State of Texas et al v. United States of America et al

Filing 64

REPLY in Support of 5 Opposed MOTION for Preliminary Injunction, filed by Phil Bryant, Paul R. LePage, Patrick L. McCrory, C.L. "Butch" Otter, Bill Schuette, State of Louisiana, State of Alabama, State of Arizona, State of Arkansas, State of Florida, State of Georgia, State of Idaho, State of Indiana, State of Kansas, State of Montana, State of Nebraska, State of North Dakota, State of Ohio, State of Oklahoma, State of South Carolina, State of South Dakota, State of Texas, State of Utah, State of West Virginia, State of Wisconsin. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Ex 1, # 2 Exhibit Ex. 2, # 3 Exhibit Ex. 3, # 4 Exhibit Ex. 4, # 5 Exhibit Ex. 5, # 6 Exhibit Ex. 6, # 7 Exhibit Ex. 7, # 8 Exhibit Ex. 8, # 9 Exhibit Ex. 9.a, # 10 Exhibit Ex. 9.b, # 11 Exhibit Ex. 10.a, # 12 Exhibit Ex. 10.b, # 13 Exhibit Ex. 10.c, # 14 Exhibit Ex. 10.d, # 15 Exhibit Ex. 10.e, # 16 Exhibit Ex. 10.f, # 17 Exhibit Ex. 10.g, # 18 Exhibit Ex. 10.h, # 19 Exhibit Ex. 10.i, # 20 Exhibit Ex. 10.j, # 21 Exhibit Ex. 10.k, # 22 Exhibit Ex. 10.l, # 23 Exhibit Ex. 10.m, # 24 Exhibit Ex. 10.n, # 25 Exhibit Ex. 10.0, # 26 Exhibit Ex. 10.p, # 27 Exhibit Ex. 10.q, # 28 Exhibit Ex. 10.r, # 29 Exhibit Ex. 10.s, # 30 Exhibit Ex. 11, # 31 Exhibit Ex. 12, # 32 Exhibit Ex. 13, # 33 Exhibit Ex. 14, # 34 Exhibit Ex. 15, # 35 Exhibit Ex. 16, # 36 Exhibit Ex. 17, # 37 Exhibit Ex. 18, # 38 Exhibit Ex. 19, # 39 Exhibit Ex. 20, # 40 Exhibit Ex. 21, # 41 Exhibit Ex. 22, # 42 Exhibit Ex. 23, # 43 Exhibit Ex. 24, # 44 Exhibit Ex. 25, # 45 Exhibit Ex. 26, # 46 Exhibit Ex. 27, # 47 Exhibit Ex. 28, # 48 Exhibit Ex. 29, # 49 Exhibit Ex. 30, # 50 Exhibit Ex. 31, # 51 Exhibit Ex. 32, # 52 Exhibit Ex. 33, # 53 Exhibit Ex. 34, # 54 Exhibit Ex. 35)(Oldham, Andrew)

EXHIBIT 26

App. 0883

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
the WHITE HOUSE PresiDeNt bArACK obAMA

BRIEFING ROOM

Contact Us

ISSUES

THE ADMINISTRATION

PARTICIPATE

Get Email Updates

1600 PENN

Search

Home • Briefing Room • Speeches & Remarks

The White House
Office of the Press Secretary
For Immediate Release

December 09, 2014

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -Nashville, Tennessee
Casa Azafran
Nashville, Tennessee
2:26 P.M. CST

THE PRESIDENT:Thank you, everybody.Thank you.(Applause.)Thank you so much.Everybody, please have a
seat.Thank you very much.Everybody, please have a seat, have a seat.
Well, hello, Nashville.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:Hola.

THE PRESIDENT:Hola.Cómo estás?

AUDIENCE MEMBER:Bien, bien.

THE PRESIDENT:Bien.Thank you, Renata, for the wonderful introduction.I’ve brought some friends with me who I
think you may know -- your Congressmen, Jim Cooper -- (applause) -- as well as Congressman Steve Cohen from
Memphis is here.(Applause.)And I want to thank -- is your mayor still here?Where did he go?There he is right
there, doing a great job.(Applause.)And his wonderful daughter -- we’ve got to brag about her, she’s a junior at
Barnard.I just embarrassed her.(Applause.)When you’re the father of daughters, your job is to embarrass them,
and I’m trying to give an assist here.(Laughter.)

I want to thank Casa Azafran for hosting us, and for being home to so many organizations that do important work
welcoming immigrants to the community.And that’s why I’ve come here today.I won’t make a long speech, because
I want to have a dialogue, but I wanted to give some remarks at the top.

As Renata mentioned, some people might think Nashville was an odd place to talk immigration.It’s not what comes
to mind when people think about gateways to America.But, as all of you know, Nashville’s got one of the fastestgrowing immigrant populations in the country.“New Nashvillians” -- they’re from Somalia, Nepal, Laos, Mexico,
Bangladesh.And Nashville happens to be the home of the largest Kurdish community in the United States as well.

“They” are “us.”They work as teachers in our schools, doctors in our hospitals, police officers in our
neighborhoods.They start small businesses at a faster rate than many native-born Americans.They create jobs
making this city more prosperous, and a more innovative place.And of course, they make the food better.
(Laughter.)I know that Tennessee barbeque is pretty popular, but Korean barbeque is pretty good too.(Laughter.)

And the point is, welcoming immigrants into your community benefits all of us.And I was talking to your Mayor, Karl
Dean, on the way over here, and he understands this.He’s been a great partner when it comes to preparing
immigrants to become citizens.

