

changed

then

since

No
You

still report

Chris

to

Madsen

Ido
0920

Has
tO

since

you

Since

13

support

the

renewals

time

14

At

JD

your

job

were

part

of

changed

At

JD

Edwards

forming

the

Peoplesoft

Edwards

16

in

that

19

function

until

MS HOUSE

18

Im sorry

WITNESS

21

MR

MoDONELL

23

24

25

remained

you

vague

You

can

answer
THE

22

Rave

today

Objection

20

O92t

you
at

group

i5

0921

of

No

12

nature

Oracle

joined

11

0920

basic

the

certifications

Im
certification
But

Merrill

or

rigt

or
if

Do

special
sure

there

that

is

essentially
you

have

any
for

training
there is

kind
your

one

you

of

job

special

thats specific

training

Legal

800

Yeah

dont

to

have

that

it

Solutions

8699132

eeaOeS$a4..4.4b35albf.ca2Qaffiaflbc

RICHARD
HIGHLY

September
16 2008
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS
EYES

CUMMINS

CONFIDENTIAL

ONLY

Page

MR
hasnt

McDONELL

changed

terms ci

in

youve been

since

your

Oracle

at

base

My

responsibilities

mistdken

Am

0935

renewals

about

10

11

Ensuring
in my

for

space

And how

13

that

Theres

14

15

go

looking

do

director

renew

we

of

our customers

whole

but

process

of

the

process

are

do

want

you

or what

are

me
you

for
Give me the

general

outline

17

The

outline

is

general

18

contacted

19

time

frame

20

that

we

21

their contract

22

contracts

23

those

25

that

that

do

16

24

support

renewals

you

details

the

through

base

your

America

support

12

Changed

base

are your

senior

as

North

for

havent

lets talk about

What

responsibilities

ag36

job

responsibilities

responsibilities
Then

Okay

0936

said your

you

that

0935

0936

thought

27

regarding
We

their renewal

then

work

purchase

get

or

and

that

if

questions

with

customers

for

the

order before

please

the

upcoming

customer
the

are

ensure

to

start date

there are any questions
about

the

services

we

of

on

answer

questions
Do

deal

you

directly

with

customers

in

your

job

Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

eGaOSSSa-O.e4-4b35.1

bfca2OafB2Obc

RICHARD
HIGHLY

September
16 2008
INFORMATION
ATTORNEYS
EYES

CIJIvIMINS

CONFIDENTIAL

ONLY

49

Page
and

managers
North

then

America

Hes
delivery

So

of

support

support

renewals

support

Mr

Rottler

for

their business offices

our

Redwood

and

here

headquarters

Jones

California

in

City

10

Yes

11

And

whats Mr

12

Hes

vice

13

support

Madsens

job

of

president

North

America

renewals

11

And

15

In

Mr Madsen

Ido

16

17

this

lB

19

have

Peoplesoft

you

the

other individuals

Exhibit

43

which

of

page

which

and

At

22

of

23

24

some

this

JD

this

individuals

25

these

of

responsibility for

21

to

report

terms of

0RCL00087625

20

1007

all

Mr

At

1006

for

job

located

physically

1006

support

are

Where

1005

as

of

renewals

support

EVP of

the

well

as

side

whats Mr Rottlers

And
1005

business

the

all

responsibility
For

Merrill

Legal

if

renewals

for

Lindsey
but

no

is

the

any
legacy

Peoplesoft

and

longer

part

other

other individuals

for

support

800

chart

the

number

products

Kathy

organizational

Bates

individuals

support

Edwards
point

is

listed on

here have

JO

Edwards

renewals

Solutions

8699132

eSatBGSa.0004.4b35..1

bt.ca2oafB82Bbc

C4INS

RICRARD

Septeer 16

2008

CONFIDENTIAL

MR
break

for

McDONELL

the

day

Im

Counsel

See

you

then

Thank

week

next

to

you

going

sir
VIDEOGRAPHER
1701

videotape

number

Cummins

Going

four
off

marks

This
in

the

the

the

end
of

deposiLion

record

the

of

time

Richard

is

502

-oOoWhereupon

502

the

adjourned

at

p.m
--eDo--

iO

declare

12

13

the

14

/VeJi-

15

was

deposition

foregoing

under

is

and

true

_____

.C1ifornia

penalty

perjury

Subscribed

correct
this

of

IS

day

that
at

of

2008

19

Signature

of

Witness

20

21

22

23

24

25

253
Merrill

Legal

800

Solutions

8699132

Errata Sheet

Deposition

Page

Rick

of

Line

41

1-22

Cummins September 16

2008

Change

Reason

Change Juans

manager

to

responsibility

Juan

is

is

responsible

service

Clarification

delivery

for service

delivery

managers
Change

14

No

havent

havent

124

talked

to

talked

hundreds

to

customers

to

No

Clarification

of customers about

TomorrowNow

174

Change

23

less

welcome

to

176

Change Hutton

207

Change

219

to

to

the

above

Correction

Murquia

Correction

renew

Correction

to

or doesnt

Change

14

Correction

Hunt

to

new

Correction

Oracle

to

Change

245

A72687826

McGee

Change were

22

232

Subject

more

Change

151

IP to IT

changes

1er

that

to

does

or

doesnt

Correction

Correction

the transcript

is

true

and correct

CERTIFICATE
WFNDY

certify that

hereby

foregoing

deposition

the

whole

by

and

therein

said

11

computer

me

witness

13

review

14

under

requested

15

deponent

16

period

of

the

stated

before

to

tell

but

the

are

reduced

in

the

to

further
either

19

deposition nor

in

20

this

that

21

parties

and

any

thereto
DATED

of

any
way

of

the
by

deposition
was

not

made

the

reporter

the

by

during

the

hereto
that
of

the

am

not

parties

interested

am not

related

Cgk

of

counsel

to

the

said
of

in

the

event

to

any

of

nc
2008

23

24

WENDY

time

typewriting

the

changes

certify
or

the

supervision

any

to

at

in

testimony

was

appended

attorney for

25

the

truth

down

person
the

completion

requested

allowed

taken

that

transcript

18

22

and

direction and

and provided

cause

sworn

nothtng

thereafter
my

If

17

the

duly

disinterested

was

That

12

and

in

said deposition was

shorthand

10

me

by

witness

the

cause

That

place

was

truth

within-entitled

Certified Shorthand

ARLEN

Reporter

truth

REPORTER

OF

ARLdN

CSR

No

4355

the

or

ORACLE

USA INC

SAP

CASE

SUPPLEMENTAL

AG

No

Ft AL

Ft AL

07-CV-01658

EXPERT REPORT

IM FINANCW
FEBRuARY

OP PAUL

FORENSICS

23

MEYER

LLC

2010

IALJ

MEYER

Rick

Cunimins

Senior Director

America

Page
SuijecI

Highly

Prolectiw
CozfidnitiilI

Order
Lnftrmition

AtWrneIJ5

Eyn Ony

of

Th1

Support Renewals

or North