A couple of weeks ago, I create a Task Force on New Americans that’s going to help do this kind of work all across
the country.But, as we all know, our immigration system has been broken for a long time.Families who come here
the right way can get stuck in line for years.Business owners who treat their workers right sometimes are undercut
by competition from folks who are not just hiring undocumented workers but then underpaying them or not paying
them minimum wage, or not giving them the benefits that they have earned.Nobody likes the idea of somebody
reaping the rewards of living in America without its responsibilities as well.And there are all kinds of folks who want
to gladly embrace those responsibilities, but they have no way to come out of the shadows and get right with the
law.

LATEST BLOG POSTS
January 07, 2015 10:27 AM EST

The Resurgence of the American Auto
Industry – in Three GIFs
See how American auto companies have roared
back to life, creating jobs, generating profits,
expanding business, and helping to strengthen the
American economy.
January 07, 2015 10:20 AM EST

President Obama's Statement on the Attack
in France
Following the attack at the offices of Charlie Hebdo
magazine, President Obama strongly condemns
the attack, and offers the Administration's
thoughts and prayers to both the victims of the
attack and the people of France.
January 06, 2015 6:08 PM EST

Being Biden: A Senate Swearing-In
In this special video edition of Being Biden, the
Vice President speaks about the importance of the
Senate ceremonial swearing-in ceremony.

VIEW ALL RELATED BLOG POSTS

Facebook

YouTube

Twitter

Vimeo

Flickr

iTunes

Google+

LinkedIn

App. 0884
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Submit

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
And a year and a half ago, a big majority of Democrats, Republicans, and independents in the Senate –- including
both of your senators -– passed a bipartisan bill to fix our broken immigration system.The bill wasn’t perfect, but it
was a common-sense compromise.It would have doubled the number of border patrol agents.It would have made
the legal immigration system smarter and faster.It would have given millions of people a chance to earn their
citizenship the right way.It was good for our economy -- independent economists estimated that it would not only
grow our economy faster but shrink our deficits faster.And if the House of Representatives had simply called for an
up-or-down vote, it would have passed.It would be the law.We would be on the way to solve -- solving this problem
in a sensible way.But for a year and a half now, Republican leaders in the House blocked this simple up-or-down
vote.

I still believe that the best way to solve this -- is by working together to pass the kind of common-sense law that was
passed in the Senate.But until then, there are actions that I have the legal authority to take that will help make our
immigration system smarter and fairer.And I took those actions last month.

We’re providing more resources at the border to help law enforcement personnel stop illegal crossings and send
home those who cross over.We’re going to focus our enforcement resources on people who actually pose a threat
to our communities -- felons rather than families, and criminals rather than children.We’re going to bring more
undocumented immigrants out of the shadows so they can play by the rules -- they have to pass a criminal
background check, pay taxes, contribute more fully to our economy.

So this isn’t amnesty, or legalization, or even a path to citizenship.That can only be done by Congress.It doesn’t
apply to anybody who’s come to this country recently, or who might come illegally in the future.What it does is
create a system of accountability, a common-sense, middle-ground approach.And what we’re saying is, until
Congress fixes this problem legislatively, if you have deep ties to this country and you are willing to get right by the
law and do what you need to do, then you shouldn’t have to worry about being deported or being separated from
your kids.

These are the kind of lawful actions taken by every President, Republican and Democrat, for the past 50 years.So
when members of Congress question whether I have the authority to do this, I have one answer:Yes, and pass a
bill.(Laughter.)If you want Congress to be involved in this process, I welcome it, but you’ve got to pass a bill that
addresses the various components of immigration reform in a common-sense way.

And I want to work with both parties to get this done.The day I sign this bill into law, then the executive actions I
take are no longer necessary and some of the changes that I’ve instituted administratively become permanent.

Unfortunately, so far, the only response that we’ve had out of the House was a vote taken last week to force
talented young people and workers to leave our country.Rather than deport students or separate families or make
it harder for law enforcement to do its job, we just need Congress to work with us to pass a common-sense law to
fix the broken immigration system.
And meanwhile, Washington shouldn’t let disagreements on this issue prevent action on every other issue.That’s
not how our democracy works.Americans are tired of gridlock.We’re seeing the economy move forward.We need to
build on that.And certainly my administration is ready to work for it on a whole range of issues.

I do recognize that there are controversies around immigration -- there always have been, by the way.Even those
who know we need to reform the system may be concerned about not having Congress get it done.Then there are
some folks who worry about immigration changing the fabric of our society, or taking jobs from native-born
Americans.And I understand those concerns, but, as I said, they’re not new.As a country, we have had these
concerns since the Irish and Italians and Poles were coming to Boston and New York, and we have the same
concerns when Chinese and Japanese Americans were traveling out West.

But what our history and the facts show is that generation after generation, immigrants have been a net-plus to our
economy, and a net-plus to our society.And that’s what cities like Nashville prove is still the case.And this city
proves that we can address these concerns together and make sure that immigration works for everybody -- that it
strengthens our economy, that it strengthens our communities, that we can talk about some of the tensions and
concerns in a constructive way rather than yelling at each other.

And so let me close with a story of somebody who’s working to bring people together.David Lubell, who many of
you know and who’s here today -- where’s David?There he is.(Applause.)So David used to run the Tennessee
Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition.And he knew that some folks were skeptical about immigrants changing
the face of Nashville.And he also knew, though, that these immigrants were good people.So he saw an opportunity
for immigration to unite this city rather than divide it.And in 2005, he started “Welcoming Tennessee,” which
connects long-term residents in the community with new immigrants.And you’d have dinners and church socials,
and at Rotary clubs, and folks got to know each other and maybe feel some empathy, and see themselves in new
arrivals.

And the conversations weren’t always easy, but it created a foundation of mutual understanding and respect.And
today, David’s initiative is expanding across the country.I think we -- you said, David, that we’ve got these kinds of

App. 0885
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
efforts going on in 42 cities around the country.

This is what makes America exceptional.We welcome strivers.We welcome dreamers from all around the world.And
it keeps us young, and it keeps us invigorated, and it keeps us striving and pushing the boundaries of what’s
possible.And then we all bind ourselves together around similar ideals, a similar creed.And one generation in,
suddenly those kids are already Americans like everybody else, and we have the same dreams and hopes for
them, the same aspirations.

And if we keep harnessing that potential, there’s no limit to what this country can achieve.So Nashville is helping to
lead the way in getting this conversation right.We hope that if it happens around the country, that eventually it will
drift into the House of Representatives -- (laughter) -- and we’re going to get the kind of comprehensive legislation
that we need to actually solve this problem.

So with that, let me start taking some questions.Thank you very much, everybody.I appreciate it.(Applause.)

So I’ve got a microphone here.This is a nice, intimate group.And so there’s no rules really.I’d just ask everybody
who wants to speak to raise their hand.I’ll call on you one at a time.We’ve got some microphones in the
audience.And why don’t you, when you’re asking your questions, stand, introduce yourself, tell us a little about
yourself, and then ask your question.Try to keep your question relatively brief so -- and I’ll try to keep my answers
relatively brief.(Laughter.)I don’t always succeed, but I’ll do my best.I’m going to take off my jacket because it’s
warm in here.Is Marvin back there?Okay, we’ve got some -- here we go.Thanks.

All right.Who wants to go first?Yes, right here in the front.

Q Hi, Mr. President.Thank you so much for coming to Nashville, and the Latin community loves you and welcome
you to Nashville.My question is -- and I think it’s a concern in the community that -- what is going to happen if the
next administration decide not to follow what you -- the executive action?And I think many of the communities -afraid are they going to be first in line to deportation because they give their information.And that would be my
question.

THE PRESIDENT:Well, I think it's a good question.So let me just -- let me go over the mechanics of what’s going to
happen.

First of all, part of what we’re saying is that we can’t deport 11 million people and it would be foolish to try, as well
as I think wrong for us to try.Congress only allocates a certain amount of money to the immigration system, so we
have to prioritize.And my priority is not to separate families who have already been living here but to try to make
sure that our borders are secure, to make sure that people come through the right way; to focus on criminals, focus
-- those who pose a real risk to our society.

And so what’s happened is, is the Department of Homeland Security, which is in charge of the immigration services,
what it said is, is that we’re going to set up priorities in terms of who is subject to deportation.And at the top are
criminals, people who pose a threat, and at the bottom are ordinary people who are otherwise law abiding.And
what we’re saying essentially is, in that low-priority list, you won’t be a priority for deportation.You’re not going to be
deported.We’re not going to keep on separating families.And that new priority list applies to everybody, all 11
million people who are here -- I mean, not 11 million, let’s say, whatever the number is.So even if somebody didn’t
sign up, they’re still much less likely to be subject to deportation.That’s because we’ve changed our enforcement
priorities in a formal way.

What we’re also saying, though, is that for those who have American children or children who are legal permanent
residents, that you can actually register and submit yourself to a criminal background check, pay any back taxes
and commit to paying future taxes, and if you do that, you’ll actually get a piece of paper that gives you an
assurance that you can work and live here without fear of deportation.That doesn’t apply to everybody, but it does
apply to roughly five million -- about half of what is estimated to be the number of undocumented workers here.

Now, that is temporary.Just like DACA, the program that we put in place for young people who are brought here
who otherwise are good citizens, are studying, working, joining our military -- we did that several years ago, where
we said, it doesn’t make sense for us to subject these young people to a deportation risk; they’re Americans in their
heart even if they don’t have the right piece of paper.That’s temporary as well, although it's been subject to
renewal.

And so it's true that a future administration might try to reverse some of our policies.But I’ll be honest with you, I
think that the American people basically have a good heart and want to treat people fairly.And every survey shows
that if, in fact, somebody has come out, subjected themselves to a background check, registered, paid their taxes,
that the American people support allowing them to stay.So I think any future administration that tried to punish
people for doing the right thing I think would not have the support of the American people.

The real question is, how do we make sure that enough people register so that it's not just a few people in a few
pockets around the country.And that’s going to require a lot of work by local agencies, by municipalities, by

App. 0886
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
churches, by community organizations.We’ve got to give people confidence that they can go ahead and register;
also make sure that they understand they don’t have to hire a lawyer or go to the notary in order to pay for
this.Because what we saw during DACA when the young people were given this opportunity, a lot of people signed
up but sometimes you would see advertisements, come and give us $1,000 or $2,000 and we'll help you -- you
don't have to do that.And so we've just got to build an effective network around the country.And the Department of
Homeland Security will be working with local organizations to make sure that people get the right information.

But I think the main response to people that we have to assure them of is that the American people actually are fairminded and want to reward rather than punish people who do the right thing.And if you register, I'm confident that
that's going to be something that allows you to then get on a path to being here in this country with your children
and watching them grow up and making a life for yourself, as you already have.

Last point.It still is important for us, though, because this is temporary to make sure that we keep pushing for
comprehensive immigration reform.Without an actual law, an actual statute passed by Congress, it's true that
theoretically a future administration could do something that I think would be very damaging.It's not likely,
politically, that they’d reverse everything that we've done, but it could be that some people then end up being in a
disadvantageous position.And nobody is going to have a path to actual citizenship until we get a law passed.

Now, the Senate law would call for people to go to the back of the line, so it would take 10, 13 years before they
have citizenship, but at least there’s that pathway.That's why we still need a law.

And then there are some areas like, for example, the business sector, a lot of high-tech businesses are still looking
for young graduates from computer science programs or physics programs around the country.And instead of
being able to recruit them and put them to work, those kids are all going home and starting new businesses and
creating jobs someplace else.And that doesn’t make any sense.So that's another area where we couldn't do
anything administratively about that.We were able to streamline some of the legal immigration system, but we've
still got more work to do.

Okay?Good.I'm going to go boy, girl, boy, girl to make sure that it's fair.(Laughter.)So, right here.

Q Thank you.Good afternoon, President.Thank you so much for doing what you did.I was undocumented for 10
years from 1996.I took advantage of the amnesty.I want to thank you.I'm a community organizer with the Center for
Community Change in Washington, D.C., working with the immigrants from the Human Rights Coalition.And I really
thank the people from Nashville, Tennessee for hosting future Chicagoans – of course, I'm from Chicago, too.
(Laughter.)

And my question to you is, thank you for the 5 million, but what about the others.There are millions of people who
are going to be in the limbo, at risk of being deported.And the second question is, since talking about confidence -–
people are skeptical about this, because they are afraid to apply for this.So what is your administration going to do
to get the confidence -- and people to feel safe to apply for this program that you just passed?Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT:Okay.Well, I sort of answered the question, but I'll try to answer it one more time.The
prioritization in terms of deportation -- that applies to everybody, even if you don't do anything.Now, this will take
time to get ICE officers at the ground level to understand what these new priorities are and to apply them in a
consistent way.And so there are still going to be stories around the country where some family is separated.

Over time, though, we're really going to be pushing to retrain and refocus and reprioritize ICE officers to understand
let’s focus on criminals, let’s focus on felons, let’s not focus on families.

In terms of setting up the system to sign people up to register so they can get an actual piece of paper that says
they can work here, that's probably going to take a couple of months. And so that gives us time then to
communicate through our community organizations, through our churches, through our cities and towns to make
sure that people have good information.

So the folks who, as you said, are in limbo, it's true that they’re not going to qualify for the DACA-like registration
process that I described.They’ll still be, if they’re law-abiding, otherwise, if they’re working, peaceful, then they’re
much less likely to deportation now than they would have been in the past.And they don't have to do anything for
that.But the registration process, if you qualify, is powerful because you’re now able to go to work without being in
the shadows, and you're paying taxes, which is good for everybody, because we want people to be above board
and to do things the right way.

And I think that those who register -- my belief is, is that when we do get to passing a law, finally, I think those who
have taken the time to register, pay taxes, gone through a criminal background check, they’ve got documentation
and proof that they’ve done all that, they’re going to have an easier time then qualifying, I think, for a more
permanent legal status because they will have already gone through the screening.And that's one incentive for why
people should want to sign up.

But building trust will take time.But that's where you come in, so that's your job.I'm going to work with you.I'll work

App. 0887
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
with Renata and I'll work with other activists here to make sure it happens.But we're going to have to do this
together.

I will point out that you already had incredible courage among young people when we announced DACA.Now, we
didn’t get 100 percent of young people who qualified signing up, but we got more than half of the people who were
qualified signing up.And slowly then, each person who has the courage to sign up, that creates more confidence
across the board.

All right, it's a young woman’s turn now.Yes, go ahead.

Q Hi, Mr. President, and thank you so much for being here with us and giving us this opportunity to speak out our
fears.I would like to ask you –- I'm with the Tennessee Immigrants and Refugee Rights Coalition.I'm part of the
Migrant Women Committee.And I would like to ask you –- people like me that will probably benefit from this
executive order, there is a lot of fear still for people that can have the path to a citizen but not immediately.But they
apply for DAPA, the Deferred Action for Parents.Will they face a bar from being in this situation?

THE PRESIDENT:No, I think that those who are -- look, I would encourage anybody who has another path for
legalization to follow that path.But this does not short-circuit whatever other strategies you're pursuing.If you are
already trying to get legal permanent resident status or citizenship through some of the existing laws, then you
should feel free to continue that.What this does do is it simply says that it gives you an opportunity to make sure
that deportation is not going to happen during this period -- which will extend for several years.

Can Big Marvin get me my cup of tea back there?Oh, here it is.All right.This isn't Big Marvin, but he’s big.
(Laughter.)

All right.Gentleman there in the back.

Q I’m a member of the Coalition for Education -- Immigration.I'm an immigrant to Nashville.I grew up -- Chicago,
have lived here the last 12 years.

THE PRESIDENT:It's warmer here.(Laughter.)

Q I do miss the White Sox.

THE PRESIDENT:Yes.

Q My question is about -- one of the many things I appreciate so much about your leadership is the civil way in
which you approach the most difficult of problems, in spite of hearing the rancor you do from those who disagree.
(Inaudible)
-– community like this, trying to talk with reason only to be greeted by deep emotion and anger and rhetoric that is
demeaning. It's almost as if we need a civility platform for our nation, an office of civility -- maybe for our U.S.
Congress.Excuse me, Jim.But I'm serious about how do we teach young people to act in a civil way if we don't rolemodel the civility?And how important is that for us to move forward, that we can engage in the kinds of
conversations in the tone that you present problems?

THE PRESIDENT:Well, look, first of all, I don't know anybody more civil than Jim Cooper.(Applause.)He is an
extraordinary gentleman, and always has been, ever since I've had a chance to know him since I came to
Washington.

Look, immigration, as I said before, has always elicited passion.And it's ironic because unless you are a member of
a Native American tribe, you came here from someplace else, or your people did.And I know that sometimes folks
talk about, well, we came here the right way rather than the wrong way.And it's true that previous generations
came through Ellis Island or they came through Angel Island or other ways of arriving here.

But I think sometimes we overstate the degree to which that was some really elaborate bureaucratic
process.There’s a reason, for example, that these days a lot of people named Smith used to be named
Smithsowsky or Smitharea or whatever it is.What happened is when they came in somebody just said, what’s your
name, and they stamped them and if they couldn't pronounce it -- you always hear stories about they Anglicized
it.A lot of times people’s papers were not necessarily being checked because folks might not have had papers.And
who came in and who didn’t varied depending on how big of a workforce -- or how much industry was looking for
new labor, and what the political climate was at that particular time.

And so what happens is, is that once folks are here we kind of forget that we used to be there.And what I try to do
when I talk about these issues is just try to put yourself in somebody else’s shoes and feel some empathy, and
recognize that to some degree, if you’re American, somewhere back there, there was somebody who was a
newcomer here too.And it wasn’t always neat and orderly the way the American population expanded across the
West.And if we have that sense of empathy then maybe that creates civility.That’s why the kinds of efforts were
seeing here in Nashville just conversations where people get to know newcomers is so important.

App. 0888
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House

It's interesting -- I was telling Steve and Jim, I get about 40,000 correspondence every day, and some of them are
just writing to say you’re doing a good job, keep going.Some of them are you are the worst President ever, you’re
an idiot, a lot of them are just people asking for help.

But more than once, multiple times during the course of my presidency, I’ve gotten letters from people who say I
don’t agree with you about anything, I am a Republican, I used to be really angry with you about your immigration
posture and then I found out that my son Jim’s best friend, Jose, was undocumented and he wasn’t going to be
able to apply to the local college because he was afraid about being deported, and this is a kid who has played in
my back yard, helped me wash my car, and been on the ball team with my kid and I loved this kid and so I don’t
think it's right that this young person shouldn’t be treated the same way that I would want someone to treat my
son.And I’ve gotten a lot of letters like that.And they say, even though I still don’t agree with you about anything -(laughter) -- I do ask you -- that you give Jose a chance.

And so that’s where civility comes from.It's that interaction and personal experience as opposed to just being able to
stereotype somebody one way or the other.Now, it's important, by the way, though, that the civility runs both
ways.And I do think -- obviously I’ve been at the receiving end of people really angry at me about not just these
executive actions, but have been ginned up by some of the conservative talk shows that think that I'm usurping my
authority despite the fact that every previous President has exercised the same authority or they think I'm favoring
immigrants over red-blooded Americans.And so that’s a lot of the criticism directed at me.

But what’s also true is sometimes advocates on behalf of immigrants have suggested that anybody who is
concerned about the impact of immigration, or asks questions about comprehensive immigration reform, that they
must be racist or they must be anti-immigrant or their ignorant.And, that’s not true either.

There are people who are good people who actually believe in immigration, but are concerned about rewarding
somebody who broke American laws.There are good people who believe in immigration but are concerned, will
new immigrants depress wages, particularly in the low-wage sectors of the economy.Those are legitimate
questions, and we have to be just as civil in addressing those questions as we expect people to be when we are
talking to them.Because I think the facts are on our side, I think the studies have shown that over time immigrants
aren’t lowering wages but in fact improving the economy, and over time, boosting wages and jobs for everyone.

So I would rather just make the argument on the facts, but just because somebody thinks that instinctually doesn’t
mean that they are bad people.So civility is good, but it doesn’t just run one way.And I think -- the good book says,
don’t throw stones in glass houses, or make sure we’re looking at the log in our eye before were pulling out the
mote in other folks eyes.And I think that’s as true in politics as it is in life.

Okay.Let’s see if I’ve got any women who want to ask questions today.I'm going to make sure I'm fair.That young
lady in the back right there.You.

Q Hi.I'm part of an organization that works with refugees and immigrants.And one question I have -- was there a
particular reason why the parents of the DACA -- the DREAMers, the DACA recipients, were excluded in your new
executive order?

THE PRESIDENT:Yes, there is.And it was -- the actions I took were bound by the legal authority that the Office of
Legal Counsel determined I had in this area.The office -- I don’t want to get too technical here, but the Office of
Legal Counsel is a special office in the Department of Justice that is mandated to give me independent judgment
not subject to politics or pressure from me about what my legal authorities are.

And so we presented to them the various things that we’d like to do.They were very clear about my legal authority to
prioritize and then provide this temporary protection for parents whose children were Americans, or -- American
citizens, or legal permanent residents.Because the argument they found compelling, and there was a lot of
precedent for, was -- essentially humanitarian argument -- that if we’re prioritizing, why would we want to separate
families.

The challenge we had in the minds of the Office of Legal Counsel was, if you’ve already exempted the young
people through DACA, and then you bootstrap off of that the capacity to exempt their parents as well, you’re not
rooted originally in somebody who is either a citizen or a legal permanent resident.So it was a legal constraint on
our authority.It was not because we did not care about those parents.

And I know that there are a lot of DREAM Act kids who are concerned that their parents may not still qualify.A
sizable number do because they have a sibling who ended up being born in the United States.But not all do.This is
one more reason why we still need to pass comprehensive immigration reform.Because what we did was to do
everything that I could within my legal authority, but not go beyond the legal authority that we possessed.

This young man right here.I think the mic is coming from behind you.

Q Thank you, Mr. President.We are delighted to have you here in Nashville and in Casa Azafran.I’m a member of

App. 0889
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
the mayor’s New American Advisory Council, and also direct a nonprofit that’s housed here called AMAC, the
American Muslim Advisory Council.And my question to you is that -- in 2004, when you gave that speech about -at the Democratic convention, kind of alluded to this idea that we are one nation, there’s no black and blue -- blue
or red America.But when it comes to this issue of immigration, as someone that works in this community, our
mantra here in Nashville is, Nashville for all of us, and Tennessee for all of us.

So to come around that idea for America for all of us, that we don’t keep having this conversation -- as the
President, you have been in this position the past six years.What would you say to other -- Americans who are
feeling now on that side even considering the newly elected Congress that are adamant on stopping these steps?
Because I got the privilege of being the -- welcoming Tennessee director, and being in those conversations -- and
inherently, Tennesseans are the nicest people.Those people are in charge of the -- that we used to have those
conversations with.But what would you say to the rest of the nation -- who thinks that now new Americans or
immigrants are getting this special treatment?

THE PRESIDENT:Well, I, I addressed the nation when I announced this action, and I made a couple of simple
points.

First of all, America is a nation of immigrants, but it’s also a nation of laws.And there does need to be accountability
if you came here in a way that was not in accordance with the law.The question then becomes, how do you make
that person accountable?I mean, one way of doing it is randomly or sporadically separating families, but you don’t
have uniform enforcement, you’re pushing people into the shadows.They may not be paying taxes.They may be
taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers.You are using all those resources instead of strengthening
borders.And that’s not a smart outcome.

The second approach would be to pass laws that say, let’s improve the legal system.Because sometimes people
actually would be qualified to come here if the system was just a little smoother, but they end up with a situation
where they’ve got to wait years to be reunited with a family member who’s legally here and the heartache just
becomes too great.So we’re -- in some cases, we’re pushing people into the illegal system because we’re not
making the legal system smart enough.

We can get people out of the shadows.We can acknowledge they are our neighbors, our friends, our
coworkers.And then we still have to be serious about border security.And there have been times -- I want to be
very frank -- there have been times where I’ve had arguments with immigrant rights activists who say, effectively,
you know, there shouldn’t be any rules, these are good people, why should we have any kind of enforcement like
this.And my response is, in the eyes of God, everybody is equal.In the eyes of God, some child in Mexico,
Guatemala, Libya, Nepal is the equal of my child.

I don’t make any claims that my child is superior to somebody else’s child.But I’m the President of the United
States, and nation states have borders.And, frankly, because America is so much wealthier than most countries
around the world, if we had no system of enforcing our borders and our laws, then I promise you, everybody would
try to come here, or if not everybody -- maybe you wouldn’t have that many Swedes or Singaporians try to come
here, but a whole lot of folks would try to come.And that we couldn’t accommodate.And it wouldn’t be fair, because
there’s -- you have to have some sort of line.It can’t just be -- it can’t be whoever is able to get in here first, and
then -- it’s sort of first one to win the race.Because sometimes it’s just an accident that one person lives in a
country that has a border with the United States, and another person in Somalia, it’s a lot harder to get here.

So the idea is, then, that what we try to do is to have a system that resets; that acknowledges -- and this is where I
think most Americans are.They recognize, you know what, people who are already here -- many times they’ve
been here 5 years, 10 years, 20 years, they’ve got deep roots here, they’ve shown themselves to be good people,
their kids are for all practical purposes Americans -- let’s just acknowledge they’re part of our community, they’re
part of our society.

But then the tradeoff is, let’s try to make the legal system fairer, and in some cases, that means, for example, doing
more work at the borders -- although, by the way, the real work at the borders is not simply to just -- more fencing
and more people every five minutes at the borders, because we’ve already got a whole lot of folks at the
borders.We can do some other additional stuff, but a lot of it is helping Mexico or helping Central American
countries strengthen their economies so people don’t feel desperate and compelled to come here.

But I guess the bottom line is, what I say to folks on the other side of this debate is, work with me to reflect the
wisdom of the American people.And I think the American people’s wisdom is, people who are already here, let’s
give them a shot, let’s get them out of the shadows, but let’s also set up a legal system that is more reliable, more
certain, more fair, doesn’t have people jumping the line, is more honest and reflecting the fact that families, it’s very
hard for them to stay separated for 10, 15 years and so you shouldn’t set up a legal system that requires
that.You’ve got to figure out a way to have it more reflective of human nature.

Now, does that mean everybody is going to listen to me on the other side?Not necessarily.They’re pretty sure I’m
an illegal immigrant.(Laughter.)That was a joke.(Laughter.)But I mean, there are going to be some who just
disagree with you.

App. 0890
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House

The good news is, is that over time, these issues work themselves out.Anybody who is of Irish extraction -- and that
includes me, because I’ve been to a little town in Ireland called Moneygall, where my great-great-great-great-greatgreat-great-great grandfather came over here.It turns out he was a boot maker, and it turns out Biden’s guy, Biden’s
great-great-great-great-great came from I think the adjoining county within like 20 years.So me and Biden are -really are cousins.(Laughter.)

But anybody of Irish extraction just has to -- read your history and look at how people talked about Irish immigrants.I
mean, it was just -- everything that’s said today was said about them -- they’re criminals, they’re shiftless, they are
draining our resources, they’re irresponsible, they’re going to change our culture.

And so if you read those passages, then you have to understand that this is not a new phenomenon.But the good
news is, it should also be a source of optimism, because over time, essentially, new people get absorbed.And it’s
always messy.It’s always a messy piece of business.

But the one thing that I want to emphasize -- because sometimes this doesn’t get emphasized enough, and it
seems somewhat abstract -- but any economist will tell you that economies with younger workforces grow faster
than economies with older workforces.One of the biggest advantages America has over Europe, over Japan, over
China is we have a younger population.And it’s almost a mathematical certainty that we will grow faster than they
do, all things being equal -- I mean, we’ve got to make good choices about investing in research and development
and education and all that stuff -- but all things being equal, we will grow significantly faster than those other
countries because our population is younger.

The only reason our population is younger is because we have this tradition of immigrants.Otherwise -- because
native-born Americans, actually, our birth rates are as low as Europeans’ are.But we replenish ourselves, and
that’s good.And, by the way, people who are about my age right now, and who are going to be looking to draw on
Social Security, when you’re 70, the way Social Security works, it’s the current workforce that pays for the retired
workforce.And so you have a stake in these folks working and paying taxes, these young people, to support your
retirement.So this is -- it’s good for the economy as well as for our society.

How much time do I have?I want to make sure I’m not -- am I doing pretty good?I’ve got a priest here who’s got his
hand up, but it’s a woman’s turn first so this is -- I’m a little nervous about not calling on him right away but I’m
trying to stick to the rules here.(Laughter.)So all right, young lady right in the front here.

Q Hello, Mr. President.I am a senior in high school.And my question to you would be, how can we as young people
in our communities get involved to address issues such as immigration or the access to a post-secondary
education?What are some things we can do?

THE PRESIDENT:Well, if you’re here, you must already be involved.(Laughter.)You know, getting young people
involved in civic life and activism and voting is one of the most important things we can do as a society.Because
there are exceptions and there are people who are young at heart and young at mind, but the truth is, you get
older, you get stuck in your ways and you start looking backwards and really focused on what was instead of what
could be.

And again, part of the reason America has done so well is because we constantly reimagine ourselves, and we
have a youthful culture that says, well, let’s -- in the words of Robert Kennedy, some people ask why, and we have
a tendency to ask why not.And that’s good.

Now, young people are also busy with -- I got a couple young people at home -- they have other things that they’re
interested.I won’t name all of them.Hopefully some if it is their books and doing their homework.(Laughter.)And one
of the most concerning things I had about the midterm elections was young people -- the voting rates among young
people dropped off drastically.

Young people have tended to vote at very high level during my presidential campaigns, but in between, they lose
interest.And part of what your peers have to do is to understand that politics and government and policy and all the
decisions that are going to shape your lives are not just a matter of one election, but it has to be sustained over
time.

And when you think about what’s at stake right now, immigration is obviously a major issue.Climate change -- most
of those of us who are 50 or over, by the time the problems of a warming climate really hit, we’ll be gone, but you’ll
still be around and your kids will be here.And if it’s having a significant impact on weather patterns, and drought,
and wildfires, and flooding, and food, and migration, it’s not going to be pretty.So you have to get involved now to
do something about it.

When we look at higher education costs, historically, Congress and state legislatures are more attentive to the
demands of seniors than they are the demands of young people for one simple reason:Seniors vote, young people
don’t.If you want state legislatures to increase support for higher education that then can help reduce tuition, then
young people have to vote at a higher percentage than just 12 percent of those who vote.

App. 0891
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House

Look at what’s happening right now with respect to concerns about bias and law enforcement, and policing.I mean,
I met with a group of young activists, including several from Ferguson, to talk to them, and I was very impressed
with how they presented themselves, and they were very serious and thoughtful.And I told them, I said, listen, I
want you to continue to be active, because that’s how change happens.You need to be respectful.You need to
understand that you’re not going to get 100 percent of the change that is needed, because that’s never been how
society works, but if you are steady and you sustain it and you push it and you don’t tired or disappointed when you
get half a loaf instead of a whole loaf, over time, the country and the world is transformed.

And I’m confident that -- I said in an interview recently -- America is a more just place, and issues of racial
discrimination are lessened today than they were 50 years ago or 20 years ago, but that didn’t just happen by
accident, that happened because people -- especially young people -- helped to make it happen.And over time,
change occurs and people adjust to a new reality, and they open their heart and mind to new possibilities.And
young people are typically the triggers of that.

So I think when your leaders like -- young leaders like you are talking to your friends, you’ve got to just remind them
that you have responsibilities and obligations.And make sure that you serve pizza at the meetings -- (laughter) -because free food always helps when getting young people involved in social causes.(Laughter.)

All right, Father.Thank you for your patience there, sir.You’ve got a microphone behind you.

Q Father Joseph Freen (ph), native Nashvillian.I think I speak on behalf of a good number of people, Mr. President,
of both parties -- some you know may not agree with some of your policies.But I think I can speak for so many who
are so proud of you for giving such a great example of a husband, of a father, and doing your very best as a
President.

So we are very proud of you, grateful you’ve come to Nashville.We wish for you -- I’m sure on behalf of all of us -- a
joyful and a blessed Christmas to you.

THE PRESIDENT:Well, I appreciate that very much.That's very nice.Thank you.(Applause.)

I appreciate that, Father.It’s worth considering the Good Book when you're thinking about immigration.This
Christmas season there’s a whole story about a young, soon-to-be-mother and her husband of modest means
looking for a place to house themselves for the night, and there’s no room at the inn.

And as I said the day that I announced these executive actions, we were once strangers too.And part of what my
faith teaches me is to look upon the stranger as part of myself.And during this Christmas season, that's a good
place to start.

So thank you for your generous comment.But if we're serious about the Christmas season, now is a good time to
reflect on those who are strangers in our midst, and remember what it was like to be a stranger.

Last question.That was a pretty good place to end, though.(Laughter.)I got to admit.I kind of want to -- but I’m going
to call on one more person.Gentlemen, you can all put your hands down.I’m going to call on this young lady right
here.

Q Hi, Mr. President.I’m an immigration attorney.And I wonder, what are the things that you deem necessary for
comprehensive immigration reform if Congress does act soon?

THE PRESIDENT:Well, the Senate bill is a pretty good place to start.I do think there’s more work we can do at the
borders.As I said before, it’s not just a matter of pouring money down there.

I’ll give you one very simple example.You’ll recall that some of the politics of this shifted during the summer when
these unaccompanied children were here.And there was two weeks of wall-to-wall coverage.And we were being
invaded by 8-, and 12- and 13-year-olds.I mean it was just terrifying, apparently.But it reflected a serious
problem.You had smugglers, coyotes, who were essentially taking money from family members here, shuttling
these kids up -- it wasn’t that they weren’t apprehended.It wasn’t like they snuck through the border.What
happened was they basically presented themselves at the border.They’d come in.And because there are so few
immigration judges down there, because we hadn’t done a very good job cooperating with Central America and
Mexico to deal -- go after these smugglers, you’d then have a situation which the kids would oftentimes simply be
released to the family member, and then that was the end of the things.

And so one of the things that we’ve done is -- well, several things we did.Number one, I met with the Central
American leaders down there and said, listen, you can't -- you've got to do something to message to families down
here:Do not send your children on a dangerous path like this because we don't know how many of them might
have gotten killed, gotten abducted, trafficked in some terrible way.We have no way of keeping track of that.You
can't have them take this dangerous journey.

App. 0892
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]

Remarks by the President in Immigration Town Hall -- Nashville, Tennessee | The White House
And to their credit, those Central American countries worked with us.We said to Mexico, you've got to do something
more about the southern border.They did that.We now have the number of unaccompanied children below the rate
that it was two years ago.So this was a momentary spike.

But also what we need to do is make sure that we have enough immigration lawyers down there that you can
process kids and immigration judges to process kids in a timely fashion, but with due process so that if they have
legitimate refugee claims, those can be presented, and if not, then they can be returned home.

So that's not a strict border issue.It’s not a fence issue.It’s “have you set up a sensible process” issue.So I think
that's one pillar.

Second pillar is improving the legal immigration system.I already mentioned this but I’ll just repeat a couple of
examples.Somebody who potentially qualifies to be a resident here, forcing them to leave the country and then
waiting for years before they come back when they’ve got family members here, that's just not how the human
heart works.It’s very hard to expect somebody to do that.

Let’s have a more sensible, streamlined system.Let’s reduce some of the backlogs that already exist for people who
actually qualify, but it’s just they're waiting in line so long that they get frustrated.Let’s do something for especially
talented and skilled people who are graduating.We educate them.We should be stapling a green card to graduates
of top schools in fields that we know we need.And by the way, we can charge fees that we then use to make sure
that American kids are getting the kinds of scholarships and training they need for those same jobs in the future.

We need to do more work.We need to deal with the agricultural sector.I’m generally skeptical when you hear
employers say, well, we just can't find any Americans to do the job.A lot of times what they really mean is, it’s a lot
cheaper if we potentially hire somebody who has just come here before they know better in terms of what they're
worth.

But in the agriculture sector, there’s truth.We enjoy a lot of cheap fruits and vegetables and food stuffs because of
the back-breaking work of farm workers.And we should find a system that is fair, make sure that they are not
subject to exploitation, and helps us run the economy.We should make sure that we're cracking down on
employers who are purposely hiring undocumented workers so that they can get around minimum wage laws or
overtime laws, so forth.

And finally, as I’ve discussed this whole afternoon, we should get people out of the shadows.And the Senate bill I
thought had a sensible approach, which said, if you've been here a certain amount of time, you've got a clean
record, you're willing to submit yourself to a background check, you're willing to pay back-taxes, you're willing to
pay a fine, learn English, go to the back of the line, but if you do all that, you can stay here for now and we're going
to put you on a pathway where eventually you can earn your citizenship, although it will be many years into the
future because we still have to clear out those folks who did it the right way.

This concept -- what I just described, that package -- has bipartisan support.It’s not that it doesn't have bipartisan
support.The challenge is, is that there’s a certain segment -- primarily within the Republican Party, although in
fairness, in the Democratic Party there are some people who are resistant as well, who just keep on believing this
notion of, that's amnesty, that's amnesty.

And what amnesty implies I think in the minds of the American people is that you're getting something for nothing;
that you're getting over.And when you describe for people that, in fact, you do have to get a background check, you
do have to register, you do have to pay fines, you do have to pay back-taxes, then people feel differently.But that's
never advertised by opponents.And that's one reason why, by the way, that I’ve said to immigrant rights groups,
you have to describe the responsibility side of this and not just the rights side of this.Because I think sometimes -- I
appreciate the immigrant rights groups.They speak from the heart, and they know the people involved.And they
love them, and they want to just do right by them.And I get that.

But this is where you need to look at the other side of the equation and what people feel like is, you know what, if
you're just coming here for nothing, and I don't know that you're paying your taxes and you broke the law, and now
suddenly I’m paying for your kid’s school and your kid’s hospitalization, and if feels unfair -- at a time when people
are already feeling burdened by their own challenges, trying to afford their own kid’s college education, or feeling
like they're worried about their own retirement.

So the langue we use I think is important.You have to speak to the fact that -- if somebody broke the law, even if
they're good people, they’ve got to be held accountable.And there are going to be responsibilities involved in
it.Because if it’s just rights and no responsibilities, then people feel resentful.

That make sense?All right, guys, I enjoyed spending time with you.Thank you.(Applause.)

END
3:37 P.M. CST

App. 0893
http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2014/12/09/remarks-president-immigration-town-hall-nashville-tennessee[1/7/2015 10:03:10 AM]